ID Metodologi Pendidikan Al Ibrah Dalam Al

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 16

+VSOBM*MNJBI%*%",5*,""HVTUVT

70-9**/0 

.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-".
"-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU


*TNBJM"OTBSJ
.BIBTJTXBQSPHSBN%PLUPSBMQBEB6OJWFSTJUZ4BJOT.BMBZTJB .BMBZTJB 
"CTUSBDU
*CSBIJTBDPOEJUJPOJOXIJDITPNFPOFSFBDIBOBCTUSBDULOPXMFEHFGSPNBDPODSFUFPOF
UISPVHIPCTFSWBUJPOBOEDPOUFNQMBUJPOUPLOPXUIFDPSFPGDFSUBJOQSPCMFNCZPCTFSWJOH 
UFTUJGZJOH DPOTJEFSJOH NFBTVSJOHBOEEFDJEJOHMPHJDBMMZVOUJMIBWJOHUIFDPODMVTJPOUIBU
DBOBGGFDUTPNFPOFTIFBSUUPPCFZ"MMBI*O"M2VSBO UIFSFBSFWBSJPVTJOTUBODFTPG*CSBI
EFQFOEPOUIFPCKFDUPGJCSBIJUTFMGTVDIBTJOUIFGPSNPGTUPSZ TUPSZPG"MMBITDSFBUVSFT 
TUPSZPG)JTHSBDF BOEBMTPJOUIFGPSNPGIJTUPSJDBMFWFOUT0OFPGJCSBIUIBUJTGPVOEJO
"M2VSBOJTBEJBMPHVFCFUXFFO1SPQIFU*CSBIJNBOEIJTGBUIFSJO4VSBI.BSZBNWFSTF


"CTUSBL
*CSBI NFSVQBLBO LPOEJTJ ZBOH NFNVOHLJOLBO PSBOH TBNQBJ EBSJ QFOHFUBIVBO ZBOH
LPOLSJU LFQBEB QFOHFUBIVBO BCTUSBL  EBMBN CFOUVL QFOHBNBUBO EBO UBGBLVS ZBOH
NFOHIBOUBSLBO NBOVTJB VOUVL NFOHFUBIVJ JOUJTBSJ TVBUV QFSLBSB EFOHBO DBSB
EJTBLTJLBO  EJQFSIBUJLBO  EJJOEVLTJ  EJUJNCBOHUJNCBOH  EJVLVS EBO EJQVUVTLBO PMFI
NBOVTJB TFDBSB OBMBS  TFIJOHHB LFTJNQVMBOOZB EBQBU NFNQFOHBSVIJ IBUJ NFOKBEJ
UVOEVL LFQBEB/ZB $POUPIDPOUPI *CSBI EBMBN "M2VSBO CFSCFEBCFEB  TFMBSBT
EFOHBO QFSCFEBBO PCKFL JCSBI JUV TFOEJSJ  BEB EBMBN CFOUVL LJTBI  DFSJUB NBLIMVL
NBLIMVL"MMBIEBOOJLNBUOJLNBU/ZB EBO*CSBIEBSJQFSJTUJXBQFSJTUJXBTFKBSBI4BMBI
TBUVOZB BEBMBI %JBMPH /BCJ *CSBIJN EFOHBO BZBIOZB ZBOH UFSEBQBU EBMBN TVSBU
.BSZBNBZBU

,BUB,VODJNFUPEPMPHJQFOEJEJLBO JCSBI LBKJBO

1&/%")6-6"/

/BCJ BUBV 3BTVM BEBMBI NBOVTJB UFSQJMJI EJ BOUBSB TFLJBO CBOZBL NBOVTJB
EBSJTVBUV[BNBOZBOHCFSUVHBTNFOZBNQBJLBOBKBSBO5VIBOLFQBEBTFMVSVIBUBV
TFLFMPNQPLNBOVTJB.FOVSVU"CVM"MBBM.BVEVEJZ3BTVMBEBMBINBOVTJBZBOH
EJVUVT "MMBI ZBOH UVHBTOZB NFOZBNQBJLBO TZBSJBUOZB LFQBEB VNBU NBOVTJB
.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-"."-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU

EFOHBO NFOFSKFNBILBO BKBSBO UFSTFCVU EFOHBO VDBQBO EBOQFSCVBUBOOZB 3BTVM


BEBMBI NBOVTJB ZBOH NFXBLJMJ LFLVBTBBO UFSUJOHHJ EJ CJEBOH QSBOBUB LFIJEVQBO
NBOVTJBEJCVNJ

#FSEBTBSLBOIBMJOJ NBLBTFPSBOH/BCJUFMBINFNJMJLJSFQVUBTJNPSBMZBOH
UBOHHVIEBONFNJMJLJSFTJTUFOTJUFSIBEBQSFBMJUBTTVBUVNBTZBSBLBUZBOHNFOKBEJ
VNBUOZBEFOHBOHBZBIJEVQZBOHTBOHBULPOUSBEJLUJGEFOHBONJTJZBOHEJCBXBOZB
5BOUBOHBO ZBOH BLBO EJIBEBQJ CBJL EBMBN CFOUVL JOUJNJEBTJ GJTJL TBNQBJ QBEB
CFOUVL JOUJNJEBTJ NFOUBM UJEBL IBOZB EBUBOH EBSJ NBTZBSBLBUOZB TFDBSB VNVN
CBILBOMFCJILIVTVTMBHJEBUBOHEBSJLBMBOHBOLFMVBSHBOZBTFOEJSJ

6OUVL NFOHIBEBQJ TFNVB UBOUBOHBO UFSTFCVU EBMBN NFOKBMBOLBO TFCVBI


VQBZBQFOZBNQBJBOSJTBMBI NBLBTFDBSBNFOUBMTFPSBOH/BCJUFMBIEJCFOUVLEBO
EJQFSTJBQLBO TFEFNJLJBO SVQB TFIJOHHB CBHBJNBOBQVO CFOUVL UBOUBOHBO ZBOH
BLBO EJIBEBQJ UJEBL BLBO NFMVOUVSLBO TQJSJU KVBOH QBSB /BCJ JUV *EFOUJGJLBTJ
LFOBCJBO JOJ UFMBI NVODVM TFKBL /BCJ JUV NBTJI LFDJM TFIJOHHB CFSMBOKVU TBNQBJ
EFXBTB$JSJVNVNJOJEBQBUEJBNBUJQBEBUJOHLBIMBLVZBOHCBJLTFCBHBJSFGMFLTJ
CJNCJOHBO5VIBOZBOHTBOHBUCFSUPMBLCFMBLBOHEFOHBOQFSJMBLVNBTZBSBLBUQBEB
VNVNOZBNFNBOH LPOEJTJ NBTZBSBLBU ZBOH TFQFSUJ JUVMBI TFPSBOH OBCJ
EJCVUVILBOTFCBHBJQFNCJNCJOHNFSFLB

4FCBHBJ NBOVTJB QJMJIBO 5VIBO  NBLB TFPSBOH /BCJ UJEBL QFSOBI MBSVU
EBMBN JSBNB QFSJMBLV NBZPSJUBT NBTZBSBLBUOZB ZBOH NFOZJNQBOH EBSJ BKBSBO
5VIBO ZBOH EJFNCBOOZB /BCJ UFSQFMJIBSB EBSJ CFSCBHBJ NBDBN CFOUVL
LFUJNQBOHBOZBOHEJMBLVLBOVNBUOZB*OJNFSVQBLBOTBMBITBUVCVLUJLFUFSMJCBUBO
5VIBO EBMBN NFOKBHB LFTUBCJMBO EJSJ TFSUB EFEJLBTJ ZBOH NBQBO UFSIBEBQ UVHBT
LFSBTVMBOOZB

%BMBNEBXBIOZB NFSFLBUJEBLKBSBOHVOUVLCFSIBEBQBOMBOHTVOHEFOHBO
BOHHPUBLFMVBSHBOZBTFOEJSJ XBMBVQVOCFSCBHBJQFOEFLBUBOZBOHEJMBLVLBOVOUVL
NFOHVCBI QSJOTJQ ZBOH TBOHBU NFOHBLBS ZBOH LFNVEJBO CFSLFNCBOH NFOKBEJ
TVBUV LFZBLJOBO ZBOH LVBU 'BLUB TFKBSBI NFOVOKVLLBO CBIXB QBEB TFUJBQ GBTF
BXBM EBSJ EBXBI /BCJ CBDB .VIBNNBE  TBOHBU TVMJU EJUFSJNB TFCBHBJ TFTVBUV

"CV "MB "M.BVEVEJZ  ,IBMJGBI EBO ,FSBKBBO &WBMVBTJ ,SJUJT 5FSIBEBQ 4FKBSBI EBO
1FNFSJOUBIBO*TMBN .VIBNNBEBM#BRJS $FU*7 #BOEVOH.J[BO  IBM

