Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Clinical Nutrition: Micha Ł Ławinski, Krystyna Majewska, Łukasz Gradowski, Iwona Fo Łtyn, Pierre Singer
Clinical Nutrition: Micha Ł Ławinski, Krystyna Majewska, Łukasz Gradowski, Iwona Fo Łtyn, Pierre Singer
Clinical Nutrition
journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/clnu
Original article
a r t i c l e i n f o s u m m a r y
Article history: Background & aims: Home parenteral nutrition (HPN) enables patients who cannot eat normally to
Received 10 February 2014 survive and function. Catheter-related bloodstream infections (CRBSIs) are the most dangerous
Accepted 22 September 2014 complication, which may be fatal if left untreated or if treatment is delayed. For over 20 years CRBSIs
were managed by catheter removal and implantation of a new one after completion of antibiotic
Keywords: treatment. However, frequent catheter replacements put the patient at risk of large vein thrombosis,
HPN
which may render parenteral nutrition impossible. The management of CRBSIs evolved into antibiotic
CRBSI
treatment without catheter removal. The effectiveness of this approach was, however, limited by the low
Antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy
penetration of the antibiotics into the biofilm. Filling catheters with concentrated ethanol destroys the
biofilm and does not result in the emergence of drug resistance. The aim of our study was to assess the
remote outcomes of CRBSI treatment using two approaches: antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy and catheter
replacement. Methods: We retrospectively analysed the treatment outcomes of CRBSI diagnosed and
managed in HPN patients. During the analysed period, a total of 428 patients between 13 and 96 years of
age were on HPN and a total of 181 of them suffered a total of 352 CRBSI episodes managed with one of
the two approaches.
Results: We showed no significant differences between the two approaches in terms of survival likeli-
hood or duration of catheter use after an episode of CRBSI caused by various bacterial species.
Conclusion: The use of antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy in the management of CRBSI is equally effective as
catheter replacement.
© 2014 Elsevier Ltd and European Society for Clinical Nutrition and Metabolism. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.clnu.2014.09.013
0261-5614/© 2014 Elsevier Ltd and European Society for Clinical Nutrition and Metabolism. All rights reserved.
ski et al. / Clinical Nutrition 34 (2015) 918e922
M. Ławin 919
implantation procedure and thrombotic complications which lead after the diagnosis of CRBSI was established. After confirming that
to the loss of vena cava access [6]. The management of CRBSIs is of colonisation of the inner surface of the catheter was the source of
dual nature and involves systemic management, including systemic bacteraemia, the justifiability of using antibiotic and ethanol lock
antibiotics, and catheter management [12]. The traditional man- with or without systemic antibiotic therapy to sterilize the catheter
agement of CRBSIs involves administration of antibiotics, removal was considered. This antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy was compared
of the catheter responsible for the infection, and implantation of a to the group of patients in whom the catheter was removed if
new catheter after the infection has been cured. However, in pa- contraindications for antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy was
tients with recurrent catheter-related infections, each subsequent identified.
catheterization of a large vein is increasingly difficult and risky, and The following were considered to be the contraindications to
may lead to the loss of venous access. Therefore, in patients antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy:
requiring parenteral nutrition, maintenance of venous access is as
important as controlling and curing the infection. Because of that, a Groshong catheter (due to its design),
attempts have been made to treat CRBSIs without catheter removal. a previously repaired catheter,
This method has been used in many modifications but it turned out a ruptured catheter hub,
that its effectiveness is limited due to the low penetration of most colonisation with fungi or bacterial strains of: Staphylococcus
antibiotics into the biofilm formed by the microorganisms in the aureus, Staphylococcus haemolyticus, Corynebacterium spp.,
catheter [7]. While the patients improved and the symptoms of Mycobacterium spp., Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Micrococcus spp.,
infection resolved during hospitalisation, the infection recurred Bacillus spp.,
after the patients were discharged home [8,9]. In their search for colonisation with strains resistant to most antibiotics or strains
agents penetrating into the biofilm, Ball et al. suggested using whose antibiotic susceptibility could not be established.
