Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ANDRES JAQUE - Transmedia Urbanism - Berlusconi and The Birth of Targeted Differnce (2017)
ANDRES JAQUE - Transmedia Urbanism - Berlusconi and The Birth of Targeted Differnce (2017)
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
The MIT Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Perspecta
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
_l
<
=> tZ
LU^ => t
O-o o
<9i=
-5Û-S
ç/)cc>
ïoo
CCL_Z
9 LU Z
|o-Li-
Li.
O
LU
o
z
LU
g LU CC
en X lu
zl~ul t
<Qt
CÛZÛ
<Q
=> - LU
^2I-
^ Solu
goo
^ c/) cc
^ Z) <
CO _l I-
Z ÜC LL
< LO O
CC CÛ
HH OC
CD
243
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
Accounts of Silvio Berlusconi's casting television programs from its Milan could afford them. They were found mainly
power seldom include two of its key headquarters at a central position in the in bars, churches, and the living rooms of
sources: namely, architecture and urban- city: Corso Sempione. The building includ- wealthy families. These places, where tele-
ism. Whereas his involvement in media is ed Studio TV3, which was, at the time, the vision was communally watched, turned
seen as a momentous constituent of his largest television studio in Europe.1 The into transfamilial spaces of interclass en-
political trajectory, what is often forgotten headquarters were redesigned by no less actments. Control over the television signal
is that his particular way of reinventing the than the architect Giò Ponti. Architecture was precious, for it brought the power to
relationship between politics and media was already an essential factor. decide what content would shape collec-
was an architectural invention, developed In postwar Italy, television was not tive existence.2
and tested through the interiors, buildings, watched alone. In 1954, the cost of a TV RAI worked hand in hand with the
landscapes, and urbanism to which he and set was 250,000 lire- three times the an- Istituto per la Ricostruzione Industriale, a
his team devoted a large part of their time nual salary of a secretary. Very few people public holding company that owned many
and resources, from the late 1960s to the
early 1990s.
In 1968, Silvio Berlusconi, then
chair and owner of urban development
company Edilnord Centri Residenzia-
li, started to promote "Milano 2," a
712,000-square-meter residential city ten
minutes from the center of Milan. Present-
ed as an alluring and inoffensive mix of
rational architecture and vernacular em-
bellishment, Milano 2 embodied a radical
urbanism. Conceived as an alternative to
the converging and homogenizing cul-
ture promoted by state-centered postwar
European governments, this new urban
model would instead segregate society
into differentiated clusters of specialized
consumption targets. Life in Milano 2 was
structured by a cable television service
that would grow to become the corpora-
tion now known as Mediaset. Milano 2's
capacity to integrate the economic, social,
and political evolution of its inhabitants
was fueled by a series of design strategies
meant to coordinate TV programming,
interiors, access to commodities and
services, architecture, and landscaping
into what I will call "transmedia urbanism."
This coordination was intended to render
Berlusconi's company as the compulsory
node in a new context in which purveyors,
consumers, and the links that brought
them together were reinvented.
TV NATIONS
The European national TV networks,
such as the BBC (United Kingdom), RTF
(France), and RAI (Italy), played a fun- ¿
>CÖ
"03
Q.
ing Union (EBU). It was precisely these
"E
CM
1
down with the intention of maximizing their o
power of self-production.
co
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
13.00 Naturalmanete in cucina.
Mon to
13 5
14.30 CentroVetríne
Canale HBH
Mon to
«»
• ¡¡¡ģM
20.30 l cesaroni IH^H
every tuesday
rete4
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
■ / cesa roni 20.30
H every tuesday
H rete4
Canale 5
ICentroVetrine Mon Canale to Fri 5 22.40
I9
Canale5
Milano 2 flB
Cuatrìlocale house CfcsSj
Mela Verde 10.00
Ragazzi and Partners. Architects CESI
Sun and Sat
Canale 5
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
capacity of the nation's industrial muscle
should aid in the development of advanced
solutions to provide the workers it at-
tracted with places to live.8 At L'Espresso
magazine, architect Bruno Zevi added his
voice to the discussion, advocating for
the relocation of workers from cities to
c
underdeveloped rural areas, where land
was cheaper. All these ideas would rapidly
«<0
E
N
O
3 develop into housing projects- but not for
0) the workers.
