Professional Documents
Culture Documents
أساليب المعاملة + مفهوم الذات
أساليب المعاملة + مفهوم الذات
أساليب المعاملة + مفهوم الذات
ǭȂǴLjdzƢƥƢǸȀǼǷDzǯƨǫȐǟȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷȁƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƣȂǴLJƗ
ƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ǁƾƥƾǸƸǷƨǬƟƢǧƽ
ǎƼǴǸdzơ
Å
ƢǔȇƗƪǧƾǿȁȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzƢƥȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơDZȂƦǬdzơǭơǁƽƛƨǫȐǟƨǠȈƦǗȄǴǟǥǂǠƬdzơȄdzƛƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƪǧƾǿ
ƨǬƥƢLjdzơƭȂƸƦdzơȁƩƢLJơǁƾdzơǑơǂǠƬLJơǶƫƾǫȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơǎƸǧȄdzƛ
Ë
ƨLJơǁƾdzơǑȁǂǧƪǻƢǯȁ
DZȁȋơǑǂǨdzơ
ǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơDZȂƦǬǴdz ƩƢǼƦdzơ DZƢǨǗȋơǭơǁƽƛǺȈƥƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .1
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂǴdz ƩƢǼƦdzơ DZƢǨǗȋơǭơǁƽƛǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .2
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ȆǻƢưdzơǑǂǨdzơ
ƩƢǼƦdzơ DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂºƬLjǷȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ
ƮdzƢưdzơǑǂǨdzơ
ǁƢƦǯDZƢǨǗȋơƶdzƢǐdzǺLjdzơǁƢƦǯȁǺLjdzơǁƢǤǏ ƩƢǼƦdzơ DZƢǨǗȋơǺȈƥȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȆǧƨdzơƽǩȁǂǧƾƳȂƫ
ǺLjdzơ
É
ǂȇƾǬƬdzǃǂǻȂǯDžƢȈǬǷȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷDžƢȈǬǷȁȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơDZȂƦǬdzơƧǁƢǸƬLJơǺȀȈǴǟƪǬËƦǗǶƫȆƬdzơƨǼȈǠdzơƪǻƢǯȁ
ƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǴǨǗǺǷƨǻȂǰǷDzǨǘdzơǭȂǴLJ
Ʃ ǁƢƦƬƻơȁǹȂLJǂȈƥǕƢƦƫǁơDzºǷƢǠǷȁƨȇǁƢȈǠǸdzơƩƢǧǂƸǻȏơȁƩƢǘLJȂƬǸdzơȁƨȈƟƢǐƷȍơƤȈdzƢLJȋơƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƾƼƬLJơȁ
ƨȈdzƢƬdzơƲƟƢƬǼdzơǺǟƨLJơǁƾdzơƩǂǨLJƗȁƩƢǘLJȂƬǸdzơǺȈƥǩȁǂǨǴdz
ǭȂǴLjdzơȁǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂǴdz ƩƢǼƦdzơ DZƢǨǗȋơǭơǁƽƛǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .1
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơȆǧ ƩƢǼƦdzơ DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁƛƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .2
DZƢǨǗȋơƶdzƢǐdzǺLjdzơǁƢƦǯȁǺLjdzơǁƢǤǏ ƩƢǼƦdzơ DZƢǨǗȋơǺȈƥȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȆǧƨdzơƽǩȁǂǧƾƳȂƫ .3
ǺLjdzơǁƢƦǯ ƩƢǼƦdzơ
The study also aimed to check the relationship between the self-concept and aggressive
behavior of children. The previous studies and researches were reviewed and the study
assumptions were as Follows:
The first assumption:
1. There is a negative correlation between the recognition of children (girls) for the
parental acceptance by the father and the mother and between the level of their
aggressive behavior.
2. There is a positive correlation between the recognition of children (girls) for the
parental acceptance by the father and the mother and between the level of their
aggressive behavior.
The second assumption:
There is a negative correlation between the self-concept and the level of aggressive
behavior of children (girls)
The third assumption:
There are indicative differences in the level of aggressive behavior between children
(girls) kids and adults in favor of children adults.
The sample which depended on the acceptance / rejection form, scale of self-concept
and a Kortz scale of evaluation of the child behavior was consisting of 174 female
children of elementary stage students.
The researcher used the statistical methods, standard averages, standard deviations,
Person's correlation coefficient and T test for differences between the standard averages.
The study brought a bout the following results:
1. There is a positive correlation between their recognition for the parental acceptance
by the father and the mother and between their aggressive behavior.
2. There is a negative correlation between the self-concept and the level of aggressive of
children (girls) in the elementary stage.
3. There are indicative differences in the level of aggressive behavior between children
(girls) kids and adults in favor of children adults
ƨǷƾǬǸdzơ
ȄdzƛȅƽƚȇǭȂǴLjdzơơǀǿȁǁƢnjƬǻȏơƨǠLJơȁƨȈǯȂǴLJƧǂǿƢǛƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơDZƢǨǗƗȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơDzǰnjȇ
ƮȈƷǀȈǷȐƬdzơȁǶǴǠǸdzơǺǷDzǯȄǴǟǽǂƯƗdžǰǠǼȇȁƨºLJơǁƾdzơƧǂƴƷDzƻơƽȆdzƢǠǨǻȏơǂƫȂƬdzơȁǭƢƦƫǁȏơȁȄǓȂǨdzơ
ȃǂƻƗƨȀƳǺǷȆLJơǁƾdzơDzȈǐƸƬdzơȄǴǟǀȈǷȐƬdzơƧǁƾǫǒǨƼǼƫƢǸǯƨȀƳǺǷǶǴǠǸdzơƔơƽƗǒǨƼǼȇ
ǹơȁƾǠdzơȁƩơǀdzơȂƸǻǾƳȂǸdzơǹơȁƾǠdzơƢǸǿǺȈǸLjǫȄdzƛƨLJǁƾǸdzơǂǸǟȆǧDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǶLjǬǼȇȁ
ȆǴȇƢǸǯƢǸǿȁǺȇǂƻȉơȂƸǻǾƳȂǸdzơ
ǹȂȀƳȂȇƮȈƷƢÅËȈǯȂǴLJǺȈƥǂǘǔǸdzơDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzǹơȁƾǠdzơǺǷǝȂǼdzơơǀǿƭƾƸȇƩơǀdzơȂƸǻǾƳȂǸdzơǹơȁƾǠdzơ .1
Å
ǪȇDŽǸƫDzưǷƧƽƾǠƬǷȏƢǰNjƗǹơȁƾǠdzơǺǷǝȂǼdzơơǀǿǀƻƘȇȁƢȀƥȃƿȋơǝƢǬȇƛȁdžǨǼdzơƔơǀȇƛǥƾȀƥƩơǀdzơȂƸǻǶȀǻơȁƾǟ
ǞƥƢǏƗǒǟȁƗǽǂǧƢǛƘƥǾǸLjƳƵǂƳȁƗǖƟƢƸdzƢƥǾLJƗǁƣǂǓȁƗǽǂǠNjƾNjȁǾȀƳȁǶǘdzȁƗǾƦƬǯȁǾLjƥȐǸdzDzǨǘdzơ
ǁƢǼdzƢƥƢȀȈǯȁƗǾǸLjƳǺǷƔơDŽƳƗǩǂƷȁƗǾȇƾȇ
ǶȀƫƢǰǴƬǸǷȄǴǟƔơƾƬǟȏơȁƗǾƥǺȈǘȈƸǸdzơǺȇǂƻȉơȄǴǟDzǨǘdzơƔơƾƬǟơȂǿȁǺȇǂƻȉơȂƸǻǾƳȂǸdzơǹơȁƾǠdzơ .2
ǍǵƽȂƦǟ ƢÅËȈǟƢǸƬƳơDZȂƦǬǸdzơǭȂǴLjdzƢƥǵơDŽƬdzȏơǵƾǟȁƢȀƥDZȂǸǠǸdzơǶǜǼdzơȁǺȈǻơȂǬdzơȄǴǟƱȁǂƼdzơȁ
ǍǵȆǼȈƥǂnjdzơǍǵƤȈºǘƼdzơȅƽƢȇDŽdzơǍǵƧƽȂǸƷ
ƢǸǿǺȈǴǰNjǺȇǂƻȉơȂƸǻDzǨǘdzơǾȀƳȂȇȅǀdzơȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǀƻƘȇȁ
Å
ȆǧƢǷƾƼƬLjǷǒǠdzơȁDzǯǂdzơȁƣǂǔdzơDzưǷǾǸLjƳƔƢǔǟƘƥǺȇǂƻȉơȄǴǟDzǨǘdzơƔơƾƬǟơȂǿȁȆǻƢǸLjƴdzơǹơȁƾǠdzơ .ﺃ
ǾǻƢǼLJƗȁǽǂǧƢǛƗȁǾȈǴƳǁȁǾȇƾȇǮdzƿ
ǺȇǂƻȉơǦǏȁȁƺȈƥȂƬdzơȁǶƬnjdzơȁƤLjdzơDzưǷǵȐǰdzơƽȁƾƷƾǼǟǦǬȇȅǀdzơȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȂǿȁȆǜǨǴdzơǹơȁƾǠdzơ
Å
ǺȇǂƻȉơǺȈƥƨǼƬǨdzơǞǫȂȇȅǀdzơƣǀǰdzơƢǔȇƗDzǸnjȇƢǸǯƨƠȈLJƩƢǨǏȁƣȂȈǠƥ
ȂǿƽȂǐǬǸdzơǹơȁƾǠdzƢǧƢÅËȈƟơȂnjǟȁƗÅơƽȂǐǬǷǹȂǰȇƾǫDZƢǨǗȋơǾƥǵȂǬȇȅǀdzơȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǹƜǧDZƢƷƨȇƗȄǴǟȁ
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȂȀǧȆƟơȂnjǠdzơǹơȁƾǠdzơƢǷƗǺȈǠǷƔȆNjȁƗƽƾƸǷǎºƼNjȂƸǻDzǨǘdzơǾȀƳȂȇȅǀdzơȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơ
DzǯƣǂǔȇȅǀdzơDzǨǘdzơDzưǷƨƸǓơȁǂȈǣǾǧơƾǿƗȁǾǠǧơȁƽǹȂǰƫȁƨȈƟơȂnjǟƨǬȇǂǘƥǺȇǂƻȉơȂƸǻDzǨǘdzơǾȀƳȂȇȅǀdzơ
ǾƟȐǷǃǺǷǾǷƢǷƗǂǸȇǺǷ
