Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 s2.0 S0958946523003256 Main
1 s2.0 S0958946523003256 Main
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Electromagnetic field aligning steel fibre technology mainly focuses on the properties of ultra-high performance
Ultra-high performance concrete (UHPC) concrete (UHPC) without considering the interference of reinforcement. In this study, an electromagnetic field
Electromagnetic coil was used to align steel fibres in UHPC reinforced beams, which verified the feasibility of this method for rein
UHPC reinforced beam
forced structures. The results indicated that the steel fibres could be magnetised automatically parallel to the
Fibre orientation
Flexural behavior
direction of the magnetic line. The computed tomography (CT) image shows that the distribution of the steel
fibres is uniform, and their orientation in the matrix is clear. The interference effects of the reinforcement were
concentrated at the end, and the fibres in the beam span were parallel to the beam length. This approach can
significantly improve the flexural capacity of the beams, and the increase in amplitude is positively correlated
with the fibre content. In addition, the aligned steel fibre UHPC beams exhibited good plastic deformation and
excellent energy dissipation capacities.
1. Introduction efficiency coefficient (30%) [13]. The primary method for improving the
material properties of a cementitious matrix is to align the fibres while
Ultra-high performance concrete (UHPC) is widely recognised as a keeping the material composition and dosage constant.
cementitious composite with exceptional properties such as exceptional Currently, fibre alignment methods mainly include flow guidance
strength, superior ductility, and exceptional durability [1,2]. Nonethe and applied electromagnetic fields [12–15]. Stähli P. et al. used the
less, the prohibitive unit cost of its basic materials has prevented its flow-properties of the fresh (self-compacting) concrete to change the
widespread adoption, necessitating a focus on material performance fiber distribution and orientation, which is regarded as the first time in
enhancement and cost reduction strategies [3,4]. Fibre is the key factor aligning the fibers [15]. Many scholars have subsequently studied
for improving mechanical properties and substantially increasing UHPC’s mechanical properties through flow and casting methods,
toughness and ductility [5–7]. However, an exceedingly high fibre vol drawing interesting conclusions [16–20]. Zhang et al. improved a UHPC
ume content increases raw material costs and introduces difficulties casting device to align steel fibres, resulting in significant enhancements
such as clumping and decreased fluidity [8,9]. in the mechanical properties [21]. Kang et al. analysed the influence of
Therefore, optimising the bonding strength, efficiency coefficient, different flow fields on fibre orientation and explained the orientation
and spatial arrangement of fibres, is a crucial strategy for improving the mechanism during casting [22]. Roy M. et al. evaluated the effect of
properties of UHPC [10]. For example, Wille et al. developed UHPC with fibre volume fraction and fibre orientation on the pullout behaviour of
a high bond strength between the fibre and matrix, which can achieve steel reinforcement bar embedded UHPC, in which the fibre orientation
strong tensile properties using a very low steel fibre content [11]. Meng was controlled by casting methods [23]. Overall, these studies demon
et al. developed a rheology control method to improve the steel fibre strate innovative techniques for improving the fibre alignment in UHPC
distribution and flexural performance of UHPC by adjusting the flow and enhancing its mechanical properties. It has been observed that the
conditions of fresh UHPC [12]. The study revealed random fibre distri flow of UHPC naturally decays during the flow process due to energy
bution in conventional steel fibre reinforced cementing composites conservation law, resulting in an inevitable instability in the efficiency
(SFRCs), with clustering and segregation defects and a low orientation of fibre orientation [24]. This instability poses a challenge to achieving
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: mingyang@seu.edu.cn (M. Yang).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cemconcomp.2023.105251
Received 3 March 2023; Received in revised form 6 August 2023; Accepted 12 August 2023
Available online 15 August 2023
0958-9465/© 2023 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
consistent and precise fibre alignment using flow guidance methods. silicone oil. In addition, the mechanical properties of the aligned steel
Furthermore, this approach is not feasible for reinforcement structures fibre reinforced UHPC beams were investigated using four-point bend
with a large number of densely laid steel rebars, where the flow guid experiments. Finally, Section 5 summarises the main results of the
ance method may not be applicable or practical. Therefore, alternative aforementioned studies and provides recommendations for future
approaches must be explored to achieve reliable and uniform fibre research, particularly for precast UHPC structures.
alignment in such complex reinforcement structures.
