MD/MS/DM/MCh/THESIS/EVALUATION CONFIDENTIAL

ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES BHOPAL MP, INDIA

MD/MS/DM/MCh THESIS EVALUATION REPORT

Name of Candidate :

Department :

Title of Thesis :

Name of Examiner :

Telephone No.
: Email:
(Mobile/Office)

All examiners are required to complete this form as follows:

1. SECTION A: Provide detailed comments on the quality of the thesis, particularly on the
strengths and/or weaknesses of the work.

2. SECTION B: Indicate your recommendation from the list of permitted recommendations.

3. Please return the documents together with your comments on thesis within the stipulated
time to the following Email: dean.exam@aiimsbhopal.edu.in

(Prof.) Dr. Bhavana Sharma

Dean Examination
AIIMS BHOPAL
462020 MP, INDIA

1
MD/MS/DM/MCh/THESIS/EVALUATION CONFIDENTIAL

SECTION A

ROBUSTNESS OF THESIS

1. Suitability of the title:

Comments:

Suggestions for improvement (if any):

2. Research objectives:
Consideration should be given to suitability and achievement of research objectives proposed.

Comments:

Suggestions for improvement (if any):

3. Literature review:
Comment on the literature review.

Comments:

Suggestions for improvement (if any):

4. Research methodology:
Consideration should be given to the technique of research adopted and the extent of work involved
in terms of laboratory and/or field work, interviews, library research and so forth and the evidence of
the amount of data collected. Consideration should also be given to the difficult nature of a subject,
the availability, the accessibility of relevant information and statistical data in the assessment.

Comments:

Suggestions for improvement (if any):

5. Analysis of research:
The candidate s originality of contribution to the research is devoted to analysis and the conclusions
drawn from the research work. Comments should be given to candidate s ability to apply appropriate
principles and practices to the research problem. Considerations should be given to candidate s
ability to analyse the data collected and his/her ability to write a critically coherent and descriptive
thesis from data and materials collected.

Comments:

Suggestions for improvement (if any):

2
 MD/MS/DM/MCh/THESIS/EVALUATION CONFIDENTIAL

6. Significance of finding(s):
Consideration should be given to the extent to which the objectives of research have been achieved.

Comments:

Suggestions for improvement (if any) :

7. References:
Consideration should be given to up-to-date professionally legitimate and peer reviewed sources and
the format of references according to Vancouver format.

Comments:

8. Contribution to existing knowledge:

9. Suggestions for improvement (if any):

OVERALL STYLE AND ORGANIZATION

10. Presentation:

Style, organization and format of the thesis including the presentation of chapters, references,
tables, diagrams, charts, footnotes, appendices and the thesis clarity of presentation.

Comments:

Suggestions for improvement (if any):

11. Mechanist aspect (grammar, spelling, numbering, punctuation):

Comments:

Suggestions for improvement (if any):

12. Other comments, if any:

(A Sheet may be attached)

3
 MD/MS/DM/MCh/THESIS/EVALUATION CONFIDENTIAL
SECTION B

RECOMMENDATION

Indicate your recommendation by placing ( √ ) in the appropriate box:

1. After examining the above mentioned thesis, I hereby recommend as follows:

S. Recommendation Please tick ( √ )

No
(1) I recommend that the thesis be accepted in its present form.

(2) I recommend that the candidate modifies the thesis as per my

suggestions and modified thesis should be sent to me for revaluation.
(3) I do not recommend acceptance of this thesis for the reasons set out in
detail in my report.

Official Stamp and Signature

Date:
Place: