Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Profession of Horticultural Therapy Compared With Other Allied Therapies
The Profession of Horticultural Therapy Compared With Other Allied Therapies
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
The 1950s and 1960s saw the beginnings of defining horticultural therapy as a profession and the need
for formally trained horticultural therapists. Historically, horticulture was used as an activity or diversion
for hospital patients, for vocational training, and in occupational therapy. Horticultural therapy continues
to be closely affiliated with these allied therapies such as occupational therapy, recreational therapy, and
activity therapy. Comparisons between these allied therapies can be a useful tool in understanding the past
and defining or identifying strategies for the growth and development of the profession into the future. This
paper provides a brief history of the profession and an in-depth comparison of the evolution of horticultural
therapy to the other allied therapies.
Currently AOTA membership consists of more It should be suggested that for the profession
than 50,000 occupational therapists and occupational of horticultural therapy to grow and thrive, the
therapy assistants. As an advocate for the profession, practitioners, researchers, and educators of horticultural
AOTA is a founding member of CARF, serves on the therapy must come together to clearly define what it
Liaison Network of JCAHO, and is active in the means to be a professional horticultural
therapist
National Committee for Quality Assurance, which is and, perhaps more importantly, to then
communicate it effectively to all constituent groups.
dedicated to improving the quality of healthcare
(AOTA, 2002). Through AOTA and NBCOT, close
relationships with federal and state agencies for health The founding name of the horticultural therapy
care are maintained, which are reflected in the professional association, - the National Council for
Therapy and Rehabilitation through Horticulture -
certification process and their assistance in state
licensure requirements for occupational therapists. recognized two philosophies of horticultural therapy in
the early 1970s. Rehabilitation was part of the title since
many horticultural therapy programs in the early 1970s
The American Horticultural Therapy Association
were found in vocational training and rehabilitation
has significantly less members than the other allied
therapy professional associations. Currently, centers
the for the developmentally disabled. Therapy was
AHTA Web site lists no educational requirement part for of the title since many programs were found in
psychiatric
entering the profession. Based on the author's review hospitals (Mattson, R., 2002, personal
of horticultural therapy position announcements communication). This philosophical difference is also
evident
received at Kansas State University and the results of in discussions from the 1970s to current times
regarding the use of the term therapeutic horticulture
mailed surveys of practicing horticultural therapists
(data not published), some entry-level positions versus horticultural therapy to distinguish between the
require a high school diploma and others require general use of horticulture with any population in any
a bachelor's degree. The AHTA does provide a setting to promote well-being and the use of horticulture
credential, but since it is a voluntary peer review for treatment of a disease or disability. This distinction
process, it is not a recognized credential in health care. is evident in the United Kingdom where the association
AHTA has developed a core curriculum for Thrive was formed to promote grassroots programming
horticultural therapy but does not have an accreditation focusing on gardening for all without an emphasis on
system in place. the medical aspects while the medical basis of
horticultural therapy exists within occupational therapy
The professional associations for music therapy, art
training at Oxford University.
therapy, and therapeutic recreation were all founded to
represent the interests and needs of their constituency. Given that the act of gardening, doing other plant-
This has been done through building government andrelated activities, and even the passive experience of
seeing, smelling, or listening to plants and nature can
all horticulture would be horticultural therapy. At the AMTA (2002). American Music Therapy Association. http://www.music-
therapy.org. Viewed July 1, 2002.
1998 People-Plant Symposium in Sydney, Australia,
AOTA (2002). American Occupational Therapy Association.
researchers from Japan proposed a different term, http://www.aota.org. Viewed July 10, 2002.
horticultural well-being, for this expanded under- ATCB (2002). Art Therapy Credential Board, http://www.atcb.org.
standing that horticulture activities or the passive Viewed July 3, 2002.
ATRA (2002). The American Therapeutic Recreation Association.
experience of seeing, smelling or listening to plants http://www.atra-tr.org. Viewed July 11, 2002.
and nature should be included in horticultural therapy Black, B. (1971). Horticultural therapy comes of age. Garden Journal
(Matsuo, 1998). Horticultural well-being is a broad 27(1), 8-11.
concept of using horticulture for human well-being Burlingame, A.W. (1959). Gardening brings new hope and health.