In 2017, Mu et al. proposed a novel method for aligning steel fibres 2. Design of electromagnetic coil
using an external electromagnetic field. This innovative approach offers
a new opportunity to achieve higher fibre alignment coefficients than 2.1. Assembly of the electromagnetic coil
traditional methods [14]. The principle is that the steel fibres are
magnetised in a magnetic field and forced to rotate until the fibre is An electromagnetic coil is a classical piece of equipment used to
aligned parallel to the direction of the magnetic lines. Steel fibre rotation produce a homogeneous electromagnetic field. Some reports have
is considered efficient if the magnetic field is sufficiently strong. Because indicated that this method can effectively improve the tensile perfor
the magnetic flux density has a good linear relationship with the current mance of steel fibre reinforced cement matrix composites [31]. The
intensity, this method is simple and manoeuvrable [25]. Compared to relative spatial position of the electromagnetic coil in this study is shown
the flow guidance method, aligning steel fibres with an external elec in Fig. 1 (a), where the magnetic lines pass through the specimen and
tromagnetic field is more suitable for the traditional fabrication of force the steel fibres to align parallel to the magnetic line at any location.
concrete specimens. To generate a magnetic field that drives the steel fibres to rotate, an
This study focuses on the distribution of steel fibres and the me empirical formula is used to estimate the magnetic flux density B of the
chanical properties of UHPC materials. Very little research has been required electromagnetic coil [32]:
conducted on aligned steel fibres in reinforced UHPC structures, let
B = μ0 nI (1)
alone reports on the magnetic field applied to reinforced UHPC struc
tures. The interference of steel (such as steel rebars and profile steel)
where B is the magnetic flux density, μ0 = 4π × 10− 7 H/m is the mag
with the spatial magnetic field distribution is a key problem in the
netic permeability in vacuo, n is the number of turns in the copper
construction of engineering structures with electromagnetic fields. Most
winding, and I is the strength of the electric current.
structures are designed based on the coordinated work principle of
A unidirectional uniform magnetic field generating device was
reinforced concrete [26]. Steel rebars are essential for structures mainly developed, as shown in Fig. 1(b). The equipment consisted of a copper
because of material compatibility, including good cohesion, a high
wire and a power supply. The wire can withstand high temperatures of
elastic modulus, and the evident yield platform of steel [23,27]. These up to 120 ◦ C, and the power supply can convert 120 V alternating cur
factors ensure cooperation between the steel bar and concrete, ductility
rent into 70 V direct current. The copper wire was wound around a 200
failure of the component, and other important characteristics. There
mm diameter framework constructed using polymethyl methacrylate
fore, steel bars are irreplaceable in structures [28]. In the typical
manufacturing process of concrete structures, concrete is poured after
the reinforced skeleton is placed [29]. At this time, the steel skeleton
affects the magnetic field and fibre distribution in the space region of the
structure. However, no calculations or predictions of the magnetic field
distribution using electromagnetism have been made. Therefore, it is
important to study the internal steel bars of magnetised directional steel
fibre UHPC beams.
This study investigated the orientation of steel fibres in a freshly
mixed UHPC matrix and explored the feasibility of producing aligned
steel fibre reinforced UHPC beams using an electromagnetic field, with a
fixed steel rebar serving as the magnetic field interference source. First,
the electromagnetic coils were designed based on a combination of
experimental and numerical analyses. The effect of a magnetic field on
the system of steel rebar and steel fibres was studied by simulating a
UHPC slurry with transparent silicone oil. Subsequently, the finite
element method (COMSOL [30]) was verified using a silicone oil test,
and the interference of the steel reinforcement on the magnetic field was
studied. A reasonable pure bending length was determined through
finite element analysis of the magnetic field, and the fibre distribution in
the reinforced UHPC beams was accurately captured using CT images.
Finally, a series of four-point bending tests were conducted on eight
UHPC beams, each with different fibre volume fractions (0.5%, 1.0%,
1.5%, and 2.0%) and magnetic flux densities (0 mT and 40 mT). The
flexural mechanical properties are extensively discussed in terms of
flexural moment, moment-deflection relationship, and failure mode. In
addition, this study demonstrated the potential of this method for
enhancing the energy absorption capacity of beams by analysing the
failure responses under four-point bending conditions.
The remainder of this paper is organised as follows: Section 2 de
scribes the design procedure and performance of the electromagnetic
coil used in all subsequent studies. Section 3 discusses the UHPC ma
terials and beam test program. Section 4 discusses the magnetic field
distribution in UHPC. The prediction results (obtained by COMSOL) are
verified by an orientation test of multiple steel fibres in transparent Fig. 1. Details of the electromagnetic equipment.
2
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
(PMMA), a material that does not interfere with magnetic fields. electromagnetic coil is shown in Fig. 3, where the top and front views are
To determine the required magnetic flux density B, a U-type magnet listed on the right side of the overall magnetic field distribution. The
with a known magnetic potential was used. As a result, the magnetic flux electromagnetic coil is reduced to a black contour, and the magnetic
density B was set to 40 mT. Initially, the number of turns n was calcu lines (purple curves) and the amplitude of the magnetic flux density B
lated using Equation (1). However, owing to the distinct characteristics (colour) of the entire field are described in detail. It can be seen that the
of the helical coil compared with those of an ideal infinitely long single magnetic field distribution has strong symmetry throughout the entire
layer coil, this initial calculation (n = 1100) failed to accurately reflect field. The magnetic field gradients at both ends of the electromagnetic
the actual situation. After a thorough evaluation, it was determined that coil were strong, and the magnetic lines were divergent. The magnetic
a more suitable number of turns (n = 1000) was required. To determine field inside the coil was stronger and more homogeneous, and the
the magnetic field distribution, COMSOL software was used for finite magnetic field strength at the core location was 40–45 mT, while the
element analysis. magnetic field distribution outside the coil was relatively weak (no more
than 10 mT).
