Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Swain Phosphate and Sulfate Mixtures
Swain Phosphate and Sulfate Mixtures
Swain Phosphate and Sulfate Mixtures
DOI 10.1007/s10904-016-0454-z
Abstract Two inorganic mixtures of copper and sodium Keywords DSC · Specific heat capacity ·
compounds have been synthesized and characterized with Nanophosphate · Optical property · Sensible heat
different measurement techniques. The thermal property
of these mixtures has been studied to low temperature up
to 223 from 573 K with DSC. The specific heat capacity 1 Introduction
of this mixture has been measured in atmospheric O2 at a
rate of 10 K min−1 from 573 to 223 K and vice versa in Nowadays phosphate materials are widely used due to their
two thermal cycles. The net specific heat capacity of these large applications such as laser host, ceramic, dielectric,
mixtures is found endothermic in first and second thermal electric, magnetic, food additives, fuel cells, pigments,
cycles. The net specific heat capacity of 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); fertilizers, metal surface treatment, detergent, catalytic
3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O (CuPHS) during first processes, solar cell for enhancing the power conversion
thermal cycle is −71203.05 J kg−1 K−1 and in second ther- efficiency etc. [1–6]. There are various types of materials
mal cycle is −73881.67 J kg−1 K−1 between temperature containing different types of phosphate groups such as poly-
range of 303–223 K. The net specific heat capacity of mix- phosphate, cyclo-phosphate and ultraphosphate. The prop-
ture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2; 2Na2SO4(CuPS) erties of these phosphate materials depend on particle size,
in first thermal cycle is −21158.37 J kg−1 K−1 and in surface area and morphology. The nanostructure phosphate
second thermal cycle is−45739.92 J kg−1 K−1 between materials improve the various functional properties than the
temperature range of 298–573 K. As both mixtures are bulk form and thin layers. The increase of various activi-
endothermic in nature in all cycles, it can be used as heat ties is thermal and chemical stabilities, densification kinet-
storage material.The average crystallite size of mixture ics due to their large surface area [7–9]. Nowadays, there
0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O is a rapid development in nanoscience and nanotechnology
and 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2; 2Na2SO4 is ~47 and which is increasing the effort of study on phosphate based
~17.3 nm, respectively. nanostructure materials [5, 8, 9]. The specific heat capac-
ity increases considerably by using phosphate cement,
KMgPO4·6H2O, [10] as binders for slag P and slag B aggre-
gates than other binders [11]. This tempted me to prepare
Electronic supplementary material The online version of this
some phosphate based materials which can act as a binder
article (doi:10.1007/s10904-016-0454-z) contains supplementary
material, which is available to authorized users. for enhancement of specific heat capacity. The energy stor-
age is an important parameter to improve the efficiency of
Trilochan Swain energy utilization in different economic aspects. It is the
scienceorissa@rediffmail.com
main route of bridging the time gap between the energy
1
Indic Institute of Design and Research, Khurda, Odisha, supply and the energy demand. In order to mitigate this the
India mixture CuPHS was prepared using metaphosphoric acid
2
Faculty of Science & Technology, IFHE, Hyderabad, and copper(II) sulfate pentahydrate at room temperature by
Telangana, India a wet preparation method. The mixture CuPS was prepared
13
2 J Inorg Organomet Polym
by heating the above mixture at 343 K for 24 h. This method characterization was performed with a vibrating sample
is simple, cost effective and nontoxic route to synthesize magnetometer (VSM) having Lake Shore Model 7410 in
nanophosphate base compound. However, these phosphate SAIF, IIT Madras. Zero field-cooled (ZFC) and field-cooled
complexes of copper can be used as thermal storage materi- (FC) scans of magnetization as a function of temperature
als as long-chain n-alkylammonium dihydrogen phosphate were performed from 20 to 300 K with an external field of
(n = 8, 9 and 10) [12]. Alonso et al. studies the solar redox 5000 Oe. The UV-Vis-NIR, HRTEM, C–H–N–S, TG-DTA
reactions of CuO for thermochemical energy storage and and ICP-AES studies were performed in ST&IC, Cochin
demonstrated successfully in a solar furnace [13]. Copper University of Science and Technology, Cochin.
nanoparticles are used as fabrication of the solar cells [14].
