Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Liver Transplantation For Urea Cycle Disorders
Liver Transplantation For Urea Cycle Disorders
Liver Transplantation For Urea Cycle Disorders
ABSTRACT
Background. Urea cycle disorders (UCD) are caused by rare inherited defects in the
urea cycle enzymes leading to diminished ability to convert ammonia to urea in the liver.
The resulting excess of circulating ammonia can lead to central nervous system toxicity and
irreversible neurologic damage. Most cases are identified in children. However, UCDs can
also be diagnosed in adulthood, and liver transplant is occasionally required.
Methods. We examined the UNOS database to evaluate outcomes in adult and pediatric
patients who underwent liver transplant as treatment for a UCD. We identified 265 pe-
diatric and 13 adult patients who underwent liver transplant for a UCD between 1987
and 2010.
Results. The majority (68%) of these patients were transplanted before age 5 years.
Ornithine transcarbamylase (OTC) deficiency was the most common UCD in both adults
and children who underwent transplant. UCD patients who underwent liver transplant
were younger, more likely to be male (67%), had lower pediatric end-stage liver disease/
model for end-stage liver disease scores, and were more likely to be Caucasian or Asian
compared with all other patients transplanted during the same time period. UCD
patients did not have an increased utilization of living donor transplantation in this US
cohort. Univariate and multivariate risk factor analyses were performed and did not
reveal any significant factors that were predictive of post-transplant death or graft loss.
Conclusions. Excellent outcomes were seen in both children and adults with UCDs who
underwent transplant with overall 1-, 5-, and 10-year survivals of 93%, 89%, and 87%,
respectively.
Table 1. Recipient and Donor Characteristics of Patients Transplanted for Urea Cycle Disorders and All Other Transplants Between
1988 and 2010
Pediatric Adult
UCD All others UCD All Others
Characteristic n ¼ 265 n ¼ 12198 P Value n ¼ 13 n ¼ 92,929 P Value
Age 2.6 " 4.0 4.8 " 5.6 <.001 28 " 12 51 " 11 <.001
Sex (% female patients) 33 52 <.001 69 36 .015
Ethnicity (%)†
Caucasian 68 58 <.001 70 76 NS
Black 8.7 18 <.001 7 8.0 NS
Hispanic 15 18 NS 0 11 NS
Asian 6.8 3.8 <.001 23 4.0 NS
Other 1.5 2.2 NS 0 1 NS
BMI* 18.6 " 4.3 18.2 " 4.4 NS 25.4 " 3.9 35.7 " 5.4 NS
Albumin (g/L) 3.6 " 0.80 3.1 " 0.80 <.001 3.4 " 0.56 2.9 " 0.73 .006
Creatinine (mg/dL) 0.38 " 0.45 0.60 " 0.90 <.001 1.0 " 0.77 1.5 " 1.3 NS
Bilirubin (mg/dL) 1.28 " 3.72 12.3 " 12.0 <.001 4.2 " 7.9 8.1 " 10.8 NS
INR‡ 1.29 " 0.65 1.99 " 2.54 <.001 1.2 " 0.32 1.9 " 1.5 NS
ALT (IU/mL)† 205 " 670 357 " 931 .048 42.8 " 45.2 206 " 709 NS
PELD or MELD 0.47 " 8.0 15.9 " 13.8 <.001 13.2 " 10.2 21.2 " 10.0 .026
MELD exception 41 23 <.001 73 27 .003
(after 2002) (%)
Cold ischemia time (hours)* 7.8 " 4.7 8.8 " 5.3 .005 7.6 " 2.4 8.4 " 4.6 NS
Living donor (%) 6.0 10.7 .015 7.7 3.1 NS
Donor age (years) 9.9 " 1 1.6 13.9 " 14.7 <.001 42 " 15 38 " 17 NS
Donor BMI* 20.8 " 10.9 43.5 " 721 NS 25 " 3.9 26 " 5.3 NS
*Data 75% complete; 90%.
†
Data 50% complete; 75%.
‡
Data <50% complete.
