Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Into The Unknown: Lived Experiences of The Selected Public-School Teachers in Conducting Action Research in The New Normal
Into The Unknown: Lived Experiences of The Selected Public-School Teachers in Conducting Action Research in The New Normal
Into The Unknown: Lived Experiences of The Selected Public-School Teachers in Conducting Action Research in The New Normal
knowledge in the conduct of action research. research and help run our education system smoothly.
This is of significance especially now that we are in
Additionally, the health standard protocols during the the process of embracing the normal delivery of
pandemic, which restricted physical contact due to the quality education for all. Knowing the challenges met
possibility of being infected by the virus, gave teachers by the researchers during the time of pandemic is of
more reasons to stop from doing research. significance so we can create recovery plans and
Connectedly, Superfine (2020) pointed out that programs so that their love and passion for research
researchers and teachers are experiencing particular will be enhanced and rekindled.
and persistent difficulties stemming from the epidemic
in universities, colleges, and elementary and secondary Research Questions
schools. These obstacles show up in the ways we, as
academics and teachers, supervise students in clinical This study's primary purpose is to determine the lived
settings, undertake education research in classrooms, experiences of the public-school teachers in
and, for some of us, deliver lectures online. conducting action research. This seeks to answer the
following questions:
However, there are still those who bravely faced the
challenge and hoped that by conducting research, they 1. What are the lived experiences of public-school
can contribute to improving the implementation of teachers in conducting action research in terms of
distance learning modality amid uncertainty. 1.1. Technical Aspects;
Conducting a research study can help them grow 1.2 Systemic Aspects; and
professionally. On the same line, Noor, Ahmed and 1.3 Personal Aspects?
Zainudin (2020) supported in their findings that action 2. What are the challenges they have encountered in
research acts as a systematic approach to initiate conducting action research in terms of
professional development among educators. 2.1 Technical Aspects;
Furthermore, action research as a model of CPD 2.2 Systemic Aspects; and
should be nurtured among educators to solve 2.3 Personal Aspects?
educational issues, notably distance teaching and 3. How do these lived experiences of public-school
learning. teachers in conducting action research relevant in the
present times?
Relevant to this, the Department of Education (DepEd)
issued new guidelines in conducting research in the
‘new normal’. DepEd Order 026, s. 2021 Amendment Literature Review
to DepEd Order 016, s. 2017 or the Research
Management Guidelines states that research-related
activities and initiatives such as call for proposals, Challenges in Conducting Action Research in the
committee evaluation, progress monitoring, New Normal
dissemination and utilization, and other support
activities may be conducted virtually/remotely. Thus, Abarintos et.al., (2021) that internet connectivity
conducting research in the new normal can still be created a big challenge among students for their online
possible through the use of technology. learning. This also applied to the institution, the school
administration, the faculty, and the staff. During the
The goal of this study is to investigate the lived time of pandemic, teachers have ample time in
experiences of the public-school teachers in preparing action research since they can multitask both
conducting action research in the ‘new normal’. This in work and in doing other stuff. As supported by
research is phenomenological by nature which Maison D, Jaworska D, Adamczyk D, Affeltowicz D
investigates how participants responded to the (2021) that the respondents greatest challenges and the
challenge and what difficulties they have been through source of the greatest suffering were: limitation of
as well as their coping mechanisms. direct contact with people; restrictions on movement
and travel; necessary changes in active lifestyle;
This study would be beneficial to educators because it boredom and monotony; and uncertainty about the
serves as a baseline to some aspiring researchers who future. However, the advent of technology can be an
are still experiencing the trauma and anxiety brought option, but it needs internet connection. Most of the
by the COVID-19 pandemic. This would also serve as researchers experienced that the internet connectivity
an eye-opener to the DepEd officials to plan for is fluctuating. Macanang, et al. (2019), supported
recovery training for all public-school teachers. these results that teachers have difficulties in
Moreover, this will rekindle their drive to go back to conducting action research, especially literature
search, presentation and publication of results, and research collaboration are the ability to share research
data collection. Parallel to this, researchers really expertise, increase productivity and efficiency, and
experienced a hard time especially in administering the enhance the quality of research. In doing so, the
questionnaires because of the health protocol brought success of conducting action research will be realized.