In this work, the evaluation of thermal storage material is
limited to a calorimetric investigation. The objective of this 2 Results
paper is to characterize and study the thermal properties of
this mixture for using as thermal storage material. 2.1 FTIR Analysis
13
J Inorg Organomet Polym 3
Fig. 1 a FTIR spectrum of mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O. b FTIR spectrum of mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH);
3.5CuH(PO4)2; 2Na2SO4
13
4 J Inorg Organomet Polym
13
J Inorg Organomet Polym 5
The description of symbols λ, θ and β are similar to Eq. (1). mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2; 2Na2SO4, mol.
K is the shape factor 0.9 and D is the average crystallite wt. = 1231.12 g, was carried out twice with ICP-AES. We
size. A graph is plotted between lnβ versus ln(1/cosθ) and took the average of the two analyses. The detail of elemental
found with equation Y = 2.8625 X − 2.5448. The calculated composition is inserted in Table 1.
average crystallite size is 48.6 nm for the mixture CuPHS.
The crystallite size can also be estimated from peak 2.5 UV–Visible–NIR Absorption Spectroscopy
broadening of XRD using well known Debye–Scherrer’s
formula The room temperature absorption spectra of the mixtures
in solid state are presented in Fig. 3. Both spectra shows
K ×λ an absorption band at about ~800 nm which is due to the
D=
(3)
β cosθ Cu2+ ions being in octahedral sites. The low intensity of
this absorption band is further explained by the position
The description of symbols λ, θ and β are similar to Eq. (1). of copper in a perfect octahedron. From this low intensity
K is the shape factor 0.9 and D is the crystallite size. The of the absorption band, it appears that copper is situated in
average crystallite size is 46.7 and 17.3 nm for the mixture a nearly perfect square planer surrounding formed by the
of CuPHS and CuPS respectively. equatorial oxygen atoms of a tetragonally distorted octahe-
dron with elongated bonds perpendicular to this plane [24].
2.4 Elemental Analysis The absorption spectrum of mixture, CuPHS, shows one
sharp and one broad peak. These two peaks show absorp-
2.4.1 C, H, N, S Analysis tion bands at 268 and 799 nm having absorbance 1.222
and 0.526, respectively. The calculated band gap from λmax
The elemental analysis of the mixture was found consis- 268 nm is 4.63 eV. In case of mixture CuPS, the absorption
tence with the theoretical values. Anal. Calcd. for mixture spectrum shows one sharp and two broad peaks. These three
{0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O, peaks show absorption bands 270, 803 and 1941 nm having
mol. wt. = 1286.28 gm.} is H 1.32 %; found H 1.78 %. absorbance 0.913, 0.686 and 0.208 respectively. The calcu-
lated band gap from λmax 268 nm is 4.59 eV. Hence, both the
2.4.2 ICP-AES Analysis mixtures are insulator at room temperature.
The elemental analysis of this mixture was carried out 2.6 TG-DTA Analysis
with ICP-AES. The Cu, P, S and Na were also consis-
tent with the theoretical values. Anal. Calcd. for mixture The mixtures undergo thermal decomposition in several
{0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O, not well-separated stages in Tg profiles. Derivative of Tg
mol. wt. = 1286.28 g}. The elemental analysis of curves reveal that the weight loss in the temperature range
802.000 0.686
0.6 866.000 0.642
0.4
0
230 430 630 830 1030 1230 1430 1630 1830
Wavelength (nm)
13
6 J Inorg Organomet Polym
a Weight loss versus Temperature sulfite lost from the mixture along with moisture. The 3.5
100 moles of CuH(PO4)2·H2O converted to the corresponding
anhydrous CuH(PO4)2 with removal of 3.5 moles of water.
