Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Two-Frequency Spin Oscillation System
A Two-Frequency Spin Oscillation System
Russian Text © The Author(s), 2020, published in Giroskopiya i Navigatsiya, 2020, No. 1, pp. 19–30.
Abstract—The features of a feedback loop in a quantum sensor with a two-frequency spin oscillator are dis-
cussed. Engineering solutions that ensure stable two-frequency oscillation and, in particular, the use of auto-
matic gain control units and all-pass filters are considered. The results of experimental studies of oscillation
modes conducted on a quantum sensor breadboard are presented for stationary and rotating bases.
115
116 BEZMEN et al.
Coils
Magnetic
shield
Bracket
with electronic
modules
ments and laser emitters as well as photodetector —power conditioning to prevent electronic noise
boards relative to each other with the required accu- or voltage surges at the input from reaching the load;
racy; —formation of signals of different reference fre-
—an electronics board with drivers for control of quencies;
the laser emitters, connectors, and communication —processing of signals from photodetectors and
lines for transmitting signals from photodetectors to generation of control signals for laser emitters and
the electronics module and receiving control signals coils.
from the electronics module for coils, heating ele-
ments, and laser emitters.
THE STRUCTURE OF THE QUANTUM
The division into two parts is explained by different SENSOR BUILT AROUND THE CONCEPT
environmental temperature requirements for the vapor OF A SPIN OSCILLATOR
cell and laser emitters of the pumping and detection
light. For a vapor cell, it must be 80°С, for laser emit- The principle of operation of the oscillator using
ters, it should not exceed 40°С. A double-loop ther- the effects of nuclear magnetic resonance in xenon
mal stabilization system is used to ensure the tempera- isotopes and electron paramagnetic resonance in
ture in each zone. cesium atoms is illustrated by the schematic in Fig. 2.
In this oscillator, electronic cesium spins oriented by
The electronics unit of the spin oscillator has a circularly polarized resonant pumping light transfer
modular structure. It consists of modules responsible their polarization to xenon nuclei through spin-
for the following tasks: exchange interaction, resulting in the formation of a
macroscopic magnetization vector M. The precession
—control of the oscillator temperature stabilization frequency of vector M (magnetization vector of xenon
systems; nuclear spin) is determined by the strength of constant
—convert electric current from an external source magnetic field B0 and the magnitude of the gyromag-
to the correct voltage, current, and frequency to power netic ratio of the corresponding isotope. The preces-
all modules of the electronics unit; sion rate of vector М is detected by the optical cesium
magnetometer, for the realization of which the elec- oscillator to its input. The difference between the sys-
tron paramagnetic resonance in cesium is excited by a tems is as follows:
strong longitudinal resonant field BAC. In this case, the —the first self-oscillation system is the one whose
transverse component of vector М is transformed into operation is based on macroscopic precession of 129Xe
amplitude modulation of the rapidly precessing trans- isotope nuclear spins. Consequently, it generates a sig-
verse component of cesium magnetization. nal at a frequency close to the frequency of the 129Xe
The transverse magnetization of cesium is detected free precession;
by measuring the Faraday rotation of the polarization —the second self-oscillation system is built in a
of a linearly polarized detection light beam, whose fre- similar way. It generates a signal at a frequency close to
quency is detuned from the optical resonance of that of the 131Xe free precession.
cesium to an optimal value, which is of the same order
as the width of the atomic optical absorption line. The The self-oscillation systems considered in this
rotation of the polarization plane is detected using a paper operate in the soft mode, characterized by
balanced circuit of two photodetectors and a polariz- unconditional quick setting of the stationary mode
ing beam splitter. upon the system activation. In the soft mode, the gain
factors change smoothly in the feedback loops,
Two signals with the frequencies corresponding to whereas in the hard mode, the variation is stepwise
the precession of two xenon isotopes, 129Xe and 131Xe, [25, 26]. The implementation of the hard mode is not
are extracted from the signal of the photodetectors. advisable since setting of self-oscillation requires addi-
These signals are used to form a resonant alternating tional conditions: either a large value of the feedback
driving magnetic field В1Xe, which determines the coefficient or an additional external impact.