by the pandemic. Moreover, Anda (2021) pointed out The Department of education issued a new research
that there is a need for the upskilling of their capability management guideline which is the DepEd Order 026,
to conduct research and having a resource person to s. 2021 which allows researchers to use the virtual
provide professional assistance to conduct action platforms in gathering the data. In fact, according to
research. Enago Academy (2021) Effective time management
can make you more productive as a researcher and
Supported by the findings of Natividad and Quilapio minimize the factors that drain your time such as
(2021) in their study that teachers find difficulty in procrastination and interruptions. Effectively
conducting research due to its technical aspects. This managing your time will help you experience
was one of the factors hindering the participation of improved job satisfaction and reduced stress.
teachers in conducting action research. Ulla, (2018)
cited the following key points in conducting action
research: (1) there should be support from school Methodology
administrators as teachers do their research, not only
financially but morally as well; (2) the school should Participants
provide for teachers be sent to research training and
workshops to motivate teachers to do research and The study consisted of ten (10) teacher respondents
provide them with the necessary skills and knowledge. who are currently holding a Teacher-III position and
Gonzales, I., Corpuz, D. and Dellosa, R. (2020) that had firsthand experience in conducting Action
respondents who attained higher educational Research during the new normal in public education.
attainment and attended national training have They were selected through a purposive sampling
improved research skills and are more knowledgeable method following the individual criteria: a.) a public-
in the research process and dissemination. On the same school permanent teacher who is holding at least
line, Gonong (2018) pointed out that action research is Teacher-1 position b.) must have experience in
one of the powerful tools for professional conducting action research in the new normal.
development.
Instruments of the Study
Chuey (2021) that online data collection methods are
expanding the ease and access of developmental This study utilized a qualitative phenomenological
research for researchers and participants alike. Shukla, research design. The phenomenological design
(2023) that the Internet is a huge research resource that describes the interpretations of the participants from
offers access to various materials on almost any their experiences. The participants were asked to
subject. Scholarly articles, books, and other respond to the questions through writing and had a
information sources are more accessible than ever follow-up in-depth individual interview (IDI) upon
because of the growth of internet databases and digital return of their narrative answers. The instruments used
libraries. Additionally, the Internet is vital for in this study include an open-ended survey question
researcher collaboration and communication because it and nontechnical literature to execute data
allows them to exchange thoughts, information, and polyangulation. The open-ended questionnaire
findings instantly. contains a single main question stated as “Please
narrate the experiences you encountered while
In contrast to the study of Macannang et.al., (2019) previously engaged or currently engaging in an action
that key difficulties and challenges emerged while research project in the new normal.” It has three guide
conducting action research during pandemic as major questions. These questions were aimed specifically at
themes such as teachers' participation in action drawing out specific personal experiences of the
research, which are greater strain and burden on the teachers relative to conducting Action Research based
teacher's part, anxiety about writing, a lack of time, on three aspects: technical, systemic, and personal.
and insufficient understanding in carrying out action
research. Skidmor, (2022) that research seminars are Procedure
important because they allow the opportunity for a
person to get feedback regarding his or her intended In identifying the respondents of the study, the
plan of study. Wilson, (2023) stated that the benefits of researcher posted a criteria which serves as basis in
Ethical Considerations
Results
Lived Experiences of Public-School Teachers in
conducting action research terms of Systemic
Significant Statements
Aspect
The initial phase in the transcendental phenomenology
analysis is the process of horizontalization in which Table 3. Meaning units or themes
statements are identified in the transcripts that provide
information about the experience of the participants.
Discussion
Technical Aspect
Table 4. Meaning units or themes The teachers consider this research process as an “easy
part in conducting action research because they have
enough preparation, “as expressed by Teacher 5. Other
teachers concur that their experience in conducting
action research is “challenging because of the
challenges encountered like internet connectivity,” as
shared by Teacher 5. Supported by the study of
Abarintos et.al., (2021) that internet connectivity
created a big challenge among students for their online
learning. This also applied to the institution, the school
administration, the faculty, and the staff. During the
time of pandemic, teachers have ample time in
preparing action research since they can multitask both
in work and in doing other stuff.
should undergo data and sampling validation. This can that there is a need for the upskilling of their capability
be done through consulting an expert in the field of to conduct research and having a resource person to
research to validate the questionnaires. Meanwhile, to provide professional assistance to conduct action
ensure that the questionnaires are functional and free research.
from technical errors, it should undergo a sampling to
a group of learners who are excluded from the study. In a mile state, seminars play a crucial role especially
Teachers considered sampling and validation as “the in upskilling the researchers to enhance their
hardest part” because capabilities and develop a positive mindset towards
research. It is noted that teachers, especially in times
The lived experiences of the public-elementary school of the pandemic, are very reluctant to exert an extra
teachers in conducting action research in terms of mile to conduct a research study because of their
technical aspect is considered the most difficult part. hectic schedules and paper stuff.
