COMPARATIVE STATEMENT (CST)

Construction of Rd above Sub Base Lvl for 137 x SUHs at Sec-S Askari-X Lahore
Quoted Cost by Contractors
At Par Cost (Rs.)
Ser Description of Work on MES Sch of M/S Zareen M/s Over Land M/s Naseer M/s A2Z Const M/S Jamko Remarks
Rates 2021 Khan Const Co Construction Co Builders Co Building Trust

Construction of Rd upto Sub

1 Base Lvl at Sec-S Askari-X 40,279,433 71,182,673 77,049,105 80,086,000 84,240,548 84,972,507
Lahore

Total Amount 40,279,433 71,182,673 77,049,105 80,086,000 84,240,548 84,972,507

Diff (At par cost & Quoted

30,903,240 36,769,672 39,806,567 43,961,115 44,693,074
cost)

Derived % age 76.72% 91.29% 98.83% 109.14% 110.96%

The rates are reasonable as quoted by the lowest bidder M/s _____________________________ and recommended for approval of competent auth.
Note:- Above Rate is Based on Housing Supply list Aug 2022 (Cement & Steel)
 Anx-A
To ADH (W)-IV Lhr Ltr no.
PANEL OF CONTRACTORS 749/Bdry Wall/Ask-X/ADH-II
dated _____ Sep 2023

Name of Proj: Construction of Outer Boundary Wall Askari-X Lahore

PEC Enlisted with Hsg Dte Proj Currently in Hand Proj Exec with Hsg
Ser Name of Firm Remarks
Regn or Not with Hsg Dte Dte
CA DH-46/21, 51/20,
1 M/s KATS Enterprises 41484 - CA DH-48/23 & 135/21
137/18 & PDH-07/19

M/s Ali Associates & CA DH-49/23, 83/23 & CA DH-54/20, 136/20,

2 27831 -
Builders 133/21 146/18, 31/17 & 45/15

M/s A 2 Z Construction
3 2566 - DH-84/21 & 138/21 DH-53/20
Company
 COMPARATIVE STATEMENT (CST)
Const of Main Park for SUHs at Sec-S Askari-X lahore
Quoted Cost by Contractors on Quotation Base
Ser Description of Work M/s Suleman M/s New Green Nursery Remarks
M/s Babar Nursery Farm
Nurseries Farm

1 Horticulture Work 8,527,080 8,782,892 8,996,069

2 Ornamental Work 3,362,000 3,462,860 3,546,910

3 Kids Playing Gadgets 6,306,600 6,495,798 6,653,463

Total Amount 18,195,680 18,741,550 19,196,442

The rates are reasonable as quoted by the lowest bidder M/S Babar Nursery Farm and recommended for approval of competent auth.
 COMPARATIVE STATEMENT (CST)
Const of Linear Park-1 for SUHs at Sec-S Askari-X lahore
Quoted Cost by Contractors on Quotation Base
Ser Description of Work M/s Suleman M/s New Green Nursery Remarks
M/s Babar Nursery Farm
Nurseries Farm

1 Horticulture Work 6,683,538 6,884,044 7,051,133

2 Ornamental Work 3,020,000 3,110,600 3,186,100

3 Kids Playing Gadgets 5,394,000 5,555,820 5,690,670

Total Amount 15,097,538 15,550,464 15,927,903

The rates are reasonable as quoted by the lowest bidder M/S Babar Nursery Farm and recommended for approval of competent auth.
 COMPARATIVE STATEMENT (CST)
Providing / Laying Asphalt work with Transportation Complete at Sec-S Askari-X Lahore
Quoted Cost by Contractors
Ser Description of Work M/S BRC M/S RBS M/S Highway Remarks
(Bitumen Road Const) Constructions & M/S SAM Enterprises International Engineering
Asphalt Plant

Cleaning and Brooming, of

prepared compacted bed surface /
existing surface, providing &
applying CUT BACK of ratio 50, 50%
Prime coat & 100% bitumen for
Tack coat. Providing & laying
compacted Wearing Course of
1 required Thickness Asphalt layer 14,200 / Ton 15,500 / Ton 16,000 / Ton 16,200 / Ton
with Bitumen 4.2% Content of
60/70 grade ARL. (JMF provide by
client). Asphalt transport to site,
laying of asphalt with machinery to
attain proper finishing and
compaction. (AWC 2" Thick)