phases of the macroscopic precession of xenon isotope The implementation of the two-frequency oscilla-
nuclear spins. The phase difference between the sig- tion system is conditioned by the fact that the gyro-
nals at the precession frequency of one of the xenon
isotopes and the reference signal, stable in frequency magnetic ratios of 129Xe and 131Xe isotopes have oppo-
and phase, carries information about the rotation of site signs, which opens up the possibility of creating a
the oscillator around the Z axis. balanced circuit in the future, the one that will sup-
press the effect of residual fluctuations of the constant
Figure 2 also shows the structure of the dual-fre- magnetic field B0.
quency oscillation system. Signals from two photode-
tectors, adjusted to receive two orthogonal compo-
nents of linearly polarized light of the detection chan- 4. ELEMENTS OF THE DUAL-FREQUENCY
nel, transmitted through a vapor cell, are fed to the OSCILLATION SYSTEM
input of the system [22–24]. The difference signal of The circuit for subtraction of signals SPD1 and SPD2
two photodiodes is fed to the inputs of two lock-in
amplifiers, LA1 and LA2, with reference harmonic taken from the photodetectors of the detection chan-
nel is intended to reduce the noise level when deter-
signals at a frequency of 133Cs resonance field BAC [12], mining the rotation angle of the detection light linear
which have a 90° phase shift relative to each other. At polarization plane transmitted through a vapor cell. In
the outputs of the lock-in amplifiers, the summed sig- this case, the noise variance of the photodiode signals
nals of xenon isotope precessions are extracted (in the can be represented as follows:
orthogonal transverse axes X and Y of the sensing ele-
ment). Individual signals of 129Xe and 131Xe isotope σ2 = σ12 + σ22 + σ32,
precessions in the axes X and Y are extracted after ana-
log-to-digital conversion via digital band-pass filters where σ1 is the value characterizing the shot noise of
BPF1, BPF2, BPF3, and BPF4. The extracted preces- the photocurrent in the 1 Hz band;
sion signals along the Y axis are fed to the input of the σ2 is the value characterizing the light intensity noise
circular shift buffers SB1 and SB2, whose output sig- of the detection channel at the frequency of the 133Cs
nals are shifted relative to the input signals by a certain resonant field;
value of the microcontroller cycles, which allows the σ3 is the value characterizing the additional intensity
signal phase shift to be controlled, but with low reso-
noise resulting from the conversion of the frequency
lution. All-pass filters APF1 and APF2 are used to
noise.
more precisely adjust the phase shift. The signals
received at the outputs of the all-pass filters are ampli- Using a balanced circuit that subtracts signals from
fied to the required value in the automatic gain control two photodetectors allows the noise with components
units AGC1 and AGC2, summed with each other and σ2, σ3 to be suppressed by several orders of magnitude.
fed to coil X to form the field B1Xe [12]. The resulting The lock-in amplifiers LA1, LA2 are used to isolate
system can be represented as two self-oscillation sys- the summed signals of xenon isotope precessions. For
tems that generate harmonic signals supported owing high-quality operation of the oscillator, the signal-to-
to transmitting a part of the generated signal through noise ratio at the LA1 and LA2 outputs must be at least
the positive feedback loop from the output of the 125 dB. This requirement makes it impossible to
Z Cs
M
Xe
B1Xe
PBS
PD1
Detection light
SPD1
B1Xe: Coli X PD2
B0 BAC
SPD2
Pumping light
SPD1
BPF2 S131XeX: 131Xe(X) precession
FCs ϕ = 90°
The rotation of the
– polarization plane
SPD2
Fig. 2. Schematic of a dual-frequency oscillation system. Xe—xenon isotopes; Cs—cesium vapor; B0 —constant magnetic field
with the Z-axis directed along it; BAC—longitudinal alternating field at the precession frequency of cesium atoms; M—macro-
scopic magnetic moment of a xenon atom ensemble; B1Xe—driving magnetic field generated by coil X at the precession frequency
of magnetic moment M; PBS—polarizing beam-splitting cube; PD—photodiodes; LA—ock-in amplifier; BPF—band-pass fil-
ters; SB—circular shift buffers; APF—all-pass filters; AGC—automatic gain control units.
