Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Entrepreneurial Small Business 4th Edition Katz Solutions Manual
Entrepreneurial Small Business 4th Edition Katz Solutions Manual
Learning Objectives
After studying this chapter, the student should be able to:
Scott Jones made his own fleece jacket because he couldn’t afford buying one. Friends saw
it and clamored for Scott to make ones for them as well. It took a little trial and error, but
Scott was able to establish pricing and product standards and Beyond Fleece is now an
extremely successful company.
Discussion Questions
1. How would you describe the pricing approaches used by Beyond Fleece when it
started and as it grew?
At first he simply covered the cost of his materials and some profits, a strategy known as
cost plus, return pricing, or return on investment pricing. He also priced below the
competition – the main reason he got into the business in the first place. As his business
grew he had additional investments to cover. The popularity of his jackets has increased
to the point where he doesn’t have to be the low price seller and can be at, or above,
competition.
2. As Beyond Fleece continues to grow Jones will face several challenges. First and
foremost how can he continue to offer a unique, customizable product as he
produces hundreds of types of garments?
9-1
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
While each garment is strictly no longer 100% customized, each model is offered in a
number of colors and with 16 different options – providing a huge number of options.
Certainly programmable sewing machines are a big help and a process of “mass
customization” has worked for firms larger than Scott’s. At this point, it appears, there
are enough options to still be considered custom.
3. As more companies offer custom sizing, will consumer continue to pay higher
prices for Beyond’s clothing?
If the customer perceives this as a mass production item or as being the same as he can
purchase many places, he may be more reluctant to pay high prices. On the other hand,
if Scott establishes his product exceptionably high quality or prestigious – the
Lamborghini of fleece wear – customers will be willing to pay more, maybe more than
the price he’s currently using.
4. What directions do you see Beyond Fleece moving as a provider of custom clothing
and how will the business’s prices be affected?
1.1 Marketing it the process of planning and executing the factors of product, price,
promotion and placement, commonly know as the 4 P’s of marketing.
1.2 A product is anything that is offered to the market to satisfy a consumer’s wants,
needs or demands.
1.4 While products are often divided into goods or services, most everything is a
combination of both goods and services.
1.4.1 A product has more tangibility (i.e., things that can be touched, seen, held,
tasted and/or moved) than a service. A purchased car is a good example.
1.4.2 A product that is nearly equal in intangible and tangible aspects – such as a
leased car – is considered a hybrid product.
9-2
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
1.5 In addition to tangibility, goods can be differentiated from services in several other
ways:
1.5.1 Services have perishability; they cannot be stored for future usage.
1.5.2 Services have inseparability; they are produced and consumed at the same
time.
1.5.3 Services have heterogeneity; each time it is offered it will be slightly
different.
Skill Module 9.1: Facing Intangibility and Perishability
This exercise allows students to explore some of the same options marketers do when
addressing the characteristics of services.
It’s important for students to realize that these characteristics of services do make a
difference to consumers who often feel somewhat “helpless” when evaluating different
providers. Often choices are made on what may be very unimportant factors –
unimportant to the actual production of the service. For example, a rundown restaurant
may serve the best food in town, but customers are reluctant to try it and will opt for a
place that looks nicer – and may serve less tasty food.
2.1 The total product is the complete bundle of goods and services that you offer, along
with what the product means to the customer.
This module allows the student to think about what characteristics they have that mean
something to someone else – their augmented product. By asking this person – their
customers – for a second list of characteristics, they will find new items – the things that
make up the total product.
2.2 The augmented product shows the distinctive competence – what sets you apart
from other competition.
2.3 The core product is the lowest common denominator – the basic good or service.
9-3
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Teaching tool: divide the students into groups and give each group a
core product. Have them develop the augmented and total product
concept for them. Have them tell briefly how their total product will
impact their pricing, their promotion and their distribution.
NOTE: this can be combined with the following teaching tool and done
as one exercise.
2.5 Branding is part of your total product. Sometimes your brand is the same as the
company name. In any case, there are several considerations in picking your brand.
2.5.1 If you use your own name:
2.5.1.1 Add descriptors so that we know what your company does or your
product is.
2.5.1.2 If you use your name, consider the implications if you sell your firm.
2.5.1.3 Consider whether your name is appropriate, overused, and/or easy to
spell/pronounce.
