Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Wall Street Journal-231102
The Wall Street Journal-231102
The Wall Street Journal-231102
* * * * * THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 2, 2023 ~ VOL. CCLXXXII NO. 105 WSJ.com HHHH $5.00
DJIA 33274.58 À 221.71 0.67% NASDAQ 13061.47 À 1.6% STOXX 600 436.57 À 0.7% 10-YR. TREAS. À 20/32 , yield 4.790% OIL $80.44 g $0.58 GOLD $1,978.80 g $6.40 EURO $1.0570 YEN 150.96
BY NICK TIMIRAOS
Disney said it expects to
pay Comcast’s NBCUniversal
WASHINGTON—Federal
at least $8.61 billion for its
Reserve Chair Jerome Powell
stake in Hulu, as the compa-
hinted the central bank might
nies continue complex nego-
be done raising interest rates
tiations over the future of the
for now but was careful not
streaming-video service. B1
to rule out another increase
Toyota gave most of its U.S. after officials extended a
auto-factory workers a 9% pay pause in hikes.
bump and shortened the time Officials voted unanimously
it takes to reach maximum on Wednesday to leave rates
pay, a sign that gains the UAW unchanged at a 22-year high.
made in Detroit are rippling RELIEF: People walk through a gate to enter the Rafah border crossing to Egypt in southern Gaza Strip on Wednesday, as “The committee is proceeding
through the auto industry. B1 foreign nationals and wounded Palestinians were allowed to leave in a diplomatic breakthrough. A8 carefully,” Powell said during
a news conference in which he
Prosecutors and defense
said nothing to shift the mar-
matic breakthrough. A8 national cricket team, the Amazon Warriors, of oil off the Guyanese coast. Some oil execu-
A Cornell University stu- is getting a new stadium that begins con- tives say they’ve never seen a success of that
dent was arrested after al- struction next spring. scale in their careers and won’t again see one
legedly threatening to kill Money is pouring into Guyana, which is like it.
Jewish students, the latest quickly being transformed from one of the Flights to Georgetown now teem with for-
in a surge of antisemitic epi- poorest countries in the Western Hemisphere eign oil-field workers looking to capitalize on
sodes since the Israel- into the world’s fastest-growing economy, ac- the find. Last week, rival Chevron bought into
Hamas war began. A3 AT LONG LAST: Texas beat the Arizona Diamondbacks, 5-0, to cording to the International Monetary Fund. the bonanza, agreeing to pay $53 billion in
capture its first championship since the franchise’s start in The economic makeover is succinctly ex- stock to buy Hess, primarily to acquire Hess’s
Rep. George Santos sur-
1961. Bruce Bochy won his fourth title as a manager. A14 plained by the sponsor named on the cricket nearly one-third stake in the Guyana project.
vived an effort in the House
team’s jersey: Exxon Mobil, the oil giant based Please turn to page A10
to expel him while the New
York Republican faces fed-
eral fraud charges related to
These Moms ‘Ozempic Effect’ Makes
No.1
his 2022 campaign. A4
A federal judge in Florida
Embrace
signaled that she is open to
delaying Trump’s criminal trial
over his handling of classified
The Mess
Wall Street Exuberant
documents set for May. A4
Teachers in Portland, Ore., i i i BY CHARLEY GRANT sengers. References to GLP
AND DAVID WAINER drugs have shot higher on
went on strike over compen-
sation, class size and other Influencers share company earnings calls over
issues, prompting the dis- The U.S. leads developed the past 12 months, according
practical tips; nations when it comes to obe- to Factiva.
in AI, Data
trict to close school for more
than 45,000 students. A3 sity. Those paying close atten- The reaction on Wall Street
Walmart budget tion to the stock market and has been extreme, creating
Cities in China are allowing recent corporate earnings opportunities for cooler
real-estate developers to cut
prices on new homes to revive
sales and are being resisted by
BY ALLIE JONES
U.S. NEWS
CAPITAL ACCOUNT | By Greg Ip
I
thanks to indefatigable con- dichotomy there. 100 suspect a lot of pessimism
sumers. By contrast, the University is “referred pain.” Just as
Not only has economic of Michigan sentiment index –10 one part of your body can
output made up ground lost is at recession-like levels. It hurt because of injury to an-
during the pandemic, it’s also appears to be more sensitive other, pessimism about the
above where it would have to inflation, in part because it 80 –20 economy may reflect dissatis-
been had the pandemic not asks people if they are finan- faction with the country as a
happened, judging by a Con- cially worse off, and recently whole. There is a lot to be dis-
gressional Budget Office pro- 40% of those feeling worse –30 GDP* satisfied about: intensifying
jection in early 2020. off blame inflation. Payrolls political and cultural conflict
60
The same goes for the job But can inflation be the and intolerance, the pan-
–40 Median
market. Unemployment at 3.8% whole story? Since peaking at weekly wage*
demic, the border, mass
is marginally above where it 9.1% in June last year, the shootings, crime, Ukraine and
Consumer
was in January 2020. The consumer-price index has sentiment
now the Middle East.
–50
share of the population 15 to fallen to 3.7%. Some gauges 40 It’s hard to explain atti-
64 with jobs topped a prepan- put underlying inflation at 5% 10 15 20 25 2020 '23 tudes otherwise. Just 37% ap-
demic peak in August. around 3%, and the Federal MISERY INDEX (unemployment rate + inflation) prove of Biden’s handling of
So why are Americans so Reserve thinks it is headed *Adjusted for inflation Note: Median wages were elevated early in pandemic due to declines in low-wage jobs.
the economy in the Journal
gloomy? Confidence readings gradually to 2%. Yet senti- Sources: University of Michigan (consumer sentiment); Commerce Dept. (GDP); Labor Dept via Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (unemployment, survey. Yet just 39% approve
are depressed. Some 69% of ment is up only moderately inflation, payrolls, median wage) of his handling of Social Se-
respondents to a Wall Street since inflation began falling. curity and Medicare, which is
Journal survey in August said than at the end of 2019. prices. Moreover, while the formerly part of Kellogg, said odd since he has literally
T
the country is headed in the he puzzle deepens Workers are getting more Fed targets inflation—the in September. done nothing to either.
wrong direction. President when I plot the Michi- time off and more flexibility. rate at which the level of Yet sticker shock doesn’t Only 45% approve of Bi-
Biden’s approval ratings are gan index since 1978 Federal pandemic relief prices rises—consumers also seem severe enough to ex- den’s handling of infrastruc-
mired around or below 40%, against the “misery index”— means household finances are care about the absolute level plain the profound dissatis- ture, and 42% of how he’s
and approval for his handling the simple sum of inflation stronger, even now, than be- of prices and are bothered faction. bringing back manufacturing
of the economy is even lower. and the unemployment rate. fore the pandemic. Mean- they remain so much higher. No doubt, polarization jobs. This is weird for a presi-
A popular explanation for Based on historic correla- while, high housing and stock The average Starbucks cof- plays a part. Democrats and dent who signed popular leg-
this dichotomy is that good tions, sentiment has been prices lifted the median fee has gone from under $3 Republicans think the econ- islation boosting infrastruc-
feelings about jobs are more more depressed this year household’s wealth after infla- at the start of the pandemic omy is great when their party ture and manufacturing.
than offset by high inflation. than you would expect given tion by 37% between 2019 and to $3.63 in the second quar- controls the White House and The good news for Biden,
There is a lot of evidence for the level of economic misery. 2022, the largest in the his- ter, according to data firm terrible when the other party if you want to call it that, is
this, but it’s still not an en- True, for a long time tory of the Fed’s survey. Numerator. Grocery prices does. Still, you’d expect Dem- that people may not be as up-
tirely satisfying answer. wages were lagging behind Part of the problem is that have stopped going up, ocrats and Republicans to set about the economy as
There are two longstand- inflation, but median weekly in inflationary periods, both but “right now, it is still a lit- balance each other out. Yet they tell pollsters. The bad
ing surveys of consumer con- wages are slightly higher prices and wages rise, but tle bit of sticker shock,” Steve the mood has worsened. The news is, they’re pretty upset
fidence. The index produced now, adjusted for inflation, people dwell more on the Cahillane, CEO of Kellanova, share of survey respondents about everything else.
Skips Rise 5
would take for the central
bank to raise rates at its next
meeting, Dec. 12-13. Pressed
picked up, defying expecta-
tions of an imminent slow-
down.
necks and shortages of goods,
freight shipping and workers.
Powell said those supply-
In Rates 4
over whether the Fed had
raised rates to a level that
would be sufficient to bring
Second, inflation continued
cooling. Core inflation, which
excludes volatile food and en-
side improvements could al-
low inflation to continue to
fall even if economic growth is
3 down inflation, he said, ergy prices and solid, suggest-
Continued from Page One “We’re not confident that we which peaked ing that stron-
aren’t eager to hike again un- haven’t, but we’re not confi- at 5.6% last ger growth
less hotter-than-expected eco- 2 dent that we have.” year, hit a 2.8% Officials have isn’t necessar-
nomic data force their hand. The big questions for the annualized rate now skipped a ily a problem
Powell echoed that senti- Fed center on what officials over the April- for the Fed.
ment on Wednesday by re-
1
are looking to see in the econ- to-September rate hike for two “We feel like
peatedly highlighting how omy, and what it would take period, accord- we’re on a path
much inflation has fallen, 0 for them to conclude they are ing to the Com-
consecutive to make more
rather than emphasizing the 2000 '05 '10 '15 '20 moving in the right or wrong merce Depart- meetings. progress, and
economy’s recent strength. Note: Midpoint of range since 2008 Source: Federal Reserve via St. Louis Fed direction. A continued slow- ment. it’s essential
“It sounds like this is a Fed down in inflation could allow Third, finan- that we do,” he
that really doesn’t want to rates. They lifted their bench- portfolio, will eventually slow them to continue holding cial conditions said.
hike again,” said Mark Cabana, mark federal-funds rate then the economy, said Michael de rates steady, while any accel- have tightened amid a swift Some former Fed officials
head of U.S. rates strategy at to a range between 5.25% and Pass, global head of rates eration in price pressures run-up in longer-dated Trea- said there is little reason for
Bank of America. 5.5%. trading at Citadel Securities. could lead them to hike again. sury yields, leading borrowing the central bank to keep hik-
“If they wanted to hike Fed officials have now “They want to maintain a Swonk said she thought the costs to rise for households ing rates as long as inflation
again this year, Powell would skipped a rate hike for two hawkish façade while believ- Fed would hold rates steady and businesses. Increases in and wage growth continue to
have pointed much more to consecutive meetings, making ing deep down that they’ve next month because there longer-term interest rates slow gradually. In that case, “I
the risk that consumer spend- it the longest period without probably done enough,” he wouldn’t be enough economic boost costs for mortgages, don’t see a reason to make
ing would undo the progress an increase since they began said. data available to convince offi- auto loans and business debt, policy more restrictive,” said
we’ve seen on inflation,” said to lift rates from near zero in Officials have been trying cials to change course. “The all of which could slow eco- Eric Rosengren, former Boston
Diane Swonk, chief economist March 2022. Since then, they to balance two risks. They Fed’s pause does not equate to nomic growth. Fed president.
at KPMG. raised rates at the fastest don’t want to overdo rate a definitive end to rate hikes, The 30-year fixed-rate
Wednesday’s Fed decision pace in four decades to com- rises to avoid causing an un- but they just won’t have the mortgage has hovered closer
comes at a delicate time for fi- bat high inflation. necessarily severe downturn. information they need by De- to 8% in recent weeks at 23- Watch a Video
nancial markets because the Powell’s comments They also don’t want to allow cember” to raise rates, she year highs, for example, which Scan this code
10-year Treasury yield has Wednesday suggest he expects inflation to reaccelerate or to said. is chilling home purchases. to watch a
risen swiftly—by nearly 1 per- the Fed’s rate increases, along settle at levels well above Since their July rate in- That inflation eased as video on the
centage point—since July, with the continuing process of their 2% target. “Those risks crease, the economic outlook growth strengthened this Fed chair’s
when officials last raised shrinking its $7.9 trillion asset are closer to being in bal- has been buffeted by three summer highlights how the statement.
CORRECTIONS
Supply-Side Boom Gives Fed Breathing Room, for Now AMPLIFICATIONS
BY GREG IP nearly triple potential. Readers can alert The Wall Street
Journal to any errors in news
The possibility of higher articles by emailing
When spending and em- potential is why some Fed wsjcontact@wsj.com or by calling
ployment grow as quickly as officials are reluctant to 888-410-2667.
they have lately, it normally raise interest rates further
means inflation pressure is based on strong growth
building and the Federal Re- alone, at least so long as in- THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
serve may have to raise in- flation keeps falling. (USPS 664-880)
(Eastern Edition ISSN 0099-9660)
terest rates. Yet Mr. Powell cautioned (Central Edition ISSN 1092-0935)
But on Wednesday Fed against extrapolating the (Western Edition ISSN 0193-2241)
chair Jerome Powell sug- good news on supply, for Editorial and publication headquarters:
gested otherwise. Demand, good reason. Labor-force 1211 Avenue of the Americas,
New York, N.Y. 10036
he said, has indeed grown participation for 15- to 64-
rapidly, but so year-olds is back to its pre- Published daily except Sundays and
general legal holidays. Periodicals postage
ANALYSIS has supply. A pandemic level. Immigration paid at New York, N.Y., and other mailing
SUSAN WALSH/ASSOCIATED PRESS
U.S. NEWS
Antisemitic
Threats
As Unions Ride Wave, Tests Await
Spur Arrest BY DAVID HARRISON
At Cornell
Inflation
tiplying strikes and sizable crease in the last contract—as
gains in a robust labor market. Top pay rate for auto- well as more paid time off and
assembly workers
The agreements could em- more generous health benefits.
bolden other unions to take 50 10 “There’s a bit more confi-
BY ALYSSA LUKPAT aggressive approaches to con- dence in getting it based on
tract negotiations and fuel what other unions have done,”
A Cornell University student more strikes in coming 25 5
he said.
was arrested after allegedly months—as long as the econ- UAW President Shawn Fain
threatening to kill Jewish stu- omy stays strong. wants to keep labor’s momen-
dents, the latest in a surge of If growth cools and unem- tum going. The union will now
antisemitic episodes since the ployment rises, however, as 0 0 focus on organizing nonunion
Israel-Hamas war began. many economists forecast, 2000 ’05 ’10 ’15 ’20 ’25 1981 ’85 ’90 ’95 2000 ’05 ’10 ’15 ’20 plants, he said Sunday.
The student, 21-year-old workers’ momentum could *Includes estimated inflation adjustment in 2023 onward. Figures are for Ford Motor but are similar at other automakers. †Work stoppages include
But how long the strike
Patrick Dai, laid out in posts chill and tip the balance of both strikes and lockouts, data for 2023 through September. wave lasts could depend on
online how he planned to kill power back toward employers. Sources: UAW (pay); Labor Department (inflation, days) broader economic factors,
any Jewish student he saw on “If there’s a recession or if such as the labor market’s
campus, according to the U.S. the labor market gets loose July-through-September pe- workdays to labor disputes averted a strike. strength, said Matthew John-
attorney’s office in New York’s again, will that interfere?” riod from a year before, com- this year through September, Public support for unions son, an economist at Duke
Northern District. He said he said Susan Schurman, a pro- pared with a 4.4% gain for more than any full year since hit 71% last year, the highest University.
planned to carry out a mass fessor of labor studies at Rut- nonunion workers, according 2000. level since 1965, before slip- Many forecasters expect job
shooting in a dining hall that gers University, referring to to the Labor Department. Hollywood writers spent ping slightly this year, accord- and wage growth to slow and
serves mostly kosher meals. unions’ efforts. “History would One factor fueling unions’ five months on strike before ing to Gallup polls. President joblessness to rise over the
The Federal Bureau of In- predict that it would, but his- demands is that they have winning a new contract in Biden has been one of their coming year amid the highest
vestigation said it arrested Dai tory has not been a good pre- seen pay rise faster for chief September. In October, 75,000 most outspoken backers. interest rates in more than
on campus Tuesday. His public dictor in the last three years.” executive officers than for workers at healthcare giant The UAW strike “raises two decades.
defender, Gabrielle DiBella, Labor shortages since the workers since the pandemic, Kaiser Permanente won pay people’s expectations,” said “When that labor market
didn’t return a request for pandemic hit gave both union- said Kate Bronfenbrenner, a increases and higher staffing John Cakmakci, president of cools, it will probably make it
comment Wednesday. ized and nonunion workers professor at Cornell Univer- levels after walking off the job United Food and Commercial so that workers and unions
Prosecutors said Dai faces more leverage than they had sity’s School of Industrial and for three days, the industry’s Workers Local 951, which rep- have to temper what they
up to five years in prison and a in decades, driving big boosts Labor Relations. In the auto largest strike on record. resents 28,000 employees at bring to the bargaining table,”
$250,000 fine on a charge of in pay and benefits. industry, CEOs now make And in August, 330,000 Meijer grocery stores in Mich- Johnson said.
making a threat using inter- Union workers, however, about 300 times what rank- drivers and package sorters at
state communications. Dai, a have seen slower compensa- and-file workers make. United Parcel Service repre-
college junior from Pittsford, tion growth than their non- More than 300,000 union sented by the International
N.Y., made his first court ap- union counterparts because it members have walked off the Brotherhood of Teamsters rat-
© Verdura. All rights reserved.
pearance Wednesday afternoon takes time for multiyear union job so far this year, the most ified a new five-year contract
in Syracuse. contracts to come up for re- since 2019, according to the that would bring average pay
Jewish communities across newal. Wages and benefits for Labor Department. The U.S. and benefits for a full-time
the country have been feeling union workers rose 3.8% in the lost more than 11 million driver to $170,000. The deal
on edge over the rise in threats
and violence against them
since the war began last
month. College campuses have
been a hotbed for protests.
Teachers Strike in Portland, Ore.,
FBI Director Christopher
Wray told senators in a hear-
ing Tuesday that antisemitic
Closes Schools for 45,000 Pupils
threats in the U.S. were reach-
ing historic levels. He said the BY JENNIFER CALFAS
war has raised the threat of a
terrorist attack in the U.S. Teachers in Portland, Ore.,
Attorney General Merrick went on strike Wednesday,
Garland said the arrest at Cor- prompting the district to close
nell on Tuesday shows the Jus- school for more than 45,000
tice Department is “focusing students.
our efforts on confronting and The Portland Association of
disrupting illegal threats wher- Teachers said it was the first
ever they arise.” He directed time the union, representing
CLAIRE RUSH/ASSOCIATED PRESS
Scan here
To enjoy flying more, visit www.FlyVolato.com or call 844.399.8998
Terms and conditions apply. Programs and prices subject to change. All Volato flights are operated by our DOT/FAA-authorized air carrier subsidiary (G C Aviation, Inc., d/b/a Volato) under Part 135 or by an approved vendor air carrier.
.
U.S. NEWS
were absent. gally receiving unemployment son (R., La.) had suggested the Greene allege Tlaib has made
While Santos has been insurance benefits. Late last effort was premature, saying antisemitic remarks, while
widely shunned in Congress, month, he pleaded not guilty to Santos’s issues should first Rep. Becca Balint (D., Vt.) pro-
the effort led by a group of Re- a 23-count superseding indict- play out in the legal system. posed to censure Greene over
publicans had been seen as fac- ment. He is scheduled to go to Only two House lawmakers her own purported antisemitic
ing an uphill battle, with top trial in September 2024. since the Civil War have been comments and other inflam-
Republicans not signaling their “I’m fighting tooth and nail Rep. George Santos, seen Wednesday night after a bid to expel expelled. Rep. Michael Myers matory statements.
support and other members of to clear my name in front of him from the House failed, has said he will clear his name. (D., Pa.) was expelled in 1980 Lawmakers voted to table,
both parties lukewarm about the entire world,” Santos said after being convicted on or kill, the proposal to censure
expelling him. Expelling Santos on the House floor while de- late “the long-held premise that traction and a political liability charges of bribery and con- Tlaib in a 222-186 vote.
would cut into the Republicans’ fending his work in Congress one is presumed innocent until for the party. The five GOP spiracy in the Abscam sting, Twenty-three Republicans
narrow 221-212 majority, and and reminding colleagues of proven guilty” and would set a members behind the proposal in which Federal Bureau of In- sided with Democrats. The
some lawmakers have said any his conservative voting record. dangerous precedent. are Reps. Anthony D’Esposito, vestigation operatives posed resolution to censure Greene
such move should wait until af- No other lawmaker spoke in The resolution to expel San- Marc Molinaro, Nick LaLota, as Arab sheikhs seeking favors didn’t get a vote on Wednes-
ter his criminal case is resolved his defense. tos was led by five New York Brandon Williams and Mike from members of Congress. day night.
or the House Ethics Committee Santos said ejecting him Republicans who said Santos’s Lawler, all of whom are ex- Rep. James Traficant (D., —James Fanelli
has completed its probe. from Congress now would vio- legal troubles have been a dis- pected to have competitive Ohio) was expelled in 2002 af- contributed to this article.
.
Before investing, consider the funds’ ETFs trade like stocks, are subject to investment risk, fluctuate
in market value and may trade at prices above or below the ETFs
SPDR® is a registered trademark of Standard & Poor’s Financial
Services LLC (S&P), a division of S&P Global, and has been
investment objectives, risks, charges net asset value. ETF shares may not readily trade in all market
conditions. Brokerage commissions and ETF expenses will
licensed for use by State Street Corporation. No financial product
offered by State Street or its affiliates is sponsored, endorsed,
and expenses. To obtain a prospectus reduce returns. sold or promoted by S&P.
or summary prospectus, which contains This communication is not intended to be an investment ALPS Distributors, Inc. (fund distributor); State Street Global
recommendation or investment advice and should not be relied Advisors Funds Distributors, LLC (marketing agent).
this and other information, call upon as such.
1.866.787.2257 or visit www.ssga.com. SPDR® S&P 500® ETF Trust is a unit investment trust, listed on
Read it carefully. NYSE Arca, Inc.