The distribution details of the magnetic field inside the electromag
2.2. Distribution characteristics of electromagnetic field
netic coil section are shown in Fig. 4. The magnetic flux density of each
measuring point was measured three times and its average value was
A portable Gaussian meter (with a margin of error of plus or minus
calculated. Firstly, the relationship between the magnetic flux density B
2% points) was used to measure the magnetic field, as shown in Fig. 1. A
along the coil axis (measuring path A) and the measured distance is
numerical analysis model was established using the COMSOL software.
plotted in Fig. 4 (a). The maximum magnetic flux density in the center of
The model ignores the permeability difference between the acrylic
the coil is about 43.8 mT, and its minimum appeared at the end was
plastic skeleton and air, and a large enough air area was established to
close to 22.1 mT. The length with magnetic flux density greater than 40
encompass the entire electromagnetic coil. For improved accuracy,
mT is 341.6 mm, accounting for 61.0% of the coil length.
finite element meshes were encrypted in the electromagnetic coil. The
Measuring path B, with a vertical distance of 80 mm from the central
established electromagnetic finite element model and its meshing details
axis of the electromagnetic coil, was selected to study the magnetic
are shown in Fig. 2. The element size of the helical coil is 0.05 m, and the
strength, and the strength of magnetic flux density B along this path is
outer air field’s is 0.15 m, while adaptive tetrahedral meshing was used
presented in Fig. 4 (b). The variations in the electromagnetic flux density
for modeling. The material constitutive model was provided by the
along the measurement line were similar to those shown in Fig. 4 (a), but
COMSOL library.
the maximum and minimum values were 44.0 mT and 27.5 mT,
To solve for the magnetic field intensity under a constant current, the
respectively. In addition, the length of the effective area (magnetic flux
magnetic vector potential A must satisfy the following equation:
density greater than 40 mT) of magnetic field intensity is also longer,
( )
∇ × μ0 − 1 ∇ × A = J (2) reaching 410.8 mm and accounting for 73.4% of the total length.
The results demonstrate a magnetic intensity difference of 0.2 mT
where, ∇ is divergence, for example, ∇a = ∂ax ∂ax ∂ax (representing 0.46% of the peak value) in the middle section and 5.4 mT
∂z ; and J is the
⇀
∂x + ∂y +
(representing 19.6% of the peak value) at the coil’s extremities. The
current density.
notable consistency between the numerical calculations and experi
The magnetic flux density B in the air is obtained from the magnetic
mental results confirms the accuracy of the calculated magnetic field
vector potential:
behaviour in the electromagnetic coil. A decline in the magnetic field
B=∇ × A (3) intensity at the end of the coil was evident. The electromagnetic coil
effectively generated the intended maximum magnetic field strength of
The magnetic field H is equal to:
40 mT, which was sufficient to rotate the steel fibres. The central 341.60
H = μ− 1 B (4) mm area exhibits a near-uniform magnetic field distribution, ensuring
where, μ0 = 1.257 × 10− 6 kg m/C2 . Four uniform coil models were used
to calculate the external current density, and each coil was composed of
250 turns of wire. The current was measured on the DC power supply
(I = 21.02A).
TA spatial magnetic field cloud image generated by the
Fig. 3. Magnetic lines (curved purple lines) and strength (color) of the mag
netic flux density B generated by the electromagnetic coil. (For interpretation of
Fig. 2. Finite element model and mesh characteristics of the electromag the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the Web
netic coil. version of this article.)
3
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
Fig. 4. Comparison between the FEA and actual measured results of magnetic flux density.
Table 1
Chemical composition of the powder.
Cement (C) Silica fume (SF) Fly ash (FA)
4
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
5
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
Table 4
Parameters used in the experimental program.
Specimen F05M0 F05M40 F10M0 F10M40 F15M0 F15M40 F20M0 F20M40
Table 6
Summary of flexural test results for beams.
Name Fibre volume fraction Yielding state Peak state
(%) Py (kN) Increase ratio (%) Dy (mm) Pp (kN) Increase ratio (%) Dp (mm)
Note: Py = load at steel rebar yield, Dy = deflection at steel rebar yield, Pp = peak load, Dp = deflection at the peak.
6
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
4. Results and discussions steel bar. The influence of the steel bar on the magnetic field is very
significant, and the magnetic lines near the end of the steel bar re
4.1. Magnetic orientation of fibres in a viscous silicone oil sembles an “arrow feather”. The steel fibres converge by magnetisation
because all the steel fibres are similar to smaller steel rebars and can trap
An acrylic silicone oil tank (as shown in Fig. 10 (a)) with 300 mm × others at the ends. Eventually, the fibres form chains that are identical
150 mm × 20 mm was used to describe the orientation of steel fibres the magnetic sensing lines. The steel fibre easily disappears when the
suspended in this viscous matrix. The rebar details are described in angle between the magnetic lines and the steel bar is between 40◦ and
Fig. 10 (b). The parallel arrangement of two rebars with a diameter of 60◦ because it can be trapped by the end of the steel bar.
