Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development of Ceramic Water Filter
Development of Ceramic Water Filter
Development of Ceramic Water Filter
Received: 9 August 2023, Accepted: 22 September 2023, Published: 29 September 2023, Publisher: UTP Press, Creative Commons: CC BY 4.0
1
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University of Uyo, Nigeria
2
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Cross River State, Calabar, Nigeria
*E-mail: mfon_obot@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
This research used the hand impress moulding method to prepare ceramic filter pots using 500 µm sieved clay, grog,
and melon shell in three ratios of 70:5:25, 75:5:20, and 80:5:15, respectively. The pot models were dimensioned to 50
mm height, 52 mm outer diameter, and 10 mm thickness and fired to 650°C, 700°C, and 750°C. The volume of effluent,
flow rate, and microbial removal efficiency were studied. From the results, filter pot 70:5:25 fired to 750°C recorded
an efficiency of 99.9% removal of heterogenic bacteria count, total fungi count, total coliform, and E.coli, and has the best
combination of flow rate and removal efficiency. This filter pot was seen to meet up with World Health Organization (WHO)
standards. Minitab analyses show a significant effect of material composition over fired temperature on the flow rate.
INTRODUCTION
Unclean water in the environment creates a health waste disposal and overburdened sanitation services.
challenge for everyone. A compromise in water quality A primary outcome of consuming polluted water
severely affects the maintenance of human health and contaminated by microorganisms is a high prevalence
other activities in the community. Thus, the microbial of gastrointestinal diseases, causing morbidity rates to
quality of water used for consumption, cooking, and peak in a nation [1]. A public health expert stated that
personal hygiene is of paramount importance [1]. The 60 million Nigerians lacking access to safe drinking
margin between untreated water bodies' proportions water are exposed to such waterborne diseases as
and potable water in developing countries like Nigeria is diarrhoea, cholera, dysentery, hepatitis A, and hepatitis
extensive. It is stated that 57% of rural Nigerians still lack B, with a high mortality rate amongst the young and
access to potable water [2]. The reasons are inadequate aged in the population [1]. Children under five years are
water management, limited infrastructure, and particularly vulnerable to death by cholera, especially
climate changes resulting in environmental flooding in rural communities of Nigeria, where access to
and water pollution. Akpabio [3] also reported that immediate treatment and spread control is severely
cities in Nigeria affected by rural-to-urban migration lacking [4].
are plighted by increased localities characterised by
poorly organised squatter shanties and overcrowded Ceramic water filtration is described as a process of
dwellings. These then bring about environmental issues purifying water through a porous ceramic structure [5].
such as pollution in the air and water from improper The technique behind it is that microorganisms and
disease pathogens bigger than water molecules are caught material proportion, researchers generally are consensual
in the nano and micro-pores in the ceramic structure, on a positive correlation between increased burn-out
allowing clean water to percolate through [6]-[8]. This material and the flow rate [5], [7],[14],[19],[22]-[23] up to
water treatment technology is simple and complete on its a certain extent at which further increase interferes with
own, free of chemical additives and added treatment to microbial removal efficiency [14],[19],[22]. However,
the water. Thus, it remains a promising way to reduce the little has been said concerning which parameters
burden of waterborne diseases domestically as a point-of- have the greater effect on the performance criteria of
use water treatment system. UNICEF highly recommended ceramic water filters.
