Microsoft Excel 16.

25 Answer Report
Worksheet: [for wan.xlsx]3 nodes
Report Created: 18/05/2019 11:31:20 PM
Result: Solver found a solution. All constraints and optimality conditions are satisfied.
Solver Engine
Engine: Simplex LP
Solution Time: 2164.752 Seconds.
Iterations: 10 Subproblems: 0
Solver Options
Max Time Unlimited, Iterations Unlimited, Precision 0.000001
Max Subproblems Unlimited, Max Integer Sols Unlimited, Integer Tolerance 100%, Assume NonNegative

Objective Cell (Min)

Cell Name Original Value Final Value
$B$17 Objective value (min. cost) GEN 1 (X14202.1428571 4202.1428571

Variable Cells
Cell Name Original Value Final Value Integer
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 300 Contin
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 55 55 Contin
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 0 Contin
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 500 Contin
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 263.16326531 263.16326531 Contin
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 454.08163265 454.08163265 Contin
$H$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-OTA 415 415 Contin
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 30 30 Contin
$J$6 Variable values (MWh) FHLY-OTA 385 385 Contin

Constraints
Cell Name Cell Value Formula Status Slack
$K$10 Node HAY Sumproduct 5.684342E-14 $K$10=$L$10 Binding 0
$K$11 Node HLY Sumproduct 0 $K$11=$L$11 Binding 0
$K$12 Node OTA Sumproduct 800 $K$12=$L$12 Binding 0
$K$13 Kirchoff's law Sumproduct 0 $K$13=$L$13 Binding 0
$K$9 Node BEN Sumproduct 300 $K$9=$L$9 Binding 0
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 $B$6<=$B$16 Binding 0
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 $B$6>=$B$15 Not Binding 300
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 55 $C$6<=$C$16 Not Binding 45
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 55 $C$6>=$C$15 Not Binding 55
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 $D$6<=$D$16 Not Binding 100
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 $D$6>=$D$15 Binding 0
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 $E$6<=$E$16 Binding 0
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 $E$6>=$E$15 Not Binding 500
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 263.16326531 $F$6<=$F$16 Not Binding 36.836734694
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 263.16326531 $F$6>=$F$15 Not Binding 263.16326531
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 454.08163265 $G$6<=$G$16 Not Binding 45.918367347
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 454.08163265 $G$6>=$G$15 Not Binding 954.08163265
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 30 $I$6<=$I$16 Binding 0
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 30 $I$6>=$I$15 Not Binding 60
NonNegative
Microsoft Excel 16.25 Sensitivity Report
Worksheet: [for wan.xlsx]3 nodes
Report Created: 18/05/2019 11:31:21 PM

Variable Cells
Final Reduced Objective Allowable
Cell Name Value Cost Coefficient Increase
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1 300 -8 4 8
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2 55 0 12 88
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3 0 88 100 1E+030
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4 500 -6 1 6
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5 263.16326531 0 7 4.5294117647
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY454.08163265 0 0 4.62
$H$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-OTA 415 0 0 14.142857143
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 30 -7.0714285714 0 7.0714285714
$J$6 Variable values (MWh) FHLY-OTA 385 0 0 1E+030

Constraints
Final Shadow Constraint Allowable
Cell Name Value Price R.H. Side Increase
$K$10 Node HAY Sumproduct 5.684342E-14 7.2857142857 0 35.392156863
$K$11 Node HLY Sumproduct 0 12 0 45
$K$12 Node OTA Sumproduct 800 9.6428571429 800 70.784313725
$K$13 Kirchoff's law Sumproduct 0 2.3571428571 0 90
$K$9 Node BEN Sumproduct 300 7 300 36.836734694
 Allowable
Decrease
1E+030
4.7142857143
88
1E+030
6
1E+030
1E+030
1E+030
14.142857143

Allowable
Decrease
252.84313725
55
110
70.784313725
263.16326531
3 nodes

GEN MER Line

Variables GEN 1 (X1) GEN 2 (X2) GEN 3 (X3) MER 1 (X4) MER 2(X5) FBEN-HAY FHAY-OTA
Price ($) 4 12 100 1 7
Variable values (MWh) 300 55 0 500 263.16327 454.08163 415

Node Balances
Node BEN 0 0 0 1 1 -1.02 0
Node HAY 0 0 0 0 0 0.98 -1
Node HLY 1 1 1 0 0 0 0
Node OTA 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
Kirchoff's law 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1

lower 0 0 0 0 0 -500
upper 300 100 100 500 300 500
Objective value (min.
cost) 4202.1429

1
Line
FHAY-HLY FHLY-OTA

30 385

Sumproduct Demand
0 0 300 300
-1 0 0 0
1 -1 0 0
0 1 800 800
1 1 0 0

-30
30
Microsoft Excel 16.25 Answer Report
Worksheet: [for wan.xlsx]3 nodes (50)
Report Created: 18/05/2019 11:32:58 PM
Result: Solver found a solution. All constraints and optimality conditions are satisfied.
Solver Engine
Engine: Simplex LP
Solution Time: 2123 Seconds.
Iterations: 10 Subproblems: 0
Solver Options
Max Time Unlimited, Iterations Unlimited, Precision 0.000001
Max Subproblems Unlimited, Max Integer Sols Unlimited, Integer Tolerance 100%, Assume NonNegative