According to the respondents, conducting action
research in the new normal requires scrutiny and Systemic Aspect
consultation. However, it is very important to consult
an expert as to the validity and reliability of the data. The result shows that three (3) themes emerged from
the process. These themes express the experience of
In relation to this, it is notable that during the public-school teachers in conducting action research as
pandemic, it is very challenging to approach somebody 1.) Attending seminars and training 2.) Pursuing
to critique your manuscript because of the health graduate study 3.) Technical assistance provided by
restrictions. As supported by Maison D, Jaworska D, administrators and peers. They are further described
Adamczyk D, Affeltowicz D (2021) that the and discussed as follows:
respondents greatest challenges and the source of the
greatest suffering were: limitation of direct contact Attending seminars and training. To equip yourself
with people; restrictions on movement and travel; with the skills in doing action research, one must
necessary changes in active lifestyle; boredom and attend seminars and training. It is a way of acquiring
monotony; and uncertainty about the future. However, knowledge, putting theory into practice, and learning
the advent of technology can be an option, but it needs through collaborating with peers to strengthen their
internet connection. Most of the researchers understanding about research. Through attending
experienced that the internet connectivity is training and seminars, it helps them get acquainted
fluctuating. with research designs, research methods and statistical
tools in analyzing and interpreting the data gathered.
Supported by the findings of Natividad and Quilapio Supported by Skidmor, (2022) that research seminars
(2021) in their study that teachers find difficulty in are important because they allow the opportunity for a
conducting research due to its technical aspects. This person to get feedback regarding his or her intended
was one of the factors hindering the participation of plan of study.
teachers in conducting action research.
The teacher considered attending research seminars as
Moreover, the IT Library Research and Innovation “challenging” because it was done online. Challenges
mentioned some technical requirements in research like poor signal and internet connection hinder their
such as: new or upgraded software and hardware; a drive to learn about action research as shared by
website or new online functionality; and data gathering Teacher 7. However, Teacher 5 considered conducting
or analysis. From the example given, it can be inferred action research as an “easy way” through the help of
that technical aspects in conducting action research research seminars and training. It is notable that
which pertains to accessibility of materials like during seminars and training teachers were tasked to
gadgets and other technology used are very important produce an output to complete the different activities
to make your research study become successful. which helped to hone themselves on how to conduct
action research.
In line with the study by Macanang, et al. (2019),
supported these results that teachers have difficulties Pursuing graduate study. In light of professional
in conducting action research, especially literature advancement and professional development, pursuing
search, presentation and publication of results, and a research study can be the ideal step towards
data collection. Parallel to this, researchers really embracing change within yourself and to the
experienced a hard time especially in administering the organization you belong to. Pursuing a degree in a
questionnaires because of the health protocol brought graduate school gives you an opportunity to expand
by the pandemic. Moreover, Anda (2021) pointed out your knowledge in terms of education and educational
management. In line to the study of Agatep, J.L.E. & during the conduct of research, you really need to
Villalobos, R.N. (2020) that the student-teachers validate your questionnaire to the master teachers or
believe in improving their research skills through school principal to ensure the validity and free from
higher degree education; likewise, as they seek higher technical errors. Apart from that, it is part of the
position in the workplace. responsibilities of the master teachers and school
administrator to provide convenient technical
Part of management is knowing how to conduct assistance to the teachers. It is their role to guide and
research to address the problems encountered in the scaffold especially those who are beginners in order to
workplace. The teachers considered pursuing a degree finish the research study.
in graduate studies as an “avenue to learn” and
embraced research as expressed by Teacher 4. As The lived experiences of the public-school teachers in
observed, research has been part of the curriculum as a terms of systemic aspect shows that seminar and
major requirement in completing a degree in graduate training on action research plays a vital role in
studies. So, it is anticipated that before a teacher conducting and completing action research. By means
finishes a master or doctoral degree, they already have of attending seminar, the respondents were exposed to
some knowledge in conducting research. Furthermore, the latest trends and processes of conducting action
Teacher 8 claimed that after he finished his master’s research. Connectedly, Skidmore, (2022) cited that
degree, he was able to lead a research team and help research seminars are important because they serve as
his co-teachers learn and embrace the culture of the basis of learning for the participants. Academic
research. It is notable that in school, the school research seminars focus on instruction that is designed
administrator will encourage teachers to conduct a for the attendee or participant to gain specific
research study to enhance the delivery of instruction knowledge within the academic area.
and help improve the academic performance of the
learners. Furthermore, Ulla, (2018) cited the following key
points in conducting action research: (1) there should
Technical assistance provided by the administrator,
be support from school administrators as teachers do
research coordinator, and peers. Coaching and
their research, not only financially but morally as well;
mentoring has been an integral part in the educative
(2) the school should provide for teachers be sent to
process most importantly in conducting action
research training and workshops to motivate teachers
research. This can be done during school-based
to do research and provide them with the necessary
training and seminars like the SLAC session and In
skills and knowledge.