]+VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT


*TNBJM"OTBSJ

ZBOH CBSV EBO IBSVT EJUFSJNB 1FSUFOUBOHBO EFNJ QFSUFOUBOHBO TFDBSB UFSVT
NFOFSVTCFSMBOHTVOHTFQBOKBOHQFSKBMBOBOQFOZBNQBJBOBKBSBO5VIBO

%BSJ CFSCBHBJ NBDBN JOEJLBTJ ZBOH EJOZBUBLBO "M2VSBO NFOVOKVLLBO


CBIXB QBSB /BCJ JUV UFMBI NFOKBMBOLBO NJTTJ LFSBTVMBOOZB  TFDBSB NBLTJNBM
EFOHBO TFHFOBQ VQBZB UFMBI EJLFSBILBO VOUVL NFOHFNCBMJLBO NBOVTJB LFKBMBO
ZBOHCFOBSTFTVBJEFOHBOGJUSBILFNBOVTJBOOZB.JTJNFSFLBQBEBEBTBSOZBTBNB 
ZBJUV NFOZBNQBJLBO TFSUB NFNQFSLFOBMLBO 5VIBO CFSTBNB EFOHBO BKBSBOOZB
ZBOH CFSJTJ CJNCJOHBO IJEVQ LFQBEBTFMVSVI VNNBU NBOVTJB .FNQFSLFOBMLBO
CBIXB 5VIBO ZBOH IBSVT EJTFNCBI IBOZBMBI "MMBI 4VCIBOBIV XB 5BBMB  TFMBJO
EBSJ/ZBBEBMBINBLIMVLZBOHUJEBLNFNQVOZBJMFHBMJUBTBQBQVO

#FSCBHBJ QFOEFLBUBO UFMBI EJMBLVLBO PMFI QBSB /BCJ CBJL CFSVQB BKBLBO
EBXBI CJM MJTBO  TJLBQ IJEVQ EBXBI CJM IBM  #BILBO VOUVL NFNQFSLVBU NJTTJ
LFOBCJBOOZB QBSB/BCJEJCFLBMJEFOHBOCFSCBHBJNPEFMiLFMFCJIBOTVQSBOBUVSBMi
BUBV EBMBN MJUFSBUVSF LFBHBNBBO EJTFCVU iNVLKJ[BUi .VLKJ[BU NFSVQBLBO TBMBI
TBUV QFNCVLUJBO LFCFOBSBO EBSJ KBSBO ZBOH EJTBNQBJLBOOZB .VLKJ[BU JUV
EJUVOKVLLBO NBOBLBMB EJCVUVILBO PMFI LFBEBBO EBO TFTVBJEFOHBO LFDFOESVOHBO
VNNBUOZB4FIJOHHBNVLKJ[BUEJBOUBSBQSB/BCJJUVCFSCFEBCFEB

"MMBI 4VCIBOBIV XB 5BBMBUFMBI NFOHVUVT QBSB /BCJ/ZB EJNVLB CVNJ


NVMBJ EBSJ "EBN BMBJIJTTBMBN TBNQBJ LFQBEB /BCJ .VIBNNBE BMMBMM IV ABMBZIJ
XB 4BMMBN  i%BO TFTVOHHVIOZB LBNJ UFMBI NFOHVUVT SBTVM QBEB UJBQUJBQ VNNBU
VOUVLNFOZFSVLBO TFNCBIMBI"MMBI TBKB EBOKBVIJMBIUIBHIVUJUVi 24 
.FSFLB LBNJ VUVT TFCBHBJ SBTVMSBTVM QFNCBXB CFSJUB HFNCJSB EBO QFNCFSJ
QFSJOHBUBO BHBS UJEBL BEB BMBTBO CBHJ NBOVTJB VOUVL NFNCBOUBI "MMBI TFTVEBI
EJEBUBOHLBO SBTVMSBTVM JUV 24   %BO TFTVOHHVIOZB UFMBI LBNJ VUVT
CFCFSBQB PSBOH SBTVM TFCFMVN LBNV  EJ BOUBSB NFSFLB BEB ZBOH LBNJ DFSJUBLBO
LFQBEBLBNVEBOEJBOUBSBNFSFLBBEBZBOHUJEBLLBNJDFSJUBLBOLFQBEBNV 24
 

%JBMPH /BCJ *CSBIJN BMBJIJTTBMBN EFOHBO BZBIOZB  NFSVQBLBO QSBHNFO


TFKBSBI VNNBU NBOVTJB  QSBHNFO TFCVBI QFSHVNVMBO EBMBN NFNQFSLFOBMLBO
EBO NFNQFSUBIBOLBO TVBUV LFCFOBSBO ZBOH IBLJLJ EFOHBO KBMBO QFOEFLBUBO
QFSTVBTJ LPNVOJLBTJZBOHTBOHBUEJBMSHUJT4VBUVQFSHVNVMBOEFOHBOQFODFSBIBO
EFOHBO LFTFTBUBO .BOVTJB  *CSBIJN EBO BZBIOZB NFSVQBLBO TJNCPM NBOVTJB



  +VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT]


.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-"."-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU

ZBOHTBNBTBNBNFNQFSUBIBOLBOLFZBLJOBONBTJOHNBTJOHZBOHTBMJOHCFSUPMBL
CFMBLBOHEBOUJEBLBLBOQFSOBIEBQBUEJQFSUFNVLBOTBNQBJLBQBOQVO

/BCJ *CSBIJN NFODPCB NFNCVLB DBLSBXBMB QFNJLJSBO BZBIOZB EFOHBO


NFOBXBSLBOTFCVBILFQBTUJBOZBOHEJUFSJNBEBSJ5VIBO:BOH.BIB,VBTB CVLBO
5VIBO ZBOH MFNBI TFQFSUJ QBUVOHQBUVOH ZBOH QFSOBI EJDJQUBLBO PMFI
BZBIOZBEJBMPH ZBOH EJTJUJS "M2VSBO EBMBN TVSBU .BSZBN BZBU   ZBOH TBSBU
EFOHBO QFTBO NPSBM JOJ  UFMBI NFOHVOHLBQLBO CBHBJNBOB LFLVGVSBO JOJ EBQBU
NFOVUVQJ EBO NFOHFOZBILBO UFSCVLBOZB BLBM TFIBU GJUSBI  NBOVTJB EBMBN
NFODFSOB LFCFOBSBOCFUBQB TFTVBUV ZBOH UFMBI NFMFLBU TFCBHBJ USBEJTJ ZBOH UFMBI
CFSMBOHTVOHTFDBSBUVSVOUFNVSVOEBMBNSFOUBOHBOXBLUVTVMJUVOUVLEJSVCBI

i&OEJOHw EBSJ LPNVOJBTJ EVB BSBI JOJ CFSBLIJS EFOHBO HBHBMOZB *CSBIJN
NFNCVLB QJOUV DBLSBXBMB QJLJSBO TBOH BZBI %BMBN IBM JOJ BZBI NFOHBOHHBQ
*CSBIJN UFMBI CFSBOJ NFOHHPZBOH TUBCJMJUBT NFOUBM LFQFSDBZBBOOZB ZBOH UFMBI
UFSQBUSJ QBEB EJSJOZB TFCBHBJ XBSJTBO OFOFL NPZBOH ZBOH UJEBL CPMFI EJVTJL PMFI
TJBQBQVO UFSNBTVL BOBLOZB TFOEJSJ  /BCJ *CSBIJN *OJMBI CBSBOHLBMJ TVBUV
i&HPJTNFiVNNBUNBOVTJBTFQBOKBOHTFKBSBIQFSBEBCBOOZB

+JLB LJUB NFOHLBJULBO QFSJTUJXB TFKBSBI  iQFSHVMBUBO BOUBSB LFCFOBSBO EBO


LFNVTZSJLBOi JOJ LFEBMBN QFSTQFLUJG QFOEJEJLBO *TMBN  TFEJLJU CBOZBLOZB LJUB
EBQBU NFNFUJL CFCFSBQB IBM  TFQFSUJ BTQFL QFOEJEJLBO BQB TBKB ZBOH UFSLBOEVOH 
CBHBJNBOBQFOEFLBUBOZBOHEJHVOBLBOEBOCBHBJNBOBQVMBSFMFWBOTJBOUBSBLFEVB
BTQFLJOJEBMBNUFSNJOPMPHJQFOEJEJLBO*TMBNLIVTVTOZB%BMBNEJBMPHJOJQBMJOH
UJEBL BEB EVB BTQFL QFOEJEJLBO :BJUV BTQFL QFOEJEJLBO NPSBM BLIMBL  JOJ EBQBU
EJBOBMJTB EBSJ FUJLB /BCJ *CSBIJN EBMBN NFOHBKBL BZBIOZB VOUVL NFOJOHHBMLBO
BMBN LFHFMBQBO LFNVTZSJLBO  EBO BTQFL QFOEJEJLBO BRJEBI LFJNBOBO  JOJ KVHB
EBQBU EJMJIBU EBSJ TFHJ JTJ QFTBO  BKBLBO /BCJ *CSBIJN LFQBEB BZBIOZB VOUVL
NFOZFNCBI "MMBI TFCBHBJ 5VIBO ZBOH NFODJQUBLBO EBO NFNFMJIBSB TFNVB
NBLIMVLDJQUBBO/ZB

