Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Expansion Model Test of Expansive Soil in Different Stress State B
Expansion Model Test of Expansive Soil in Different Stress State B
1007/s11204-015-9307-y
Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering, Vol. 52, No. 2, May, 2015 (Russian Original No. 2, March-April, 2015)
The hydroscopic expansion of expansive soil always leads to engineering safety problems.
With mid-expansive soil at Nanyang, the relationship among the expansion ratio caused
by total wetting of expansive soil, eventual and initial ratio of water content, and overly-
ing loads was studied. By taking measures such as improving the controlling system of
water inlet and measuring the outer body changes, tri-axial stress state expansive tests
were realized, and the rules and relationships among volume expansion ratios caused by
total wetting, eventual and initial ratio of water content, and averaged primary stress
were studied. The experiments show that the volume expansion ratio under different stress
states and eventual ratio of water content both decrease with increase in overlying pres-
sure or averaged primary stress, which represents a relatively good linear relationship in
semilogarithmic coordinates. The relationship among expansion models at different stress
states and the unified expression for these models were established, on the basis of which
any expansion constitutive relation of expansive soil at any water-containing ratio could
be obtained. The expansion experiments are easily carried out with concise model expres-
sions and parameters with explicit physical meanings and can also be used in numerical
analysis and simplifying calculations.
1. Introduction
Expansive soil is distributed widely in many areas of China, and its hydroscopic expansion charac-
teristics always do great harm to buildings and structures on it, such as inclined cracks of buildings, insta-
bility of slopes, etc., which leads to large losses in the domestic economy. Thus carrying out researches on
expansive soil, especially on expansion models, is of significance in engineering construction.
The available approaches to the prediction of heave can be divided into methods based on the
actual stress path or total stress path. Methods that follow the actual stress path are based on matric suc-
tion measurements [1-9]. The primary difficulties associated with these methods are related to the accu-
racy of soil suction measurements. Methods that follow a total stress path make use of the results from
oedometer, swelling apparatus, triaxial apparatus, pressure cell equipment, constant volume, and
oedometer load-back swell pressure devices without soil suction measurements [10-16]. The use of
water content instead of suction allows the simplification of experimental procedures [17]. Total stress
path methods are commonly used because soil suction measurements are not required and water content
can be accurately measured.
58
a b
Expansion rate, % Final water content, %
8 30.0
6 29.6
4 29.2
2 28.8
0 28.4
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Load, kPa Load, kPa
Fig. 1. Results of K0 expansion test: a) the relationship curve between expansion ratio and load;
b) the relationship curve between final water content and load.
Expansion rate, %
8
0
-2
1 10 100 1,000
Load (1 + σ/p0) (p0 = 1 kPa)
Fig. 2. The semilog relationship curve between expansion ratio and load of expansive soil.
59
Final water content, %
30.0
29.6
29.2
28.8
28.4
1 10 100 1,000
Load (1 + σ/p0) (p0 = 1 kPa)
Fig. 3. The semilog relationship curve between final water content and load of expansive soil.
It can be seen that the expansion ratio is linearly related to the logarithm of the load. Thus the
expansion ratios at the K0 stress state can be uniformly expressed as
σ
δ ep = a + b ln(1 + ), (1)
p0
where δep is the expansion ratio of the expansive soil (%), σ is the load (kPa), p0 = 1 kPa, a and b are
parameters related to the initial and final water content. The parameters are a = 11.5 and b = −2.46 for
Nanyang mid-expansive soil with 96% compactness.
2.5 Establishment of linear expansion parameter formula
Figure 3 shows the curve of final water content versus load in semilogarithmic coordinates.
According to the expansion ratio model, the final water content model considering the overlying loads
can be established as
σ
wult = c + d ln(1 + ), (2)
p0
where wult is the final water content (%) of the totally wetted expansive soil, and c and d are parameters
related to the initial water content and compactness, whose values are equal to 30.6 and −0.419, respec-
tively, for Nanyang mid-expansive soil with 20.4% water content and 96% compactness.