2.5.2 For brand names in general:
2.5.2.1 Consider whether you are too close to a trademark.
2.5.2.2 Consider something that describes your firm or product and is easy to
remember and catchy.
2.5.2.3 Creative spellings are okay, as long as they are not too extreme.
2.5.2.4 Consider words that are evocative of the benefits your products offer.
2.5.2.5 Beware of a name that is too narrow to allow your firm to grow.
2.5.3 Many firms have different company names and product names. This has the
advantage of a poor product not necessarily being linked with the firm who
produced it.
2.5.4 For many small businesses, the owner and the brand are virtually
indistinguishable.
Teaching tool: Using the total products developed in the exercise above,
have students come up with several suggestions for brand names.
9-4
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
3.1. Before a product is introduced, it needs to go through a series of steps known as the
new product development process.
3.1.1. These steps may take years or a few hours or days.
3.1.2. More innovative product will take longer, while me-too products may even
skip steps of the process.
3.2. The first step is idea generation (and was covered in chapter 4). There are several
processes to consider:
3.2.1. Often ideas for new products come from something the entrepreneur wants
and can’t find.
3.2.2. Using the SCAMPER approach found in Chapter 4 is another approach.
3.2.3. Keep a product notebook and jot down every idea. Review them from time
to time. Use SCAMPER to “play” with them.
3.2.4. Look at your job, your hobbies, your family and friends, and your customers
for new ideas.
Skill Module 9.3: Creating Your Own Idea Notebook
Many goods and services are invented because someone was unhappy with what already
existed. Jotting down these dissatisfiers and exploring possibilities using tools such as
SCAMPER, are ways to potential create a new product or service.
3.4. In idea evaluation, step three, you consider more specific details to see if the idea is
feasible.
3.4.1. Additional information is gathered on its cost, how it should be marketed and
its market potential.
3.4.2. Consider how it fits with your mission.
3.4.3. The tool to use is Feasibility Analysis (chapter 4).
3.4.4. The results will normally be:
3.4.4.1.The idea cannot be economically made.
3.4.4.2.The product can be made but the market is insufficient.
3.4.4.3.The product can be made and the market is large enough, but you
need resources to make it happen.
9-5
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
3.5. The fourth step is product development; in this step the “serious” evaluation gets
done.
3.5.1. Build (or have built) prototypes for consumer testing for advanced consumer
concept testing.
3.5.1.1.Prototypes can be expensive, but perhaps a “desktop” version will do
for now.
3.5.1.2.You may be able to rough it out using products you have at home and
can get from a craft store.
3.5.1.3.Universities may have rapid prototyping equipment capacity.
3.5.1.4.A manufacturer may prototype your product in exchange for part of
your business.
3.5.1.5.For services a mock-up Website or example projects can serve the
same purpose.
3.5.2. Conduct test marketing.
3.5.2.1.This is a good method to test not only your product, but promotion,
distribution and pricing strategies as well.
3.5.2.2.Largest drawback is that competitors can see what you are doing and
possibly get a head start.
3.5.3. Simulated test markets can be developed. Although these are harder for
competitors to infiltrate, they are artificial settings and the results aren’t quite
as true.
3.5.4. Family and friends are low cost test markets that are unlikely to tell the
competition, but they may try to spare your feelings if they don’t like your
product.
3.5.5. Groups such as a church’s Ladies Aid or the local Friends of the Library may
be willing to try your product and report back, perhaps for a donation to their
cause.
3.5.6. Leverage social media by having participants share their opinions on a
private Facebook group or LinkedIn.
3.5.7. If you are not in business, in a very different business or where prototyping
and test marketing are difficult, consider focus groups discussed further in
chapter 12.
3.6. The final step is commercialization or making the product available to consumers.
3.6.1. There may be government or university assistance
3.6.2. Small businesses with limited budgets may want to introduce their products
city by city or region by region.
3.6.3. You may want to hire a contract manufacturer to make and sell your product
for you
9-6
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Mike Zane of Kryptonite has a constant stream of new products coming. He tests his
prototypes in unique ways – such as sitting in a surveillance van for 48 hours seeing if
any one could steal his bike.
Objective 4: Understand why pricing is an important but difficult task for small
businesses.
4.1 While marking or changing a price is an easy task, determining what number to use
can be challenging.