U.S. NEWS
U.S.WATCH WASHINGTON
More Can Go Into
PENNSYLVANIA
Court Rules Against Firefighters Work
CALIFORNIA IMMIGRATION
Mayors Press Biden
401(k) Plans in ’24 Carbon Pricing To Contain Blaze For More Assistance
Most workers will be able Pennsylvania can’t enforce a More than 1,200 firefight- The mayors of Chicago, Den-
to put up to $23,000 into regulation to make power plant ers are attacking a big South- ver, Houston, Los Angeles and
their 401(k)s and similar owners pay for their planet- ern California wildfire, and fire New York are pressing to meet
workplace retirement plans in warming greenhouse gas emis- officials said Wednesday they with President Joe Biden about
2024, up $500 from this year, sions, a state court ruled have made inroads in contain- getting federal help in manag-
the IRS said. Wednesday, dealing a setback ing the flames, though many ing the surge of migrants they
The limit on contributions to the centerpiece of former homes remain threatened. say are arriving in their cities
to an individual retirement Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf’s The size of the Highland with little to no coordination,
account will also increase by plan to fight global warming. Fire remained unchanged at support or resources from his
$500, climbing to $7,000 in The Commonwealth Court just under 4 square miles af- administration.
2024. People ages 50 and up last year temporarily blocked ter minimal overnight activity The Democratic leaders say
can make additional catch-up Pennsylvania from becoming but containment grew to 15%, that while they appreciate Bi-
contributions to IRAs and the first major fossil fuel-pro- the California Department of den’s efforts so far, much
401(k)-style plans, though ducing state to adopt a car- Forestry and Fire Protection more needs to be done to
those limits remain $1,000 bon-pricing program, and the said. ease the burden on their cities.
and $7,500, respectively. new ruling makes that deci- One firefighter was re- Biden has requested $1.4
The contribution limits are sion permanent. ported injured as crews tack- billion from Congress to help
WTAE/ASSOCIATED PRESS
the same for Roth and pretax The ruling is a victory for led the fire, aided by air tank- state and local governments
401(k) and for individual re- Republican lawmakers and ers and helicopters. provide shelter and services
tirement accounts. coal-related interests that ar- Firefighters were on the for migrants, after earlier
Some older Americans will gued the carbon-pricing plan lookout for erratic fire behav- pleas from Democratic may-
also be able to get larger tax amounted to a tax, and ior, and extremely steep and ors and governors. The may-
benefits from a charitable- therefore would have re- rugged terrain also posed a ors in their letter are asking
SNOWY TRAGEDY: At least one person died and six others giving strategy. quired legislative approval. challenge, Cal Fire said. for $5 billion.
were hurt in a crash Wednesday on I-80 in Mercer County, Pa. —Richard Rubin —Associated Press —Associated Press —Associated Press
Effect’ Stirs shey is down 19%, while Coca- Ozempic effect is exacerbating Eli Lilly Mounjaro
50
Cola and PepsiCo have shed 9% those issues. +52% Wegovy
and 13%, respectively. “I think the worst-case sce- 40 Ozempic
Wall Street Meanwhile, shares of medi- nario is being priced in,” said 40 Novo
Nordisk* 30
cal-device companies have James Lewis, portfolio man-
dropped on studies that show ager and senior research ana- +44%
20
Novo’s drugs reduced the risk lyst at Bartlett Wealth Manage-
Continued from Page One of heart attack and kidney fail- ment. “There’s a big question 20 10
those drugs truly make the ure. Insulet, which makes insu- mark over accessibility.”
U.S. a slimmer nation are no- lin pumps, is down more than The drugs currently cost up- 0
where near. Among the obsta- 50% over the past three ward of $10,000 a year per 2023 ’24 ’25 ’26 ’27 ’28
cles are the high sticker price months, while Dexcom, which person, putting them out of 0
of such therapies, unpleasant manufactures glucose moni- reach for the majority of the
S&P Food & Beverage Select
side effects such as nausea tors, has fallen 29%. Zimmer more than 100 million obese
DexCom Industry Index performance,
and a sad, but inescapable Biomet, which makes knee-re- and overweight people in the
–17% past three months
fact: Americans placement U.S.
have poor eat- products, has Lewis said his fund owns –20 0%
$339B
ing habits. decreased about Costco stock and has been Zimmer
Sales of 24%. buying shares of PepsiCo as Biomet
Ozempic and The selloff staples stocks sold off. –18% –5
Wegovy, devel- gathered steam Signs that Ozempic usage is –40
oped by Novo Market value added after anecdotes actually hitting sales and prof- –10
Nordisk, and Eli and clinical tri- its of major companies are
Lilly’s Moun-
this year by als suggested scant. Insulet
jaro, are pro- drugmakers Novo even greater PepsiCo Chief Executive Ra- –60
–53% –15
jected to reach Nordisk and Eli Lilly potential for mon Laguarta recently said the Jan. 2023 March May July Sept. Nov. Sept. 2023 Oct. Nov.
$21 billion in GLP-1 drugs. In company isn’t seeing any drug-
2023 and swell October, the related impact on its business. *ADRs †Consensus analyst forecasts Source: FactSet
to $53 billion by head of Wal- Abbott Laboratories and Dex-
2028, according to FactSet. The mart’s U.S. business told com both reported surprisingly ert Ford said on the com- Dale Wettlaufer, partner at which was trading under $30
two drugmakers have added Bloomberg News that Ozempic strong earnings and robust pany’s October earnings call, Bleecker Street Capital, com- at the time, is now hovering
$339 billion in market cap this users are consuming slightly sales of their glucose-monitor- noting that consensus figures pared the current fervor to around $260.
year, a sum greater than the fewer calories when they shop ing systems. Sales of Abbott’s put the GLP-1 market at a enthusiasm surrounding the “Back then, the belief state
value of all but 18 companies in for food at the company’s Libre glucose-monitoring sys- fraction of the global diabetes low-carbohydrate Atkins Diet that Atkins was going to kill
the S&P 500. stores. tem for diabetes patients were market size. “I think early on that surged in popularity two fast food and consumer pack-
Those gains are taking a Consumer staples and other up nearly 31% in the latest those initial thoughts about decades ago. aged goods was just as pro-
bite out of other sectors. The stocks in slower-growing in- quarter. the future are generally im- McDonald’s shares, for ex- nounced. It turned out to be a
S&P Food & Beverage Select In- dustries have struggled this “I think the concerns are pacted more by emotion than ample, fell about 30% in the fantastic investment opportu-
dustry Index has declined 12% year. Interest rates have overblown,” Abbott CEO Rob- facts and data.” winter of 2003. The stock, nity,” Wettlaufer said.
.
PAID ADVERTISEMENT
240
INNOCENT PEOPLE
25
NATIONALITIES
STILL HELD
HOSTAGE
IN GAZA
NOW
BRING THEM HOME
WORLD NEWS
Foreigners Exit
Gaza for Egypt
After Talks
In a breakthrough, State Department officials. In-
stead, messages were con-
over 400 people, veyed through Qatar.
including Americans, Among other challenges,
the U.S. had to identify the
cross the border Americans, ensure they had
the proper documentation,
Israel
Intensifies
dog•ged Campaign
/'dôg d/ Continued from Page One
the attacks have destroyed
crucial military infrastructure
adjective and killed key leaders of
Hamas, a U.S.-designated ter-
rorist organization.
Despite spending my early life in a shelter, there’s no dog more Israel also said it has
determined than me. Thanks to the National Disaster Search Dog moved significant ground
forces into Gaza. The troops
ABED KHALED/ASSOCIATED PRESS
Foundation, if you’re ever trapped under rubble after a disaster, appear to be digging in on the
I’ll find you. That’s my job, and what I was born to do. You’ll never find northern coastline of Gaza,
where their flank is protected
a dog more dogged. and can receive cover fire
from Israel’s navy, said Mi-
THE NATIONAL DISASTER SEARCH DOG FOUNDATION chael Horowitz, the Israel-
Strengthening disaster response in America by rescuing dogs and partnering them based head of intelligence for
with first responders to save lives. Be Part of the Search™ today. Call (888) 4K9-HERO, the consulting firm Le Beck. Rescuers on Wednesday pulled a girl from the rubble of a
visit SearchDogFoundation.org, or write to SDF, 6800 Wheeler Canyon Road, Israeli troops appear to be building Israeli airstrikes destroyed in the Jabalia refugee camp.
Santa Paula, CA 93060. making short raids into cen-
tral Gaza to attack Hamas, Hamas command and tunnel about potential Israeli strikes
then falling back to more-pro- network under Jabalia, killing on population centers and ci-
tected areas, he said. the commander who was lead- vilian infrastructure in Gaza.
The air-and-ground assault ing Hamas’s forces against Is- The Pentagon has empha-
comes after the killing of more raeli forces operating in sized that it is advising and
than 1,400 people in Israel— northern Gaza at that time, guiding Israeli forces, rather
the worst massacre in its his- and who also played a pivotal than issuing directives or put-
tory—prompted Prime Minis- role in the Oct. 7 attacks. On ting restrictions on their use
ter Benjamin Netanyahu’s Wednesday, Israeli military of U.S.-provided weapons.
government to launch a war to spokesman Rear Adm. Daniel Tuesday’s attack reflects Is-
drive Hamas from power in Hagari said Israel understood rael’s shift to more-bare-
Gaza, where the group has civilians were in the area on knuckle tactics.
ruled since 2007. Tuesday and could be affected, Israel’s calculus has
It is a far different kind of but argued the Hamas com- changed, some analysts said:
war than Israel has fought, at mander, Ibrahim Biari, was a It will order strikes it might
least since it invaded Lebanon legitimate military target. have avoided in the past be-
in 1982. Its sweeping goals The attack caused hundreds cause of the risk of killing or
have shown Israel’s willing- of casualties, Gaza officials injuring bystanders.
ness to target Hamas’s leaders said. Israel’s military said doz- Israeli officials said Hamas
with fewer restraints than in ens of militants were killed. It fighters hide among civilians,
the past. was followed on Wednesday believing they won’t be tar-
The attacks and broader by several more large strikes geted, or that if they are, the
bombing campaign underscore in populated areas. deaths of noncombatants will
the delicate balance Israel is Israel faced a growing dip- produce international pres-
Victor trying to strike between de- lomatic backlash in the wake sure that will force Israel to
stroying Hamas and minimiz- of Tuesday’s strike. Bolivia cut curtail the attacks before
Active Search Dog ing civilian deaths in an urban off diplomatic relations, while Hamas is destroyed.
Rescued from Redding, CA.
Photographed by Shaina Fishman area where Hamas’s military Jordan, Colombia and Chile Hamas leader Azat Al-Rishq
at SDF’s National Training Center. capabilities are interwoven recalled their ambassadors. denied the group uses civil-
within residential neighbor- The United Arab Emirates, ians as shields. “This adds to
hoods and in hundreds of which has built friendly ties the series of lies on which
miles of tunnels beneath them. with Israel since normalizing their narrative is built,” he
Israel has defended its tac- relations in 2020, condemned said on his Telegram channel.
tics in the air campaign, say- the strike. The United Nations Critics said Israel might not
ing it has for weeks urged ci- Human Rights Office, mean- be complying with the require-
vilians to vacate northern Gaza while, said it had serious con- ments of international law to
to protect themselves. More cerns that the attack on Jaba- minimize civilian casualties. Le-
than 800,000 people have left lia could be disproportionate gal experts said civilian infra-
their homes, many of them and amount to war crimes. structure can become a legiti-
fleeing south or taking shelter U.S. officials have been mate military target if used by
in hospitals, schools and inter- pressing their Israeli counter- militants, but any attack must
national aid facilities in hopes parts to avoid civilian casual- be proportional in terms of the
of escaping the fighting. ties, including asking what a military value of the target.
In Tuesday’s attack, Israel senior defense official de- —Gordon Lubold
said it used airstrikes to hit a scribed as tough questions contributed to this article.
.
WORLD NEWS
LOVELY IN LAVENDER
Hamas’s Oct. 7 attacks on Is- on X and apologized. the critiques, saying U.S. spy
rael, some officials say Wash- In public speeches in early agencies were properly
ington misjudged the threat to 2023, CIA Director William trained for years on a group
U.S. national security. Burns warned of increased that had killed nearly 3,000 RAYMOND YARD PARAIBA EARRINGS
“In terms of intelligence tensions and possible violence Americans in September 2001,
failures, which really do lie between Israel and the Pales- bombed American embassies
Famed jeweler. Rare gemstones. Exceptional color.
mostly on Israel, I think we tinians, reflecting intelligence and conducted many other Four very rare Paraiba tourmalines display their
should also share some blame analysis at the time. deadly terrorist attacks. remarkable brilliance in these convertible earrings
for missing this event,” said But the idea that the Middle “I don’t recall at the time
Marc Polymeropoulos, a re- East wasn’t ripe for a new war anybody saying you were fo-
by Raymond Yard. Exhibiting a luminous lavender
tired CIA operations officer was reinforced in an essay on cusing too much on al Qaeda,” hue, the untreated jewels hail from Mozambique and
with extensive counterterror- President Biden’s foreign pol- a former senior CIA official total 6.05 carats. The lower drops detach, allowing
ism experience. “Ceding the icy, written just before the said. for different styling options. Diamonds totaling 3.26
carats. Set in platinum. 1½” length. #31-7838
Masked members of Hamas’s military wing at a protest in August in the central Gaza Strip.
.
would start to plateau some- Chancellor Paloma Mohamed ous government’s contract ne- “The developed world can
time in the next decade, and he Martin. gotiations with Exxon, which change this, they can decarbon-
needed to plan ahead. Guyana’s oil boom has were conducted in secret and ize faster, the same people who
When Shell, then Exxon’s kicked off a real-estate bo- kept from the public more than lecture us. I’m at peace with
partner in Guyana, pulled out nanza. New shopping malls, a year after the deal was my philosophy and con-
of the country after dozens of roads and high-end condos ca- Exxon’s headquarters in Georgetown in June. signed in 2016. science.”
.
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
© 2023 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, November 2, 2023 | A11
Which is which?
No less nettlesome for some
travelers: the small print on those
big bottles of shampoo, conditioner
and body wash hotels have installed
in showers in recent years to re-
place mini bottles.
ILLUSTRATION BY GREG CLARKE
A
showers that aren’t functional, fun at them in his “Saturday Night cold water. Don’t get British author Frances
lan Benjamin was stay- temperature controls that call for Live” monologue last week. Barga- “There’s no opportunity to Quinn started on hotel showers.
ing at a luxury hotel in an instruction manual and confus- tze joked that he’s befuddled by warm the water or test the water,” Quinn lives in Brighton, England,
Washington in early Oc- ing dispensers that require read- how the world “is so future now.” she says. “You kind of turn it on and travels to promote her histori-
tober when he pressed ing glasses in the shower so you Instead of enclosed showers, he and jump out as fast as you can.” cal fiction books.
the plush in-room bath- don’t wash your hair with body said, hotels now have those “half-a- And forget trying to keep your hair A few weeks ago at a “very nice
robes into emergency wash. glass” showers. dry during a quick body rinse. hotel” in Ipswich, the shower came
service. “People who design hotel show- “That’s the future. That’s what While it annoys her, Canfield ac- with laminated instructions.
The doorless shower in his room ers have never actually taken a they want,” he said. “In the future, cepts it as a part of life on the road: “It’s a tap, for God’s sake, not a
was flooding, water spilling onto shower,” one traveler posted in a the floors are always wet.” “In the end, it’s just a shower.” nuclear reactor,” she says.
the slate tile floor. Marriott forum on Reddit earlier One traveler’s tactic, according Christian Super, a retired IT ex- Quinn says she quickly studied
“I literally wound up taking two this year. A chorus of thumbs-up to the Reddit thread, is a standing ecutive who lives in New Orleans, the instructions, then jumped in the
robes and making a dam so that followed. request for extra towels: “When I has platinum status with Marriott shower before she forgot them, be-
water would not run out of the check in to a hotel and they have and prefers the half-glass showers cause they were only printed on the
shower,” says Benjamin, chief exec- Half a shower the half door, I call housekeeping to curtained ones, but has little else side facing away from the shower.
utive of a company that purchases On the list of pressing world is- and request eight additional tow- nice to say about them. In the end, she gave up.
furniture, fixtures and equipment sues, hotel showers with half a els.” “The design is ridiculous,” he “I just took a bath,” she says.
W
the Hudson’s descent. My grand-
hen I was 9, I discovered mother told me she was so scared
my family’s 1923 Hudson going down this pitch, she closed
Speedster at my grand- her eyes.
parents’ cabin near Lake Tahoe. I’d Their cabin in Christmas Valley is
never seen an antique car. The still in the family, and it was at this
seats were so fragmented, the wire cabin that I first saw the Hudson as
springs poked through the leather, a child. My grandparents used the
and the steering wheel had decades Speedster on their 50th
of hand sweat soaked in. wedding anniversary, in a
The story that my paternal family parade across San
grandfather, Adolfo de Urioste, Francisco in 1975. I rode
told me about this car seemed so with them in the car. I
extraordinary, even to my 9-year- later used the car in my
old ears, that I dreamed of some- wedding.
day owning this Hudson and keep- The Hudson Motor Car
ing the story of its adventures Co. of Detroit was suc-
alive. cessful in its day. It manu-
In 1923, my grandfather was a factured cars from 1909
salesman at a Hudson Motor Car into the 1950s. [In 1954,
Co. dealership in San Francisco. Be- Hudson merged with
cause of his relationship with the other brands to form
company, he was able to purchase American Motors Corp.] I
this Speedster with special customi- have my grandfather’s original sales George de Urioste, seen with his
zations. The company imprinted his kit for Hudsons, which consists of wife, Cara, spent three years having
name on the hood ornament and on rolls of film and a projector. He his grandfather’s 1923 Hudson
the leather spare-tire covers, and would take this sales kit to people’s Speedster professionally restored.
added beveled-glass side wing win- homes or businesses, then project a His daughters, far right, plan to use
dows, among other upgrades. presentation—an interesting mar- it for whenever they get married.
In 1925, my grandparents used keting concept in 1923.
the Hudson in their wedding and When my grandparents passed my grandfather drove it off
CAROLYN FONG FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (5)
drove it on their honeymoon from away in the late ’80s, I acquired the the lot.
San Francisco to Wyoming. I have car. It sat in my garage for years The Hudson is a time
photographs that my grandfather before I could afford a professional capsule and has now been
took of the car, his new wife, Mary, restoration. I made a meticulous re- in my family for a century.
and their dog named Speed in front search effort to make sure the car My daughters have learned
of the Grand Tetons. was restored with authenticity. The to drive it. They have al-
In 1933, my grandfather used the Hudson was 100% disassembled; ready reserved it for when-
Hudson and its straight-six engine the work was done by Ricky Reed ever they have future wed-
as a workhorse to haul supplies of Antique Auto Restoration in Cali- dings. I am honored to be
from San Francisco nearly 200 fornia. It took three years, and the a caretaker of the car and
miles to build a cabin in a place car uses almost all of its original of family history. It feels
called Christmas Valley, near Lake parts. It looks today like it did when like a dream come true.
.
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
ON THE
CLOCK
CALLUM
BORCHERS
F
or a prestigious early-ca-
reer job, it’s hard to beat
FROM TOP: PHOTO ILLUSTRATION BY CHANTAL JAHCHAN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, ISTOCK (4); MARISSA MOSS
Teach for America.
The program typically
admits less than 20% of
applicants, giving it the
hard-to-get-into cachet of an elite
university. Plus joining TFA’s corps
of educators in struggling schools
brings admiration for doing good
along with access to a network of
accomplished alumni. Yet the non-
profit’s ranks have dwindled from
roughly 6,000 teachers a decade
ago to about 2,200 today.
One reason stands out: pay.
Teach for America has added mil-
lions of dollars in grants to ap-
proximate signing bonuses. This
helped make this fall’s cohort 38%
larger than the last.
In the tug of war between love
and money, cash has more pull
right now. From accounting firms
to medical research labs, busi-
nesses and organizations that have
traditionally wooed candidates
with bragging rights instead of the
biggest bucks are losing out on
talent.
Inflation, housing costs, Avani Desai left a director-level
student debt and rising in- position at KPMG for a position at
terest rates have many a much smaller CPA firm.
workers saying the idea of
a prestige discount—ac-
cepting less money for a his clients who are willing to leave
job that is highly re- money on the table for a presti-
garded—is simply imprac- gious job has declined to about
tical. 30% during the past three years.
Pay has to be a major Most would join a lesser-known
factor when would-be consulting business or take a job
teachers can make consid- in a different field for $25,000 to
erably more in the private $35,000 more.
sector, says Teach for “Sometimes they lose out on
America Chief Executive great talent because they can’t of-
Elisa Villanueva Beard. The fer more,” he says of the top-tier
goal: regrowing to between companies.
3,000 and 4,000 teachers.
“Our competition for re- Recruiting opportunity
cent college grads is tech Avani Desai felt like an oddity
companies and consulting when she walked away from a di-
groups where they could be Prestigious jobs often rector-level position at KPMG in
making double,” says Vil-
lanueva Beard. “We’ve lost
demand lengthy travel 2012. Her role at a Big Four ac-
counting firm was a mark of suc-
a lot in the last few years. or long hours, reducing cess, and she believed she was on
How do you win when fi- track to make partner.
nances are a big deal for their appeal. Yet she saw a higher ceiling at
folks?” Schellman, a much smaller CPA
firm based in Tampa, Fla., that
Widespread was 10 years old at the time. She
challenge also was drawn to the option to
Surveys by Gallup and work from home, having spent 52
the Pew Research Center show raise when he made a lateral move has convened a working group to service isn’t the draw that it once days with her then-infant son dur-
that compensation, always a key to a venture-backed startup be- address the recruitment problem. was, so the federal government is ing the first year of his life be-
piece of career decisions, has be- cause he earned more on an NIH-funded postdoc positions look dangling better pay and benefits, cause of work-related travel. Desai
come an even higher priority for hourly basis. impressive on résumés but come such as $20,000 signing bonuses joined Schellman as an executive
job seekers in recent years. Many It’s smart to look with critical with first-year stipends of $56,484, for some hard-to-fill jobs with U.S. vice president and became CEO in
workers don’t define themselves eyes at any role that doesn’t maxi- far less than many industry roles. Customs and Border Protection. 2021.
by their job titles like they did mize your worth, says Betsey Ste- “In biomedicine, postdocs are Even blue-chip banks and con- “This was a strategic move at
before the pandemic, so they venson, former chief economist of running the experiments. They’re sulting firms that siphon talent maximizing my career growth and
don’t mind working for no-name the U.S. Labor Department. doing the cutting-edge science,” from the likes of Teach for Amer- professional contributions, and
companies if those employers pay “It only makes sense to take a says Donna Ginther, a University ica have boosted salaries to remain maximizing what my financial po-
up so they can have fuller per- pay cut for a prestigious job if you of Kansas economist who is part of competitive, as more workers look tential was going to be over time,”
sonal lives. think it’s going to ultimately pay the NIH working group. A postdoc past established brands to reach she says.
