Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2012, Thermal Performance of 3D IC Integration TSV
2012, Thermal Performance of 3D IC Integration TSV
net/publication/273997284
CITATIONS READS
4 1,145
8 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ra-Min Ray Tain on 01 April 2015.
AbstractThermal performance of 3D IC integration is inves- Finally, the feasibility of these equivalent equations is demon-
tigated in this study. Emphasis is placed on the determination of strated through a simple 3D IC integration SiP.
a set of equivalent thermal conductivity equations for Cu-filled
TSVs with various TSV diameters, TSV pitches, TSV thicknesses,
passivation thicknesses, and microbump pads. Also, the thermal CU-FILLED TSV EQUIVALENT THERMAL
behavior of a TSV cell is examined. Furthermore, 3D heat trans- CONDUCTIVITY EXTRACTION
fer simulations are adopted to verify the accuracy of the equiva-
lent equations. Finally, the feasibility of these equivalent equations A. Simulated Model Establishment
is demonstrated through a simple 3D IC integration structure.
Fig. 1 shows and defines a TSV cell for extracting its equiv- F1
Keywords3D IC integration, equivalent thermal conductivities alent thermal conductivities, and Table I shows the parameter T1
of Cu-filled TSVs, SiO2, through silicon via (TSV)
matrix for simulations. In the figure and table, DTSV is the
diameter of the TSV (from 10-50 mm); H is the chip thickness
(from 10-200 mm; the thinner chips are meant for stacked
INTRODUCTION memories, while the thicker chips are for active/passive inter-
hermal management is one of the critical issues of 3D IC posers); P denotes the TSV pitch; and tSiO2 denotes the thick-
T integration [1-19]. This is because [9-19]: (1) the heat flux
generated by stacked multifunctional chips in miniature pack-
ness (from 0.2-1.0 mm) of the deposited SiO2.
The equivalent thermal conductivities to be extracted
ages is extremely high; (2) 3D circuits increase the total power include kxy and kz. The subscripts xy and z mean, respectively,
generated per unit surface area; (3) chips in the 3D stack may the in-plane direction and cross-plane direction of the chip/
be overheated if cooling is not properly and adequately pro- interposer. For Cu-filled TSV in-plane equivalent thermal con-
vided; (4) the space between the 3D stack may be too small for ductivity (kxy), we apply a positive heat flux (Qin00 ) to one of its
cooling channels (i.e., no gap for fluid flow); and (5) thin chips sidewalls (called the hot surface); and a negative heat flux
00
may create extreme conditions for on-chip hot spots. Thus, (Qout ) to the opposite sidewall (called the cold surface) for
effective thermal management design methods, tools, guide- drawing out the heat, as shown in Fig. 2. Based on Fourier’s F2
lines, and solutions are desperately needed for widespread use law, we have the equivalent, kxy, which can be expressed as
of 3D IC integration.
Even with the most advanced software and high-speed hard- Thot Tcold
Qin00 ¼ kxy
ware, it is very time-consuming to model all the TSVs in a 3D P
IC integration system-in-package (SiP). In [10, 15, 16], empir-
ical equations for the equivalent thermal conductivities of TSV where Thot and Tcold are the average temperature of the hot
chips/interposers with various copper (Cu)-filled TSV diame- surface and the cold surface, respectively, and P is the TSV pitch.
ters, pitches, and aspect ratios have been determined. Unfortu- For extracting the Cu-filled TSV cross-plane equivalent ther-
nately, the passivation layer (SiO2) was not considered. mal conductivity (kz), we add one buffer block on the top side of
In this study, empirical equations for the equivalent thermal the TSV and one at the bottom side as shown in Fig. 3. The F3
conductivities of Cu-filled TSV chips/interposers with various buffer blocks serve to smooth the heat flow that enters and exits
passivation thicknesses, TSV diameters, TSV pitches, TSV the cell in order to obtain a more reliable and accurate result.
thicknesses, and microbump pads, are determined. Also, the Again, by using Fourier’s law, the equivalent thermal con-
thermal behavior of a Cu-filled TSV cell with a SiO2 layer is ductivity kz can be expressed as
examined. Furthermore, 3D heat transfer simulations are per-
formed to verify the accuracy of the equivalent equations. Thot Tcold
Qin00 ¼ kz
H
Manuscript received September 2011 and accepted April 2012
Electronics and Optoelectronics Research Laboratories Industrial Technol-
where Thot and Tcold are defined as the average temperature of
ogy Research Institute (ITRI), Chutung, Hsinchu, Taiwan the hot section and the cold section, respectively, and DH is
*Corresponding author; email: Jack_Chien@itri.org.tw the spacing between both sections and is assumed to be 2 mm.
