Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Voltage Control of Current Source Inverters: IEEE Transactions On Energy Conversion July 2006
Voltage Control of Current Source Inverters: IEEE Transactions On Energy Conversion July 2006
net/publication/3270529
CITATIONS READS
35 3,461
4 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Piergiacomo Cancelliere on 13 November 2013.
Abstract—The current source inverters may become direct com- proposed even for ac drives. In all such cases proper voltage
petitors of the voltage source inverters thanks to the voltage control control techniques are necessary to allow fast reaction to load
techniques. The paper proposes an improved voltage control tech- variations. However, in order to produce optimal output in a
nique for current source inverters, that chooses the current vectors
relying on bang-bang controllers. This technique is compared to wide range of frequency and/or with arbitrary waveform by
a well-established one using current space vector modulation and means of PWM VSIs with filters, the adoption of well-suited
synchronous-frame proportional and integral controllers. The pre- control and/or design techniques are required [7].
sented controller is explained and validated by means of off-line as The CSIs are less investigated and applied than the VSIs, nev-
well as real time simulations and experimental tests. The numeri- ertheless the recent technological improvements achieved for
cal results prove that the proposed control technique produces less
distorted voltage waveforms in terms of total harmonic distortion the switching devices as well as for the computation architec-
and spectrum. According to the real-time simulations performed tures have made the CSIs more attractive in several applications
the proposed control technique is computationally less expensive from low to medium power range, as in PACSs, UPSs, ac drives
than the benchmark. Finally, the experimental results obtained and reactive power compensators. These applications may ben-
confirm the feasibility of the proposal. efit utilizing the CSIs because of their better load voltage and
Index Terms—Current source inverter (CSI), power conversion, current shape, inherent short circuit protection and regeneration
pulse width modulated power converters, voltage control. capability even with line commutated thyristor rectifiers. Due
to these major advantages, the CSIs are already appreciated
I. INTRODUCTION in medium voltage, large power induction drives [8], [9], and
are currently being investigated even in the low-power range in
HE current source inverters (CSIs) may become direct
T competitors of the voltage source inverters (VSIs) in sev-
eral applications, thanks to the voltage control techniques. The
direct competition with the VSIs [10], [11].
CSIs control and applications were studied in [8], [12]–[15].
Reference [16] evidenced that the use of synchronous frame,
paper presents an improved voltage control algorithm for CSI Proportional and Integral (PI) d, q voltage feedbacks yields zero
tailored to the applications cited in the following. steady-state errors on both magnitude and phase for ac reference
Today, pulse-width modulated voltage source inverters signals. This technique-referred in the following as proportional
(PWM VSIs) without output filters are widely employed in ac and integral (PI) regulated current space vector modulation
drives, notwithstanding the following negative effects. (PI-CSVM)—is reported in the paper and is utilized as a
• The high common-mode component tends to force bear- benchmark. Moreover, [16] developed a set of rules allowing to
ing currents, degrading the lubricant and accelerating the extend to the CSI some techniques formerly developed for the
bearings wearing [1], [2]. VSI, and this extension permits also the use of VSI-dedicated
• The high time rate of the voltage (dv/dt) accelerates the microprocessor features. Another form of voltage control for
degradation of motor insulation by exciting over voltages CSIs was proposed in [17]. The paper compares the PI-CSVM
due to the action of the cables [3], [4]. with an original voltage-controlled current modulation (VCCM)
• The high harmonic content sustains distorted flux and cur- scheme. The VCCM is derived from the flux/charge control,
rent producing additional losses in iron and copper [5], [6]. introduced to regulate the voltage and the current in VSIs and
Coping with such negative effects could increase the life of CSIs respectively. The theory of charge modulation was defined
motor bearings, the life of motor insulation, the motor rating in [18] for CSIs and unified with the flux modulation in [19].
and the efficiency. The aim of the proposal is to improve the voltage control
PWM VSIs with output filters are increasingly applied in of the CSIs. Section II illustrates the power circuit structure
programmable ac sources (PACSs) and uninterruptible power and operation of the CSI. Section III gives a description of the
supplies (UPSs). Moreover, the use of filters has been recently PI-CSVM control strategy used as a benchmark. Section IV
explains the principle of the VCCM. Sections V and VI report
off line and real time numerical results respectively. The off
Manuscript received November 29, 2004; revised April 8, 2005. This paper line numerical results relate to time and frequency response
was presented in part at PEMD 2002, International Conference on Power Elec- of the system and focus only on the inverter (dc/ac) stage of
tronics, Machines and Drives, 2002 (Conf. Publ. No. 487), Bath, U.K., June
4–7, 2002. Paper no. TEC-00330-2004. the complete (ac/ac) current source converter. The real time
The authors are with the DAEIMI Department of Automation and Mag- simulations compare the computational load produced by the
netics, The University of Cassino, 03043 Cassino (FR), Italy (e-mail: considered techniques. Finally, Section VII is dedicated to
delli-colli@unicas.it; cancelliere@unicas.it; marignetti@unicas.it; distefano@
unicas.it). the experimental results verifying the optimal behavior of the
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TEC.2005.859974 VCCM.
