Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Perceived Effects of COVID-19 To Mental Health of Grade 9 Students and Parents
The Perceived Effects of COVID-19 To Mental Health of Grade 9 Students and Parents
The Perceived Effects of COVID-19 To Mental Health of Grade 9 Students and Parents
Literature Review work life and home/family life (Regis College, 2021).
Students’ Responses
Procedure
Table 1. “Reasons for Stress of Students under
The study began on April 26, 2021 until May 16, 2021 COVID”
(an overall time frame of: 21 Days) via a series of
Google Form surveys and an Online Diary made with
the help of Padlet that were handed out to 5 sections
(El Nido, Kayangan Lake, Hundred Islands, Tarak
Ridge, Mt. Maynoba) under the supervision of the
researcher. Two Google Forms were sent out: one for
the students, and one for the parents. They carried the
same list of questions to be able to cross-reference
between the two groups' answers. The Padlet Online
Diary is an anonymous space for the students to Parents’ Responses
express their most raw feelings as they please without
parental or authoritative barriers. The overall research Table 2. “Reasons for Stress of Parents under
hopes to garner answers from these surveys to get to COVID”
the root of the connection and correlation between
Mental Health and COVID-19, how the mental health
of parents may affect their children, what are the
different reactions to the current situation based on
these two groups, and what can be done about it.
what they want to do in life? And more. Most of the The remaining qualitative survey questions simply
responses highlight being tired: of schoolwork, of their affirm what we mentioned. Parents and Guardians are
day-to-day chores, of having to watch over younger suffering deeply from the ongoing pandemic. Not only
family members, of teachers who do not teach, and the does it pose immense ear for the safety of themselves
rising pandemic. The students are in a bubble of and their loved ones, it affects their source of income.
repetitive movement under yet to be certain ground, Many businesses had to close under quarantine while
this huge contrast could trigger multiple bouts of others released employees to make ends meet. The
anxiety due to uncertainty. “Uncertainty affects stress Philippines unemployment reached increased by 8.7%
levels that elevate into clinical levels of anxiety,” in April of 2021, this translates to nearly 4.2 million
(Ironside, n.d.) Stress makes it difficult for the brain to people. Parents are internally given the choice, food on
concentrate and it deals massive damage on the the plate or a virus in your home. And with the
students all while they try to keep up with schoolwork constant increase of the number of cases, it seems that
that as we’ve stated, they have difficulty doing. either choice will lead to a grim end. Their answers
truly highlight the difference between that of their
In the second short answer question we asked them, student counterparts. Students fear the uncertainty of
“Want to talk about it?” Most students responded with the future while their guardians fear the present and
a “No,” “Maybe not,” or a “No thanks.” There is how they can continue living with a shortage in the
hesitance to speak their mind, some prefer to speak needs that keep them alive, but both are afraid of the
about it face to face because perhaps it feels more real, effect COVID had on their lives.
and you can get a real time response or reaction. Some
students said no because their afraid of being too The parents and guardians were also asked for optional
unstable that perhaps doing this will crack them further short answer responses, but most responses came with
while other simply do not feel like sharing. Some a flat “No, thank you.” Not only did only half the
believe that they can handle this and that they can do original respondents answer both short response
this, and they would only share if they believed they questions, but they also felt no need to share. This
could no longer carry this burden. cements the theory that parents, and guardians prefer
to keep their feelings under great barriers in order to
But students are not the only one’s part of the school “fulfill their role and responsibility” and a few
community, parents and guardians continue to help responses highlight this: “It really hard to cope or to
mold the situation of the student outside of school. To solve problem in this pandemic such as financial
know the experiences, they have can help build a problem as a mother of a family I have a biggest
better picture on the on-going home life of the responsibility to my child but I'm still thankful because
students. every day we have a meal to eat and being safer day by
day” and “As a mother its my responsibility to take
The results of the parents and guardians seemed to be care of my children and i am willing to fight and be
more positive than their student counterpart and there strong to my family because if you love someone you
is one response in the next question that helps explain are willing to sacrifice it for. Just what i am doing in
this. “we always think positive, be thankful on every my family.”
blessing we received, every time we woke up and
having complete family.” Guardians and parents At the end of each survey, the researcher asked the
always wish to think highly of their situation, they respondents, what have they been doing to cope with
only wish to see their children excel and become a this situation but aside from what the graph dictates is
positive force in the world. Being the heads of their it important to discuss the idea of Anonymity. One of
families, they have no room to think of things the main foundations of the researcher is built on the
negatively, they must work constantly day by day to Online Diary, an anonymous platform open to the
achieve things for their family to survive. This kind of students of the 5 rooms for them to list their feelings.