80
The remaining three moles of water and a sulfite lost from
Weight loss / %
99
The DSC curve of mixture, CuPHS, was plotted between spe-
98.5 cific heat capacity versus temperature from 303 to 223 K in
98
two thermal cycles in Fig. 6a. The total specific heat capacity
of this mixture is 25985.95 J kg−1 K−1 in the first cycle during
97.5
cooling from 303 to 223 K and −97189.18 J kg−1 K−1 during
97 heating in reverse. So, the net specific heat capacity during
300 500 700 900
Temperature/K
1100 1300 1500
first cycle is −71203.05 J kg−1 K−1 while in case of other
phosphate complex such as nickel is 1747.86 J kg−1 K−1
Fig. 4 a TG and DTG profile of mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); [25]. Hence, the first cycle is endothermic in nature. The
3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2Ointhetemperaturerange313–1002K. total specific heat capacities in second thermal cycle dur-
b TG and DTG profile of mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2;
2Na2SO4 in the temperature range 311–993 K
ing cooling and heating in the same temperature ranges as
above are 23879.90 J kg−1 K−1and −97761.57 J kg−1 K−1,
respectively. The net specific heat capacity during second
313–1002 K consists of three steps in both mixtures. In cycle is −73881.67 J kg−1 K−1 and in case of Ni3(PO4)2 is
DTG curve, these three peaks CuPHS mixture temperature −6401.38 J kg−1 K−1 [25]. As both cycles are endothermic
are 383.18, 426.93 and 553.46 K Fig. 4a. From Tg analysis, in nature, it can be used as heat storage material.
the mass loss up to the above temperature are 4.25, 8.90 The DSC curve of mixture, CuPS, was plotted between
and 14.33 %, respectively. From DTA curve, this mixture is specific heat capacities versus temperature from 298 to
found endothermic in nature at 430.60 K, ∆H = 95.95 J g−1 573 K in two thermal cycles in Fig. 6b. The specific heat
Fig. 5a. The mass loss up to temperature 1002.82 K capacities in both cycles each during heating and cool-
is 19.481 %. Up to 1002.82 K, 6.5 moles of water and a ing occurred in two thermal stages. The total specific heat
capacity of this mixture is −3717.12 J kg−1 K−1 in the first
cycle during heating from 298 K to 383.33 K and 19652.8 J
kg−1 K−1 from 384 to 573 K. The net specific heat dur-
ing heating is 15935.68 J kg−1 K−1. The total specific heat
capacity is 3392.85 J kg−1 K−1 during cooling from 573
to 489.33 K and −40486.9 J kg−1 K−1 from 488.66 K to
298 K. The net specific heat during cooling is − 37094.05 J
kg−1 K−1. So, the net specific heat capacity in first cycle is
−21158.37 J kg−1 K−1. Hence, the first cycle is endothermic
in nature. The total specific heat capacity of this mixture
is −11812.3 J kg−1 K−1 in the second cycle during heating
from 298 to 464 K and 19416.13 J kg−1 K−1 from 464.66
to 573 K. The net specific heat during heating is 7603.83 J
Fig. 5 DTA profiles of mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O;
2NaHSO4·H2O and 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2; 2Na2SO4 in the kg−1 K−1. The total specific heat capacity is 2842.35 J
temperature range 313–993 K kg−1 K−1 during cooling from 573 to 486 K and −56186.1 J
13
J Inorg Organomet Polym 7
a Specific heat capacity versus Temperature the second cycle is endothermic in nature. As both cycles
400 are endothermic in nature, it can be used as heat storage
material.
Specific heat capacity/J kg-1 K-1
200
The by-products of the pyrometallurgical refining pro-
Exo
0
210 230 250 270 290 310 cess of copper have specific heat capacity Cp = 571 J kg−1
-200
1st cycle K−1 (373 K) and Cp = 648 J kg−1 K−1 (373 K) for Slag-P and
Endo
-400 2nd cycle Slag-B [11]. The mixture of CuPS is specific heat capacity
-600 Cp = 144.82 J kg−1 K−1 (373 K) during cooling in first cycle
-800 and the specific heat capacity in second cycle is 225.82 J
-1000 kg−1 K−1 (373 K) during cooling. It is found from the above
Temperature/K
calorimetric discussion that this mixture can be used as a
Specific heat capacity versus Temperature thermal storage material using sensible technique for the
b 400 substitution of other materials Table 2 [11, 26].