Objective Cell (Min)

Cell Name Original Value Final Value
$B$17 Objective value (min. cost) GEN 1 (X14202.1428571 4060.7142857

Variable Cells
Cell Name Original Value Final Value Integer
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 300 Contin
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 55 25 Contin
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 0 Contin
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 500 Contin
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 263.16326531 294.3877551 Contin
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 454.08163265 484.69387755 Contin
$H$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-OTA 415 425 Contin
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 30 50 Contin
$J$6 Variable values (MWh) FHLY-OTA 385 375 Contin

Constraints
Cell Name Cell Value Formula Status Slack
$K$10 Node HAY Sumproduct -5.684342E-14 $K$10=$L$10 Binding 0
$K$11 Node HLY Sumproduct 0 $K$11=$L$11 Binding 0
$K$12 Node OTA Sumproduct 800 $K$12=$L$12 Binding 0
$K$13 Kirchoff's law Sumproduct 0 $K$13=$L$13 Binding 0
$K$9 Node BEN Sumproduct 300 $K$9=$L$9 Binding 0
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 $B$6<=$B$16 Binding 0
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 $B$6>=$B$15 Not Binding 300
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 25 $C$6<=$C$16 Not Binding 75
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 25 $C$6>=$C$15 Not Binding 25
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 $D$6<=$D$16 Not Binding 100
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 $D$6>=$D$15 Binding 0
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 $E$6<=$E$16 Binding 0
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 $E$6>=$E$15 Not Binding 500
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 294.3877551 $F$6<=$F$16 Not Binding 5.612244898
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 294.3877551 $F$6>=$F$15 Not Binding 294.3877551
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 484.69387755 $G$6<=$G$16 Not Binding 15.306122449
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 484.69387755 $G$6>=$G$15 Not Binding 984.69387755
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 50 $I$6<=$I$16 Binding 0
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 50 $I$6>=$I$15 Not Binding 100
NonNegative
Microsoft Excel 16.25 Sensitivity Report
Worksheet: [for wan.xlsx]3 nodes (50)
Report Created: 18/05/2019 11:32:59 PM

Variable Cells
Final Reduced Objective Allowable
Cell Name Value Cost Coefficient Increase
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1 300 -8 4 8
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2 25 0 12 88
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3 0 88 100 1E+030
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4 500 -6 1 6
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5 294.3877551 0 7 4.5294117647
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY484.69387755 0 0 4.62
$H$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-OTA 425 0 0 14.142857143
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 50 -7.0714285714 0 7.0714285714
$J$6 Variable values (MWh) FHLY-OTA 375 0 0 1E+030

Constraints
Final Shadow Constraint Allowable
Cell Name Value Price R.H. Side Increase
$K$10 Node HAY Sumproduct -5.684342E-14 7.2857142857 0 5.3921568627
$K$11 Node HLY Sumproduct 0 12 0 75
$K$12 Node OTA Sumproduct 800 9.6428571429 800 10.784313725
$K$13 Kirchoff's law Sumproduct 0 2.3571428571 0 150
$K$9 Node BEN Sumproduct 300 7 300 5.612244898
 Allowable
Decrease
1E+030
4.7142857143
88
1E+030
6
1E+030
1E+030
1E+030
14.142857143

Allowable
Decrease
282.84313725
25
50
10.784313725
294.3877551
3 nodes

GEN MER Line

Variables GEN 1 (X1) GEN 2 (X2) GEN 3 (X3) MER 1 (X4) MER 2(X5) FBEN-HAY FHAY-OTA
Price ($) 4 12 100 1 7
Variable values (MWh) 300 25 0 500 294.38776 484.69388 425

Node Balances
Node BEN 0 0 0 1 1 -1.02 0
Node HAY 0 0 0 0 0 0.98 -1
Node HLY 1 1 1 0 0 0 0
Node OTA 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
Kirchoff's law 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1

lower 0 0 0 0 0 -500
upper 300 100 100 500 300 500
Objective value (min.
cost) 4060.7143

1
Line
FHAY-HLY FHLY-OTA

50 375

Sumproduct Demand
0 0 300 300
-1 0 0 0
1 -1 0 0
0 1 800 800
1 1 0 0

-50
50
Microsoft Excel 16.25 Answer Report
Worksheet: [Electricity Assignment 3 nodes.xlsx]3 nodes (51)
Report Created: 20/05/2019 4:32:09 PM
Result: Solver found a solution. All constraints and optimality conditions are satisfied.
Solver Engine
Engine: Simplex LP
Solution Time: 55836931.223 Seconds.
Iterations: 11 Subproblems: 0
Solver Options
Max Time Unlimited, Iterations Unlimited, Precision 0.000001
Max Subproblems Unlimited, Max Integer Sols Unlimited, Integer Tolerance 100%, Assume NonNegative