and promoted ceramic filters as a household water
treatment and safe storage (HWTS) device. This is based Locally manufactured ceramic filters have traditionally
on established research on 99.9% microbial removal been used in third-world nations to treat household
efficiency under laboratory conditions [9]-[12]. Ceramic water for four decades now [17]. Their starting raw
filters can be designed into shapes of flower pots, discs, and materials, such as clay and burn-out materials, are
candles for functionality purposes [13]. Currently, the most usually ubiquitous and readily available locally, and
widely implemented ceramic filter is the Potters for Peace the production methods are tenable and affordable,
design [14]-[15], which is a flower pot design with average which allows for the skill of local ceramists and artisans
dimensions of 32 cm lip diameter, 23 cm base diameter, and working in correlation with research institutions. To this
22 cm height, and holds about 8-10 litres of water, and sits end, a lot of research has gone into the development
inside a plastic or ceramic receptacle [16]. and manufacture of filters in Nigeria as a precursor to
providing affordable alternatives to household water
An accepted method for developing ceramic filters is treatment [14],[18]-[19], [20],[22],[25]. The purpose
adding a sacrificial phase (burn-out material) to the of research into the viability of producing ceramic
pre-fired clay [17]. As the name implies, a burn-out is water filters in Nigeria is also fuelled by the fact that
any combustible material, typically biomass, which each clay origin lends its unique characteristics to
can be pulverised and processed by sieving to grains the filter's functionality [26]. In addition, the cost of
similar in size range to the clay [18]. Examples used in importation for foreign-made filters would make its
literature include sawdust and rice husk [14],[18]-[23]. purpose as affordable amenities impossible for low-
It is mixed with clay and water into a green ceramic income Nigerians. The ceramic water pot is a very
body and incinerated at elevated temperatures during common traditional household utensil in most villages,
the firing stage. This ensures an aggregate of left-behind especially in the south-south and south-eastern parts of
pore spaces suitable for contaminated water filtration [6]. the country. Leveraging on this socio-cultural appeal, it
Researchers manipulate the proportion of burn-out is expected that the introduction of ceramic pot filters
material to clay to improve upon the filter properties will gain traction in rural communities in Nigeria.
such as porosity and flow rate [5],[7],[14],[18]. Another
parameter that can influence filter properties is MATERIALS AND METHODS
the sintering temperature. Research studies have
postulated the effect of sintering temperature and The prong of this present research was to develop
burn-out material content on the performance of and test laboratory scale pot filters by flow rate and
ceramic filters [21]-[24]. Several researchers have varied removal efficiency using clay of Ikot Ebom Itam origin
the sintering temperature, selecting high firing ranges in Akwa Ibom State, south-eastern Nigeria, and melon
of 1000°C to 1200°C to optimise full sintering, which seed shell as burn-out material. The influent source
improves filter mechanical properties [22]. In contrast, was a community stream at Afaha Obio Eno with GPS
others have chosen lower firing ranges of 700°C to Latitude 5.08◦N and Longitude 7.87◦E in Ibiono Local
900°C to mitigate the effects of sintering on the ceramic Government Area (LGA), which rural indigenes collect
microstructure and improve filter flow rate properties without close access to treated water.
[5],[7],[21]. Among these, some researchers reported
a negative correlation between increased firing Clay, melon shells, and grog were the raw materials
temperature with porosity and flow rate, while others used to produce ceramic filters. Grog is a non-plastic
have presented contrary findings to show a positive material used to control shrinkage and the effects of
correlation [5],[7],[22],[24]. Regarding the burn-out thermal cracking. Melon shell is derived from seeds of
the melon plant (Citrullus colocynthis lanatus), known Processing of Clay and Melon Husk
locally as ikon in Ibibio and egusi in the Igbo dialect; it Melon seeds (Figure 4), harvested from farms in Uyo,
was used as a burn-out additive. Akwa Ibom State, were de-milled, and the empty
shells were collected into a stainless steel basin. The
Sample Collection from the Quarry melon shells (MSH) were then sun-dried for five days
The clay quarry is cited in Ikot Ebom Itam with GPS and blended to powder using a blending machine
Latitude 5.03◦N and Longitude 7.59◦E in Itu LGA of Akwa (Faberware model PC550). Clay and grog were crushed
Ibom State (Figure 1). Five hundred grams clay clumps of in a steel pan using a 5 kg cast iron hammer and dried
light grey to white colouration were carefully excavated in the sun for five days. The clay, grog, and melon shell
from multi-colour strata at a depth of 4.5 m and taken to powder were screened separately using a 500 µm sieve.
the laboratory for processing, depicted in Figures 2 and 3. Sieved clay, grog, and melon shell were mixed dry in
The clay soil comprises 69% quartz, 29% kaolin, and ratios of 70:25:5, 75:20:5, and 80:15:5, prepared for firing
2% rutile [27]. in batches as indicated in Table 1.