ȆǧƨƦǣǁǾȇƾdzǾǻƗƢǸǯǭȂǴLjdzơơǀǿƔơǂƳǺǷǽǂȈǤdzȁƗǾdzƭƾƸȇǥȂLJƢǸƥȄdzƢƦȇȏȆǻơȁƾǠdzơDzǨǘdzơǹƗǂǯǀdzƢƥǂȇƾƴdzơȁ
ǍǪƥƢLjdzơǞƳǂǸdzơȆǼȈƥǂnjdzơ ƲȈƴǔdzơƧǂưǯȁDZƢǠǨǻȏơƨǟǂLjƥǶLjƬȇȁǺȇǂƻȉơƧǁƢƯƛ
ǮdzƿȆǧƢǸƥDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơȁȆLjǨǼdzơǪǧơȂƬdzơȄǴǟǂƯƚƫȆƬdzơDzǷơȂǠdzơǶǿƗǺǷƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗǂƦƬǠƫȁ
Ǎǵ ƵƢƬǨdzơƾƦǟǂǯƿƾǬdzȁ ǍǵȆǟƢǧǂdzơ ǾǷƾǟǺǷǶȀƫƢȈǯȂǴLJȄǴǟƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơǁȂȀǛ
ȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơDzƥƢǬǷDZȂƦǬdzơƢǸǿǺȈȈLjȈƟǁǺȇƾǠƥȆǧDzưǸƬƫƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗǹƗ
ǺȇȂǰƫȄdzƛȅƽƚȇơǀǿȁƨǨǴƬƼǸdzơǦǫơȂǸdzơȆǧDzºǨǘǴdzǺȇƾdzơȂdzơǾȇƾƦȇȅǀdzơƤƸdzơȃƾǸƥǾǼǟǂƦǠȇȅƾdzơȂdzơDZȂƦǬdzƢǧ
ǍǵǶƳǂƬǷDzȇƢƳǁƗ DzǨǘdzơȃƾdzƢȀȈǧƣȂǣǂǸdzơƨȈǐƼnjdzơƩƢǸLJǺǷƽƾǟ
ƨǷȐLJ ȆǻƾƦdzơƣƢǬǠdzơȁDZƢǸǿȍơȁƶȇǂǐdzơǒǧǂdzơƢȀǼǷǂǿƢǜǷƧƾǟǀƻƘȇǾǻƜǧDzǨǘǴdzȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơƢǷƗ
ǞƥƢǘdzơǀƻƘȇǾǯȂǴLJǹƗƢǸǯDzǨǘdzơȃƾdzȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơȁȆLjǨǼdzơǪǧơȂƬdzơǵƾǟȄdzƛȅƽƚȇơǀǿȁ Ǎƣ
)( Crick &Grotpeter, 1995, P:711ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ƨǨǐƥȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƨǷƢǟƨǨǐƥƨȈǯȂǴLjdzơƩƢƥơǂǘǓȏƢƥǾƬƥƢǏƛȆǧƢÅǸȀǷ Ë ÅơǁȁƽǾƫơƿǺǟDzǨǘdzơǵȂȀǨǷƤǠǴȇǮdzǀǯ
ǍǵƵƢƬǨdzơƾƦǟ ǾƫơǀdzƽǂǨdzơǭơǁƽƛƨȈǨȈǯȆǼǠȇƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷȁ)( John, 1986, P:23ƨǏƢƻ
ǵƾǟȄdzƛȆƦǴLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǂȈnjȇƢǸǼȈƥƢȀdzǽǂȇƾǬƫȁǾLjǨǼdzƽǂǨdzơDZȂƦǫȃƾǷȄdzƛƩơǀdzơǺǟȄƥƢƴȇȍơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǂȈnjȇƮȈƷ
ǺǷȁƿȂƦǼǷȁǂȈǬƷǾǻƗȄǴǟǾLjǨǻȄdzƛǂǜǼȇǮdzǀdzȁ ǍƗǵƨǷȐLJ ƢȀǻƘNjǺǷǾǴȈǴǬƫȁǾLjǨǼdzƽǂǨdzơDZȂƦǫ
ǶȈǿơǂƥƛ ƨȈǿơǂǯȁƾǬƷƧǂǜǻǺȇǂƻȊdzǂǜǼȇȁǾLjǨǻȄǴǟȅȂǘǼȇǾǴǠƴȇơǀǿȁƧǁƢƦƬǟơȏȁǾdzƨǸȈǫȏǾǻƗȁǝƢƬǸdzơǖǬLJ
Ǎǵ
ǹƗƢǸȀƬLJơǁƽƲƟƢƬǼdzƢǸȀƬnjǫƢǼǷƾǼǟ) Rina & Thomas, 1992, P:230 DžƢǷȂƫȁƢǼȇǁǺǷDzǯƩǁƢNjƗƾǬdzȁ
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗƢȀƴƟƢƬǻȆǧƪƸǓȁƗƨưȇƾƸdzơƨȈǸǴǠdzơƩƢLJơǁƾdzơǺǷƽƾǟǭƢǼǿ
ǶȀƫơǀdzǶǿǂȇƾǬƫǑƢǨƼǻơȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdz
ƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǴǰnjǷ
ƨȈǷȂǰƸdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơDžǁơƾǷǺǷǂȈƦǯƽƾǠdzƨȈǻơƾȈǷƧǁƢȇDŽƥǺȈȈǓƢǸdzơǺȈȈLJơǁƾdzơǺȈǷƢǠdzơDZȐƻƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƢǫƾǬdz
ǽǀǿDZƢǨǗƗƢȀǼǷȆǻƢǠȇȆƬdzơƨȈǠǫơȂdzơȁƨȈǬȈǬƸdzơƩȐǰnjǸdzơȄǴǟǥǂǠƬǴdzǑƢȇǂdzơȁƨǷǂǰǸdzơƨǰǷȁƧƾƳǹƾǸƥƨȈǴǿȋơȁ
ƨȈǯȂǴLjdzơƩȐǰnjǸdzơǶǿƗǺǷǂƦƬǠȇȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǹƗƨưƷƢƦdzơƩƾƳȁƾǫȁƨȈǸǴǟƨLJơǁƽƢȀƬLJơǁƽǥƾȀƥƨǴƷǂǸdzơ
ǺǷÅơǂȈưǯǭƢǼǿǹƗƩƾƳȁƮȈƷƨǏƢƻƨǨǐƥǶȀǼǷƭƢǻȍơȁƨǴƷǂǸdzơǽǀǿȆǧƨºǷƢǟƨǨǐƥDZƢǨǗȋơƢȀǼǷȆǻƢǠȇȆƬdzơ
ǹơȁƾǠdzơǀƻƘȇƾǫȁƨƠȇǀƥǙƢǨdzƘƥǚǨǴƬdzơȁǶƬnjdzơȁƤLjdzƢƥȁƗƣǂǔdzƢƥǺȀƫȐȈǷǃȄǴǟƔơƾºƬǟȏƢƥǺǸǬȇƩơǀȈǸǴƬdzơ
ȁƗǵȐǫȋƢƥƢȀȈǴǟƨǘƦƼnjdzƢƥǺǸǬȇȁƗǖƟƢƸdzơȄǴǟƨǬǴǠǸdzơƨȈǸȈǴǠƬdzơDzƟƢLJȂdzơǪȇDŽǸƬƥǺǸǬȇƮȈƷȃǂƻƗƧǁȂǏǺȀȇƾdz
ƢǿǂȈLjǰƫƾƷȄdzƛǂºǷȋơDzǐȇƾǫȁƧȏƢƦǷȐƥǑǁȋơȄǴǟƩȏȁƢǘdzơȁȆLJơǂǰdzơƔƢǬdzƜƥǺȀǼǷǒǠƦdzơǵȂǬȇƢǸǯǹơȂdzȋơ
ǺǴǷȂǟȅǀdzơƣȂǴLJȋơƾȈǴǬƬdzƢǷƛǹȂǰȇƾǫƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǾƥǵȂǬƫȅǀdzơȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǹƗƔƢǸǴǠdzơȃǂȇȁ
,Karlen, 1996 ƵǁƢƴdzơǵȐǰdzơȁƨȇǂƼLjdzơȁƾȈǟȂdzơȁƾȇƾȀƬdzơȁƣǂǔdzơDzºưǷǺȇƾdzơȂdzơDzƦǫǺǷƧǂLJȋơȆǧǾƥ
P:65 ƔơƾºƬǟȏơǺºǠǘƬLjȇƩƢºȇǂƻƗȄdzƛǹơȁƾºǠdzơDzȇȂƸƬƥǺȇƾdzơȂdzơǺǷǵƢǬƬǻȏơȆǧƨƦǣǂdzơǺǟdžȈǨǼƬǴdzƢǷƛȁ
ǍǵȆǼȈƥǂnjdzơ ǺȀºȈǴǟ
ȅǀdzơƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǹƗƔƢǸǴǠdzơȃǂȇȁǺȀƫơƿǺǟƤdzƢLJǵȂȀǨǸdzǺȀǼȇȂǰƫȄdzƛǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǞƳǂȇƾǫƢǔȇƗȁ Å
ƨǫȐǟƣơǂǘǓơǂǐƸdzơdžȈdzȁDZƢưǸdzơDzȈƦLJȄǴǟƢȀǼǷƧƾȇƾǟƣƢƦLJȋǞƳǂȇƢȀƫơƿǺǟƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƧǀȈǸǴƫǾǻȂǰƫ
ƩƢȇǂƻȋơǹƘƥǂǠnjƫȁƢȀLjǨǼƥƨǬưdzơƾǬǨƫƢȀǴǠƴȇƢǸǷƢȀƫȐȈǷDŽƥȁƗ Karlen, 1996, P:67 ƢȀȇƾdzơȂƥƨǴǨǘdzơ
ǞƥƢǘdzơǀƻƘȇȅǀdzơƢȀǯȂǴLJȄǴǟǮdzƿdžǰǠǼȇȁƢȀƥǺȈǘȈƸǸǴdzȁƢȀǻơǂǫȋƨȈǿơǂǰdzơȁƾǬƸdzơƢȀLjǨǻȆǧƾdzȂƬȈǧƢȀǼǷDzǔǧƗ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơǽǀǿƔơǂƳȍƨƸǴǷƨƳƢƷǭƢǼǿǹƗƨưƷƢƦdzơƩƗǁǮdzǀdzȁ Rina & Thomas, 1992, P:222 ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂǴdzƧƾƳƨǼȇƾǸƥƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǼȈǟǭơǁƽƛǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨǠȈƦǗȄǴǟǥȂǫȂǴdz
Å
ǭȂǴLjdzƢƥǺȀƫơƿǺǟƩơǀȈǸǴƬdzơƔȏƚǿǾǻȂǰƫȅǀdzơƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơǎƸǨdzƢǔȇƗȁǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁ
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơƨȈǸǿƗ
ƨȈdzƢƬdzơƤǻơȂƴdzơȆǧƨºȈdzƢƸdzơƨºLJơǁƾdzơƨȈǸǿƗȆƫƘƫ
ƨǨǐƥƩơǀȈǸǴƬdzơȁƨǷƢǟƨǨǐƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơǀȈǷȐƫǾƳơȂƫȆƬdzơƩȐǰnjǸdzơǶǿƗǺǷƾǠƫƨǴǰnjǸdzǑǂǠƬƫƢȀǻƗ .1
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơƨǴǰnjǷȆǿȁƨǏƢƻ
ǭȂǴLjdzƢƥƢȀƫơƿǺǟƨǴǨǘdzơǵȂȀǨǷȁȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơDZȂƦǬdzơƣȂǴLJƗǺǷDzǯǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨǠȈƦǗǎƸǨƫƢȀǻƗ .2
ƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ƨȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨƠȈƦdzơȆǧDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơƨǴǰnjǷƪƴdzƢǟȆƬdzơƩƢLJơǁƾdzơȁƭȂƸƦdzơƧǁƾǻ .3
ǺǰǸȇȆƬdzơDZȂǴƸdzơȁƩƢƷǂƬǬǸdzơǒǠƥǞǓȁȆǧǶȀLjƫǹƗǺǰǸȇƨLJơǁƾdzơǽǀǿƢȀǼǟǂǨLjƫƾǫȆƬdzơƲƟƢƬǼdzơǹƗ .4
ǶȀǼǷƭƢǻȍơȁƨǷƢǟƨǨǐƥǺȈȇƽȂǠLjdzơDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơƨǴǰnjǷƱȐǠdzȅǂLJȋơȁȆLjǨǼdzơƽƢNjǁȍơȆǧƢȀǼǷƧƽƢǨƬLJȏơ
ƨǏƢƻƨǨǐƥ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơǥơƾǿƗ
DZȂƦǬǴdzƧƾƳƨǼȇƾǸƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǼȈǟǭơǁƽƛƨǫȐºǟƨǠȈƦǗȄǴǟǥǂǠƬdzơȄdzƛƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơǥƾȀƫ
Å
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơǎƸǧȄdzƛƢǔȇƗǥƾȀƫƢǸǯȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǺȀǯȂǴLjƥȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơƩƢƸǴǘǐǷ
ȅƾdzơȂdzơDZȂƦǬdzơ .1
ƮȇƾƸdzơǺLjƷȁDzǨǘdzơȄǴǟƔƢǼưdzƢǯDZȂǬdzƢƥǾǼǟǂƦǠȇƾǫȁǶȀdzƢǨǗȋƨƦƸǸdzơȁƔǥƾdzơǺȇƾdzơȂdzơǾƸǼǸȇǹƗǺǰǸȇƢǷȂǿ
ƾǼǟǾǠǷƾƳơȂƬdzơȁDzǨǘdzơƨȇƢǟǂdzȆǠLjdzơȁƨƦǟơƾǸdzơȁDzȈƦǬƬdzơDzưǷDzºǠǨdzƢƥȁƗƺdzƛǾdzƢǸǟƘƥȁǾƥǂƼǨdzơȁǾȈdzƛ
ǍƣǵƨǷȐLJ ƺdzƛƨƳƢƸdzơ
ƣȂǣǂǷȁƢǸȀǼǷƣȂƦƸǷǾǻƘƥǂǠnjȇǾǴǠƴȇȅǀdzơȁƢǸȀǴǨǗǹơƾdzơȂdzơǾƥDzǷƢǠȇȅǀdzơƣȂǴLJȋơǾǻƘƥƢÅËȈƟơǂƳƛƨưƷƢƦdzơǾǧǂǠƫȁ
ǽǂǜǻƨȀƳȁǵơǂƬƷơȁǽǁȂǷƗȆǧǾƬnjǫƢǼǷȁǾdzǝƢǸƬLJȏơȁǾȈǴǟƔƢǼưdzơȁDzºǨǘdzơǹȂƠnjƥǵƢǸƬǿȏơDzưǷǾȈǧ