3FMFWBOTJ LFEVB BTQFL EJ BUBT EBMBN UFSNJOPMPHJ QFOEJEJLBO TBOHBU


NFOHJLBU EBO CFSLBJUBO FSBU *TMBN BEBMBI BHBNB LFEBNBJBO  NBLB EBMBN
NFNQFSLFOBMLBO *TMBN BQBQVO BMBTBOOZB UJEBL EJCFOBSLBO NFMBLVLBO TFDBSB
UPUBMJUFS NFMBJOLBO EFOHBO QFOVI LFCJKBLTBOBBO TFSUB EJJSJOHJ EFOHBO BSHVNFO

]+VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT


*TNBJM"OTBSJ

BSHVNFOZBOHMPHJT 24  1FOEJEJLBO*TMBNBEBMBIQFOEJEJLBOZBOH


VUVIEBOJOUFHSBMBOUBSTFNVBBTQFL

1&.#")"4"/

1SPGJM/BCJ*CSBIJN

/BCJ *CSBIJN BMBJIJTTBMBN BEBMBI TBMBI TFPSBOH EBSJ  3BTVM "MMBI ZBOH
UFMBIEJVUVTLFQBEBVNNBUNBOVTJBTFQBOKBOHTFKBSBILFIJEVQBOVNNBUNBOVTJB
ZBJUVNVMBJEBSJ/BCJ"EBNTFCBHBJNBOVTJBQFSUBNBTFLBMJHVT/BCJZBOHQFSUBNB
TBNQBJ LFQBEB /BCJ ZBOH UFSBLIJS .VIBNNBE BMMBMM IV ABMBZIJ XB
4BMMBNTFCBHBJNBOBZBOHUFMBIEJVOHLBQLBOEBMBN"M2VSBOi%BOUJEBLBEBTVBUV
VNNBU NFMBJOLBO UFMBI BEB TFPSBOH /BCJ QFNCFSJ QFSJOHBUBO LFQBEB NFSFLBi
24 /BCJ*CSBIJNBMBJIJTTBMBNBEBMBI/BCJZBOHLFFOBNEBSJ/BCJZBOH
IBSVTEJZBLJOJPMFITFUJBQNVTMJN.FOVSVUBOHHBQBOCFCFSBQBPSBOHCBIXB/BCJ
*CSBIJN BEBMBI OFOFL NPZBOH CBOHTB :BIVEJ  ,SJTUFO EBO *TMBN /BNVO "M
2VSBONFNCBOUBIBOHHBQBOCBIXBBEBIBMIBMZBOHEBSJ:BIVEJEBO,SJTUFOQBEB
EJSJ*CSBIJNi*CSBIJNCVLBOMBITFPSBOH:BIVEJ EBOCVLBOQVMBTFPSBOH/BTSBOJ
UFUBQJ JB BEBMBI TFPSBOH ZBOH MVSVT MBHJ NFOZFSBI EJSJ LFQBEB "MMBI  TFPSBOH
NVTMJNw 24 "M2VSBOMFCJIMBOKVUNFOKFMBTLBOCBIXBQFOEJSJBTBMVNNBU
NBOVTJB NBTZBSBLBU*TMBN BEBMBI/BCJ*CSBIJNBMBJIJTTBMBN 24 

%JEBMBN"MRVSBOOBNB*CSBIJNEJTFCVULBOEFOHBOVUVITFCBOZBLLBMJ
ZBJUVTFLBMJUFSTVTVOEBMBNBZBUBZBUOZBEBOTBUVLBMJVOUVLOBNBTFCVBITVSBU
*CSBIJNBEBMBIOBNBTFPSBOH/BCJEBOSBTVMVUVTBO"MMBI iTFTVOHHVIOZB*CSBIJO
JUVBEBMBITFPSBOH/BCJZBOHCFOBSw 24 

4FCBHBJ CBQBL EBSJ LFUJHB BHBNB TBNBXJ UFSCFTBS UFMBI NFOHBOUBSLBOOZB


NFOKBEJ iQJPOFSi NPOPUIFJTNF  TFIJOHHB OBNB /BCJ *CSBIJN TFMBMV EJTFCVU EBO
EJIVCVOHLBOEFOHBOQFOHIPSNBUBO EPBEBOLFBHVOHBOi"M2VSBOEFOHBOKFMBT


 "CEVSSBINBO 4BMFI  5FPSJ 1FOEJEJLBO #FSEBTBSLBO "M2VSBO  BMJI CBIBTB . "SJGJO 
+BLBSUB3JOFLB$JQUB  IBM

.B[IFSVEEJO4JEEJRJZ ,POTFQ"M2VSBO5FOUBOH4FKBSBI +BLBSUB1VTUBLB'JSEBVT  
IBM

%FQBSUFNFO"HBNB3* &OTJLMPQFEJB*TMBNEJ*OEPOFTJB  +BLBSUB IBM



  +VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT]


.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-"."-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU

EBO TFJNCBOH UFMBI NFOKFMBTLBO LFEVEVLBO /BCJ *CSBIJN TFCBHBJ UPLPI MVIVS
QBSB/BCJEBO3BTVM CFMJBVBEBMBICBQBLMFMVIVS*TMBNEBONVTMJNTFEVOJBw

4FCBHBJNBOB ZBOH UFMBI EJKFMBTLBO TFCFMVNOZB  CBIXB ZBOH UFMBI


NFOHBOUBSLBO/BCJ*CSBIJNQBEBKBKBSBO/BCJUFSQJMJI VMVMB[NJ BEBMBISFQVUBTJ
NPSBMOZB ZBOH UJOHHJ EBO BHVOH *B BEBMBI UFMBEBO ZBOH CBJL CBHJ NBOVTJB 
wy4FTVOHHVIOZB "LV UFMBI NFOHBOHLBU FOHLBV IBJ *CSBIJN NFOKBEJ JNBN
PSBOH JLVUBO  CBHJ NBOVTJB i 24   %J TBNQJOH JUV  EBSJ LFUVSVOBO /BCJ
*CSBIJN JOJMBI OBOUJOZB MBIJS LFUVSVOBO #BOJ *TSBJM EBSJ BOBLOZB *TIBR ZBOH
NFMBIJSLBO/BCJ:BDPCZBOHEJKVMVLJ#BQBL#BOJ*TSBJM%BSJLFUVSVOBO#BOJ*TSBJM
JUVCBOZBLNFOFMPSLBOQBSB/BCJEBOCFSBLIJSQBEB/BCJ*TBBMBJIJTTBMBN

%JEBMBN,JUBC1FSKBOKJBO#BSVEJTFCVULBO CBIXB*TBQVUSB.BSZBNUFMBI
CFSLBUB QBEB QBSB QFOHJLVUOZB UFOUBOH /BCJ *CSBIJN *CSBIJN BEBMBI PSBOH UVB
LBNV  JB CFSHFNCJSB IJOHHB NFMJIBU NBTBLV TFLBSBOH JOJ  JB NFMJIBU NBLB
CFSHFNCJSBMBI JB  4FKBMBO EFOHBO QFSOZBUBBO ZBOH UFSNBLUVC EBMBN ,JUBC
1FSKBOKJBO #BSV UFSTFCVU  "M2VSBO TFDBSB MFCJI HBNCMBOH NFOHVUBSBLBO
LFNVMJBBO/BCJ*CSBIJNEFOHBOTFCVBILBMJNBUZBOHCFSCFOUVLQFSUBOZBBOZBOH
TBOHBU NFOHHFMJUJL CBHJ PSBOH ZBOH NFOEFOHBSOZB i4JBQBLBI ZBOH MFCJI CBJL
BHBNBOZB EBSJ PSBOH ZBOH NFOVOEVLLBO NVLBOZB LFQBEB "MMBI  TFEBOH JB
CFSCVBU LFCBKJLBO EBO NFOHJLVUJ BHBNB /BCJ *CSBIJN ZBOH MVSVT  "MMBI UFMBI
NFOHBOHLBU /BCJ *CSBIJN TFCBHBJ TVSJ UBVMBEBOi 24   %J EBMBN BZBU JOJ
EFOHBO KFMBT EBQBU EJQBIBNJ CBIXB /BCJ *CSBIJN BEBMBI QSPGJM QFNFSTBUV UJHB
BHBNB CFTBS TBNBXJ EBMBN TBUV EJNFOTJ LFUBVIJEBO ZBOH NVSOJ TFSUB IBOJG %J
CBXBI QBOKJQBOKJ BKBSBO UBVIJE JOJMBI /BCJ *CSBIJN NFNCFOUVL TVBUV VNNBU 
TFIJOHHB "MMBI NFOKFMBTLBO CBIXB /BCJ *CSBIJN TFOEJSJ BEBMBI TVBUV VNNBU
"SUJOZBJBTFOEJSJNFSVQBLBOVNNBUEJBOUBSBVNNBUVNNBUEBMBNTBUVQSJOTJQ
BRJEBIZBOHTBNB