■O
"5>
3
g>
MILANO 2
is
O)
"5
x:
Q_ due to the noise pollution of air traffic from
c
tt>
the nearby Linate International Airport.
E
-e
Berlusconi's political influence facilitated
(0
Q.
co
a reduction of air traffic and the accep-
CM
O
tance by left-wing municipal authorities of
c
JS
Milano 2's masterplan. This development
Ü was designed not only to supply accom-
o
modation for ten thousand inhabitants, but
£
o
'c also as a complete urbanism equipped to
provide education, fitness, entertainment,
_0)
3=
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
logically advanced systems and societies
should be specifically applied in new forms
of urbanism and architecture.
TJ
might be like to be Number Ones them- "5
3
selves. This use of printed media set into O)
2
motion the evolution of the potential sub- >»
-Q
jectivity of Number Ones by the way they </>
.C
were confronted with fictionalized, stylized Q.
2
versions of themselves. These media out- O)
o
o
lets created a mirror-based dynamic meant JZ
Q_
0
into a progression from the actual to the C
1
was produced by the fictional architecture o
V)
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
Milano 2 show apartment, 1976.
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
co
r-
CD
CD
0)
c
O
cū
.o
E
o
Z
cu
x:
CD
C
■Ë
o
Q.
"O
o
_c
LU
>>
Xł
"O
(U
O
13
"O
O
Q.
(D
C
CU
o
CD
"05
C
O
"o
LL
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
ESCAPING URBAN PROMISCUITY
In the sales brochures, Berlusconi
himself encouraged buyers to "escape
from metropolitan chaos- from traffic,
crime, immigrants, and workers. From the
city itself."12 Milano 2's marketing suggest-
ed self-banishment from urban promiscu-
ity. Milano 2 provided an additional means
to render oneself as a nonworker and as a
nonimmigrant. Being a Number One was
not only a progression to the aspirational,
but a departure from urban promiscuity into
a realm of class sorting and clarification.
The strategy of offering an escape
was paralleled by offering a suburban
marketplace within Milano 2, and Edilnord
managed to reap a share of the money
spent on every good or service that Milano
2's residents purchased on a daily basis.
A central part of Edilnord's strategy was to
retain ownership of the on-site commercial
spaces.13
If gray concrete and modern archi-
tecture had once embodied the aspirations
of Milanese society, now red vernacular
seemed to cater to the sensitivities of the
emerging Number Ones, who were young
enough to enjoy the then-trendy aesthet-
ic context brought about by folk music,
picturing themselves in a globalizing rural
romanticism.14 Along with the red ver-
nacular came mansard roofs. Milano 2's
underground cables ensured TV antennas
did not ruin the picturesque atmosphere.15
The center of Milano 2 has never
been occupied by the symbolic presence
of religious or administrative power but,
instead, by the Lago dei Cigni, the Lake of
the Swans. The core of Milano 2's infra-
c
"(O
structure, which could be perceived as a
E
N pleasant architecture celebrating pictur-
3
O esque banality, also contained a sports
0)
-o
and business center, schools, retail, a four-
"čū
3
O)
star hotel, and a park intended- accord-
2 ing to the apartment sales brochures- to
x?
w
allow the children of Number Ones to play
£
Q. Cowboys and Indians and have organized
2
O) treasure hunts.16
O
o
-C Together, these elements provid-
Q.
