Professional Documents
Culture Documents
High Definition Liposculpture 18 Year Evolution .12
High Definition Liposculpture 18 Year Evolution .12
Aesthetic Outcomes
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by ofc8TXUZUfnfFCTtwMEPM3wEi2mewPOMynrDpZialgJ
N
owadays, every plastic surgeon has read or
heard about high-definition liposculpture Disclosure: Dr. Hoyos was an unpaid consultant
(HDL), and some have been trained on and speaker for the product development team of the
the technique specifics, which demonstrate that Sound Surgical Technologies system and Cannulas
improved aesthetic outcomes can be achieved (now VASER 2018, Solta Medical, Bausch Health
through minimal incisions without body scar- Companies, Inc.) up to May of 2013 and receives
ring.1 The senior author (A.E.H.) first explained royalties for the liposuction kits named after him. The
HDL in 2002 during plastic surgery meetings and authors have no financial interest in nor receive any
then popularized it in the first journal publication financial support for the products and devices men-
in 2007.1,2 tioned in this article, and have no conflicts of interest
to declare. No financial support was received for the
From the 1Total Definer Research Group, Bogota; 2private
research, authorship, or publication of this article.
practice; 3Total Definer Research Group, New York; and
4
Total Definer Research Group, Mexico City.
Received for publication May 12, 2020; accepted April 1,
2022. Related digital media are available in the full-text
Copyright © 2022 by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons version of the article on www.PRSJournal.com.
DOI: 10.1097/PRS.0000000000009988
www.PRSJournal.com 737
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • April 2023
an amalgamation of technologies and anatomic authors, the anticipated benefits and potential
and artistic concepts based on patient safety and risks of the study and the discomfort it may entail,
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by ofc8TXUZUfnfFCTtwMEPM3wEi2mewPOMynrDpZialgJ
sophisticated aesthetic outcomes. The usual can- poststudy provisions, and outcomes accord-
didate for traditional liposuction was the patient ing to the Helsinki Declaration. They were also
who was overweight or obese, but HDL changed informed of the right to refuse to participate in
the target population to a younger, slimmer, and the study or to withdraw consent to participate at
more demanding population than that seen with any time without reprisal. A freely given informed
other liposuction techniques, which reinforces consent was signed for each patient participating
the concept that HDL is more about revealing in our study.
rather than just removing.
We have published the results and advances Statistical Analysis
in HDL with the most important of its upgrades,
e+idUJKmWci91IwlJ on 11/14/2023
dynamic definition liposculpture (4D Lipo),3–5 Descriptive analysis was made through means
but no comparison among them is available. This and medians according to the distribution of vari-
article compares the rates of common complica- ables. For categorical variables, counts and per-
tions and improvements in patient safety among centages were used. The quantitative variables
the current and preceding HDL techniques. were compared using t test or Mann-Whitney U
test for nonparametric variables and the frequen-
cies of the qualitative variables were compared
PATIENTS AND METHODS using the chi-square test. Bilateral hypotheses
We conducted a retrospective review of our were formulated at two tails with significance level
records regarding HDL surgery. Three private less than 0.05. Data were analyzed using STATA
plastic surgery centers in Bogota, Colombia version 15 software.
(Evolution Medical Center, Santa Barbara
Medical Center, and Dhara Clinic) and one in SURGICAL TECHNIQUES
Bucaramanga, Santander (FOSCAL) provided
information on patients who underwent any of Suction-Assisted Lipoplasty (2002 through 2005)
the HDL procedures over an 18-year period (2002 HDL initially was performed with the aid of
through 2019). continuous suction devices, which generated a
Patients were classified into one of the follow- constant negative pressure that eased fat extrac-
ing three groups of procedures: suction-assisted tion (without prior emulsification), but the pro-
lipoplasty (SAL), vibration amplification of sound cedure itself was as traumatic as conventional
energy at resonance (VASER)–assisted HDL, or liposuction. The prolonged exposure of nega-
dynamic definition liposculpture. Complication tive pressure upon tissues was relatively contra-
rates and other variables were analyzed per group. indicated and if applied near the skin, contour
Demographic and clinical characteristics are irregularities, cutis marmorata, skin necrosis,
shown in Table 1. and scarring could occur.6–8 Patients with obesity
and those with previous liposuction procedures
were considered poor candidates for suction-
By reading this article, you are entitled to claim assisted HDL. Although results were good, the
one (1) hour of Category 2 Patient Safety Credit. surgery was arduous and required great physical
ASPS members can claim this credit by logging effort by the surgical team (with an average sur-
in to PlasticSurgery.org Dashboard, clicking gical time ≈2 hours), and was traumatic and pain-
“Submit CME,” and completing the form. ful for the patient. [See Figure, Supplemental
Digital Content 1, which shows a 38-year-old man
of normal weight (left) who underwent SAL. The
A Video Discussion by Simeon Wall, MD, postoperative photograph (right) shows a more
accompanies this article. Go to PRSJournal. athletic and muscular appearance, http://links.