concentrated ethanol, previously used to restore catheter patency
[10,11]. The Infectious Disease Society of America does not un-
equivocally recommend ethanol lock therapy as a method for 2.3. Establishment of the antibiotic-ethanol lock
endoluminal eradication of microorganisms in cases of catheter
colonisation [5]. It is, however, widely believed that the use of The residual content and blood were aspirated from the cath-
ethanol to destroy the biofilm, followed by the use of antibiotic lock eter, the catheter hub and lumen were flushed to remove the re-
therapy to completely cure catheter contamination, may be bene- sidual blood using a 0.9% saline solution and the catheter was filled
ficial. The aim of our study was to assess the remote outcomes of with a 95% ethanol solution. The solution was left in the catheter for
CRBSI treatment in patients on long-term home parenteral nutri- 24 h. The next day blood was aspirated, the catheter lumen and hub
tion (HPN) using two approaches: antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy were flushed and the catheter was filled with ethanol again. Four
and the traditional approach involving replacement of the days later, the ethanol solution was replaced with an antibiotic
contaminated catheter with a new one. solution, which was administered according to the same procedure
for the next four days. The antibiotic was selected according to
2. Material and methods culture results. Twenty-four hours after the last dose of the anti-
biotic, the patient was started on his/her nutrient mixture and the
2.1. Material next day blood from the central catheter was drawn for follow-up
culture. If the patient had remained asymptomatic for the past
Between 1 January 2005 and 31 December 2010, HPN was 48 h and the culture was negative, he/she was discharged home.
provided to 428 patients from our hospital outpatient clinic: 240 The following antibiotic solutions at the following concentrations
females (56%) aged 16e92 years (mean age: 56.5 ± 16 years) and were used to fill the catheters: amikacin 100 mg/ml, teicoplanin:
188 males (44%) aged 13e96 years (mean age: 54 ± 17 years). In- 40 mg/ml, vancomycin: 50 mg/ml. If the patient developed fever
dications for parenteral nutrition in this patient group included: and/or chills or if his/her condition deteriorated, the treatment was
short bowel syndrome, multilevel bowel obstruction, postoperative discontinued, the catheter was removed and a new catheter was
gastrointestinal fistulas, malabsorption syndrome, gastrointestinal implanted after completion of antibiotic treatment.
motility abnormalities, cachexia, radiation enteritis. The patients
were fed through 5 kind of permanent venous accesses: tunnelized
single lumen catheters the name of Broviac (n ¼ 305), Groshong 2.4. Statistical analysis
(n ¼ 67), Broviac-Lifecath Expert 19, Cook Redo TPN (n ¼ 29), ports
(n ¼ 8). The antibiotic lock therapy group was compared to the catheter
Data was obtained from the hospital database and retrospective removed group. Data were expressed as median with a 25the75th
study was approved 20.09.2011 by the ethics committee of the percentile interquartile range. The median time of new catheter use
Medical University of Warsaw. after catheter replacement and after antibiotic-ethanol lock ther-
apy was compared using the U ManneWhitney test. Time to
2.2. Management of suspected catheter-related infection recurrence of infection and survival for each of the two analysed
treatments were compared with the KaplaneMeier method and
In each case of suspected catheter-related infection, the patient the significance of the results was assessed with the CoxeMantel
was hospitalized for evaluation and treatment. Throughout that test. The rates of recurrent infections with the same strains were
period, the catheter was excluded from use and the patient was assessed with the chi-square test and, for low number of cases, with
being fed and hydrated via peripheral veins. In patients in grave the Yates continuity correction. The mean follow-up time to
condition and patients with catheter exit-site or tunnel infection, recurrence was assessed with the U ManneWhitney test. In order
the catheter was removed. Cultures for microbial evaluation were to identify the effect of factors associated with infection recurrence,
obtained from skin smears around the entry of the catheter, multivariate logistic regression analysis of factors identified as
hemocultures taken from CV catheter, peripheral vein. Final deci- potentially relevant in univariate analysis was performed. The IBM
sion on the course of management was made after obtaining the SPSS Statistic software package (version 21.0) was used for statis-
culture results for blood collected from the central catheter and tical analysis.
920 ski et al. / Clinical Nutrition 34 (2015) 918e922
M. Ławin
3. Results Table 2
The treatment of catheter-related infections (median and IQR e Inter Quartile
Range).
The total duration of parenteral nutrition in 428 patients on HPN
between 1 January 2005 and 31 December 2010 was 404,808 days. Duration of using the catheter U Manne p Value
During the follow-up period, 34 (7.9%) patients discontinued the after treatment Whitney
value
treatment due to regained nutritional autonomy, 214 (50.0%) Antibiotic-ethanol Catheter
continued treatment, 178 (41.6%) died and 2 (0.5%) transferred to lock removal
Table 1
Demographic data of antibiotic-ethanol and catheter removal groups (n ¼ 181).
Treatment
Gender Male 23 75
Female 25 58
Age ± SD 54.8 ± 15 55.1 ± 18
Catheter care Independent 28 (58.3%) 66 (49.7%)
Caregiver 20 (41.7%) 67 (50.3%)
Fig. 1. Likelihood of using the catheter without recurrence of infection with the same
Place of residence Urban 30 (62.5%) 98 (73.7%)
microbial species according to the treatment approach (p ¼ 0.00169 [NS] in
Rural 18 (37.5%) 35 (26.3%)
CoxeMantel test).
ski et al. / Clinical Nutrition 34 (2015) 918e922
M. Ławin 921
Fig. 2. Effect of various factors on the development of recurrent CRBSI with the same Fig. 4. Patient survival likelihood according to the treatment approach employed
microbial species after treatment with catheter removal. during the first episode of CRBSI (p ¼ 0.48663[NS] in CoxeMantel test).
4. Discussion
[15,16]. More recent studies, however, showed a greater efficacy of
When evaluating the effectiveness of treatment of catheter- antibiotic lock therapy compared to antibiotic infusion through the
related infections, one should not only take into account the im- catheter [17,18] and a longer survival of the dialysis catheter after
mediate outcomes (control of the acute infection and eradication of lock therapy versus catheter replacement (154 and 71 days,
the source of infection) but also patient survival after treatment, respectively) [19].
duration of fault-free use of the catheter and the rate of infection A number of factors contributing to infection recurrence after
recurrences. antibiotic lock therapy have been identified. It is believed that the
If the goal of the treatment is to preserve a permanent catheter, principal factor that interferes with successful eradication of mi-
then antibiotic lock therapy or ethanol lock therapy becomes the croorganisms colonising the catheter and contributing to re-
only option. The body of experience gained so far and the resulting currences of infections with these microorganisms is the biofilm
current recommendations confirm the justifiability of antibiotic and its resistance to antibiotics [6,7]. Studies were therefore con-
lock therapy for the treatment of catheter-related infections ducted to investigate the use of substances along with the antibiotic
without the need to remove the catheter in patients requiring long- that would destroy the biofilm or facilitate penetration of antibi-
term venous access [5,13,14]. Rannem et al. successfully managed otics into the biofilm: N-acetylcysteine, macrolide antibiotics
some of the infections solely with antibiotics administered through (especially erythromycin) and ethanol [20e22]. The properties of
the catheter and Buchman et al., in patients treated between 1986 ethanol, such as good penetration into the biofilm, no risk of se-
and 1989, managed to preserve 87% catheters using this method lection of resistant strains, low cost, low risk of recurrences and low
risk of emergence of resistance, make it an ideal agent to eradicate
microorganisms from catheters [23]. Experimental studies show,
however, that the older the biofilm is and the shorter the exposure
time, the less effective ethanol is [24].