Fig. 1. Power circuit of the current source inverter (fed by a step-down con-
verter for laboratory purposes).
Fig. 3. Current space vectors of the CSI as function of the state patterns.
Fig. 4. Voltage control of a CSI with synchronous frame d, q PI controllers and current space vector modulation (PI- CSVM).
VCCM algorithm is a digital synchronous modulation tech- acts as a disturbance of the previous control action
nique, therefore can be compared with carrier-based methods. ∆t
The target of this modulation algorithm is the selection of a ∆vC = (i0 − iL ) (5)
Ca,b,c
sequence of CSI state patterns in order to maintain the output
voltage vector in a reference locus. At the midpoint of each previous equation allows to construct a discontinuous control
inverter leg, in terms of space vector, the current shares as action choosing i0 in order to keep vC very close to its ref-
erence trajectory. However, to obtain a stable voltage control,
i0 = iC + iL (3) neglecting all other model uncertainties, must be [20]
∆vC
i0 ≥ Ca,b,c + iL . (6)
where i0 , ic , and iL are respectively the space vectors of inverter ∆t
output currents, the space vector of the capacitor currents and the Conversely, the dc-link inductor current, then the magnitude
space vector of the motor currents. During no-load operation, of i0 , should be kept as low as possible in order to improve
iL = 0, and, in discrete time, the capacitor voltage space vector efficiency. As it is shown in Fig. 5, the voltage error is computed
vC varies as and expressed as a space vector in the synchronous frame.
The obtained d and q error components determine the next
∆t favorable state. The selection of vectors of Fig. 3 is executed in
∆vC = i0 (4)
Ca,b,c discrete-time by means of the following switching rules, graph-
ically represented in Fig. 6:
where ∆t is the sampling period and Ca,b,c are the filter ca- • if the real part of the error is positive, VCCM imposes a
pacitors; in other words, the current imposed to the capacitors zero state;
moves the output voltage vector exactly along the direction of • if the real part of the error is negative, VCCM imposes an
the current vector applied. The application of the load, iL = 0, active state;
454 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ENERGY CONVERSION, VOL. 21, NO. 2, JUNE 2006
V. OFF-LINE SIMULATIONS
The two techniques of voltage control—VCCM and PI-
CSVM—have been compared by means of numerical simu-
lations. Inverter switches are supposed to behave ideally, and
the effect of the digital implementation is modeled by sampling
rates and delays corresponding to the subsequent experimen-
tal realization. Simulations have been executed imposing the
same control timing for both methods, although the VCCM
algorithm executes in a shorter time than the PI-CSVM counter- Fig. 9. Simulation of transient performance of VCCM with a frequency refer-
part, as proved in the Section VI. Simulation conditions are as ence containing a step from steady-state.
in Table I.
The data show the behavior of both algorithms under four
test conditions relevant to the synthesis of sinusoidal voltages.
The amplitude of the voltage is a function of the frequency
implementing a Volt/Hertz law typical of ac machines drives.
The dc-link current has to be controlled as in [11]. The cases
considered are listed below.
• Frequency step from zero followed by a frequency ramp;
the results are reported in Fig. 7 for the VCCM and in
Fig. 8 for the case of PI-CSVM.
• Frequency step from steady-state conditions; the results
are reported in Fig. 9 for the VCCM and in Fig. 10 for the
case of PI-CSVM.
• Time and frequency analysis in steady-state conditions Fig. 10. Simulation of transient performance of PI-CSVM with a frequency
at 50 Hz, 220 Vrms (phase-to-neutral); the results are reference containing a step from steady-state.