One college professor who took you more down the line by facili- shortage threatens the national for the top bids. Desai notices similar decisions
a pay cut to jump from a state tating a faster climb up the lad- pipeline of medical research, she Davis Nguyen, a job coach for are now more common for her
school to Yale several years ago der,” says Stevenson, now a pro- adds. people trying to break into man- peers and—to her delight as a
told me he’s not so sure he would fessor of public policy and Churches and synagogues are agement consulting, says histori- boss—for the people she recruits,
make the same decision today. economics at the University of warning of a looming clergy short- cally many candidates would set- too. She says the combination of
Others add that prestigious jobs Michigan. age. Being revered as a reverend tle for lower salaries if offered great pay and more flexibility has
often demand long hours or time or rabbi isn’t drawing people to di- positions at one of the three helped her poach from better-
away from family, which can make Settling for more vine work like it used to. best-known firms, McKinsey & known companies, including Mi-
even six-figure salaries feel dis- So many scientists are snub- And if God is having a hard Co., Boston Consulting Group and crosoft and Amazon, landing hires
counted. A former Google engineer bing postdoctoral fellowships that time, imagine what it’s like for Bain & Co., where he worked. who wouldn’t have considered her
described feeling like he got a the National Institutes of Health Uncle Sam. The honor of public Nguyen estimates the share of company in the past.
L
enders have a proposition for cost of the mortgage today to make most competitive refinancing deal
home buyers who can’t stom- it work down the road. Others ex- later.
ach an 8% mortgage rate: Buy pire in just a few years. This means There are also situations in
now, and refinance later for free. you ultimately might not save any- which you are unable to refinance
Lenders are making these offers thing at all. later despite having signed up for
because the market for mortgages “Nothing is free,” said Bradley one of these offers. If your credit
cratered as the Federal Reserve Hilton, a financial planner in Atlanta. deteriorates or if your property
raised interest rates to two-decade Offers to refinance for free later aren’t as attractive as they initially seem. value drops significantly you may
highs to tame inflation. The average How do refinance-for-free not qualify, said Laurie Goodman, a
rate on a 30-year fixed-rate mort- offers work? fellow at the Urban Institute.
gage is 7.79%, according to Freddie Usually, lenders who offer buy- tion program offers a no-lender-fee or interest rates, said Hilton, the fi-
Mac. now-refinance-later mortgages will refinance. nancial planner in Atlanta. Ask the What else should home
But is it a good deal for buyers? give some borrowers a certificate or lender how it is able to offer free or buyers consider?
As those buyers who have had to another type of IOU that gives When buyers can save reduced refinancing. Typical refinancing is usually an
put their signature down the 50- them access to a credit that can be Let’s say the buy-now-refinance- If you refinance with your cur- option later if interest rates drop,
plus times it takes to get a home used to pay for some of the costs later offer covers $3,000 in future rent lender, you will still likely pay said Hilton, the financial planner.
loan know, nothing about mort- associated with a future refinance, refinancing closing costs. A home third-party fees for services such as When rates drop, loan processors
gages is ever simple. said Jacob Channel, senior econo- buyer could come out ahead if it an appraisal, said Holden Lewis, seize the opportunity to drum up
The particulars of the offers for mist at LendingTree. turns out the closing costs of the home and mortgage specialist at more business. You can make the
refinancing later vary. Generally, Other lenders may roll the future future refinance are less. You typi- NerdWallet. The median price for a lenders compete against each
DAVID PAUL MORRIS/BLOOMBERG NEWS
buyers get the option to refinance closing costs into the loan amount cally won’t pocket the difference. typical, single-family home appraisal other for your business then, he
their mortgage later if rates fall, or waive lender fees. The benefits will vary depending is $500, according to a 2023 study said.
without having to pay much of the Each lender’s offer is different. on which lender you choose and by the National Association of Real- Focus on what you can afford
closing costs. The closing costs on a Amplify, for instance, offers no- what rates are in the future, said tors. now. Don’t buy the house today
mortgage refinance for a single- cost, no-cash out refinances with Channel at LendingTree. Some of these offers also come with the assumption that rates will
family home averaged $2,375 in zero appraisal fees. CrossCountry with a time limit. If the lender’s fall in the future, said Rossman at
2021, according to ClosingCorp. Mortgage provides a lender credit What are the downsides? credits expire after a year or two, Bankrate.
While these offers could save of up to $1,500 toward refinancing. Buy-now-refinance-later mort- they might essentially become “Sometimes things don’t go ac-
you money, they often aren’t as at- Guild Mortgage’s payment protec- gages may have higher initial fees worthless if rates don’t drop within cording to plan,” said Rossman.
.
No youth
should ever be
without a home
— period.
Join us at covenanthouse.org.
.
ARTS IN REVIEW
BY PETER PLAGENS
A
Los Angeles
lthough curator Diana
Nawi says in the excel-
lent catalog for “Made
in L.A. 2023: Acts of
Living” that it’s simply
not “possible to be com-
prehensive in surveying the city,”
and only 10 of the 39 artists (in-
cluding two collectives) in the ex-
hibition are Latino, the show has—
to its advantage, actually—a
distinct Hispanic flavor.
Nothing could be further from
what Ms. Nawi calls the “cool, ten-
der conceptualism and finish fe-
tish minimalism . . . that long
dominated discussions of mid- to
late-twentieth century L.A.” than,
for example, the “Valley Tours”
currently given by Vincent En-
rique Hernandez in his old Volvo.
Photographic evidence of these
five-hour meanderings through
working-class neighborhoods and
down normal commercial boule-
vards is possibly the best work in
the exhibition at the Hammer Mu-
seum in west Los Angeles. (This
spacious and superbly installed
sixth edition of the show is on
view through Dec. 31.)
“PCH and Cherry at 7 p.m.”
(2023)—Christopher Suarez’s ART REVIEW
Estrada—a slightly surreal overall 17) small, casual, vaguely figura- ceived sections”—one concerning drawing of a female figure as a Made in L.A. 2023: Acts of Living
composition of floating shapes on tive assemblage sculptures by Te- “place,” two regarding the body, penis by Jibz Cameron, whose ex- Hammer Museum, through Dec. 31
a light red background—and three resa Tolliver give this “Made in another dealing with abstraction, cuse might be that she’s actually a
large mixed-media, shape-inten- L.A.” a delicate lift. one consisting of craft, and a final performance artist. Mr. Plagens is an artist and writer
sive, abstract wall works from the “Acts of Living” is not a perfect category concerning, perhaps inev- In his catalog essay, fellow cu- in Connecticut.
Of Adornment
materials and craft. But when you
their own pecu- read the accompanying handouts
liar qualities. An and look at the architectural
intricate sculp- ephemera, including photographs
tural relief from and blueprints, you become aware
BY MICHAEL J. LEWIS and most significant collection of a hotel reveals of the convulsive events that
architectural artifacts in the coun- the exquisite shook loose all these bits of stone
St. Louis try, spanning everything from sharpness of line and metal. You are surprised to
THE OBJECTS THAT WE SEE ev- carved capitals and cast-iron col- that a chisel can learn that many of the buildings
eryday can become invisible to us umns to entire facades. coax from lime- represented here stood in the way
unless something causes us to see The contrast between the exu- stone. Terra- of St. Louis’s two most ambitious
them in a fresh and unexpected berant artifacts on view and the cotta, on the postwar architectural projects,
way, such as a change in lighting stringent minimalism of the Pulit- other hand, must Eero Saarinen’s Gateway Arch and
or a perceptive observation from a zer’s architecture could not be be molded and the Pruitt-Igoe Housing Complex.
friend. greater. It is as if Tiffany’s had in- baked in the Although one is celebrated as the
“Urban Archaeology: Lost stalled a pop-up showroom in a kiln, and works defining monument of the city and
Buildings of St. Louis,” the exhibi- Cistercian monastery. We begin in best with deep, the other was subsequently dyna-
tion of architectural artifacts now a barren white gallery, empty ex- well-defined mited in ignominy, both had the
on view at the Pulitzer Arts Foun- cept for a few ornamental panels shadows; Louis same urban ramifications: the de-
dation here, does this with a radi- executed in sgraffito, that tradi- Sullivan elevated molition of dozens upon dozens of
cal shift in context. It brings us tional Italian technique of building this to a high city blocks, and the dislocation of
into intimate contact with objects up plaster in coats of different art, as we see entire neighborhoods.
that we normally see only at a color, and then cutting into the here in an early This is an exhibition that will
great distance: those carved and topmost layer to make flat orna- example of his affect visitors differently accord-
cast decorative elements that mental designs. The panels, which geometric orna- ing to their age. Older viewers
crowned offices, hotels and the- come from a vanished Art Deco ment from the might feel a pang at seeing the
aters in those years before mod- movie palace, are vaguely Egyptian lost St. Nicholas vestiges of the thriving life of the
ernism declared ornament off-lim- in character—foliage with strong conventional pedestals, she kept Hotel of 1894. The language of older downtown America that they
its. Brought down to eye level, outlines that swirl to fill almost them on their rough wooden pal- copper is different yet again; here remember. Younger ones are likely
they reveal just how vast was the every inch of the available space. lets, or on the same wheeled dol- it is the hammered planes and to be pleasantly surprised at the
range of materials and techniques These panels are placed casu- lies on which they arrived. sharp angles that matter, as in the sheer tactile richness of baked
that once decorated the buildings ally, as if they had just arrived There are no explanatory la- strangely faceted lion that once clay, carved stone, and wrought
of St. Louis. from the loading dock and were bels; those who want to know guarded the National Bank of metal; tactile richness, after all, is
The objects on display come waiting to be installed. Stephanie more will have to seek out the ob- Commerce, a charmingly bewil- not a property of a digital age.
from the collection of the National Weissberg, who curated the exhi- ject notes that are tucked dis- dered Cubist creature.
NATIONAL BUILDING ARTS CENTER
Building Arts Center, located just bition together with Michael Allen creetly away at the entrance to By far the most attractive note Urban Archaeology:
across the Mississippi in Sauget, of the NBAC, told me she wanted the room. All this is in keeping of color in the entire exhibition is Lost Buildings of St. Louis
Ill. That organization was founded to remind the visitor of the fitful with the philosophy of Emily Rauh an enamel-glazed disk in lustrous Pulitzer Arts Foundation, through
by Larry Giles, a St. Louis preser- journey these objects took— Pulitzer, the founder of the Pulit- celadon green, clenched in the Feb. 4, 2024
vationist and Vietnam veteran, scrounged from out of demolition zer Arts Foundation: You are sup- fangs of another lion, this one sur-
who began picking over demolition debris or pried from a wall just posed to look, not read. mounting a 6-foot-high terracotta Mr. Lewis teaches architectural
sites in 1973 and who amassed, be- before it fell to the wrecking ball. Subsequent galleries make pendant from the Missouri Pacific history at Williams and reviews
fore his death in 2021, the largest And so rather than place them on clear that different materials have Building. Reduced in size, it would architecture for the Journal.
.
SPORTS
Texas Rangers Win World Series
With a 5-0 victory over the Arizona Diamondbacks in Game 5, the Rangers clinched their first championship
the closer, hunting dog) across the court. tion—he was known later in ary sensation that turned out
Down F L E A L O O T H O R N E
often 50 Players F L O U R I S H F I N I S H His indecent antics finally his career as “The General”— to be one of the bestselling
1 X, sometimes T O T A L S P E E T A
cost him his job at Indiana, and coached Army’s basket- sports books ever.
23 Pet with a who may S P E E D G A M S D A B
dewlap sack a QB 2 Doesn’t follow Y O N R E L I C H O R S after a former player named ball team from 1965 until Knight became a broad-
suit, say N O T I C E A T R A I N Neil Reed accused Knight of 1971. One of his players there caster after leaving coach-
24 Org. that 51 “Not true!” C H E R I S H H A S H I S H choking him during a prac- was Mike Krzyzewski, the ing. In that role, he called an
added a P for 53 Gertrude 3 Delicate R A D I U M WH O O P I
tice three years earlier. The Duke coach who surpassed Indiana game in 2012, end-
“Paralympic” Stein and dessert H A T S N E I L L N A P
E R A S Y N E MA S T S school investigated the al- Knight as college basketball’s ing a self-imposed exile. He
in 2019 Alice B. 4 Ancient L O I R E S I G H E D leged incident and an- all-time winningest coach. finally returned to Assembly
25 Red state? Toklas, e.g. assembly site P U N I S H B R A N D I S H nounced that Knight would It was at Army where Hall in 2020 to a standing
U S E D T O A E R E R I E
be subject to a “zero toler- Knight honed the sense of ovation and chants of
▶ Solve this puzzle online and discuss it at WSJ.com/Puzzles. P E R S O N R E P R E AM
ance” policy. discipline that he carried for “Bobby! Bobby!”
.
OPINION
The Democrats and Anti-Semitism BOOKSHELF | By Priscilla M. Jensen
‘A
media that the 15 Democrats some 1,400 Israelis tollah Ali Khamenei, mazing grace,” intoned the eulogist, and repeated
who didn’t vote for the measure on Oct. 7 is described A Hamas-raided house in a kibbutz near Gaza. sits placidly ponder- it. He began to sing: “how sweet the sound, that
were “despicable and do not in media reports as ing the completion saved a wretch like me,” and the congregation, a
speak for the party.” the worst attack on Jews most American schoolchildren of the final solution. FBI Direc- bit startled, joined in, as the pianist scrambled to accom-
Mr. Gottheimer was only “since the Holocaust.” The Ho- had a functioning knowledge tor Christopher Wray testified pany them. The singer was President Barack Obama, who
half right. Those 15 members locaust, a central event of of the Holocaust and the Tuesday that Islamic State had been addressing mourners at a 2015 memorial service
from progressive constituen- World War II, is the greatest camps. No longer. Universities’ “urged its followers to target for the Rev. Clementa Pinckney and eight parishioners,
cies may in fact represent the calamity in the history of the hiring and enabling of activist Jewish communities in the African-Americans murdered by a white supremacist
Democratic future. The party Jews. But that phrase, “since left-wing professors—propo- United States and Europe.” during Bible study at their Charleston, S.C., church.
of Franklin D. Roosevelt has an the Holocaust,” manifestly has nents of the anti-Israel move- Democratic progressives This riveting moment introduces James Walvin’s
anti-Semitism problem. no meaning or resonance for ment called Boycott, Divest- had already pushed the party exploration of the past and present of what may be the
many recently educated Amer- ment and Sanctions—has onto the bubble with many most widely known Christian hymn in English. Mr. Walvin,
icans. It is an abstraction. affected a generation of stu- voters over litmus-test issues an emeritus professor of history at the University of York,
The party never Readers of this column do dents. A Quinnipiac poll found like gender identity, systemic encountered the hymn during his study of the Atlantic
not need this summary, but 51% of Democrats younger racism and defunding the po- slave trade, and in “Amazing Grace: A Cultural History of
expected Jew-hatred what is going on now among than 35 don’t support sending lice. Despite that, most Demo- the Beloved Hymn,” he describes its origin, transmission
to be a feature of its the American left requires it. military aid to Israel after crats would still vote the party and flourishing survival into the 21st century.
The Jewish Holocaust ran from Hamas’s attack. line. But maybe not now. The origins of “Amazing Grace” are themselves well es-
coalition. Now it is. 1933 to 1945. Germany’s Nazi Political parties don’t care The Hamas person-by-per- tablished: “Faith’s Review and Expectation,” as it was
party under Adolf Hitler called much what adherents think so son slaughter is an event on a originally titled, was written in 1772 by a Church of Eng-
it “The Final Solution to the long as the votes go into their scale beyond any standard po- land clergyman who became prominent in Britain’s aboli-
This week progressive ac- Jewish Question.” The Nazis column. Maybe Democrats litical issue. The question is tion movement. But, in an
tivist groups released a “Gaza collected and sent Jews to 23 never expected Jew-hatred to whether the embrace by so earlier part of his life,
2024 statement” asserting main concentration camps in be a feature of their coalition. much of the party’s emerging John Newton (1725-1807)
they won’t vote for Joe Biden Europe. Extermination camps Now it is. It is possible today rank and file of anti-Semi- captained numerous slave-
“if he does not end U.S. sup- included Auschwitz-Birkenau, to divide the Democratic tism—a euphemism for active trading voyages between
port for Israel’s brutal war in Treblinka, Sobibor, Belzec and Party between those who Jew hatred—will finally push West Africa and the Carib-
Gaza.” The announcement of- Chelmno. Some six million know what the Holocaust was Democrats over the line with bean and North American
fers background on “Israeli Jews were murdered, often in and those who have no clue, voters, not least the histori- colonies. His ports of call
ethnic cleansing and genocide gas chambers, burned and or don’t care. For the record, cally reliable Jewish vote. included Charleston, where
in Gaza.” dumped into mass pits. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Best case, President Biden Mr. Obama would sing his
An open letter this week One reason the U.S.’s Great- Schumer gave a strong floor would explicitly and publicly hymn more than two centu-
from 100 Columbia professors est Generation is called the statement Oct. 17, recalling drive a stake through the heart ries later.
called the Hamas massacre “a greatest is that it includes his own family’s Holocaust of the anti-Jewish sentiment Newton “became an ac-
military response by a people thousands of American GIs experience. taking over his party. Cynics tive hymn-writer at a time
who had endured crushing and who helped liberate the con- On balance, the Biden ad- will reply that the anyone-but- when hymns were relatively
unrelenting state violence centration camps. Despite the ministration’s support for Is- Trump factor will overcome new in England,” Mr. Walvin
from an occupying power.” war, the experience of seeing rael has been firm because its even this, but don’t count on informs us, but before the
Because the Democrats now the camps and the scale and representatives understand it. Rationally, many large Jew- turn of the century “Amazing
consider Muslim Americans an evidence of a systemized kill- the direct line between the ish donors already are pulling Grace” had crossed the Atlan-
important part of the party’s ing of Jews was an unspeak- 1930s and Oct. 7. Testifying to the plug on giving to anti-Se- tic and appeared in no fewer than three collections of
voting coalition, meetings were able horror. As their relatives the Senate Tuesday, Secretary mitic fermentation tanks such hymns, with more to come as the Second Great Awakening
held this week at the White know, many of these soldiers of State Antony Blinken related as Harvard, Columbia and “transformed and reinvigorated” religious life in America.