These two methods were combined into one, antibiotic-ethanol
lock therapy, on the premise that after four days of exposure
ethanol would destroy the biofilm, which would facilitate pene-
tration of the antibiotic and eradication of the remaining micro-
organisms from the inner surface of the catheter. The low number
of recurrences and the long follow-up period confirm that this
premise was correct. The comparison of the remote outcomes in
the group of patients managed with catheter replacement with the
outcomes in the group of patients managed with antibiotic lock
therapy showed that both methods are generally equally effective.
Survival of patients after antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy
compared to survival of patients managed with catheter replace-
ment, after excluding cancer patients from the analysis, were
similar. The median duration HPN from the first episode of CRBSI
was 1193 days (IQR: 631e1524) in patients managed with antibiotic
and ethanol lock therapy and 1026 days (IQR: 566e1580) in pa-
tients managed with catheter replacement.
Our study has several limitations. The first is that taurolidine use
for prevention was not a possible alternative since the study was
Fig. 3. Effect of various factors on the development of recurrent CRBSI with the same started in 2005, when taurolidine lock was not a true alternative for
microbial species after antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy. prevention of CRBIs. Second, the groups were not randomly chosen
922 ski et al. / Clinical Nutrition 34 (2015) 918e922
M. Ławin
but according to a protocol making the value of our study weaker. catheter-related infection: 2009 update by the Infectious Diseases Society of
America. Clin Infect Dis 2009 Jul 1;49(1):1e45. No abstract available. Erratum
However, the large number of patients followed for a long time is
in: Clin Infect Dis. 2010 Feb 1;50(3):457. Clin Infect Dis. 2010 Apr 1;50(7):
giving a strong signal of the equal value of the 2 strategies. 1079.
[6] Del Pozo JL. Role of antibiotic lock therapy for the treatment of catheter-
5. Conclusions related bloodstream infections. Int J Artif Organs 2009 Sep;32(9):678e88.
[7] Donlan RM. Biofilms on central venous catheters: is eradication possible? Curr
Top Microbiol Immunol 2008;322:133e61.
We conclude that the use of antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy in [8] Guedon C, Nouvellon M, Lalaude O, Lerebours E. Efficacy of antibiotic-lock
the management of CRBSI is equally effective as catheter replace- technique with teicoplanin in staphylococcus epidermidis catheter-related
sepsis during long-term parenteral nutrition. J Parenter Enteral Nutr 2002
ment, after exclusion of absolute indications of catheter removal. MareApr;26(2):109e13.
No complications associated with catheter filling with ethanol were [9] Opilla MT, Kirby DF, Edmond MB. Use of ethanol lock therapy to reduce the
observed. The duration of catheter use and survival after treatment incidence of catheter-related bloodstream infections in home parenteral
nutrition patients. J Parenter Enteral Nutr 2007 JuleAug;31(4):302e5.
of a CRBSI episode and patient survival did not differ relative to the [10] Ball PA, Brokenshire E, Parry B, Merrie A, Gillanders L, McIlroy K, et al. Ethanol
approach employed. Recurrences of CRBSIs with the same micro- locking as a possible treatment for microbial contamination of long-term
bial species over a period of up to 120 days after the completion of central venous catheters. Nutrition 2003 Jun;19(6):570.
[11] Johnston DA, Walker K, Richards J, Pennington CR. Ethanol flush for the
treatment were observed in 7% of patients managed with prevention of catheter occlusion. Clin Nutr 1992 Apr;11(2):97e100.
antibiotic-ethanol lock therapy and 2.2% of patients managed with [12] Pagani JL, Eggimann P. Management of catheter-related infection. Expert Rev
catheter replacement. Development of recurrences of CRBSIs was Anti Infect Ther 2008 Feb;6(1):31e7.
[13] Gillanders L, Angstmann K, Ball P, O'Callaghan M, Thomson A, Wong T,
associated with the absence of systemic antibiotic treatment.
Thomas M. A prospective study of catheter-related complications in HPN
patients. Clin Nutr 2012 Feb;31(1):30e4.
