Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Epidemiology and Neurobiology of Female Sexual Dysfunction
Epidemiology and Neurobiology of Female Sexual Dysfunction
ORIGINAL ARTICLES
Anita H. Clayton, MD
Department of Psychiatry & Neurobehavioral Sciences, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, USA
DOI: 10.1111/j.1743-6109.2007.00609.x
ABSTRACT
Introduction. Although several conceptual frameworks for female sexual dysfunction (FSD) have been advanced,
there still is considerable disagreement over what constitutes a normal vs. abnormal response. Sexual dysfunction is
a disturbance in sexual functioning involving one or multiple phases of the sexual response cycle or pain associated
with sexual activity, while a sexual disorder includes both dysfunction and marked distress.
Aim. Review the literature regarding the epidemiology and neurobiology of FSD.
Methods. Review of the literature.
Results. While a wide range of epidemiologic studies has been published, it is still difficult to determine the scope
of FSD and sexual disorders in the general population. It is becoming clear that good sexual health is associated with
good physical and mental health as well as compatible relationships with one’s sexual partner. Central nervous system
(CNS) control of the sexual response is a relatively new area of scientific exploration.
Conclusions. We are improving our understanding of the contributions of the CNS neuroendocrine and neurotrans-
mitter systems that modulate sexual behavior. Clayton AH. Epidemiology and neurobiology of female sexual
dysfunction. J Sex Med 2007;4(suppl 4):260–268.
Key Words. Female Sexual Dysfunction; Epidemiology; Neurobiology
J Sex Med 2007;4(suppl 4):260–268 © 2007 International Society for Sexual Medicine
Epidemiology and Neurobiology of FSD 261
The American Psychiatric Association’s defini- populations. Unfortunately, many of these studies
tions for FSD and Hypoactive Sexual Desire use nonstandard or discarded definitions of sexual
Disorder (HSDD) focus on persistent or recurrent dysfunction, and results across studies have not
deficiencies or absence of sexual fantasies and been consistently reproducible. Even among
desire for sexual activity [6]. The disturbance must major surveys with solid methodology, contradic-
cause a marked distress or interpersonal difficulty, tory findings appear across demographic variables
and cannot be better accounted for by another such as race, education, and socioeconomic status.
primary psychiatric disorder, substance abuse, or a In the United States, the 1999 National Health
general medical condition. The American Foun- and Social Life Survey of 1,749 women aged 18 to
dation of Urological Disease 2000 update on FSD 59 years provided one of the first clear glimpses at
included definitions for desire/interest disorder, the scope of the problem of sexual dysfunction [9].
subjective sexual arousal disorder, genital arousal In this survey, 43% of women claimed a sexual
disorder, and combined disorders [7]. These dysfunction, compared with 31% of men. Interest-
include the following definitions, all of which ingly, women of different racial groups had dif-
depend on either persistence or recurrence of fering patterns of sexual dysfunction, with black
symptoms in order to establish a diagnosis: women complaining of low sexual desire and
reporting less pleasure than white women, who
• Hypoactive Sexual Desire Disorder (HSDD):
reported higher rates of sexual pain. Hispanic
Deficiency (or absence) of sexual fantasies/
women in this survey reported fewer sexual prob-
thoughts, and/or desire for or receptivity to
lems overall than either black or white respondents.
sexual activity, which causes personal distress.
Another finding of the National Health and
• Sexual Aversion Disorder: Phobic aversion to
Social Life Survey was that women with higher
and avoidance of sexual contact with a sexual
educational attainment were less likely overall to
partner, which causes personal distress.
complain of sexual dysfunction than those with less
• Sexual Arousal Disorder: Inability to attain or
education. Among women, this difference was
maintain sufficient sexual excitement, causing
especially pronounced between women with less
personal distress, which may be expressed as a
than a high school education compared to women
lack of subjective excitement, or genital (lubri-
with a college degree.
cation/swelling) or other somatic responses.