4.1.1 It has an impact on your personal earnings
4.1.2 It determines how many sales you can make.
4.1.3 It sets expectations about the quality of your product or service.
4.3 Your fundamental goal should be your optimum price. Four factors help you
determine this.
4.3.1 The demand for your product or service
4.3.2 The value delivered to the customer.
4.3.3 Prices set by competing firms.
4.3.4 Your business strategy and product placement.
4.4 Businesses often use some arbitrary rule-of-thumb in setting prices with disastrous
results.
5.1 While your magic number can give you sales, here is where you break that down
into price.
5.1.1 Annual sales can break down into daily sales which can be used to find out
how many units you might need to sell based on a certain price.
9-7
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
5.1.2 Mark-up pricing looks at the costs you have plus the mark-up (what you
need or would like to make) to tell you the price you need to have.
5.1.2.1 This computation will also tell you your margin.
5.1.2.2 One way to increase sales is to lower prices – but this means you’ll
need to sell a lot more in order to make your magic number.
5.4 Screaming Eagle provides a good example of why prices are not just cost plus a
profit margin.
5.4.1 Demand for a product drives prices up.
5.4.2 Price is tied to the value the customer perceives he/she is getting.
5.4.3 Competition must be considered.
5.4.3.1 Lower prices than competition.
5.4.3.1.1 While tempting to have a lower price, the competition will
catch on and can react by lowering their prices.
5.4.3.1.2 Your revenue as a percentage of sales will decline as well.
5.4.3.2 Higher than competition: Sounds good, but will only work if the
customers see the value in the higher prices.
5.4.4 Examining your product/service against the values discussed in chapter 7 are
ways to determine if your product could bear higher prices.
5.5 The factors that influence setting the right price vary from industry to industry, but
there are some underlying similarities:
5.5.1 If you are operating profitably at or near capacity, the price needs to be high
enough not to leave any money on the table.
5.5.2 If the product is extremely popular or rare (e.g., patented), charging high
prices is warranted.
5.5.3 If you are operating below capacity, setting prices low should bring in
enough business to meet payroll and keep operating.
9-8
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
5.5.4 Growing a business or planning your exit strategy are other goals that can
influence the prices you set.
J.P. Keating set a low price for his service, but his customer showed him that he was
under pricing.
9-9
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
5.9.3 If price escalation puts your price too high compared to competition, consider
direct distribution (see chapter 11).
5.10 Competition:
5.10.1 Small businesses generally do NOT want to be the low price in the market
for reasons mentioned above.
5.10.2 Deciding how to price in comparison with the competition means comparing
your “bundle or satisfactions” against your competition’s product.
6.1 After knowing your objectives, costs, competition and all the other categories
consider, you still need to think about your customers.
6.2 Pricing psychology has to do with the customer’s perception about the price and
varies customer to customer and from time to time. Some of the more frequently
observed pricing psychology phenomena are:
6.2.1 Internal reference price: Customer’s have a mental image of what a product
should cost based on past experiences, what he/she remembers reading or
hearing and the value the product has to the customer.
6.2.2 External reference price: The customer’s perception of what a product
should cost is now based on outside influences – what friends have said,
comparison shopping, ads, salesmen’s spiels, etc.
6.2.3 Perception of value: Customer will pay more if they perceive the value the
get is higher. If it’s important for me to have, I’ll pay more; if you don’t
really care, you’ll pay less.
6.2.4 Expectations of future prices: If you think prices are going to go up, you’ll
pay more; if you think they are going down, you’ll pay less.
6.2.5 Price range of acceptability: Consumers set a range of prices, below which
they believe the quality is questionable and above which they think they are
being taken advantage of.
6.3 There are a number of pricing strategies that small businesses can use:
9-10
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
6.3.1 Price skimming is charging the highest price the market will bear. This is
used if you are the first one in the market and is often used to recoup start-up
expenses before competition sets in.
6.3.2 Prestige or premium pricing is setting prices high and supporting it with
the rest of your marketing strategy in order to create the impression that your
product has high quality (premium) or is a status symbol to own (prestige)
6.3.3 Odd-even pricing means ending your price with a 9, 7 or 5. $99.99 sounds
much cheaper than $100 to customers.
6.3.4 Partitioned pricing is setting a price for the main component and pricing all
the peripheral components, installation, delivery, etc., separately. Consumers
select the main component based on the preset price they had in mind and
may spend much more to get all the accessories.