House with Muslim leaders. Mr. would never talk about what in frankly unbearable detail Penn. The party of FDR could The importance of communal singing in American
Biden in his national address they saw. Hamas’s dismemberment of an be next. Protestantism, and the rise of a popular method of hymn-
last month spoke at length There was a time when Israeli father, mother, daugh- Write henninger@wsj.com. singing using easy-to-read musical notes known as “shape
notes,” meant that Newton’s composition established a
footing, among both white and black congregations, that it
The Unrestrained 2024 Front Runners has never lost. Importantly, the music by which we know
it was not always the standard: The words of “Amazing
Grace” have been sung to a number of tunes, some
By Karl Rove ist, saying he was “disrespect- likely explanation. Either way, rated.” Ms. Haley is “bird- peculiar to only one or two localities. But the now-familiar
ful to . . . voters of color.” Even he’d be better off playing brain” and former New Jersey melody is from a tune originally called “New Britain,”
T
he behavior of the front- Minnesota’s Democratic gover- down the polls and saying he Gov. Chris Christie a “bum” associated with the words by the 1830s and appearing
running Democratic and nor disparaged Mr. Phillips, expects the contest to tighten. and “fat pig.” Shortly after with them in the widely used 1844 collection “The Sacred
Republican presidential suggesting in a Biden fundrais- That would soften the blow if Mike Pence gracefully with- Harp.”
campaigns is perplexing. Nei- ing email that he was doing he gets a surprise. drew from the contest Satur- Mr. Walvin follows “Amazing Grace” through the next
ther Joe Biden’s surrogates nor “crazy things” and creating And one may well arrive. In day, Mr. Trump couldn’t con- century, describing its survival as part of the American
Donald Trump seems to know “political side shows.” Iowa, where voters have seen trol himself. He lambasted his folk repertoire: He draws on oral histories from former
the value of restraint. But why give the largely more of the rest of the field, former vice president as “very slaves to describe their memories of “shouting” it. In fact,
First there’s the rhetorical unknown congressman the at- Mr. Trump’s numbers are disloyal,” “delusional” and the song was not included in African Methodist Episcopal
hell Democrats rained down tention? Trashing him gener- lower. A new poll there has him “not a very good person.” hymnals until 1890, “not because the hymn was unpopular
on Minnesota Rep. Dean Phil- ates more coverage of him and at 43%, followed by Mr. DeSan- He even attacks his Repub- but because of concerns about how the church would be
lips after he announced he’s his argument that Mr. Biden is tis and former South Carolina lican opponents’ supporters as viewed by outside critics,” that is, as too informal and
running in the New Hampshire too old. That’s a statement “disloyal RINOs” and “global- lacking “choral discipline.” The development of gospel
presidential primary. Mr. Phil- 73% of voters, including two- ist special interest donors.” music—both the white evangelical style of Dwight L. Moody
lips believes that Mr. Biden is thirds of Democrats, agreed Biden’s surrogates A candidate who is way and Ira D. Sankey and the slightly later black church music
too old and that Democrats with in an Aug. 30 Wall Street ahead can afford to be gra- exemplified by Thomas A. Dorsey—carries the narrative
will lose the White House un- Journal poll. Instead of flame- attack Dean Phillips, cious. Why isn’t Mr. Trump? forward to the remarkable pop phenomenon that occurred
less they nominate a younger throwing the Minnesotan, the while Trump attacks Perhaps fearing his lead is in 1970, when Judy Collins’s a cappella recording became
leader. smart move for Team Biden fragile, he believes he needs an international hit, selling millions of copies and entering
Mr. Biden’s allies quickly would have been a polite ac- practically everyone. insults to win. Maybe he the British hit parade seven times over the next two years.
blasted away. Former Demo- knowledgment of his entry by thinks there’s no downside to The hymn’s overwhelming ubiquity after that (don’t
cratic National Committee a level-three underling. Then smash-mouth politics. More forget the bagpipe versions) has intensified a paradoxical
Chairman Donna Brazile pre- silence by all concerned. Gov. Nikki Haley at 16% each. likely, he’s addicted to abusive secularization of what is, after all, quite an orthodox
dicted Mr. Phillips won’t be at Keeping quiet when it’s While a 27-point lead is language and no one can con- assertion of the Christian doctrine of unearned grace. Mr.
the party’s convention next wise has never been the Re- healthy, it could shrink. Fifty- trol him. Walvin points out that many who have encountered
summer “unless he’s an auto- publican front-runner’s four percent of Republicans say Whatever the case, trash- “Amazing Grace” over the past 50 years or so were
matic superdelegate.” Demo- strength, either. These days they’re open to changing their talking other Republicans and
cratic House colleagues called Donald Trump can’t stop harp- minds. Between the undecideds their supporters will make it
his bid a “head scratcher” and ing on the polls. In Waterloo, and those committed to some- hard to produce the enthusias- The words to ‘Amazing Grace’ were written by
an “exercise in futility.” Joe Iowa, last month, he bragged, one else, nearly 6 in 10 aren’t tic GOP unity Mr. Trump a clergyman with his own catalog of sins to
Trippi, who managed Howard “We’re leading by a lot.” “Na- in Mr. Trump’s camp today. Ms. would need in a close general
Dean’s 2004 presidential bid, tionally,” he said, “we’re lead- Haley especially has momen- election if he wins the nomi- repent. The tune we all know came later.
called Mr. Phillips’s entry ing by numbers that nobody’s tum in Iowa, where she’s risen nation. He has more than
“clueless.” actually quite ever seen.” He 10 points since August. Postur- enough enemies; it’s perplex-
A “senior Black Democrat” claimed to be 67 points ahead ing as having an insurmount- ing he wants to make more “unaware that, in origin, it was a piece of sacred music.”
told ABC News that by filing of Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis. able lead could make Mr. needlessly. Not everyone, of course—during Covid lockdowns in 2020,
for the New Hampshire pri- Actually, that day he was at Trump look weak if he wins Then again, this is the a London vicar attached some loudspeakers to his bicycle
mary without entering the 57% in the RealClearPolitics Iowa with significantly less strangest presidential election and cycled through his parish, playing the Collins
South Carolina contest, Mr. average, 45 points ahead of than 50% and someone’s nip- in our lifetimes, which is say- recording and inviting his hearers to join him in prayer.
Phillips is “skipping a very di- Mr. DeSantis. That’s strong ping on his tail—never mind if ing a lot after the past two. (At that point “Amazing Grace” took part in a different
verse state to go to a non- but not 67 points. he loses. sort of contemporary religion: When Ms. Collins saw a
diverse state.” That’s “a telltale It’s strange Mr. Trump Mr. Trump combines his Mr. Rove helped organize video of the vicar, she was inspired to convene a “global
sign of where your values are.” keeps stressing and exaggerat- bravado about the polls with the political-action committee virtual choir” via Zoom; proceeds from their re-recording
Congressional Black Caucus In- ing how far ahead he is. Does constant personal attacks on American Crossroads and is went to the World Health Organization.)
stitute Chairman Bennie he think that will demoralize other GOP candidates. The author of “The Triumph of Yet for all the secularized impact of “Amazing Grace,” it
Thompson (D., Miss.) came his competitors’ supporters? Florida governor is “DeSancti- William McKinley” (Simon & is firmly established at the heart of American gospel
close to calling Mr. Phillips rac- Maybe. Narcissism is a more monious” and “really over- Schuster, 2015). music. Mr. Walvin highlights Aretha Franklin’s “dazzling”
1972 recording as part of a concert at the New Temple
Missionary Baptist Church in Los Angeles, a rendition that
Ireland’s Tax-Cutting Success Story would feature at the center of Franklin’s double album of
the same name, as well as in a documentary film of the
performance released in 2018. “Watching that film,” Mr.
By Stephen Moore dismal welfare-state economy. ness and capital investment. left has ridiculed international Walvin writes, “it is hard to imagine the hymn’s humble
And Steve Forbes Between 1971 and 1991, its na- It worked. Even the most tax competition as a “race to origins in a quiet English village.”
tional debt as a share of gross optimistic architects of this low the bottom,” even as Ireland Mr. Walvin is compelling in his description of the deep
E
uropean Union officials domestic product rose from flat rate couldn’t have imag- has raced straight to the top. presence of “Amazing Grace” in Anglophone, especially
and Treasury Secretary 40% to 95%, and its unemploy- ined the economic recovery it The Biden administration— American, culture. He is less persuasive in some of his
Janet Yellen are pushing ment rate topped out just shy would launch. The American which has proposed raising the theological observations: I find it vanishingly unlikely that
for a global minimum corporate of 18% in 1987. But in 1995, Chamber of Commerce Ireland U.S. corporate tax rate from the famous 19th-century evangelist Dwight Moody
tax, and no wonder. High-tax reports that the number of U.S. 21% to between 25% and 30%, “portrayed Christ himself as a sinner . . . with whom armies
countries are getting bled to multinational companies oper- as well as higher tax rates on of ordinary people could identify.” The 18th-century
death, while low-tax ones expe- It slashed its levy ating in Ireland now stands at capital gains and dividends— Church of England did not consist of a “Latin-based
rience stunning growth. about 950, with 209,000 em- doesn’t get this at all. These priesthood” conducting “impenetrable Latin-based wor-
Ireland, whose economy on corporations and ployees. Only five million peo- are self-defeating policies that ship”—that had been decisively seen off 200 years earlier.
grew by 12.5% last year—faster became a magnet ple live in Ireland. This is the the Irish rejected, to their And to say that 19th-century American Protestant worship
than any other European na- equivalent of a U.S. policy cre- great benefit. was “suffused with the theme of salvation” seems tauto-
tion—is one of the greatest for business and jobs. ating 10 million jobs. logical.
tax-cutting success stories of Ireland is an industrialized Mr. Moore is an economist Still, his affection for his subject is contagious and his
modern times. The Journal re- country with one of the with the Heritage Foundation. engagement comprehensive, and his account is full of
cently reported that Ireland is Dublin implemented a contro- world’s largest budget sur- Mr. Forbes is chairman and fascinating detail—not least that there are 3,049
“swimming in money.” It’s a versial about-face economic pluses, thanks to new tax reve- editor of Forbes Media and co- recordings of “Amazing Grace” in a special Library of
vivid example of the Laffer plan. The country replaced its nue, especially from big tech author of the book “Inflation: Congress collection. The list of famous singers who haven’t
Curve, which shows that lower 40% corporate tax rate with a and pharmaceutical companies What It Is, Why It’s Bad, and recorded it might be shorter than the one of those who
tax rates can result in faster 12.5% rate, phased in over domiciled in Dublin. The mys- How to Fix It.” They are co- have—I’m watching for the Taylor Swift version myself.
growth and higher revenue. about a decade. Ireland be- tery is why other nations ha- founders of the Committee to
In the 1990s, Ireland had a came a magnet for new busi- ven’t imitated the Irish. The Unleash Prosperity. Ms. Jensen is a writer and editor in Northern Virginia.
.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
The Ukraine-Israel Test for U.S. Democracy What the U.N. Secretary-General Left Out
Regarding your editorial “The Dis- Your editorial calls Mr. Guterres’s
T
he Beltway press likes to fret about the cerns Members claim to have: That Mr. Biden
fate of U.S. democracy, invariably be- lacks a plan to end the war; U.S. financial aid is grace of the United Nations” (Oct. remarks on the Gaza war “disgrace-
26): U.N. Secretary-General António ful.” But to explain, and to put events
cause of Republicans. But now a real paying bureaucratic salaries in Kyiv; no one
Guterres is correct when he says that in historical context, isn’t to justify. If
democratic test is arriving: knows where American weap- “the attacks by Hamas did not happen you believe that the unjustifiable
support for Israel and Ukraine. Can Washington still ons and money are ending up. in a vacuum.” But he hurts the cause events of Oct. 7 had no relationship
Can Washington’s factions rise function to provide A House bill could focus on le- of peace when he elides the real to the 56 years of Israeli occupation
above their parochial interests thal aid and trim the financial cause of the crisis. of the West Bank and Israel’s stran-
and compromise to help two military aid to allies? support that the European The Palestinian people would not glehold on Gaza, then you haven’t
U.S. friends fighting for their Union is stepping up to pro- “have been subjected to 56 years of been following the Middle East.
national survival? vide. Aid for Ukraine is already suffocating occupation” had they ac- H.D.S. GREENWAY
The House plans to vote this week on $14 bil- examined by several inspectors general, but the cepted, as the Jewish people did, the Needham, Mass.
lion in aid for Israel, and Washington is ab- House is free to add more scrutiny. U.N.’s offer of statehood in 1947; or if
sorbed with infighting over whether to combine President Biden has too often offered Ukraine they had worked toward establishing Acting through the United Nations
a state on the disputed territories Relief and Works Agency for Pales-
that measure with support for Ukraine and Tai- enough weapons to tread water but not enough
which were then occupied by Jordan tine Refugees (Unrwa), the only refu-
wan. But strip away the inside baseball and the to prevail. The political high ground for Republi- and Egypt for 19 subsequent years; or gee agency that prevents resettle-
stakes are whether America can still rally to a cans is to insist on victory, which means pushing had they and their Arab allies not re- ment, the U.N. has funded schools
common purpose, as an axis of hostility works Russia back to its pre-invasion borders or further. fused to negotiate with Israel—their and textbooks in Gaza that have
together against U.S. interests. Force Mr. Biden to transfer the long-range Army famous “three Nos”—following the taught hatred of Jews and Israel for
i i i tactical missile system at scale. Give the Adminis- 1967 Six Day War; or had they ac- the past 75 years. Many millions of
The Chinese Communist Party is forging a tration a deadline for procuring 1,000 more mis- cepted any of the offers of Palestinian dollars in financing, cement and
deeper relationship with Iran, the ventriloquist siles. This is better politics than no House offer, statehood made by Israeli govern- other materials, designated by the
for the terrorist groups now menacing Israel. which sets up the House to be cornered by the ments over recent decades. U.N. and other international donors
Tehran is working to help Vladimir Putin devas- White House and Senate at crunch time. To this day, the Palestinian leader- for civilian use, have been diverted to
tate Ukraine. These adversaries hope Washing- ship has demonstrated repeatedly, in Hamas’s construction of perhaps 300
Senate Republicans can help Mr. Johnson by
word and deed, that eliminating the miles of tunnels. Mr. Guterres should
ton will descend into dysfunction and fail to making concessions to his narrow majority. Jewish state is more important to it know that the U.N. is complicit in the
fend off aggression in Europe, the Middle East Democratic leader Chuck Schumer will have to than establishing a Palestinian state. tragedy on both sides of the Israel-
and the Pacific. abandon domestic pork and offer substantive That is the missing context. Gaza border.
The House Israel bill would help America’s concessions on border security. Fixing the bro- BARRY BEST CHARLES ICKOWICZ
premiere ally in the Middle East buy more air ken incentives in asylum policy would make a New Rochelle, N.Y. Teaneck, N.J.
defense interceptors, among other assistance. much bigger difference than dumping more
It has funds for U.S. forces working overtime in money into asylum tribunals or bailing out New
the region. The House also claws back funding York for its migrant spending.
from the Internal Revenue Service to pay for the The Senate may be tempted to jam the House Drug Use, Legalization and Our City Streets
spending, though Congress’s budget gnomes with a single bill. But the risk is ending up with
Andy Kessler’s “Three Ideas to End ber is estimated at over 170,000.
claim that adds to the deficit. nothing, which is the worst outcome. No one
Tent Cities” (Inside View, Oct. 30) Mr. Kessler rightly points out that
New Speaker Mike Johnson no doubt wants will remember if the aid passes as one bill or raises worthy points to address San shoplifting and the illicit market for
to show that his conference is now united and several. Francisco’s and the nation’s balloon- consumer goods have exploded. There
can pass bills after weeks of circular firing i i i ing homeless crisis. The column is arguably a strong connection to
squads. Mr. Johnson may even pick up a few Mr. Biden also has an obligation to behave would benefit, however, from ac- drugs here as well. A study by the
Democratic votes. But his bill won’t pass the like a Commander in Chief rather than a politi- knowledging that addiction and the California Policy Lab at UCLA found
Senate, which is working on a larger package ty- cal faction leader. That means compromising legalization of drugs is a significant that, across 15 states, half of unshel-
ing Israel, Ukraine, Taiwan and a porous south- with Republicans, even if it demands facing contributor to homelessness. tered people reported that they suffer
ern border. The Senate is correct on the com- down his left flank on immigration and domes- In 2016 California passed Proposi- from a combination of a physical- or
mon strategic thread. The House bill is tic spending. He has already rammed through tion 64, the “Adult Use of Marijuana mental-health condition and sub-
insufficient for the urgency of the moment, trillions in domestic spending that will roll out Act.” It was a monumental step in the stance abuse. As the number of peo-
wrong direction, because it normal- ple with access to drugs increases, so
which requires a real expansion of U.S. weapons for years to come.
ized the use of marijuana and THC too does the economic and health
stocks and military power. Mr. Biden might think he can blame Republi- drugs, which are addictive and detri- damage done to those at risk of
Mr. Johnson recently signaled that he sup- cans if Ukraine aid fails, but his political stand- mental to public health and safety. homelessness.
ports aid to Ukraine and the U.S.: “We can’t al- ing is on the line. If Russia rolls over Ukraine This matters because today’s mari- Mr. Kessler is on the right track,
low Vladimir Putin to prevail in Ukraine, be- next year, he will share the blame as President juana is up to 20 times as powerful but we need to look at all the root
cause I don’t believe it would stop there.” He and play into Donald Trump’s hands. as the marijuana of the past, and it is causes, including expanded drug use
said China might then make a play for Taiwan. As the world gets more dangerous, Washing- connected to a fivefold increase in and the legalization of marijuana, to
He’s right, and credit to him for political cour- ton’s political dysfunction is becoming more psychosis and schizophrenia. have a shot at solving this national
age given that support for Ukraine is toxic in dangerous as well. If Washington can’t help two According to the state, “on a single problem.
about half the Republican conference. allies defend themselves, with no U.S. troops night in 2016, more than 118,000 peo- KEVIN SABET AND JONATHAN TALCOTT
ple experienced homelessness in Cali- Smart Approaches to Marijuana
The new Speaker can help the GOP assemble fighting, the world will conclude that our adver-
fornia.” Seven years later, that num- New York and Washington
a position on Ukraine that addresses the con- saries are right about American decline.
R
onald Reagan said “trust but verify” not the script the Biden Administration has been Pays Dearly for Labor Peace” (Oct. American auto executives also have
when making deals with adversaries. rehearsing. On Oct. 17 Caracas and the opposi- 27): I spent 24 years selling Fords been weak. Most of them, unlike Toy-
President Biden’s variation on the tion signed an electoral agreement. Secretary of and other brands of cars. The tax- ota Chairman Akio Toyoda, have
theme, “trust and hope for the best,” is failing State Antony Blinken called it an “election road- payer will keep paying dearly for this failed to resist government mandates.
America’s friends. Latest example: Venezuela’s map” and “a concrete step toward resolution of labor peace and government-created Recent market results, including big
electric-vehicle bubble. None of this losses on EVs at many auto makers,
democratic opposition. Venezuela’s political, economic, and humanitar-
is sustainable. have vindicated Mr. Toyoda’s “all of
At issue is the Biden Administration’s Oct. 18 ian crisis.” The auto makers are guaranteeing the above” stance, serving the needs
decision to lift sanctions in exchange for prom- He noted in a press statement that the regime higher pay and benefits while being of customers over the wants of gov-
ises by the regime in Caracas to allow a free and was supposed to produce, by the end of November, mandated to produce unprofitable ernment and unelected bureaucrats.
fair election in 2024. Two weeks later dictator a “timeline and process for the expedited rein- products that depend on taxpayer- Historically, the UAW has been
Nicolás Maduro has already broken his word. statement of all candidates” who were banned. Ca- funded credits to be made and sold. very effective at negotiating its work-
Who would have thought? racas was also to begin “the release of all wrong- The United Auto Workers would have ers out of jobs and their employers
Venezuela’s Oct. 22 opposition presidential fully detained U.S. nationals and Venezuelan represented the interests of their into bankruptcy. Like the executives
primary drew some 2.4 million voters to the political prisoners,” numbering around 300. members better had they directed at auto companies, union brass al-
polls. Vente Venezuela party candidate Maria In return, the U.S. gave Mr. Maduro what he their energy and influence toward ways make out well when the music
Corina Machado won more than 90% of the bal- wanted: sanctions relief. The U.S. issued a six- stops. The U.S auto industry took de-
cades to catch up to the Japanese in
lots cast. This is strong evidence that Mr. Ma- month general license authorizing transactions
duro would lose an honest election. in oil and gas in Venezuela. And it awarded what
Will Biden Enforce His Red quality and innovation, and even now
struggles to compete, partly because
Mr. Maduro seems to agree because on Mon- the State Department called “a second general Line as Attacks Continue? it has always had uncompetitive labor
day his handpicked Supreme Court suspended license” for Venezuela’s state-owned gold min- Your editorial “Biden’s Red-Line arrangements.
the primary results. It ordered the primary com- ing company and “amended relevant licenses to Moment with Iran” (Oct. 25) states Now U.S. auto makers are con-
mission to turn over voter information, ballots, remove the secondary trading ban on certain that by repeatedly warning Iran but strained by the UAW and the govern-
tally sheets and other documents. Organizers Venezuelan sovereign bonds and PdVSA debt doing little else, the White House ment, forcing the customer and the
were summoned before the attorney general, and equity.” runs the “risk” that “Iran or its prox- market to take a back seat in product
who launched a criminal investigation last week. On Tuesday Mr. Blinken told Sen. Marco Ru- ies will eventually kill Americans in portfolio decisions. Quality control
The high court also ratified the regime’s ban on bio that if the U.S. finds that Venezuela has vio- these attacks.” will continue to decline. The taxpayer
It isn’t only a risk. On Oct. 7, is forced to pay for the gravy train of
Ms. Machado’s candidacy. lated its agreement with the opposition, it is
Hamas killed at least 33 Americans. state-driven misallocation of capital—
This crackdown on Venezuelan democrats is ready to reimpose sanctions. He didn’t say what In its endless warnings to Iran—in- from which so many others would
business as usual for the dictatorship. But it’s he’s waiting for. cluding the subsequent U.S. pinprick have benefited—as well as the bailouts
strikes—the Biden administration is to follow when the EV bubble bursts.
I
s Gary Gensler ever going to win a case? The U.S. Chamber of Commerce sued, argu- peatedly says, “Alice, this is the last
On Tuesday the Fifth Circuit Court of Ap- ing that the SEC violated the Administrative time. . . .” Invariably, he does nothing Pence Need Not Be Finished
peals handed the Securities and Exchange Procedure Act by failing to quantify the rule’s and his threats prove idle, much to
I concur wholeheartedly with your
Commission Chairman an- costs and benefits. Although the amusement of the audience. A
editorial “Mike Pence Makes a Gra-
other legal defeat by scuttling The SEC chief’s stock- the SEC claimed these “cannot central character spewing hot air can
be the foundation for a rewarding sit-
cious Exit” (Oct. 30). While it might
the agency’s stock-buyback buyback rule takes a be quantified,” the agency dis- com. Not so for a nation’s foreign
be difficult to ask of him, how about
rule (U.S. Chamber of Com- regarded data that the Cham- Mr. Pence joining Nikki Haley’s
policy.
merce v. SEC.) drubbing in court. ber submitted in a public com- JAMES SPIRO
ticket? Fresh ideas combined with
The SEC in May finalized a ment that would have enabled top-level experience and leadership.
New Orleans
BILL RYCKBOST
rule requiring public compa- the agency to do so.
Holland, Mich.
nies to disclose their daily share repurchases A three-judge Fifth Circuit panel skewered
and the reason for buying back their stock. Mr. the SEC for failing to substantiate the rule’s DEI Backfires on the Military
Gensler claimed companies might buy back purported benefits and applying inconsistent The diversity, equity and inclusion
their stock to boost executive compensation, logic. While the SEC claimed the cost to com- framework has damaged the military
Pepper ...
which is sometimes tied to accounting metrics panies of disclosing proprietary information (“Patriotism’s Decline Imperils the And Salt
such as earnings per share. would be modest, it also argued the disclo- Military” by Owen West and Kevin
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
A 2020 SEC staff study found scant evidence sures would yield valuable information for in- Wallsten, op-ed, Oct. 31), just as it
for Mr. Gensler’s suspicion, explaining that re- vestors. “The SEC cannot have it both ways,” has damaged every other institution
purchases help issuers “maintain optimal levels the judges opined. that allows it to fester. Would I want
of cash holdings and minimize their cost of cap- The panel remanded the rule to the agency to to give up years of my life only to be
told the promotion I deserved went
ital” and “on average” have “a positive effect on correct its defects within 30 days. That means
to someone with a preferred sexual
firm value.” Nonetheless, Mr. Gensler claimed the agency will have to quantify its costs and preference or skin color? Unintended
that investors would benefit from knowing why benefits as well as demonstrate that “opportu- consequences strike again.
and when shares were being repurchased. nistic or improperly motivated buybacks are a KEITH BROWN
His real motivation appears to have been to genuine problem.” The available evidence sug- Fort Lauderdale, Fla.
shame companies and help his friends in the se- gests it isn’t, which should doom the rule.
curities litigation bar sue companies over their By flooding the zone with new regulations,
Letters intended for publication should
buybacks. Companies faced potentially hefty le- Mr. Gensler is forcing businesses to pick and be emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com. Please
gal bills defending against lawsuits challenging choose their legal battles. But his fast-and-furi- include your city, state and telephone
the motivation and timing of their share buy- ous rule-making is leaving the agency vulnera- number. All letters are subject to
backs, especially if they resulted in higher exec- ble to legal challenges, and he is racking up editing, and unpublished letters cannot “Just because we mate for life
be acknowledged.
utive compensation. some record of defeat. doesn’t mean I can’t look.”
