Critical Review

By: [name] [nim]

Introduction
[Briefly explain what is the main topic of this critical review. For example, your team would
like to review 3 journals about HCM, specifically the topic of leadership. Provide a definition
of the chosen topic and what is the goal of writing a critical review. Write in paragraphs for
the whole document and for answering all questions. Those marked blue are only for
pointers/guidance. One paragraph is at least 3 sentences. Use proper APA 7 th style citation and
referencing format.]
Article 1: [Title]
a. Research background and phenomena
b. Research urgency
c. Research purpose
d. Variables & Hypothesis
e. Research method
f. Research result

Article 2: [Title]
a. Research background and phenomena
b. Research urgency
c. Research purpose
d. Variables & Hypothesis
e. Research method
f. Research result

Article 3: [Title]
a. Research background and phenomena
b. Research urgency
c. Research purpose
d. Variables & Hypothesis
e. Research method
f. Research result

Comparison
[Compare & contrast each journal’s research design]
a. What aspects / components are similar?
b. What aspects / components are different?
c. Common research result?
d. What different findings are found?
Conclusion
[Write one paragraph of the critical review conclusion explaining the major findings /
takeaway among the 3 journal articles reviewed].
References
[Use APA 7th style referencing.
https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/references/examples/journal-article-
references ]