6.3.5 Captive pricing occurs when the customer spend usually a low price for a
base system but then is locked into certain expendables he/she must purchase
to use the system. These expendables are where the business makes most of
their profits.
6.3.6 Price lining is an attempt to please a wider target market by setting multiple
price points for closely related products – often “good” quality, “better”
quality, and “best” quality. This can work on products from shampoo to
clothing to appliances.
6.4 While having low prices is not recommended for small businesses, there are times
and occasions when it makes sense to temporarily reduce price, or to give the
impression of lower prices. These reasons include:
6.4.1 These reasons include:
6.4.1.1 Attracting more business.
6.4.1.2 Smoothing service cycles
6.4.1.3 Building loyalty
6.4.1.4 Moving excess inventories
6.4.1.5 Alleviating temporary cash flow problems
6.4.2 Some price lowering techniques include:
6.4.2.1 Periodic or random discounting is having a sale on a regular cycle
(periodic) or not (random).
6.4.2.2 Off-peak pricing works especially well for seasonal products or for
services trying to reduce perishability. During slack times, lower
prices are charged in order to get people to change their buying
patterns
9-11
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
6.5 Setting prices too low is a big problem for small businesses.
6.5.1 Most small businesses in financial difficulties have set their prices too low,
especially as only 15 – 35% of consumers decide on a product using price as
the number one factor.
6.5.2 There are other pricing techniques in table 9.1, but these only scratch the
surface.
9-12
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Key Terms
Augmented product: core product plus features that tend to differentiate it from
competition.
Bundling: combining two or more products in one unit and pricing it less than if the units
were sold separately.
Captive pricing: setting the price for an item relatively low and then charging much higher
prices for the expendables it uses.
Core product: the very basic description of what the product is – a bar of soap, a house-
cleaning service.
Elastic product: product for which there are any number of substitutes and for which a
change in price means a difference in quantity purchased.
Elasticity: the degree to which a product’s demand changes when its price changes.
4 P’s of marketing: the four elements of a marketing plan – product, price, promotion
(advertising) and placement (distribution).
Inelastic product: product for which there are few substitutes and for which a change in
price means very little difference in quantity purchased.
Internal reference price: a consumer’s mental image of what a product’s price should be.
Law of Supply and Demand: the economic theory that describes how the demand for
products (or services) and the supply of them affect each other.
Margin: the amount of profit usually stated as a percentage of the total price.
9-13
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Markup pricing: a price setting method where an amount is added to the cost of a product
to set the retail price and provide a profit.
Multiple or bonus pack: combining more than one unit of the same product and pricing it
less than if they were each sold separately.
Off-peak pricing: charging lower prices at certain times to encourage customers to come
during slack periods.
Optimum Price: the price that would generate the most income possible for the year for
the product or service you are selling.
Partitioned pricing: setting the price for a base item and then charging additional for each
additional component.
Peak pricing: charging more for a product or service during high demand periods.
Perishability: services exhibit perishability in that if it is not used when offered, it cannot
be saved for later use.
Price lining: the practice of setting (usually) three price points: good quality, better
quality, best quality.
Referral discount: a discount given to a customer who refers a friend to your business.
Skimming: setting a price at the highest level the market will bear, usually as there is no
competition at the time.
9-14
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Target market: the group of people on which a marketer focuses promotion and sales
efforts.
Total product: the entire bundle of products, services and meanings of your offering.
Includes extras like service, warranty, or delivery as well as what the product means to the
customer.
Discussion Questions
NOTE: many questions allow for a number of different answers. Below are some
suggestions
1. A college education comes pretty close to a true service. Discuss the four
main characteristics of service – intangibility, inseparability, perishability
and heterogeneity – as they pertain to a college education
Inseparability: a student must consume (listen, participate, learn) at the time the
service is produced (lecture, discussion, etc.). A professor must be engaged in
teaching (lecturing, etc.) when teaching is done.
2. What is the core component, the augmented product and the total product
sold at your college or university? How does it differ from your institution
to others in the area?
Total product: will vary considerably but might include the school’s mission,
social and sports experiences of the student, the prestige of the school, etc.
If students are experiencing difficulty, ask them why they selected this particular
school (and why they did NOT pick other ones).