These U.S. results correspond to those
• Orgasmic Disorder: Difficulty, delay in, or
reported from a British community survey of
absence of attaining orgasm following sufficient
sexual functioning among 436 women aged 35–59
sexual stimulation and arousal, which causes
who had sexual partners [10]. One-third of these
personal distress.
women had operationally defined sexual dysfunc-
• Sexual Pain Disorders: Dyspareunia is defined as
tion, including reduced sexual interest, vaginal
genital pain associated with sexual intercourse.
dryness, infrequency of orgasm, and dyspareunia.
Vaginismus is currently defined as the involun-
The risk of sexual dysfunction increased with age,
tary spasm of the musculature of the outer third
but was unrelated to socioeconomic class. In this
of the vagina that interferes with vaginal pen-
survey, there was no link between sexual dysfunc-
etration, which causes personal distress. Nonco-
tion and gynecologic conditions, except that
ital sexual pain disorder is defined as genital pain
women with sexual dysfunction were more likely
induced by noncoital sexual stimulation.
to report an episode of stress incontinence at least
Although there are strong psychological and once a week. There was no association between
physical components to the definitions of various sexual dysfunction and menopause in this sample.
disorders, it should be noted that neither exits in a Sexual dysfunction is widely recognized as
vacuum. In one study of college students, individu- increasing with age. In the Reproductive Risk
als with lower levels of sexual desire showed Factors for Incontinence Study at Kaiser (RRISK),
reduced physiologic responses to appetitive 2,109 women aged 40–69 years were randomly
sexual stimuli as well as a higher startle response selected from a database of long-term Kaiser
threshold [8]. Permanente members [11]. Data were collected by
self-reported questionnaires and in-person inter-
views. The mean age of the study population was
Epidemiology of FSD
55.9 (⫾8) years and nearly three-fourths of the
The literature is now replete with studies that women were sexually active. The population was
attempt to quantify the extent of FSD within given also racially diverse, with less than half of the
participants identifying themselves as white (48%), Women’s International Study of Health and Sexu-
with approximately equal distribution of the ality (WISHeS) divided women into two age
remainder describing themselves as black (18%), groups [13]. The younger group—aged 20 to 49
Hispanic (17%), or Asian (16%). years—was stratified by whether they were pre-
Among this population of women who menopausal or were surgically menopausal. The
described themselves as generally healthy, 33% older group—aged 50 to 70 years—was stratified
reported a problem in one or more domains by whether they arrived at menopause naturally or
associated with sexual dysfunction. Satisfaction through surgery. Mail surveys were distributed
with sexual activity was associated with African- that included validated instruments of quality of
American race, lower body mass index (BMI), life and/or sexual function and distress.
and higher mental health score (all P < 0.05). In the WISHeS report, the prevalence of
More sexual dysfunction was associated with HSDD ranged from 9% in naturally postmeno-
having a college degree or greater, poor health, pausal women to 26% in younger surgically post-
being in a significant relationship, and a low menopausal women. The prevalence of HSDD
mental health score (all P < 0.05). Some of these was significantly greater among surgically post-
results are in conflict with the earlier National menopausal women, aged 20 to 49 years, than pre-
Health and Social Life Survey, particularly the menopausal women of similar age (Table 2).
relationship between education level and sexual HSDD was associated with emotional and psycho-
dysfunction. In this survey, higher educational logical distress as well as significantly lower sexual
levels were associated both with increased sexual and partner satisfaction. HSDD was also associ-
activity and increased risk of sexual dysfunction. ated with significant decrements in general health
Few epidemiological surveys have estimated the status, including aspects of mental and physical
rates of sexual disorders in the general population health.