ƨƳƢƸdzơƾǼǟǾǠǷƾƳơȂƬdzơȁǾǷȏƕǦȈǨƼƫȁƾȈƳDzǸǠƥǵȂǬȇƢǷƾǼǟǾǠȈƴnjƫȁƢȀǼǟǂȈƦǠƬdzơȄǴǟǾƫƾǟƢLjǷȁ
ȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơ .2
ƧȏƢƦǸdzơǵƾǟƧǁȂǏȆǧȁƗǾǿƢƴƫƔơƾǟȁDzǨǘdzơȄǴǟǹơȁƾǟƧǁȂǏȆǧƢǿǂȀǜȇȁƨƦƸǸdzơƔǥƾdzơƣƢȈǣȆǼǠȇȂǿȁ
ǂȈnjȇƢǸǼȈƥDzǨǘǴdzƨȀƳȂǸdzơƨȈǿơǂǰdzơȁƔƢȈƬLJȏơȁƤǔǤdzơǂǟƢnjǷȄdzƛƔơƾǠdzơǹơȁƾǠdzơǵȂȀǨǷǂȈnjȇȁǾdzƢǸǿƛȁDzǨǘdzƢƥ
ȁƗǾȈǴǟǞǬȇǹơȁƾǟƧǁȁǂǔdzƢƥǭƢǼǿǹȂǰȇǹƗǹȁƽDzǨǘdzƢƥȆǬȈǬƸdzơǵƢǸƬǿȏơǵơƾǠǻơȄdzƛƧȏƢƦǸdzơǵƾǟDZƢǸǿȍơǵȂȀǨǷ
ƨºǷȐLJ ǾºdzƨƦLjǼdzƢƥƨȇǁȁǂǓȁƨǸȀǷƢǿơǂȇȆƬdzơǁȂǷȌdzȁDzǨǘǴdzDzǿƢƴƫȁDZƢǨǣƛƽǂƴǷDZƢǸǿȍơǹȋǾdzǾƳȂǷǹơȁƾǟ
Ë
ǍƗǵ
ǾȈǧƣȂǣǂǷǂȈǣȁǽȁǂǰǷǾǻƘƥǂǠnjȇǾǴǠƴȇȅǀdzơȁƢǸȀǴǨǗǹơƾdzơȂdzơǾƥDzǷƢǠȇȅǀdzơƣȂǴLJȋơǾǻƘƥƢÅËȈƟơǂƳƛƨưƷƢƦdzơǾǧǂǠƫȁ
ǾǨƫȋǾƥǂǓȁƞǘƼȇǺȈƷƧȂLjǬƥǾƬǴǷƢǠǷȁDzǠǨdzƢƥȁƗDZȂǬdzƢƥDzǨǘdzơȄǴǟǶƟơƾdzơƔơƾƬǟȏơDzưǷǾȇƾdzơȁDzƦǫǺǷ
ƧƾǟƢLjǷȄdzƛƱƢƬƸȇƢǷƾºǼǟǾǴǿƢƴƫȁǺȇǂƻȉơǵƢǷƗǽǂǟƢnjǷƵǂƳƾǸǠƫȁǾȈdzƛƵǁƢƴdzơǵȐǰdzơǾȈƳȂƫȁƣƢƦLJȋơ
ǾƬƦƸǏƤǼƴƫȁ
ƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷ .3
ƨƠȈƦdzơȆǧǾƫǂƦƻDZȐƻǺǷƢȀǴȈǰnjƫǶƬȇƩƢǯơǁƽȍơǽǀǿȁǾLjǨǼdzDzºǨǘdzơǭơǁƽƛƨȈǨȈǯǾǻƘƥƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǥǂǠȇ
ǍǵƵƢƬǨdzơƾƦǟ ǾƫƢȈƷȆǧǺȈǸȀǸdzơǺºȇǂƻȉơȁƨƠȈƦdzơƩƢºǸȈǟƾƬƥǍȂºǐƼdzơǾƳȁȄǴǟǂƯƘƬƫȁ
ƢǓǂdzƢƥǂǠnjȇǾƫơƿǺǟƤƳȂǷǵȂȀǨǷǾȇƾdzȅǀdzơDzǨǘdzƢǧǾLjǨǼdzDzǨǘdzơƢȀƥǂǜǼȇȆƬdzơƨǬȇǂǘdzơǾǻƘƥƢÅËȈƟơǂƳƛƨưƷƢƦdzơǾǧǂǠƫȁ
Å
ǾƫơƿǂǬƸȇƢǸƟơƽȁǾLjǨǻǺǟƢǓǂdzơǵƾǠƥǂǠnjȇǾǻƜǧǾƫơƿǺǟƤdzƢLJǵȂȀǨǷǾȇƾdzȅǀdzơDzǨǘdzơƢǷƗǾƫơǀdzǂȇƾǬƬdzơȁǾLjǨǻǺǟ
ƧƢȈƸdzơȆǧǾdzƨǸȈǫȏǾǻƘƥǂǠnjȇȁƢȀǻƢNjǺǷDzǴǬȇȁ
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơ .4
ȄǼǠȇǾǼǷȆƦǴLjdzơƤǻƢƴdzơȁǵȐºǰdzƢƥȁƗDzºǠǨdzƢƥǺȇǂºƻȉƢƥǁƢǷƾdzơȁȃƿȋơǩƢƸdzƛȄdzƛȅƽƚȇȅǀdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȂǿ
ǍǵƽȂƦǟ ƩơǀºdzƢƥȃƿȋơǩƢƸdzƛ
ƤLjdzơDzưǷDZȂǬdzƢƥƔơȂLJǶȀƟơǀȇƛǥƾȀƥǺȇǂƻȉơȄǴǟDzǨǘdzơǾƥȅƾƬǠȇȅǀdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǾǻƘƥƢÅËȈƟơǂƳƛƨưƷƢƦdzơǾǧǂǠƫȁ
DzǨǘdzơǵơƾƼƬLJơDZȐƻǺǷDzǠǨdzƢƥȁƗǶȀǼȈƥƨǼƬǨdzơǝƢǬȇƛȁƨƠȈLJƩƢǨǐƥǺȇǂƻȉơǦǏȁȁƵǁƢƴdzơǵȐǰdzơȁǶƬnjdzơȁ
DzǯǂdzơȁǒǠdzơȁƣǂǔdzơDzưǷǽƾLjƳƔƢǔǟȋ
ƨºǬƥƢºLjdzơƩƢººLJơǁƾdzơ
Å
ƔƢǼƥȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗƪdzȁƢǼƫȆƬdzơƩƢLJơǁƾdzơȏȁƗ
ƢȀƥDzǷƢǠȇȆƬdzơƨȇƾdzơȂdzơǕȂǤǔdzơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơǎƸǧƢȀǧƾǿǹƢǯƨLJơǁƾƥ(Gerald, 1996 )ƾdzơǂȈƳǵƢǫǩƢȈLjdzơơǀǿȆǧ
ǕȂǤǔdzơǹƗǺǟƨLJơǁƾdzơƲƟƢƬǻƩǂǨLJƗƾǫȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǂȈǣǭȂǴLjdzƢƥƢȀǗƢƦƫǁơȃƾǷȁǶǿƔƢǼƥƗǹơƾdzơȂdzơ
ƔƢǼƥȋơȃƾdzƨǏƢƻƨǨǐƥȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƨǷƢǟƨǨǐƥȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǂȈǣǭȂǴLjdzơƔơǁȁǺǸǰƫƨȇƾdzơȂdzơ
ȅǀdzơȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨǠȈƦǗƨLJơǁƽȄdzƛƪǧƾǿƾǬǧ Hiram, et al, 1989 ǾºƟȐǷǃȁǵơǂȈǿƨLJơǁƽƢǷƗ
ǭƢǼǿǹƗȄdzƛƢȀƴƟƢƬǻȆǧƨLJơǁƾdzơƪǴǏȂƫƾǫȁƔƢǼƥȋơƔȏƚǿȃƾdzȆƬdzơƨȈǯȂǴLjdzơƩȐǰnjǸdzơȁǶǿƔƢǼƥƗǹơƾdzơȂdzơǾƥDzǷƢǠȇ
DZƢǨǗȋơƔȏƚǿȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁǶǿƔƢǼƥƗǹơƾdzơȂdzơǾƥDzǷƢǠȇȅǀdzơȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟ
ƨºȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơǎƸǧȄdzƛ Geri & Dana, 1993 ƢǻơƽȅǂȈƳƨLJơǁƽƪǧƾǿƢǸǯ
ƪǴǏȂƫƾǫȁƨǼLJǺȈƥǶºǿǁƢǸǟƗƵȁơǂƬƫǺǷƪǻȂǰƫDZƢºǨǗȋơǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdzƨȈǯȂǴLjdzơƩƢƥơǂǘǓȏơȁ
ƨǫȐǠƥǖƦƫǂƫƧȏƢƦǸdzơǵƾǟȁDZƢǸǿȍơȁǒǧǂdzơȆǧDzưǸƬƫȆƬdzơƨƠǗƢƼdzơƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗǹƗȄdzƛƢȀƴƟƢƬǻȆǧƨLJơǁƾdzơ
DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƣƢƠƬǯȏơȁǪǴǬdzơǺǷDzǯǞǷƨƦƳȂǷ
DzǨǘdzơǺȈƥƨȈǟƢǸƬƳȏơƨǫȐǠdzơǎƸǧȄdzƛǥƾȀƫ Wintzel & Asher, 1995 ǂȈNjƗDZDŽƬǻȁƨLJơǁƽƪǻƢǯƢǸǼȈƥ
ǺǷƨºLJơǁƾdzơƨºǼȈǟƪǻȂǰƫƾǫȁȆLJơǁƾdzơǾǴȈǐƸƫȁȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǾǯȂǴLJǺǷDzǰƥƢȀƬǫȐǟƨǠȈƦǗȄǴǟǥǂǠƬǴdzǾȇƾdzơȁȁ
ǁȂǠNjǹƗƢȀǸǿƗƲƟƢƬǻȄdzƛƨLJơǁƾdzơƪǴǏȂƫƾǫȁȆƟơƾƬƥȏơǞƥƢLjdzơȁDžƽƢLjdzơǺȈǨǐdzƢƥǹȂLJǁƾȇǺǸǷȐºǨǗ Å
Å
ǒǧǂdzơǹƗƢǔȇƗƲƟƢƬǼdzơƪƸǓȁƗƢǸǯƨƦƳȂǷƨǫȐǠƥDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzƢƥǖƦƫǂȇȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzƢƥƔƢǼƥȋơ
ƔƢǼƥȋơȃƾdzȆLJơǁƾdzơDzȈǐƸƬdzơǑƢǨƼǻƢƥǖƦƫǂȇȆǻơȁƾǠdzơDzǨǘdzơǭȂǴLJȁȅƾdzơȂdzơ
DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆƥƢƠƬǯȏơƱơDŽǸdzơƨǫȐǟǎƸǧȄdzƛ Xinyin, et al, 1995 ǾƟȐǷǃȁǺȇƢǼȈLjǯƗƨLJơǁƽƪǧƾǿƢǸǯ
ǖƦƫǂƫƨȈLJǁƾǸdzơȁƨȇǂLJȋơǕȂǤǔdzơǹƗƢȀǸǿƗƲƟƢƬǻȄdzƛƨLJơǁƾdzơƪǴǏȂƫƾǫȁƨȈLJǁƾǸdzơȁƨȇǂLJȋơǕȂǤǔdzƢƥǺȈȈǼȈǐdzơ
Å
ǑơǂǟƗȃȂƬLjǷǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗƢǔȇƗƲƟƢƬǼdzơƪƸǓȁƗƢǸǯƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗȃƾdzƣƢƠƬǯȏƢƥƨƦƳȂǷƨǫȐǠƥ
DZƢǨǗȋơƔȏƚǿȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁƣƢƠƬǯȏơ
ǭȂǴLjdzơƔơǁȁǺǸǰƫȆƬdzơDzǷơȂǠdzơȄǴǟǥǂǠƬdzơƢȀǧƾǿȁƨȈǟȐǘƬLJơ Karlen, 1996 ǺȈdzǁƢǯƨLJơǁƽƪǻƢǯǺȈƷȆǧ
ǾǻƘƥDzǨǘdzơǂǠnjÉƫȆƬdzơƨƠǗƢƼdzơƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗǹƗƨLJơǁƾdzơǽǀǿƲƟƢƬǻƪǼȈƥƾǫȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ƔƢǼƥȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǁȂȀǛȄdzƛȅƽƚƫȆƬdzơDzǷơȂǠdzơǶǿƗǺǷƪǻƢǯǾȇƾdzơȁǺǷǑȂǧǂǷ
DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷƪdzȁƢǼƫȆƬdzơƩƢLJơǁƾdzơƢȈǻƢƯ Å
ȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨǠȈƦǗȄǴǟǥǂǠƬdzơ Kinard, 1978 ƽǁƢǼȈǯƨLJơǁƽƪdzȁƢƷ
Å
ȄdzƛƨLJơǁƾdzơƲƟƢƬǻƪǴǏȂƫȁƨǼLJ-ǺȈƥǶǿǁƢǸǟƗƵȁơǂƬƫȐºǨǗǺǷƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟƪǻȂǰƫƾǫȁDZƢǨǗȋơ
DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗ
ǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơǎƸǧȄdzƛǮdzǀǯƪǧƾǿƾǬǧ Burdett & Jenson, 1983 ǹȂLjǼȈƳƩƽǁȂƥƨLJơǁƽƢǷƗ
Å
ƵȁơǂƬƫȆưǻƗȁÅơǂǯƿǶȀǼǷȐǨǗǺǷƨǻȂǰǷDZƢºǨǗȋơǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơ
ƩơǀdzơǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗƨLJơǁƾdzơƲƟƢƬǻƪǼȈƥƾǫȁƨǼLJ-ǺȈƥǶǿǁƢǸǟƗ
ƲƟƢƬǼdzơƩǂȀǛƗƢǸǯƭƢǻȍơǺǷƨȈǻơȁƾǟǂưǯƗǁȂǯǀdzơǹƗƲƟƢƬǼdzơƪƸǓȁƗǮdzǀǯDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁ
Å
ǩȁǂǨdzơƪǻƢǯȁȆǼǷDŽdzơǂǸǠǴdzƢǬǧȁǺȈLjǼƴdzơǺǷƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȆǧƨdzơƽ Å
ƢǫȁǂǧǭƢǼǿǹƗ Å
ƢǔȇƗ
ƢÅËǼLJǂƦǯȋơDZƢǨǗȋơƶdzƢǐdz
ǹơǂǫȋơǞǷȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơDzǟƢǨƬdzơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺǷDzǯƨǫȐǟǺǟǦnjǰdzơ John, 1986 ǹȂƳƨLJơǁƽƪǧƾȀƬLJơƢǸǯ
Å
džȈdzȐǨǗȁȆǻơȁƾǟǭȂǴLJǶȀȇƾdz Å
ȐǨǗǺǷƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟƪǻȂǰƫƾǫȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzƢƥ
ƲƟƢƬǼdzơƩǁƢNjƗƾǫȁȆƟơƾƬƥȏơdžǷƢƼdzơȁǞƥơǂdzơǺȈǨǐdzƢƥǹȂLJǁƾȇǺǸǷƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗǞȈǸƳǹƢǯȁȆǻơȁƾǟǭȂǴLJǶȀȇƾdz
DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁǹơǂǫȋơǺǷȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǒǧǂdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗȄdzƛ
ǺȈƥƨȈǟƢǸƬƳȏơƨǫȐǠdzơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺǷDzǯƨǫȐǟƪưƸƥƾǬǧ Philip, et al, 1987 ǾƟȐǷǃȁƤȈǴȈǧƨLJơǁƽƢǷƗ
ǽǀǿƪǻȂǰƫƾǫȁǶǴǠƫƩƢƥȂǠǏǶȀȇƾdzǺȇǀdzơDZƢǨǗȋơǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdzDzǐǨdzơDzƻơƽDzǨǘdzơƩƢȈǯȂǴLjƥǾƟȐǷǃȁDzǨǘdzơ
Å
ǭƢǼǿǹƗƨLJơǁƾdzơǽǀǿƢȀȈdzƛƪǴǏȂƫȆƬdzơƲƟƢƬǼdzơǶǿƗǺǷǹƢǯȁƨǼLJ-ǺȈƥǶǿǁƢǸǟƗƵȁơǂƬƫȐǨǗǺǷƨǼȈǠdzơ
ȃƾdzǞǨƫǂȇȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǹƗȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨǫȐǟ
ǶǿǁƢǸǟƗǵƾǬƫǞǷDZƢǨǗȋơ
ȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơDZȂƦǬdzơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨǠȈƦǗȄǴǟǥǂǠƬdzơ Rina & Thomas, 1992 DžƢǷȂƫƢǼȇǁƨLJơǁƽƪdzȁƢƷƢǸǯ
ƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƽȂƳȁǺǟƲƟƢƬǼdzơƪǨnjǯƾǫȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺǷDzǯȁƔƢǫƾǏȋơǺǷ
ƢǸǯDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǺǷDzǯȁƔƢǫƾǏȋơǺǷȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǒǧǂdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷ
Å
DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗƢǔȇƗƲƟƢƬǼdzơƪƸǓȁƗ
ǾƬǫȐǟȁƔƢǫƾǏȋơǞǷȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǪǧơȂƬdzơƨLJơǁƽȄdzƛ Ann & Stephen, 1994 ǺǨȈƬLJǹƕƨLJơǁƽƪǠLJƢǸǼȈƥ
Å
-ǺȈƥǺǿǁƢǸǟƗƵȁơǂƬƫƢƬǼƥǺǷƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟƪǻȂǰƫƾǫȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzƣƢƠƬǯȏơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺǷDzǰƥ
ǞǷȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǪǧơȂƬdzơǵƾǟǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗƢȀǸǿƗƲƟƢƬǻǺǟƨLJơǁƾdzơƩǂǨLJƗƾǫȁƨǼLJ
Å
ǭƢǼǿǹƗƢǔȇƗƲƟƢƬǼdzơƪǼȈƥƢǸǯƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗȃƾºdzƣƢƠƬǯȏơȁƩơǀdzơǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǺǷDzǯȁƔƢǫƾǏȋơ
DZƢǨǗȋơƔȏƚǿȃƾdzƣƢƠƬǯȏơȃȂƬLjǷȁƩơǀdzơǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟ
džǼƳǺǷDzǯƨǫȐǟƨǠȈƦǗȄǴǟǥǂǠƬdzơ Crick & Grotpeter, 1995 ǂƬȈƦƫȁǂƳǭǂȈǯƨLJơǁƽƪdzȁƢƷǺȈƷȆǧ
Å
ǺǷȐǨǗǺǷƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟƪǻȂǰƫƾǫȁDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzƢƥȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơȁȆLjǨǼdzơǪǧơȂƬdzơȁDzǨǘdzơ
ȃȂƬLjǷǹƗƢȀƴƟƢƬǻȆǧƨLJơǁƾdzơƪƸǓȁƗƾǫȁȆƟơƾƬƥȏơDžƽƢLjdzơȄƬƷƮdzƢưdzơǦǐdzƢƥǹȂLJǁƾȇǺȇǀdzơǺǷǺȈLjǼƴdzơ
Å
ǺǷDzǯǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗƢǔȇƗƲƟƢƬǼdzơƩǂȀǛƗƢǸǯǁȂǯǀdzơǺǟƭƢǻȍơȃƾdz Å
ƢǠǨƫǂǷǹƢǯƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ƢǸǯǺȈLjǼƴdzơǺǷDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƩơǀdzơǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơǵȂȀǨǸdzơȁƣƢƠƬǯȏơȁƨȈLjǨǼdzơƧƾƷȂdzƢƥǁȂǠnjdzơ
Å
ǶǿǁƢǸǟƗǵƾǬƫǞǷDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzǞǨƫǂȇƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơȃȂƬLjǷǹƗƢǔȇƗƲƟƢƬǼdzơƪƸǓȁƗ
ƨǬƥƢLjdzơƩƢLJơǁƾdzơȄǴǟǪȈǴǠƬdzơ
ȆǴȇƢǷƢȀǼǷǎǴƼƬLjǻǹƗǺǰǸȇƢȀȈdzƛƪǴǏȂƫȆƬdzơƲƟƢƬǼdzơǶǿƗȁƨǬƥƢLjdzơƩƢLJơǁƾǴdzƨưƷƢƦdzơǑǂǟƾǠƥ
ƨǷƢǟƨǨǐƥȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǂȈǣǭȂǴLjdzơǞǷƨƦƳȂǷƨǫȐǠƥǖƦƫǂƫDZƢǨǗȋơȄǴǟǹơƾdzơȂdzơƢȀLJǁƢǸȇȆƬdzơƨȇƾdzơȂdzơǕȂǤǔdzơǹƗ .1
Kinard, 1978 DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzƨǏƢƻƨǨǐƥȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁ
ƧȏƢƦǸdzơǵƾǟȁDZƢǸǿȍơȁǒǧǂdzơȆǧDzưǸƬƫȆƬdzơƨƠǗƢƼdzơƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗ .2
; Burdett & Jenson, 1983 )DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾºdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƣƢƠƬǯȏơȁǪǴǬdzơǺȈƥȁDzǨǘdzơȄºǴǟǹơȁƾǠdzơȁ
John, 1986 ; Philip, et al, 1987; Ann &
Stephen, 1994
Å
ƨǫȐǟƢǔȇƗƾƳȂƫƢǸǯDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzƣƢƠƬǯȏơȁƨȈLJǁƾǸdzơȁƨȇǂLJȋơǕȂǤǔdzơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫǾǻƗ .3
Rina & Thomas, 1992 ǶȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƣƢƠƬǯȏơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơ
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǾǯȂºǴLJȁǾƫơƿǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơDzǨǘdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗ .4
(Kinard, 1978 ; Burdett & Jenson, 1983 ; John, 1986 ; Philip, et al, 1987 ; Rina &
Thomas, 1992, Crick & Grotpeter, 1995)
Å
ƢǔȇƗƾƳȂƫƢǸǯǾǻơǂǫƗǺǷȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǾǔǧǁȁǾƫơƿǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơDzǨǘdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿǹƗ .5
& John, 1986; Philip, et al, 1987 ; Rina)ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǾǯȂǴLJȁǾǻơǂǫƗǺǷDzǨǘdzơǒǧǁǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨǫȐǟ
Thomas, 1992 )
ǾǻơǂǫƗǺǷȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǾǔǧǁȁǾƫơƿǺǟƤdzƢLjdzơDzǨǘdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺǷDzǯǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫǮdzǀǯ .6
ǾȇƾdzƣƢƠƬǯȏơǑơǂǟƗȁ
(Philip, et al, 1987 ; Ann & Stephen, 1994 )
DZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƣƢƠƬǯȏơǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟǭƢǼǿ .7
(Philip, et al, 1987 ; Crick & Grotpeter, 1995)
ǶǿǁƢǸǟƗǵƾǬƫǞǷDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzǞǨƫǂȇƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơȃȂƬLjǷǹƗ .8
( Burdett & Jenson, 1983 ; Philip, et al, 1987 ; Crick & Grotpeter, 1995 )
ƨLJơǁƾdzơǑȁǂǧ
ƨưƷƢƦdzơǡȂǐƫƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƢȀƴdzƢǠƫȆƬdzơƩơǂȈǤƬǸdzơDzǛȆǧȁƨǬƥƢLjdzơƩƢLJơǁƾdzơƲƟƢƬǻǾǼǟƩǂǨLJƗƢǷƔȂǓȆǧ
ȆǴȇƢǸȈǧƨLJơǁƾdzơǑȁǂǧ
ȆƫȉơȄǴǟǎǼȇȁDZȁȋơǑǂǨdzơ
ǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơDZȂƦǬǴdzƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǭơǁƽƛǺȈƥƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .1
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǑƢǨƼǻơȁ
ǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂǴdzƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǭơǁƽƛǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .2
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǝƢǨƫǁơȁ
ȆǴȇƢǷȄǴǟǎǼȇȁȆǻƢưdzơǑǂǨdzơ
ƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǑƢǨƼǻơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǝƢǨƫǁơǺȈƥƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ
ƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơ
ȆǴȇƢǷȄǴǟǎǼȇȁƮdzƢưdzơǑǂǨdzơ
ǺLjdzơǁƢƦǯȁǺLjdzơǁƢǤǏƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺȈƥȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȆǧƢÅËȈƟƢǐƷƛƨdzơƽǩȁǂǧƾƳȂƫ
ǺLjdzơǁƢƦǯƩơǀȈǸǴƬdzơƶdzƢǐdz
ƨLJơǁƾdzơƲȀǼǷ
ǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨǠȈƦǗǦnjǰdzƤLJƢǼǸdzơȂǿƲȀǼǸdzơơǀǿǹƛƮȈƷƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơȆǧȄǨǏȂdzơƲȀǼǸdzơƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǠƦƫơ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơƩơǂȈǤƬǷ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟ
ǹƗƩƾƳȁȁƧƾƳƨǼȇƾǸƥƨǫǂǨƬǷƔƢȈƷƗȆǧǞǬƫȆƬdzơƨȈǷȂǰƸdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơDžǁơƾǸdzơǺǷƾȇƾǠdzơƧǁƢȇDŽƥƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƢǫƾǬdz
ƧƾƳƨǼȇƾǸƥƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǞǸƬƴǷDzưǸƫǺȈǠƦLjdzơȁƨǠƥƢLjdzơȁǺȈƯȐưdzơȁƨLjǷƢƼdzơǺȈƬLJǁƾǸdzơ
ǞǫȁǮdzǀdzȅƽƢǐƬǫȏơȁȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơȃȂƬLjǸdzơȆǧƨǘLJȂƬǸdzơƨǬƦǘdzơƔƢǼƥƗǺǷƢȀƫơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷȄǸǜǠdzơƨȈƦdzƢǤdzơǹȋǮdzƿȁ
ǺǷƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟƪǻȂǰƫƾǫȁƢǸȀƫơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǼȈǟȄºǴǟƢȀƬLJơǁƽƩơȁƽƗǪȈƦǘƬdzǺȈƬLJǁƾǸdzơǺȈƫƢǿȄǴǟƨưƷƢƦdzơǁƢȈƬƻơ
ƨLjǷƢƼdzơƨLJǁƾǸdzơǺǷƧǀȈǸǴƫ ǺȀǼǷǹƢǯȁǺȈƬLJǁƾǸdzơǺȈƫƢȀƥȆƟơƾƬƥȏơDžƽƢLjdzơȁƮdzƢưdzơǺȈǨǐdzƢƥƨǴǨǗ
ǖLJȂƬǸƥƨǼLJ - ǺȈƥǺǿǁƢǸǟƗƪƷȁơǂƫƾºǫȁǺȈǠƦLjdzơȁƨǠƥƢLjdzơƨLJǁƾǸdzơǺǷƧǀȈǸǴƫ ȁǺȈƯȐưdzơȁ
ƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗǞȇǃȂƫ ǶǫǁDZȁƾƴdzơǺȈƦȇȁ ǽǁƾǫȃǁƢȈǠǷǥơǂƸǻơȁÅơǂȀNj ǽǁƾǫȃǂǸǟ
ƨLJǁƾǸdzơȁǦǐdzơƤLjƷ
ǶǫǁDZȁƾƳ
ƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗǞȇǃȂƫǺȈƦȇ
ƨȇȂƠǸdzơƨƦLjǼdzơ ǀȈǷȐƬdzơƽƾǟ ƨLJǁƾǸdzơ ȆLJơǁƾdzơǦǐdzơ
ǹȂƯȐưdzơȁƨLjǷƢƼdzơ
ƮdzƢưdzơ
ǹȂǠƦLjdzơȁƨǠƥƢLjdzơ
ǹȂƯȐưdzơȁƨLjǷƢƼdzơ
DžƽƢLjdzơ
ǹȂǠƦLjdzơȁƨǠƥƢLjdzơ
ºº ǝȂǸƴǸdzơ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơƩơȁƽƗ
DZƢǨǗȌdzȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơDZȂƦǬdzơƨǻƢƦƬLJơ .1
ǵ ƨǷȐLJƨȈƥǂǠǴdzƢȀƬǸƳǂƫƾǫȁǾȇƾdzơȁDzƦǫǺǷǒǧǁȁƗDZȂƦǫǺǷDzǨǘdzơǾǯǁƾȇƢǷdžȈǬƫȆƫơǀdzơǂȇǂǬƬǴdzƧơƽƗȂǿȁ
ȆǿƨȈǟǂǧdžȈȇƢǬǷƨǠƥǁƗȄǴǟƨǟǃȂǷƧǁƢƦǟ ǺǷǹȂǰƬȇȂǿȁȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơȁDZȂƦǬǴdzǂǻȁǁDžƢȈǬǷǺǟ Ʊ
ǹȂǰƬȇȁƽƾƸǸdzơǂȈǣǒǧǂdzơȁƧȏƢƦǸdzơǵƾǟDZƢǸǿȍơȁǭǁƾǸdzơƔơƾºǠdzơǹơȁƾǠdzơȁǭǁƾǸdzơƨƦƸǸdzơƔǥƾdzơ
ǺǷƢȀƫơǁƢƦǟƨǣƢȈǏǂȈȈǤƫǞǷƣȋơƧǁȂǏƩơǁƢƦǟƢȀLjǨǻƢȀƥǵȌdzȃǂƻȋơȁƣȌdzƢǸǿơƾƷƛǺȈƫǁȂǏǺǷDžƢȈǬǸdzơ
DzǯȆǧȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơȁDZȂƦǬdzơǺǷDzǰdzƨǴǬƬLjǷƨȈǴǯƨƳǁƽȄǘǠƫǺȈƫǁȂǐdzơǺȈƫƢǿǺǷƧǁȂºǏDzǯȁƮǻƚǸǴdzǂǯǀǸdzơ
ƧƾƳȄǴǟƧǁȂǏ
ǂnjǼdzơƪƸƫƗǁƾƥ ƨǬƥƢLJƨLJơǁƾƥƢȀǷƢȈǫƔƢǼƯƗȆǧƨȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨƠȈƦdzơȄǴǟDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǺȈǼǬƬƥƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƢǫƾǬdzȁ
ƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷǺȈǼǬƬdzơƨǼȈǟƪǻƢǯȁƨȈdzƢƸdzơƢȀƬLJơǁƽǾȈǧƩǂƳƗȅǀdzơȆLJơǁƾdzơǵƢǠdzơǾLjǨǻȆǧƢȀƫǂƳƗ
Å
ǩǂǘdzǑǂǟȆǴȇƢǸȈǧȁƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟǎƟƢǐƻƢǷƢǸƫǾƦnjƫƪǻƢǯǺȈǼǬƬdzơƨǼȈǟǎƟƢǐƻǞȈǸƳȁƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǩƾǏȁƩƢƦƯƣƢLjƷ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơƩƢƦƯ
ƩȐǷƢǠǷƪǻƢǯȁƹƢƦǻȁǂǰdzƢǨdzƗȆǿȄdzȁȋơƨǬȇǂǘdzơƪǻƢǯƮȈƷǺȈƬǬȇǂǘƥDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀȀdzƩƢƦưdzơDzǷƢǠǷƣƢLjƷǶƫ
ȁǭǁƾǸdzơƔơƾǠdzơǹơȁƾǠǴdz ȁǭǁƾǸdzơƨƦƸǸdzơƔǥƾǴdz ȆǿƨȈǟǂǨdzơdžȈȇƢǬǸǴdzƩƢƦưdzơ
ƨºȈǨǐǼdzơƨƟDŽƴƬdzơȆǿƨºȈǻƢưdzơƨºǬȇǂǘdzơƪǻƢǯƢǸǼȈƥƽƾƸǸdzơǂȈǣǒºǧǂǴdz ȁƧȏƢƦǸdzơǵƾǟDZƢǸǿȎdz
ȅȁƢLjȇƩƢƦưdzơDzºǷƢǠǷǹƢǯȁ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơǩƾǏ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơȁƧǁƢƦǟDzǯƨƳǁƽǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƪǻƢǯȁȆǴƻơƾdzơǩƢLjƫȏơǪȇǂǗǺǟDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǩƾǏƣƢLjƷǶƫƾǬdz
ȄǟǂǧDžƢȈǬǷDzǯƨƳǁƽǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƪǻƢǯƢǸǯ - ǺȈƥƵȁơǂƬƫǾȈdzƛȄǸƬǼƫȅǀºdzơȆǟǂǨdzơ
ǺȈƥƵȁơǂƬƫƨǻƢƦƬLJȐdzƨȈǴǰdzơƨƳǁƾdzơȁ
ȃȂƬLjǷƾǼǟƨdzơƽƢȀǠȈǸƳȁ -
DZƢǨǗȌdzƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷDžƢȈǬǷ .2
ȅƢnjƥȁǁȂǐǼǷǺǷDzǯǽƾǟƗƾǫȁǾƫơǀdzDzǨǘdzơǭơǁƽƛƨȈǨȈǯǺǟǦnjǰƫȆƫơǀdzơǂȇǂǬƬǴdzƧơƽƗƢǔȇƗȂǿȁ Å
DžƢȈǬǸdzơǹȂǰƬȇȁ
ƩơǂƦƼdzơȁƔƢǫƾǏȋơǞǷƩƢǫȐǠdzơȁƨȇǂLJȋơƩơǂƦƼdzơȆǿƨȈǟǂǧdžȈȇƢǬǷƨƯȐƯȄǴǟƨǟǃȂǷƧǁƢƦǟ ǺǷ
ƪƸƫǁƾƥ ƨǬƥƢLJƨLJơǁƾƥƢȀǷƢȈǫƔƢǼƯƗƨȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨƠȈƦdzơȄǴǟDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǺȈǼǬƬƥƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƢǫƾǬdzȁƨȈLJǁƾǸdzơ
ǺǷǺȈǼǬƬdzơƨǼȈǟƪǻƢǯȁƨȈdzƢƸdzơƢȀƬLJơǁƽǾȈǧƩǂƳƗȅǀdzơȆLJơǁƾdzơǵƢǠdzơdžǨǻȆǧƢȀƫǂƳƗ ǪƥƢLjdzơǞƳǂǸdzơǂnjǼdzơ
Å
ƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟǎƟƢǐƻƢǷƢǸƫǾƦnjƫƪǻƢǯǺȈǼǬƬdzơƨǼȈǟǎƟƢǐƻǞȈǸƳȁƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǩƾǏȁƩƢƦƯƣƢLjƷǩǂǘdzǑǂǟȆǴȇƢǸȈǧȁ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơƩƢƦƯ
ǵƢǫǁȋơƩơƿƩơǂǬǨdzơȁƨȇƽǂǨdzơǵƢǫǁȋơƩơƿƩơǂǬǨdzơǺȈƥƨȈǨǐǼdzơƨƟDŽƴƬdzơǪȇǂǗǺǟDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀȀdzƩƢƦưdzơƣƢLjƷǶƫ
ǹȁơǂƥȁǹƢǷǂȈƦLJƨdzƽƢǠǸƥǾƸȈƸǐƫƾǠƥ ȅȁƢLjȇƩƢºƦưdzơDzºǷƢǠǷǹƢǯȁƨȈƳȁDŽdzơ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơǩƾǏ
ƧǁƢƦǟDzǯƨƳǁƽǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƪǻƢǯƾǫȁȆǴƻơƾdzơǩƢLjƫȏơǪȇǂǗǺǟDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǩƾǏƣƢLjƷǶƫƾǬdz
džȈȇƢǬǸdzơƩƢƳǁƽǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƪǻƢǯƢǸǼȈƥ - ǺȈƥƵȁơǂƬƫǾȈdzƛȆǸƬǼƫȅǀdzơȆǟǂǨdzơDžƢȈǬǸdzơȁ
ƵȁơǂƬƫDžƢȈǬǸǴdzƨȈǴǰdzơƨƳǁƾdzơȁƨȈǟǂǨdzơ
ȃȂƬLjǷƾǼǟƨdzơƽƩƢǗƢƦƫǁȏơǽǀǿǞȈǸƳȁ - ǺȈƥ
ǶǴǠǸdzơǂȇƾǬƫDzǨǘdzơǭȂǴLJǂȇƾǬƬdzǃǂǻȂǯDžƢȈǬǷ .3
ƨǴƷǂǸdzơDZƢǨǗƗȃƾdzƨȈǯȂǴLjdzơƩƢƥơǂǘǓȏơdžȈǬƫȆƬdzơƩơȁƽȋơǶǿƗǺǷDzǨǘdzơǭȂǴLJǂȇƾǬƬdzǃǂǻȂǯDžƢȈǬǷǂƦƬǠȇ