Figure 1 Map of Ikot Ebom clay sampling location in Itu LGA, Akwa Ibom State
Figure 2 Clay strata in situ with an arrow showing Figure 3 Clay clumps excavated and taken to the
sampled layer laboratory
Table 1 Batch formulation of clay, melon shell, and the fired temperature for weight percentage of grog at 5 wt%
Figure 6 Filters charged Figure 7 Produced filters Test for Microbial Removal Efficiency
into a muffle furnace Stream water percolated out of produced ceramic filter
pots was transferred by sterile 10 ml sample bottles
After shaping in POP mold, pot samples were extracted,
to the microbiology laboratory for analysis. Serial
and the inner surfaces were fettled with a spatula. After
dilution was carried out according to the method of
that, the cups were set out to dry for 72 hours in a well-
Cheesbrough [29]. 1 ml per sample was measured using
ventilated room. After room drying, they were placed in
a syringe and introduced into 9 ml of sterile distilled
an electric oven (Witec model WOF-105) set at 110°C and
water in a test tube. The test tube was shaken, and 1 ml
preheated for eight hours to eliminate moisture content
aliquot from the dilution was transferred aseptically
further. Next, the preheated pots were charged into a
over a lit flame burner into sterile Petri dishes. The
muffle furnace (Gallenkamp size 2), (Figure 6), and fired
Pour Plate method described by Prescot [30] was used
to temperatures 650°C, 700°C, and 750°C at 10°C per
for microbial analysis of both source and filtered water
minute heating and cooling rate and kept at four hours
samples. The Total Heterotrophic Bacterial Count (THBC),
soak time in between temperatures, and cooled to room
Fungal Count (TFC), Coliform Count (TCC), and Fecal
temperature, temperature (Figure 7).
Coliform Count (FCC) were determined using Nutrient
Agar (NA), Sabouraud Dextrose Agar (SDA), Maclonkey
Measurement of Water Filtration
Agar (MCA) and Eosine Methylene Blue Agar (EMBA) as
Four litres of stream water from Afaha Obio Eno in Ibiono
analytical media respectively. Incubation of bacterial
Ibom LGA, Akwa Ibom State, was collected for water
cultural plates was carried out for a duration of 24
filtration and quality testing. Polyethylene terephthalate
hours at 25°C, and the fungal plates were incubated
(PET) 160 ml cups served as a percolate reservoir, and
at 28°C ± 2°C for 5-7 days in a Gallenkamp incubator
50 ml syringes were used to extract and measure out
(model DV-160) for growth to occur. Microbial colonies
filtrated water at intervals. Fired ceramic pots were
that emerged on the incubated plates after incubation
soaked in distilled water for 12 hours (overnight) to
were enumerated with a colony counter and recorded
eliminate air pockets in the structure. The ceramic pot
as Colony Forming Units (CFU) per 100 millilitres of
was placed upright inside the PET cup, ensuring that
water samples.
the inner rim rests over the outer rim of the cup. Stream
water was carefully filled into the pot to the brim, and a
Microbial removal efficiency was calculated in terms of
stopwatch was used to record the duration of filtering.
percentage of removal efficiency:
The time and volume of filtrated water were recorded
on a filter log. The setup was aseptically contained in a % Removal (Cinfluent _ Ceffluent)
= ×100% [31] (3)
5-litre parent bucket with a cover (Figure 8). efficiency Cinfluent
where,
Porosity Test
Preliminary test results on porosity values of MSH Figure 9c MSH15 apparent porosity
premixed Ikot Ebom Itam ceramic samples indicate
70
a linear relationship between firing temperature 60
and porosity values, Figures 9a, 9b, and 9c. There 50
was decreasing porosity in the samples as the firing 40 ◦C
temperature increased from 650 to 1000°C. This report 30 ◦C
◦C
is consistent with the sintering behaviour of clays [32], 20
◦C
Figure 9a MSH25 apparent porosity
◦C
◦C
the firing of ceramic bodies to higher temperatures, premixed with 15 weight percentage of melon shell.
there is consolidation and densification of grains in the Among the fastest pots, MSH25-650, 25-700, and 25-
structure, which leads to a resultant reduction in pore 750, only MSH25-750 filtered effluent show no detected
spaces within the filters [30]. microbial load per 100 ml, which meets the standard
for clean water [36].