Objective Cell (Min)

Cell Name Original Value Final Value
$B$17 Objective value (min. cost) GEN 1 (X14060.7142857 4035.2941176

Variable Cells
Cell Name Original Value Final Value Integer
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 300 Contin
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 25 19.607843137 Contin
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 0 Contin
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 500 Contin
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 294.3877551 300 Contin
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 484.69387755 490.19607843 Contin
$H$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-OTA 425 426.79738562 Contin
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 50 53.594771242 Contin
$J$6 Variable values (MWh) FHLY-OTA 375 373.20261438 Contin

Constraints
Cell Name Cell Value Formula Status Slack
$K$10 Node HAY Sumproduct -2.842171E-14 $K$10=$L$10 Binding 0
$K$11 Node HLY Sumproduct -1.136868E-13 $K$11=$L$11 Binding 0
$K$12 Node OTA Sumproduct 800 $K$12=$L$12 Binding 0
$K$13 Kirchoff's law Sumproduct 1.136868E-13 $K$13=$L$13 Binding 0
$K$9 Node BEN Sumproduct 300 $K$9=$L$9 Binding 0
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 $B$6<=$B$16 Binding 0
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1) 300 $B$6>=$B$15 Not Binding 300
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 19.607843137 $C$6<=$C$16 Not Binding 80.392156863
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2) 19.607843137 $C$6>=$C$15 Not Binding 19.607843137
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 $D$6<=$D$16 Not Binding 100
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3) 0 $D$6>=$D$15 Binding 0
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 $E$6<=$E$16 Binding 0
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4) 500 $E$6>=$E$15 Not Binding 500
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 300 $F$6<=$F$16 Binding 0
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5) 300 $F$6>=$F$15 Not Binding 300
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 490.19607843 $G$6<=$G$16 Not Binding 9.8039215686
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY 490.19607843 $G$6>=$G$15 Not Binding 990.19607843
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 53.594771242 $I$6<=$I$16 Not Binding 46.405228758
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 53.594771242 $I$6>=$I$15 Not Binding 153.59477124
NonNegative
Microsoft Excel 16.25 Sensitivity Report
Worksheet: [Electricity Assignment 3 nodes.xlsx]3 nodes (51)
Report Created: 20/05/2019 4:32:09 PM

Variable Cells
Final Reduced Objective Allowable
Cell Name Value Cost Coefficient Increase
$B$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 1 (X1 300 -8 4 8
$C$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 2 (X2 19.607843137 0 12 88
$D$6 Variable values (MWh) GEN 3 (X3 0 88 100 1E+030
$E$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 1 (X4 500 -10.529411765 1 10.529411765
$F$6 Variable values (MWh) MER 2(X5 300 -4.5294117647 7 4.5294117647
$G$6 Variable values (MWh) FBEN-HAY490.19607843 0 0 4.62
$H$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-OTA426.79738562 0 0 14.142857143
$I$6 Variable values (MWh) FHAY-HLY 53.594771242 0 0 7.0714285714
$J$6 Variable values (MWh) FHLY-OTA 373.20261438 0 0 1E+030

Constraints
Final Shadow Constraint Allowable
Cell Name Value Price R.H. Side Increase
$K$10 Node HAY Sumproduct -2.842171E-14 12 0 80.392156863
$K$11 Node HLY Sumproduct -1.136868E-13 12 0 80.392156863
$K$12 Node OTA Sumproduct 800 12 800 80.392156863
$K$13 Kirchoff's law Sumproduct 1.136868E-13 -8.881784E-16 0 139.21568627
$K$9 Node BEN Sumproduct 300 11.529411765 300 83.673469388
 Allowable
Decrease
1E+030
4.7142857143
88
1E+030
1E+030
1E+030
1E+030
1E+030
14.142857143

Allowable
Decrease
19.607843137
19.607843137
19.607843137
460.78431373
10
3 nodes

GEN MER Line

Variables GEN 1 (X1) GEN 2 (X2) GEN 3 (X3) MER 1 (X4) MER 2(X5) FBEN-HAY FHAY-OTA
Price ($) 4 12 100 1 7
Variable values (MWh) 300 19.607843 0 500 300 490.19608 426.797386

Node Balances
Node BEN 0 0 0 1 1 -1.02 0
Node HAY 0 0 0 0 0 0.98 -1
Node HLY 1 1 1 0 0 0 0
Node OTA 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
Kirchoff's law 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1

lower 0 0 0 0 0 -500
upper 300 100 100 500 300 500
Objective value (min.
cost) 4035.2941

1
Line
FHAY-HLY FHLY-OTA

53.594771 373.20261

Sumproduct Demand
0 0 300 300
-1 0 0 0
1 -1 0 0
0 1 800 800
1 1 0 0

-100
100