The linear expansion parameter of expansive soil refers to the change in the expansion ratio
caused by the change in unit water content of the expansive soil. The expansion characteristics were
determined by both internal and external factors [27]. The change in water content is the main external
factor causing volume expansion and contraction. The larger the change in water content, the larger the
expansion and contraction deformation, which is a qualitative conclusion and can't characterize the vol-
ume change caused by change in unit water content of different expansive soils. On the contrary, the lin-
ear expansion parameter can quantitatively determine the relation between the change in expansion and
contraction deformation and the change in water content. This is the internal factor, which is the effect
of the special material elements and structural characteristics of the expansive soil on its expansion
characteristics [28]. Chen [29] stated that the amount of volume change increases in direct proportion to
the degree of saturation at the end of the test. The linear expansion parameter is always constant.
60
From the definition, it can be shown that the linear expansion parameter can be obtained when
the final water content, expansion ratio, and initial water content are known. Taking Nanyang mid-
expansive soil as an example, its linear expansion parameter can be expressed as
δ ep ⎧⎪ σ ⎫⎪ ⎧ σ ⎫
α= = ⎨a + b ln(1 + )⎬ / ⎨c + d ln(1 + ) − w o⎬ , (3)
wult − wo
⎩⎪ p 0 ⎪⎭ ⎩ p0 ⎭
where α is the linear expansion parameter; a, b, c, and d represent parameters related to the initial water
content under a certain compactness. The model parameter values of K0 linear expansion parameters
with 20.4% initial water content and 96% compactness are: a = 11.5, b = −2.46, c = 30.6, d = −0.419.
61
a b
Expansion rate, % Final water content, %
8 35
6 32
29
4
26
2
23
0 Cell pressure σ3, kPa
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 20
Cell pressure σ3, kPa 0 30 50 70 90 110 130 150 170
-2
Fig. 4. Results of tri-axial expansion test: a) the relationship curve between expansion ratio and
cell pressure; b) the relationship curve between final water content and cell pressure.
Expansion rate, %
8
6
4
2
0
-2
-4
10 100 1,000
Average principal stress (1 + σm/p0) (p0 = 1 kPa)
Fig. 5. The semilog relationship curve between expansion ratio and averaged principal stress of
expansive soil.
expansion ratio decreases with increase in the surrounding pressures. The change in the expansion ratio
with change in the surrounding pressures is large when the surrounding pressures are relatively small,
However, these effects weaken with the increase in surrounding pressures. Usually, when the overburden
load is less than the swelling pressure, the specimen reflects moisture expansion; but when the overbur-
den load is larger than the swelling pressure, a negative expansion ratio occurs when the wetting defor-
mation is greater than the expansion of the specimen that causes the compression. The final water con-
tent of the expansive soil decreases with increase in the surrounding pressures.
3.4 The establishment of formulas for the expansion ratio
With regard to tri-axial expansive constitutive study, Einstein [30] and Wittke [31] proposed the
tri-axial expansive constitutive assumption on the basis of Huder-Amberg's [20] one-dimensional expan-
sion constitutive relation. "Expansion strain is due to the change in the first invariant of the stress. " Jun
Sun [23] and Qiang Yang et al. [25] verified the assumption of Einstein and Wittke according to the tri-
axial expansion experimental results of expansive rocks.
The curve of the experimentally obtained volume expansion ratio versus averaged principal stress
(equal to 1/3 of the first invariant) was plotted in the semilogarithmic coordinates shown in Fig. 5.
It can be seen that under the initial water content and compactness, the volume expansion ratio
caused by total wetting is linearly related to the logarithm of the averaged primary stress. The tri-axial
stress state expansion ratio can be uniformly expressed as
62
Final water content, %
35
32
29
26
23
20
10 100 1,000
Average principal stress (1 + σm/p0) (p0 = 1 kPa)
Fig. 6. The semilog relationship curve between final water content and averaged
principal stress of expansive soil.
σm
ε v = a + b ln(1 + ),
p0 (4)
where εv is the volume expansion ratio (volume change) (%), σm is the averaged primary stress, p0 = 1
kPa, and a, b are parameters obtained by tri-axial hydroscopic expansion experiments relating to the ini-
tial water content and compactness, which are equal to 22.7 and −4.73, respectively, for Nanyang mid-
expansive soil with 20.4% initial water content and 96% compactness.
3.5 Establishment of the linear expansion parameters and formulas
Figure 6 shows the curve of the final water content versus load in semilogarithmic coordinates.