Table I
The Analyzed Parameters Matrix
DTSV (mm) 10 20 30 40 50
H (mm) 10, 20, 30, 10, 20, 50, 10, 20, 50, 10, 20, 50, 10, 20, 50,
50, 100, 100, 150, 100, 150, 100, 150, 100, 150,
150 200 250 250 250
P (mm) 25, 35, 40, 35, 45, 55, 45, 55, 65, 55, 65, 75, 65, 75, 85,
50, 70, 65, 80, 75, 100, 85, 100, 100, 150,
100, 130 120, 150 150, 200 150, 200 200
tSi02 (mm) 0.2, 0.5, 0.2, 0.5, 0.2, 0.5, 0.2, 0.5, 0.2, 0.5,
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
Fig. 2. TSV cell for kxy extraction. (a) The stereogram of the cell, and (b) the
The hot and cold sections are mutually parallel and symmetri- cross section of the cell.
cal to the cell horizontal central line of the Cu-filled TSV.
Fig. 9. Correlations between equivalent kz and the TSV diameter. The chip
thickness (H ) is 50 mm and the SiO2 thickness (tSiO2) is 0.2 mm.
Fig. 11. Comparison between the simulation data (dot) and equivalent kz
B. Comparison Between the Results Obtained from kxy and kz equation (curve). The error bar is 10%.
and from 3D Heat Transfer Simulations
F10
F11
F10 ; F11 Figs. 10 and 11 show the comparisons between the 3D
simulation data and the equivalent equations. For equivalent
kxy and equivalent kz, it can be seen that the largest error of
the empirical equations is less than 15%. Most simulation
data agree with the equivalent equations, with an error of less
than 10%.
ory chips (each with three TSVs and the TSV diameter is
DTSV ¼ 10 mm) bonded together (with a 20 mm diameter
microbump) on top of an interposer. Each chip has two heaters
(on opposite directions) and each heater generates a heat flux
of 1 × 106 W/m2. The chip thickness is 50 mm. The SiO2
thickness ¼ 0.2 mm. Each chip size is 10 mm × 10 mm and
each dissipates 0.8 W of heat. Thus, for the four-chip stacking,
the total power generated from the heat is 3.2 W.
Fig. 10. Comparison between the simulation data (dot) and equivalent kxy The boundary conditions are: h ¼ 10,000 W/m2K on the
equation (curve). The error bar is 10%. top side of the model and h ¼ 500 W/m2K on the bottom of
6 Journal of Microelectronics and Electronic Packaging, Vol. 9, No. 2, 2nd Qtr 2012
Fig. 15. Heater temperature comparison: DTSV, H, tSiO2, and bump diameter
are 10, 50, 0.2, and 20 mm, respectively. The ambient temperature is 35 C.
Fig. 13. Detail and equivalent models for feasibility verification. (a) The
detailed model, and (b) the equivalent model. There are two heaters on a chip
and each heater generates 106 W/m2. What would the thermal path and temperature distribution of
the memory-chip stacking be with microbumps but without
TSVs? The simulation results show that all the chip tempera-
the interposer. Physically, it means the SiP has an air cooling tures are higher than those of the model with TSVs (Cu-filled
heat sink on the top side and natural convection cooling on TSVs provide a better thermal conducting path than Si). The
the bottom side. The slice model is introduced: (1) because it temperature is higher by about 2.5 C for chip #4, 2 C for chip
is a semi-2D model that can simplify the simulation effort, #3, 1.2 C for chip #2, and 0.1 C for chip #1. These results
and (2) for the verification and demonstration of its accuracy indicate that TSVs do indeed increase the chips’ heat dissipa-
and feasibility. tion effect, and thermal performance. For this simple example,
F14F14 Fig. 14 shows the temperature distributions of the detailed the thermal performance enhancement is about 6%.
model (left) and the equivalent model (right). It can be seen
that: (1) the TSVs are dissipating the accumulated heat from
the chips to ambient (left), and (2) even the heat flow within SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS
both models is different; however, the temperatures of the Empirical equations for the equivalent thermal conductivi-
heaters of the two models are quite the same. ties of Cu-filled TSV chips/interposers with various passiv-
F15F15 Fig. 15 shows the heater temperature comparisons between the ation thicknesses, TSV diameters, TSV pitches, TSV thicknesses,
detailed model and the equivalent model. It can be seen that: (1) and microbump pads were determined in this investigation.