Horticulture 37 , 482.
including persons of all abilities, whether or not they Flagler, J.S. (1992). Horticultural therapy: Potentials for Master
are in a treatment setting. Horticultural therapy exists Gardeners. In D. Reif (Ed.), The role of horticulture in human well-
within this broad area of horticultural well-being when being and social development (pp. 178- 180). Portland, OR: Timber
Press.
the objective is limited to the people who need medical
Kafami, D. (1997). Maryland inmates become Master Gardeners.
or other health-care involvement because of
HortTechnology 7(4), 342.
impairment, disability, or handicap. ThisKaplan,
effortR. & S.to
Kaplan. (1989). The experience of nature: A psycholog-
distinguish the use of horticulture with ical
various
perspective. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Larson, J. (1997). Master Gardeners and Horticultural Therapy.
populations or for various purposes clearly hasHortTechnology
helped 7(4), 344.
advance both professions in Japan. This effort has(1900). Principles of education for the feeble minded.
Lawrence, G.M.
helped define the training and experience for both
Journal of Psycho- Aesthenics 4(3), 100-108. As cited in S. Simson
& M. Straus (Eds.), Horticulture as therapy: Principles and
professions - for someone wanting to practice
practice . Binghamton, New York: The Haworth Press.
horticultural well-being as well as someone wanting to
Lewis, C. (1976). The evolution of horticultural therapy in the United
practice horticultural therapy. It also has aided in
States. Presented at the Fourth annual meeting of the National
Council
explaining it to health-care administrators and city for Therapy and Rehabilitation through Horticulture.
September 6, Philadelphia, PA.
officials who are interested in adopting programs for
Lewis, C. (1996). Green nature/Human nature: The meaning of plants in
their patients or constituents, respectively. In the U.S.,
our lives. Chicago, IL: University of Illinois Press.
the use of the terms human issues in horticulture
Marshall, A.S.,(1997). Master Gardeners and the greening of a children s
people-plant interaction, and people-plant hospital. HortTechnology 7(4), 340.
Matsuo, E. (1998). What is "horticultural well-being" - in relation to
relationships, mainly by academicians, is, in part, an "horticultural therapy"? In M.D. Burchett, J. Tarran, & R. Wood
effort to make this distinction. (Eds.), Towards a new millennium in people-plant relationships
(pp. 174-1 80). Sydney, Australia: University of Technology Printing
Services.
The profession of therapeutic recreation emerged
from two philosophical positions similar to thatMcDonald,
in J. (1995). A comparative study of the horticultural therapy
professions in the United Kingdom and the United States of
horticultural therapy yet has succeeded in being anAmerica. Master's thesis: University of Reading, England.
important component of medical treatment. The other
Menninger, C.F. (1942). Philosophy about gardening. Bui Menninger
professions have also succeeded in establishing Clinic 6(3), 66.
themselves in the health care arena. A clear Migura, M., Whittlesey, L.A. & Zajicek, J.M. (1996). Effects of the
Master Gardener Program on the self-development of female
understanding of what each of these allied therapies is prison camp. In P. Williams & J. Zajicek (Eds.),
inmates of a federal
and the requirements for being a practitioner
People-plantare
interactions in urban areas: Proceedings of a research
and education symposium (pp.72-76). College Station, TX:
certainly components of their firm establishment as a
Department of Horticultural Sciences, Texas A&M University.
profession. The profession of horticultural
NBCOTtherapy
(2002). National Board for Certification in Occupational
must do the same if it also wants to beTherapy,
firmly Inc. http://www.nbcot.org. Viewed July 10, 2002.
established as a profession. NCTRC (2002). National Council for Therapeutic Recreation
Certification, http://www.nctrc.org. Viewed July 1, 2002.
NCTRH (1981). National Council for Therapy and Rehabilitation
through Horticulture Newsletter. Horticultural therapy education.
8(1): 2.
NTRS (2002). National Therapeutic Recreation Society.
http://www.nrpa.org. Viewed July 11, 2002.
£
£ H "3
H- Ē
- 3 (L>
"3n ®
7 (TtS?
Ih -j;
3" C
)U <ť (D 3 ÎTx
(L> «3 t n
5 ^T«
ij 7 ä
"ì£ (T
8 H 3« "3 - - -g 3 t (L> n 7 (Tt Ih )U I <ť (D fc >. o Id 3 £ ÎT
<£2c -g feb^ 3 £ fi "g | ¿ § 3 53
fi
š«p2
š«p2
•g 2 2 >§§ o
3 1? «^2 2><■
•£2>><■ 5où
«52où 25 .2
ISS2.2 Iū SS.2-5-5.2
SM > öd
g 2 22 := 2ca 75
« «:=9- < fi
c.5<ť 2 := 2 8 := 2'
E
0
73
3
333 êû.û.oo22 H
Ö O,
H O,
Ü °-
ŪU ü Ü
w swŪü
ü ^S g.
w S w f-s
CX u ü a
O g.
