Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Psychological Distress and Work Related Musculoskeletal Disorders Among Nurses-2
Psychological Distress and Work Related Musculoskeletal Disorders Among Nurses-2
Psychological Distress and Work Related Musculoskeletal Disorders Among Nurses-2
CHAPTER ONE
Introduction
The Ekiti State Teaching Hospital is one of the largest healthcare facilities in the
region, and it employs a large number of nurses who provide care to patients on a
daily basis. However, the prevalence of psychological distress and WRMSDs
among nurses in this hospital has not been well studied. Therefore, this research
aims to investigate the prevalence and associated factors of psychological distress
and WRMSDs among nurses working in the Ekiti State Teaching Hospital.
Previous studies have shown that the prevalence of psychological distress among
nurses is high, with reports of depression, anxiety, and burnout. These mental
health issues have been associated with high levels of job demands, inadequate
social support, and poor work conditions (Adewuya & Afolabi, 2020; Khamisa et
al., 2019). Similarly, WRMSDs have been identified as a significant occupational
health problem among nurses, with high rates of musculoskeletal pain reported in
various body regions (Choobineh et al., 2021; Ogunsanya & Onigbinde, 2019).
The Ekiti State Teaching Hospital is one of the largest healthcare facilities in the
region, and it employs a large number of nurses who provide care to patients on a
daily basis. However, the prevalence and associated factors of psychological
distress and WRMSDs among nurses working in this hospital are not well
understood. The lack of data on these health issues among nurses in Ekiti State
Teaching Hospital hinders the development of targeted interventions and policies
to address the health needs of this vulnerable population.
Therefore, the main problem this research seeks to address is the prevalence and
associated factors of psychological distress and WRMSDs among nurses working
in the Ekiti State Teaching Hospital. This study aims to contribute to the existing
literature on the health and well-being of healthcare workers in Nigeria and
provide insights for the development of effective interventions to promote the
physical and mental health of nurses in the workplace.
The first objective aims to determine the prevalence of work-related MSDs among
nurses in Ekiti State Teaching Hospital. This objective seeks to provide insights
into the extent of the problem and the need for interventions to prevent and
manage work-related MSDs among nurses.
The fourth objective aims to identify the risk factors associated with work-related
MSDs and psychological distress among nurses in Ekiti State Teaching Hospital.
This objective seeks to provide insights into the factors that contribute to the
development of these conditions and the need for targeted interventions to
address them.
Hypothesis 4: There are significant risk factors associated with work-related MSDs
and psychological distress among nurses in Ekiti State Teaching Hospital.
Improving healthcare delivery: The findings of this study will help healthcare
policymakers and managers to develop evidence-based policies and interventions
aimed at promoting the health and well-being of nurses. This will lead to a
reduction in the incidence and prevalence of work-related MSDs and
psychological distress among nurses, which will, in turn, improve the quality of
healthcare delivery.
Informing occupational health and safety: The study provides insights into the
factors that contribute to work-related MSDs and psychological distress among
nurses, which will inform occupational health and safety practices in the
healthcare sector. This will promote the development of appropriate
interventions and measures to prevent and manage work-related MSDs and
psychological distress among nurses.
Enhancing nurse job satisfaction: Nurses play a critical role in healthcare delivery,
and their job satisfaction is essential for optimal performance. This study will help
identify the factors that contribute to work-related MSDs and psychological
distress among nurses, which, when addressed, will improve their job satisfaction.
1. Sample: The study will focus on nurses working in Ekiti State Teaching
Hospital, Nigeria. The sample will include only registered nurses working in
the hospital. The study will not include other healthcare professionals, such
as doctors or allied health workers.
2. Variables: The study will focus on work-related musculoskeletal disorders
(MSDs) and psychological distress among nurses. The study will not include
other health-related issues that may affect nurses, such as infectious
diseases or non-work-related health conditions.
3. Time frame: The study will cover the period from January 2022 to
December 2022. The study will not include data from previous years or
subsequent years.
4. Geographical location: The study will focus on Ekiti State Teaching Hospital,
Nigeria, and the findings may not be generalizable to other hospitals in
Nigeria or other countries.
5. Research design: The study will use a cross-sectional research design, which
will provide a snapshot of the prevalence and associated risk factors of
work-related MSDs and psychological distress among nurses at a particular
point in time. The study will not use other research designs, such as
longitudinal or experimental designs.
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
Introduction:
The existing literature suggests that psychological distress and WRMSDs are
interrelated and may have common risk factors. For example, work-related stress,
job demands, and lack of social support have been identified as risk factors for
both psychological distress and WRMSDs among nurses (Gan et al., 2020;
Jahanian et al., 2021; Smith-Miller et al., 2018). However, the exact mechanisms
underlying the relationship between these health issues remain unclear, and
more research is needed to better understand the complex interplay between
psychological distress and WRMSDs among nurses.