.
OPINION
S
imultaneous crises are
threatening global sta-
bad actors would ease their hos-
tility and turn them into reliable
partners. The U.S. thought that
Diagnosis
bility and taxing U.S. trade with China would gradu-
power and attention. ally alter Beijing’s incentives by By Matthew Hennessey
Russia’s war in creating a peace-loving middle
I
Ukraine, Hamas and Iran’s ag- class and deeper diplomatic ties. slamophobia is again the obses-
gression against Israel and The Western bet that expand- sion of progressives and the
China’s threats in the Pacific ing trade would overcome ideo- media. “I know many of you in
are all products of the grand logical differences and political the Muslim-American community,
ambitions of evil imperial re- rivalries was wrong. States en- the Arab-American community, the
gimes. gage in trade to become wealthy Palestinian-American community,
The West has cultivated illu- and competitive, not peaceful. and so many others, are outraged,
sions that have allowed these Often they want to be wealthy saying to yourself, here we go
threats to rise and have left it so they can attack their enemies again with Islamophobia and dis-
unprepared. Three in particular and dominate others. As Russia trust we saw after 9/11,” President
are deeply ingrained in the has done with Europe since Pe- Biden said in his Oct. 19 prime-time
American and European mind- ter the Great, China now is pur- address. The Council on American-
sets. suing more trade with the U.S. Islamic Relations says it has re-
The first is that leaders are to gain an advantage over its ceived complaints from Muslims
responsible for wars and these commercial partner. facing “a hostile work environ-
MARTIN KOZLOWSKI
countries are our rivals only be- Trade also fosters the desire ment” caused by employers’ “Islam-
cause of their bad leaders. Sec- for power. Many states that ophobic and anti-Palestinian mes-
retary of State Antony Blinken traded and grew economically saging.”
said of the Ukraine invasion at as a result developed large Horsefeathers. Islamophobia isn’t
the United Nations Security power-projection capabilities, real. I defy anyone to prove its ex-
Council in September 2022: “One yond the Kremlin. The result is that United Nations and was willing to most often through navies. Venice in istence. Same goes for homophobia,
man chose this war. And one man Russia can incur massive casual- postpone hard negotiations with the 11th century, Britain in the 17th, transphobia and xenophobia. These
can end it.” ties—recently around 1,000 a day, Moscow to have it participate in the Germany and the U.S. at the turn of political “phobias” are all fictions.
But the war isn’t only Vladimir according to some estimates—with- founding of the U.N. Western lead- the 20th—each backed its commerce They are cynically potent neolo-
Putin’s; it is Russia’s war. In a June out much political backlash. ers hoped China would become a re- with a powerful navy, leading to gisms designed to equate conserva-
2022 poll, 75% of Russians either The hostility of Russia, Iran, sponsible stakeholder in the global great clashes. tism with mental illness.
definitely or mostly supported the China and even Hamas can have order once a member of institutions Military might, not interdepen- Racism exists. So do sexism, al-
actions of Russia’s military forces. deep cultural roots and popular sup- such as the World Trade Organiza- dence, gives states the ability to act coholism and many other bad isms.
port that allows these actors to en- tion. in their best interests without con- People can be cruel to each other—
gage in lengthy and devastating But like Russia, a permanent straints imposed by other powers. and to themselves—in classifiable
Bad leaders alone don’t conflicts. Removing a bad leader or member of the U.N. Security Coun- Our rivals have been arming while ways. We have flaws rooted in hu-
regime doesn’t necessarily turn an cil, China hasn’t become a benign the West, Europe especially, hoped manity’s fallen nature that we
cause conflict, global enemy into a responsible actor. geopolitical actor after participating that trade would render military ca- should all try to overcome. But the
governance has failed, and The second illusion is that inter- for more than two decades in the pabilities useless. phobias that politicians and jour-
national organizations and global WTO. The formative power of inter- Deep enmities can’t be tran- nalists bandy about are phony.
trade doesn’t create peace. governance can overcome conten- national institutions has been scended through leadership They exist only to stigmatize ordi-
tious national and regional politics. greatly exaggerated, and the grand changes, international organizations nary political thought and intimi-
Because these institutions are the strategy based on it has left the or trade. They can be checked, and date people into silence.
One respondent asserted that “war sources of international order for West unprepared for the hard com- when necessary defeated, only Begin at the beginning: Fear and
is the locomotive of history” and many Western policy makers, the petition, including war, in front of through military power. hatred aren’t the same. Both are
that it was time for Russia to assert primary objective of their diplomacy us. powerful emotions. Some relation-
its independence. The Russian Or- is to bring more states, democracies The third illusion is that greater Mr. Grygiel is a professor of poli- ship exists between them. But they
thodox Church is an instigator of or not, under their pacifying um- trade and wealth produce peace. For tics at the Catholic University of aren’t synonyms. Where they occur
the war and has formed a deep cul- brella. President Franklin D. Roose- decades German foreign policy has America, a senior adviser at the together, fear generally comes first.
ture of Russian nationalism and im- velt hoped the Soviet Union would followed the principle of “change Marathon Initiative and a visiting It’s a natural response to danger.
perial entitlement that extends be- behave better once it joined the through trade.” Berlin thought trad- fellow at the Hoover Institution. Fear comes from the gut. Its pur-
pose is to activate the instinct for
self-protection. When someone tells
The First Amendment Threat in the Trump Civil Case you not to be afraid even though
every cell in your body is saying
you should be, chances are good
By Philip Hamburger degree of culpability typically re- Mr. Trump’s case could therefore trast. This is liability without culpa- that person has an agenda.
quired for fraud is intent to deceive, become an important precedent. In bility—that is, without intent, reck- We often hate the things we’re
C
an the government penalize the Executive Law requires neither U.S. v. Alvarez (2012), the Supreme lessness or mere negligence. It afraid of precisely because of how
someone for an inaccurate intent, recklessness or negligence. Court emphatically declared that the ordinarily is reserved for especially fear makes us feel and behave.
statement that wasn’t made This means the law can punish mere Constitution “rejects the notion that dangerous conduct, not words alone, Someone suffering from claustro-
with bad intent, recklessness or negli- untruth without any prior culpabil- false speech should be in a general and requires proof that the hazard- phobia might have an emotional
gence, and that didn’t cause concrete ity or subsequent concrete harm. category that is presumptively un- ous conduct caused actual harm. breakdown at the mere thought of
harm to an identifiable third party? As Judge Arthur Engoron ex- protected.” The court now needs to The Executive Law imposes strict li- being confined in a small room. He
That’s the First Amendment question plained in Mr. Trump’s case in Sep- clarify that laws against mere inac- ability simply for words, without may say he hates it, but what he
underlying the civil-fraud suit against tember, a “lack of fraudulent intent” curacy are fully protected, even proof of tangible damage to any in- really means is he’s terrified. The
Donald Trump. The stakes are high and a “failure to allege losses” when regulating business speech. dividual. fear and the hatred aren’t one.
for the former president—and for the aren’t relevant under the Executive This is especially necessary in New Although Ms. James’s case
rest of us. Law. He even imposed sanctions on York, where attorneys general have against Mr. Trump concerns his
New York’s Attorney Gen. Letitia Mr. Trump’s lawyers, fining them interpreted the Executive Law to real-estate valuations, much more is Political cynics use the
James has charged Mr. Trump under $7,500 each for questioning these reach dissenting scientific and polit- at stake. Progress depends on the
the state’s Executive Law for alleg- ical opinion, notably in their pro- willingness of scientists and the rest term to make normal
edly overstating his business’s real- ceedings against ExxonMobil for its of us to try out conclusions that human reactions to terror
estate assets. The statute, however, New York’s Executive Law climate research. may be wrong. By targeting merely
seem crazy or bigoted.
has long been constitutionally sus- To understand the Executive inaccurate speech, the Executive
pect. Although historically only threatens to suppress Law’s threat to free speech, con- Law thus undermines the founda-
courts or their grand juries could is- scientific and political as sider that even perjury isn’t defined tions of scientific inquiry and intel-
sue subpoenas, the law grants the simply in terms of falsity. The gov- lectual exploration. As evidenced by Modern progressives relish the
state’s attorney general a subpoena well as commercial speech. ernment must prove that a defen- the state’s proceedings against Exx- opportunity to pathologize conser-
power to fish through private docu- dant willfully recited under oath onMobil, the statute endangers the vative views, diagnosing those who
ments. Worse, the statute autho- what he didn’t believe to be true. commercial exploration of scientific hold them as sick or crazy. When
rizes Ms. James to bring a civil- points and declaring their doubts The crime isn’t merely the falsity of ideas and threatens the progressive used effectively, a term like “Islam-
fraud suit for inaccurate statements “frivolous.” Judge Engoron didn’t his statement but also his intent to improvement of the human condi- ophobia” freezes its target, forcing
discovered in the process. pause to consider that in targeting tell a falsehood. tion. a denial of prejudice. A denial that
Common-law fraud doesn’t pun- mere inaccuracy—let alone on the The subsequent harm is generic— Rarely has there been a better is awkward or unconvincing can be
ish mere inaccuracy. It requires the basis of a nonjudicial fishing expedi- i.e., damage to society, not a con- opportunity to challenge the Exec- a debate-ender.
plaintiff to prove the defendant tion—the Executive Law might be crete injury to a specific person— utive Law for its assault on our We can tell that this is a parti-
knowingly made a false statement of profoundly dangerous, even uncon- but the government must show, freedom of speech. Whatever New san phenomenon because the pho-
material fact with intent to deceive, stitutional. beyond a reasonable doubt, that the York’s attorney general may say, bia diagnoses only run one way.
and that the victim was injured by The statute is utterly dispropor- defendant acted with bad intent. we have a right to be wrong. Mr. Liberals claim to be afraid of ram-
his reliance on the false statement. tionate, authorizing the court to shut Moreover, perjury’s domain is con- Trump should ask the courts to pant gun violence, but they don’t
The Executive Law, by contrast, down a defendant’s entire business— fined. Rather than generally regu- vindicate that right, for his sake describe themselves as suffering
defines fraud to include something simply for inaccuracy. The law is so late private speech, perjury is lim- and ours. from “gunphobia.” The other guys
as slight as a “false pretense” in the draconian that few have challenged ited to sworn court testimony and, are crazy, not us.
course of business—adding only it. What defendant would want to by extension, statements made to Mr. Hamburger teaches at Colum- No one is afraid of Islam per se,
that the statement be “repeated” or dispute the attorney general’s author- officials. bia Law School and is CEO of the which is what the word “Islamo-
otherwise “persistent.” Whereas the ity given the risk of retaliation? Strict liability offers another con- New Civil Liberties Alliance. phobia” implies. I have met many
Christians, Jews, Hindus, Buddhists
and atheists who are intrigued by
AI Won’t Stop People From Playing Games Islam, curious about its theology
and teachings. I have never met
anyone who is afraid of it.
By Bruce Pandolfini who now worry that AI will leave or Deep Blue. But knowing Michael tasks will be replaced by AI. Legal But many people fear becoming
And Max Raskin them unemployed. Jordan exists doesn’t prevent briefs and accounting memos writ- the victims of Islamic terrorism.
We are a student-teacher pair. pickup basketball games. ten by AI programs are already They are afraid of being killed in
T
oday’s existential questions Mr. Pandolfini watched the Ka- Creatives have spent too much comparable in quality to their hu- their homes or their offices, on the
about artificial intelligence sparov-Deep Blue match in person, time obsessing over the question man-generated counterparts. This street or at the theater, by wild-
began in 1997 over a chess- while Mr. Raskin started learning posed most famously by mathema- may concern lawyers and accoun- eyed jihadists hopped up on syn-
board. That year, world champion the game later that year. Those tician Alan Turing: Can we distin- tants, although we imagine they’ll thetic amphetamines. They are
Garry Kasparov lost to a computer who watched the match knew how guish between what is produced by afraid of car bombs and subway
named Deep Blue, forcing the chess the story would end. At some point, a computer and what is produced stabbings. They are afraid of guys
world to grapple with the limits of if not in 1997, the algorithm would by a human? Instead, we should Maybe a computer can shouting “Allahu Akbar!” while
human talent. Instead of collapsing, be victorious. But that hasn’t di- ask: Why do we engage in these beat a human at chess, but filming themselves slaughtering in-
chess flourished, with more play- minished our zeal for the game. pursuits in the first place? nocent people.
ers, games and communities than Most people know someone out We all take joy in play—in prac- where’s the fun in that? I know a lot of people who are
ever. That should encourage the there can beat them, be it Norwe- ticing a game and learning its angry that this happened last
screenwriters, poets and artists gian chess master Magnus Carlsen rules, in bonding with a coach and month. They have noticed that sim-
team, in the excitement of the con- do just fine. But in the world of ilar atrocities have been happening
test and its result. Fans take joy in play, good chess instructors, like all with frequency for decades. They
connection. Deadheads didn’t fol- coaches, impart the lesson early hate that it never seems to stop.
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY low the Grateful Dead around be- that winning isn’t everything. It’s rational to be afraid of Is-
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson cause the band accurately repli- When grandmaster Tigran Petro- lamic terror. It’s understandable to
Executive Chairman, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp cated studio tracks; they expected sian blundered his queen in a 1956 be angry about the World Trade
Emma Tucker Almar Latour experiences that were real, not per- match, he was still poised to win. Center, Bali, Madrid, London, Paris,
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher
fect. But having marred a masterpiece, the Boston Marathon, San Bernar-
Liz Harris, Managing Editor DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: Play is the sign of an advanced he chose to resign instead. The art- dino, Charlie Hebdo, the Manches-
Charles Forelle, Deputy Editor in Chief Daniel Bernard, Chief Experience Officer;
Elena Cherney, News; Chip Cummins, Newswires; Mae M. Cheng, EVP, General Manager,
civilization not solely concerned with istry was more important than the ter Arena, the Brussels Metro, the
Andrew Dowell, Asia; Taneth Evans, Associate Leadership; David Cho, Barron’s Editor in Chief; survival. Philosopher Leon Kass outcome. Maybe a computer can Orlando nightclub, Salman Rush-
Editor; Brent Jones, Culture, Training & Jason P. Conti, General Counsel, Chief wrote that “liberated from the cares play chess better than we can. die—the list goes on.
Outreach; Alex Martin, Print & Writing; Compliance Officer; Dianne DeSevo, Chief People
Michael W. Miller, Features & Weekend; Officer; Frank Filippo, Chief Transformation of everyday life, spectators are given Maybe it could have written this It isn’t wrong to hate the people
Emma Moody, Standards; Prabha Natarajan, Officer; David Martin, Chief Revenue Officer, privileged access to some of life’s article. But where is the fun in who live streamed the slaughter of
Professional Products; Bruce Orwall, Enterprise; Business Intelligence; Elizabeth O’Melia, Chief deepest truths. . . . Sport invites and that? entire families on Oct. 7. It isn’t a
Philana Patterson, Audio; Michael Siconolfi, Financial Officer; Dan Shar, EVP, General
Investigations; Amanda Wills, Video Manager, Wealth & Investing; Ashok Sinha, SVP, rewards not only game-specific skills, phobia to abhor senseless death de-
Head of Communications; Josh Stinchcomb, EVP but also the indispensable virtues of Mr. Pandolfini is U.S. Chess Fed- livered in the name of God. It may
Paul A. Gigot
Editor of the Editorial Page
& Chief Revenue Officer, WSJ | Barron’s Group; determination, discipline, courage, eration national master and a chess even be laudable.
Sherry Weiss, Chief Marketing Officer
Gerard Baker, Editor at Large
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS:
endurance, enterprise, perspicacity, teacher. Mr. Raskin is an adjunct
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y., 10036 and mental toughness.” law professor at New York Univer- Mr. Hennessey is the Journal’s
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES Some say all human cognitive sity. deputy editorial features editor.
.
WORLD NEWS
NAND flash‡
Forecast $600 billion Projections
400
the U.S. government, which is The company cited growing in many products ranging 4
BY CORINNE RAMEY spending billions on expand- demand related to artificial in- from PCs and smartphones to
ing chip production. telligence and new personal data centers and cars. 300
Prosecutors and defense at- In recent weeks, executives computers and smartphones The prospect of a healthier 3
torneys clashed over whether at Intel, Taiwan Semiconduc- incorporating more memory as industry is also reassuring to 200
FTX founder Sam Bankman- tor Manufacturing Co. and reasons for optimism. the U.S. government. Under
Fried was a liar who stole bil- Samsung Electronics have ex- “We think that the current last year’s Chips and Science 2
100
lions of dollars—or an uncon- pressed confidence that the recovery that we’re seeing will Act, the U.S. is spending some
ventional executive who made worst is over for the chip in- continue next year,” said Kim $53 billion to promote semi-
mistakes. dustry, which had been in a Jae-june, a Samsung memory- Please turn to page B4 1 0
During his closing argu- prolonged slump. chip executive. 2021 ’22 ’23 ’24 2018 ’20 ’25
ment Wednesday, Assistant South Korea-based Sam- The emerging recovery of Heard on the Street: PC *4Q 2023 is estimate †2023 is an estimate ‡512Gb TLC wafer **DDR4 8Gb
U.S. Attorney Nicolas Roos sung, the world’s largest mem- the semiconductor market boost won’t last............... B12 Sources: TrendForce (prices); IBS (market size)
told jurors that almost a year
ago, when thousands of people
were trying to withdraw their
money from the collapsing
crypto exchange, their dread
Leaders Pledge to Act INSIDE Real-Estate Agents’
To Limit Harms of AI
turned to despair.
“Who was responsible?”
said Roos, who then turned
and pointed his finger at the
Fees to Get Revamp
defense table. “This man,
Samuel Bankman-Fried.” BY SAM SCHECHNER dozen other countries pledged BY NICOLE FRIEDMAN sibility of the biggest changes
The FTX founder’s defense closer cooperation in evaluat- AND LAURA KUSISTO in decades to how Americans
attorney told jurors that pros- BLETCHLEY, U.K.—Here in ing the risks posed by coming buy and sell homes, and the
ecutors were portraying Bank- the English countryside, at an AI systems—called models— Home buyers and sellers costs associated with those
man-Fried as a movie villain. estate where World War II that are more powerful than face the prospect of major transactions.
“In the real world people mis- codebreakers cracked the Na- those available today, and to BUSINESS NEWS changes to how much and in In a report released ahead of
judge things,” Mark Cohen zis’ Enigma encryption ma- consider legal frameworks to Theme-park operators what way they pay their real- the verdict, Ryan Tomasello, a
told the jury. “They make mis- chine, world leaders pledged govern their deployment. estate agents, after Tuesday’s real-estate industry analyst
takes.” to work together to lessen “There is potential for seri-
Six Flags and Cedar verdict against the National with Keefe, Bruyette & Woods,
The arguments came at the risks of a technology they said ous, even catastrophic, harm, Fair are near a deal to Association of Realtors and predicted the lawsuits could
end of the monthlong trial of also poses a grave threat. either deliberate or uninten- merge. B3 large residential brokerages. lead to a 30% reduction in the
Bankman-Fried, 31 years old, Artificial intelligence, they tional, stemming from the Those changes could range $100 billion that Americans
who faces seven criminal said, could in its most ad- most significant capabilities of from minor tweaks to the pay in real-estate commissions
counts, including fraud and vanced forms create cata- these AI models,” the joint commission system to a more every year and push well over
money-laundering offenses. strophic risks in realms in- statement said, citing poten- radical restructuring of the half of the almost 1.6 million
At the defense table, Bank- cluding cybersecurity and tial misuse of powerful AI sys- residential real-estate indus- agents out of the industry.
man-Fried sat flanked by his biotechnology—or even escape tems by bad actors or even try, such as more people buy- “I have a hard time believ-
lawyers, at times his whole human control. loss of control of systems that ing homes without using ing that this could be the ver-
body vibrating under his over- “It is sometimes worthwhile aren’t fully understood and agents or buyers paying their dict and there’s no material
size gray suit. His parents, to take science fiction seri- are hard to predict. agents by the hour. changes,” said Anthony La-
who have been a regular pres- ously,” said Michelle Donelan, The pledge is the first ma- A federal jury in Missouri macchia, whose brokerage La-
ence in the courtroom, were U.K. secretary of state for sci- jor international statement found NAR and large broker- macchia Realty has more than
notably absent from their seat ence, innovation and technol- that echoes warnings over a TECHNOLOGY ages conspired to keep costs ar- 500 agents in six states. “It’s
behind the sketch artists dur- ogy, quoting a codebreaker potential existential risk to Write-downs cast tificially high and awarded $1.8 just what, and when, and what
ing prosecutors’ presentation, who worked at the estate. humanity from powerful new billion in damages, which could does it lead to?”
but returned when their son’s In a statement, issued at AI models.
gloom over the outlook be tripled to more than $5 bil- Nothing has changed yet for
lawyer spoke to the jury. the opening of a two-day sum- Debates about how seriously for wind-power lion under antitrust rules. NAR real-estate agents or for con-
Over nearly four hours, mit that kicked off Wednes- to take those warnings, and companies. B4 has said it plans to appeal. sumers in the middle of trans-
Please turn to page B2 day, the U.S., China and two Please turn to page B4 The verdict raises the pos- Please turn to page B2
.
