Druga gimnazija Sarajevo

International Baccalaureate Middle Years Programme

[Subject]

TASK

Critique

Word count: 490

Student: Teacher:

Lejla Redžović Aida

Sejdić-Melezović
"Fly Me to the Moon" is a timeless classic that has been played many times over the

years. This critique is on the topic of the performances of two celebrated artists,

Michael Bublé and Frank Sinatra, and examines their interpretation, technical

excellence, cultural significance and artistic value of the work.

Frank Sinatra's rendition of "Fly Me to the Moon" is one of the key versions of the

song. Sinatra's soft voice glides effortlessly through the song. Its rich tones and

subtle dynamics add depth and emotional touch to the lyrics. Sinatra's performance

is a testament to his exceptional vocal technique. His breath control allows him to

seamlessly continue long lyrics, creating an intimate connection with his audience.

In addition, Sinatra's ability to effortlessly control a song's melody in his own unique

way demonstrates his mastery as an artist. Overall, Sinatra is able to give the song a

suave and romantic aura.

Culturally and historically, Sinatra's performance of "Fly Me to the Moon" occupies a

prominent place in the Great American Songbook. It represents an era of elegance,

sophistication and timeless romance. He set the standard for interpreting popular

songs with depth and authenticity.

Michael Bublé gives "Fly Me to the Moon" a modern feel with his own interpretation.

Bublé's warm and charismatic voice is very charming and gives the songs their own

personality. He combines elements of swing and contemporary pop, injecting

modern elements into classic songs. Bublé's technical prowess is evident in his

ability to effortlessly move through different vocal ranges. His performance has a

playful energy, while Sinatra's is more serious.

In terms of cultural and historical context, Bublé's performance pays homage to

Sinatra's legacy while adding his own touches to make the song accessible to a new

generation of listeners. Bublé's success has helped revive interest in classical

standards and remain relevant to contemporary music.

Sinatra's interpretation of "Fly Me to the Moon" is characterized by elegance,

emotional depth and technical precision. His rich, expressive voice and phrasing

create an intimate connection with the listener. It is a smooth and romantic

rendition of such a timeless song. However, some have argued that Sinatra's

interpretation closely follows the original arrangement, leaving less room for
personal interpretation. Bublé's interpretation, on the other hand, offers a new and

contemporary interpretation of the song. His charismatic and versatile voice,

combined with his playful interpretations, appeals to a wide audience. However,

some traditionalists felt that Bublé's version strayed far from the original character

of the song, missing some of its nostalgic aesthetic.

Both Michael Bublé and Frank Sinatra performed "Fly Me to the Moon" beautifully,

showing their own strengths and unique approaches. Sinatra's playing embodies

the timeless grace and emotional depth of the classic, while Bublé's playing lends the

song a contemporary appeal. Ultimately, the quality and artistry of their

performances come to the ears of the beholder, and they present a beloved musical

gem in two different yet equally mesmerizing renditions.