%J BOUBSB TVNCFSTVNCFS TFKBSBI ZBOH CBOZBL NFOHVOHLBQLBO TJBQB


TFCFOBSOZB TPTPL /BCJ *CSBIJN EBMBN "M2VSBO "M2VSBOMBI ZBOH NFOKFMBTLBO
IBMIBMZBOHTBOHBUQSJOTJQJMEBONFOEBTBSUFOUBOH/BCJ*CSBIJNTFCBHBJNBOVTJB


%FQBSUFNFO"HBNB3* &OTJLMPQFEJB*TMBNy IBM

 %FQBSUFNFO"HBNB3* %JSKFO#JNBT,BUPMJL ,JUBC1FSKBOKJBO#BSV +PIBOOFT $FU7*** 
 IBM

]+VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT


*TNBJM"OTBSJ

CJBTB EBO TFCBHBJ TFPSBOH /BCJ ZBOH NFNCBXB TZBSJBU EBSJ 5VIBO TFCBHBJNBOB
TFKVNMBIBZBUCBJLZBOHUFMBIEJLVUJQNBVQVOZBOHBLBOEJLVUJQOBOUJOZB

6OUVL MFCJI NFNQFSKFMBT UFOUBOH QSPGJM /BCJ *CSBIJN UFSVUBNB EBSJ BTQFL
LFNBOVTJBBOOZB EBMBN IVCVOHBOOZB EFOHBO BKBSBO UBVIJE ZBOH EJSJTBMBILBO
LFQBEBOZB NBLBBEBTFCBJLOZBEJQBQBSLBOTFEJLJUUFOUBOHCJPHSBGJ LFIJEVQBOOZB
EBO TFEJLJU MBUBS CFMBLBOH QFSHVNVMBO BOUBSB MJOHLVOHBO UFNQBU EJNBOB JB
NFOZBNQBJLBO SJTBMBI LFOBCJBOOZB ,BSFOB VOUVL NFOZJOHLBQ QBOKBOH MFCBS
UFOUBOH CJPHSBGJ VUVI /BCJ *CSBIJN EJUBOUBOH PMFI CBOZBL LFOEBMB  ZBJUV TVMJUOZB
NFNQFSPMFI JOGPSNBTJ ZBOH MFOHLBQ .FOVSVU CFCFSBQB MJUFSBUVSF TFKBSBI *TMBN
ZBOH EJUVMJTPMFI TFHFMJOUJS TFKBSBXBO NVTMJNNFOZFCVULBO  CBIXB /BCJ *CSBIJN
EJMBIJSLBO EJ #BCJMPOJB QBEB [BNBO QFNFSJOUBIBO 3BKB /BNSV[ ZBOH UFSLFOBM
EBMBN TFKBSBI TFCBHBJ SBKB EJLUBUPS ZBOH LPOPO MBHJ NFOHBLV EJSJOZB TFCBHBJ
5VIBO 4FDBSB HFPHSBGJT EBFSBI JOJ EJLFOBM TFCBHBJ LBXBTBO ZBOH TBOHBU TVCVS 
LBSFOBCFSBEBQFSTJTEJTFQBOKBOHBMJSBOTVOHBJ5JHHSJTEBO&VGSBU *SBLTFLBSBOH 
/BNVO LFNBLNVSBO LFIJEVQBO NBTZBSBLBUOZB UJEBL EJJNCBOHJ EFOHBO JLMJN
LFCFCBTBOCFSGJLJSZBOHCFOBS%JUBNCBIMBHJEFOHBOMBUBSCFMBLBOHLFMVBSHBZBOH
TBNBTFLBMJUJEBLNFOVNCVILFNCBOHLBOOJMBJOJMBJLFUBVIJEBO%JUFOHBIUFOHBI
LFHFMBQBO QFSBEBCBO EBO USBEJTJ TFQFSUJ JOJMBI /BCJ *CSBIJN EJMBIJSLBO "ZBIOZB
ZBOH CFSOBNB "[BS  TFPSBOH QFOZFNCBI CFSIBMB EBO BIMJ QFOHVLJS QBUVOH ZBOH
EJKBEJLBO TFTFNCBIBO NBTZBSBLBU QBEB XBLUV JUV %J CBMJL TFNVB GFOPNFOB JOJ
TFBLBOBLBOUFSHBNCBSTVBUVQFOHIBSBQBODFSBINBOBLBMB/BCJ*CSBIJNMBIJSEBO
IBEJSEJUFOHBIUFOHBILFNVTZSJLBOJUV

4BMBITBUVLFNBOEFLBOCFSGJLJSVNNBU/BCJ*CSBIJNBEBMBINBTJILVBUOZB
LFQFSDBZBBONBTZBSBLBUMVBTCBILBO3BKB/BNSV[TFOEJSJUFSIBEBQiQBSBOPSNBMi
BUBV BIMJ OVKVN #BILBO EBMBN TUSBUB NBTZBSBLBU BIMJ OVKVN NFSVQBLBO FMJU
UFSTFOEJSJZBOHTBOHBUCFTBSQFOHBSVIOZBEBMBNLFCJKBLBOLFCJKBLBOQFNFSJOUBIBO
3BKB /BNSV[ UFSIBEBQ KBMBOOZB SPEB QFNFSJOUBIBO EBO LFEJLUBUPSBOOZB (FKBMB
BUBV LFDFOESVOHBO TFNBDBN JOJ TFDBSB UJEBL MBOHTVOH NFOBOEBLBO CBIXB
LFCJKBLBO ZBOH EJKBMBOLBO CVLBO CFSEBTBSLBO BLBM QJLJSBO ZBOH TFIBU OBNVO
CFSQJKBLQBEBIBXBOBGTVFNPTJPOBMCFMBLBZBOHTBNBTFLBMJUJEBLEFNPLSBUJT

1VODBLEBSJLF[BMJNBOJOJUFSKBEJNBOBLBMB3BKB/BNSV[BEBTVBUVNBMBN
CFSNJNQJ UFOUBOH TFPSBOH BOBL MBLJMBLJ ZBOH NFODBCVU NBILPUB EJ LFQBMBOZB
.BLB BIMJ OVKVN TFHFSB NFNQSFEJLTJLBO CBIXB EBMBN XBLUV EFLBU TUBCJMJUBT



  +VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT]


.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-"."-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU

LFLVBTBBO/BNSV[BLBOEJSVOUVILBOPMFITFPSBOHBOBLMBLJMBLJ%BOTBBUJUVKVHB
/BNSV[ NFOHFMVBSLBO LFCJKBLBO UFSCBSVOZB VOUVL NFNCVOVI TFUJBQ BOBL MBLJ
MBLJ ZBOH MBIJS  EJ UFOHBI LFUJEBLNFOFOUVBO JUVMBI /BCJ *CSBIJN MBIJS EFOHBO
TFMBNBU EJUBLEJSLBO "MMBI EBO BUBT VTBIB JCVOZB NFOZFNCVOZJLBO LFEBMBN
TFCVBIHVBEJIVUBOCFMBOUBSBTBNQBJCFMJBVEFXBTB*OJMBIVKJBOQFSUBNBZBOHEJ
BMBNJ PMFI /BCJ *CSBIJN EBMBN QFOHBMBNBO IJEVQOZB  VOUVL TFUFSVTOZB "MMBI
BLBO UFSVT NFOHVKJOZB EFOHBO DPCBBODPCBBO ZBOH MFCJI CFSBU  EFOHBO UVKVBO
UJEBLMBJOBEBMBIVOUVLNFOFHVILBOIBUJEBOLFZBLJOBO LFJNBOBO /BCJ*CSBIJN
UFSIBEBQOZB

%BO UFSOZBUB QFSHVMBUBO BLBM ZBOH NVSOJ NBOVTJB TFNBUBNBUB UBOQB


IJEBZBI5VIBOUJEBLBLBONFNCFSJLBOUJUJLUFSBOHLFQBEBNBOVTJBEBMBNNFODBSJ
IBLJLBUTVBUVLFCFOBSBO4FJSJOHEFOHBOTFNBLJONBUBOHOZBJOUFMFLUVBMJTBTJ/BCJ
*CSBIJNNVMBJNFOZFCBSLBOSJTBMBIOZBEFOHBONFNBKVLBOEBZBOBMBSOZBEFOHBO
XBIZV ZBOH EJUFSJNB EBSJ 5VIBO 4FCBHBJNBOB EJLFUBIVJ CBIXB LBVN /BCJ
*CSBIJN TBOHBU TVLBS EJBSBILBO EBO EJCFSJ OBTFIBU  BEBOZB BMBTBO EBO CBOUBIBO
ZBOHTFOHBKBNFSFLBSFLBZBTBVOUVLNFNFOBOHLBOQFOEBQBUOZB/BNVOEFOHBO
LFTBCBSBO ZBOH MVBS CJBTB /BJ *CSBIJN TFEJLJU EFNJ TFEJLJU NFODPCB NFNCVLB
QBOEBOHBONFSFLBCBIXBBQBZBOHEJTBNQBJLBOOZBJUVBEBMBICFOBS