for all the TSV pitches, both models predict almost the same Also, the thermal behavior of a SiO2-Cu-filled TSV cell was
heater temperature; (2) for all the TSV pitches, the smallest discussed. Furthermore, the accuracy of the equivalent equa-
heater temperature occurs at the top chip #4 and the largest heater tions was verified by 3D heat transfer simulations. Finally,
temperature occurs at the bottom chip #1 (this is because the the feasibility of these equivalent equations was demon-
main dissipation path of the heat is via the model top side to strated through a simple 3D memory-chip stacking structure.
the ambient); and (3) except for the top chip, the smaller the Some important results and recommendations are summarized
TSV pitch (a denser TSV arrangement), the lower the heater as follows.
temperature (this is caused by the higher longitude equivalent
thermal conductivity (kz) of TSV and microbumps). 1. kxy and kz for SiO2-Cu-filled TSV memory-chip stacking
and interposer have been provided and they are very useful
for 3D IC integration design and analysis.
2. Based on the 3D simulation results, most errors of kxy and kz
are within 10% and in a few cases the maximum error is 15%.
3. For thermal performance of 3D IC integration, the SiO2
layer serves as a thermal barrier in a TSV, which reduces
the value of kxy and kz. On the other hand, the filled Cu
increases the value of kxy and kz.
4. For most cases considered in this study, the value of kxy is
smaller than that of silicon, that is, the effect of the SiO2
layer is larger than that from the filled Cu (i.e., the SiO2
layer blocks the heat flow into the filled Cu). However,
for the practical cases (real applications) such as SiO2 ¼
Fig. 14. A typical temperature distribution of the detailed model (left) and
the equivalent model (right). Here, DTSV, tSiO2, H, and bump diameter are 10, 0.2 mm and H ¼ 50 mm for memory-chip stacking and H ¼
0.2, 50, and 20 mm, respectively. The boundary conditions and heat generation 100-200 mm for interposer, the value of kxy is almost the
are shown in Fig.13. same as silicon’s.
Chien et al.: Thermal Performance of 3D IC Integration with Through-Silicon Via (TSV) 7
5. For all the cases considered in this study, the value of kz is [6] A. Jain, R. Jones, R. Chatterjee, and S. Pozder, “Analytical and numerical
larger than that of silicon, that is, the contribution of the modeling of the thermal performance of three-dimensional integrated
circuits,” IEEE Transactions on Components and Packaging Technolo-
filled Cu is larger than the negative effect of the SiO2 layer. gies, Vol. 33, No. 1, pp. 56-63, 2010.
6. The guidelines for using kxy and kz for 3D IC integration SiP [7] P. Leduca, F. de Crecy, M. Fayolle, B. Charlet, T. Enot, M. Zussy, B.
have been provided through examples. Jones, J.-C. Barbe, N. Kernevez, N. Sillon, S. Maitrejean, and D. Louisa,
7. For the simple 3D IC integration SiP examples considered “Challenges for 3D IC integration: Bonding quality and thermal manage-
herein (memory-chip stacking with TSVs and without TSVs), ment,” Proceedings of International Interconnect Technology Confer-
ence, pp. 210-212, 2007.
the TSV thermal performance enhancement is about 6%. [8] M. Hsieh, C. Yu, and S. Wu, “Thermo-mechanical simulative study for
8. Thermal management is on the critical path of 3D IC inte- 3D vertical stacked IC packages with spacer structures,” Proceedings
gration and 3D Si integration. The research institutions and of Semiconductor Thermal Measurement and Management Symposium,
electronic industry should: (a) perform more innovative pp. 47-54, 2010.
[9] A. Yu, N. Khan, G. Archit, D. Pinjalal, K. Toh, V. Kripesh, S. Yoon, and
researches and collect more useful data in this area, and (b) J.H. Lau, “Development of silicon carriers with embedded thermal solu-
provide some effective thermal management design methods, tions for high power 3-D package,” IEEE Transactions on Components
tools, guidelines, and solutions for the widespread use of and Packaging Technology, Vol. 32, No. 3, pp. 566-571, 2009.