com and click on “Video Discussions” in the lww.com/PRS/F700.]
“Digital Media” tab to watch. Postoperative safety measures included the use
of drains, 10 to 12 weeks of wearing compression
738
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 151, Number 4 • High-Definition Liposculpture Evolution
Sex, n (%)
Female 854 (92.6) 1078 (84.8) 2368 (82.9) 0.000a
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by ofc8TXUZUfnfFCTtwMEPM3wEi2mewPOMynrDpZialgJ
BMI, body mass index; Hb, hemoglobin; HCT, hematocrit; IQR, interquartile range.
a
Statistically significant results.
garments, postoperative massages, lymphatic but also improved deltoid definition, http://
drainage, and ultrasound. links.lww.com/PRS/F701.]
In addition to the aforementioned periop-
erative measures, we started antihypothermia
VASER-Assisted HDL (2006 through 2010)
measures for all patients undergoing HDL with
The incorporation of VASER technology external prewarming with a thermal blanket 1
to HDL resulted in reduced energy applied hour before and during the entire procedure.
to tissues, and the pulse mode decreased heat Intravenous fluids were heated to 40ºC and then
generation compared with that from previous administered to patients. For venous thrombo-
devices. Because of these features, VASER was embolism (VTE) prophylaxis, we prescribed
consolidated as an efficient technology to carve enoxaparin 0.5 mg/kg/day subcutaneously dur-
the superficial fat layer while reducing the risk ing the first 7 days after surgery in high-risk cases
for skin necrosis and scarring.1 VASER emulsi- (eg, obesity, surgery time ≥3 hours, leg liposuc-
fied and allowed the fat to be handled like a tion, lipoaspirate ≥5000 cc, family history or
sculptor handles clay; hence, the surgeon could previous VTE). We also used multipolar radio-
sculpt the anatomy of the superficial muscles in frequency (Venus legacy) and carboxytherapy
a detailed and less traumatic manner. This tech- (unusual nowadays) in selected postoperative
nology allowed us to perform HDL in patients cases.
with overweight and secondary procedures.
Because the superficial musculature affects
the external appearance of the human body, a Dynamic Definition (4D) Liposculpture (2011
broad anatomic knowledge and an artistic per- through 2019)
spective are both required to achieve HDL out- Although the procedure itself was the same
comes. The concept of art anatomy permitted during this period, the outcomes differed. Some
us to handle the superficial and deep fat layers patients had excellent aesthetic results whereas
to shape the well-known three-dimensional body others seemed to be lacking athletic definition;
contour, which resulted in an increase in both therefore, we devised a new dynamic concept,
surgical time (average ≈2.8 hours) and learn- whereby each muscle group was analyzed and
ing curve. [See Figure, Supplemental Digital differentiated into either power muscles or defi-
Content 2, which shows a 42-year-old man with nition muscles. For the latter, sharpness was the
obesity who underwent VASER-assisted HDL. goal, to achieve a youthful and athletic appear-
The preoperative photograph (left) shows abun- ance; for the former, we considered bigger as bet-
dant skin laxity and an increased abdominal ter, to give the appearance of physical strength.
perimeter; the postoperative photograph (right) The technique changed by including new transi-
displays not only a natural and athletic defini- tion zones delimited by the contraction dynamics
tion of both the abdominal and pectoral areas, of two or more muscular groups.3–5
739
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • April 2023
iZDnaRuQfErSd3RMaTDC2v6RSecRDcjiT26qZ2NPu1qZesjOeIPUV82GMNKtmkeCSXvWAux8ju1HdQdrooaz6mv5mrfN0ibPSllU
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by ofc8TXUZUfnfFCTtwMEPM3wEi2mewPOMynrDpZialgJ
e+idUJKmWci91IwlJ on 11/14/2023
Fig. 1. A 40-year-old woman underwent 4D Lipo with basic muscular definition. The preopera-
tive photograph (left) shows abundant fat deposits in the central and lateral abdominal region,
compared with a slim and youthful contour observed in the postoperative photograph (right).