440
420
340
200
280
360
400
220
260
300
320
100
140
160
380
120
180
240
60
20
40
80
Fig. 5. Signals of 131Xe oscillation along 131Xe oscillation signals in the transverse axes of the sensing element (precession of 131Xe
(X)—plot 1; precession of 131Xe (Y)—plot 2) processed with the use of lock-in amplifiers with the reference frequency equal to
the frequency of the resonance field of the 131Xe xenon isotope (10 readings along the abscissa axis are equal to 1 s). Feedback
opens at 180.
1080
1000
1020
1040
1060
1200
1440
1400
1480
1560
1140
1220
1240
1260
1280
1420
1460
1500
1520
1580
1380
1540
1300
1320
1360
1340
1100
1160
1120
1180
Fig. 6. Signals of 131Xe oscillation along in the transverse axes of the sensing element with an incorrectly chosen phase (precession
of 131Xe (X)—plot 1; precession of 131Xe (Y)—plot 2) processed with the use of lock-in amplifiers with the reference frequency
equal to the frequency of the resonance field of the 131Xe isotope (10 readings along the abscissa axis are equal to 1 s). Feedback
opens at 1440.
able oscillation at the filter cutoff frequency, such that tion signal during the base rotation with angular rates
differs from the Larmor precession frequency by less from –90 to 90°/s) and Fig. 9 (129Xe isotope oscillation
than 0.1 Hz, an exponential attenuation of signals will signal during the base rotation with angular rates from
show itself upon the opening of the feedback loop. 50 to –50°/s).
This attenuation is due to the relaxation of the macro-
scopic magnetic moment of xenon isotopes, which,
before opening, precessed at the filter cutoff fre- 6. CONCLUSIONS
quency, and after opening, at the Larmor frequency.
To confirm the occurrence of spin oscillation at the The paper describes the structure and construction
Larmor frequency, it is necessary to check the opera- of a two-frequency spin oscillator as well as its main
tion of this system on a rotating base because operation elements and units. Focus is made on the implemen-
in this mode will cause a shift in the generated fre- tation of the feedback loop that provides stable two-
quencies by a value equal to the angular rate of the base frequency oscillation. The experimental results
rotation. The operation of the oscillation system on a obtained on the spin oscillator breadboard on station-
rotating base is shown in Fig. 8 (129Xe isotope oscilla- ary and rotating bases are discussed. Their analysis has
AA
Uin Uout
Eagj
D
~ F
~
Fig. 7. A diagram of automatic gain control (AGC): Uin and Uout—input and output signals, respectively; AA— adjustable ampli-
fier; D—AGC detector; F—AGC filter; Eadj—adjustment signal obtained by detecting the input signal.
Mult 118 sx
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0
–0.05
–0.10
–0.15
–0.20
–0.25
–0.30
12150
12200
12250
12300
12350
12400
12450
12500
12550
12600
12650
12700
12750
12800
12850
12900
13000
13050
13100
13150
13200
13250
Fig. 8. Signals of 129Xe oscillation along the transverse axis of the sensor processed with the use of a lock-in amplifier with the
reference frequency equal to the frequency of the resonance field of the 129Xe isotope during rotation with angular rates from‒90
to 90°/s (10 readings along the abscissa axis equal to 1 s).