Statement of authorship [14] Pittiruti M, Hamilton H, Biffi R, MacFie J, Pertkiewicz M. ESPEN.: ESPEN
guidelines on parenteral nutrition: central venous catheters (access, care,
diagnosis and therapy of complications). Clin Nutr 2009 Aug;28(4):365e77.
MŁ is responsible for planned the article and manuscript [15] Buchman AL, Moukarzel A, Goodson B, Herzog F, Pollack P, Reyen L, et al.
preparation. ŁG performed statistical analysis KM, IF collections Catheter-related infections associated with home parenteral nutrition and
and analysed data, PS reviewed the data and revised the manu- predictive factors for the need for catheter removal in their treatment.
J Parenter Enteral Nutr 1994 JuleAug;18(4):297e302.
script. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. [16] Rannem T, Ladefoged K, Tvede M, Lorentzen JE, Jarnum S. Catheter-related
septicaemia in patients receiving home parenteral nutrition. Scand J Gastro-
Conflict of interest statement enterol 1986 May;21(4):455e60.
[17] Fortún J, Grill F, Martín-Da vila P, Bla
zquez J, Tato M, Sa
nchez-Corral J, et al.
Treatment of long-term intravascular catheter-related bacteraemia with
Each author declared no conflict of financial or personal in- antibiotic-lock therapy. J Antimicrob Chemother 2006 Oct;58(4):816e21.
terests in this study. [18] Rijnders BJ, Van Wijngaerden E, Vandecasteele SJ, Stas M, Peetermans WE.
Treatment of long-term intravascular catheter-related bacteraemia with
antibiotic lock: randomized, placebo-controlled trial. J Antimicrob Chemother
References 2005 Jan;55(1):90e4.
[19] Poole CV, Carlton D, Bimbo L, Allon M. Treatment of catheter-related bacter-
_
[1] Pertkiewicz M, Korta T, Ksia˛ zyk J, Łyszkowska M, Matczuk M, Spodaryk M, aemia with an antibiotic lock protocol: effect of bacterial pathogen. Nephrol
_
et al. Standardy Zywienia Pozajelitowego i Dojelitowego PZWL 2005;1:1e76. Dial Transplant 2004 May;19(5):1237e44.
[2] Pertkiewicz M, Majewska K, Korta T. Doste˛ p zylny _ _
do zywienia pozajelito- [20] Aslam S. Effect of antibacterials on biofilms. Am J Infect Control 2008
wego. In: Zasady, zapobieganie, rozpoznawanie i leczenie powikłan . Wars- Dec;36(10):S175.e9e175.e11.
zawa; 1997. p. 5e61. [21] Laird J, Soutar R, Butcher I. Complications of the ethanol-lock technique in the
[3] Arnow PM, Quimosing EM, Beach M. Consequences of intravascular catheter treatment of central venous catheter sepsis. J Infect 2005 Nov;51(4):338.
sepsis. Clin Infect Dis 1993 Jun;16(6):778e84. [22] Wu CY, Lee PI. Antibiotic-lock therapy and erythromycin for treatment of
[4] Sitges-Serra A, Puig P, Lin ~ ares J, Perez JL, Farrero
N, Jaurrieta E, et al. Hub catheter-related Candida parapsilosis and Staphylococcus aureus infections.
colonization as the initial step in an outbreak of catheter-related sepsis due to J Antimicrob Chemother 2007 Sep;60(3):706e7.
coagulase negative staphylococci during parenteral nutrition. J Parenter [23] Maiefski M, Rupp ME, Hermsen ED. Ethanol lock technique: review of the
Enteral Nutr 1984, NoveDec;8(6):668e72. literature. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2009 Nov;30(11):1096e108.
[5] Mermel LA, Allon M, Bouza E, Craven DE, Flynn P, O'Grady NP, et al. Clinical [24] Chambers ST, Peddie B, Pithie A. Ethanol disinfection of plastic-adherent
practice guidelines for the diagnosis and management of intravascular micro-organisms. J Hosp Infect 2006 Jun;63(2):193e6.