Therefore, this literature review aims to critically evaluate the existing research
on psychological distress and WRMSDs among nurses, identify the gaps in the
current knowledge, and develop research questions that this study seeks to
address. The findings of this literature review will provide a foundation for the
development of a comprehensive research methodology and data analysis plan in
Chapter 3.
Overall, the conceptual literature review highlights the significant impact of work-
related MSDs and psychological distress among nurses working in healthcare
facilities. The review identifies several risk factors associated with these
conditions and underscores the need for interventions to mitigate these risks and
promote the health and well-being of nurses. The review also emphasizes the
implications for patient care and healthcare systems and the need for policies and
practices that support a healthy work environment for nurses.
Health
+
Job Strain
_
Resources
Psychosocial
_ Job demands +
The theoretical framework for this study is based on the Conservation of
Resources (COR) theory, which proposes that individuals strive to obtain, retain,
and protect valuable resources, including physical, psychological, and social
resources, to prevent stress and maintain well-being (Hobfoll, 2018). According to
this theory, stress occurs when individuals perceive that their resources are
threatened or depleted, and the resulting strain can lead to negative outcomes
such as psychological distress and physical health problems.
The COR theory has been applied in various occupational health studies, including
research on work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WRMSDs) and psychological
distress among healthcare workers (De Boer et al., 2018; Roche et al., 2020).
Previous research has shown that job demands such as heavy physical workloads
and high job demands are associated with increased risk of WRMSDs among
nurses, while job resources such as social support, job control, and autonomy are
protective factors.
The COR theory provides a useful framework for understanding the dynamic
interplay between job demands, job resources, and their effects on the health
and well-being of nurses. This theory posits that resources are critical for
preventing stress and maintaining well-being, and it proposes that individuals
who possess more resources are better able to cope with stress and adapt to
changing work environments (Hobfoll, 2018).
Therefore, this study will use the COR theory as a theoretical framework to
explore the relationships between job demands, job resources, psychological
distress, and WRMSDs among nurses in Ekiti State teaching Hospital. Specifically,
we will examine the direct and indirect effects of job demands and job resources
on psychological distress and WRMSDs and investigate the moderating role of job
resources in the relationship between job demands and employee outcomes. By
using this theoretical framework, we aim to develop a comprehensive
understanding of the factors that contribute to psychological distress and
WRMSDs among nurses and inform the development of effective interventions to
improve the health and well-being of healthcare workers.
For instance, a study by Griep and colleagues (2018) found that nurses with
WRMSDs had significantly higher levels of psychological distress compared to
those without WRMSDs. This study also found that job demands, such as high
physical workloads and long working hours, were significantly associated with
both WRMSDs and psychological distress among nurses.
Other studies have also investigated the specific types of WRMSDs that are most
prevalent among nurses, as well as the risk factors and preventive measures
associated with these disorders. For instance, a study by Sutrisna and colleagues
(2019) found that low back pain was the most common WRMSD among
Indonesian nurses, with heavy lifting and awkward postures identified as the
primary risk factors. This study also highlighted the importance of ergonomic
interventions, such as training and equipment modifications, for preventing and
managing WRMSDs among nurses.
Similarly, a systematic review by Choobineh and colleagues (2020) identified
several risk factors for WRMSDs among nurses, including heavy physical
workloads, awkward postures, and insufficient rest breaks. This review also
highlighted the potential benefits of interventions such as ergonomic assessments,
exercise programs, and organizational support for preventing and managing
WRMSDs among nurses.
Overall, the empirical literature suggests that psychological distress and WRMSDs
are significant occupational health issues among nurses, with several risk factors
and preventive measures identified. By synthesizing this existing literature, the
present study aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the relationships
between psychological distress, WRMSDs, and job demands and resources among
nurses in Ekiti State teaching Hospital.
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction
A cross-sectional survey design is appropriate for this study as it allows for the
collection of data from a large and diverse sample of nurses, while also enabling
the investigation of associations between variables of interest (Lavrakas, 2021).
Specifically, the study will involve the administration of a self-administered
questionnaire to a sample of nurses working in Ekiti State Teaching Hospital.
The questionnaire will be developed based on existing validated instruments,
including the Copenhagen Psychosocial Questionnaire (COPSOQ) (Kristensen et
al., 2015) and the Nordic Musculoskeletal Questionnaire (Kuorinka et al., 1987),
which have been widely used in previous studies investigating psychological
distress, WRMSDs, and job demands and resources among healthcare workers.