thinking is also very dangerous, it is akin to toxic Within the ethics it was mentioned that the way
positivity, a positivity that dictates that despite “pain students could approach this were suspicious at best
or difficult situations, the only acceptable mindset, is a and when opening the Diary, the researcher had many
positive one…” When, “Positivity is predominant, and hesitant feelings towards it. But as the 21 days passed,
authentic human emotional experiences are shunned the researcher decided to not put a halt to the online
away and deemed invalid.” (Scully et al., 2020) This Diary, until today it remains up all because of the
kind of thinking is predominant during the current positive force it’s become. The dashboard is a collage
pandemic and has been within families who constantly of colors and messages that range from heartfelt rants
must think positively. and word-spill to positive affirmations reminding those
who enter that they are loved and cared for. online class and how it works because I'm wondering
Anonymity can be a positive force for good. A New if my daughter' stress is related to it. Then I am happy
York Times article by Daniel Solove says, “Under because she is able to do well and she can pass her
anonymity, people can express ideas and be critical modules at the right time.”
without fear. Anonymity allows people to be free
without feeling inhibited” (Solove, 2016). Anonymity Theme 2: Home & Family Life
can create safe spaces for students and the Online
Diary is a great example of where to start. Students are at home in quarantine and as they are
minors, they aren’t legally allowed to leave the house
The prevalent themes from the Online Diary entries, to go anywhere limiting their movement to just their
Survey responses, and open-ended questions are residence and the people who live there. Education is
extremely like the choices given by the researcher in affected by the psychological and physical
the question “Why?” pertaining to how pandemic has environment that surrounds the student. (Warfield &
affected them. Teacher Products, Carson-Dellosa™ Publishing, 2016)
A few students have described an unstable home life
Theme 1: Stress due to Online Classes that leads them to sacrifice both their own mental
psyche and , “In our family sometimes sa gusto ko na
Education is vital to the proper and continuous growth wag mag away parents ko ako na yung nagsasacrifice
of an individual. It helps to develop self-dependency, kase I want to have a happy family…” and “I'm not ok
fulfill dreams and ambitions, make a fairer world, etc. dito sa bahay di ko na alam kung saan ako lulugar
As DepEd announced that the next school year will minsan laging umiiyak si mama di ko alam kung pano
start via Online Classes it created an invisible barrier ko sya macocomfort,kahit ako mismo sobrang dami ko
between those who could afford this style of education na din pinagdadaanan sobrang hirap lang isipin kung
and those who could not. Many students within the pano ko malulutasan yung mga problemang yun tas
various mediums have expressed their stress towards syempre online class sobrang nahihirapan din akong
the online set-up, they have listed: teachers, amount of sumabay wala pa kaming wifi stress din sa mga school
work, and the need to be greater as just some of the works”
main causes. The stress has numbed the students to fall
into a pit of depression. Many students have remarked Theme 3: Financial Problems
that they are “unsure of what to do first” in relation to
their home vs school life such as: “I dont know what The parents are the most affected by this theme, many
im going to do first my school works or helping my parents detailed that they only want what’s good for
mom on household. Sometimes my parents telling me their family. However, the pandemic makes it
na ganyan kapag may gagawin dito sa bahay bigla exceedingly difficult for them to keep up with the
kang may gagawin , hoenstly sometimes I want to go basic needs such as food or internet connection for
far away kung saan malaya kong masasabi malalabas classes. A few parents goes on to state: “It really hard
yung sama ng loob ko yung bigat ng nararamdaman to cope or to solve problem in this pandemic such as
ko…” Multiple students’ also expressed the fact that in financial problem as a mother of a family i have a
the past few days prior to them answering the different biggest responsibility to my child but I'm still thankful
mediums they had experienced various bouts of because everyday we have a meal to eat and being
breakdowns caused by overwork from online classes safer day by day”, “Because of the pandemic now, as a
and anxiety. Such as: “Yes its fun but it doesn't change parent I am having a hard time where to get food for
the fact that it's just giving everyone an anxiety or a my children.” , “We have financial problems, due to
problem to have a reason to cry and have a covid 19 pandemic because my husband stopped
breakdown's when we feel like we're giving up.”, “.We working because if he continue working he might get
suffer mental breakdown because the grades you gave covid 19”
us is too low although we pass the requirements and
have a fine scores. Not because we're voicing out our Theme 4: No
problems in acads means we're lazy, we are just tired
doing our best yet it still enough just to reach the A common theme was the occurrence of the word ‘No’
school/teachers/ our parents high standard of being a in the study, although it is completely valid of the
student/child.” Parents have also noticed this issue and respondent to answer as they please. There is a certain
a few go to say, “Every time i see my child, i know hesitance to express this but when given the chance to
this is stress, if you ask me i also don't like online anonymously voice out their concerns, the effect is
learning for kids.” And “I'd like to talk about the powerful. Not every student will want to talk to about
what they’re going through but when gifted with balance something they’ve separated for so long.