10 mm is similar to that in the above experiment, the UHPC matrix is
simulated by this clear viscous medium (50 000 CST silicone oil) [30]. 4.2. Electromagnetic field distribution in the UHPC beam
The thickness of the silicone oil tank is only 20 mm, therefore, the fibre
orientation effect can be visually observed during magnetisation. In the Fig. 11 (a) shows the distribution diagrams of the magnetic flux
experiment, the steel fibres with 1.0% volume ratio are evenly mixed density in the UHPC beam, and the details of the mid-span area are
into the silicone oil, the dispersed state of magnetised steel fibres is shown in Fig. 11 (b). Orange was used to fill the steel bar area; the
shown in Fig. 10(c). These fibres are all common types of cement-based magnetic lines are represented by black curves, and the magnetic field
composites and are widely used. Through finite element analysis, the intensity is shown in the colour nephogram. As shown in Fig. 11 (a), the
diagram of the angle (θ) between the magnetic lines and the steel rebar magnetic flux density at the end of the rebar reached 200 mT, whereas
was obtained, as shown in Fig. 10 (d). the magnetic field strength in the middle of the steel rebar was close to
During the test, it was found that this magnetic strength was suffi that of the background magnetic field. The magnetic flux density in the
cient to align the all fibres within 30 s in the electromagnetic coil. centre of the beam is even higher when the effect of the steel bar end was
Because the plastic viscosity of silicone oil is similar to that of UHPC, ignored. The magnetic field distribution in the flexural test area of the
oriented steel fibre in UHPC are feasible. The distribution of steel fibres beam can also explain this regular. The maximum value of magnetic flux
in silicon oil can be accurately simulated by electromagnetic finite density is 42.8 mT and the minimum value is 41.2 mT. The deviation
element program. The angle between the steel fibre and steel bar was was 3.7%, which indicated that the distribution of magnetic flux density
smaller when it was closer to the middle of the steel bar, and the steel was uniform. It should be noted that the magnetic flux density around
fibre between the two steel bars could obtain more scope parallel to the the rebar increased and the distribution characteristics of the steel fibres
Fig. 10. The test and simulation result on fibre orientation (unit: mm).
7
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
were disrupted. In addition, the magnetic flux density in most areas of details of several typical measurement paths are shown in Fig. 13. Six
the beam span was nearly uniform. measurement paths were chosen according to the symmetry principle. In
Fig. 12 shows the angle between the magnetic lines and the coil axis, addition, three interesting sections were selected to analyse the influ
and the vector direction of the magnetised steel fibres in the electro ence of the steel bar end.
magnetic coil may follow this regular. As shown in Fig. 12 (a), fibres As shown in Fig. 14, the magnetic flux density and magnetic lines
with a maximum angle of 90◦ were concentrated at the end of the steel were symmetrically distributed in the UHPC matrix. The peak value of
rebar and may not be advantageous for the axial tensile performance of the magnetic flux density in the middle of the beam was 42.5 mT. The
the beam. The angle between the magnetic lines and the axis in most of magnetic field intensity weakened rapidly away from the mid-span area
the inner space of the beam is less than 10◦ , which contributes to the and then increased near the end of the steel rebar. The most evident
enhancement of flexural performance. The maximum angle between the effect was on the central axis of the beam, which was closest to the steel
magnetic lines and the coil axis in the flexural test area was 1.4◦ (Fig. 12 bar.
(b)), which was sufficient to drive the steel fibre evenly parallel to the The “bridging effect” of fibres is the key factor in improving the
axis. mechanical properties of UHPC. If the minimum fibre length utilisation
The distribution of the steel fibres along the beam length may affect is set to 95%, 18◦ (cos (18◦ ) = 0.951) will be the threshold for this
the envelopes of various internal stresses. Moreover, most civil engi determination. The magnetic lines were more uniform in the middle of
neering structures follow the planar cross-sectional assumption. The the beam and almost parallel to the beam. The angle between the
8
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
9
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
which grayscale intensities are correlated with material densities. Given converge towards the reinforcement. This indicates that the end effect of
the notably higher density of steel fibres compared with other constit the steel bar is evident and that the finite element simulation can
uents, steel fibres exhibit a distinctive bright white appearance on CT accurately predict this effect. The obvious parallelism between the steel
images, allowing for straightforward extraction and differentiation [44]. fibre and rebar is clearly shown in Fig. 17 (c), which indicates that the
Fig. 17 shows 3D reconstructions of the steel fibres, as observed in the orientation of the steel fibre in the mid-span area of the test beam was
CT images. very successful. Because the compressive strength of the UHPC is much
The fibre distribution in the UHPC sample obtained by the classical higher than its tensile strength, most of the area near the bottom of the
concrete pouring method is shown in Fig. 17 (a). The reconstruction and beam was subjected to tensile stress during the bending load. In this
qualitative visualisation of 3D images from CT were reported by Liu case, the steel fibres work together with the UHPC matrix and can
et al. [44]. It can be clearly observed that the fibres in the UHPC matrix effectively improve the tensile properties.