secondary to the need to assess both sexual dys- Sexual dysfunction is also commonly seen in
function and associated distress. Recently, the non-Western countries. In a survey of Moroccan
Prevalence and Correlates of Female Sexual Dis- women over the age of 20, almost 30% reported a
orders and Determinants of Treatment Seeking sexual dysfunction, and 18.3% fit the definition of
(PRESIDE) study was undertaken in 2006 by HSDD [14]. Similar surveys from other countries
mailing surveys to 50,000 U.S. women [12]. The have come to the same conclusion—that up to
survey population was a representative sample of one-third of adult women suffer from a sexual dys-
U.S. women based on a variety of demographic function, and that the risk for sexual disorders
variables, including age, race, geographic location, increases with age and diminished estrogen status.
household size, household income, and marital The distribution of specific sexual disorders
status. Response rate was high, with 31,581 returns. within populations reporting sexual dysfunction
The results were tabulated to establish specific was analyzed in an analysis of 11 epidemiologic
sexual disorders, with rates ranging from 9.5% for studies representing more than 25,000 subjects
HSDD to 4.6% for Orgasm Disorder (Table 1). [15]. The authors found that among women
Estrogen status may also be correlated with reporting sexual difficulties, 64% reported desire
a diagnosis of HSDD. U.S. results from the difficulties, 31% experienced arousal difficulty, and
35% reported orgasm difficulty (Figure 1). Among
Table 1 Prevalence of sexual disorders from the women reporting sexual dysfunction, about one-
PRESIDE survey of 31,581 women, randomized to be a third noted that the duration of the difficulty was
demographically representative sample of U.S. women [12] at least 6 months.
Hypoactive Arousal Orgasm Sexual dysfunction is not commonly associated
desire disorder* disorder* disorder* with treatment-seeking behavior among women.
Prevalence 10.0 5.4 4.7 This is compounded by the fact that clinicians
PRESIDE [%] (9.6–10.3) (5.1–5.7) (4.4–4.9) rarely inquire about the sexual health of their
(95%–CI)
patients. In the U.S. National Health and Social
Age-adjusted 9.5 5.1 4.6
prevalence for
Life Survey, 20% of women who reported a sexual
U.S. dysfunction stated that they had sought medical
population [%] attention for that problem [9]. In the British com-
*Definitions based on the respective domains/items of the female version of munity survey, only 4% of women reporting
the Changes in Sexual Functioning Questionnaire for presence of respective
sexual dysfunction, and the Female Sexual Distress Scale for dysfunction
sexual difficulties stated that they would like to
causing distress. receive help for their condition [10]. Among the
P value*
0.351
0.125
0.067
Table 2 Proportions of women classified as having low sexual desire and Hypoactive Sexual Desire Disorder by age and postmenopausal status in the Women’s
Surgically postmenopausal
62/197 (33)
27/197 (14)
27/62 (44)
(n = 197)
n/N (%)
71/252 (29)
23/71 (33)
23/252 (9)
care.
Surgically menopausal
56/414 (14)
56/96 (59)
[19].
n/N (%)
dysfunction (27% vs. 15%, respectively) in this Major depressive disorder has long been associ-
case-control survey [20]. One hundred twenty ated with a reduced interest in sex [6,23]. This is
women attending a diabetes clinic were matched most likely due to the general anhedonia associated
with 180 healthy women attending an outpatient with depression. Up to 80% of patients report
gynecology clinic. However, no association was reduced libido as a symptom of their depression.
found between sexual dysfunction and age, BMI, However, depressed patients do not generally ap-
duration of diabetes, HbA1c, use of medication, pear to be distressed by their lack of interest in
menopausal status, or complications of diabetes. sex.