9-15
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
3. List all the products/services you have seen lately that are promoted as new,
different, improved or otherwise changed from what has been available
before. What percentage of these are actually me-too products? Identify
the differential advantages these companies believe they have over the
competition.
Students will/should discover that differential advantages are often subtle and
dependent on the belief of the consumer. Does one product REALLY taste
better than another? Is one company TRULY faster than another? And, beyond
this, do consumers really CARE about the differences? A classic example is the
airline industry that advertised based on safety records and on-time arrivals;
while customers do want safe, timely flights, things such as pricing, comfort and
destinations were far more critical deciders. (Thus the birth of many discount
airlines, etc.)
If prices are too high, you may lose customers. If they are too low, you may be
cutting into your profits. How high or low your price is sends signals to the
customer about your quality. Competitors will also watch and react to your
prices.
5. Suppose you are operating a copy service. You learn that FedEx Kinkos is
going to open an outlet just a few blocks away. You are concerned that you
cannot compete with the marketing power of FedEx. What is likely to
happen to your business if you lower your prices and place colorful
advertising banners in the windows announcing the lowered prices?
FedEx Kinkos, being a large company with “deep pockets” is likely to meet or
beat your prices.
Basically, they work hand in hand. Your business strategy (factor 4) may
indicate that you have a prestigious product (factor 2) sold in exclusive channels
(factor 4) at a price higher than the competition (factor 3) even though this price
will limit the customers who can afford it (factor 1) – and similarly in reverse.
The model will vary but might look something like (showing the opposite side of
9-16
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
the coin):
Lower prices
Answer will vary, but should reflect one of the pricing psychology situations.
8. Think of two products in the same product category – one high priced and
one low priced. How do the other parts of the marketing mix – the product
itself, the advertising message and the distribution – support or detract from
the message the price tag gives?
Answers will vary but certain things will come out: Wal-Mart distribution for
low priced items; “rich” colors on expensive product ads, “because you deserve
it” messages for more expensive items, etc.
Experiential Exercises
1. At this point in time, you are fairly experienced with a college education.
What could you suggest could be done in order to reduce intangibility,
inseparability, perishability and heterogeneity of this service?
Intangibility: Show statistics about earning power with a degree versus without.
9-17
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Heterogeneity: Have all professors teaching the same class adhere to covering
certain materials. Provide teaching classes or other help to sub-standard teachers
to improve the level. Have professors rotate classes to ensure that all students
hear the same material.
If students are having some difficulty figuring out what this means, ask them
what brands they “insist” on buying, or will go out of their way to get. At what
stores “must” they shop? The follow-up question is “why?”
3. With a group of friends, brainstorm a list of ideas for a service you could
provide for your college professors. Design an idea checklist to evaluate this
list.
Answers will vary, but should resemble the checklist in the text.
Answers will vary, but should show incremental changes rather than radical
changes. Have them look back at the SCAMPER model to help generate ideas.
5. Set up several selling scenarios for the same product displaying different
cues about the value of a product (e.g., where it’s sold, whether it’s on sale),
the motivation of the seller, prices of competitive products (external
reference price) and other possibilities appropriate for your product. Ask
several people what they would pay under the circumstance you’ve set up.
9-18
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
6. For one week collect all the coupons you find in newspapers, magazine,
mail, etc., etc. What percentage are for products or services or brands that
you would really buy? Typically, how many coupons do you actually use in
a week? Pull all the coupons for one product category and visit a store. Are
there other brands of that same product that do not have coupons? Are
they engaging in any other method to attract customers – rebates, sales,
contests, multipacks, etc.?
Answers will vary. Generally students find that they are exposed to way more
promotional materials than they’ll ever use. While they usually believe that
before this exercise, they often do not realize exactly how many they see.
1. Donna Harsch is opening a bed and breakfast in a historic old house with a
distinctive red roof. This famous home is located in a seaport in Maine. What
parts of her operations are goods and what parts are services?
Answer:
Goods would include the actual room, bed and other furnishing and the food she
provides.
Services would include the cleaning and maintaining of the rooms, including the
9-19
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
ambiance created by the décor. The preparation of the breakfast and its
presentation are also services. Donna probably accepts credit cards, offers
advice about tourist attractions, makes reservations at local restaurants and may
provide airport pick-up.
2. Address the four characteristics that differentiate services from goods for
Donna's bed and breakfast. How might she address each one?