had a relatively random distribution. The fibre distributions at locations
I and II are shown in Fig. 17 (b) and (c), respectively. The positions of 4.3.2. Load–deflection relationship and crack pattern
the steel bars and fibres can be clearly distinguished in the figures. Fig. 18 illustrates the results of a four-point flexural test conducted
Overall, the fibres in the UHPC matrix were distributed uniformly and on the reinforced UHPC beams. The left side displays load-midspan
did not form chains owing to magnetisation, as shown in Fig. 10. This is deflection curves for various fibre volume fractions, with deflection
mainly because the UHPC matrix has different hydromechanical prop measurements precisely corrected for the deformation of the test system.
erties (such as greater viscosity and density) from silicon oil; therefore, The mid-span fracture failure modes of the test beams are shown on the
the UHPC matrix is more suitable for this method of aligning steel fibres right-hand side of the figure.
using an electromagnetic field. The 50 mm square (red dashed lines) in the cracking failure mode
The orientation of the fibres in the UHPC matrix was consistent with diagram is used to demarcate the crack location, and there are three
the magnetic lines in Fig. 16 (a). Fig. 17 (b) shows the distribution small squares in the horizontal direction in the figure because the pure
characteristics of the steel fibres at location I. The steel fibres tend to bending length is 150 mm. Remarkably, the fracture direction and
10
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
largest cracks predominantly occurred in the pure bending region of the reinforced tensile performance of the UHPC. The test results underscore
beam, substantiating the reliability of the test results. When the fibre the potential of aligned steel fibres for augmenting the strength of UHPC
volume content was 0.5%, the final failure of the beam body was and contributing to its strain-hardening behaviour.
dominated by multiple uniform tensile cracks, which is similar to that of The mechanical properties were subjected to qualitative analysis
ordinary concrete. However, as the fibre content increased, the material based on the load-deflection curve, and the key data are compiled in
exhibited more pronounced strain-hardening behaviour. The bottom of Table 6, following the analytical method outlined in Ref. [45]. The
the beam exhibited narrow cracks at various positions during loading, Young’s modulus of each beam was deduced using the Euler-Bernoulli
and a significant single crack emerged in the weakest area. Furthermore, beam theory, and it was observed that the initial Young’s modulus be
the presence of the aligned steel fibres appeared to amplify the collapsed tween classical UHPC beams and aligned steel fibre UHPC beams
area on the top surface of the beam. This phenomenon can be attributed exhibited no significant difference. However, when the fibre content
to the enhanced utilisation of steel fibres at the bottom, resulting in the remained constant, the aligned steel fibres demonstrated an average
11
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
12
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
strength improvement of approximately 20% over the classical UHPC with aligned fibres, and the gap became more obvious with an increase
reinforced beams. Notably, at 2% fibre volume content, the strength in the fibre volume fraction. When the fibres were randomly distributed
enhancement reached approximately 24%. This indicates that the effect in the UHPC, the ductility of the sample increased with an increase in the
of performance optimization is enhanced with the increase of fibre number of fibres. When the fibres have a directional distribution, the
volume content, and the benefit of directional steel fibre is significant. ductility of other samples seems to be little different, except for the fibre
Upon comparing the test results of beams with 0.5% and 2% fibre vol content of 0.5%. This may be because the fibre content of 0.5% was low
ume content, it becomes evident that the strength index of the 0.5% and the matrix’s property was still the dominant factor. This phenom
directional steel fibre test beam (F05M40) was comparable to that of the enon can also be reflected in the load-displacement curves. The yield
2% classical test beam (F20M0). This suggests that the proposed method load and deflection (Dy ) of the aligned steel fibre UHPC beams increased
can substantially reduce the volume fraction of steel fibres while significantly, and the capacity decreased significantly after the peak
maintaining similar mechanical properties. Consequently, the fibre load. The tensile strength of the matrix was much lower than that of the
alignment process significantly augmented the yield loads and peak fibres, and the fibres were fully utilised in a certain direction. Then, the
loads of each specimen, offering the possibility of cost reduction in fibres in the cracked zone withdrew from the work quickly while the
UHPC production and promoting the adoption of green prefabricated material reached the ultimate load, and the ultimate load and deflection
UHPC structures. (Du ) did not appreciably increase as a result.
Furthermore, the mechanical properties of the samples in the During the entire life cycle of a structural operation, the energy ab
strengthening stage were determined by fitting the slope (tangent sorption capacity is a comprehensive index reflecting the susceptibility
modulus) of the curve from the yield stage to the peak stage. As can be of a structure to damage and is often used to evaluate the ductility of the
seen from Fig. 18, when the fibre contents are 0.5%, 1.0%, 1.5% and structure. The total area under the force-displacement curve represents
2.0%, aligning the steel fibres can increase the tangent modulus of the the energy required to destroy the specimen, and the increase in the
beam by 1.0, 1.6, 4.5 and 4.9 times, respectively. The increase in the energy absorption capacity of the specimen was quantified using the
tangential modulus during the strengthening stage was linear with envelope area (shadow map in Fig. 18). A mid-span displacement of 10
respect to the fibre content. Therefore, the steel fibres are parallel to the mm was selected because the bearing capacity of classical UHPC rein
beam length direction and can work efficiently during the crack devel forced beams decreased significantly at this point.