compassion and anonymity it becomes a gateway into Anonymity became a grace for them; giving the
their true feelings. Parents deal with something similar researcher a perfect look into the thoughts of the
and feel the need to place a strong façade on for their students and how they wish to cope. The Online Diary
families disregarding their own feelings which could became more than a place to tell one’s secrets to, it
have an effect on their family life. was a positive force, the dashboard was littered with
the whole feelings of the students but also supportive
Theme 5: Suicide messages from their peers to encourage them to keep
pushing and being better people than they were
Although not a predominant theme within the data, it yesterday. This research aimed to understand the
is an important theme. Three students opened up on psyche of Parent’s and Student’s after nearly a year
wanting to end their lives due to the stress of under Quarantine, for the betterment of the way
everything around them both citing family problems as authorities and teachers approach the next school year.
the main reason for the stress. The following students Over the span of this research, this research uncovered
go on to say: “I don't want to live anymore but I'm one last theme: Everything is connected back to
thinking about my brother.”, I tried to kill myself again COVID-19 and the way our lives completely changed.
last night because of the fight between my mom and I.
I wish things will get better soon. I still want to live.”,
and “I already want to earn money to treat my dad he's Conclusion
so hardworking and very generous man, he's spending
a lot of time to earn, im sad because he's getting older
A thematic analysis of the study has revealed that there
already that's why i want to rush things and pay for all
are several mental health effects of COVID-19 to the
his sacrifices. I already want to end my life because of
students and parents of Rizal High School. With the
our family problems my mother has an affair with our
sudden shift in the educational setup brought by the
neighbor and always see them flirting but i can't talk to
pandemic, the highest ranked stressor as perceived by
my dad about that thing I don't want to ruin our family
students is the stress from online classes, while the fear
and my siblings are young for this. So that problems
of COVID-19 is the highest ranked for the parents.
affect my studying+ anxiety.”
New Normal education is not at all similar to that of
As the data has been set it seems to be apparent that the previous face to face classes, students are at the
COVID-19 is truly more than a physical crisis. most isolated and some even disoriented.
COVID-19 has affected the mental well-being of
everyone from the fear of catching it and spreading it References
to your loved ones to the extreme financial difficulty.
COVID stands as a domino effect for all these issues Centre for Clinical Intervention & Government of Western
mentioned, it is the core of everything and slowly all Australia. (2020, March 3). The Vicious Cycle of Depression.
the regulations are set, and the children are isolated,
the parents are suffering, home life dissolves, and Grøtan, K., Sund, E. R., & Bjerkeset, O. B. (2019, January 24).
Mental Health, Academic Self-Efficacy and Study Progress Among
people are left barely hanging on. The pandemic has College Students – The SHoT Study, Norway. National Center for
done nothing but inflame problems currently existing Biotechnology Information.
or creating problems that would have otherwise not https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6354661/
been there before. Students have determined that
Ironside, A. (n.d.). Coping with Lockdown Fatigue. Tearfund.
Online Classes is the biggest reason for their stress and https://www.tearfund.org.nz/Get-Involved/Covid-19-and-the-NZ-Ch
coupled with the environment that they have at home urch/Fragility_and_Fatigue.aspx
enlightened by the mental health of their parents.
National College Learning Center Association, Vanderlind, R., &
Parents have said that COVID and financial problems Texas State University. (2016-2018). Effects of Mental Health on
are the root of theirs and all this leads back into the Student Learning. The Learning Assistance Review, 22(2), 39-59.
core. COVID has deeply affected the school
Regis College. (2021). What Impact Does Parental Mental Health
community, it has created a constant loop where the
H a v e o n C h i l d r e n ? Regis C o l l e g e .
environment of everyone affects the other. Parental https://online.regiscollege.edu/blog/parental-mental-health/
stress is felt by their adolescent children, a vulnerable
group that feels deeply and is unsure of how to Scully, S. M., Zuckerman, J., & Karoll, C. (2020, July 22). ‘Toxic
Positivity’ Is Real — and It’s a Big Problem During the Pandemic.
respond while their mind racks for the answers of their Healthline.
modules. The two worlds: Family Life and School Life https://www.healthline.com/health/mental-health/toxic-positivity-du
become, one and many students are unsure of how to ring-the-pandemic