Answer:
Answers may vary, but here are some possibilities:
Heterogeneity: If Donna has help with cooking, she may wish to establish some
“tried and true” recipes so that her guests experience the same great food each
time they visit.
Perishability: While Donna may have no trouble filling her inn during the
summer and the fall foliage months, she is likely to experience hiring vacancies
the rest of the year. Donna could arrange special packages with special prices to
encourage tourism year round.
9-20
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Learning objective 2
3. Describe the core, augmented and total product Donna offers. How could she
use this information?
Answer:
Note: augmented and particularly total product definitions may vary depending
on what you think Donna’s mission is.
These will help her decide how to decorate and what services to offer. It will
help her advertise and promote her Bed and Breakfast by giving her clues about
the message and the media to use. It will help her price her product/service so as
to meet the needs of her target market.
4. Donna has a list of possible names for her business. Critique each of the
following:
a. Donna’s Place
b. Harsch Bed and Breakfast
c. Come On Inn
d. Inntimate
e. Red Roof Bed and Breakfast
Answer:
a. Donna’s Place could be a bar, a hairdresser, a candle shop . . .
b. “Harsch” sounds like “harsh.” Would you want to stay somewhere harsh?
c. “Come On Inn” is cute in that it sounds like an invitation. On the other hand,
a “come-on” is a synonym for some types of fraudulent (or near fraudulent)
behavior.
d. “Inntimate” is creative spelling, but some may not catch that it’s a B&B.
“Inntimate Bed and Breakfast” would work better and would attract the
honeymooners and romantic getaway crowd, but if Donna wants to attract
businessmen or families, it may not work as well.
e. While “Red Roof” does describe her building, this is trademark infringement
against “Red Roof Inns.” She’d be better off with “Red Shingle” or
something less close.
9-21
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Learning objective 3
Answer:
a. Product development
b. Idea generation
c. Idea screening and evaluation
d. Idea generation
e. Commercialization
f. Idea screening and evaluation
g. Product development
h. Commercialization
6. Alice is a single mom raising two young children. Recently, her uncle said that
he’d provide a $10,000 gift and co-sign loans to help her start a new business if
she could come up with a good idea. She had kept an idea notebook since taking
an entrepreneurship class in college and considered four of those ideas.
Idea 1: Would it be neat if there were bacteria that could eat plastic and we
wouldn’t have to just throw it away?
Idea 2: There needs to be a daycare center that’s open for evenings and nights
for parents who work those shifts.
Idea 3: Everybody raves about my spaghetti sauce.
Idea 4: I’d love a service that would run all sorts of errands for me so that I
wouldn’t have to go out everywhere with two little kids. Besides, I just really
hate driving and all that traffic.
Alice mused, “Well, there’s some things here that I don’t know much about, but
others that I do. I love kids and my home is large enough for the daycare. I like
cooking as well, but I’d need a bigger stove and a freezer. Hmmm, it’s hard to
9-22
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Help Alice decide which idea might be work further consideration by putting
together an idea screening comparison. (You can make some assumptions about
Alice if you need to complete the checklist.)
Answer:
With this scoring system, it looks like Alice should consider the plastic bacteria.
(Here’s a case where the weighting is deceptive. It is probable that Alice has NO
ability to produce this product regardless the potential, and would be better off
with one of the three others. In a case of a tie, such as with the final three, Alice
could go back and rescale certain factors. For instance, if she made the
profitability score range from 1 – 10, the evening day care becomes the winner.).
9-23
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Learning objective 4
7. Higher or lower? Read the following scenarios and decide if each entrepreneur
should raise or lower prices. What basic element of setting optimum prices
should they react to?
a. Portia had projected selling 1000 bottles of her organic bubble bath in the
first quarter. She had only sold 800 bottles though by the end of the quarter.
b. Most customers found Jacquelyn’s customer service just okay and her hours
of operating inconvenient.
c. Verna’s marketing research showed the local coffee shops sold their coffee
25% above her price.
d. Margaret intended that her one of a kind quilts be considered collector’s
items.
e. Mary Louise’s customers like the prestige of owning clothing once owned by
movie stars and other famous people.
f. Neil is worried; Toys “R” Us has announced that they will be building a
store less than a mile from his toy shop.
g. Pam was interested in selling as many World Series Champion T-Shirts as
she could before the next baseball season.
h. Terry had trouble keeping up with orders for his new lawn care service.