opment stage, to ensure that the beam body can sustain high stiffness. Fig. 19 (b) shows the variation of energy absorption capacity with
When the fibre volume content is only 0.5%, the fact that the fibres in different fibre volume fractions. The variation of energy absorption ca
the UHPC matrix cannot improve the tangent modulus of the beam is not pacity is monotonically increasing with the fibre volume fraction, and
really surprising. Considering the lower volume percentage of steel fibre aligning the steel fibres is also superior to conventional processes, con
application, the matrix performance is still dominant. trary to what is shown in Fig. 19 (a). As can be seen from the shadow
map in Fig. 18, this increase in the energy absorption capacity is largely
4.3.3. Ductility and energy absorption capacity due to the utilisation efficiency of the fibres being maximized and the
The ductility index is used to measure the resistance of civil engi changes in the carrying capacity. The displacement ductility index of the
neering structures to deformation during the transition from the elastic UHPC beams decreases obviously due to the steel fibres rapid with
zone to the plastic zone to failure. In this study, the deflection ductility drawal from work. After the bearing capacity reached its peak, the in
index, according to Equation (5) [46] was used to evaluate the ductility ternal force of the section was redistributed, and the tension borne by
of the specimens. the steel fibres is changed to that borne by the steel bars. Only the
tension reinforcements worked in the tension zone, and the mechanical
Du
μu = (5) properties of classical beams are similar to those of aligning steel fiber
Dy
UHPC beams. Therefore, aligned steel fibre reinforced UHPC beams
where μu is the ductility characteristic of the member, Du is the deflec retain sufficient ductility and mechanical properties, and do not exhibit
tion of the member at the ultimate load, and Dy is the deflection of the the brittle failure characteristics of rapid loss of bearing capacity after
reaching the peak of bearing capacity. It is not recommended to use the
member at the yield load.
traditional deflection ductility index to evaluate the ductility perfor
Fig. 19(a) shows the variation in deflection ductility index for
mance of the new structure.
different fibre volume fractions. The fibres were randomly distributed in
samples that were not magnetised, whereas they were distributed
directionally using an electromagnetic field. The ductility of the sample
group with a random fibre distribution was significantly higher than that
Fig. 19. (a) Variation of ductility, (b) Variation of energy absorption capacity.
13
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
This study starts from the aligning steel fibres by the electromagnetic The authors declare that they have no known competing financial
field, the distribution characteristics of steel fibres in reinforced beams interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence
were studied, and many new conclusions for improving the performance the work reported in this paper.
of UHPC reinforced structures are proposed, which are summarized as
follows: Data availability
i) It is proven for the first time that an electromagnetic field is Data will be made available on request.
effective and feasible for aligning steel fibres in UHPC reinforced
beams, and the fibre direction can be predicted by electromag Acknowledgements
netic finite element analysis. Electromagnetic orientation tech
nology offers the advantages of high efficiency and easy control. The study of this paper is financially supported by Natural Science
Reusable electromagnetic equipment can reduce the unit cost and Foundation of Jiangsu Province (Grant No. BK20221472), Innovative
amount of critical materials required for construction. This is Project of Key Disciplines with Advantages and Characteristics of Key
beneficial for carbon reduction in civil engineering and has a Laboratory for Safety Control of Bridge Engineering of Ministry of Ed
positive significance for the global carbon-neutral goal. ucation in Changsha University of Science and Technology (Grant No.
ii) The distribution characteristics of the steel fibres can be directly 15KD01).
observed by replacing the UHPC matrix with transparent silicon
oil. The steel fibres were magnetised in silicon oil and then turned References
and connected end-to-end in a chain arrangement (Fig. 9)
consistent with the direction of the magnetic line. In the UHPC [1] Jihui Qin, et al., Development and characterization of magnesium phosphate
cement based ultra-high performance concrete, Compos. B Eng. 234 (2022),
matrix, the CT images show that the steel fibres produced the 109694.
same orientation effect as the silicon oil matrix. Compared with [2] Hadi Bahmani, Davood Mostofinejad, Sayyed Ali Dadvar, Mechanical properties of
the CT method, the silicon oil method has a lower cost, and a ultra-high-performance fiber-reinforced concrete containing synthetic and mineral
fibers, ACI Mater. J. 117 (3) (2020) 155–168.
larger observation scale and is more suitable for the study of fibre [3] Ali Alsalman, et al., Mixture-proportioning of economical UHPC mixtures, J. Build.
distribution characteristics at the structural scale. Eng. 27 (2020), 100970.
iii) The fixed steel bars significantly change the vector characteristics [4] You Dong, Performance assessment and design of ultra-high performance concrete
(UHPC) structures incorporating life-cycle cost and environmental impacts,
of the original electromagnetic field. In the entire beam region, Construct. Build. Mater. 167 (2018) 414–425.