Real-Estate
Seah, Peter................................B10 vice provided and the commis- going to be more costly mis- “When we return to the bar-
C Laguarta, Ramon...................A6 Shanahan, Pat..........................B6 sion that the broker is get- takes made.” gaining table in 2028, it won’t
Cabana, Mark............................A2 Lamacchia, Anthony.............B1 Su, Lisa.........................................B12 ting,” said Ted Tozer, a just be with the Big Three,
Fees to Get
Cahillane, Steve.......................A2 Lara, Luana Lopes..............B10 Swonk, Diane.............................A2 nonresident fellow at the Ur- Sellers can choose whether but with the Big Five or Big
Calhoun, Dave...........................B6 Lewis, James.............................A6 T ban Institute’s Housing Fi- to offer a commission upfront Six,” Fain said on Sunday
F Litt, Jonathan............................B3 Tessier, Martin..........................B4 nance Policy Center. The most modest of the night.
Ford, Robert................................A6
G-H
M
Mansour, Tarek......................B10
Mould, Russ................................B4
Tomasello, Ryan.......................B1
W
Wettlaufer, Dale......................A6
A Revamp Such a system is likely to
work better for buyers in a
weaker market, when they
outcomes would make it op-
tional for sellers agents to of-
fer upfront to compensate the
Executives at the foreign-
car companies closely moni-
tored union negotiations in
Gelsinger, Pat..................B4,B12 would have more leverage to buyer’s agent. That would Detroit during the strike, con-
Musk, Elon.........................B4,B12 Wirth, Mike...............................A10
Gentile, Tom...............................B6 Continued from page B1 try to get the seller to cover barely differ from the current cerned it might affect their
Gupta, Piyush.........................B10 N-P Z actions. But new commission the cost. In the current mar- scenario because NAR said in business in a tight labor mar-
Hartung, Jack.............................B3 Nipper, Mads..............................B4 Zimmerman, Richard..........B3 policies could come from a va- ket, with tight inventory, sell- recent weeks that sellers ket.
riety of directions. The federal ers may have more leverage agents can make an offer of Foreign-based automakers
trial judge might require not to cover the cost. compensation as low as zero. have long spent less on labor
BUSINESS NEWS
wage for fast-food workers in the company and allow gen- advance of the possible IPO.
California will increase to $20 eral managers at restaurants Panera Brands said in May
an hour from the state’s cur- to operate more efficiently. A that it generated $4.8 billion
rent hourly minimum wage of Panera spokesman said the ef- in sales in its 2022 fiscal year
$15.50. The law applies to fast- forts would improve custom- across its 3,852 locations.
food chains with at least 60
national locations and will
come as the state’s minimum
wage is set to rise to $16 an
hour in January. Chipotle cur-
The company, which pays California workers $17 to $18 an hour, will have to raise that to $20. Kraft Heinz Vows to
rently pays California workers
around $17 to $18 an hour,
said Chief Financial Officer
second-biggest line item and
then you increase it by 20%, it
definitely has an impact.”
gap,” according to Hartung.
Analysts are watching
closely for signals that con-
Meanwhile, he said, companies
directly affected by the change
may feel pressure to lift pay
Avoid Item Discounts
Jack Hartung. Hartung added, “It’s signif- sumers are pulling back with elsewhere in their restaurants.
The higher wages are icant enough that it puts a inflation and interest rates up “They can’t have compres- BY JESSE NEWMAN prepandemic promotional lev-
poised to hit as Chipotle’s la- dent in our economics.” and pandemic-era savings sion of their [hourly workers] els, or offer discounts that
bor costs have risen consider- To offset the higher costs, dwindling. Chipotle’s custom- to the people who have been Inflation-weary shoppers hurt profitability.
ably in the past few years, Chipotle will raise menu ers so far continue to spend, there for a while, so every- are resisting higher grocery The company said it is still
with the competitive market prices in California. The com- with the company’s compara- body’s pay has to go up,” ac- prices, but Kraft Heinz is battling pockets of inflation
pushing workers’ pay up. The pany is still assessing the im- ble restaurant sales, which cording to Palmer. But with vowing not to discount its tied to labor, tomatoes and
company spent $616.3 million pact of the law, but Hartung typically look at transactions Chipotle’s menu prices tending products too much. sugar. Prices for its products
on labor globally for the quar- said California menu prices in restaurants open for at to fall below its peers, the com- Company president and were 7 percentage points
ter ended Sept. 30, up around will likely increase in the mid- least 13 full months, increas- pany is in a “good spot” to soon-to-be CEO Carlos higher in the third quarter
10.5% from the prior-year pe- to high-single-digit range. ing by 5% for the quarter raise prices to a level that Abrams-Rivera on Wednesday compared with year-ago levels,
riod and an increase of more This would follow a 3% price ended Sept. 30. Net income will offset higher labor costs, said price increases across while volumes and the mix of
than 50% from the same pe- increase last month, the com- rose to $313.2 million in the he said. three-quarters of the com- products sold fell 5 percentage
riod in 2020. The law in Cali- pany’s first national price lift three-month period, compared Chipotle is sensitive to the pany’s portfolio and reduced points.
fornia, where roughly 15% of in over a year. with $257.1 million a year ear- fact that some consumers’ food-stamp benefits have pres- The maker of sliced cheese
Chipotle’s more than 3,300 The finance chief doesn’t lier, and revenue increased wallets are under pressure, sured demand, but that Kraft and ketchup reported sales of
restaurants are located, will currently see a need to pull 11.3% to $2.47 billion. Hartung said, particularly in a Heinz would stay disciplined $6.6 billion, up 1% from a year
increase overall labor costs by additional levers in response For companies with fast- key demographic who are fac- when it comes to promotions. ago. The food maker’s adjusted
between 2.5% and 3% next to the higher minimum wage, food workers in California, ana- ing the resumption of student Kraft Heinz stock climbed profit of 72 cents a share beat
year, according to Hartung. such as opening fewer-than- lysts are looking at how the loan payments. But customers more than 2% on Wednesday. the 66 cents a share Wall
In California, the CFO said, planned new restaurants in wage change may hit finan- have so far stomached the in- The company said it is Street analysts had expected.
those costs will rise on aver- California, unless customers cials. Those companies that creased prices, said Hartung, planning for a higher level of Kraft Heinz raised its out-
age by 15% to 20%. “That’s a resist pricing actions. “But the don’t fall within the remit of adding that the recent pricing promotions in its current look for adjusted earnings per
huge hit,” said Hartung, add- reality is, every restaurant the law may find it more diffi- action was relatively modest. quarter, which overlaps with share in 2023 but said organic
ing that labor is Chipotle’s company in California is prob- cult to hire if they can’t meet “The average chicken bur- the winter holidays—but exec- sales growth would come in
second-highest cost at the res- ably going to have to take a the hourly $20 wage floor, said rito costs $9,” he noted. “So utives said volume trends toward the lower end of its
taurant level, behind only similar increase, so we will Evercore ISI food and restau- 3% means it’s going to be were improving and that the previously stated range of 4%
food. “Any time you take the probably still keep our value rant analyst David Palmer. about a quarter more.” company wouldn’t revert to to 6%.
– MAKES A –
GREAT GIFT
TYLER DANE HANSEN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Six Flags has been pursuing a turnaround that includes lifting prices and investing in its parks.
world have set ambitious tar- state’s power coming from re- in Virginia. And Orsted con-
gets to increase the share of newables by 2035. firmed its final investment de-
renewables in their energy “The industry isn’t in a cision into Revolution Wind, an
mixes, but good shape,” said Martin Tess- offshore 704-megawatt project
SUSTAINABLE their plans are ier, Stifel’s vice president of in Connecticut and Rhode Is-
BUSINESS now under equity research for utilities land. Orsted’s CEO told analysts
pressure as and renewables. “I think we’ll the company has confidence in
wind developers face a surge see a softening of long-term Orsted scrapped projects in New Jersey citing supply-chain problems and high interest rates. its portfolio of European and
in financing costs. targets…and less projects will Asia Pacific construction and
Orsted, BP and Equinor be developed in the long term.” to renegotiate power-purchase agreements for an 804-mega- fall said earlier this year that development properties.
collectively written off $4.8 Project owners usually sign terms to reflect inflationary watt wind-farm project known it saw project costs rising up In Europe, policy makers
billion against U.S. offshore long-term deals outlining pressures and permitting de- as Park City Wind in Connecti- to 40% and it booked an im- recently released an action
wind projects in recent days. terms to sell electricity or se- lays. Equinor, BP’s partner on cut due to financial challenges. pairment for halting the de- plan to address the sector’s
Danish renewable-energy cure subsidies before con- the Empire Wind and Beacon SouthCoast Wind—a joint ven- velopment of the Norfolk Bo- mounting challenges.
company Orsted said Tuesday struction starts. Some are now Wind projects, booked an im- ture between Shell New Ener- reas wind farm in the U.K.
that it booked an impairment lamenting that these terms pairment of around $300 mil- gies US and Ocean Winds Germany’s Siemens Energy
charge of 28.4 billion Danish
kroner, equivalent to $4.02
billion, against its U.S. off-
don’t reflect increased costs
and say their projects aren’t
viable anymore.
lion on its U.S. portfolio. The
companies said they are as-
sessing the impact of the reg-
North America—said it would
terminate PPAs for a planned
project in Massachusetts due to
warned of worse-than-ex-
pected 2024 losses in its
wind-turbine business as it
WSJ PRO
shore portfolio and abandoned
the development of two wind
Earlier this week, BP
booked a $540 million pretax
ulators’ decision on their fu-
ture development plans.
a significant increase in pro-
jected capital expenditures and
works through quality issues
and ramp-up challenges.
SUSTAINABLE
projects off the coast of New impairment charge on three Other projects have been finance costs. Ocean Winds was “The economics of wind are BUSINESS
Jersey—Ocean Wind 1 and 2— wind projects off the coast of canceled. Earlier in October, created by Portugal’s EDP Ren- proving more difficult thanks to wsj.com/pro/
due to spiraling costs and sup- New York after regulators re- Iberdrola subsidiary Avangrid ovaveis and France’s Engie. higher costs of capital and sustainable-business
plier delays. Orsted previously jected the company’s request scrapped power-purchase Swedish developer Vatten- higher interest rates,” said Russ
The Marketplace
ADVERTISEMENT
DOJ Probes Live Nation Pacts With Venues
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds BY ANNE STEELE events, and what restrictions The investigation began last and that use its Ticketmaster
AND DAVE MICHAELS those agreements might in- year and gained momentum in service.
clude, are among the practices November 2022 after Ticket- “We do not understand DOJ
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES The Justice Department’s in- the Justice Department is master, which Live Nation ac- to be investigating any idea
vestigation of Live Nation is probing. It is also exploring quired in 2010, crashed during that it could be anticompetitive
focusing on whether the com- whether the company’s agree- a fan presale to Taylor Swift’s for us to pay artists more than
Innovative Branded Footwear Company pany uses anticompetitive ments restrict venues’ ability Eras Tour. A Justice Depart- others,” a Live Nation spokes-
Mid-Atlantic U.S. agreements with venues and to work with other promoters ment spokeswoman declined to woman said. “Artists get paid
other partners to book top tal- or ticket services. comment. based on competitive bidding,
Seeking buyer for two flagship brands, e-commerce platform, ent and serve as the ticketing Live Nation’s heft and nego- Competitors say Live Nation and it would be strange, to say
extensive retail network, inventory provider for their shows, ac- tiating power in concert pro- pays artists much more than the least, for antitrust agencies
Nationally recognized designer and distributor of on-trend footwear cording to people familiar with motion, ticketing and venues— other promoters can afford, to say that anyone should pay
products with a 100 year+ operating history. Multi-channel the matter. including buildings it owns— and is able to do so because it artists less.”
distribution network including 2,300 accounts (over 600 active) The deals that Live Nation are at the heart of the antitrust makes money by routing shows —Brent Kendall contributed
and a proprietary D2C e-commerce platform. The ideal buyer will offers artists to land their investigation, the people said. through venues that it controls to this article.
fund the upcoming seasonal inventory commitments.
Sale process already underway.
Chips Look
Contact: Debbie Beall 2022 with rising inflation and
(443) 951-4854 • specialsituations@schgroup.com the war in Ukraine among
other factors. Consumers and
NOTICE OF SALE ANNOUNCEMENTS
To Rebound corporate tech departments
pulled back spending, and
many electronics makers were
NOTICE OF UCC PUBLIC AUCTION SALE
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE, that in accordance with applicable
provisions of the Uniform Commercial Code of the States
of Delaware and New York (as applicable), VP IRVINE
LENDER LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the
Your Life Story
For Family. For Generations.
After Bust left with too much inventory.
Semiconductor firms—with
the exception of those closely
“Secured Party”), will sell at public auction all limited tied to the artificial-intelli-
Professional Biographers Write
liability company interests (the “Equity Interests”) held
by (i) 18831 VON KARMAN MILANI LLC, a Delaware Your Book OR We Help You Write. Continued from page B1 gence boom, such as Nvidia—
limited liability company (the “Milani Pledgor”), in
18831 VON KARMAN IRVINE DELAWARE MEZZ LLC, a Affordable & Personalized Service. conductor manufacturing, and cut production, delayed in-
Delaware limited liability company (the “Milani Pledged LegaciesandMemories.com U.S. allies including European vestments and instituted
Entity”) and (ii) 17422 DERIAN PISTOIA LLC, a Delaware
limited liability company (the “Pistoia Pledgor”, (904) 293-9893 * Since 1999 nations, Japan and South Ko- hiring freezes and layoffs. Op-
AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES
ADVERTISE
Leaders Vow speculative risks are a distrac- feared AI could be used as harms she said already exist—
and will not resell the Equity Interests unless pursuant
to a valid registration under applicable federal and/
or state securities laws, or a valid exemption from the tion from current problems— part of an arms race between such as bias, discrimination or
registration thereunder. The Equity Interests have not
been registered under such securities laws and cannot TODAY such as protecting elections the world’s superpowers. its ability to spread misinfor-
To Reduce
be sold by the winning bidder(s) without registration or
application of a valid exemption. The Equity Interests will from AI-created false videos. Wu Zhaohui, China’s vice mation. Several of those is-
be offered for sale at the Public Auction “as-is, where-
is”, and there are no express or implied warranties or
(800) 366-3975 “If you spend that much minister of science and tech- sues were targeted by a U.S.
representations relating to title, possession, quiet time worrying about some- nology, said at the summit executive order signed earlier
For more information
AI Harms
enjoyment, merchantability, fitness, or the like as to the
Equity Interests. The Equity Interests will be sold as a thing out there, you spend less that the country supported in- this week.
single lot, and will not be divided or sold in any lesser
amounts. THIS NOTICE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN
visit: time worrying about stuff ternational work to establish Those concerns also have
OFFER TO SELL, NOR THE SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER
TO BUY, THE EQUITY INTERESTS TO OR FROM ANYONE
wsj.com/classifieds right in front of your nose,” testing and assessment sys- been echoed by some digital-
IN ANY JURISDICTION IN WHICH SUCH AN OFFER OR
SOLICITATION IS NOT AUTHORIZED.
Clegg said Tuesday. tems for AI. rights and labor groups, which
All bids (other than credit bids of the Secured Party) Continued from page B1 On Wednesday, the U.S. The threat of an AI apoca- issued an open letter criticiz-
must be for cash. In order for a prospective bidder (other
than the Secured Party) to be deemed qualified and what to do about them, are the said it would create an AI lypse at the hand of godlike ing the summit’s priorities.
eligible to bid at the Public Sale, such prospective bidder
must provide an earnest money deposit in the amount main agenda of the meeting, Safety Center as part of its machines has long been an ob- “This is about being fired
of at least $5,000,000.00, which may be in the form of a
money order, certified or cashier’s check or wire transfer
which includes a U.S. delegation Commerce Department, pledg- ject of pop culture fascination. from your job by algorithm, or
to an escrow account, as more fully detailed in the Terms led by Vice President Kamala ing that it would work with a But since the release of Open- unfairly profiled for a loan
of Public Sale. Within two (2) business days of the Public
Sale, the successful bidder (other than the Secured Harris, as well as executives counterpart in the U.K. to set AI’s ChatGPT, which show- based on your identity or
Party) must deliver an additional deposit so that, when
added to the original earnest money deposit, the total from leading AI companies, in- standards for benchmarking cased the new technology’s postcode,” the letter read.
deposit equals ten percent (10%) of the successful bid,
with the balance to be delivered within ten business
cluding Elon Musk and OpenAI the capabilities of AI systems, uncanny ability to produce “Small businesses and artists
(10) days of the Public Sale, including the payment of all Chief Executive Sam Altman. and gathering reporting data plausible and fluid answers to are being squeezed out, and
transfer taxes, stamp duties and similar taxes incurred
in connection with the purchase of the Equity Interests. Both of the tech executives from AI companies. questions on nearly any topic, innovation smothered.”
Parties interested in bidding on the Equity Interests
must contact Brock Cannon, Secured Party’s broker, have warned of what they say The U.K. also announced fu- it has also become a subject of
Cannon of Newmark & Company Real Estate Inc., d/b/a is the potentially destructive ture plans for AI safety sum- debate over what priorities
Newmark (“Broker”), via email at brock.cannon@nmrk.
com. Upon execution of a standard non-disclosure potential of AI, which they are mits to be hosted in South Ko- policy makers should set. Watch a Video
agreement, additional documentation and information
will be available. Interested parties who do not contact separately trying to build. rea and France the next year. In a speech Wednesday, Scan this code
Broker and register before the Public Sale will not
be permitted to participate in bidding at the Public
Others, including Meta China’s involvement in the Harris said experts should ex- to watch a
Sale. Additional information can be found at https:// Platforms policy executive and summit is seen as notable by pand their definition of AI video on
rimarketplace.com/listing/50791/ucc-disposition-
sale-indirect-interest-in-a-multifamily-development- © 2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. former U.K. deputy prime min- Western officials and industry safety to look at a broader set whether AI can
portfolio-irvine-ca. All Rights Reserved.
ister Nick Clegg, said those executives, as some have of risks including the societal think.
.
ADVERTISEMENT
BUSINESS NEWS
FELINE LIM/REUTERS
most problematic suppliers. ing accounts for nearly two- in which the plane maker have been a source of friction, gained a reputation as an op-
His mission: shape up man- thirds of Spirit’s sales; making would pay higher rates and and the two have sparred over erational fixer skilled at get-
ufacturing at Wichita, Kan.- up much of the rest are Boe- provide Spirit with a $100 mil- pricing and production. Spirit ting supply chains and pro-
based Spirit AeroSystems af- ing’s chief rival, Airbus, and de- lion cash infusion to increase executives say Boeing’s pric- duction on track. He was
ter a series of mishaps have fense contractors. Pat Shanahan. 737 and 787 production. ing demands have saddled it viewed as a contender to run
disrupted operations at Boe- Shanahan, 61 years old, Spirit shares closed up with contracts that are unsus- Boeing’s defense and commer-
ing, slowing production and said in an interview that the “The advantage I have is nearly 8% Wednesday. Its tainable. cial units before he left in
leaving the plane maker short decades he spent working that I speak the language of stock is up about 40% since The supplier’s problems, 2017 to work as deputy to Jim
of jets it promised to deliver with Spirit as a Boeing execu- the customer,” Shanahan said. Spirit struck the deal with from a brief labor strike ear- Mattis, who was then defense
to airlines. tive positioned him to make “And we can be brutally hon- Boeing, but down about 20% lier this year to production secretary. He later served as
“Right now, there’s no per- needed changes. He has sat on est with one another where year to date. flaws with its fuselages used acting defense secretary for six
son more important to Boeing Spirit’s board since 2021. He we see deficiencies, and our “The selection of Pat at ex- in Boeing’s 737 MAX jets, are months and was the Trump
than Pat,” said Jim Albaugh, said he has recruited several teams can collaborate to re- actly this moment in time to reverberating throughout the administration’s pick to suc-
who once ran Boeing’s com- retired Boeing executives to solve them.” sort of get them really focused industry. ceed Mattis but withdrew from
mercial airplane unit during work at the supplier. Spirit on Wednesday said it on factory performance, I’m Last week Boeing blamed consideration.
FEATURED SPEAKERS
Anand Giridharadas
Author, “Winners Take All”; “The Persuaders”
PRESENTING SPONSORS The Wall Street Journal CEO Council will convene
in Washington on Dec. 11 and 12 just weeks ahead of
the crucial 2024 presidential primaries. Policy makers
and executives will discuss the most pressing themes
of the moment, including the geopolitical landscape,
the economy, energy and sustainability and how those
forces will influence business and the battle for the White
House. We’ll explore the outlook for artificial intelligence,
as well as opportunities, risks and regulatory efforts
in the nascent space. And we’ll zoom in on the key
challenges facing CEOs as they navigate ever-shifting
workplace dynamics.
CONTRIBUTING SPONSOR
MEMBERSHIP IS BY INVITATION
CEOCouncil@wsj.com.
© 2023 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ9157
.