Most UCDs are mainly or exclusively expressed in the liver. characteristics and outcomes of patients who underwent
Therefore, the enzyme defect is essentially cured by a liver liver transplant for a UCD. To our knowledge, this is the
transplant. However, liver transplant carries risks of its own largest and most comprehensive study of its kind.
including surgical risk and long-term risk of for infection and
malignancy related to immunosuppression. Data are limited METHODS
regarding the long-term outcomes of liver transplant for Case Identification
UCDs. Morioka et al [6] published a review of the review of
the worldwide English literature and 13 cases at Kyoto Uni- Patients with UCDs were identified from the UNOS Standard
Transplant Analysis and Research files of liver transplant recipients
versity. They report excellent survival of approximately 90%
between October 1987 and May 2010. UNOS does not have specific
at 5 years. However, this study was limited by small numbers diagnosis codes for UCDs. Therefore, patients with UCDs were
and limitations as the result of a literature reviewebased identified by text-searching the diagnosis fields in the UNOS data-
approach. More recently, Perito et al [7] analyzed the United base for text containing “urea,” “ornithine,” “OTC,” “carbamoyl,”
Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) database data for com- “CPS” (carbamoylphosphate synthetase I), “argin,” or “citrul.”
bined outcomes in pediatric patients with UCDs and organic Patients identified with a specific or an unidentified UCD were
acidemias. Excellent outcomes were noted in the combined included in the study. Available data were >90% complete for age,
group. UCDs and OAs can present with common symptoms, sex, bilirubin, creatinine, and albumin. Available data were >75%
but the metabolic pathways involved and the medical thera- complete for recipient body mass index (BMI), donor BMI, and
pies are distinct. Therefore, a combined outcome may not cold ischemia time. Available data were >50% complete for ala-
naine aminotransferase (ALT) and ethnicity data. International
accurately reflect outcomes in the individual disorders.
normalized ratio (INR) was documented in less than 50% of the
With increasing frequency, UCDs are diagnosed in data. Data on pediatric end-stage liver disease (PELD), model for
adulthood, often in the setting of an acute illness triggering end-stage liver disease (MELD), and the use of PELD/MELD ex-
increased nitrogen turnover [8]. The majority of cases ceptions were only available for data collected after March 2002.
diagnosed in adulthood are mild and can be controlled with Patient data were excluded if abnormal and/or unrealistic values for
medical therapy alone. However, liver transplant is occa- albumin (<0.5 or >6 g/dL), bilirubin (<0.1 or >50 mg/dL), creat-
sionally required [9], and fatal cases of adult onset UCDs inine (<0.1 or >15 mg/dL), or BMI (>55 kg/m2) were identified.
have been reported [10,11].
The UNOS dataset is a nationwide registry of organ Statistical Analysis
transplants performed in the United States since 1987. In All statistical analyses were performed with the use of the SSPS 20.0
this study, we queried the UNOS dataset to determine the statistical package (SPSS Inc, Chicago, Ill, United States). A P value
LIVER TRANSPLANTATION FOR UREA CYCLE DISORDERS 2415
Table 2. Causes of Death for Patients Transplanted for UCDs management of a UCD may represent a subset of patients
Cause of Death (n ¼ 27) Number of Patients (%) with mild disease. Clinically, liver transplant is generally
Infection 12 (44.4)
reserved for patients in whom medical therapy fails or for
Multi-organ failure 7 (26.0) neonatal onset of a UCD [1].