According to the established route of the expansion ratio model, the final water content model consid-
ering the overlying loads can be established as
σm
wult = c + d ln(1 + ),
p0 (5)
where c = 47.9, and d = −4.44 for Nanyang mid-expansive soil with 20.4% water content and 96% com-
pactness.
The linear expansion parameters can be expressed as
εv ⎧⎪ σ ⎫⎪ ⎧ σ ⎫
α= = ⎨a + b ln(1 + m )⎬ / ⎨c + d ln(1 + m ) − w o⎬ , (6)
wult − wo ⎪⎩ p 0 ⎪⎭ ⎩ p0 ⎭
where a = 22.7, b = −4.73, c = 47.9, and d = −4.44 represent the tri-axial linear expansion parameter model.
63
According to Eqs. (3) and (6), the linear expansion parameters can be uniformly expressed as
⎪⎧ σ ⎪⎫ ⎧ σ ⎫
α = ⎨a + b ln(1 + )⎬ / ⎨c + d ln(1 + ) − w o ⎬. (9)
⎩⎪ p 0 ⎪⎭ ⎩ p0 ⎭
Thus the expansion ratio of expansive soil caused by inadequate wetting can be calculated
according to
εv w0 ≤ w ≤ wult
= α (w − w0 ), (10)
σm = σ = p e . (11)
Thus parameters a and b in the K0 stress state expansion model and the tri-axial stress state
expansion model are related as follows:
ak 0 bk0
= . (13)
atri-axial btri-axial
Under the same initial water content and compactness, the values of parameters a, b, c, and d
in the K 0 stress state are 11.5, −2.46, 30.6, −0.419, respectively; and in tri-axial expansion test are
22.7, −4.73, 47.9, and −4.44, respectively; converted parameters a, b, c, and d, obtained in K 0 expan-
sion test are 23.0, −4.92, 44.8, −3.39, respectively.
Parameters a and b in K0 stress state and tri-axial stress state basically satisfy the proportional
relation shown in Eq. (13) and the parameter numeric values in tri-axial expansion ratio model are near-
ly two times those in K0 stress state. In addition, the author also carried out similar research on strong-
ly expansive soil in Handan and the obtained parameters in tri-axial expansion model were also basical-
ly two times those in K0 stress state expansion model.
In engineering practice, the research on the tri-axial expansion model requires special tri-axial
equipment and takes a long time, about 1-2 weeks per sample. Thus, with regard to practicality and
manipulation simplicity, the K0 expansion ratio experiments considering the compactness, initial water
64
content, and overlying loads are more easily to performed. Quantitative relations can be established
between parameters in the tri-axial expansion model and in the K0 expansion model.
The parameters of the expansion model atri-axial and btri-axial can be obtained by Eqs. (14) and (15).
where k is usually 2.
The parameter ctri-axial can be obtained approximately through the saturated water content under
the assumed three-dimensional zero loading conditions. At this state, the volume expansion ratio can be
|
obtained by Eq. (4), namely εv σ =0 = atri-axial (%). By combining with Eq. (14), the parameter ctri-axial is
calculated as the saturated water content of the sample when the expansion stabilizes, as shown by
where ρd is the drying density of samples (g/cm3) and Gs is the density of soil particles.
Inserting Eq. (11) into Eqs. (2) and (5), we obtain
pe p
wult σ = pe = ctri-axial + dtri-axial ln(1 + ) = ck0 + dk0 ln(1 + e ). (17)
p0 p0
The calculating formula can be deduced from Eqs. (16) and (17):
Eqs. (14)-(16) and (18) are the approximate conversion formulas among parameters of expansion
models at different stress states. The converted parameters obtained in the K0 expansion model and the
calculated parameter values of atri-axial, btri-axial, ctri-axial, and dtri-axial are 23.0, −4.92, 44.8, and −3.39, respec-
tively. Compared with the parameters obtained in tri-axial expansion experiments, the absolute values of
relative errors were all within 23.5%, and the error signs of c, d with slightly larger errors are opposite,
leading to some neutralization of errors. Thus the accuracy of converted parameters basically satisfies
the geotechnical engineering demands.
The experimental study of this paper is aimed at Nanyang mid-expansive soil and applies to the
expansion model, as shown in [32]. Different replacement thickness deformation, stability, and plastic
zone distribution of expansive soil slope were calculated by using the expansion model. Then the Han-
dan strong-expansive soil was also analyzed. The conclusion is in accordance with this paper and rele-
vant results can be found in [33].