Women with more diabetes complications, It is also common knowledge that certain drugs
however, reported significantly more sexual dys- used for the treatment of depression can be associ-
functions. Both diabetic women and controls ated with sexual dysfunction [24]. In a cross-
reporting sexual dysfunction described a lower sectional observational study conducted in more
overall quality of their marital relationship and than 1,100 primary care clinics in the United States,
more depressive symptoms than their respective more than 6,200 adult patients receiving antide-
counterparts without sexual problems. pressant monotherapy were surveyed for the pres-
Also in diabetic women, sexual function and ence of sexual dysfunction. Clinicians enrolled
sexual distress vary according to the phase of the their first five consecutive patients appearing in
menstrual cycle, with decreased sexual function their practice for any reason to avoid selection bias;
and increased sexual distress compared with the study did not attempt to balance the patients on
control subjects during the luteal, but not the the basis of antidepressant therapy; however, the
follicular, phase of the menstrual cycle [21]. Fifty enrolled population did not differ from national
premenopausal women with diabetes were com- prescribing practices. In this population, the overall
pared with 47 healthy controls via semistructured prevalence of sexual dysfunction was 37%. Effects
medical interviews and self-administered ques- are medication-specific, with the selective seroto-
tionnaires on sexual function, depression, and nin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and venlafaxine SR
sexual distress. Blood samples were also drawn to having greater negative effects on sexual function-
measure indicators of diabetes, as well as to obtain ing than agents such as bupropion. These results
an endocrine profile during the subjects’ follicular were consistent across both the entire study popu-
or luteal phase of their menstrual cycle. lation as well as within a subgroup of patients whose
The authors found that during the follicular sexual dysfunction could not be attributed to causes
phase, women with diabetes had lower hormone other than their antidepressant regimen. This
levels including estrogenic basal tone, delta4- report also found that the participating primary
androstenedione and dihydroepandrosterone care clinicians consistently underestimated the
sulfate production, and free-triiodothyronine (T3) prevalence of sexual dysfunction in their patients
and free-thyroxine (T4) levels compared with taking antidepressants. Prior to receiving the
control subjects. During the luteal phase, total tes- results of this study, physicians estimated that 20%
tosterone levels were higher in patients with dia- of their patients taking antidepressants would dem-
betes than control subjects, while 17beta-estradiol onstrate a sexual dysfunction; the reported percent-
and progesterone levels were lower in patients age was almost twice that.
with diabetes than in the controls. These findings Drug-induced sexual dysfunction is also
may have implications related to the clinical attributed to a variety of agents used to treat
assessment of sexual function in premenopausal hypertension, schizophrenia, and certain cancers,
women with diabetes. particularly treatments for hormone-sensitive
Overactive bladder (OAB) is another common tumors [25]. The mechanism of action behind
condition that is associated with a high risk of iatrogenic sexual dysfunction varies by drug class.
sexual dysfunction. In one study, 52% of women Antihypertensive agents are proposed to cause
involved in an open-label clinical trial of a therapy central adrenergic inhibition and block adrenergic
for OAB reported reduced interest in sex at study receptors, among other effects. Antipsychotics are
entry [22]. Patients in this study received a trans- dopamine blockers, have anticholinergic effects,
dermal formulation of oxybutinin for their OAB, may increase prolactin levels, and produce sedative
reporting increased interest in sex, improvement effects. The impact of oral contraceptives on sexual
in their sex lives, and improvements in their rela- functioning is controversial, although the prepon-
tionship with their partner. (P < 0.0001 from base- derance of the evidence suggests that only a minor-
line for all comparisons) at study end point. ity of women will experience negative effects [26].
preoptic area, and dopamine may activate addi- Assessment of Patients with FSD
tional CNS steroid receptors. Estrogen, however, Our understanding of the biological and neurobio-
appears to play only an indirect role in the sexual logical correlates of sexual response is improving.
response cycle [31]. Identifying and assessing women with sexual com-
Other hormones also are involved in CNS plaints is still a relatively labor-intensive process.
modulation of sexual behavior. These include oxy- However, that does not mean that patients with
tocin, which may enhance sexual receptivity sexual dysfunctions must necessarily undergo
and is associated with perineal contractions and extensive physical examinations in order to be
increased systolic blood pressure at the time of properly diagnosed and treated. A physical exami-
orgasm [32,33]. On the down-regulation side, the nation may not be required, or helpful in reaching
pituitary hormone prolactin negatively influences a diagnosis of HSDD, for example, where no
the sexual excitement phase, and is inversely physical abnormalities account for the lack of
related to dopamine function [31]. sexual desire. However, physical exams are useful
In the periphery, sex hormones are important in ruling out other, treatable causes of sexual dys-
mediators of genital structure and function [29,34]. function and may also be appropriate as part of
They also influence stasis with one another; for good general medical care.