Graft failure 4 (14.8) In a large multicenter trial including more than 300 pa-
Hemorrhage 1 (3.7) tients treated with combined sodium phenylacetate and
Neurologic 1 (3.7) sodium benzoate for hyper-ammonemia, 83% survival was
PTLD 1 (3.7) reported after up to 11 years of follow-up [12]. However,
Malignancy, NOS 1 (3.7) death was strongly correlated with age at presentation of a
UCD. Newborns (age less than 30 days) had the lowest
overall survival, at 35%. In our analysis, data for newborns
compared with pediatric cases. The type of UCD was not were not available because the UNOS dataset does not re-
documented in 11% of cases (UCD-NOS in Fig 1). cord age in days. In a sub-analysis, we used weight to give a
Table 1 shows the age distribution for patients trans- rough estimate of age, with the average 30-day-old newborn
planted for UCDs over the study period. The most frequent weighing approximately 5 kg. We identified 17 patients
age for transplant was less than age 1 year (37%). and the transplanted for a UCD who weighed less than 5 kg at the
majority of patients were transplanted before age 5 years time of transplant. The 5-year survival rate for these pa-
(68%). However, a broad range of ages was seen, with 1 tients was 84%, which suggests that transplant survival is
patient being transplanted at age 62 years. equivalent in newborns compared with other age groups.
Regardless of survival equivalence, a patient medically
Survival
treated for a UCD can expect to require close medical
Kaplan-Meier survival curves are shown in Fig 2A. There follow-up and recurrence of hyper-ammonemic crises.
were no statistically significant differences in patient or graft Because liver transplant cures the underlying metabolic
survival between age groups. Overall, patient and graft abnormality, recurrent hyper-ammonemia is not seen, and
survival compared favorably to liver transplant for all other the quality of life after liver transplant would be expected to
causes during the same time period (not shown). One-year be improved. Patients with UCDs treated medically are
and 5-year patient survival rates were 97% and 89%, more likely to have intellectual disabilities [13] and sub-
respectively, for children transplanted for a UCD. One-year optimal neurologic outcomes [14]. The UNOS database
and 5-year graft survival rates were 100% and 90%, does not provide cognitive function or developmental data
respectively, in adults. Early death and graft loss (<30 days) that would be useful to further evaluate outcomes in UCD
occurred in 3% and 15% of the patients and grafts, patients after transplant. Limited studies suggest that
respectively. A total of 27 patients (10%) who underwent neurologic outcome may be better if liver transplantation
liver transplant for UCDs died during the study period. The occurs before age 1 year. Campeau et al [5] report that
causes of death are shown in Table 2. The primary cause of developmental quotient scores were improved in patients
death was infection. The cause of graft loss was available for who underwent transplantation before age 1 year compared
53 of 59 graft losses. The main causes of graft loss were with patients transplanted at age 3 years. They postulated
vascular thrombosis, primary graft failure, biliary compli- that early transplantation limits the cumulative number
cations, and infection (Table 3). hyper-ammonemic episodes, reducing the potential for
irreversible neurologic damage, and thus improving long-
Risk Factors for Death or Graft Failure term outcomes in these patients. The most common age
Risk factors for death or graft failure were analyzed by both for liver transplant for UCDs in this study was less than 1
univariate and multivariate logistic regression analysis. For year, and overall survival for this age group was comparable
these analyses, we used variables listed in Table 1. No fac- to all other age groups.
tors were identified that were predictive of death or graft Recently, results from a combined cohort of pediatric
loss. patients with UCDs (n ¼ 186) and/or organic acidemias
(OAs) (n ¼ 137) was presented [7]. Overall, transplant missed. Therefore, we have probably underestimated the
outcomes were excellent for patients in this cohort, partic- total number of patients transplanted for UCDs. Further-
ularly in patients transplanted after age 5 years, who had more, there is no information regarding how the UCD di-
99% 5-year survival. We focused on outcomes in UCDs agnoses were made. Some of the cases identified here may
alone because it may not be valid to combine outcomes for represent misdiagnoses. Finally, important outcome data
two distinct disease processes. OAs represent a diverse relevant to this study, including developmental and neuro-
family of metabolic diseases caused by defects in amino acid logic complications, were not reliably available.
metabolism. Liver transplant outcomes for more common
forms of organic acidemia, including maples syrup urine CONCLUSIONS
disease, and methylmalonic academia, have been studied
with favorable outcomes reported [15,16]. Unlike the anal- UCDs are rare indications for liver transplant, especially in
ysis presented here, neither of these studies included adult adults. Excellent post-transplant survival was seen in both
patients, ostensibly because most OAs generally become children and adults who underwent liver transplant for
clinically apparent during the newborn period or early in- UCD. This can probably be attributed to 2 main factors: 1)
fancy [17]. UCD patients do not have chronic liver disease leading into
We did not see an increased utilization of living donor liver transplant, and 2) liver transplant cures the underlying
transplant (LDLT) in this cohort of US patients undergoing metabolic defect, eliminating the risk of recurrent disease.