ǶºƳǂƫƾǫȁƢȀƳǁƢƻȁƗƨLJơǁƾdzơƧǂƴƷDzƻơƽǮdzƿǹƢǯƔơȂLJǶǴǠǸdzơǂǜǻƨȀƳȁǺǷǮdzƿȁƨLJǁƾǸdzơDzƻơƽƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơ
DzǨǘdzơǭȂǴLJǂȇƾǬƬdz Conners ǃǂǻȂǯDžƢȈǬǷǺǷ Ɨ ƧǁȂǐdzơǺǟ ǵ ȄǻȁƽƢǸLjdzơƨºȈƥǂǠǴdzDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿ
ǪǴǬdzơȁƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơȁƨȈǟƢǸƬƳȏơȆǿƨȈǟǂǧdžȈȇƢǬǷƨLjǸƻȄǴǟƨǟǃȂǷƧǁƢƦǟ ǺǷDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǹȂǰƬȇȁ
ǎƬƼƫȆƬdzơdžȈȇƢǬǸdzơǺȈƥƨǤdzƢƥƨȈǸǿƗǺǷDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǾƥȄǜƸȇƢǸdzÅơǂǜǻȁȆǯǂƸdzơǕƢnjǼdzơǕǂǧȁǽƢƦƬǻȏơǦǠǓȁ
ƶǴǐȇDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǺǷȆǟǂǧDžƢȈǬǷDzǯǹƘƥƨȈƥǂǠǴdzDžƢȈǬǸdzơƾǠ Ë ǷǾǼȈƥƢǸdz
É Å
ƢǬǧȁȁñ ƨǨǴƬƼǸdzơǽƽƢǠƥƗǺǷƽƾƸǷƾǠƥDžƢȈǬƥ
ȆǟǂǨdzơDžƢȈǬǸdzơƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƾƼƬLJơǮdzǀdzǾƥǍƢƼdzơƾǠƦǴdzƨȈǯȂǴLjdzơǂǿƢǜǸdzơDžƢºȈǬdzDzǬƬLjǷDžƢȈǬǸǯǾǷơƾƼƬLJȏ
ƩƗǁƮȈƷƢȀƬLJơǁƽƨǼȈǟƽơǂǧƗȃƾdzǶǴǠǸdzơǂǜǻƨȀƳȁǺǷƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơȃȂƬLjǷDžƢȈǬdzǮdzƿȁDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǺǷǹơȁƾǠǴdz
ƧǂƴƷDzƻơƽƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơǀȈǷȐƫȃƾdzƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơȃȂƬLjǷdžȈǬȇǾǻƗȁƨǏƢƻǑǂǤdzơơǀȀdzƶǴǐȇDžƢȈǬǷDzǔǧƗǾǻƗ
ƢȀƳǁƢƻȁƨLJơǁƾdzơ
ƪƸƫƣǁƾƥ ƨǬƥƢLJƨLJơǁƾƥƢºȀǷƢȈǫƔƢǼƯƗȆǧƨȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨƠȈƦdzơȄǴǟDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǺȈǼǬƬƥƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƢǫƾǬdzȁ
ƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷǺȈǼǬƬdzơƨǼȈǟƪǻƢǯȁƨȈdzƢƸdzơƢȀƬLJơǁƽǾȈǧƩǂƳƗȅǀdzơǾLjǨǻȆLJơǁƾdzơǵƢǠdzơȆǧƢȀƫǂƳƗ ǂnjǼdzơ
Å
ƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟǎƟƢǐƻƢǷƢǸƫǾƦnjƫƪǻƢǯDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀȀdzǺȈǼǬƬdzơƨǼȈǟǎƟƢǐƻǞȈǸƳȁƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀǿǩƾǏȁƩƢƦƯƣƢLjƷǩǂǘdzǑǂǟȆǴȇƢǸȈǧȁ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơƩƢƦƯ
ǵƢǫǁȋơƩơƿƩơǂǬǨdzơȁƨȇƽǂǨdzơǵƢǫǁȋơƩơƿƩơǂǬǨdzơǺȈƥƨȈǨǐǼdzơƨƟDŽƴƬdzơƨǬȇǂǘƥDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀȀdzƩƢƦưdzơƣƢLjƷǶƫ
ǹȁơǂƥȁǹƢǷǂȈƦLJƨdzƽƢǠǸƥǾƸȈƸǐƫƾǠƥ ȅȁƢºLjȇƩƢƦưdzơDzºǷƢǠǷǹƢǯȁƨȈƳȁDŽdzơ
DžƢȈǬǸdzơǩƾǏ
DzǷƢǠǷǹƢǯȁȆƫơǀdzơǩƾǐdzƢƥȄdzȁȋơƨǬȇǂǘdzơȆǧǾƥƢLjƷǶƫƮȈƷǩǂǗƭȐưƥDžƢȈǬǸdzơơǀȀdzǩƾǐdzơƣƢLjƷǶƫ
ȃȁƢLjƫ Ʃ ƪǻƢǯƾǫȁƨȈǧǂǘdzơƨǻǁƢǬǸdzƢƥƨȈǻƢưdzơƨǬȇǂǘdzơȆǧǾƥƢLjƷǶƫƢǸǼȈƥ ȅȁƢLjȇǩƾǐdzơ
ȃȂƬLjǷƾºǼǟƨºdzơƽȆǿȁ
DzǯƨƳǁƽǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƪǻƢǯƾǫȁȄǴƻơƾdzơǩƢLjƫȏƢƥƨưdzƢưdzơƨǬȇǂǘdzơȆǧǾƥƢLjƷǶƫǮdzǀǯ
ƨƳǁƽǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƪǻƢǯƢǸǯ - ǺȈƥƵȁơǂƬƫǾȈdzƛȆǸƬǼƫȅǀdzơȆǟǂǨdzơDžƢȈǬǸdzơƨƳǁƽȁƧǁƢƦǟ
ǺȈƥƵȁơǂƬƫDžƢȈǬǸǴdzƨȈǴǰdzơƨºƳǁƾdzơȁȆǟǂǧDžƢȈǬǷDzǯ
-
ǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƪǻƢǯƾǬǧƨȈdzƢƸdzơƢȀƬLJơǁƽȆǧƨưƷƢƦdzơǾǷƾƼƬLjƫȅǀdzơ ȆǟǂǨdzơ ƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơDžƢȈǬǸdzƨƦLjǼdzƢƥƢǷƗ
ơǀȀdzƨȈǴǰdzơƨºƳǁƾdzơǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơDzǷƢǠǷǹƢǯƢǸǯ - ǺȈƥƵȁơǂƬƫǾdzƨȈǴǰdzơƨƳǁƾdzơȁƧǁƢƦǟDzǯƨƳǁƽ
ƾǼǟƨºdzơƽǂǯǀdzơƨǨdzƢLJƩƢǗƢƦƫǁȏơǽǀǿǞȈǸƳȁ Ȇǿ ǃǂǻȂǯ DžƢȈǬǸdzƨȈǴǰdzơƨºƳǁƾdzơȁȆǟǂǨdzơDžƢºȈǬǸdzơ
ȃȂƬLjǷ
ƢȀǷơƾƼƬLJȏǺƠǸǘȇƢǸƥƩƢƦưdzơȁǩƾǐdzơǺǷƨȈdzƢǟƨƳǁƾƥǞƬǸƬƫƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƩơȁƽƗǞȈǸƳǹƗȄdzƛǮdzƿǺǷǎǴƼǻȁ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơǽǀºǿȆǧ
ƨLJơǁƾdzơƩơƔơǂƳƛ
ƧǁơƽƛǺǷȆǸLJǁǹƿƛȄǴǟƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǴǐƷǺȈǠƦLjdzơȁƨǠƥƢLjdzơȁǺȈƯȐưdzơȁƨLjǷƢƼdzơǺȈƬLJǁƾǸdzƢƥƨLJơǁƾdzơǹƢǰǷƾȇƾƸƫƾǠƥ
ǺǷƨǼȈǟȄǴǟƢȀƬLJơǁƽƩơȁƽƗǪȈƦǘƫǺǷƨưƷƢƦdzơǺȈǰǸƬdzǺȈƬLJǁƾǸdzơǺȈƫƢǿȆƫǂȇƾǷȄdzƛǾƳȂǷƧƾƴƥǶȈǴǠƬdzơȁƨȈƥǂƬdzơ
ƢȀLjǨǼƥƪǷƢǫȁǺȈƬLJǁƾǸdzơǺȈƫƢǿƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨȈƟơȂnjǟƨǼȈǟǁƢȈƬƻƢƥǮdzƿƾǠƥƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƢǫǶƯǺȈƬLJǁƾǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫ
DžƢȈǬǸdzƨƦLjǼdzƢƥƢǷƗƨȇƽǂǧƨǬȇǂǘƥƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗȄǴǟƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷDžƢȈǬǷȁȅƾdzơȂdzơǒºǧǂdzơDZȂºƦǬdzơƨǻƢƦƬLJơǪȈƦǘƬƥ
ÅơƾƳơȂƫǂưǯȋơƩƢǸǴǠǸdzơȄǴǟƨưƷƢƦdzơǾƬǬƦǗǮdzǀdzǶǴǠǸdzơǂǜǻƨȀƳȁǺǷDZƢǨǗȋơƨȈǻơȁƾǟdžȈǬȇǾǻȋÅơǂǜǼǧƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ƨȈƥȐǘdzơƧƾNjǂǸdzơǺȈƥƪƯƾƷƩơǁȁƢnjǷƧƾǟƾǠƥƩƢǸǴǠǸdzơƔȏƚǿǁƢȈƬƻơǶƫƾǬdzȁƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗƩơǀȈǸǴƬdzƢƥƢǯƢǰƬƷơȁ Å
Å
ƽơǂǧƗƩơǀȈǸǴƬdzơǞǷȐǷƢǠƫȁ ÅơƾƳơȂƫǂưǯȋơƩƢǸǴǠǸdzơǺǿǺǷȄǴǟǥǂǠƬǴdzǺȈƬLJǁƾǸdzơǺȈƫƢǿǺǷƨLJǁƾǷDzǰƥƧǂȇƾǸdzơȁ
ƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƨǼȈǟ
ƨȈdzƢƬdzơƨȈƟƢǐƷȍơƩƢƴdzƢǠǸdzơƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƾƼƬLJơƨȈƟƢǐƷȍơƨƴdzƢǠǸdzơ
ǖȈLJȂdzơȁǖLJȂƬǸdzơ ƨȇDŽǯǂǸdzơƨǟDŽǼdzơdžȈȇƢǬǷ .1
ȅǁƢȈǠǸdzơǥơǂƸǻȏơȁȃƾǸdzơ ƪƬnjƬdzơdžȈȇƢǬǷ .2
ǹȂLJǂȈƥǕƢƦƫǁơDzǷƢǠǷ .3
T. Test ƩǁƢƦƬƻơ .4
ƢȀƬnjǫƢǼǷȁƨLJơǁƾdzơƲƟƢƬǻ
ȆǴȇƢǷȄǴǟǎǼȇȁDZȁȋơǑǂǨdzơ
ǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơDZȂƦǬǴdzƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǭơǁƽƛǺȈƥƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .1
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǑƢǨƼǻơȁ
ǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂǴdzƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǭơǁƽƛǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .2
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǝƢǨƫǁơȁ
ƽơǂǧƗƩơǀȈǸǴƬdzơǭơǁƽƛƩƢƳǁƽƩƢǘLJȂƬǷǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƣƢLjƸƥƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƢǫǑǂǨdzơơǀǿƨƸǏǺǷǪǬƸƬǴdzȁ
ǶǫǁDZȁƾƴdzƢƥǺȈƦǷȂǿƢǸǯǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơȁDZȂƦǬǴdzƨǼȈǠdzơ
ǶǫǁDZȁƾƳ
ƩơǀȈǸǴƫǭơǁƽƛƩƢƳǁƽƩƢǘLJȂƬǷǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơƩȐǷƢǠǷƶǓȂȇ
ǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơȁDZȂƦǬǴdzƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơ
ƨdzȏƾdzơȃȂƬLjǷ ƨȈdzȁƾƴdzơƨǸȈǬdzơ ǁ ǝ ǵ ƩơǂȈǤƬǸdzơ
ƣȋơDZȂƦǫ
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơ
ƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơȁȅƾdzơȂdzơDZȂƦǬdzơ
ǵȋơDZȂƦǫ
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơ
Å
ǺǷǞǨƫǂǷȃȂƬLjǷǺȀȇƾdzǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷƩƢǓȂǧǂǷǺȀLjǨǻƗǺǯǁƽƗȆƟȐdzơƪǻƢǯƢǸǼȈƥƢǔǨƼǼǷǺȀȇƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơ
ȃƾdzȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơȁȆLjǨǼdzơǪǧơȂƬdzơȄǴǟƾǟƢLjƫȆƬdzơDzǷơȂǠdzơǶǿƗǺǷƾǠ Ë ÉȇȅƾdzơȂdzơDZȂƦǬdzơǹƘƥƲƟƢƬǼdzơǽǀǿƨưƷƢƦdzơǂLjǨƫȁ
ǺȇȂǰƫȁȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơǪǧơȂƬdzơȁȆLjǨǼdzơǦȈǰƬdzơȄǴǟǽƾǟƢLjƫDzǨǘǴdzǺȇƾdzơȂdzơDzƦǫǺǷƨǼLjƸdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơǹƛƮȈƷDZƢǨǗȋơ
ǂǠnjȇȄƬdzơȁDzǨǘǴdzǺȇƾdzơȂdzơDzƦǫǺǷƨƠȈLjdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơǹƗƾƴǻǮdzƿǺǷǒȈǬǼdzơȄǴǟȁǺȇǂƻȉơǞǷƨƦȈǗƨȈǟƢǸƬƳơƩƢǫȐǟ
Geri) (ƣƢƠƬǯȏơȁǪºǴǬdzƢƥǾƬƥƢǏƛȄdzƛȃƽƚƫȁǾLjǨǻȆǧƨǬưdzơƾºǬǨȇǾǴǠƴƫǾºȈǧƣȂǣǂǷǂȈǣȁǑȂǧǂǷǾǻƗƢȀǼǷ
& Dana, 1993, P : 26džǰǠǼȇȁ ǍǵȄǟƢǧǂdzơ ƨȇȁơƽȂLJƧǂºǜǻƧƢºȈƸǴdzǂǜǼȇǾǴǠƴȇơǀǿȁ
ǞȈǘƬLjȇȏȆƬdzơǾƬȈǻơȁƾǟǶȀȈdzƛǾƳȂȇȁǶȀƥǾƬǫȐǟƣǂǘǔƫƮȈƷǾǻơǂǫƗƨºǏƢƻǺȇǂƻȉƢƥǾƬǫȐǟȄǴǟǮdzƿ
ǾdzƨƦLjǼdzƢƥȄƳǁƢƼdzơǖƦǔdzơȁƨǘǴLjdzơǁƾǐǷǹȐưǸȇƢǸȀǻƗȃǂȇǺÌȇǀǴdzơǺȇƾdzơȂǴdzƢȀȀȈƳȂƫ
ǹƗ Ǎǵ džǻȂȇǂǯǀƫƮȈƷƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƲƟƢƬǻƾȇƚƫȆƬdzơƔơǁȉơǺǷƾºȇƾǠdzƢƥƭơǂºƬdzơƢºǻƾǸȇȁ
ǾǻƢǷǂƷȁǾdzǾȇƾdzơȁƔơƾǟƨǏƢƻǾƬƠȈƥȆǧDzǨǘdzơǾȈǻƢǠȇƢǸdzDzǠǧƽǂǯƭƾƸƫDZƢǨǗȋơȃƾdzƨȈǯȂǴLjdzơƩƢƥơǂǘǓȏơǞȈǸƳ
ȆƫƢƥȂǰȈLjdzơȁƗȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȄdzƛƘƴǴȈǧƢǸȀǨǘǟǺǷ
ƢȀǼǷǹȁǂǠnjȇȆƬdzơƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƔȂLJǺǷǹȂǻƢǠȇǺȈȈǻơȁƾǠdzơDZƢǨǗȋơǹƗȄdzƛ Ǎǵ ȆLjǼǷǂȈnjȇƢǸǯ
ǶȀȈǧƣȂǣǂǷǂȈǣȁǹȂǓȂǧǂǷǶȀǻƗ
ƽƢǔǸdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǶȀǼȈƥǞȈnjȇȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơǹȁǂǠnjƬLjȇǺȇǀdzơDZƢǨǗȋơǹƗ Ǎǵ ȄǫȂLJƽǺȈƦȇƢǔȇƗȁ Å
ǺȇǂƻȉơǺȈƥƨǼƬǨdzơǞǫȂȇȅǀdzơƣǀǰdzơȁƨǫǂLjdzơȁƧȂLjǬdzơȁȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơDzưǷǞǸƬƴǸǴdz
ǭȂǴLjdzơȄdzƛǹȂǴȈǸȇǶȀdzǺȇƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂƥǹȁǂǠnjȇǺȇǀdzơDZƢǨǗȋơǹƗ ǍǵǶƳǂƬǷ DzȇƢƳǁƗǂǯǀȇƢǸǯ
ȆƫƢƥȂǰȈLjdzơǥơǂƸǻȏơǮdzƿȆǧƢǸƥȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ȄdzƛDzȈǸȇǺȇƾdzơȂdzơDzƦǫǺǷǾȈǧƣȂǣǂǸdzơǂȈǣȁDzǸȀǸdzơDzǨǘdzơǹƗ Ǎǵ ȄǟƢǧǂdzơƶǓȂȇǮdzǀǯ
Å
ƢǻƢȈƷƗƨǫǂLjdzơȁƣǀǰdzơȁȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơ
ȏǺȈȈǧƢǯȃȂƥƗǦǘǟȁƤƷȄǴǟǹȂǴǐƸȇȏǺȇǀdzơDZƢǨǗȋơǹƗȄdzƛ Ǎǵ ƾǸƸǷǂȈnjȇƢºǸǯ
ǶȀǴǷƢǠȇǺȇǀdzơǶȀǻơǂǫƗǺǟÅơǂƫȂƫȁƢǬǴǫǂưǯƗȁǞǸƬƴǸdzơȆǧ
Å Å
ƢƳƢǷƾǻơDzǫƗȁǶȀLjǨǻƘƥƨǬƯDzǫƗǶȀǻƗƢǸǯǺǷȋƢƥǹȁǂǠnjȇ
ȅƾdzơȂdzơȆǨǗƢǠdzơƔǥƾdzƢƥǹȁǂǠnjȇȁƤƸƥǹƾdzơȂdzơ
ǀƦǼdzơȁȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzƢƥDŽȈǸƬȇȅǂLJƗȂƳȆǧǹȁƘnjǼȇǺȇǀdzơDZƢǨǗȋơǹƗ Ǎǵ ƨȈǿƢǻȂƥƗǂǯǀȇƢǔȇƗ Å
ǶȀƥƨǘȈƸǸdzơƨƠȈƦdzơǞǷǦȈǰƬdzơǶȀȈǴǟƤǠǐȇȁȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȄdzƛǹȂǴȈǸȇǶȀdzƔơƾǠdzơȁ
ǦǠǓȁǪǴǬdzƢƥǶȀƬƥƢǏƛȄdzƛȅƽƚƫDZƢǨǗȌdzǺȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǷƔȂLJǹƗ Ǎǵ DzǷƢǯȃǂȇÅơǂȈƻƗȁ
ǶȀȇƾdzƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơȃȂƬLjǷǝƢǨƫǁơȁǶȀƫơǀdzǶǿǂȇƾǬƫ
ƨƠǗƢƼdzơƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗǺȈƥƨƦƳȂǷƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫǾǻƗƪǼȈƥȆƬdzơƨǬƥƢLjdzơƩƢLJơǁƾdzơƲƟƢƬǻǞǷƨƴȈƬǼdzơǽǀǿǪǨƬƫȁ
ȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǺȈƥȁDzǨǘdzơȄǴǟǹơȁƾǠdzơȁƨȇƾdzơȂdzơǕȂǤǔdzơȁƧȏƢƦǸdzơǵƾǟȁDZƢǸǿȍơȁǒǧǂdzơȆǧDzưǸƬƫȆƬdzơ
DZƢǨǗȋơ
( Gerald, 1986 ; Hiram, et al, 1989 ; Geri & Dana, 1993 ; Wintzel & Asher, 1995 ;
Xinyin, et, al, 1995 ; Karlen, 1996 )
ȆƫȉơȄǴǟǎǼȇȁȆǻƢưdzơǑǂǨdzơ
ƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǑƢǨƼǻơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǝƢǨƫǁơǺȈƥƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ
ƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơ
ȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơDzǷƢǠǷƣƢLjƸƥƨưƷƢƦdzơƪǷƢǫǑǂǨdzơơǀǿƨƸǏǺǷǪǬƸƬǴdzȁ
ǶǫǁDZȁƾƴdzƢƥǺȈƦǷȂǿƢǸǯƨǼȈǠdzơƽơǂǧƗ
ǶǫǁDZȁƾƳ
ƩƢƳǁƽƩƢǘLJȂƬǷǺȈƥǕƢƦƫǁȏơDzǷƢǠǷƶǓȂȇ
ƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷ
ƨdzȏƾdzơȃȂƬLjǷ ƨȈdzȁƾƴdzơƨǸȈǬdzơ ǁ ǝ ǵ ƩơǂȈǤƬǸdzơ
ȆǴȇƢǸȈǧƲƟƢƬǼdzơǽǀǿǎȈƼǴƫǺǰǸȇƢȀƬnjǫƢǼǷȁƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơƲƟƢƬǼdzƨưƷƢƦdzơǑǂǟƾǠƥ
ǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǑƢǨƼǻơȁǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơDZȂºƦǬdzơǺȈƥƢÅËȈƟƢǐƷƛƨdzơƽƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .1
ƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǝƢǨƫǁơȁǵȋơȁƣȋơDzƦǫǺǷȅƾdzơȂdzơǒǧǂdzơǺȈƥƢÅËȈƟƢǐƷƛƨdzơƽƨƦƳȂǷƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .2
ƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơ
ƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷǑƢǨƼǻơȁƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷǝƢǨƫǁơǺȈƥƨƦdzƢLJƨȈǗƢƦƫǁơƨǫȐǟƾƳȂƫ .3
ƧƾƴƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơ
ǺLjdzơǁƢǤǏ ƧƾƴƥȆƟơƾƬƥȏơƮdzƢưdzơǦǐdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫǺȈƥȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȆǧƢÅËȈƟƢǐƷƛƨdzơƽǩȁǂǧƾƳȂƫ .4
ǺLjdzơǁƢƦǯ DžƽƢLjdzơǦǐdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫƶdzƢǐdz ǺLjdzơǁƢƦǯ DžƽƢLjdzơǦǐdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȁ
ƨƷǂƬǬǸdzơƩƢLJơǁƾdzơȁƭȂƸƦdzơ
ƨȈǴǸǠdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơȄdzƛƱƢƬƸƫȆƬdzơƩȐǰnjǸdzơǺǷÅơƽƾǟƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơǂȈưƫ
ƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơƧƾƷǦȈǨƼƬdzƵǂƬǬǷȅƽƢNjǁƛƲǷƢǻǂƥƨȈǴǟƢǧȃƾǷ .1
ǞǷƢȀǻȂǠƦƬȇȆƬdzơƨƠǗƢƼdzơƨȈƥǂƬdzơƤȈdzƢLJƗȁǹơƾdzơȂdzơƢȀdzǑǂǠƬȇȆƬdzơƨǘǣƢǔdzơƧƢȈƸdzơǦǫơȂǷǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨLJơǁƽ .2
ǶȀƟƢǼƥƗ
ƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȁƨȈLjǨǼdzơƧƾƷȂdzƢƥǁȂǠnjdzơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨLJơǁƽ .3
ƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁƧǂLJȌdzȅƽƢǐƬǫȏơȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơȃȂƬLjǸdzơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨLJơǁƽ .4
ƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơ
ƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁǶǴǠƬdzơƩƢƥȂǠǏǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨLJơǁƽ .5
ƩƢȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơƩơǀȈǸǴƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơȃȂƬLjǷȁȆLJơǁƾdzơǂƻƘƬdzơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƨLJơǁƽ .6
ƩƢȈǏȂƬdzơ
ȆǴȇƢǸƥƨưƷƢƦdzơȄǏȂƫƢȀƴƟƢƬǻȆǧƨȈdzƢƸdzơƨLJơǁƾdzơǾȈdzƛƪǴǏȂƫƢǷƔȂǓȆǧ