Mult 118 sx
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0
–0.05
–0.10
–0.15
–0.20
–0.25
–0.30
–0.35
10800
10900
10750
10950
10850
11850
11000
11050
11650
11250
11400
11600
11200
11300
11550
11800
11350
11700
11500
11100
11150
11750
Fig. 9. Signals of 131Xe oscillation along the transverse axis of the sensor processed using a lock-in amplifier with the reference
frequency equal to the resonance field frequency of the 131Xe xenon isotope during rotation with angular rates from 50 to –50°/s
(10 readings along the abscissa axis equal to 1 s).
confirmed that the technical solutions implemented in 3. Zhivun, E. et al., Dual-axis pi-pulse spin-exchange re-
this work are correct. laxation-free magnetometer, Physical Review Applied,
18 Mar 2019, 11(3).
4. Larsen, M. and Bulatowicz, M. Nuclear magnetic res-
REFERENCES onance gyroscope: for DARPA’s micro-technology for
1. Budker, D. and Romalis, M., Optical Magnetometry, positioning, navigation and timing program, Proc.
Nature Phys., 2007, 3(4), pp. 227–234. IEEE Int. Frequency Control Symposium, 2012, pp. 1–5.
2. Aleksandrov, E.B., and Vershovskii, A.K., Modern ra- 5. Feng, D., Review of quantum navigation, IOP Conf. Se-
dio-optical methods in quantum magnetometry, Us- ries: Earth and Environmental Science, 2019, vol. 237,
pekhi Fizicheskikh Nauk, 2009, 52.6, pp. 573–601. pp. 032027.
6. Vershovskii, A.K. and Shevchnko, A.N., Nuclear mag- of gas mixtures in the cells of a quantum rotation sensor,
netic resonance gyroscope: principle of operation, his- Nauchnoe priborostroyenie, 2018. vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 62–
tory, prospects, 17 konferentsiya molodykh uchenykh 68.
“Navigatsiya i upravlenie dvizheniem” (17th Conference 19. Shevchenko, A.N. and Zakharova, E.A., Studying the
of Young Scientists Navigation and Motion Control), dependence of resonance quality on the distribution of
Navigatsiya i upravlenie dvizheniem, Materialy 17 kon- cesium in a cell of a quantum rotation sensor, Nauchno-
ferentsii molodykh uchenykh, 2015, pp. 19–28. tekhnicheskii vestnik informatsionnykh tekhnologii, me-
7. Liu, Y., Shi, M., and Wang, X., Progress on atomic gy- khaniki i optiki, 2019. vol. 19, no. 4, pp. 567–573.
roscope, 2017, 24th Saint Petersburg International Con- 20. Vershovskii, A.K. et al., Influence of polarization char-
ference on Integrated Navigation Systems 2017, pp. 1–7. acteristics of test light on an optically detectable mag-
8. Yoshimi, A. et al. Development of NMOR magnetom- netic resonance signal in magnetometric and gyroscop-
eter for spin-maser EDM experiment, Physics Procedia, ic quantum sensors, Pis’ma v Zhurnal tekhnicheskoi
2011, vol. 17, pp. 245–250. fiziki (Letters in the Journal of Technical Physics),
9. Rosenberry, M.A. and Chupp, T.E., Atomic electric 2019, vol. 45, no. 20, pp. 3–6.
dipole moment measurement using spin exchange 21. Maleev, N.A., Blokhin, S.A., Bobrov, M.V., Kuzmen-
pumped masers of 129Xe and 3He, Phys. Rev. Lett., 2001, kov, A.G., Kulagina, M.M., and Ustinov, V.M., Laser
86, pp. 22–25. source for a compact gyroscope based on the NMR ef-
10. Walker, T.G. and Larsen, M.S., Spin-exchange- fect, Giroskopiya i navigatsiya, 2018, vol. 26, no. 1,
pumped NMR gyros, Advances in Atomic, Molecular, pp. 81–92.
and Optical Physics, 2016, vol. 65, pp. 377–405.
22. Popov, E.N. et al., Behavior of signal from optical cir-
11. Wang, S.G. et al., Progress on Novel Atomic Magne- cuit of quantum rotation sensor based on nuclear mag-
tometer and Gyroscope Based on Self-sustaining of netic resonance, Gyroscopy and Navigation, 2018, vol. 9,
Electron Spins, China Satellite Navigation Conference, no. 3, pp. 183–190.