liver transplant. Wakiya et al [18] indicated that LDLT is a Outcomes were similar across all ages, and liver transplant
viable option for OTC patients. The caveat is that if a relative is should be considered early in neonatal cases of UCD and
used as a living donor, they should be tested to rule out a those considered refractory to optimal medical therapy.
clinically silent UCD in the donor liver. The lack of utilization
of LDLT this US cohort probably reflects a deceased utilization REFERENCES
of LDLT overall in the United States compared with Japan
[1] Lanpher BC, Gropman A, Chapman KA, et al. Urea cycle
rather than a specific bias toward UCD patients [19]. disorders overview. In: Pagon RA, Bird TD, Dolan CR, et al., ed-
OTC is the most common type of UCD and also the most itors. GeneReviews. Seattle (WA): University of Washington,
common type of UCD to receive a liver transplant. OTC is Seattle; 1993.
an X-linked disorder, and this accounts for the male pre- [2] Summar ML, Dobbelaere D, Brusilow S, Lee B. Diagnosis,
symptoms, frequency and mortality of 260 patients with urea cycle
dominance of UCD patients in this and other liver trans- disorders from a 21-year, multicentre study of acute hyper-
plant cohorts [6]. No difference in survival was seen that was ammonaemic episodes. Acta Paediatr 2008;97:1420e5.
based on type of UCD at the time of transplant. [3] Summar M, Tuchman M. Proceedings of a consensus con-
UCDs are increasingly being identified in adults. There is ference for the management of patients with urea cycle disorders.
an abundance of case reports of adult patients diagnosed J Pediatr 2001;138(1 Suppl):S6e10.
[4] Haeberle J, Boddaert N, Burlina A, et al. Suggested guide-
with UCDs [8e10,20e25]. The presentation of a UCD in lines for the diagnosis and management of urea cycle disorders.
adults is similar to presentation in pediatric cases with Orphanet J Rare Dis 2012;7:32.
repeated episodes of encephalopathy and hyper- [5] Campeau PM, Pivalizza PJ, Miller G, et al. Early orthotopic
ammonemia. However, given that UCDs are so rare in liver transplantation in urea cycle defects: follow up of a develop-
mental outcome study. Mol Genet Metab 2010;100(Suppl 1):S84e7.
adults, there is usually a significant delay in diagnosis [8,23]. [6] Morioka D, Kasahara M, Takada Y, et al. Current role of
Most cases of adult-onset UCDs can be managed with di- liver transplantation for the treatment of urea cycle disorders: a
etary restriction and ammonia scavenging therapies alone. review of the worldwide English literature and 13 cases at Kyoto
Most presentations of encephalopathy and hyper- University. Liver Transplant 2005;11:1332e42.
ammonemia are triggered by stress-induced increased ni- [7] Perito ER, Rhee S, Roberts JP, Rosenthal P. Pediatric liver
transplantation for urea cycle disorders and organic acidemias:
trogen turnover. Several recent reports indicate that gastric United Network for Organ Sharing Data for 2002-2012. Liver
bypass can trigger adult-onset UCDs as well [26,27]. Transplant 2014;20:89e99.