Fig. 2. A 29-year-old endomorphic woman underwent HDL with moderate muscle defini-
tion. The new abdominal athletic and slim appearance with a sharp definition of the linea
alba and semilunaris line can be noted in the postoperative photograph (right) compared
with preoperatively (left).
Two other concepts were introduced later (eg, posterior, anterior, medial, lateral) would
in this period—the all or nothing and the receive intervention to reveal its natural anat-
360-degree concepts—which take into con- omy rather than simply defining muscles. In this
sideration that performing 4D Lipo involves manner, 4D Lipo became a true anatomic detail
all body segments in order to avoid unnatu- technique (average surgical time ≈3.1 hours)
ral results (considering the body as a whole). with exceptional aesthetic outcomes (Figs. 1
Therefore, the whole surface of a body segment through 4).
740
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 151, Number 4 • High-Definition Liposculpture Evolution
iZDnaRuQfErSd3RMaTDC2v6RSecRDcjiT26qZ2NPu1qZesjOeIPUV82GMNKtmkeCSXvWAux8ju1HdQdrooaz6mv5mrfN0ibPSllU
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by ofc8TXUZUfnfFCTtwMEPM3wEi2mewPOMynrDpZialgJ
e+idUJKmWci91IwlJ on 11/14/2023
Power-assisted liposuction plus VASER was the increased risk for postoperative skin hyperlaxity
high-tech combination behind the methods for and hyperchromia. Therefore, we switched to a
4D Lipo. Both of these devices aided high preci- new technology, radiofrequency, with which we
sion with muscular definition; however, power- used Thermi (2014), then BodyTite (2016), and
assisted liposuction was later associated with an later Renuvion (2018). These provided greater
741
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • April 2023
all patients could benefit from the same degree of ids are warmed (~40ºC).
definition.10
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by ofc8TXUZUfnfFCTtwMEPM3wEi2mewPOMynrDpZialgJ
742
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 151, Number 4 • High-Definition Liposculpture Evolution
Table 2. Most Frequent Secondary Procedures Table 4. Hematologic Measures of Blanketrol versus
Secondary Procedure No. % Blanketrol + Tranexamic Acida
Gluteal lipoinjection 3352 81 Blanketrol +
Characteristics Blanketrol Tranexamic Acid P
Mastopexy 1862 45.1
iZDnaRuQfErSd3RMaTDC2v6RSecRDcjiT26qZ2NPu1qZesjOeIPUV82GMNKtmkeCSXvWAux8ju1HdQdrooaz6mv5mrfN0ibPSllU
743
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • April 2023
Fig. 5. Frequency distribution of complications of all HDL procedures. Leg and thigh cellulitis were classified alone
because of higher incidence.
in aesthetics, we determined that power muscles allowed us to achieve more natural and muscu-
should be enhanced and definition muscles lar results while decreasing the rates of adverse
should be sharply defined. This new perception events (Table 5). The notion of transition zones
744
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 151, Number 4 • High-Definition Liposculpture Evolution
iZDnaRuQfErSd3RMaTDC2v6RSecRDcjiT26qZ2NPu1qZesjOeIPUV82GMNKtmkeCSXvWAux8ju1HdQdrooaz6mv5mrfN0ibPSllU
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by ofc8TXUZUfnfFCTtwMEPM3wEi2mewPOMynrDpZialgJ
e+idUJKmWci91IwlJ on 11/14/2023
Fig. 6. “Photo shoot quality” long-term follow-up of two patients who underwent 4D Lipo,
with 7-year (left) and 10-year (right) postoperative photographs, respectively. Results are
maintained by following a healthy diet and a workout routine 3 to 5 days per week.