Service Training (INSET). The goal of providing
technical assistance is to help, guide and assist the In line with this, the support system from the
teachers who lack of skills on how to conduct a
administrators plays a crucial role in strengthening the
research study.
positive mindset of the researchers towards action
research. By means of giving them support through
The teachers considered this as “scaffolding” provided
local funds it will give the researchers an added fuel to
by their co-teachers which help them finish their
continue doing research. Additionally, it is noted that
research study despite their limited knowledge as
expressed by Teacher 3. As observed in school where through seminars and workshops, teachers will be
teachers are doing action research as a team headed by more capable of doing action research. In line to the
the research coordinator. There is really a need to findings of Gonzales, I., Corpuz, D. and Dellosa, R.
collaborate with each other because there are members (2020) that respondents who attained higher
who are neophyte in the field that needs assistance educational attainment and attended national training
from an expert peer. On the same line, Wilson, (2023) have improved research skills and are more
stated that the benefits of research collaboration are the knowledgeable in the research process and
ability to share research expertise, increase dissemination. On the same line, Gonong (2018)
productivity and efficiency, and enhance the quality of pointed out that action research is one of the powerful
research. In doing so, the success of conducting action tools for professional development.
research will be realized.
Moreover, they need to update themselves on activities
Furthermore, Teacher 6 claimed that their co- that will help them perform their functions. In a mile
researchers are very hands on and approachable in state, it is notable that teachers are required to do
providing technical assistance, most especially in research for the so called continuing professional
validating their survey questionnaires. It is notable that development to enhance their craft as educators.
sustaining a successful program of research. proves that conducting action research in Camp
Evangelista Elementary School is not a problem
Hence, it is notable that managing your time properly because mentors including the School Principal are
can help you became progressive, and this can be best very supportive. The teacher respondents during the
applied especially when you are conducting action ‘new normal’ are very much willing to attend training
research because aside from it you will be facing your and seminars to help them learn and improve their
day-to-day job, so it is imperative to manage time skills in conducting action research. Despite being
effectively in order to perform tasks at the specified provided with virtual seminars, teachers still need to
time duration. learn more about how to start good research. The
teacher respondents’ experiences in conducting Action
Results revealed that during the pandemic, it is easier Research during the ‘new normal’ is not complicated
to finish the research study due to having technology since they have more time to scrutinize the gathered
as a means of communication and data gathering. data. They are more focused since time is not a
Better and easier communication was made, thereby problem due to the researchers doing all the work at
allocating more time for the analysis of data. home, with continuous supervision of the assigned
Supported by Shukla, (2023) that the Internet is a huge mentors. This proves that the researchers are not
research resource that offers access to various having a hard time in conducting Action Research
materials on almost any subject. Scholarly articles, during the ‘new normal’.
books, and other information sources are more
accessible than ever because of the growth of internet The study r eco m m e n d s that school
databases and digital libraries. Additionally, the administrators/Head should lead teachers in
Internet is vital for researcher collaboration and conducting action research. The school head should
communication because it allows them to exchange motivate every teacher to conduct a study on problems
thoughts, information, and findings instantly. that need action. This will help the school to
develop/improve in certain aspects. Additionally,
In contrast to the study of Macannang et.al., (2019)
schools and the School Division Office may give
that key difficulties and challenges emerged while
commendations to teachers who complete their
conducting action research during pandemic as major
research papers. This way teachers will be motivated
themes such as teachers' participation in action
to conduct action research papers that are useful and
research, which are greater strain and burden on the
helpful in the future. Furthermore, Research
teacher's part, anxiety about writing, a lack of time,
Coordinators including the School Head should
and insufficient understanding in carrying out action
conduct more training and seminars on action research,
research.
particularly in the process of data gathering and data
Relative to the findings of the study, this became analysis, so that teachers needing proper guidance in
difficult especially to the neophyte in the field of conducting action research will be guided accordingly.