Effects of increased composition of melon shell
burn-out premix from 15 to 25 of weight percentage,
improve filtration rate and filtered volume of the
effluent, shown from the plots in Figures 14 and 15.
The produced ceramic pot at 650°C with 25% melon
shell filtered 38 ml of filtered water in an hour,
compared to 31 ml and 14 ml volume of filtered water
from pots premixed with 20% and 15% melon shell,
respectively. This correlation agrees with previous
research on the pertinent role burn-out biomass
plays in the production of ceramic filters by increasing
the filtration volume of water as weight percentage Figure 13 Removal efficiency for each composition
of the filter
content is increased [5],[21]-[22].
Table 2 Water quality test results using Ikot Ebom filter
Grade
Temperature THBC TFC TCC E-Coli
Clay:MSH:
(°C) (%) (%) (%) (%)
Grog
70:25:5 650 99.9 99.9 95.0 95.0
Figure 12 Effluent volume against temperature and 75:20:5 650 99.9 99.9 98.0 99.17
duration for each composition of the filter
700 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.1
However, it was observed that over time, there was a 750 99.9 99.9 99.0 99.9
reduction in the filtration rate of produced filter pots,
80:15:5 650 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9
with a 70% reduction in filtration rate for MSH25-650,
the fastest filter over a spread of 5 hours, Figure 12. 700 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9
This undesirable effect is deduced to be caused by the 750 - - - -
clogging of the pore spaces by the bacterial load in the
source water. Van Halem [11], Latagne [34], Fahlin [35]
Comparison of Effects
and postulated the theory that the flow rate reduces
The effects of sintered temperature and the composition
considerably in ceramic filters due to clogging, and
of the burn-out material have both been seen to impact
clogging is dependent on the quality of the influent
the filter properties and performance. Higher sintering
water. Meanwhile, the volume of percolate shows a
temperatures up to 750°C have diminished the flow
steady rise per time for all tested filters, Figure 12, with
performance of the produced ceramic filter mixed
MSH25-650 turnout increasing from 38 ml in one hour
with the least content of burn-out. However, increasing
to 53 ml after five hours.
the burn-out ratio from 15 to 25 weight percentage
has greatly increased the filter's performance, even
The quality of water filtration results, Figure 13 and
at higher sintered temperatures. The results for flow
Table 2 show a distinctive improvement in the levels
rate as a function of temperature and composition
of E. Coli, total coliform, heterotrophic bacterial and
were fed into Minitab 19 software and a Pareto Chart
fungal count between the effluent and influent at filters
was generated. From the result, it is shown that
fired in between 650°C to the 750°C firing range and
out of the two compared parameters, the burn-out material composition is more significant than the fired
material composition has a greater effect on the filter temperature.
performance than the fired temperature at a 0.05 level
of significance, Figure 14. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
REFERENCES
zone, southern Ethiopia," Environmental System Res, vol.8, [Online]. Available: http://www.pottersforpeace.
no. 1, 2019, doi: 10.1186/s40068-018-0129-6 org/?page_id=63. Accessed: Oct 12, 2022).
[8] A. C. Elmore, W.G. Fahrenholtz, L. G. Glauber, and A. N. [18] V. E. Efeovbokhan, O. O. Olurotimi, E. O. Yusuf, O. G.
Sperber, "Calculation of ceramic pot filter hydraulic Abatan and E. E. Alagbe, "Production of Clay Filters
conductivity using falling-head data," Water Science & for Waste Water Treatment," Journal of Physics:
Technology: Water Supply, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 358-363, Conference Series, p. 1378, 2019, doi:10.1088/1742-
2011. 6596/1378/3/032028
[9] WHO/UNICEF, "A toolkit for monitoring and evaluating [19] C. C. Nnaji, B. C. Afangideh, and C. Ezeh, "Performance
household water treatment and safe storage evaluation of clay-sawdust composite filter for point of
programmes," World Health Organization, Geneva, use water treatment," Nigerian Journal of Technology,
Switzerland, 2012. vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 949 – 956, 2016.