3FGMFLTJ1FOEJEJLBO*TMBNEBMBN%JBMPH/BCJ*CSBIJN

.FOVSVU "M2VSBO BZBI /BCJ *CSBIJN BEBMBI "[BS 24   "M2VSBO
UJEBL NFOZFCVULBO OBNB JCVOZB "[BS KVHB TBMBI TFPSBOH ZBOH UFOHHFMBN EBMBN
LFNVTZSJLBO  CBILBO TFCBHBJ LSFBUPS VMVOH EBMBN IBM QFNCVBUBO QBUVOHQBUVOH
ZBOH LIVTVT EJKBEJLBO TFCBHBJ TJNCPM 5VIBO VOUVL EJTFNCBI CVLBO VOUVL
EJLPMFLTJLBO TFCBHBJ BTTFTPSJT TFCVBI LBSZB TFOJ ZBOH TBSBU EFOHBO OJMBJ EBO
FTUFUJLBOZB

/BCJ *CSBIJN NFOHFSUJ  CBIXB #BQBLOZBMBI NBOVTJB ZBOH QBMJOH EFLBU


EFOHBOOZB 0MFI LBSFOB JUV CBQBLOZB TFOEJSJ JUVMBI ZBOH QFSUBNB TFLBMJ IBSVT
EJCFSJQFUVOKVLEBOEJIJOEBSLBOEBSJLFTFTBUBO EJCFSJOBTFIBUTFQBOKBOHBQBZBOH
EJBKBSLBO PMFI "MMBI 4VCIBOBIV XB 5BBMBLFQBEBOZB 5FSIBEBQ CBQBLOZB JUV 
*CSBIJNIBSVTFLTUSBIBUJIBUJTFCBHBJQFOBTFIBUUFUBQJKVHBTFCBHBJTFPSBOHBOBL 
CFMJBVTBOHBUNFOKBHBBHBSUJEBLUFSTFOUVIiEJOEJOHEJOEJOHiQFSBTBBOCBQBLOZB

]+VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT


*TNBJM"OTBSJ

4FCFMVN EJVSBJLBO QBOKBOH MFCBS JOUJTBSJ QFOEJEJLBO ZBOH UFSLBOEVOH EJ


EBMBNEJBMPHJOJBEBCBJLOZBLJUBIBSVTNFSVKVLLFQBEBTVNCFSBTMJZBJUV"M2VSBO
TVSBU.BSZBNBZBU

& '( )* # +% , ! " # $%


+% , - ( 3 0 & ( 4 ( . 0 ' 0(% ( . 0 ' , - .' / 0 1 2
( /' % 9 ') ( 56:' " #, - ( . 0 & ( 4 1 ( 3 0 ' ( 56'$ 0 ( 78
( ( 4= , - ;3 (4 0% + ; 2 & 5 < " # , - & */' 0 * !
  - > + ) ( 4 0 ? + 0 (
@

 ,

"SUJOZB*OHBUMBILFUJLB*CSBIJNCFSLBUBLFQBEBCBQBLOZB8BIBJ#BQBLLV 
NFOHBQB LBNV NFOZFNCBI TFTVBUV ZBOH UJEBL NFOEFOHBS  UJEBL NFMJIBU EBO
UJEBL EBQBU NFOPMPOH LBNV TFEJLJUQVO  8BIBJ #BQBLLV  TFTVOHHVIOZB UFMBI
EBUBOHLFQBEBLVTFCBHJBOJMNVQFOHFUBIVBOZBOHUJEBLEBUBOHLFQBEBNV NBLB
JLVUJMBI BLV  OJTDBZB BLV BLBO NFOVOKVLLBO LFQBEBNV KBMBO ZBOH MVSVT 8BIBJ
#BQBLLV  KBOHBOMBI LBNV NFOZFNCBI TZBJUIBO  TFTVOHHVIOZB TZBJUIBO JUV
EVSIBLBLFQBEB5VIBO:BOH.BIB1FNVSBI8BIBJ#BQBLLV TFTVOHHVIOZBBLV
LIBXBUJSCBIXB LBNVBLBOEJUJNQBB[BCEBSJ 5VIBO:BOH.BIB1FNVSBI NBLB
LBNV BLBO NFOKBEJ LBXBO CBHJ TZBJUIBO #FSLBUB #BQBLOZB i#FODJLBI LBNV
LFQBEB 5VIBO5VIBOLV *CSBIJN  KJLB LBNV UJEBL CFSIFOUJ NBLB  OJTDBZB LBNV
BLBO LVSBKBN  EBO UJOHHBMLBOMBI BLV EBMBN XBLUV ZBOH MBNBi #FSLBUB *CSBIJN
i4FNPHB LFTFMBNBUBO EJMJNQBILBO LFQBEBNV  BLV BLBO NFNJOUBLBO BNQVO
CBHJNVLFQBEB5VIBOLV%BOBLVBLBONFOKBVILBOEJSJEBSJQBEBNVEBOEBSJBQB
ZBOH LBNV TFSV TFMBJO EBSJ QBEB "MMBI  EBO BLV BLBO CFSEPB LFQBEB 5VIBOLV
NVEBINVEBIBOBLVUJEBLBLBOLFDFXBEFOHBOCFSEPBLFQBEB5VIBOLVw

%BSJ EJBMPH BOUBSB TFPSBOH BOBL *CSBIJN  ZBOH UFMBI NFOEBQBU QFUVOKVL
5VIBOEFOHBOTFPSBOHZBOHZBOHCFMVNNFOEBQBUQFUVOKVLLFNVEJBOiEJUBXBSJw
QFUVOKVLUFOUVTBSBUEFOHBOJLUJCBS JCBSBU BUBVQFMBKBSBOZBOHEBQBUEJQFEPNBOJ
PMFI NFSFLB ZBOH CFSBLBM %BMBN EJBMPH ZBOH UFSLFTBO TBOHBU EJQMPNBUJT EBO
LPNVOJLBUJGJUVQBMJOHUJEBLBEBEVBBTQFLVNVNQFOEJEJLBO:BJUVZBOHQFSUBNB
BTQFLEPLUSJOBM EBOZBOHLFEVBBTQFLNPSBM%BMBNIBMJOJ/BCJ*CSBIJNTFQFSUJ
TFPSBOHQFOEJEJLZBOHTFEBOHNFOHIVKBNLBOOJMBJOJMBJVOJWFSTBMLFUVIBOBOEBO



  +VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT]


.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-"."-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU

NFUPEF QFOVI IJLNBI EBO NBVJEIBUVM IBTBOBI ZBOH TBOHBU NFOZFOUVI EBO
NFSBTVLJ SFMVOHSFMVOH LBMCV BZBIOZB  OBNVO BQB ZBOH EJLBUBLBO IJEBZBI "MMBI
CFMVNEBUBOHLFQBEBTBOHBZBI "[BS 

.BLB EBSJ JOUFSQSFUBTJ BZBUBZBU JOJ QBMJOH LVSBOH UFSEBQBU EVB BTQFL
QFOEJEJLBOZBOHEBQBUEJKBEJLBOSFGMFLTJEJSJCBHJPSBOHZBOHJOHJONFNBIBNJOZB
,FEVBBTQFLQFOEJEJLBOEJNBLTVEBEBMBI

1FOEJEJLBO"RJEBIEBOQFOEFLBUBOOZB

4FCFMVN "M2VSBO NFOKFMBTLBO CBHBJNBOB /BCJ *CSBIJN NFOHBKBL


BZBIOZBVOUVLNFOZFNCBI"MMBI "M2VSBOUFSMFCJIEBIVMVNFOHBNCBSLBOTPTPL
/BCJ *CSBIJN  EJNBOB CFMJBV BEBMBI TFPSBOH /BCJ ZBOH TBOHBU NFNCFOBSLBO
TFNVB IBM HIBJC ZBOH EBUBOHOZB EJQBTUJLBO EBSJ "MMBI 4VCIBOBIV XB 5BBMB )BM
JOJNFOVOKVLLBOCBIXBTFCFMVNCFMJBVNFZBLJOLBOLFNBIBCFOBSBO"MMBIZBOHJB
TFNCBI LFQBEB PSBOH MBJO  NBLB UFSMFCJI EBIVMV LFJNBOBO CFMJBV TFOEJSJ TVEBI
TBOHBU LPLPI EBO NBOUBQ *OEJLBTJ JOJ EBQBU EJQFEPNBOJ EBMBN QSPTFT CFMBKBS
NFOHBKBS  EJNBOB TFPSBOH QFOEJEJL IBSVT MFCJI EBIVMV NFOHVBTBJ NBUFSJ ZBOH
BLBOEJBKBSLBOLFQBEBBOBLEJEJL