the magnetic field could effectively drive the steel fibres in the [5] J. Ye, C. Cui, J. Yu, et al., Fresh and anisotropic-mechanical properties of 3D
UHPC matrix. In this study, the magnetic field presented a sym printable ultra-high ductile concrete with crumb rubber, Compos. B Eng. 211
(2021), 108639.
metrical distribution, and the orientation of the steel fibres
[6] Y.Y.Y. Cao, G. Liu, H.J.H. Brouwers, et al., Enhancing the low-velocity impact
changed with the direction of the magnetic line. The magnetic resistance of ultra-high performance concrete by an optimized layered-structure
lines in the middle region of the steel bar are parallel to the steel concept, Compos. B Eng. 200 (2020), 108221.
bar. A strong magnetic field gradient was generated at the end of [7] Zhu Yuan, Yanmin Jia, Mechanical properties and microstructure of glass fiber and
polypropylene fiber reinforced concrete: an experimental study, Construct. Build.
the steel bar, and the shape of magnetic line distribution re Mater. 266 (2021), 121048.
sembles an "arrow plume". [8] R. Yu, Przemek Spiesz, H.J.H. Brouwers, Mix design and properties assessment of
iv) Compared with traditional UHPC reinforced beams, the yield and ultra-high performance fibre reinforced concrete (UHPFRC), Cement Concr. Res.
56 (2014) 29–39.
peak strengths of aligned steel fibre UHPC beams can be [9] Doo-Yeol Yoo, et al., Effects of fiber shape, aspect ratio, and volume fraction on
increased by 20% on average. The bearing capacity of the beam flexural behavior of ultra-high-performance fiber-reinforced cement composites,
increases with the increase in fibre content within the range of Compos. Struct. 174 (2017) 375–388.
[10] R.N. Swamy, Fibre reinforcement of cement and concrete, Matériaux et
0.5–2%. By comparing the mechanical properties of beams Construction 8 (1975) 235–254.
F20M0 and F05M40, it was found that the steel fibre alignment [11] Kay Wille, Joo Kim Dong, E. Antoine, Naaman, Strain-hardening UHP-FRC with
technique can effectively reduce the amount of steel fibre low fiber contents, Mater. Struct. 44 (2011) 583–598.
[12] Weina Meng, Kamal Henri Khayat, Improving flexural performance of ultra-high-
(approximately three-quarters in this study) in the UHPC rein performance concrete by rheology control of suspending mortar, Compos. B Eng.
forced beam. 117 (2017) 26–34.
v) After the peak bearing capacity was reached, the bearing capacity [13] Huanghuang Huang, et al., Improvement effect of steel fiber orientation control on
mechanical performance of UHPC, Construct. Build. Mater. 188 (2018) 709–721.
of the beam decreased. The traditional deflection ductility and
[14] Ru Mu, et al., Aligning steel fibers in cement mortar using electromagnetic field,
energy absorption capacity indices are significantly different Construct. Build. Mater. 131 (2017) 309–316.
when evaluating the ductility of structures, and the ductility of [15] Patrick Stähli, Rocco Custer, Jan GM van Mier, On flow properties, fibre
this new material cannot be accurately determined by a single distribution, fibre orientation and flexural behaviour of FRC, Mater. Struct. 41
(2008) 189–196.
evaluation system. Therefore, an energy-absorption capacity [16] L. Martinie, N. Roussel, Simple tools for fiber orientation prediction in industrial
evaluation method is recommended. The ductility of the UHPC practice, Cement Concr. Res. 41 (10) (2011) 993–1000.
reinforced beams was significantly improved compared to that of [17] Su Tae Kang, et al., The effect of fibre distribution characteristics on the flexural
strength of steel fibre-reinforced ultra-high strength concrete, Construct. Build.
traditional UHPC reinforced beams. Mater. 25 (5) (2011) 2450–2457.
[18] Kay Wille, J. Gustavo, Parra-Montesinos, Effect of beam size, casting method, and
The potential of magnetic field aligned steel fiber technology was support conditions on flexural behavior of ultra-high-performance fiber-reinforced
concrete, ACI Mater. J. 109 (2012) 3.
presented, and this paper outlined study methods for predicting mag [19] Shaoqin Qu, et al., Prediction of tensile response of UHPC with aligned and ZnPh
netic field and fiber distribution. However, it is imperative to treated steel fibers based on a spatial stochastic process, Cement Concr. Res. 136
acknowledge that the current research is confined to investigating the (2020), 106165.
[20] R.A. Raju, S. Lim, M. Akiyama, T. Kageyama, Effects of concrete flow on the
mechanical properties of UHPC beams with a simple reinforcement distribution and orientation of fibers and flexural behavior of steel fiber reinforced
frame. Further inquiry is warranted to explore fiber distribution through self-compacting concrete beams, Construct. Build. Mater. 262 (2020), 119963.
profile steels and complex reinforcement frames. [21] Yang Zhang, et al., Improvement of flexural and tensile strength of layered-casting
UHPC with aligned steel fibers, Construct. Build. Mater. 251 (2020), 118893.