example, increased levels of estrogen result in rising Diagnosis of female sexual disorders ideally
levels of sex hormone-binding globulin, which then begins with a biopsychosocial assessment, where
leads to the reduction of free testosterone. Nitric two partners are interviewed together and then
oxide (NO) and vasoactive intestinal peptide are individually [2]. The assessment should investigate
implicated in engorgement of clitoral tissue follow- any predisposing factors, such as past sexual
ing sexual stimulation; however, adequate levels of trauma; current precipitating or perpetuating
estrogen and free testosterone are needed in order factors, including interpersonal relationships; and
for NO to stimulate vasocongestion. Peripheral any past or present medical/surgical conditions,
serotonin has negative effects on vasocongestion, including pharmacologic treatments, which might
NO function, and sensation. affect sexual functioning.
Melanocortins are a newly described group of Physical examination should be conducted in
small protein hormones that appear to have both women who complain of dyspareunia, or who have
CNS and peripheral effects on sexual function a history of pelvic trauma or other medical or
[35]. Five melanocortin receptors have been iden- psychiatric conditions. Differential diagnosis of
tified, associated with complex pathways related to dyspareunia requires an evaluation of both the
skin pigmentation, weight, and sexual response. location of pain as well as factors that may suggest
Melanocortin signaling activates adenylate cyclase, a confounding issue (e.g., pain only with a specific
leading to increased levels of cyclic adenosine partner, etc.) [40]. In women with suspected
monophosphate, which is responsible for driving HSDD, differential diagnosis may suggest exami-
various physiologic functions. Each of the five nations of genital neurologic status and vaginal
melanocortin receptors has a different binding structure and muscle tone in order to rule out
affinity for the various melanocortin peptides. The other treatable conditions [41].
melanocortin-4 receptor (MC4R), implicated in
the control of food intake and energy expenditure,
Conclusions
also modulates erectile function and sexual behav-
ior [36]. In animal and human models, MC4R Female sexual dysfunction is common, but, unfor-
agonists are directly erectogenic, and also provoke tunately, is not currently a focus of general medical
an increase in sexual behaviors, which will be care. Sexual dysfunction in women increases with
reviewed in this supplement by Pfaus et al. Of age and declining estrogen status. Sexual activity is
interest is the potential interrelationship between seen as a sign of youth and vitality. Therefore, one
appetite and sexual response that may be mediated might expect that its importance will increase in
by MC4R. There are several examples where our aging society, and that more and more women
satiety and sexual function may be modulated by will not blithely consider the lack of a pleasurable
the same neurotransmitter, including the role of sex life to be a natural part of growing old.
the satiety hormone leptin on reproductive func- FSD and sexual disorders are multifactorial
tion [37–39]. This leads to the theory that energy in nature; thus greater understanding of the com-
homeostasis and reproductive function are broadly plex interrelationship between hormonal, neuro-
linked. biological, and psychosocial systems is needed in
dysfunction in women with type 1 diabetes. Diabe- 31 Halaris A. Neurochemical aspects of the sexual
tes Care 2002;25:672–77. response cycle. CNS Spectrums 2003;8:211–6.