Specific heat capacity/Jkg-1K-1
200
2.7 TEM Analysis
0
290 340 390 440 490 540 590 The high resolution TEM (HRTEM) measurements car-
1st cycle
2nd cycle
ried out on synthesized mixture, 0 CuPHS, are shown in
-200
the Fig. 7.
-400
2.8 Magnetic Properties
-600
Temperature/K The magnetic moment measurement was carried out with
field cooled (FC) and zero field cooled (ZFC) of the mixture
Fig. 6 a This is DSC graph of mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH);
3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O between specific heat capacity CuPHS. It is shown in the Fig. 8. The Curie–Weiss tem-
versus temperature in the temperature range 303–223 K and vice versa perature (θ) and Curie constant (C) are calculated from the
in two thermal cycles and kept at 223 K for 3 min. b This is DSC graph formula given below.
of mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2; 2Na2SO4 between spe-
cific heat capacity versus temperature in the temperature range 298–
C
573 K and vice versa in two thermal cycles and kept at 573 K for 1 min χg =
(4)
(T − θ )
kg−1 K−1 from 485.33 to 298 K. The net specific heat during
cooling is −53343.75 J kg−1 K−1. So, the net specific heat where, χg is mass magnetic susceptibility. This equation is
capacity in second cycle is −45739.92 J kg−1 K−1. Hence, for T > θ.
13
8 J Inorg Organomet Polym
Magnetic moment/emugm-1
0.012
Magnetic moment/emugm-1
0.01
0.01
ZFC sodium extract of mixture CuPHS till effervescence ceases.
0.008
0.008
0.006
A pinch of NH4Cl followed by 2 ml. of magnesium sulfate
0.004 was added in the above solution. A white precipitate was
0.006
0.002 observed after addition of excess of ammonium hydroxide.
0
0.004 10 110 210 310 So, presence of phosphate group is conformed in mixture.
Temperature/K
FC
0.002
0
3 Discussion
10 60 110 160 210 260 310 360
Temperature/K
3.1 Stoichiometry Calculation
Fig. 8 Magnetic moment measurement of mixture 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH);
3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O In the typical synthesis of 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH);
3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O mixture, the following
compounds formed.
The Eq. (4) is further simplified to inverse of mass mag- NaPO3 + H 2 O → NaH 2 PO 4
netic susceptibility. 4.5CuSO4·5H 2O + 7.5NaH 2 PO 4 → 0.5Cu 2 ( PO 4 )( OH )
+ 3.5CuH(PO 4 ) 2·H 2O + 18H 2O + 4.5SO 24 − + 7.5Na + + 16H +
T θ
χ g−1 = −
(5)
C C
NaH 2 PO 4 + 7.5Na + + 4.5SO 24 − + 16H + + 18H 2O
The linear equation of the graph between χ g−1 versus tem-
perature in zero field-cooled is → 4.5NaHSO4·H 2O + PO34− +13.5H + + 13.5H 2O + 4Na +
From the above reaction, the mixture should contain 1:1.5
molar ratio of phosphate: sulfate. According to elemental
χ g−1 = 0.1033T + 1.3559. analysis, the mixture contained 2:1 molar ratio of phosphate
and sulfate compound. The excess sodium hydrogen sulfate
The Weiss constant (θ) and Curie constant (C) are −13.125 K reacted with ethanol, during washing of the mixture, to form
and 9.6805 respectively. ethyl sulfuric acid as follows [27].
The linear equation of the graph between χg−1 versus
temperature in field-cooled (FC) is T <305.3 K
2 NaHSO 4 ·H 2 O + C2 H5 OH ← → C2 H5 HSO 4
+ Na 2SO 4 + 2H 2 O
χ g−1 = 532.84T + 4606. The sodium sulfate formed combine with water present in
the reaction mixture and removed from this mixture during
The Weiss constant (θ) and Curie constant (C) are −8.644 K washing.
and 0.001877 respectively. In the typical synthesis of CuPS mixture, the following
The negative Weiss constant values indicate that the mix- compounds formed.
ture is antiferromagnetism.