Answer:
a. Lower Demand
b. Lower Perceived Value
c. Higher Competition
d. Higher Business Strategy (possibly Perceived Value as well)
e. Higher Perceived Value
f. Lower Competition
g. Lower Business Strategy
h. Higher Demand
Learning objective 5
Lonnie piped up, “At that price you’d be getting excellent quality and all the
latest technology.”
Leta had a television set in her room. “I can’t see why we’d spend that kind of
9-24
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Linda added her opinion, “You know Ates is going out of business; they should
be really dropping prices as their time runs out.”
The Lawsons all had opinions on what the price should be for their new
television set. All their opinions reflected different pricing psychology effects –
internal reference prices, external reference prices, perception of value,
expectation of future prices, range of price acceptability, motivation of the seller,
and price as a proxy for quality. Can you identify who used what?
Answer:
Larry: external reference price
Lila: internal reference price; range of price acceptability
Lonnie: perception of value
Leta: perception of value
Linda: motivation of the seller; perception of future prices.
Learning objective 6
9. All of the following entrepreneurs have carefully studied pricing strategies and
have put these principles to work. From the information below, can you tell
which strategy from table 9.1 they have decided to use?
a. Ervin’s barber shop offers $15 haircuts and $10 shaves, but you can get them
both for $22.
b. Albert’s photography has won a number of awards for its outstanding
quality. Due to this, he now charges 30% more than his competitors.
c. The Anna Brown Museum offers a discounted admission price on weekdays
when attendance is low.
d. Angela’s Tanning sells tanning packages for $99.
e. Floyd sells good shirts $15, better shirts at $25 and best shirts at $35.
f. Assured Lawn Care Service charges $25 to mow the lawn, $5 more if you
want the grassed bagged, $10 to do edging, $30 to fertilize, $15 to aerate
and $25 for weed killing.
g. Gail offers a back-to-school sale each year.
h. The Auto Shack’s ad mentioned an incredibly low priced car, but when you
got there, it was way in the back of the lot and about the ugliest color you
had ever seen – nothing at all like that red sports car you passed near the
entrance.
i. Tian told her best friend, Ahn, to use Associated Brokers and the next time
Tian made a trade, the company waived their fee because Ahn had set up an
account with them.
j. Delmar was happy; he just bought his 9th carwash and now got one free.
k. Melissa was the newest babysitter in the neighborhood. In order to attract a
lot of clientele quickly, she set her prices considerably below the competition.
9-25
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Answer:
a. Bundling
b. Prestige or premium pricing
c. Off-peak pricing
d. Odd-even pricing
e. Product line pricing
f. Partitioned pricing
g. Periodic discounting
h. Bait pricing
i. Referral discount
j. Loyalty program
k. Penetration pricing
Mini-Case:
Yak Milk
Dongzhou Gongbu saw yak milk as a way of supporting his native people and helping
China’s food crisis. Along the way he had to consider his product and pricing strategies.
Mini-Case Questions
This was a case of solving two problems with the same solution – finding a help for
China’s food problem and helping out his native people. Under SCAMPER, it is an
illustration of Combine
These unique characteristics meant that he could charge a premium price for this
product.
The rareness of yak milk and remoteness of the Tibetan plateau combined with the
“magic” of the yak should be included in his message. Taglines might be something
like “magic milk makes healthy kids.” (Again, there’s a lot of room for variation
here.)
9-26
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
5. Can you think of another product that is basically the same as the competition
and has been positioned much differently in order to command a higher price?
Answers will vary, but most premium or prestige priced products are not too much
different than their less expensive competition. Compare designer clothing to mass
marketed clothing.
Epilog: Dongzhou did market his milk as a health product rather than a pure substitute for
cow’s milk. In addition, he pursued the more lucrative international market with specialty
cheeses.
Additional Activities
1. The Internet is now a good tool for investigating consumers’ thoughts about
products – everything from test marketing ideas (like the Proof-of-Concept
Website discussed in the last chapter) to solicit customers’ feedback on products.
Chat rooms, in particular are often used to discuss new products and disseminate
information about the pros and cons of new products.
A. Have any students participated in Internet chats where products were
discussed? What sorts of products? What sorts of information?