and the variable degree of definition according values. Five out of seven cases that required trans-
to each body biotype10 were also crucial topics fusion were mini tummy tuck procedures, which
that helped us to achieve improved outcomes in could be explained by the increased trauma after
4D Lipo, although specifics are outside the scope excisional body contour procedures. Nonetheless,
of this article (Fig. 7). the absolute risk of requiring a transfusion after
Bleeding and postoperative anemia are com- 4D Lipo is almost zero (0.03%).
mon concerns that arise because of the usual Drains helped reduce seroma incidence and
large amounts of lipoaspirate during HDL. Our allowed us to increase the volumes of infiltra-
data support a statistically significant decrease in tion and fat extraction. The first period showed a
these events (Table 1) when comparing the third higher incidence of hematoma and seroma com-
period with periods 1 and 2, regardless of the pared with that from average standards, which
lipoaspirate volume (higher for period 3), which could be caused by SAL; however, we later found
supports the technique’s evolution to a safer pro- that early postoperative edema was being labeled
cedure. Independent analysis showed that the as seroma and the data were not modifiable.
combination of tranexamic acid + Blanketrol Dehiscence and local infections were higher in
decreases bleeding during surgery compared period 2 compared with periods 1 and 3, which
with Blanketrol alone, with statistically significant might imply that VASER itself could somehow
745
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • April 2023
iZDnaRuQfErSd3RMaTDC2v6RSecRDcjiT26qZ2NPu1qZesjOeIPUV82GMNKtmkeCSXvWAux8ju1HdQdrooaz6mv5mrfN0ibPSllU
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by ofc8TXUZUfnfFCTtwMEPM3wEi2mewPOMynrDpZialgJ
e+idUJKmWci91IwlJ on 11/14/2023
Fig. 7. HDL evolution timeline and the most relevant publications related to the technique.
cause heat trauma over the ports, altering the the same hematocrit level from the first and the
early phase of tissue healing. Moreover, legs and second periods, respectively.
thighs were more prone to cellulitis, hematoma, Further studies should be carried out to
and seroma (Fig. 5), which could be secondary analyze the differences among radiofrequency
to gravity and the decreased perfusion follow- devices for 4D Lipo, although in our experience,
ing postoperative edema. Although no compart- they all provide a greater retraction of the skin,
mental syndromes were reported, further studies which improves the aesthetic results.9 Moreover,
need to be conducted to support our findings. although not mentioned in our data, these new
Skin necrosis incidence was very low among devices are effective for patients who require any
the three periods (~0.6%); furthermore, the revision procedure, because radiofrequency helps
tendency has been toward decline as the proce- to soften the fibrous tissue while keeping the skin
dure has evolved. Most patients with postopera- safe.
tive contour irregularities or asymmetries had to
undergo a revision procedure, but the incidence
decreased as the techniques improved (Table 5). CONCLUSIONS
It should also be noted that a simple rule of The HDL technique has evolved through
three showed that the amount of lipoaspirate extensive medical, anatomic, artistic, and techno-
could have been increased by 42% in the third logical knowledge to provide patients improved
period to reach the same hemoglobin average higher aesthetic results framed in surgical safety.
level from the first period. Likewise, it could have The technique needs future developments to
been increased by 38.5% during the third period improve the surgeon’s performance and hope-
to reach the average hemoglobin level from the fully reach the “zero rate” of complications. This
second period. When considering the hemato- long-term HDL experience has taught us that
crit (a direct measure of red blood cell popula- no matter how good we are, we still have a lot
tion), results were 20% and 6.5% increase in the to learn and a lot to improve. Further data and
lipoaspirate volume in the third period to reach studies, as well as multicenter studies with various
746
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 151, Number 4 • High-Definition Liposculpture Evolution
HDL-trained surgeons, are needed to support our 5. Hoyos AE, Perez ME, Castillo L. Dynamic definition mini-lipoab-
findings. dominoplasty combining multilayer liposculpture, fat grafting,
and muscular plication. Aesthetic Surg J. 2013;33:545–560.
Alfredo E. Hoyos, MD 6. Young VL, Brandon HJ. The physics of suction-assisted lipo-
Carrera 15, No. 83-33, Suite 304 plasty. Aesthetic Surg J. 2004;24:206–210.
iZDnaRuQfErSd3RMaTDC2v6RSecRDcjiT26qZ2NPu1qZesjOeIPUV82GMNKtmkeCSXvWAux8ju1HdQdrooaz6mv5mrfN0ibPSllU
747
Copyright © 2022 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.