[10] UNICEF, "Improving Household Drinking Water Quality: [20] A. S. Adeleke, K. T. Oladipo and J. O. Jeje, "A Study of
Use of Ceramic Water Filters in Cambodia," Water and Ceramic Pot Filters Made From Clay Body and Sawdust,"
sanitation program, 2008. [Online]. Available: https:// Journal of Resources Development and Management,
www.unicef.org/eapro/WSP_UNICEF_FN_CWP_Final. vol. 45, pp. 1-9, 2018.
pdf. Accessed: Oct 24, 2018).
[21] T. Dung, V. Nam, T. Nhan, B. Hoang, D. Hung,
[11] D. Van Halem, "Ceramic silver impregnated pot filters and D. Viet Quang, "Utilisation of Rice Husk, an
for household drinking water treatment in developing Abundant and Inexpensive Biomass in Porous Ceramic
countries," MSc Thesis, Delft University of Technology, Membrane Preparation: A Crucial Role of Firing
the Netherlands, p. 139, 2006. Temperature," Journal of Nanomaterials, pp 1-7, 2021,
doi:10.1155/2021/8688238.
[12] M. D. Sobsey, "Managing Water in the Home: Accelerated
Health Gains from Improved Water Supply", Department [22] O. A. Omoniyi, A. A. Salifu, J. D. Obayemi, O. K.
of Protection of the Human Environment. WHO, Geneva. Oyewole, P. Nigay, O. Akin-Ojo and W. O. Soboyejo,
p. 69, 2002. "Effects of sintering temperature on the filtration
and mechanical properties of ceramic water filters,"
[13] H. Yang, S. Xu, D. E. Chitwood and Y. Wang, "Ceramic Water Cogent Engineering, vol. 9, no. 1, 2022. p. 2119536, doi:
Filter for point-of-use water treatment in developing 10.1080/23311916.2022.2119536
countries: Principles, challenges and opportunities."
Front. Environmental Science Engineering vol. 14, no. 5, [23] S. M. Bader, M. M. Shukur and M. A. Aswad., "Preparation
p. 79, 2020, doi: 10.1007/s11783-020-1254-9 Ceramic Filter Using Rice husk and Yeast as Pores
forming agents." Advances in Natural and Applied
[14] S. I. Akosile, F.O. Ajibade, K. H. Lasisi, T. F. Ajibade, J. Sciences. vol. 11, no. 11, pp. 71- 76, 2017
R. Adewumi, J. O. Babatola and A. M. Oguntuase,
"Performance evaluation of locally produced ceramic [24] A. I. A. Soppe, S. G. J. Heijman, I. Gensburger, A. Shantz,
filters for household water treatment in Nigeria," Scientific D. V. Halem, J. Kroesbergen, G. H. Wubbels and P.W.M.H.
African, vol. 7,2020, doi: 10.1016/j.sciaf.2019.e00218 Smeets, "Critical parameters in the production of
ceramic pot filters for household water treatment in
[15] CDC "Household Water Treatment Options in developing countries." Journal of Water and Health, vol.
Developing Countries: Ceramic Filtration," 2008. 13, no.2, pp. 587-599, 2015.
[On;ine]. Available: https://www.cdc.gov/safewater/
publications_pages/options-ceramic.pdf [25] M. Saheed, T. J. Oladejo, N. M. Muhammed, A. A.
Saka, A. A. Oluwabunmi, M. Abdulkabir and O. O.
[16] M. Klarman, "Investigation of Ceramic Pot Filter Design Joel. "Fabrication of Porous Ceramic Pot Filters
Variables," MPublic Health Thesis, Rollins School of for Adsorptive Removal of Pollutants in Tannery
Public Health, Emory University. Atlanta, Georgia. pp. Wastewater," Scientific African, 2021, doi: 10.1016/j.
89, 2009. sciaf.2021.e00705