B. How does this or could this affect the product life cycle?
Students may be unaware the businesses often surf the net looking for feedback on
their products – feedback that they feel may be more honest (less filtered) than
focus groups or surveys.
2. Have students select a service provider to visit this week and make a purchase (or
consider making a purchase). The student should take notes about the typical
customer, the facilities of the store/location, the salespeople, types of advertising
or signage used, the salespeople and their knowledge and the transaction as a
whole. The student should be prepared to ask several questions – location of a
product, return policy, technical information, special services, etc – of the
salespeople. What attempts at reducing intangibility and other service
characteristics did they note? How does the whole package (the total product)
work, that is, do all the pieces seem to support the idea/concept?
This multi-task case requires students to incorporate and apply a number of distinct but
interrelated business management disciplines-- marketing, finance, retail merchandising and
operations. It may be helpful to guide and direct your students through some logical
progression of research, analysis and documentation.
9-27
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Target market groups are usually the first and primary focus. Decisions regarding product
mix and promotion must be directly related to the demographics and buying behaviors of the
customer base. Students should clearly define their markets and should then proceed to
select the package of products, services and promotional activities that will maximize profits
and achieve the goals established by the principles.
There are many acceptable floor plans for this business. This element of the case challenges
student’s creativity and imagination and requires them to research and observe the ways in
which any physical plant can be laid out and operated. Customer satisfaction, employee
efficiency, safety and profit maximization should be incorporated into each sketch and
supporting narrative.
For their grand opening, Fred and Larry “borrowed” an idea that they heard about from a
guest speaker back in their business school days. That gentleman had recently opened a new
restaurant in Massachusetts and was faced with many of the same challenges as Fred and
Larry.
That idea which was slightly modified to fit Fred and Larry’s business was to formally
invite people from each prospective market group to sample free wines and foods and to
tour the new establishment. Fred and Larry invited the local fire and police departments,
schoolteachers, business owners, club members, senior citizens, sports organization
members and assorted other community leaders and groups. The store was full of people
seven days a week for the first six weeks of operation. By that time, hundreds of locals
knew about the House of Wine and had enjoyed a pleasant first-hand experience. Fred and
Larry’s “show” was on the road and off to a great start. Their “grand opening act” cost them
$25,000-- they considered this to be a wise investment.
For the next six months, Fred and Larry worked hard to capture the local year-round
markets in order to sustain their cash flow. A variety of promotional, seasonal and holiday
events took place. They started a “Wine Cellar for the Ages” program that focused on
building personal home wine cellars through an annual case-purchasing program. Cases are
offered at a reduced price. The goal for a personal wine cellar owner is to have at least five
times their annual consumption on hand, including gift bottles. For example, a family that
“consumes” an average of four bottles per week, including gifts, will work to build a cellar
with at least one thousand bottles.
Fred and Larry spent a lot of time on their showroom floor establishing personal
relationships with customers and listening carefully to their opinions and requests for wine
and complementary products. They tracked inventory turnover and sales very closely and
constantly “tweaked” their product mix.
First year sales were just under $1,250,000. Fred and Larry were very pleased.
9-28
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Chapter 09 - Small Business Marketing: Product and Pricing Strategies
Fred and Larry then worked to develop their seasonal and tourist markets through selected
ads in papers, magazines and local cable. Town records (public information) allowed them
to gather useful demographic and geographic data about the many cottage owners in the
area.
During their second year of operation, Fred and Larry also established partnerships with
area hotels and restaurants and became a supplier for several of those businesses. This also
included a catering service that featured wine tasting and special event parties. Fred and
Larry’s lower level warehouse thus became a profit center of its own, as hundreds of cases
of wine and party platters made their way to customers via local delivery.
Fred and Larry were also wise to have created a computer database right from their grand
opening start. This enabled them to stay in touch with both area and seasonal customers all
year round and to obtain many referrals from those satisfied customers.
At last check, Fred and Larry were getting fat on both profits and wine!
Additional Materials
Available on Create
Alma Products, Inc
Whale Printing Company
Giberson's Glass Studio
Video Case
Craft Beer Boom
STVP Videos
The Product Vision
Role of Market Research
ItsYourBiz.com Videos
Howard Wright, Inventor of the Storm Safety Whistle, part-time business, marketing
Market Research
9-29
© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution
in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.