Conclusions
Through indoor K0 and tri-axial stress state expansion ratio experiments, the expansive charac-
teristics of Nanyang mid-expansive soil were studied and conclusions were drawn as follows.
1. Under the same initial water content and degree of compactness, the expansion ratio of the
expansive soil decreases with increase in overlying compressive stresses or averaged primary pressures,
65
which represents a relatively good linear relationship in semilogarithmic coordinates. Relatively small
overlying loads show clear inhibitions on hydroscopic expansion of expansive soil. However, these inhi-
bitions weaken with increase in loads or averaged primary pressures.
2. The experimental results at the K0 stress state and tri-axial stress state were summarized. The
uniform relationship among the volume expansion ratio due to total wetting, final water content, linear
expansion parameters, and overlying loads or averaged primary pressure, namely expansive constitutive
model, was established.
3. By using linear expansion parameters, the expansion ratio expression at any water content
between the initial and final total wetting water content can be obtained. Namely, the relation between
the expansion ratio of the expansive soil and the water content at any state was considered. The expan-
sive soil in engineering practice doesn't necessarily absorb water up to a saturated state. The initial and
saturated water content has been fully considered in this model, and the method used makes it more
widely applicable.
4. Approximate converting relations were established between the parameters in the tri-axial
expansion model and in the K0 expansion model. The parameters of the tri-axial stress state expansion
model can be obtained through the easily manipulated K0 stress state expansion ratio experiments with
the accuracy, basically satisfying demands of geotechnical engineering and possessing the universality of
engineering applications.
The unified expansion model has several advantages such as simplicity of expression, and explic-
it physical meanings and requires simple tests to obtain model parameters. It can be used for numerical
analysis and simplified calculation of expansive soil foundation or slope, which is strongly practical.
Acknowledgments
This research is financially supported by Basic Research Funds for Scientific Research on Pub-
lic Causes of China (Grant No. CKSF2013035 and Grant No. CKSF2015051) and National Natural Sci-
ence Foundation of China (Grant No. 51309028 and Grant No. 51378403).
REFERENCES
1. G. D. Aitchison and R. Martin, "A membrane oedometer for complex stress-path studies in expansive
clays," Proc. 3rd International Conference on Expansive Soils, Haifa, Israel, 2, 83-88 (1973).
2. D. R. Snethen, "Characterization of expansive soils using soil suction data," Proc. the 4th International
Conference on Expansive Soils, Denver, Colorado, 1, 54-75 (1980).
3. B. G. Richards, P. Peter, and R. Martin, "The determination of volume change properties in expansive
soils," Proc. 5th International Conference on Expansive Soils, Adelaide, Australia, 179-186 (1984).
4. R. G. McKeen, "A model for predicting expansive soil behaviour," Proc. 7th International Conference
on Expansive Soils, Dallas, Tex., 1, 1-6 (1992).
5. P. Delage, M. D. Howat, and Y. J. Cui, "The relationship between suction and swelling properties in
a heavily compacted unsaturated clay," Eng. Geol., 50(1), 31-48 (1998).
6. H. A. Perko, R. W. Thompson, and J. D. Nelson, "Suction compression index based on CLOD test
results," Proc. In Advances in Unsaturated Geotechnics: Proceedings of Sessions of GeoDenver 2000,
Denver, Colorado, 393-408 (2000).
7. E. Cokca, "Relationship between methylene blue value, initial soil suction and swell percent of
expansive soils," Turk. J. Eng. and Environ. Sci., 26, 521-529 (2002).
8. W. J. Likos, H. W. Olsen, and L. Krosley, "Measured and estimated suction indices for swelling
potential classification," Geotech. and Geoenviron. Eng., 129(7), 665-668 (2003).
9. Y. Erzin, and O. Erol, "Swell pressure prediction by suction methods," Eng. Geol., 92(3), 133-145
(2007).
10. L. Borgesson, "Water flow and swelling pressure in non-saturated bentonite-based clay barriers," Eng.
Geol., 21(3), 229-237 (1985).