DELLI COLLI et al.: VOLTAGE CONTROL OF CURRENT SOURCE INVERTERS 455
Fig. 13. Simulation of steady-state performance of PI-CSVM: voltage versus tationally heavier than the actual one, because a code segment
time. was added to simulate the behavior of the controlled system
during the real-time execution; the additional processor load
reported in Figs. 11 (waveform) and 12 (spectrum) for was the same for both methods. The code related to all nec-
VCCM; Fig. 13 reports the waveform and Fig. 14 the essary analog input and digital output was considered. Both
spectrum for PI-CSVM. programs were at the same level of optimization. Such set-
• Time and frequency analysis in steady-state conditions up allowed evaluating the computational loads in almost real,
at 25 Hz, 110 Vrms (phase-to-neutral); the results are fair conditions. The times required by each algorithm to ex-
reported in Figs. 15 (waveform) and 16 (spectrum) for ecute are shown by Fig. 19 where data are reported in per
VCCM; Fig. 17 reports the waveform and Fig. 18 the unit, taking the performance of the PI-CSVM as the base. A
spectrum for PI-CSVM. Dspace 1103 board, which adopts a 400 MHz PowerPC micro-
The THD values recorded in the above simulated cases are processor, was used to implement both algorithm. The software
reported in Table II. was written in the Simulink environment. The recorded com-
The presented data evidences the VCCM algorithm performs putation time were 13 µs for the VCCM and 17.3 µs for the
better than the PI-CSVM algorithm at the same sampling time. PI-CSVM.
TABLE III
MEASUREMENTS CONDITIONS
TABLE II
THD SIMULATION RESULTS
VIII. CONCLUSION
An approach to the voltage control of CSIs has been pre-
sented in the paper. The approach suggested was compared to
the well established PI control of d, q voltage with Space Vector
Modulation. Numerical results prove that the proposed algo-
rithm performs better than the traditional PI d, q control when
both methods operate with same timing. In fact, the proposed
algorithm achieved a better THD and a smoother spectrum of
the voltage in both the 25 and 50 Hz tests. Real-time simulations
demonstrate that the new method is lighter from a computational
standpoint. Furthermore, the experimental measures confirm the
Fig. 23. Measured 25 Hz, 110 Vrms line-to-line voltage waveforms. numerical results obtained for the VCCM algorithm.
From the previous considerations, it follows that voltage con-
trolled modulation can be considered as a valid alternative to
traditional techniques in the voltage control of CSIs.
REFERENCES
[1] R. Ong, J. Dymond, R. Findlay, and B. Szabados, “Shaft current in AC
induction machine—An online monitoring system and prediction rules,”
IEEE Trans. Ind. App., vol. 37, pp. 1189–1196, Jul./Aug. 2001.
[2] H. Zhang, A. Von Jouanne, and S. Dai, “A reduced-switch dual-bridge
inverter topology for the mitigation of bearing currents, EMI, and DC-
link voltage variations,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 37, pp. 1366–1372,
Sep./ Oct. 2001.
Fig. 24. Measured 50 Hz, 220 Vrms line-to-line voltage waveforms. [3] C. Hudon, N. Amyot, T. Lebey, P. Castelan, and N. Kandev, “Testing
of low-voltage motor turn insulation intended for pulse-width modulated
applications,” IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul., vol. 7, pp. 783–789,
Dec. 2000.
[4] M. Kaufhold, H. Auinger, M. Berth, J. Speck, and M. Eberhardt, “Elec-
trical stress and failure mechanism of the winding insulation in PWM-
inverter-fed low-voltage induction motors,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron.,
vol. 47, pp. 396–402, Apr. 2000.
[5] E. N. Hildebrand and H. Roehrdanz, “Losses in three-phase induction
machines fed by PWM converter,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 16,
pp. 228–233, Sep. 2001.
[6] A. Vamvakari, A. Kandianis, A. Kladas, S. Manias, and J. Tegopoulos,
“Analysis of supply voltage distortion effects on induction motor opera-
tion,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 16, pp. 207–213, Sep. 2001.
[7] R. Seliga and W. Koczara, “Instantaneous current and voltage control strat-
egy in low-pass filter based sine-wave voltage DC/AC converter topology
for adjustable speed PWM drive system,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Symp. Ind.
Fig. 25. Measured voltage waveforms in a 25 to 50 Hz step transient. Electron., 2002, pp. 813–817.
[8] J. R. Espinoza and G. Joos, “A current-source-inverter-fed induction mo-
tor drive system with reduced losses,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 34,
Results from some of the most significant tests are reported pp. 796–805, Jul./Aug. 1998.
[9] Y. Yin and A. Y. Wu, “A low-harmonic electric drive system based on
hereafter as follows: current-source inverter,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 34, pp. 227–235,
• steady-state conditions at 5 Hz, 22 Vrms line-to-line, Jan./Feb. 1998.