Ask- XI, FWO, DHA & Citi Ask-V, Ask-X, Ask-XI & Ask-X,XI ,Lake city,park view and DHA Lhr, MES, Lhr Smart
2 Work Experience Housing -------35 Yrs NLC -------- 11 Yrs Lahore Moter way city -------- 26 Yrs City & SA Garden ----25Yrs

3 Asphalt Plant Location DHA Phase -9 Mahmood Booti Faiz pur inter change Mohlanwal Multan road
DHA Rehbar sec-4 Lahore
4 Distance from Sec-S Askari-X 10 km & 15 Km 8 km 35 km 30 km
a.Asphalt plant -2
a.Asphalt plant -2 a. Asphalt plant - 2
a.Asphalt plant -1
5 Machinery b. PTR -2
b. PTR -2 b. PTR -4 b. PTR - 4
c. Dumper Truck - 12 c. Dumper truck -10 c. Dumper truck - 5 (inc as per req) c. Dumper truck - 13
6 Per Day Capacity 1000 Ton / day 1000 Ton / day 900 Ton / day 1000 Ton / day
7 Bitumen Direct to be paid to Direct to be paid to Direct to be paid to PARCO / firm Direct to be paid to
PARCO / firm PARCO / firm PARCO / firm
8 DLP 1 Year 1 Year 1 Year 1 Year
 COMPARATIVE STATEMENT (CST)
Providing / Laying Asphalt work with Transportation Complete at Sec-S Askari-X Lahore

Ser Description of Work M/S RBS M/S Highway Remarks

Constructions & M/S SAM Enterprises International Engineering
Asphalt Plant

Cleaning and Brooming, of

prepared compacted bed surface /
existing surface, providing &
applying CUT BACK of ratio 50, 50%
Prime coat & 100% bitumen for
Tack coat. Providing & laying
compacted Wearing Course of
1 required Thickness Asphalt layer 15,500 / Ton 16,000 / Ton 16,200 / Ton
with Bitumen 4.2% Content of
60/70 grade ARL. (JMF provide by
client). Asphalt transport to site,
laying of asphalt with machinery to
attain proper finishing and
compaction. (AWC 2" Thick)

Ask-V, Ask-X, Ask-XI & Ask-X,XI ,Lake city,park view and DHA Lhr, MES, Lhr Smart
2 Work Experience NLC -------- 11 Yrs Lahore Moter way city -------- 26 Yrs City & SA Garden ----25Yrs

3 Asphalt Plant Location Mahmood Booti Faiz pur inter change Mohlanwal Multan road
Lahore
4 Distance from Sec-S Askari-X 8 km 35 km 30 km
a.Asphalt plant -2
a. Asphalt plant - 2
a.Asphalt plant -1
5 Machinery b. PTR -2
b. PTR -4 b. PTR - 4
c. Dumper truck -10 c. Dumper truck - 5 (inc as per req) c. Dumper truck - 13
6 Per Day Capacity 1000 Ton / day 900 Ton / day 1000 Ton / day
7 Bitumen Direct to be paid to Direct to be paid to PARCO / firm Direct to be paid to
PARCO / firm PARCO / firm
8 DLP 1 Year 1 Year 1 Year
 COMPARATIVE STATEMENT (CST)
Const of Cycle Track at Sec-S Askari-X lahore
Quoted Cost by Contractors on Quotation Base
Ser Description of Work MES Sch of rate Remarks
M/S Babar Nursery
2021 at par M/S Suleman M/S New Green
Farm
Cost

1 Const of Cycle Track at Sec-S 3,040,907 5,683,967 5,766,495 5,963,357

Ask-X Lahore

Total Amount 3,040,907 5,683,967 5,766,495 5,963,357

Diff (At par cost & Quoted cost) 2,643,060 2,725,588 2,922,450

Derived % age 86.91% 89.63% 96.10%

The rates are reasonable as quoted by the lowest bidder M/S Babar Nursery Farm and recommended for approval of competent auth.