"EBQVO ZBOH EJNBLTVE EFOHBO QFOEJEJLBO BRJEBI EBMBN EJBMPH /BCJ


*CSBIJN EFOHBO BZBIOZB  ZBJUV TFSVBO VOUVL NFOZFNCBI "MMBI 4VCIBOBIV XB
5BBMBEBO NFOJOHHBMLBO LFNVTZSJLBOOZB %BMBN BZBU  TVSBU .BSZBN  /BCJ
*CSBIJN NFNVMBJ EJBMPHOZB EFOHBO NFSBOHTBOH EBZB OBMBS BZBIOZB  NFOHBKBL
CFSGJLJS SFBMJTUJT UFOUBOH BQB ZBOH TFMBNB JOJ NFOKBEJ TFTFNCBIBO BZBIOZB /BCJ
*CSBIJN NFODPCB NFOEPSPOH BZBIOZB VOUVL NFOHHVOBLBO BLBM QJLJSBOOZB EBO
NFOFMBBI TFSUB NFNQFMBKBSJ HFKBMB LFIJEVQBOOZB TFOEJSJ %BMBN SVBOH MJOHLVQ
QFOHFNCBOHBOBLBMQJLJSBOJOJMBIZBOHNFOEPSPOHNBOVTJBVOUVLCFSGJLJSBOBMJUJT
EBO TJOUFTJT NFMBMVJ QSPTFT CFSGJLJS JOEVLUJG EBO EFEVLUJG "ZBU JOJ KFMBT
NFOHBOEVOHTVBUVJNQMJLBTJNFUPEPMPHJTEFOHBOQFOEFLBUBOSFBMJUBTZBOHBEB

,PNVOJLBTJ QFSTVBTJ ZBOH EJUVOKVLLBO /BCJ *CSBIJN EFOHBO CFSEJTLVTJ


UFOUBOHQFSJOUBI"MMBIVOUVLUJEBLNFOZFNCBITFMBJOEBSJQBEB/ZBEBSJTBUVTJTJ
UFMBI NFOVUVQJ EJSJOZB VOUVL CFSTJLBQ EJLUBUPS NFNBLTB LFIFOEBL UFSIBEBQ
BZBIOZB  EJ TJTJ MBJO /BCJ *CSBIJN NBTJI NFOZBEBSJ CBIXB CFMJBV EBMBN IBM JOJ


 ). "SJGJO  *MNV 1FOEJEJLBO *TMBN 4VBUV 5JOKBVBO 5FPSJUJT EBO 1SBLUJT #FSEBTBSLBO
1FOEFLBUBO*OUFSEJTJQMJOFS $FU** +BLBSUB#VNJ"LTBSB  IBM

]+VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT


*TNBJM"OTBSJ

CFSBEB QBEB QPTJTJ TFCBHBJ TFPSBOH BOBL ZBOH IBSVT NFOKBHB IBL BTBTJ TFPSBOH
BZBI

%BMBN QFOEJEJLBO BRJEBI  TFMBJO NFOHHVOBLBO QFOEFLBUBO SBTJPOBM KVHB


NFOHHVOBLBOQFOEFLBUBOEPLUSJOBM1FOEFLBUBOEPLUSJOBMJOJEJNBLTVELBOBEBMBI
CVLBO QFOEFLBUBO EPHNBUJT TUBUJT  NFMBJOLBO EPHNB ZBOH EJJSJOHJ EFOHBO
BSHVNFOBSHVNFO ZBOH TBOHBU MPHJT TFSUB EJBMPHJT UFSIBEBQ LFCFCBTBO QJLJSBO
NBOVTJB "UBV EFOHBO LBUB MBJO QFOEFLBUBO EPLUSJOBM EFOHBO BMBTBOBMBTBO
SBTJPOBM EJBMFLUJTEBOEJBMPHJT

1BEB BZBUBZBU TFMBOKVUOZB /BCJ *CSBIJN MFCJI KBVI NFOHFNVLBLBO


CFCFSBQBQFOKFMBTBOUBNCBIBOVOUVLNFOHVBULBOEPLUSJOLFUBVIJEBOSJTBMBIZBOH
TFEBOH EJLPNVOJLBTJLBO LFQBEB BZBIOZB 1FSOZBUBBO UBNCBIBO ZBOH
EJLFNVLBLBOOZB BEBMBI CBIXB NFOUBVIJELBO NFOH&TBLBO  "MMBI NFSVQBLBO
KBMBO LFIJEVQBO ZBOH MVSVT  KBMBO ZBOH NFOZFMBNBULBO TFNVB NBOVTJB EBSJ UJQV
EBZB TZBJUIBO OBGTV  ZBOH NFOZFTBULBO NBOVTJB TFSUB NFOHBOUBSLBOOZB LFQBEB
B[BC "MMBI EJ IBSJ BLIJSBU 1FSCVBUBO NFOZFNCBI CFSIBMB BEBMBI LFNVTZSJLBO
ZBOH EJMBLVLBO UFSIBEBQ "MMBI  JUVMBI EPTB ZBOH QBMJOH CFTBS EBO BLBO NFOEBQBU
CBMBTBOZBOHQFEJIEBSJ"MMBI

%BMBN QFSOZBUBBO FLTQMJTJU UFOUBOH B[BC EBSJ BLIJSBU  TFDBSB JNQMJTJU QVMB
/BCJ *CSBIJN TFPMBIPMBI JOHJO NFNCFSJUBIVLBO LFQBEB BZBIOZB CBIXB TFUFMBI
BEBOZB LFIJEVQBO EVOJB JOJ NBLB BEB QVMB LFIJEVQBO EJ BLIJSBU OBOUJ %J NBOB
EBMBN LFIJEVQBO ZBOH LFEVB TFHBMB QFSCVBUBO NBOVTJB BLBO EJNJOUB
QFSUBOHHVOHKBXBCBO TFCBHBJTFPSBOHBOBLCFMJBVTBOHBULIBXBUJSLFQBEBBZBIOZB
ZBOHBLBOEJUJNQBB[BCZBOHUFMBIEJKBOKJLBOJUV

%J TBNQJOH JUV /BCJ *CSBIJN TFMBMV NFOHVMBOHVMBOH CBIXB 5VIBOOZB


"MMBI  BEBMBI 5VIBO ZBOH .BIB 1FNVSBI 1FNVSBI EBMBN BSUJBO TFOBOUJBTB
NFOFSJNB UBVCBU IBNCBOZB ZBOH CFSCVBU LIJMBG "MMBI ZBOH EJ TFNCBI *CSBIJN
EBQBU NFOPMPOH NBOVTJB EBSJ B[BC/ZB ZBOH TBOHBU QFEJI 5VIBO :BOH .BIB
.FMJIBU .FOEFOHBSEBOEBQBUNFOPMPOHTFNVBIBNCB/ZBEBONFOKBVILBOEJSJ
EBSJQFSCVBUBOTZJSJL


 "SEJBM  i1FSBOBO ,BTJI 4BZBOH EJ &SB (MPCBMJTBTJ EBMBN 1FNCJOBBO ,FMVBSHB #BIBHJB w
)BSJBO6NVN8BTQBEB .FJ

  *COV ,BUTJS  5BGTJS *COV ,BUTJS  5FSK )BKJ4BMJN#BISFJTZ EBO) 4BJE #BISFJTZ  $FU*** 
+BLBSUB#JOB*MNV  IBM



  +VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT]


.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-"."-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU

1FOEJEJLBO"LIMBLEBO1FOEFLBUBOOZB

%BMBN EJBMPH JOJ CBOZBL OJMBJOJMBJ QFOEJEJLBO NPSBM ZBOH EBQBU EJBNCJM
TFCBHBJ TVBUV MBOEBTBO NPSBM LFQSJCBEJBO EBMBN JNQMFNFOUBTJ LFQFOEJEJLBO
4FCBHBJ TPTPL TFPSBOH VUVTBO 5VIBO  /BCJ *CSBIJN KFMBT NFNJMJLJ UFNQSBNFO
NFOUBM ZBOH NBOUBQ EFOHBO SFQVUBTJ NPSBM ZBOH TFNQVSOB 4FTVOHHVIOZB QBEB
EJSJ*CSBIJNUFMBIBEBTVSJUBVMBEBOCBHJNV EFNJLJBOKVHBPSBOHPSBOHZBOHUFMBI
NFOHJLVUJOZB 24 