Although only 13 adult patients were identified in this study, [8] Legras A, Labarthe F, Maillot F, et al. Late diagnosis of
excellent survival was seen. In general, adult patients had ornithine transcarbamylase defect in three related female patients:
polymorphic presentations. Crit Care Med 2002;30:241e4.
baseline characteristics similar to pediatric UCD patients. [9] Bates TR, Lewis BD, Burnett JR, et al. Late-onset carbamoyl
They were transplanted with low native MELD scores and phosphate synthetase 1 deficiency in an adult cured by liver trans-
were more likely to receive MELD exceptions compared with plantation. Liver Transplant 2011;17:1481e4.
all other transplants during the same time period. Thus, liver [10] Bezinover D, Douthitt L, McQuillan PM, et al. Fatal
transplant appears to be a good option for an adult UCD hyperammonemia after renal transplant due to late-onset urea cycle
deficiency: a case report. Transplant Proc 2010;42:1982e5.
patient who is refractory to medical therapy. [11] Lien J, Nyhan WL, Barshop BA. Fatal initial adult-onset
There are several limitations of this study. The UNOS presentation of urea cycle defect. Arch Neurol 2007;64:1777e9.
database does not have a specific diagnosis code for UCDs. [12] Enns GM, Berry SA, Berry GT, et al. Survival after treat-
Therefore, we relied on text entry for diagnoses. We used a ment with phenylacetate and benzoate for urea-cycle disorders.
N Engl J Med 2007;356:2282e92.
text search for partial words and abbreviations to attempt to [13] Krivitzky L, Babikian T, Lee HS, et al. Intellectual, adap-
capture all diagnoses. However, diagnoses entered that were tive, and behavioral functioning in children with urea cycle disor-
grossly misspelled or not entered at all would have been ders. Pediatr Res 2009;66:96e101.
2418 YU, RAYHILL, HSU ET AL
[14] Enns GM. Neurologic damage and neurocognitive [21] Ben-Ari Z, Dalal A, Morry A, et al. Adult-onset ornithine
dysfunction in urea cycle disorders. Semin Pediatr Neurol 2008;15: transcarbamylase (OTC) deficiency unmasked by the Atkins’ diet.
132e9. J Hepatol 2010;52:292e5.
[15] Mazariegos GV, Morton DH, Sindhi R, et al. Liver trans- [22] Peterson DE. Acute postpartum mental status change and
plantation for classical maple syrup urine disease: long-term follow- coma caused by previously undiagnosed ornithine transcarbamylase
up in 37 patients and comparative United Network for Organ deficiency. Obstet Gynecol 2003;102(5 Pt 2):1212e5.
Sharing experience. J Pediatr 2012;160:116e21.e1. [23] Summar ML, Barr F, Dawling S, et al. Unmasked adult-
[16] Niemi AK, Kim IK, Krueger CE, et al. Treatment of onset urea cycle disorders in the critical care setting. Crit Care
methylmalonic acidemia by liver or combined liver-kidney trans- Clin 2005;21(4 Suppl):S1e8.
plantation. J Pediatr 2015;166:1455e61.e1. [24] Gaspari R, Arcangeli A, Mensi S, et al. Late-onset presen-
[17] Leonard JV, Morris AA. Inborn errors of metabolism tation of ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency in a young woman
around time of birth. Lancet 2000;356:583e7. with hyperammonemic coma. Ann Emerg Med 2003;41:104e9.
[18] Wakiya T, Sanada Y, Mizuta K, et al. Living donor liver [25] Trivedi M, Zafar S, Spalding MJ, Jonnalagadda S. Ornithine
transplantation for ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency. Pediatr transcarbamylase deficiency unmasked because of gastrointestinal
Transplant 2011;15:390e5. bleeding. J Clin Gastroenterol 2001;32:340e3.
[19] Vagefi PA, Ascher NL, Freise CE, et al. Use of living donor [26] Hu WT, Kantarci OH, Merritt 2nd JL, et al. Ornithine
liver transplantation varies with the availability of deceased donor transcarbamylase deficiency presenting as encephalopathy during
liver transplantation. Liver Transpl 2012;18:160e5. adulthood following bariatric surgery. Arch Neurol 2007;64:126e8.
[20] Atiq M, Holt AF, Safdar K, et al. Adult onset urea cycle [27] Fenves A, Boland CR, Lepe R, et al. Fatal hyper-
disorder in a patient with presumed hepatic encephalopathy. J Clin ammonemic encephalopathy after gastric bypass surgery. Am J Med
Gastroenterol 2008;42:213e4. 2008;121:e1e2.