3D Si/IC integrations. [10] J.H. Lau and G. Tang, “Thermal management of 3D IC integra-
tion with TSV (through silicon via),” IEEE Proceedings of ECTC,
pp. 635-640, 2009.
[11] N. Khan, L. Yu, P. Tan, S. Ho, N. Su, H. Wai, K. Vaidyanathan, D.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Pinjala, J.H. Lau, and T. Chuan, “3D Packaging with through silicon via
The authors would like to thank the VP and Director of (TSV) for electrical and fluidic interconnections,” IEEE Proceedings of
ECTC, pp. 1153-1158, 2009.
Electronics & Optoelectronics Research Labs, Dr. Ian Yi-Jen [12] G. Hoe, G. Tang, P. Damaruganath, C. Chong, J.H. Lau, X. Zhang, and
Chan for his strong supports on this project. Also, the authors K. Vaidyanathan, “Effect of TSV interposer on the thermal performance
are grateful for financial support from the Ministry of Eco- of FCBGA package,” IEEE Proceedings of Electronics Packaging and
nomic Affairs (MOEA), Taiwan. Technology Conference, pp. 778-786, 2009.
[13] J.H. Lau, T.G. Yue, G.Y.Y. Hoe, X.W. Zhang, C.T. Chong, P.
Damaruganath, and K. Vaidyanathan, “Effects of TSV (through silicon
via) interposer/chip on the thermal performances of 3-D IC packaging.”
REFERENCES ASME Paper no. IPACK2009 89380.
[1] M. Groger, S.M. Harb, D. Morris, W. Eisenstadt, and S. Puligundla, [14] G. Tang, O. Navas, D. Pinjala, J.H. Lau, A. Yu, and V. Kripesh, “Inte-
“High speed I/O and thermal effect characterization of 3D stacked ICs,” grated liquid cooling systems for 3-D stacked TSV modules,” IEEE
Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Digital Object Identi- Transactions on Components and Packaging Technologies, Vol. 33,
fier, pp. 1-5, 2009. No. 1, pp. 184-195, 2010.
[2] T. Hung, M. Yew, C. Chou, and K. Chiang, “A study of thermal perfor- [15] J.H. Lau, C.K. Lee, C.S. Premachandran, and A. Yu, Advanced MEMS
mance for chip-in-substrate package on package,” Proceedings of Micro- Packaging, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2010.
electronics and Packaging Conference, pp. 1-6, 2009. [16] J.H. Lau, “Reliability of RoHS Compliant 2D & 3D IC Interconnects,”
[3] H. Oprins, V. Cherman, C. Torregiani, M. Stucchi, B. Vandevelde, and McGraw-Hill, New York, 2011.
E. Beyne, “Thermal test vehicle for the validation of thermal modelling [17] H.-C. Chien, Y.-L. Chao, J.H. Lau, R.-M. Tain, M.-J. Dai, P.J. Tzeng,
of hot spot dissipation in 3D stacked ICs,” Proceedings of Electronic C.-H. Lin, Y.-C. Hsin, S.-C. Chen, J.-C. Chien, C.-C. Chen, C.-H. Ho,
System-Integration Technology Conference, pp. 1-6, 2010. W.-C. Lo, T.-K. Ku, and M.-J. Kao, “A thermal performance measure-
[4] H. Oprins and V. Cherman, V.M. Stucchi, B. Vandevelde, G. Van der ment method for blind through silicon vias (TSVs) in a 300 mm wafer,”
Plas, P. Marchal, and E. Beyne, “Steady state and transient thermal anal- Proceedings of the IEEE ECTC, pp. 1204-1210, 2011.
ysis of hot spots in 3D stacked ICs using dedicated test chips,” Proceed- [18] J.H. Lau, H.C. Chien, and R. Tain, “TSV interposers with embedded
ings of Semiconductor Thermal Measurement and Management microchannels for 3D IC and multiple high-power LEDs integration
Symposium, pp. 131-137, 2011. SiP,” ASME Paper no. InterPACK2011-52204.
[5] A. Jain, “Thermal characteristics of multi-die, three-dimensional inte- [19] J.H. Lau, Y.S. Chan, and S.R. Lee, “Thermal-enhanced and cost-
grated circuits with unequally sized die,” Proceedings of Thermal and effective 3D IC integration with TSV (through-silicon via) interposers
Thermomechanical Phenomena in Electronic Systems, pp. 1-6, 2010. for high-performance applications,” ASME Paper no. IMECE2010-40975.