,FMVIVSBO TJLBQ EBO LFUJOHHJBO QFSJMBLV UFMBI EJUVOKVLLBO /BCJ *CSBIJN


LFUJLB NFOHHJSJOH BZBIOZB LFKBMBO LFTFMBNBUBO %BSJ BZBU  TVSBU .BSZBN
EBQBU EJQFSIBUJLBO TFUJBQ BLBO NFNCFSJLBO OBTFIBU QFSUBNB TFLBMJ TFMBMV
NFNBOHHJM i8BIBJ #BQBLLVw  TVBUV QFOEFLBUBO CBIBTB ZBOH DVLVQ IBMVT EBO
CJKBLTBOBZBOHTFLBMJHVTNFOKFMBTLBOCBIXBEJBTFOEJSJBEBMBIBOBLEBSJCBQBLJUV
%FOHBO LBMJNBU TFQFSUJ JOJ UVKVBOOZB UJBEB MBJO BEBMBI VOUVL NFOEFLBULBO EJSJ
TFPSBOHBOBLEFOHBOBZBIOZBZBOHQFOVISBTBLBTJITBZBOH

*CSBIJN UJEBL NFNCBOHHBLBO EJSJOZB EFOHBO JMNV QFOHFUBIVBO ZBOH


UJOHHJ  ZBJUV EFOHBO QFSLBUBBO iUFMBI EBUBOH TFCBIBHJBO JMNV QFOHFUBIVBOw 
TFIJOHHBUJEBLUBNQBLCBIXBNFSBTBJBMFCJIJOUFMFLUVBMEBSJQBEBBZBIOZB

4FCFMVNOZB TFPMBIPMBI /BCJ *CSBIJN JOHJO CFSUBOZB  BUBT EBTBSEBTBS


BQBLBIEBOBMBTBOBMBTBOBQBLBIZBOHNFOZFCBCLBOCBQBLOZBTBNQBJNFOZFNCBI
QBUVOHQBUVOH CFSIBMB TFUFMBIJBTFOEJSJZBOHNFNCVBUOZB"LIJSOZBTFDBSBKVKVS
JBNFOHBLVJCBIXB/BCJ*CSBIJNNFOEBQBUJMNVEBOXBIZVEBSJ"MMBI4VCIBOBIV
XB 5BBMB  IBM JOJ EJTBNQBJLBOOZB LFQBEB BZBIOZB EFOHBO CBIBTB ZBOH MFNBI
MFNCVU %FOHBO IPSNBU EBO LIJENBU  UVUVS EFNJ UVUVS LBUB ZBOH UFSBUVS EBO
TJTUFNBUJT  *CSBIJN NFOHBKBL CBQBLOZB VOUVL QFSDBZB LFQBEB/ZB EBO VOUVL
TBNBTBNBNFOHFOBM5VIBO "MMBI4VCIBOBIVXB5BBMB LFNVEJBONFOZFNCBI
/ZB TFSUB NFOJOHHBMLBO CFSIBMBCFSIBMB ZBOH TFEJLJUQVO UJEBL NFNCFSJLBO
NBOGBBU

%J EBMBN EJBMPH UFSTFCVU  /BCJ *CSBIJN UFMBI CFSVTBIB TFNBLTJNBM


NVOHLJO NFOHBKBL BZBIOZB LF KBMBO 5VIBO ZBOH QFOVI IJLNBI EBO QFMBKBSBO
QFMBKBSBO ZBOH CBJL .FOVSVU "M2VSBO  CBIXB ZBOH EJNBLTVE EFOHBO LBUB
IJLNBI BEBMBI QFSLBUBBO ZBOH UFHBT EBO CFOBS ZBOH EBQBU NFNCFEBLBO BOUBSB


#FJ"SJGJO 3BOHLBJBO$FSJUBEBMBN"M2VSBO 4VSBCBZB"M.BSJG  IBM

]+VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT


*TNBJM"OTBSJ

ZBOHIBLEBOZBOHCBUJM%BMBNJMNVLFQFOEJEJLBOQFOEFLBUBOTFQFSUJJOJEJTFCVU
QFOEFLBUBOZBOHNFOHBOEVOHNFUPEFCJNCJOHBO TFSVBOBUBVBKBLBOiy/BTFIBU
NFOBTFIBUJ TVQBZB NFOUBBUJ LFTBCBSBOw 24  1FOEFLBUBO ZBOH QFSMV
EJMBLVLBOEBMBNNFMBLTBOBLBONFUPEFUFSTFCVUBEBMBINFMBMVJTJLBQZBOHMFNBI
MFNCVUEBOMVOBLIBUJEFOHBOHBZBNFOVOUVONFNCJNCJOHLFBSBILFCFOBSBO

1FOEFLBUBO BLIJS VOUVL NFOEVLVOH TFNVB QFOEFLBUBO EJ BUBT BEBMBI


BEBOZBVOTVSLFUFMBEBOBOZBOHNFMFLBUFSBUQBEBEJSJEBOLFQSJCBEJBOPSBOHZBOH
NFOVOUVO EBO ZBOH NFNCFSJ CJNCJOHBO JUV ,BSFOB LFUFMBEBO BEBMBI DPOUPI
LPOLSJUZBOHMBOHTVOHEBQBUEJBNBUJLFTFTVBJBOBOUBSBBQBZBOHEJEFOHBSEFOHBO
ZBOHEJMJIBUEBMBNQFSCVBUBOOZBUB*UVMBI/BCJ*CSBIJN CFMJBVUFMBINFODPCBEBO
NFODVSBILBO TFNVB QFOEFLBUBO EFOHBO CFSCBHBJ NBDBN NFUPEB VOUVL
NFOZFMBNBULBOBZBIOZBZBOHUFSDJOUBEBSJLF[BMJNBOEBOLFTFTBUBOIJEVQ

%FOHBO QFOVI LFTBCBSBO EBO LFCFTBSBO KJXB ZBOH UFMBI EJDVSBILBO UBOQB
NFSBTB QVUVT BTB EBO IJMBOH LFTBCBSBOOZB JUV TFTVOHHVIOZB UFSMFUBL LFBHVOHBO
/BCJ *CSBIJN ZBJUV QBEB LFCFTBSBO KJXBOZB ZBOH UVMVT EBO JLIMBT ,BSFOB
LFBHVOHBO NPSBM /BCJ *CSBIJN TFNBLJO OZBUB UFSMJIBU LFUJLB TFSVBO ZBOH
EJTBNQBJLBO LFQBEB BZBIOZB EFOHBO CBIBTB ZBOH TBSBU TPQBO TBOUVO EBO QFOVI
LFMFNCVUBOTFDBSBFNPTJPOBMEJUPMBLBZBIOZB #BILBOUJEBLIBOZBJUVBLBOUFUBQJ
MFCJI EBSJ JUV CFMJBV EJVTJS TFSUB EJBODBN  XBMBVQVO EFNJLJBO CFMJBV UFUBQ UBCBI
EBONFNCBMBTTFNVBOZBJUVEFOHBOJSJOHBOEPBLFQBEBBZBIOZBEFOHBOIBSBQBO
NFOEBQBUQFUVOKVLEBOLFNCBMJLFKBMBOZBOHCFOBS

/BNVO EFNJLJBO BMBTBO ZBOH EJCFSJLBO BZBIOZB  CFMJBV TBOHBU TBZBOH


LFQBEB BZBIOZB EFOHBO UJEBL NFNCJBSLBO JB CFSHFMJNBOH EJ EBMBN LFTFTBUBO
"LIJSOZBCBHBJNBOBQVOKVHBBZBI/BCJ*CSBIJNUJEBLTFEJLJUQVOUFSCVLBIBUJOZB
,FHFMBQBO BMBN QJLJSBO ZBOH EJEVLVOH PMFI TJLBQ LPOTFSWBUJTNF BZBI /BCJ
*CSBIJNUFMBINFOVUVQLFCPEPIBOBLBMOZBZBOHTFIBU#FMJBVTFLBSBOHNFOZBEBSJ
CBIXBUJBEBMBHJZBOHEBQBUEJIBSBQLBOMFCJICBOZBLLFQBEBBZBIOZBTFMBJOCFSEPB
EBONFOKBHBKBSBLTFIJOHHBUJEBLBEBQFSUFOUBOHBOZBOHMFCJISVNJU

#BSBOHTJBQBZBOHEJCFSJLBOQFUVOKVLLFQBEB"MMBIUJBEBBLBOTFTBUTFMBNB
MBNBOZB  EBO CBSBOH TJBQB ZBOH EJ TFTBULBO PMFI/ZB  NBLB UJEBL TFPSBOHQVO
NBNQV NFNCFSJ QFUVOKVL %FNJLJBO QVMB IBMOZB ZBOH NFOJNQB BZBI /BCJ
*CSBIJN 4VOOBUVMMBI UFMBI CFSMBLV UFSIBEBQOZB i"MMBI NFNCFSJLBO IJLNBI
LFQBEB TJBQB ZBOH EJLFIFOEBLJ/ZB EBO CBSBOH TJBQB ZBOH EJCFSJ



  +VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT]


.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-"."-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU

IJLNBI TFTVOHHVIOZB JB UFMBI EJCFSJLBO LFCBJLBO ZBOH CBOZBL 24  
4BMBNLV EBO TFMBNBU UJOHHBM LFQBEB #BQBLLV TBZB NPIPO BNQVOBO CBHJ CBQBL 
QFOHIPSNBUBOLVBEBMBILBSFOBFOHLBVCBQBLLV EFNJLJBOLBUBLBUBUFSBLIJS/BCJ
*CSBIJNUFSIBEBQBZBIOZB