The demographic and work-related characteristics section will include items such
as age, gender, years of experience, and job position. The psychological distress
section will assess symptoms of psychological distress using a validated
instrument, such as the Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Scale (DASS) (Lovibond &
Lovibond, 1995). The WRMSDs section will assess the prevalence and severity of
WRMSDs among nurses using the Nordic Musculoskeletal Questionnaire
(Kuorinka et al., 1987), which has been validated for use among healthcare
workers (da Costa et al., 2010). Finally, the job demands and resources section
will assess various aspects of job demands and resources using items from the
COPSOQ (Kristensen et al., 2015).
Data analysis will involve descriptive statistics, such as means and standard
deviations, to summarize the demographic and work-related characteristics of the
sample, as well as the prevalence and severity of psychological distress and
WRMSDs. Bivariate and multivariate regression analyses will be used to
investigate the relationships between psychological distress, WRMSDs, and job
demands and resources, while controlling for potential confounding factors.
3.2 Research Design
The research design for this study is a cross-sectional survey design. This design is
appropriate for collecting data at a specific point in time, as it allows for the
collection of data from a large sample within a short period. The cross-sectional
survey design also allows for the collection of data on multiple variables, enabling
the researcher to examine the relationship between variables.
A convenience sampling technique will be used to select the study sample from
the population of nurses working in the hospital. This sampling technique will
enable the researcher to select participants who are readily available and willing
to participate in the study. The sample size will be determined using a sample size
calculator to ensure that the study has adequate power to detect significant
relationships between variables.
Data collected will be analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics, such as
chi-square test, t-test, and logistic regression analysis, to examine the relationship
between variables. The study findings will be disseminated through academic
publications and conference presentations to inform policy and practice in
healthcare facilities.
The research setting for this study is the Ekiti State Teaching Hospital, which is
located in the southwestern region of Nigeria. The hospital is a tertiary healthcare
facility that provides a wide range of specialized healthcare services to patients
from Ekiti State and neighboring states. The hospital has several departments,
including the nursing department, which is the focus of this study.
The population of this study is all nurses working in the Ekiti State Teaching
Hospital. Nurses working in the hospital are eligible to participate in the study
regardless of their department, work experience, or other personal
characteristics.
The hospital has a significant number of nurses working in various units, including
the intensive care unit, emergency unit, general ward, and outpatient clinic. The
exact number of nurses in the hospital is not known, but it is estimated to be
several hundred.
To select the study sample, a convenience sampling technique will be used, and
the sample size will be determined using a sample size calculator to ensure that
the study has adequate power to detect significant relationships between
variables. The sample size will also be determined based on the ethical and
practical considerations of the study, including time and resource constraints.
3.5 Sample Size Determination
The sample size for this study will be determined using a sample size calculator,
which takes into account the population size, margin of error, and confidence
level.
The sample size of 150 nurses will also be determined using a sample size
calculator, with a margin of error of 5% and a confidence level of 95%. The
estimated population of nurses working in the hospital is several hundred, but a
precise number is not known.
The researcher will use a convenience sampling technique to select the sample of
150 nurses. The selection of participants will be based on their availability and
willingness to participate in the study. The researcher will ensure that the sample
is representative of the nursing population in the hospital by selecting
participants from various units and departments.
The sample size of 150 nurses is considered adequate for the study, as it provides
sufficient power to detect significant relationships between variables. The sample
size also takes into account the ethical and practical considerations of the study,
including time and resource constraints.
To calculate the sample size for the study, the researcher used the formula for
determining sample size for a single population proportion. The formula is as
follows:
Where:
Z = the Z-value for the desired level of confidence (in this case, a 95% confidence
level, which corresponds to a Z-value of 1.96)
Using this formula, the sample size calculation for this study is as follows:
n = 384.16
The sampling technique used for this study will be convenience sampling. This
technique involves selecting participants who are readily available and willing to
participate in the study.
The instrumentation used for this study will involve the use of two standardized
and validated questionnaires: the General Health Questionnaire-28 (GHQ-28) and
the Nordic Musculoskeletal Questionnaire (NMQ).
Before administering the questionnaires, the researcher will ensure that the
participants understand the instructions and the purpose of the study. The
participants will also be informed that participation is voluntary, and they can
withdraw from the study at any time. The researcher will also ensure that the
participants provide informed consent before participating in the study.
The pilot study will involve recruiting a small sample of nurses (approximately 10-
15) from the Ekiti State Teaching Hospital, who are similar to the study population
in terms of their demographics and work-related characteristics. The selected
nurses will be asked to complete the GHQ-28 and NMQ questionnaires, and
provide feedback on the clarity, readability, and relevance of the questions.