21 Salonia A, Lanzi R, Scavini M, Pontillo M, Gatti E, 32 Cushing BS, Carter CS. Prior exposure to oxytocin
Petrella G, Licata G, Nappi RE, Bosi E, Briganti A, mimics the effects of social contact and facilitates
Rigatti P, Montorsi F. Sexual function and sexual behavior in females. J Neuroendocrinol 1999;
endocrine profile in fertile women with type 1 dia- 11:765–9.
betes. Diabetes Care 2006;29:312–6. 33 Melis MR, Argiolas A. Central oxytocinergic
22 Sand PK, Goldberg RP, Dmochowski RR, neurotransmission: A drug target for the therapy of
McIlwain M, Dahl NV. The impact of the overac- psychogenic erectile dysfunction. Curr Drug
tive bladder syndrome on sexual function: A pre- Targets 2003;4:55–66.
liminary report from the Multicenter Assessment of 34 Imbimbo C, Gentile V, Palmieri A, Longo N,
Transdermal Therapy in Overactive Bladder with Fusco F, Granata AM, Verze P, Mirone V. Female
Oxybutynin trial. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2006; sexual dysfunction: An update on physiopath-
195:1730–5. ology. J Endocrinol Invest 2003;26(3 suppl):102–4.
23 Casper RC, Redmond DE Jr, Katz MM, Schaffer 35 Voisey J, Carroll L, van Daal A. Melanocortins and
CB, Davis JM, Koslow SH. Somatic symptoms in their receptors and antagonists. Curr Drug Targets
primary affective disorder. Presence and relation- 2003;4:586–97.
ship to the classification of depression. Arch Gen 36 Van der Ploeg LH, Martin WJ, Howard AD,
Psychiatry 1985;42:1098–104. Nargund RP, Austin CP, Guan X, Drisko J, Cashen
24 Clayton AH, Pradko JF, Croft HA, Montano B, D, Sebhat I, Patchett AA, Figueroa DJ, DiLella AG,
Leadbetter RA, Bolden-Watson C, Bass KI, Connolly BM, Weinberg DH, Tan CP, Palyha OC,
Donahue RMJ, Jamerson BD, Metz A. Prevalence Pong S-S, MacNeil T, Rosenblum C, Vongs A,
of sexual dysfunction among newer antidepressants. Tang R, Yu H, Sailer AW, Fong TM, Huang C, Tota
J Clin Psychiatry 2002;63:357–66. MR, Chang RS, Stearns R, Tamvakopoulos C,
25 Smith PJ, Talbert RL. Sexual dysfunction with anti- Christ G, Drazen DL, Spar BD, Nelson RJ, MacIn-
hypertensive and antipsychotic agents. Clin Pharm tyre DE. A role for the melanocortin 4 receptor in
1986;5:373–84. sexual function. PNAS 2002;99:11381–6.
26 Schaffir J. Hormonal contraception and sexual 37 Wade GN, Lempicki RL, Panicker AK, Frisbee
desire: A critical review. J Sex Marital Ther RM, Blaustein JD. Leptin facilitates and inhibits
2006;32:305–14. sexual behavior in female hamsters. Am J Physiol
27 Pauls RN, Kleeman SD, Karram MM. Female 1997;272(Pt 2):R1354–8.
sexual dysfunction: Principles of diagnosis and 38 Schneider JE, Zhou D, Blum RM. Leptin and
therapy. Obstet Gynecol Surv 2005;60:196–205. metabolic control of reproduction. Horm Behav
28 Munarriz R, Kim NN, Goldstein I, Traish AM. 2000;37:306–26.
Biology of female sexual function. Urol Clin North 39 Schneider JE, Zhou D. Interactive effects of central
Am 2002;29:685–93. leptin and peripheral fuel oxidation on estrous
29 Clayton AH. Sexual function and dysfunction in cyclicity. Am J Physiol 1999;277(Pt 2):R1020–4.
women. Psychiatr Clin North Am 2003;263:673–82. 40 Heim LJ. Evaluation and differential diagnosis
30 Hull EM, Lorrain DS, Du J, Matuszewich L, of dyspareunia. Am Fam Physician 2001;63:1535–44.
Lumley LA, Putnam SK, Moses J. Hormone- 41 Warnock JJ. Female hypoactive sexual desire disor-
neurotransmitter interactions in the control of der: Epidemiology, diagnosis and treatment. CNS
sexual behavior. Behav Brain Res 1999;105:105–16. Drugs 2002;16:745–53.