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
33274.58 s 221.71, or 0.67% Trailing P/E ratio 24.29 19.91 4237.86 s 44.06, or 1.05% Trailing P/E ratio * 20.14 18.68 13061.47 s 210.23, or 1.64% Trailing P/E ratio *† 28.92 23.35
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 18.08 17.47 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 18.55 17.03 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate *† 25.15 21.14
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.18 2.22 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield * 1.68 1.75 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield *† 0.93 0.99
All-time high 36799.65, 01/04/22 All-time high 4796.56, 01/03/22 All-time high: 16057.44, 11/19/21
COMMODITIES wsj.com/market-data/commodities
Closing Chg YTD SPDR S&PMdCpTr MDY 435.00 0.57 –1.8 High-yield issues with the biggest price increases…
Wednesday, November 1, 2023 SPDR S&P Div SDY 112.21 0.24 –10.3 Bond Price as % of face value
ETF Symbol Price (%) (%)
Closing Chg YTD TechSelectSector XLK 167.18 1.93 34.3 Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
ETF Symbol Price (%) (%) iSh1-5YIGCorpBd IGSB 49.74 0.45 –0.2 VangdInfoTech VGT 414.49 1.64 29.8
CnsmrDiscSelSector XLY 153.98 1.24 19.2 iSh1-3YTreaBd SHY 80.98 0.22 –0.2 VangdSC Val VBR 152.77 0.66 –3.8 Toledo Hospital TOLHOS 5.325 9.11 Nov. 15, ’28 85.000 8.13 n.a.
iShRussMC IWR 66.12 0.50 –2.0 VangdExtMkt VXF 135.12 0.58 1.7
ConsStaplesSPDR XLP 67.79 –0.10 –9.1
iShRuss1000 IWB 231.68 1.03 10.1
Lumen Technologies LUMN 7.600 25.05 Sept. 15, ’39 31.938 2.66 26.500
DimenUSCoreEq2 DFAC 25.52 0.71 5.1 VangdDivApp VIG 153.85 0.49 1.3
EnSelSectorSPDR XLE 84.99 –0.23 –2.8 iShRuss1000Grw IWF 266.19 1.56 24.2 VangdFTSEAWxUS VEU 50.70 0.98 1.1 Liberty Interactive LINTA 8.500 43.16 July 15, ’29 28.250 1.96 27.000
iShRuss1000Val IWD 147.13 0.48 –3.0 VangdFTSEDevMk VEA 42.67 1.02 1.7
FinSelSectorSPDR XLF 32.57 0.65 –4.8
iShRussell2000 IWM 165.46 0.57 –5.1 VangdFTSE EM VWO 38.21 0.71 –2.0 Navient NAVI 5.625 10.73 Aug. 1, ’33 69.577 1.78 69.375
HealthCareSelSect XLV 124.80 0.21 –8.1
iShS&P500Grw IVW 67.55 1.17 15.5 VangdFTSE Europe VGK 56.52 0.68 1.9 1.58
IndSelSectorSPDR XLI 98.68 0.33 0.5
iShS&P500Value IVE 152.35 0.87 5.0 VangdGrowth VUG 271.64 1.54 27.5
Xerox XRXCRP 6.750 11.26 Dec. 15, ’39 66.777 67.158
InvscNasd100 QQQM 146.93 1.80 34.1
InvscQQQI QQQ 356.96 1.74 34.1
iShSelectDiv DVY 105.27 0.60 –12.7 VangdHlthCr VHT 226.31 0.23 –8.8 Occidental Petroleum OXY 6.450 6.66 Sept. 15, ’36 98.186 1.06 96.522
iSh7-10YTreaBd IEF 90.37 1.15 –5.6 VangdHiDiv VYM 100.92 0.47 –6.7
InvscS&P500EW RSP 136.29 0.34 –3.5
iShShortTreaBd SHV 110.07 0.03 0.1 VangdIntermBd BIV 71.54 1.04 –3.7
Hughes Satellite Systems … 6.625 12.98 Aug. 1, ’26 85.690 1.04 85.083
iShCoreDivGrowth DGRO 48.44 0.44 –3.1
iShCoreMSCIEAFE IEFA 62.94 0.93 2.1
iShTIPSBondETF TIP 103.24 0.87 –3.0 VangdIntrCorpBd VCIT 75.03 1.15 –3.2 Venture Global Calcasieu Pass VENTGL 4.125 7.27 Aug. 15, ’31 81.520 0.90 80.125
iSh20+YTreaBd TLT 85.10 2.17 –14.5 VangdIntermTrea VGIT 56.80 0.76 –2.9
iShCoreMSCIEM IEMG 46.40 1.00 –0.6
iShCoreMSCITotInt IXUS 58.45 0.97 1.0
iShUSTreasuryBd
iSh0-3MTreaBd
GOVT
SGOV
21.85
100.29
0.81 –3.8
0.02 0.1
VangdLC
VangdMC
VV
VO
193.68
199.22
1.15 11.2
0.41 –2.3
…And with the biggest price decreases
iShCoreS&P500 IVV 424.53 1.09 10.5 JPMEquityPrem JEPI 52.73 0.90 –3.2 VangdMC Val VOE 126.96 0.61 –6.1
iShCoreS&P MC IJH 237.45 0.61 –1.8 Bausch Health BHCCN 11.000 26.53 Sept. 30, ’28 58.655 –2.35 63.470
JPM UltShIncm JPST 50.00 0.04 –0.3 VangdMBS VMBS 43.12 1.37 –5.3
iShCoreS&P SC IJR 89.28 0.44 –5.7 PacerUSCashCows100 COWZ 48.03 0.61 3.8 VangdRealEst VNQ 73.37 0.62 –11.0 Dish DBS … 5.875 16.81 Nov. 15, ’24 90.000 –1.75 93.000
iShCoreS&PTotUS ITOT 92.55 0.96 9.1 ProShUltPrQQQ TQQQ 34.47 5.16 99.2 VangdS&P500ETF VOO 388.40 1.10 10.5
iShCoreTotalUSDBd IUSB 43.20 1.05 –3.9 SPDRBbg1-3MTB BIL 91.44 0.03 –0.0 VangdST Bond BSV 75.15 0.42 –0.2
Navient NAVI 6.125 7.38 March 25, ’24 99.500 –0.38 99.375
iShCoreUSAggBd AGG 93.05 1.10 –4.1 –0.37 101.909
SPDR DJIA Tr DIA 332.68 0.67 0.4 VangdSTCpBd VCSH 74.98 0.46 –0.3 Crown Cork & Seal … 7.375 6.92 Dec. 15, ’26 101.250
iShEdgeMSCIMinUSA USMV 72.20 0.63 0.1 SPDR Gold GLD 183.51 –0.32 8.2 VangdShtTmInfltn VTIP 47.28 0.30 1.2
iShEdgeMSCIUSAQual QUAL 131.18 1.03 15.1 SPDRPtfDevxUS SPDW 30.23 1.04 1.8 VangdShortTrea VGSH 57.56 0.22 –0.4 United States Cellular USM 6.700 7.39 Dec. 15, ’33 95.125 –0.36 93.712
iShGoldTr IAU 37.46 –0.35 8.3 SPDRS&P500Value SPYV 40.90 0.89 5.2 VangdSC VB 178.96 0.51 –2.5
iShiBoxx$HYCpBd HYG 72.87 0.95 –1.0 SPDRPtfS&P500 SPLG 49.72 1.08 10.5 VangdTaxExemptBd VTEB 47.52 0.46 –4.0
Royal Caribbean RCL 7.500 7.97 Oct. 15, ’27 98.438 –0.33 96.750
iShiBoxx$IGCpBd LQD 100.22 1.43 –4.9 SPDRS&P500Growth SPYG 58.55 1.23 15.6 VangdTotalBd BND 68.99 0.97 –4.0 Transocean RIG 6.800 10.74 March 15, ’38 71.440 –0.15 71.722
iShMBS MBB 87.46 1.29 –5.7 SPDR S&P 500 SPY 422.66 1.07 10.5 VangdTotIntlBd BNDX 47.86 0.56 0.9
iShMSCIACWI ACWI 90.92 1.00 7.1 SchwabIntEquity SCHF 33.22 1.03 3.1 VangdTotIntlStk VXUS 52.23 0.99 1.0 Bath & Body Works BBWI 9.375 7.47 July 1, ’25 102.901 –0.10 102.875
iShMSCI EAFE EFA 67.55 0.94 2.9 SchwabUS BrdMkt SCHB 48.98 0.99 9.3 VangdTotalStk VTI 208.86 1.00 9.2
iSh MSCI EM EEM 37.04 0.93 –2.3 SchwabUS Div SCHD 68.15 0.13 –9.8 VangdTotWrldStk VT 91.35 0.98 6.0 *Estimated spread over 2-year, 3-year, 5-year, 10-year or 30-year hot-run Treasury; 100 basis points=one percentage pt.; change in spread shown is for Z-spread.
iShMSCIEAFEValue EFV 47.64 0.87 3.8 SchwabUS LC SCHX 49.87 0.99 10.5 VangdValue VTV 134.86 0.42 –3.9 Note: Data are for the most active issue of bonds with maturities of two years or more
iShNatlMuniBd MUB 101.20 0.43 –4.1 SchwabUS LC Grw SCHG 72.72 1.54 30.9 WisdTrFRTrea USFR 50.34 0.04 0.1 Source: MarketAxess
.
Trading Startup Sues CFTC Over Election-Bet Plan up compliance, I think there
will be a greater investment in
both compliance and due dili-
emphasis on controlling for-
eign access to technology that
could have potential military
gence to try and integrate a implications amid trade and
BY PAUL KIERNAN pair of 27-year-old Massachu- nipulation around an election, presidential election, accord- company quickly and to try to political tensions, especially
AND ALEXANDER OSIPOVICH setts Institute of Technology it then makes the CFTC essen- ing to data scraped by Wake see if there’s any skeletons in with China and Russia.
graduates and backed by Wall tially an election cop,” CFTC Forest University economist the closet.” Deputy Attorney General
WASHINGTON—A financial Street veterans. Chairman Rostin Behnam said Koleman Strumpf. Some buyers and sellers Lisa Monaco emphasized in
startup is turning to the Kalshi says its contracts in October. “And I’m not com- Small-stakes bets on U.S. could obtain representations her Oct. 4 speech announcing
courts to settle a long-running would enable investors to fortable with that.” elections are possible through and warranty coverage for the policy the importance of
debate over whether Ameri- hedge against political risk. It Before George Gallup a variety of venues. their transactions, which helps taking national-security con-
cans should be able to bet on said in the lawsuit that the launched scientific opinion Since the early 1990s, the protect them financially if cerns into account when eval-
U.S. elections. CFTC’s decision to reject its polling in the 1930s, newspa- University of Iowa has been they don’t get what they think uating a target company.
Online-trading startup plan was “arbitrary, capricious pers published data from allowed to operate a small they are getting. Such policies “National security compli-
Kalshi sued the Commodity and otherwise contrary to the bookmakers to provide Ameri- election market for research, typically provide protection ance risks are widespread,
Futures Trading Commission law.” If the U.S. Court of Ap- cans with an idea of who was but wagers are limited to from financial losses resulting they are here to stay, and they
on Wednesday, arguing the peals for the D.C. Circuit ahead in an election, histori- $500 per person. from inaccuracies in areas like should be at the top of every
regulator wrongfully denied its agrees, it could ans say. They New Zealand’s Victoria Uni- financial statements, material company’s compliance risk
application to launch a market clear a path for stopped doing versity runs another small contracts, material customers, chart,” Monaco said.
for derivatives tied to results the largest U.S.- so as polling market called PredictIt, which
of congressional elections. based election Kalshi says the became more won a lawsuit against the
The lawsuit could help de- markets in regulator sophisticated, CFTC this year after the
termine whether Americans nearly a cen- however, and agency tried to shut it.
will be able to bet significant tury, some his- wrongfully betting on elec- In contrast, Kalshi says its
amounts of money on election torians say. tions became congressional-election market
outcomes, after gambling rev- A CFTC
denied its bid to less common. would serve investors and
enue in the U.S. reached a re- spokesman de- launch a market. S e v e ra l businesses looking to hedge
cord last year. Kalshi’s plan clined to com- states outlaw political risk. Some businesses
would let U.S. investors wager ment on the gambling on with a demonstrated need to
on whether Republicans or lawsuit. Agency elections—a hedge could enter trades of as
Democrats will capture the officials have previously ex- fact that was key to the much as $100 million under
SULLIVAN & CROMWELL
House or Senate in a particu- pressed reluctance to wade CFTC’s rejection of Kalshi’s Kalshi’s proposal.
KING & SPALDING
lar year. into what they see as a sensi- plan. The company was co-
The court fight pits a small tive question for U.S. democ- But demand could be high. founded in 2018 by Tarek
federal agency traditionally racy. One overseas platform, Bet- Mansour and Luana Lopes
focused on agriculture mar- “If there is a suspicion or fair.com, handled more than Lara, who studied together at
kets against a startup run by a an allegation of fraud or ma- $2 billion of bets on the 2020 MIT. Deal attorneys Melissa Sawyer and Tim FitzSimons.
Lows Baijiayun
Bakkt
RTC
BKKT
2.42
0.94
2.8
-6.9
Compass COMP
CompassMinerals CMP
1.82 -4.0
23.91 2.6
FreyrBatteryWt FREY.WS
FreyrBattery FREY
0.38 -6.9 IndlTechII Wt
3.08 -1.2 InFinTAcqnWt
ITAQW
IFIN.WS
0.00 -92.5 MatchGroup
0.01 -19.5 MaxeonSolar
MTCH
MAXN
27.85 -15.3 PRA Group
5.70 -7.4 PacBiosciCA
PRAA
PACB
11.85 1.0 SafeguardSci
5.74 -3.4 Sagimet
SFE
SGMT
0.95 -1.0 TopgolfCallaway MODG
3.48 -3.0 Transalta TAC
11.59 -3.6
7.22 2.5
AMTD Digital HKD 3.94 -0.7 Bally's BALY 7.28 -14.8 Conduent CNDT 2.54 -18.5 FTC Solar FTCI 1.02 -1.9 InflaRx IFRX 1.45 -4.1 MedicennaTherap MDNA 0.15 -13.2 PagerDuty PD 19.18 -2.5 SaverOne2014 SVRE 0.33 -2.5 TransMedics TMDX 36.42 1.5
A-MarkPrecMet AMRK 25.52 -3.9 BatteryFutureWt BFAC.WS 0.03 -17.1 ConnexaSports CNXA 0.75 -3.8 Farfetch FTCH 1.41 -2.0 InMedPharm INM 0.44 -4.9 MediciNova MNOV 1.87 -1.6 PagSeguroDig PAGS 6.93 1.1 SchnitzerSteel RDUS 22.34 2.8 TravereTherap TVTX 6.35 3.7
ARBIOT ARBB 0.92 -17.1 BeamGlobal BEEM 5.22 -2.4 Conn's CONN 2.91 1.7 Fathom FTHM 2.58 -6.9 InMode INMD 18.57 -0.4 Medifast MED 67.40 -0.6 ParamountPfdA PARAP 15.13 -1.0 Seer SEER 1.58 -0.6 Tredegar TG 4.35 -2.7
ATA Creativity AACG 0.89 -1.0 BeamrImaging BMR 1.07 -10.7 ContainerStore TCS 1.56 -4.9 FinchTherap FNCH 3.53 -0.6 InnatePharma IPHA 1.81 -12.1 Medigus MDGS 2.90 -6.5 ParamountB PARA 10.51 -0.7 SenesTech SNES 0.28 -1.8 TrilogyMetals TMQ 0.43 -4.8
AXT AXTI 1.90 -3.0 BeautyHealth SKIN 3.90 -2.2 ContraFect CFRX 0.26 -12.3 FiverrIntl FVRR 20.04 -3.2 InnovAge INNV 5.04 -4.6 MesaAir MESA 0.43 -6.2 ParamountA PARAA 13.40 -2.4 SensataTech ST 30.81 -0.7 Trimble TRMB 39.57 -13.1
Accolade ACCD 6.33 2.9 Big5SportingGds BGFV 5.36 -22.5 CoreCard CCRD 16.61 -21.9 FlexSolInt FSI 1.89 -0.5 Inotiv NOTV 1.80 -2.6 MesaLabs MLAB 87.77 -5.1 PaycomSoftware PAYC 146.88 -38.5 SensusHealthcare SRTS 2.05 -3.2 Tripadvisor TRIP 14.15 -3.2
AcumenPharm ABOS 1.83 1.6 Bio-Techne TECH 51.79 -3.3 Cutera CUTR 2.84 -4.5 ForresterRes FORR 22.34 -2.9 InspireVeterinary IVP 0.58 -22.5 MetaMaterials MMAT 0.11 -4.7 PaycorHCM PYCR 18.25 -12.0 ServiceIntl SCI 52.89 -1.7 Tucows TCX 15.65 -6.8
AdaptHealth AHCO 6.92 -2.3 BioCardia BCDA 0.36 1.8 CyclacelPharmPfd CYCCP 7.00 -2.0 ForteBiosci FBRX 0.46 -6.4 IntercorpFinSvcs IFS 18.39 -1.0 MidAmApt MAA 115.56 -0.5 Paylocity PCTY 154.10 -8.5 Servotronics SVT 9.56 -3.8 UDR UDR 30.95 -1.3
Adaptimmune ADAP 0.52 -0.1 BioNexusGene BGLC 0.36 -11.7 CyclerionTherap CYCN 2.35 0.2 FortressBiotech FBIO 1.62 -6.1 IntlMediaAcqnRt IMAQR 0.02 ... Middleby MIDD 109.59 -1.6 PediatrixMedical MD 11.03 -2.2 ShoalsTech SHLS 14.31 -5.9 U-Haul UHAL 48.07 -0.8
AEternaZentaris AEZS 1.36 -3.5 Biotricity BTCY 0.95 -8.3 Cyngn CYN 0.29 -2.9 Fossil FOSL 1.43 -7.7 IntlMoneyExpress IMXI 15.76 0.2 MillenniumGrpIntl MGIH 1.09 -24.2 Peraso PRSO 0.13 -2.9 Sientra SIEN 0.59 33.0 U Power UCAR 2.55 -5.0
AevaTech AEVA 0.47 -4.5 BlackLine BL 47.27 -2.1 DZS DZSI 1.25 -1.6 FreshDelMonte FDP 21.41 -14.1 Inuvo INUV 0.12 -4.0 Minim MINM 0.76 1.2 PerimeterSolns PRM 2.79 -8.8 SigmaLithium SGML 23.76 4.7 Unisys UIS 2.60 -5.4
Agriforce AGRI 1.68 -10.3 BlueRidgeBkshs BRBS 2.09 -33.7 Dana DAN 11.10 -1.8 Frontier ULCC 3.19 -4.7 JBG SMITH Prop JBGS 12.72 1.6 MisterCarWash MCW 4.80 -4.2 PhioPharm PHIO 1.17 -1.6 SiliconLabs SLAB 74.56 -5.4 UnitedGuardian UG 5.84 -3.9
BowenAcqnRt BOWNR 0.13 -1.4 DanimerScientific DNMR 1.32 -6.3 FuryGoldMines FURY 0.31 -4.5 Joann JOAN 0.55 -4.3 MiX Telematics MIXT 4.80 -4.7 PiedmontLith PLL 25.81 -2.2 SilvercorpMetals SVM 2.12 -0.5 Upexi UPXI 1.02 -9.6
Agrify AGFY 1.20 1.6
BrookfldInfrPfdA13 BIPpA 15.00 2.6 DarioHealth DRIO 0.97 -21.1 FusionFuelGreen HTOO 0.67 -3.8 Janover JNVR 0.76 -8.7 MobivAcqnUn MOBVU 7.85 -5.5 PineappleFinl PAPL 2.05 -43.8 SingularGenomics OMIC 0.31 -0.7 VF VFC 12.85 -11.1
Airgain AIRG 3.13 -3.3
BruushOralCare BRSH 0.21 -4.0 DefinitiveHlthcr DH 5.53 -1.0 GamcoGlbGoldPfB GGNpB 21.04 -0.5 Jet.AI JTAI 1.02 -26.2 MoneyHero MNY 1.26 4.5 PlanetLabs PL 2.04 -4.6 60DegreesPharmWt SXTPW 0.09 -20.0 Valhi VHI 10.80 -1.3
Akili AKLI 0.33 4.6
Bumble BMBL 12.38 -4.0 DesktopMetal DM 0.80 -5.8 GAN GAN 0.83 -5.3 JohnsonOutdoors JOUT 47.00 0.6 Morphic MORF 19.35 0.5 PowerFleet PWFL 1.74 -4.9 60DegreesPharm SXTP Velo3DWt VLD.WS 0.08 -20.0
AlaskaAir ALK 30.75 -1.7 0.55 6.6
ButterflyNtwkWt BFLY.WS 0.03 -11.2 DiamondHillInvt DHIL 145.86 -5.9 GainTherap GANX 2.78 0.3 Joint JYNT 7.45 -3.6 MultiWays MWG 0.20 -12.0 PreludeTherap PRLD 1.66 10.1 SkeenaRscs VentyxBiosciences VTYX 14.03 0.1
Albemarle ALB 119.61 -3.0 SKE 3.41 -4.7
CFSB Bancorp CFSB 6.11 -4.8 DianaShipping DSX 3.17 -1.5 Galecto GLTO 0.50 -1.8 KoruMedSys KRMD 2.18 -1.3 MyersIndustries MYE 15.65 -2.6 Prenetics PRE 0.31 3.8 SkyWaterTech VerisResidential VRE 13.07 -1.3
AllarityTherap ALLR 0.53 -0.9 SKYT 4.73 0.2
C4 Therap CCCC 1.23 -11.4 DigiIntl DGII 23.23 -7.1 GamerPakistan GPAK 0.60 -0.5 KulrTech KULR 0.28 1.1 Napco Security NSSC 17.76 ... PrestigeWealth PWM 1.84 -8.8 SleepNumber
VerticalAerospace EVTL 0.83 -5.5
Allbirds BIRD 0.77 -6.6 SNBR 15.05 -4.9
CVS Health CVS 64.41 -0.4 DigitalTurbine APPS 4.34 -6.3 ViemedHealthcare VMD 5.90 -3.8
Allot ALLT 1.75 -3.3 GeneDx WGS 1.81 1.1 KwesstMicroSys KWE 1.35 -4.7 NFT MI 0.12 0.5 PriviaHealth PRVA 19.68 -2.9 SOQUIMICH SQM 46.84 -1.9
View VIEW 2.90 -7.6
AlphaTech ATGL 3.73 -3.6 CadrenalTherap CVKD 0.41 -2.5 DigitalOcean DOCN 19.39 -3.1 Gentherm THRM 38.21 -2.5 KaivalBrands KAVL 0.28 -9.2 NGM Biopharm NGM 0.76 -8.8 PubMatic PUBM 10.92 -1.0 SolidPowerWt SLDPW 0.07 -31.7
VirnetX VHC 3.50 -11.3
AltaEquipment ALTG 8.76 0.7 CanadaGoose GOOS 9.80 -8.7 DineBrands DIN 43.50 -9.9 GlenBurnieBncp GLBZ 4.90 -4.8 KelsoTech KIQ 0.17 -3.3 NICE NICE 149.54 -1.5 PureCycleTech PCT 4.13 -6.1 Soluna SLNH 2.09 -2.8
VisionMarineTech VMAR 1.75 6.1
AltamiraTherap CYTO 0.14 6.2 CanooWt GOEVW 0.04 17.4 Diodes DIOD 62.81 ... GlMedREIT PfdA GMREpA 23.32 -1.1 Kennametal KMT 22.08 -1.3 NaaSTechnology NAAS 2.60 -9.3 PureCycleUn PCTTU 5.93 -14.3 SonomaPharm SNOA 0.16 -0.1 VislinkTech
VISL 3.02 -0.8
AlzamendNeuro ALZN 1.49 -11.5 CareMax CMAX 1.79 -10.0 Dominari DOMH 1.82 -7.5 GlbSysWt GSDWW 0.01 -15.2 Kidpik PIK 0.47 -1.3 NanoVibronix NAOV 0.73 -10.1 PureTechHealth PRTC 17.86 ... SouthwestAir LUV 21.91 ... Visteon VC 110.19 -2.1
Amarin AMRN 0.65 0.3 CaribouBio CRBU 3.44 -1.4 Domo DOMO 7.78 -3.7 GlobalFoundries GFS 48.12 -1.6 KintaraTherap KTRA 0.48 -34.6 NatWest NWG 4.30 -1.4 PurpleInnovation PRPL 0.83 -13.4 Sphere3D ANY 0.92 -7.0 VividSeatsWt SEATW 0.86 -6.4
Ambarella AMBA 43.59 0.4 CarriageSvcs CSV 20.91 -1.9 DouglasElliman DOUG 1.64 -7.3 GlucoTrack GCTK 0.18 -3.0 Kirkland's KIRK 1.53 0.6 NemauraMedical NMRD 0.24 -4.2 QuantumScape QS 4.99 -2.5 SplashBeverage SBEV 0.53 -6.9 VorBiopharma VOR 1.62 -9.6
Ameresco AMRC 24.95 -2.4 CastorMaritime CTRM 0.33 -1.8 DragonflyEnergy DFLI 0.71 -12.6 Gogo GOGO 10.39 0.6 LaRosa LRHC 0.90 -24.2 NeptuneWellness NEPT 0.66 -6.0 QurateRetailA QRTEA 0.40 -9.2 Sportradar SRAD 8.08 -8.3 WM Tech Wt MAPSW 0.03 -12.5
AmerAcqnOpp AMAOU 5.72 ... cbdMD PfdA YCBDpA 0.92 -3.7 DrillingToolsIntl DTI 3.62 -1.3 GoldenEnt GDEN 30.38 -2.6 LanternPharma LTRN 2.38 3.2 NetLeaseOfficeProp NLOP 17.10 -10.0 QwestNts2056 CTBB 9.86 -13.1 SprucePower SPRU 3.60 -1.1 WahFuEducation WAFU 1.58 0.5
AmericanAxle AXL 6.29 -5.5 CenntroElec CENN 0.15 -4.2 DrivenBrands DRVN 10.61 -4.0 GoldenstoneAcqn GDST 9.63 0.6 Lanvin LANV 3.08 -3.4 Nevro NVRO 14.02 1.2 QwestNts2057 CTDD 10.21 -12.9 Starbox STBX 0.49 -23.1 WalgreensBoots WBA 20.14 -2.1