O CX O. o
O rr Ö P
O o O 3 O§ S) rr o
U < a. cd <x>cN < o* o¿ < < rt < r- < < O -O m o. >;
l'
<ł> ¿00 . <L> .5 <»- 1
i "8 1-S§ . «tí5§ « ° >;
o
"S
-oofc
<}■> to
to ^ c u ^ g s 5c
a 3u ^ t:
c , Jd -s s «
2cd.2wo 2 q¡ S
s 'S
.Q-^'Sb
0) ^ Oh <}■> to
O qj 'H h Ê.SÊ'H
E tť Í3Q^Oc« g
O 1-2^2« Oh
sc 5 a c
r O cd r^o
0) t S S c o ^ M 2 g.« -e qj jg _ 3 -Łtiffl-S.
•- e e eS"'ï- 2>.cl*|''-'^"(-)??o _ g 5 c g c sSogocg^-o S - 2 cd
•- «« eo ojo ee g« 'H
•2-s e oc«
oc« «-fiShc^ocS0
- « I, S ¿wgo «q 5
j= è« ^'-P
© gj=Öfc22 S-oO^'-5°S ^ «.2 c 73
.2 « Z, ^ e# -a
8
8 « o
2¡
>M
• o. O
- -or<ü_
aj bü
r~
»-h § črt
^-> (D
- (uä»-c/5
ûû bû•c •-
c o¿>« bü
fl)
u 'S
>M 3
1
Jgobû "O ^ £ .2 ^ -o o ^ -O O cg §
Oí -Sil C £ ° £ o o o £ 3 S £ £ £ .2 >»
&
ķiķi
¿ M£ o S3cS.2c<u
.t¡J=ö-c3 cl o ^ ^ cl
tTî J=ö-c3 mmc§ rü
¿ rü£«u^ So ^oo«j
S 2
D
ĒO
ĒO
-fi
*n C
_ rjj*n
»0550 o ^ > o o o
»0550 o oo
o
C ^ o o
i
£ Är-
O _^ h C (N
"I £ m
en °° O
«4-1
0
Ä C ir> C/3
- 8 g _S so fl S" ^0 *-^13 w ! s
-55S§cgf
^ "S T
^ " 3g -§»
cd cd"ti
-¿.i-*-j
"ti -o-o
.m f-,
so 2.1«.m4_>4_>
s> 1 3s>S"3S^siissí^Jž«
_c ^ On ^ On .£2^^ *-^13
.£2 O s-O^s-O^ OÇÇ■*-
■*- » »w v.,
v., àS"
S" -*->
a
--o 3*^T-ȣ
^ " T O g 3£ Uj<SžH cd S^.S^^CcduJo
Q. 'u ^ S -*-j Ż i0 f-, A .m ^ 4_>
^ O s> ^o">
_c ^Ö On O s- ^ sÇ v., g
•H 3*^T-»£ .2 u § fi £< SžH §"o^o..5i^tŁ&SJ3Oh Q. 'u
šo-go u fi g ll'Sfeol^c^l 3S-8<|í|Í85-g^t: ¿ 13
fi
.2
OOucdh^^-S.S^y-Q
o S ucdh^^-S.S^y-Q à< ^<Do^n<DfVcd<L>y
(uv-Lh^»-hÇ2P(dOc •§ à|
<u j-3F-
S Id-s£.§o^<Do^n<DfVcd<L>y
;ï
t; ^ ;ï cd o oo Z •§
z <5 žg cd
••§ £
^ gr^.2
'i I IĒęs3 ;ï I «S ••§ 'I#o I i S à "8
<»c<DX7t<L>x:Çcc/55 <u c^H'PoHxìOco^^ccoaN'TT'^'T'ciDS^so
C(ü>cdD^7_(UW,= -CcflX5í5-Ü^Cx:2^2^
t; cd z cd *So
t/3
1
o ^ o
S « a fi c
s^
c«la
« Sti O
a 5
^
o
^
0
"s ^ S la « Ä ^ tš ^ >>
Oí
go. ¿ o. « a « a. 'S
.s s*-
£ c«4> « u « 9> «
t-
*-a¿
fc-fc-
^ oí o
'S1- Su
o a> 1
o -fi ^ h ja o v 3 ja -e u
o
XH C HPÈ ŽH OH
z
e2