[22] Su-Tae Kang, Jin-Keun Kim, Numerical simulation of the variation of fiber
orientation distribution during flow molding of ultra-high performance
14
Y. Xiong et al. Cement and Concrete Composites 143 (2023) 105251
cementitious composites (UHPCC), Cement Concr. Compos. 34 (2) (2012) [35] Nengsen Wu, et al., Use of sugar cane bagasse ash in ultra-high performance
208–217. concrete (UHPC) as cement replacement, Construct. Build. Mater. 317 (2022),
[23] Manish Roy, Hollmann Corey, Wille Kay, Influence of volume fraction and 125881.
orientation of fibers on the pullout behavior of reinforcement bar embedded in [36] Mehrab Nodehi, Shahab Edin Nodehi, Ultra-high performance concrete (UHPC):
ultra-high performance concrete, Construct. Build. Mater. 146 (2017) 582–593. reactive powder concrete, slurry infiltrated fiber concrete and superabsorbent
[24] M.G. Alberti, A. Enfedaque, J.C. Gálvez, On the prediction of the orientation factor polymer concrete, Innovative Infrastructure Solutions 7 (1) (2022) 39.
and fibre distribution of steel and macro-synthetic fibres for fibre-reinforced [37] T/CBMF 37-2018, Fundamental Characteristics and Test Methods of Ultra-high
concrete, Cement Concr. Compos. 77 (2017) 29–48. Performance Concrete, 2018 (in Chinese).
[25] Guorui Cao, et al., Characterization of toughness enhancement of aligned steel [38] Yang In Hwan, Changbin Joh, Byung-Suk Kim, Structural behavior of ultra high
fibers in cement-based composites based on DDM method and meso-scale performance concrete beams subjected to bending, Eng. Struct. 32 (11) (2010)
simulation, Construct. Build. Mater. 347 (2022), 128517. 3478–3487.
[26] GB 50010-2010, Code for Design of Concrete Structures, Standardization [39] Jiahui Feng, et al., Shear behavior of externally prestressed UHPC beams without
Administration of China, Beijing, China, 2010. stirrups, Case Stud. Constr. Mater. 18 (2023), e01766.
[27] A. Hu, X. Liang, Q. Shi, Bond characteristics between high-strength bars and [40] Venkatesh Kodur, et al., Analysis of flexural and shear resistance of ultra-high
ultrahigh-performance concrete, J. Mater. Civ. Eng. 32 (1) (2020). performance fiber reinforced concrete beams without stirrups, Eng. Struct. 174
[28] X. Zhang, S. Zhang, Y. Luo, L. Wang, Effects of interface orientations on bond (2018) 873–884.
strength between old conventional concrete and new self-consolidating concrete, [41] Samaneh Khaksefidi, Mansour Ghalehnovi, Jorge De Brito, Bond behaviour of
ACI Struct. J. 117 (5) (2020) 191–201. high-strength steel rebars in normal (NSC) and ultra-high performance concrete
[29] M. Yang, L. Tian, Y. Yuan, et al., The study on composite trough beam with (UHPC), J. Build. Eng. 33 (2021), 101592.
corrugated steel web wrapped with steel plate: experiment and bending properties, [42] Jianan Qi, Jingquan Wang, John Ma Zhongguo, Flexural response of high-strength
J. Constr. Steel Res. 185 (2021), 106853. steel-ultra-high-performance fiber reinforced concrete beams based on a mesoscale
[30] M.J.H. Wijffels, et al., Magnetic orientation of steel fibres in self-compacting constitutive model: experiment and theory, Struct. Concr. 19 (3) (2018) 719–734.
concrete beams: effect on failure behaviour, Cement Concr. Compos. 80 (2017) [43] Xiangbo Xu, et al., Impact properties of Ultra High Performance Concrete (UHPC)
342–355. cured by steam curing and standard curing, Case Stud. Constr. Mater. 17 (2022),
[31] Jiangjiang Yu, et al., Multi-scale analysis on the tensile properties of UHPC e01321.
considering fiber orientation, Compos. Struct. 280 (2022), 114835. [44] Jiaping Liu, et al., Study on 3D spatial distribution of steel fibers in fiber reinforced
[32] E.M. Purcell, D.J. Morin, Electricity and Magnetism, third ed., Cambridge cementitious composites through micro-CT technique, Construct. Build. Mater. 48
University Press, Cambridge U.K, 2013. (2013) 656–661.
[33] GB175-2007, Cement, Common Portland, 2007 (in Chinese). [45] Zheng Feng, et al., Flexural and cracking behaviors of reinforced UHPC beams with
[34] Xin Shu, et al., Effect of hydrophobic units of polycarboxylate superplasticizer on various reinforcement ratios and fiber contents, Eng. Struct. 248 (2021), 113266.
the flow behavior of cement paste, J. Dispersion Sci. Technol. 38 (2) (2017) [46] Tai-Kuang Lee, Austin DE. Pan, Estimating the relationship between tension
256–264. reinforcement and ductility of reinforced concrete beam sections, Eng. Struct. 25
(8) (2003) 1057–1067.
15