AmpioPharm AMPE 2.35 -1.2 CetusCapitalAcqnWt CETUW 0.02 -5.0 DuluthHoldings DLTH 4.81 -3.0 GrabWt GRABW 0.18 -0.1 Lazard LAZ 27.16 0.5 Newegg NEGG 0.52 -3.5 RENN Fund RCG 1.55 -4.6 Stratasys SSYS 9.95 -0.2 WallboxWt WBX.WS 0.16 -22.6
AmtechSystems ASYS 6.85 -3.7 Charles&Colvard CTHR 0.32 -4.7 EIDP$3.50Pfd CTApA 51.96 6.9 GreatElm GEG 1.75 -2.3 Leggett&Platt LEG 22.65 -0.4 NewellBrands NWL 6.50 -1.5 RH RH 207.26 -2.1 StryveFoodsWt SNAXW 0.00 ... WaveDancer WAVD 1.55 -3.7
AnaptysBio ANAB 15.88 1.4 CharlesRiverLabs CRL 161.65 -0.5 1847Holdings EFSH 0.57 -11.2 Greenlane GNLN 0.51 -3.7 LibertyGlobal A LBTYA 15.01 -2.4 Next.e.GO EGOX 0.63 -14.4 Radcom RDCM 7.55 -1.1 SunPower SPWR 3.75 -5.6 WernerEnterprises WERN 35.54 -0.9
Angi ANGI 1.55 -3.1 ChesapeakeUtil CPK 86.24 0.7 Electro-Sensors ELSE 3.65 -2.3 HeartTestLabs HSCS 0.20 -7.7 LibertyGlobal C LBTYK 16.27 -2.9 NKGenBiotech NKGN 2.80 -4.1 Radware RDWR 13.53 -3.6 SunriseNewEner EPOW 1.40 2.0 WesternCopper WRN 1.17 -2.5
AngioDynamics ANGO 6.06 0.8 Chevron CVX 143.82 -1.2 ElevationOnc ELEV 0.42 -8.3 HeartlandExp HTLD 11.44 2.0 LionElectric LEV 1.50 -2.5 Nogin NOGN 0.27 -4.2 RailVision RVSN 0.27 1.2 SurgePaysWt SURGW 0.82 3.6 WestrockCoffee WEST 7.93 -3.0
AnnovisBio ANVS 6.17 -5.7 ChickenSoupWt CSSEL 0.01 -9.0 ElmeComms ELME 12.44 -1.6 HenrySchein HSIC 63.29 -1.4 Livent LTHM 13.37 -1.9 Noodles NDLS 1.96 -7.5 Ranpak PACK 2.63 -14.9 Synlogic SYBX 1.71 -7.4 WeWork WE 1.05 -46.5
AntelopeEnterprise AEHL 2.11 -5.7 ChinaPharma CPHI 0.09 1.8 EmergentBiosol EBS 1.93 -6.2 HertzGlobal HTZ 8.29 -1.2 LomaNegra LOMA 5.64 1.4 NortechSystems NSYS 7.45 6.7 RayonierAdvMatls RYAM 2.66 -0.7 SyraHealth SYRA 1.18 -3.2 WiSA Tech WISA 0.14 -2.3
AptIncmREIT AIRC 28.22 -2.3 ChinaSXTPharm SXTC 2.01 5.1 EncoreCapital ECPG 37.08 -0.7 HillmanSolns HLMN 6.46 0.6 LoopMedia LPTV 0.25 -16.4 NoEuroOil NRT 7.87 -27.1 Rayonier RYN 24.84 -0.3 TFF Pharm TFFP 0.26 1.1 XPEL XPEL 45.40 3.7
AppliedMolecular AMTI 0.13 -2.9 ChoiceHotels CHH 109.30 0.4 EndeavourSilver EXK 2.06 -1.9 HiltonGrandVac HGV 34.91 -1.5 LouisianaPacific LPX 49.47 5.6 NuScalePower SMR 3.01 -8.0 Reading A RDI 1.80 -1.6 TH Intl THCH 1.43 -8.1 XWELL XWEL 1.45 -4.6
Aptiv APTV 84.03 -1.3 ClarosMtg CMTG 9.60 -3.5 EnergemWt ENCPW 0.02 -31.1 HimalayaShipping HSHP 4.42 0.4 Lucid LCID 3.96 -1.7 Nuwellis NUWE 0.64 -5.5 Reading B RDIB 12.50 -2.3 TPG RE Fin TRTX 4.64 -4.4 XponentialFit XPOF 11.31 -8.1
Aptorum APM 1.50 -1.8 ClearmindMed CMND 0.12 15.7 EnergyFocus EFOI 1.49 4.6 HinghamSvg HIFS 147.01 1.3 LucyScientific LSDI 0.25 -3.4 Nxu NXU 0.03 -4.2 reAlphaTech AIRE 15.00 -9.6 TPG RE FinPfdC TRTXpC 13.10 -0.5 YatsenHolding YSG 0.81 0.3
ArborRealtyPfdD ABRpD 15.90 -0.8 Clene CLNN 0.36 -3.1 EnphaseEnergy ENPH 74.70 -3.6 HudsonGlobal HSON 14.66 5.7 LumenTech LUMN 0.97 -32.9 O-I Glass OI 13.56 -5.3 ReconTech RCON 0.21 -8.2 Tapestry TPR 25.99 -3.5 YumChina YUMC 41.48 -15.2
ArtemisStratWt ARTEW 0.00 -33.3 Clorox CLX 114.69 -2.0 Envista NVST 22.59 -1.2 Huntsman HUN 22.14 -1.1 LumiraDx LMDX 0.08 -17.5 ONE GroupHosp STKS 4.18 -2.7 RedRockResorts RRR 37.82 -3.6 TechTarget TTGT 23.43 -6.5 ZimIntShipping ZIM 7.65 ...
AstecIndustries ASTE 30.18 -22.2 CogentBio COGT 8.08 0.4 EquityResdntl EQR 52.57 -3.9 IAC IAC 41.39 -1.1 LuxUrbanHtlsPfdA LUXHP 23.90 0.7 Oblong OBLG 0.14 -3.4 Renalytix RNLX 0.95 -1.9 TeledyneTech TDY 364.98 -1.5 ZebraTech ZBRA 194.59 -5.5
AtmusFiltration ATMU 18.21 -1.4 Cognex CGNX 34.28 -3.4 EstablishLabs ESTA 28.69 7.8 ICU Medical ICUI 95.19 0.3 MiraPharm MIRA 1.51 -22.2 OceanPwrTech OPTT 0.27 -9.3 RenttheRunway RENT 0.50 -6.2 TelesisBio TBIO 0.72 4.0 ZeroFox ZFOX 0.59 -7.0
AvidBioservices CDMO 5.80 -4.9 Cohbar CWBR 0.88 -48.9 EsteeLauder EL 102.22 -18.9 i-80Gold IAUX 1.34 -3.6 MKS Instrum MKSI 63.44 0.2 Olaplex OLPX 1.35 -4.2 RingCentral RNG 25.08 -4.5 TempoAutomation TMPO 0.04 -44.5 ZivoBiosci ZIVO 2.20 -11.1
AvinoSilver ASM 0.40 -3.2 Cohu COHU 29.65 0.5 EternaTherap ERNA 1.21 -12.8 IGM Biosci IGMS 3.81 6.6 MP Materials MP 15.22 -3.8 OmegaTherap OMGA 1.30 -1.5 RiskOnIntl ROI 0.52 -26.4 TenonMedical TNON 0.08 -38.9 ZoomInfoTech ZI 12.36 -3.3
.
MARKETS
ite added 1.6%. The S&P 500 the recent jump in bond yields St. Aubin, chief investment offi- than 3.5% apiece, while Micro- warned of higher costs from Applications
Accepted bids
$162,455,278,600
$56,404,603,600
rose 1.1%, led by the informa- is pushing up borrowing costs cer for Sierra Mutual Funds. soft posted a 2.9% gain. customers on Medicare. But the " noncompetitively $650,187,200
tion-technology and communi- in ways that could ease price “But the trend is not your But the big winner among stock later clawed back most of " foreign noncompetitively
Auction price (rate)
$0
98.234833
cation services sectors. pressures and slow the robust friend right now.” artificial-intelligence aligned the losses and ended the ses- (5.340%)
Major indexes have logged U.S. economy. That could affect Wednesday’s slip in yields tech stocks was Advanced Mi- sion 0.4% lower. Coupon equivalent
Bids at clearing yield accepted
5.527%
25.05%
three straight monthly declines the central bank’s monetary opened the door for the “Mag- cro Devices. Shares jumped DuPont slid 8.2% after the Cusip number 912797JG3
as a run-up in Treasury yields policy moving forward. nificent Seven” stocks to climb. 9.7% after executives forecast chemical and materials maker The bills, dated Nov. 7, 2023, mature on March 5, 2024.
Real-Time
News At Your
Fingertips
Download the WSJ
app for breaking news
and full coverage
on !inance, politics,
business and more.
SCAN HERE
tistics bureau and combining data China’s top 100 property develop-
from factories and the services ers were marginally better in Oc-
sector—declined to its lowest level tober than in September, accord-
this year, just above the 50-point ing to data released Tuesday by
level separating expansion from China Real Estate Information.
contraction. The manufacturing It is too early to push the panic
PMI from Caixin, released on A job fair at Zhengzhou University in Zhengzhou, China, in September. button, but the October lending
Wednesday, fell below the 50- and official real-estate data due
point mark for the first time in tivity ahead into September. Goldman Sachs. be seasonal too. later this month could be telling.
three months. China’s statistics bureau asserted The more worrying signal is on Moreover, the sudden weakness At the very least, it is very early
There are a few important cave- that seasonality was a factor in domestic demand. If one takes the in employment—following a pol- to conclude that China’s economy
ats. For one, the long, combined the factory PMI’s weakness. statistics bureau’s seasonality ar- icy-driven bump in property-sec- has won the many battles—against
mid-autumn and Chinese National For another, the two surveys gument at face value, that means tor activity—bears a certain un- household pessimism, shambolic
Day holidays—which happened to sent conflicting signals on exports. that some of the improvement in nerving resemblance to China’s government finances and multina-
occur together this year and ran The official factory PMI showed the September data—especially in growth stall-out in late spring. tionals’ “de-risking,” to name just
from the very end of September new export orders falling faster, building-related indicators like Then, a surge of pent-up de- a few—needed to put growth back
through early October—might very but Caixin’s survey had the decline new housing space started and mand released after the end of on a sustainable footing.
well have pulled some factory ac- moderating slightly, according to construction employment—might China’s zero-Covid lockdowns pe- —Nathaniel Taplin
350
annual sales declines in the years
ahead of the pandemic. And at
least some of that optimism seems
Have the
PC sales have been in a
downspin since early last year, af-
ter two years of pandemic-induced
For Intel and AMD, that market is
in a bit of a transition. The popular-
ity of generative artificial intelli-
300
tied to the belief that AI-enabled
PCs expected to hit the market
next year will be big sellers. “The
Unhappiest
Homeowners
growth. The downturn has been gence has blown up demand for one 250 arrival of the AI PC represents an
such that the 7.6% year-over-year chip—the graphics processor-based 200
inflection point in the PC indus-
decline in unit sales that market- accelerator systems made by Nvidia. try,” Intel Chief Executive Pat Gel-
research firm IDC reported for the Tech giants such as Microsoft, 150 singer said on his company’s earn-
third quarter counted as a notable Google, Amazon.com and Facebook ings call last week. Lisa Su, CEO of
improvement, as sales had been parent Meta Platforms redirected 100 AMD, predicted on Tuesday’s call American home prices are back
falling by double digits for the much of their capital spending to- that AI PCs “will fundamentally on an upswing. Not everyone is
previous five periods. IDC projects ward AI-server components—bene- 50 redefine the computing experience feeling the love.
PC shipments will total 252 mil- fiting Nvidia primarily. Intel’s and 0 over the coming years.” The S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller
lion units globally this year—down AMD’s combined data-center reve- But a strong market for AI PCs National Home Price Index rose
2015 ’20 ’23 ’24
14% from last year and the lowest nue for the six-month period ended right out the gate hardly seems a 2.6% from a year earlier in August,
annual sales number the firm has September fell 11% from the same Note: 2023-24 are projections sure thing. Many of the PCs sold S&P Dow Jones Indices reported
reported in more than a decade. period last year. Nvidia’s data-center Source: IDC during the pandemic will be within on Tuesday. That put the index at
PCs have proved to be the saving revenue is estimated to have tripled the five-to-six-year replacement a record, leaving the shallow
grace for Intel and Advanced Micro in roughly the same time, based on line next year, which is a fraction cycle that is common for such de- swoon it entered last year further
Devices this earnings season. AMD Wall Street’s consensus projections of Nvidia’s projected data-center vices once these new AI machines behind.
reported Tuesday that revenue for for the company’s fiscal third quar- sales for the same time but would go on sale. IDC is currently pro- But in seven of the 20 large
that segment jumped 42% year over ter that ended in October. represent a strong uplift for AMD. jecting PC sales to grow less than metro areas covered by the na-
year during the third quarter—mak- Intel and AMD are hardly giving Wall Street is expecting the 4% next year globally, and many tional index, home prices were be-
ing it the chip maker’s only business up on AI. Both are planning company’s data-center sales to analysts expect the industry’s an- low year-earlier levels. Count it as
to show growth for the period. In- splashy media events next month surge 58% in 2024 to $10.4 billion, nual shipments to remain in the a reminder that real estate is a lo-
tel’s PC revenue slipped 3% from a to showcase new chips for the mar- according to FactSet. That disclo- 250-million-to-270-million range cal affair—and that, in some lo-
year earlier, but that was far better ket, and AMD even surprised ana- sure helped AMD’s shares jump that was the norm before the pan- cales, conditions are poorer than
than the 10% drop Wall Street ex- lysts on Tuesday by projecting rev- 9.7% on Wednesday. demic. Getting consumers to spend in others.
pected. And for both companies, enue specifically for its data center But AMD’s PC revenue is ex- up for smarter computers that are The places where home prices
sales in their PC divisions offset GPU chips for the current quarter pected to jump 27% next year, still mostly used for email and web are down fit into two broad cate-
more serious weakness in their and next year. The company ex- while Intel’s is forecast to rise surfing could be a tall order. gories. The first are those still suf-
data-center segments—which repre- pects $2 billion from that product 13%. That reflects high hopes for a —Dan Gallagher fering from the effects of the out-
migration the pandemic set off.
This is epitomized by the San
Francisco area, where the Case-
Trucking Sector Gets Its Musk vs. Twitter Saga Shiller index shows prices in Au-
gust were down a seasonally ad-
justed 9.5% from their May 2022
peak.
The second are the places
In most children’s games, there Forward Air share price structured: Omni’s private-equity prove Omni’s alleged breach of where many people flocked after
are no takesies-backsies. A similar owners would be given only a agreements and covenants per- the pandemic hit, now experienc-
principle seems to apply when a $130 Deal with Omni small part of their stake in For- taining to issues such as preclos- ing a hangover. Phoenix, where
announced
company signs a pretty ironclad ward in common shares, with the ing access to information, confi- prices were down 6.1% from June
contract to buy another. 120 rest in the form of a huge amount dentiality and financing of the 2022 peak, fits the bill there. But
Late on Tuesday, Dallas freight Merger of nonvoting preferred shares. deal—not the least because these better examples can be found in
110
forwarder Omni Logistics said it blocked These would pay such high divi- have only come to the fore after more granular data from Zillow.
filed a lawsuit against trucking 100
by court dends that shareholders would be anger erupted toward Schmitt. In These show, for instance, that
company Forward Air asking for forced to convert them, massively an interview with The Wall Street home values in Austin, Texas,
the Delaware Court of Chancery to 90 Merger diluting themselves. Journal, he appeared somewhat were down 14.8% in September
enforce the merger agreement that cleared Some of them were angry enough repentant over how he communi- from a June 2022 peak.
both companies signed back in Au- 80 to file for a temporary restraining cated with shareholders, overesti- For homeowners in places
gust. This follows a statement last order to stop the merger, arguing mating their desire for a high-risk, where prices are down, the lock-in
week in which Forward said it 70 their rights were violated, but a high-gain investment. effect of mortgage rates is poten-
might terminate the acquisition, ar- Tennessee court denied their re- Schmitt turning on Omni is hav- tially even more of a constraint
guing Omni—which happens to be 60 quest last week. ing another damaging side effect. than for homeowners in other ar-
one of its trusted suppliers—failed It is uncertain where all of these He can no longer openly praise the eas: Not only would they have to
50
to comply with merger obligations. legal venues will lead, beyond all industrial logic of the merger as pay a much higher mortgage rate
This continuing soap opera is July 2023 Sept. Nov. parties spending heavily on legal much, even though he might have on any home they move into than
reminiscent of when Elon Musk Source: FactSet fees. Activist investor Ancora, which to go through with it. This is what what they are paying now, but the
stamped his signature on a $44 bil- called for Forward to renege on the happened to Musk after Twitter money they might fetch by selling
lion deal to buy Twitter (rebranded closed the deal, which led the com- deal and was exploring ways to oust filed a lawsuit against him: He their home has fallen.
as X) last year, and attempted to pany’s stock to drop 40%. the directors, celebrated the U-turn was forced to buy a company he This could especially be an is-
get out of it. Though Musk con- Investors are up in arms about and said the board “is right to be denigrated. sue in the places where people
tended the company hadn’t the $3.2 billion price tag placed on diligent in holding Omni account- Because Forward’s executives flocked. San Francisco home sales
cracked down on spambot accounts Omni—a valuation of 18 times the able for any and all noncompliance can’t emerge from this unscathed were fairly low when prices there
as much as it promised, he was earnings before interest, taxes, de- with the agreement’s terms.” no matter the outcome, they might peaked in 2022, so not a lot of
probably motivated by the realiza- preciation and amortization it Yet, despite an initial rebound, have been better off sticking to their people would lose money on a
tion that the price was too high. (A made in 2022, when the logistics Forward’s stock headed back down. guns, rather than souring the rela- home sale—not that selling for
year after closing, the company es- industry was on a sugar high of “Forward Air’s threat to termi- tionship with Omni from the start. less than your neighbor did is easy
timates it is worth $19 billion.) postpandemic disruptions. They nate the transaction is unenforce- The moral of the story: When it to stomach. But when prices
What is apparently behind the balked at the huge amount of debt able,” Omni wrote Tuesday in an comes to corporate acquisitions, it peaked in Austin, sales were high.
change of heart of Forward Chief they would be taking on. open letter to Forward’s share- is often better to ask for permission Moving out of a house there could
Executive Thomas Schmitt is the Worse, though, is they felt holders. than to ask for forgiveness. be especially painful.
shareholder uproar after he dis- tricked by the way the deal was Indeed, Forward will struggle to —Jon Sindreu —Justin Lahart