The data collected from the pilot study will be analyzed using descriptive statistics
to identify any issues with the study design or data collection methods. The
feedback obtained from the participants will be used to refine the study
instruments and make any necessary changes to the study design.
The pilot study will also provide an opportunity to assess the feasibility of the
study and identify any logistical issues, such as the time required to complete the
questionnaires, and any technical difficulties with the online survey platform.
Based on the results of the pilot study, adjustments will be made to the study
design, and the instruments will be finalized for use in the main study. The pilot
study will ensure that the main study is well-designed and will improve the quality
and reliability of the study results.
i. Validity of Instrument
In this study, the validity of the instruments (General Health Questionnaire-
28 and Nordic Musculoskeletal Questionnaire) will be assessed through
construct validity. This involves examining the extent to which the
instruments measure the constructs they are intended to measure. To
assess construct validity, the researcher will examine the correlations
between the instrument items and the relevant constructs. Additionally,
the researcher will conduct factor analysis to determine the underlying
factor structure of the instruments. A confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) will
also be conducted to confirm the factor structure identified in the
exploratory factor analysis (EFA). The results of these analyses will provide
evidence of the validity of the instruments and support the use of these
instruments in the study.
The data for this study will be collected using a self-administered questionnaire.
The questionnaire will consist of two parts: the General Health Questionnaire-28
(GHQ-28) and the Nordic Musculoskeletal Questionnaire (NMQ). The GHQ-28 will
be used to assess psychological distress, while the NMQ will be used to assess
work-related musculoskeletal disorders. The questionnaire will be distributed to
the selected sample of 150 nurses working in the Ekiti State Teaching Hospital.
The participants will be given clear instructions on how to complete the
questionnaire, and they will be asked to return the completed questionnaires
within a week. To ensure the quality of data collected, the researcher will be
available to provide clarification on any questions or items in the questionnaire.
The data collected will be kept confidential and anonymous to ensure the privacy
of the participants.
3.11. Method of Data Analysis
The data collected in this study will be analyzed using statistical software such as
SPSS or STATA. Descriptive statistics such as frequencies, percentages, means, and
standard deviations will be used to summarize the demographic characteristics of
the study participants and the variables of interest. Inferential statistics such as
correlation analysis, t-tests, and regression analysis will be used to examine the
relationships between psychological distress, work-related musculoskeletal
disorders, and other variables of interest. A significance level of 0.05 will be used
to determine statistical significance. The results of the analyses will be presented
in tables and graphs and will be discussed in the context of the study objectives
and research questions.
This study will be conducted in accordance with ethical principles and guidelines
for research involving human subjects. The study will obtain ethical clearance
from the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of the Ekiti State Teaching Hospital
before data collection. Informed consent will be obtained from each participant
before they are enrolled in the study. The participants will be informed of the
purpose of the study, the procedures involved, the potential risks and benefits,
and their right to withdraw from the study at any time. The confidentiality of the
participants will be maintained, and all data will be kept secure and anonymous.
The study will adhere to the principles of non-maleficence, beneficence, justice,
and respect for persons in the conduct of research involving human subjects. Any
potential conflicts of interest will be disclosed, and the study will be conducted
with integrity and honesty.
PSYCHOLOGICALDISTRESSANDWORKRELATEDMUSCULOSKELETALDISORDERSAMONGNURSES
WORKNGINEKITISTATETEACHINGHOSPITAL
QUESTIONARE
Thisquestionnaireisaboutyourjoint,back,neck,boneandmusclesymptomssuchasaches,painsand/
orstiffness.
Pleasefocusontheparticularhealthproblem(s)forwhichyousoughttreatmentfromthisservice.
Section1:DemographicInformation
Foreachquestiontick()oneormoreoftheboxestoindicatewhichstatementbestdescribesyou
1.AreyouaRegisteredNurse Yes No
Section2:Work-RelatedMusculoskeletalDisorders
4.Haveyoueverexpe Yes. No
riencedanywork-
relatedmusculoskel
etaldisorders
5.Ifyes,pleasedescri (a)Neckpain.(b)Backpain.
bethetypeandlocati
onoftheinjury. (c)Shoulderpain.(d).Elbowpain
(e)Wrist/handpain(f)Hippain.
(g)Kneepain.(h)Ankle/footpain
(i)Other(pleasespecify).....................................
6.Haveyoueverhadtotaketim Yes No
eoffworkduetoawork-
relatedinjuryorillness?
7.Didyouseekmedicalattenti Yes No
onforthispainordiscomfort?
Section4:CopingStrategies