11. A. S. Al-Homoud, A. A. Basma and A. I. H. Malkawi, "Cyclic swelling behavior of clays," Geotech.
Eng., 121(7), 562-565 (1995).
12. E. Cokca, "Comparison of suction and oedometer methods for the measurement of swelling pressure,"
Eng. Geol., 33(2), 141-147 (2000).
13. K. S. S. Rao, S. M. Rao, and S. Gangadhara, "Swelling behavior of a desiccated clay," Geotech. Test.
J., 23(2), 193-198 (2000).
66
14. S. Tripathy, K. S. S. Rao, and D. G. Fredlund, "Water content -void ratio swell-shrink paths of
compacted expansive soils," Can. Geotech. J., 39(4), 938-959 (2002).
15. A. Sridharan, and Y. Gurtug, "Swelling behaviour of compacted fine-grained soils," Eng. Geol.,
72(1), 9-18 (2004).
16. R. W. Thompson, H. A. Perko, and W. D. Retharnel, "Comparison of constant volume swell pressure
and oedometer load-back pressure," Proc. Fourth International Conference on Unsaturated Soils,
Carefree, Ariz., 1787-1798 (2006).
17. S. J. F. Gould, J. Kodikara, and P. Rajeev, "A void ratio − water content − net stress model for envi-
ronmentally stabilized expansive soils," Can. Geotech. J., 48(6), 867-877 (2011).
18. H. H. Einstein, "Suggested methods for laboratory testing of arginaceous swelling rock," Rock Mech.
and Min. Sci., 26(5), 415-426 (1989).
19. W. G. Holtz, and H. J. Gibbs, "Engineering properties of expansive clays," Trans. of Am. Soc. of
Civil Eng., 121, 641-663 (1956).
20. J. Huder and G. Amberg, "Quellung in Mergel, Opalinuston und Anhydrit," Schweizerische
Bauzeitung, 43, 975-980 (1970).
21. I. Noorany and J. V.Stanley, "Settlement of Compacted Fills Caused by Wetting," Proc. vertical and
horizontal deformations of foundations and embankments, Texas, ASCE, 2, 1516-1530 (1994).
22. B. X. Wei, Y. F. Zhou and Y. G. Liu, "Constitutive model for expansive soil based on engineering
application," Chin. J. Highway Transport, 3(2), 18-23 (2007).
23. J. Sun, D. X. Zhang and C. J. Li, "The coupled-creep effect of pressure tunnels interacted with its
water-osmotic swelling viscous elasto-plastic surrounding rocks," Proc. Advances in tunneling
technology and subsurface use, Peking, 25-27 (1984).
24. Z. D. Liu and Y. Wang, "Study on triaxial deformation of expansive soils soaked in water," J. Wuhan
Univ. of Hydraulic Electric Eng., 27(6), 616-621 (1994).
25. Q. Yang and J. K. Jiao, "The determination of volume expansive properties in swelling clay," Proc.
second international conference on unsaturated soils, Beijing, 450-454 (1998).
26. ASTM, "Standard Test Methods for One-Dimensional Swell or Collapse of Soils," ASTM standard
D4546-14 (2014).
27. S. W. Liao, Expansive soils and railway engineering, China Railway Publishing House, Peking,
China (1984).
28. R. E. Grime, Clay mineralogy, McGraw Hill: New York (1968).
29. F. H. Chen, Foundation on expansive soils, Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands (1988).
30. H. H. Einstein, N. Bischoff and E. Hofmann, "Verhalten von Stollensohlen in quellendem mergel,"
Proc. the international symposium on underground openings, Lucerne, 296-319 (1972).
31. W. Wittke and P. Rissler, Dimensioning of the lining of underground openings in swelling rock
applying the finite element method, Institute for Foundation Engineering, Soil Mechanics, Rock
Mechanics and Water Ways Construction, RWTH (University), 2, 7-48 (1976).
32. H. Xu, Z. L. Cheng, and B. Huang, "The Mechanism of Inhibition Swelling Deformation and Slope
Instability of Expansive Soils by Replacement Method," Tech. Gaz., 21(5), 1057-1063 (2014).
33. Z. Z. Cheng, J. H. Ding and X. B. Rao, "Physical Model Tests of Expansive Soil Slope," Proc.
Geo-Congress 2013, San Diego, California, ASCE, 731-740 (2013).
67