4*.16-"/

 .FOHBLIJSJ UVMJTBO JOJ  NBLB TVEBI TFXBKBSOZB LJUB NFSFOVOHJ EBO


NFOHBNCJM TVBUV JLIUJCBS EBSJ LJTBILJTBI QBSB 3BTVM  /BCJ TFSUB XBMJXBMJ "MMBI
EFOHBOIJLNBIEBOQFMBKBSBOTFIJOHHBNFOKBEJCBIBOQFSCBOEJOHBOEBMBNNFOJUJ
EBO NFNCFOUVL LFIJEVQBO ZBOH MBOHHFOH EBO TFSBTJ TFTVBJ EFOHBO UVOUVUBO
LFNBOVTJBBO EBO TVOOBUVMMBI ZBOH UFMBI EJHBSJTLBO NFMBMVJ SJTBMBI 3BTVM
1FOEFLBUBO EBMBN LPNVOJLBTJ BUBV EBMBN QFOZBNQBJBO TVBUV QFTBO UFOUVOZB
NFSVQBLBO TVBUV IBM ZBOH UJEBL CPMFI EJBOHHBQ LVSBOH QFOUJOH 1FMVBOH VOUVL
EJUFSJNBOZB TVBUV QFTBO ZBOH UFMBI EJTBNQBJLBO TBOHBU UFSHBOUVOH QBEB
CBHBJNBOB TVBUV QFOEFLBUBO ZBOH EJMBLVLBO  EFNJLJBO NFOVSVU TBMBI TBUV UFPSJ
LPNVOJLBTJ %FNJLJBO KVHB IBMOZB ZBOH UFMBI EJUFNQVI /BCJ *CSBIJN EBMBN
EJBMPHOZBEFOHBOTBOHBZBI/BCJ*CSBIJNUJEBLMBOHTVOHNFNBLTBBZBIOZBVOUVL
NFOFSJNBBKBLBOEBONFOJOHHBMLBOQSBLUFLLFNVTZSJLBOEBOTFHFSBNFOZFNCBI
"MMBI XBMBVQVO VOUVL EJSJOZB /BCJ *CSBIJN UFMBI NFZBLJOJ CBIXB ZBOH
EJTBNQBJLBOOZBJUVBEBMBITVBUVLFCFOBSBOZBOHNVUMBL

#FMJBVUFSMFCJIEBIVMVNFOHBEBLBOLPNVOJLBTJQFSTVBTJEFOHBOCFSEJTLVTJ
UFOUBOHQFSJOUBI"MMBIVOUVLUJEBLNFOZFNCBITFMBJOEBSJQBEB/ZBDBSBJOJ /BCJ
*CSBIJN TFCBHBJ TFPSBOH BOBL ZBOH CBJL CFMJBV NFMBMVJ QFOEFLBUBO QFSTVBTJ
NFOHIBSHBJ IBL BTBTJ BZBI %FOHBO DBSB TFQFSUJ JOJ /BCJ *CSBIJN UFMBI
NFNCFSJLBO TVBUV DPOUPI UFMBEBO EBMBN NFOKBMJO LPNVOJLBTJ BOUBSB PSBOH UVB
EBOBOBLZBOHDFOESVOHVOUVLCFSGJLJSTFDBSBQPTJUJG

,FTFMVSVIBOEJBMPHJOJTBSBUEFOHBOOJMBJOJMBJQFOEJEJLBO NVODVMEBSJDBSB
/BCJ *CSBIJN NFMBLVLBO EJBMPH TFSUB LBOEVOHBO QFTBO VOUVL NFOUBVIJELBO
"MMBI ,FTFMVSVIBO BLIMBL CFMJBV UFSHBNCBS EBMBN EJBMPHOZB JOJ TFSUB
LFTBCBSBOOZBZBOHUJEBLUFSUBOEJOHJNFMFLBUFSBUQBEBLFQSJCBEJBOOZBZBOHNVMJB
+BMJOBOTJMBUVSSBINJBOUBSBBOBLEBOBZBIUFUBQUFSKBHBVUVIXBMBVQVOQFSCFEBBO
BRJEBITFCBHBJTVBUVQSJOTJQUFMBIKBVIEFOHBOLFNVTZSJLBO

]+VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT


*TNBJM"OTBSJ

.FUPEFEBXBIZBOHEJHVOBLBO/BCJ*CSBIJNTFCFOBSOZBTBOHBUTFEFSIBOB 
OBNVO TBOHBU NFOFOUVLBO :BJUV NFUPEF QFSTVBTJ EJBMPEJT  EFOHBO QFNJMJIBO
LBUB ZBOH TBOHBU LPNVOJLBUJG EBO EJQMPNBUJT 6OTVSVOTVS LFTFEFSIBOBBO EBO
LFSFOEBI IBUJBO TFOBOUJBTB NFOHJSJOHJ TFUJBQ LBU ZBOH EJVDBQLBOOZB UBOQB
TFEJLJUQVO UBNQBL BEBOZB VOTVS NFNBLTB "SHVNFOBSHVNFO MPHJT UFSVT
NFOHBMJSTFQBOKBOHEJBMPHOZBCFSMBOHTVOH

"LIJSOZB TFKBSBI NFOFOUVLBO MBJO CBIXB UJEBL TFMBNBOZB VTBIB NBOVTJB


EFOHBO CFSCBHBJ DBSB ZBOH UFMBI EJUFNQVI BLBO NFOKBNJO UFSMBLTBOBOZB TFCVBI
NBLTVE*BNFSVQBLBOIBMZBOHIBSVTEJMBLVLBO OBNVOQFUVOKVLQFUVOKVLZBOH
EJLFIFOEBLJPMFI"MMBILFQBEBTFUJBQNBOVTJBJUVMBIPSBOHPSBOHZBOHIBOJG:BOH
EJBMBNJ PMFI /BCJ *CSBIJN  UFSOZBUB LFMVBSHBLFMVBSHB /BCJ  TFOEJSJ UJEBL
NFOKBNJO TFTFPSBOH VOUVL EFOHBO NVEBI EJCFSJLBO IJEBZBI PMFI 5VIBO .BLB
EBMBNIBMJOJXBMBVQVOCFMJBVNFOZBNQBJLBOTFCVBIEPLUSJOUFOUBOH5VIBO:BOH
.BIB (IBJC UFUBQ TBKB NFOHIBEJSLBO EFOHBO BSHVNFOBSHVNFO ZBOH EBQBU
EJUFSJNB



  +VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT]


.&50%0-0(*1&/%*%*,"/"-*#3")%"-"."-263"/,BKJBO)JTUPSJT1BFEBHPHJTUFSIBEBQ
,JTBI/BCJ*CSBIJNEBMBN4VSBU.BSZBNBZBU

%"'5"31645","

"SEJBM  i1FSBOBO ,BTJI 4BZBOH EJ &SB (MPCBMJTBTJ EBMBN 1FNCJOBBO ,FMVBSHB
#BIBHJB w)BSJBO6NVN8BTQBEB .FJ
"SJGJO #FJ 3BOHLBJBO$FSJUBEBMBN"M2VSBO 4VSBCBZB"M.BSJG 
"SJGJO  ).  *MNV 1FOEJEJLBO *TMBN 4VBUV 5JOKBVBO 5FPSJUJT EBO 1SBLUJT
#FSEBTBSLBO1FOEFLBUBO*OUFSEJTJQMJOFS $FU** +BLBSUB#VNJ"LTBSB 
%FQBSUFNFO"HBNB3* %JSKFO#JNBT,BUPMJL ,JUBC1FSKBOKJBO#BSV +PIBOOFT $FU
7*** 
@@@@@@ &OTJLMPQFEJB*TMBNEJ*OEPOFTJB +BLBSUB
,BUTJS *COV 5BGTJS*COV,BUTJS 5FSK)BKJ4BMJN#BISFJTZEBO)4BJE#BISFJTZ $FU
*** +BLBSUB#JOB*MNV 
"M.BVEVEJZ "CV"MB ,IBMJGBIEBO,FSBKBBO&WBMVBTJ,SJUJT5FSIBEBQ4FKBSBIEBO
1FNFSJOUBIBO*TMBN .VIBNNBEBM#BRJS $FU*7 #BOEVOH.J[BO 
4BMFI  "CEVSSBINBO  5FPSJ 1FOEJEJLBO #FSEBTBSLBO "M2VSBO   BMJI CBIBTB .
"SJGJO +BLBSUB3JOFLB$JQUB 
4JEEJRJZ .B[IFSVEEJO ,POTFQ"M2VSBO5FOUBOH4FKBSBI +BLBSUB1VTUBLB'JSEBVT 


]+VSOBM*MNJBI%JEBLUJLB7PM9** /P "HVTUVT

You might also like