ǞȈǸƳƨǧǂǠǷǥƾȀƥƨȈLJǁƾǸdzơȁƨȇǂLJȋơǺȈƬƠȈƦdzơȄǴǟƨȈǴƦǬƬLjǸdzơƨȈǸǴǠdzơƭȂƸƦdzơȁƩƢLJơǁƾdzơDŽȈǯǂƫƧǁȁǂǓ .1
ƨǨǐƥǶȀǼǷƭƢǻȍơȁƨǷƢºǟƨǨǐƥƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzơǀȈǷȐƫȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơƔơǁȁǺǸǰƫȆƬdzơƣƢƦLJȋơȁDzǷơȂǠdzơ
ƨǏƢƻ
ǶǴǟƧǀƫƢLJƗƢȀȈǧǂǓƢƸȇƨȈƟơƾƬƥȏơƨǴƷǂǸdzƢƥǺȈȈƥȐǘdzơǺȇƾNjǂǸdzơȁƩơƾNjǂǸǴdzƨȈƦȇǁƾƫƩơǁȁƽƾǬǟȄǴǟDzǸǠdzơ .2
ƩơǀȈǸǴƬdzơǞǷDzǷƢǠƬdzơƨȈǨȈǯȄǴǟǶȀƦȇǁƾƫȁƨȈǼȀǸdzơǶȀƫƔƢǨǯǞǧǂdzǮdzƿȁƩƢǠǷƢƴdzƢƥȆLjǨǼdzơƤǘdzơȁƨȈƥǂƬdzơȁdžǨǼdzơ
ǞǓȁǶȀǼǰǸȇȄƬƷȆǯȂǴLjdzơƱȐºǠdzơƩƢȈǼǧȄǴǟǶȀƦȇǁƾƬdzǮdzǀǯȁǞǨƫǂǷƨȈǻơȁƾǟȃȂƬLjǷǶȀȇƾdzǺȇǀdzơǀȈǷȐƬdzơȁ
ƢȀƥǹȂǴǸǠȇȆƬdzơDžǁơƾºǸdzơȆǧƢȀǻȁƾƴȇȆƬdzơƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơƩȏƢƸdzƨȈǯȂǴLJƨȈƳȐǟƲǷơǂƥ
ǂȈǐƦƫƢȀǧơƾǿƗǺǸǓǹȂǰȇƮȈƸƥƨȇƽȂǠLjdzơƨȈƥǂǠdzơƨǰǴǸǸdzơƔƢƸǻƗǞȈǸƴƥȅǂLJȋơǾȈƳȂƬǴdzDŽǯơǂǷƔƢnjǻƛƧǁȁǂǓ .3
Å
ǹƘƥǶȀǼǷƢǼǛƭƢǻȎdzƨǏƢƻǶȀdzƢǨǗȋǶȀƬǴǷƢǠǷȆǧǶȀǼǷǹȂLjǬȇǺȇǀdzơǦȇǂǠƫȁƨƸȈƸǐdzơƨȇȂƥǂƬdzơǩǂǘdzƢƥǺȇƾdzơȂdzơ
ȅƽƚȇȁƨȈLjǨǼdzơǶȀdzƢǨǗƗƨƸǏȄǴǟƤǴLjdzƢƥdžǰǠǼȇƣȂǴLJȋơơǀǿǹƘƥǺȀǸȇȂǬƫȁǺȀƬȈƥǂƬdzDzưǷȋơȂǿƣȂǴLJȋơơǀºǿ
ƨǓǂǟǶȀǴǠƴȇƢǸǷƨǨǴƬƼǸdzơƨȈǯȂǴLjdzơȁƨȈLjǨǼdzơƩƢƥơǂǘǓȏƢƥǶȀƬƥƢǏƛȄdzƛȁȆǟƢǸƬƳȏơȁȆLjǨǼdzơǶȀǬǧơȂƫǵƾǟȄdzƛ
ǥơǂƸǻȐdz
ƧǂºǿƢǬdzƢƥ
Ʊǵ
ƨƠnjǼƬdzơȆǧƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƩƢǿƢƴƫȏơȁƨȈǟƢǸƬƳȏơƨƠnjǼƬdzƢƥƢȀƬǫȐǟȁƨȈǻơȁƾǠdzơƨȈǐƼnjdzơǂǐǻƨƸȈǸLJȆǼǤdzơƾƦǟ .16
džǸNjǺȈǟƨǠǷƢƳƣơƽȉơƨȈǴǯƧǁȂnjǼǷǂȈǣǂȈƬLjƳƢǷƨdzƢLJǁƨȈǐƼnjdzơǶȀƫƢǸLJǒǠƥȁƔƢǼƥȋơƨȈǻơȁƾǠƥƢȀǗƢƦƫǁơȁ
ǵ ƧǂǿƢǬdzƢƥ
ƨǬǴƸdzơƣȐǗȃƾdzȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzơǦȈǨƼƫȆǧȅƽƢNjǁƛƲǷƢǻǂƥƨȈǴǟƢǧȃƾǷȆǼǤdzơƾƦǟǺȇƾdzơƵȐǏƽȂƦǟ .17
ǵ ǂǐǸƥǕȂȈLJƗƨǠǷƢƳƨȈƥǂƬdzơƨȈǴǯƧǁȂnjǼǷǂȈǣǂȈƬLjƳƢǷƨdzƢLJǁȆLJƢLJȋơǶȈǴǠƬdzơǺǷƨȈǻƢưdzơ
ǂǐǷǺȈƥƨǻǁƢǬǷƨLJơǁƽƣƢƠƬǯȏƢƥǾƬǫȐǟȁƨǬǿơǂǸdzơƨǴƷǂǷȆǧƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷƤȇǂǣƵƢƬǨdzơƾƦǟƤȇǂǣ .18
ǍǍ ǵ ƧǂǿƢǬdzƢƥƨȇǂǐǸdzơȂǴƴǻȋơƨƦƬǰǷdžǨǼdzơǶǴǠdzǺǷƢưdzơǂǸƫƚǸdzơƭȂƸƥƧƾƸƬǸdzơƨȈƥǂǠdzơƩơǁƢǷȍơȁ
-
ƭȂƸƥƨȇǂǐǷƨǼȈǟȄǴǟƨȇǂƬǷȁƾȇƗƨLJơǁƽDZƢǨǗȋơDZƢǸǿƛȁƨǴǷƢǠǷƔȂLJƾǸƸǷƣƢǿȂdzơƾƦǟDzǷƢǯ .19
ǍǍ ǵ ƧǂǿƢǬdzƢƥdžǸNjǺȈǟƨǠǷƢƳƨdzȂǨǘdzơƩƢLJơǁƽDŽǯǂǷȅǂǐǸdzơDzǨǘǴdzǞƥơǂdzơȅȂǼLjdzơǂǸƫƚǸdzơ
-
ƔƢǼƥȋơƢȀǯǁƾȇƢǸǯƨȈǟƢǸƬƳȏơƨƠnjǼƬdzơȆǧƩƢȀǷȋơƩƢǿƢƴƫơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƩƢǻȂǰǷƵƢƬǨdzơƾƦǟǦLJȂȇƾǸƸǷ .20
ǵ ƧǂºǿƢǬdzƢƥƨȈLjǨǼdzơƩƢLJơǁƾǴdzƨȇǂǐǸdzơƨȈǠǸƴdzơdžǨǼdzơǶǴǠdzdžǷƢƼdzơǂǸƫƚǸdzơƭȂƸƥǶȀƫƢȈǐƼNjǺȈƥȁ
-ǍǍ
ǶǴǟƨǴƴǷǶȀȇƾdzƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷȁƔƢǼƥȋơƢȀǯǁƾȇƢǸǯƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨȇƢǟǂdzơǺȈƥƨǫȐǠdzơƵƢƬǨdzơƾƦǟǦLJȂȇƾǸƸǷ .21
-ǍǍǂnjǟƮdzƢưdzơƽƾǠdzơ ǵ ƧǂǿƢǬdzƢƥƣƢƬǰǴdzƨǷƢǠdzơƨȇǂǐǸdzơƨƠȈȀdzơdžǨǼdzơ
ȆǻơȁƾǠdzơǭȂǴLjdzƢƥƢȀƬǫȐǟȁƨȇƾdzơȂdzơƨǴǷƢǠǸdzơȆǧƨȇȂLjdzơǂȈǣȁƨȇȂLjdzơƤȈdzƢLJȋơǶȈǴƸdzơƾƦǟƽȂǸƸǷȄLjǼǷ .22
ƢǘǼǗƨºǠǷƢƳƨºȈƥǂƬdzơƨºȈǴǯƨǴƴǷƨºȇǁƾǼǰLJȍƢƥȆLJƢLJȋơǶºȈǴǠƬdzơǺǷȄdzȁȋơƨǬǴƸdzơǀºȈǷȐƫǺǷƨǼȈǟȃƾdz
ǵ ǂºǐǷ
ƧǂƻƘƬǸdzơȁȄǘLJȂdzơƨdzȂǨǘdzơȆƬǴƷǂǷȆǧDZƢǨǗȌdzƩơǀdzơǵȂȀǨǷDžƢȈǬǷDzȈdzƽǶȈǴƷȅƢnjƥƪǠǴǗǁȂǐǼǷ .23
-ǍǍ ǵ ƪȇȂǰdzơƨǠǷƢƳƣơƽȉơƨȈǴǰƥdžǨǼdzơǶǴǟǶLjǫƨǴƠLJȋơȁƩƢǸȈǴǠƬdzơƨLJơǂǯ
ǵ ƧǂǿƢǬdzƢƥǥǁƢǠǸdzơǁơƽȆǻƢLjǻȍơǭȂǴLjdzơǁƢǐƬǻơdžǻȂȇ .24
ƨȈƦǼƳȋơǞºƳơǂºǸdzơ
25. Ann, N. & Stephen, j : Peer victimization and its relationship to self-concept and
depression among school girls. Personality and individual difference, (1994). V16,NI,
PP:183-186.
26. Arther, T.J., Judith, S.B. and David, W.B.: The psychology of adolsscent. 3rd
edition, Macmillan puplishing Co. Inc. New York (1978).
27. Burdet, K, & Jenson, L.C: The self-concept and aggressive behavior among
elementary school children from two grade levels psychology in the schools,(1983) Vol
20, N3, PP:370-379.
28. Carolyn, Z.W.: Problem Behavior in young children, Child Development,
Baltimore, MD, (1987). PP:23-26.
29. Charlotte, J. P. et al,: Children’s perceptions of self and relationship with other
as a function of sociometric status. Child Development, (1990). V61, N5, PP : 1335 –
1349.
30. Crick, N. R. &Grotpeter, J.K.: Relation aggression, gender And social
psychological adjustment, Child Development, (1995). 66, PP : 710 – 722.
31. Gerald, R. P. : Performance models for antisocial boys, American
Psychopathology, (1986). V41, N4, PP : 432 – 444.
32. Gri, R. D. & Dana, N. : Family interactions and Child Psychopathology Child
Development, New Orleans, (1993). PP : 25-28.
33. Hiram, E. F. et al: Parental aggression related to behavior problems in three
years old sons of alcoholics. The world congress meeting of the world association on
infant psychiatry and Allied disciplines (4th, Lugono, Switzerland ), (1989). PP: 497 –
499.
34. John, E. L.: Self and peer perceptions and attributional biases of aggressive and
nonaggressive boys in Dyadic interaction. Annual convention, Annual convention,
American psychological Association, 9th , Washington, (1986). PP: 22 – 26.
35. Karlen, L. R.: Attachment relationship among children with aggressive behavior
problems : The role of the disorganized early attachment patterns. Journal of
Consulting and Clinical Psychology, (1996). V64, NI, PP: 64-73.
36. Kevin, B. & Larry, C. J.: The Self concept, and aggressive behavior among
elementary school children from two socioeconomic area and two grade levels.
Psychology in the school, (1993). V20, PP: 370 – 375.
37. Kinard, E. M.: Emotional development in physically abused children : A study of
self-concept aggression. DIS – Abs. Int. (1978). V39, PP: 2964 – B.
38. Philip, D. & Thomas, J. B.: Self concept, social skill, and teacher rating of
behavior as predictors of depression in learning disabled children, the Southwestern
Psychology Association, 33 rd, New Orleans, LA, (1992). PP: 16 –18.
39. Rina, D. & Thomas, J. B: Relation of preschooler social acceptance to peer
rating and peer rating and self-perceptions. Early Education and Development, (1992).
V3, N3, PP: 221 – 231.
40. Wnetzel, K. R. & Asher, S. R.: Academic lives of neglected rejected popular and
controversial children, Child Development, (1995). V66, N3, PP: 754 – 763.
41. Xinyin, C. et al : Depressed mood in Chinese children : Relations with school
performance and family environment. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,
(1995). V63, N6, PP:938 – 947.