Springer, Singapore, 2017, pp. 535–542.
23. Popov, E.N. et al. The frequency shifts of the nuclear
12. Vershovskii, A.K., Litmanovich, Yu.A., Pazgalev, A.S., magnetic momenta Larmor precession in the mixture
and Peshekhonov, V.G., Nuclear Magnetic Resonance of two noble gases, Applied Magnetic Resonance, 2017,
Gyro: Ultimate Parameters, Gyroscopy and Navigation, vol. 48, no. 8, pp. 761–770.
2018, vol. 9, pp. 162–176.
13. Jiang, M. et al. Floquet-state Maser under Real-time 24. Popov, E.N. et al. Frequency line of nuclear magnetic
Quantum Feedback Control, arXiv preprint resonance in quantum rotation sensor: Negative effect
arXiv:1901.00970, 2019. of detection circuit, Gyroscopy and Navigation, 2017,
vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 91–96.
14. Sato, T. et al., Development of co-located 129Xe and
131Xe nuclear spin masers with external feedback 25. Belov, L. et al., Formirovanie kolebanii i signalov (For-
scheme, Physics Letters A., 2018, vol. 382, no. 8, mation of oscillations and signals), 2nd ed., Textbook
pp. 588–594. for undergraduate and graduate courses, Litres, 2018.
15. Inoue T. et al., Frequency characteristics of nuclear 26. Abubakirov, E.B. and Konyushkov, A.P., On soft and
spin oscillator with an artificial feedback toward search hard oscillation regimes in a backward wave lamp, Iz-
for 129Xe atomic electric dipole moment, The European vestiya VUZov, Radiofizika, 2010, vol. 53, pp. 645–651.
Physical Journal D., 2016, vol. 70, no. 6, pp. 129. 27. Belov, L.A., Bogachev, V.M., and Blagoveshchenskii, M.V.,
16. Kulachenkov, N.K., Shevchenko, A.N., and Bezmen G.V., Ustroistva generirovaniya i formirovaniya radiosignalov (Devic-
Stdying magnetic shields using modern design methods, 18 es for Generation and Formation Radio Signals), A textbook
konferentsiya molodykh uchenykh “Navigatsiya i upravlenie for high schools, Moscow: Radio i svyaz’, 1994.
dvizheniem” (18th Conference of Young Scientists “Naviga- 28. Medichenko, M.P. and Litvinov, V.P., Radiotekhnich-
tion and Motion Control), Navigatsiya i upravlenie dvizhe- eskiye tsepi i signaly (Radio Engineering Circuits and
niem, Materialy 17 konferentsii molodykh uchenykh, 2016, Signals), A training manual, Moscow: MGOU, 2011
pp. 678–682.
17. Shevchenko, A.N. and Zakharova E.A., Methods of 29. Küpfmüller, K., Über die Dynamik der selbsttätigen
forming requirements for the magnetic field gradient in Verstärkungsregler, Elektrische Nachrichtentechnik,
determining the metrological characteristics of the nu- 1928, vol. 5, no. 11, pp. 459–467.
clear magnetic gyroscope cells, Al’manakh nauchnykh 30. Plaksienko, V.S. and Plaksienko, N.E., Ustroistva priie-
rabot molodykh uchenykh universiteta ITMO (Almanac ma i obrabotki signalov (Devices for Receiving and pro-
of Scientific Works of Young Scientists of ITMO Uni- cessing signals), Textbook, Part 3, Taganrog: TRTU.
versity). XLVII Scientific and Educational Conference 2001
of ITMO University, 2018, pp. 176–179. 31. Fomin, N.N. et al., Radiopriemnye ustroystva (Radio
18. Shevchenko, A.N., Kuz’min, A.G., and Titov Yu.A., receiving devices) Textbook for High Schools, 3rd edi-
Mass spectrometric measurement of the composition tion, Moscow: Goryachaya liniya, Telekom, 2007. c.