research that they still need to go to experts and Moreover, Research Coordinators including the School
statisticians in order to complete their study and the Head should motivate and encourage the Researchers
health protocol brough by the pandemic has made this as well to publish their completed papers because this
very challenging. However, if the researchers are well- could help teachers aiming for promotions.
equipped and already efficient in this field, they need
not to consult experts and statisticians because they References
can do it by themselves thus, they can manage their
time well. RA 10173 Data Privacy Act
Agatep, J.L.E. & Villalobos, R.N. (2020) Research capabilities West Central School through the Implementation of Project
among selected graduate school students in Philippines. Science RADIANT. SIYASIG District Journal Volume 1.
Insights Education Frontiers, 6(2):691-705.
Ruedas, M. D., and Ruedas, E. G. (2020). Public School Teachers’
Anda, R. J (2021). Project I-CARE: Research Capability Program to Attitude towards Action Research in Magsaysay, Occidental
Improve the Conduct of Action Research of School Heads and Mindoro. Asian Journal of Education and Social Studies.
Teachers of Gumaca West District. SIYASIG District Journal DOI:10.9734/ajess/2020/v7i130187
Volume 1.
Shukla, U. (2023) ‘Role of Internet in Research’, Tutorials point
Byrne, A. B. (2018). Educational neuroscience benefits from [Preprint].
educators’ research in the classroom. Learning & Education.
https://bold.expert/teachers-conducting-research/#:~:text=This%20e Macanang, D, Guzman J. and Tindowen D. (2019). Teachers'
nables%20them%20to%20try,relating%20to%20their%20own%20i Conception and Difficulties in Doing Action Research. DOI:
nterests 10.13189/ujer.2019.070817
Castro A. (2020). Conducting research in the time of pandemic: A Noor, M.S.A.MAhmad, S. and Zainudin, Z. (2020) “Initiating a
pause or an opportunity?. J Math Teacher Educ 23, 429–431 (2020). Professional Development on Action Research During the
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10857-020-09478-w COVID-19 Pandemic.” ·https://osf.io/3nd9k/download
Chase JA, Topp R, Smith CE, Cohen MZ, Fahrenwald N, Zerwic JJ, Skidmore, S. (2022) ‘Research Seminar| Overview, Importance &
Benefield LE, Anderson CM, (2020). Time management strategies Comparisons’, study.com [Preprint].
for research productivity. West J Nurs Res. 2013 Feb;35(2):155-76.
doi: 10.1177/0193945912451163. Epub 2012 Aug 6. PMID: Tindowen, D.J., Guzman, J. and Macanang, D. (2019) “Teachers'
22868990. Conception and Difficulties in Doing Action Research,' Universal
Journal of Educational Research [Preprint]. Available at:
Chuey, A. (2021) ‘Moderated Online Data-Collection for https://doi.org/DOI: 10.13189/ujer.2019.070817.
Developmental Research: Methods and Replications’, Frontiers in
Psychology [Preprint]. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.734398. Ulla, M. B. (2018). Benefits and challenges of doing research:
Experiences from Philippine public-school teachers. Issues in
Enago Academy (2021) “Effective Time Management Tips for Educational Research, 28(3), 797–810.
Researchers.” Available at: https://web.s.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=8&sid=
https://doi.org/https://www.enago.com/academy/time-management-t aa29d0d2-c817-4379-a798-0cc80b861ff1%40redis
i p s -for-
researchers/#:~:text=Effective%20time%20management%20can%2 Ventura, A. (2018). Action Research to Improve Higher Education.
0make,reduced%20stress. Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
Gonzales, I., Corpuz, D. and Dellosa, R. (2020) RESEARCH Wilson (2023) 7 Top Points: Research Collaboration Benefits
CAPABILITIES OF PUBLIC ELEMENTARY SCHOOL [Preprint].
TEACHERS AND MANAGEMENT SUPPORT OF THE
SCHOOLS DIVISION OF NUEVA VIZCAYA, PHILIPPINES’, Affiliations and Corresponding Information
Humanities and Social Sciences Reviews [Preprint].
doi:10.18510/hssr.2020.8427. Ryan C. Tura
Camp Evangelista Elementary School
Maison D, Jaworska D, Adamczyk D, Affeltowicz D (2021) The
Department of Education - Philippines
challenges arising from the COVID-19 pandemic and the way
people deal with them. A qualitative longitudinal study. PLoS ONE
16(10): e0258133. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258133