Fig. 21; [10] P. Cancelliere, V. Delli Colli, R. Di Stefano, F. Marignetti, and M. Scarano,
“On the harmonic influence of voltage controlled current source inverters
• steady-state conditions at 10 Hz, 44 Vrms line-to-line in induction motor drives,” J. Electr. Eng., vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 84–92.
Fig. 22; [11] P. Cancelliere, V. Delli Colli, R. Di Stefano, and F. Marignetti, “Compar-
• steady-state conditions at 25 Hz, 110 Vrms line-to-line ative experimental analysis of the effects produced by PWM voltage and
current source inverter on a low power induction motor,” in Proc. EPE
Fig. 23; 10th Eur. Conf. Power Electron. Appl., 2003.
• steady-state conditions at 50 Hz, 220 Vrms line-to-line [12] J. R. Espinoza and G. Joos, “Three-phase series var compensation based on
Fig. 24; a voltage-controlled current source inverter with supplemental modulation
index control,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 14, pp. 587–589, May
• frequency and voltage step, from steady-state conditions 1999.
Fig. 25; [13] J. R. Espinoza and G. Joos, “Current—source converter on-line pattern
• frequency and voltage step, from zero and voltage- generator switching frequency minimization,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron.,
vol. 44, pp. 198–206, Apr. 1997.
frequency ramp, Fig. 26. [14] J. R. Espinoza and G. Joos, “On line generation of gating signals for
The mean values of dc-link current are reported on each current source converter topologies,” in Proc. 1993 IEEE Int. Symp. Ind.
figure. Electron., 1993, pp. 674–678.
[15] J. R. Espinoza, G. Joos, and P. D. Ziogas, “A general purpose voltage
The measures confirm the numerical results obtained for the regulated current-source power supply,” in Proc. 8th Ann. Appl. Power
VCCM algorithm. Electron. Conf. Expo., 1993, pp. 778–784.
458 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ENERGY CONVERSION, VOL. 21, NO. 2, JUNE 2006
[16] D. N. Zmood and D. G. Holmes, “Improved voltage regulation for Fabrizio Marignetti (M’00) received the Laurea
current-source inverters,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 37, pp. 1028–1036, degree (with honors) in electrical engineering and
Jul./Aug. 2001. the Ph.D. degree in electrical engineering from the
[17] S. Rees and U. Ammann, “New stator voltage controller for high speed University “Frederick II” Naples, Italy in 1993 and
induction machines fed by current-source inverters,” in Proc. PESC, vol. 1, 1998, respectively, with a thesis on “A preliminary
2004, pp. 541–547. study for the construction of a novel axial-flux mi-
[18] P. C. Loh and D. G. Holmes, “A variable band universal flux/charge cromotor with etched windings.”
modulator for VSI and CSI modulation,” in Proc. IEEE IAS Ann. Meeting, In 1998 he joined the University of Cassino,
2001, pp. 1778–1786. Cassino, Italy, where he is presently an Associate
[19] A. Veltman and D. G. Holmes, “Charge controlled modulation of a current Professor of power electronic converters, electrical
source inverter,” in Proc. IEEE IAS Ann. Meeting, vol. 2, New Orleans, machines and drives. Since 1996, he lectures at the
LA, Oct. 1997, pp. 1529–1533. University of Cassino in electrical machines dynamics and since 2000 in elec-
[20] V. Utkin, J. Guldner, and J. Shi, Sliding-Mode Control in Electromechan- tromechanical systems design. Since 2004, he lectures also in design of electric
ical Systems. Taylor & Francis, 1999. drives for electric vehicles. His research interests include design, analysis and
control of electrical machines, especially fractional horsepower and unconven-
tional machines, linear machines, tubular actuators, axial-flux machines and
micromachines. He is actively involved in many projects both of national and
of industrial relevance.
Dr. Marignetti is a Member of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society. He
has been bestowed a scholarship of Rational Mechanics by the University of
Vincenzo Delli Colli received the Laurea degree Cassino. He is a member of the Editorial board of the Journal of Electrical Engi-
in electrical engineering from The University of neering and is a reviewer for many journals, including the IEEE TRANSACTIONS
Cassino, Cassino, Italy, in 1996 and the Ph.D. degree ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS.
in conversion of electrical energy from The Second
University of Naples, Naples, Italy, in 2000.
Since 2001, he has been a Research Assistant
in the Giovanni D’Angelo Industrial Electronic Lab-
oratory, the University of Cassino, Italy. His main
research interest is the control of electrical machines
and power converters.