13
J Inorg Organomet Polym 9
2NaHSO4·H 2O ∆ → 2NaHSO4 + 2H 2O where, fR is the spring constant. The mixture is governed by
~ 353 K
the Hamiltonian
→ Na 2S2O7 + 3H 2O ∆
∆ ~353 K
→ Na 2SO 4 + SO32 − + 3H 2O
P2 f
(9)
HC = + C Q2
3.5CuH(PO4 ) 2 ·H 2 O ∆
~ 353 K
→ 3.5CuH(PO 4 ) 2 + 3.5H 2 O 2M 2
13
10 J Inorg Organomet Polym
Table 1 ICP-AES analysis data of mixtures 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O and 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2;
2Na2SO4
0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O; 2NaHSO4·H2O 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2; 2Na2SO4
Sl. no. Element Found (%) Calculated (%) Found (%) Calculated (%)
13
J Inorg Organomet Polym 11
From Eq. 16, the value of ω0 is given below size is ~47 nm for 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH); 3.5CuH(PO4)2·H2O;
2NaHSO4·H2O and 17.3 nm for 0.5Cu2(PO4)(OH);
ω 3.5CuH(PO4)2; 2Na2SO4.
ω0 =
(20) 1
{ς ± (ς 2 − 1) 2 } Acknowledgments The author TS thanks Indic Institute of Design
and Research for providing necessary laboratory facility for the prepa-
ration of this salt. GSB is thankful to the Director, FST, IFHE for grant-
The damping ratio is <1 for underdamped complex, so the ing permission to get associated with this work.
value of ω0 is negative. Hence the system containing this
mixture is negative specific heat capacity.
Hence, the specific heat capacity of the system at high
temperature is negative. References
In case of heating from low temperature to high tempera-
ture, the bond stability of atoms or molecules in complex at 1. H. Onoda, T. Ohta, K. Kojima, Mater. Chem. Phys 98(2–3), 363
low temperature turns into more instability at high tempera- (2006)
2. H. Onoda, T. Ohta, J . Tamaki, K. Kojima, Appl. Catal. A. 288
ture due to increase of different motions of atoms and mol- (1–2), 98 (2005)
ecules. So, the part of the heat supply utilizes for making 3. H. Onoda, H. Nariai, A. Moriwaki, H. Maki, I. Motooka, J. Mater.
instability in complex and others discard. In present case, Chem. 12(6), 1754 (2002)
the instability of chemical compounds owing to increase of 4. H. Onoda, K. Yokouchi, K. Kojima, H. Nariai, Mater. Sci. Eng. B
116(2), 189 (2005)
different motions of atoms and molecules present in mixture 5. H. Onoda, K.-I. Okumoto, A. Nakahira, I. Tanaka, Method Mater.
for low temperature heating of CuPHS from 223 to 302.5 K 2, 1 (2009)
makes the damping ratio <1. So, specific heat capacity is 6. Q. Li, Y. Yuan, T. Wei, Y. Li, Z. Chen, X. Jin, Y. Qin, W. Sun, Sol.
negative. In case of high temperature heating of mixture Energy Mater. Sol. Cells 130, 426 (2014)
7. L.P. Podgornova, Y. I. Kuznetsov, S.V. Gavrilova, Prot. Met.
CuPS in first thermal cycle from 298 to 383 K and second 39(3), 217 (2003)
thermal cycle from 298 to 464 K is also negative specific 8. B. Lucheva, T.S. Tsonev, R. Petkov, J . Univ. Chem. Technol.
heat capacity. In this case, the amount of heat absorbs by Metall. 40(3), 235 (2005)
making the instability of bonds between atoms and mol- 9. S.-N. Le, A. Navrotsky, V. Pralong, J . Solid State Sci. 10, 761
(2008)
ecules present in the mixture. Hence, the damping ratio is 10. J. Formosa, J.M. Chimenos, A.M. Lacasta, M. Niubo, Ceram. Int.
<1 due to increase in different of motions among atoms and 38, 2483 (2012)
molecules. 11. M.E. Navarro, M. Martinez, A. Gil, A.I. Fernandez, L.F. Cabeza,
In case of positive specific heat capacity, the amount of R. Olives, X. Py, Sol. Energy Mater. Sol. Cells 107, 131 (2012)
12. Li-Jun Zhang, You-Ying Di, Zhi-Cheng Tan, Jian-Min Dou, Sol.
energy release is more and makes the mixture more stable Energy Mater. Sol. Cells 101, 79 (2012)
than before. This is due to decrease in instability by reduc- 13. E. Alonso, C. Perez-Rabago, J . Licurgo, E. Fuentealba, C.A.
ing the different motions of atoms and molecules in mix- Estrada, Sol. Energy 115, 297 (2015)
ture. The positive specific heat capacity is observed for two 14. F. Parveen, B. Sannakki, M.V. Mandke, H.M. Pathan, Sol. Energy
Mater. Sol. Cells 144, 371 (2016)
stages in two thermal cycles of cooling from 302.5 to 223 K 15. N. Onmura, T. Tagawa, S. Goto, Appl. Catal. A: Gen 166(2), 321
in mixture for CuPHS and from 573 to 489.33 K in first (1998)
thermal cycle and 573 to 486 K in second thermal cycle of 16. N. Abadzhjieva, P. Tzokov, I. Uzunov, V. Minkov, D. Klissurski,
mixture CuPS. V. Rives, React. Kinet. Catal. Lett. 53(2), 413 (1994)
17. A. Periasamy, S. Muruganand, M. Palaniswamy, Rasayan J .
Chem., 2(4), 981 (2009)
18. M. Ouchabi, M. Baalala, A. Elaissi and M. Bensitel, J . Mater.
4 Conclusion Environ. Sci. 7(4), 1417 (2016)
19. L. Chen, F. Liu and D. Li, Hydrometallurgy, 105, 229 (2011)
20. X.-Z. Chen, J.-H. Tang, Y.-N. Cui, M. Liu and D. Mao, J. Chem.
The characterization of these mixtures was carried out by Eng. Data 59, 481 (2014)
FT-IR, C–H–N–S, ICP-AES, TG-DTA, UV–Vis–NIR, 21. C. Rodriguez-Navarro, E. Doehne, E. Sebastian, Cem. Concr.
HRTEM, VSM, XRD and magnesia mixture test. The cop- Res. 30, 1527 (2000)
per containing mixtures, CuPHS and CuPS, can be used as 22. G.K. Willianson, W.H. Hall, Acta. Metall. 1(1) 22 (1953)
23. A. Monshi, M.R. Foroughi, M.R. Monshi, World J. Nano. Sci.
thermal storage material using latent heat technique because Eng. 2(3), 154 (2012). doi:10.4236/wjnse.2012.23020
both the mixtures are endothermic in nature in all cycles. 24. S.F.A. Kettle, in Physical Inorganic Chemistry: A Coordination
The both mixtures are far superior for using as thermal Chemistry Approach, ed. by W.H. Freeman (Spectrum Academic
storage materials than other materials. The first mixture is Publishers, Oxford, 1996)
25. T. Swain, J . Therm. Anal. Calorim. doi:10.1007/
found antiferromagnetism due to negative Weiss constant s10973-016-5810-2
value. The band gap of both mixtures at λmax 268 nm is 26. B. Bogdanović, A. Ritter, B. Spliethoff, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.
~4.60 eV. So, both are insulators. The average crystallite 29, 223 (1990)
13
12 J Inorg Organomet Polym
27. M. Leatherman, Process for the preparation of anhydrous ethyl 32. P. Hanggi, G.-L. Ingold, P. Talkner, New. J . Phys. (2008).
sulphuric acid, US Patent No. US3024263A, 1952 doi:10.1088/1367-2630/10/11/115008
28. T. Swain, J. Therm. Anal. Calorim. 103(3), 1111 (2011) 33. A.J . Leggett, S. Chakravarty, A.T. Dorsey, M.P.A. Fisher, A.
29. T. Swain, J. Therm. Anal. Calorim. 110, 929 (2012) Garg, W. Zwerger, Rev. Mod. Phys. 59, 1 (1987)
30. T. Swain, J. Therm. Anal. Calorim. 109, 365 (2012) 34. G-L. Ingold, Lect. Notes. Phys. 611, 1 (2002)
31. P. Hanggi, G-L. Ingold, Acta. Phys. Pol. B 37, 1537 (2006)
13