C'j
ed potential buyers of apartments with
0
c evidence of the way that Milano 2 would
produce Number Ones and their children
JO
1
0 as competitive, healthy, earnest, aggres-
w
sive, treasure-seeking, and athletic beings,
1
> prepared to occupy a position in a socially
stratified world. In the way this infrastruc-
ture in Milano 2 is used even today, it can
still be considered part of Edilnord's proj-
traveled from the fictional settings to explained that neither he nor Edilnord had ect to shape bodies and societies through
magazines and newspapers and even- the funds to complete the development, architecture and urbanism. An important
tually to real life. The isolated apartment but that funds would be mobilized by a factor in achieving this goal is that part of
towers of Milano 2, where the Number pyramidal financing scheme: those who Milano 2's architecture remains virtually
Ones would be spatially confined, did not bought early would get an apartment that invisible: namely, the underground studios
grow out of a city or even the countryside, would double its value as others joined. of Mediaset, where the core of Berlus-
but rather from media. Milan's new social From a financial point of view, Milano 2 coni's political coordination is concealed,
type, the Number Ones, were segregated was sold as the device that would help an architecture that needs to be hidden to
spatially, aesthetically, and economically. adventurous early buyers become success- maximize its political efficacy.
Berlusconi, who involved himself person- ful investors.
ally in selling the apartments, insistently
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
ai
c
a)
E
tr
<0
Q.
(0
OJ
0
c
w
1
c
a>
(U
a>
_Q
_c
O)
c
Q.
(0
o
O)
"O
c
_cd
c
a>
a>
O)
a>
_c
o
£
a;
>
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
00
O)
CD
O)
c'j~
0
c
JO
1
c
</)
o
"O
D
to
o
c
JO
ü
JU
di
I-
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
In 1974, Giacomo Properzj and Alceo urban-market promiscuity. Fininvest's pia ?- left RAI to become Mediaset's star
Moretti started to broadcast amateur team lacked experience in logistics, and presenter. As part of his contract, Bon-
programming by tapping into this under- the competence of stronger retail groups giorno would live in Milano 2, so he could
ground, wired network. Tele Milano had made this initiative fail. Second, in 1980 become part of the community of Number
just been born. Unlicensed movies and Fininvest created the media agency Pub- Ones. In contrast to gated communities,
amateur, self-produced happenings were litalia. Within ten years, Publitalia would Milano 2 welcomed visitors, and it became
broadcast from the Jolly Hotel located in completely transform urban mediation a popular place to go to see celebrities.
Milano 2. The TV station was cheap but between production and consumption.21 The superstars would dwell in penthouses
successful. It recruited residents to its Formed to sell TV advertising space for in the Garden Towers, but they could be
official board, who would help in choosing Mediaset, Publitalia developed a different seen when using the facilities gathered
the content. A program showing images of way to recruit advertisers, based on four around the lake. The bellini, sexy young fe-
women undressing, as male residents of principles.22 male models playing secondary roles in TV
Milano 2 called into the station to partici- First, television would no longer shows, would occupy apartments on the
pate in a quiz game, would rapidly achieve be a space for top-down pedagogy, but, first floor, where their domestic life could
an unexpected success. Not only did it instead, a device to bring production and be seen from the gardens.
attract viewers, but also it mobilized a par- consumption together. Second, TV content
ticular sector of Milano 2 society, the adult would be designed according to advertis- TRANSMEDIA APARTMENTS:
males, and placed them into a differenti- ers' goals. Third, instead of programming MIRRORED BODIES
ated time gap, experienced by its sectored to serve generic audiences, content would Mediaset provided a mirrored broad-
audience as an exclusive late-night TV be designed to attract specific publics- if casted home, an implemented version of
salon. If RAI homogenized society, gather- toys needed to be sold, there would be TV the model apartments publicized by Vogue
ing the public together into a media space shows for children; if middle-aged males magazine that first compelled the Num-
inhabited by generic shows, Tele Milano were targeted, there would be late-night ber Ones to buy apartments in Milano 2:
started to break Milano 2's society into shows for them to inhabit. Whereas RAI a home that has kitchens, mothers, living
specialized clusters according to the TV had promoted urban convergence and rooms, sofas, hosts, bedrooms, showers,
content promoted. Whereas RAI coordi- the creation of a unified public, Publitalia and older brothers. In order to increase the
nated bedtime to ensure national industrial focused on differentiation and distribution; legally regulated maximum percentage of
production, Tele Milano kept adult males progressively scaling up what was previ- promotional space, advertisements leapt
awake to glean a share of revenue from ously developed as the 2000-apartment from commercials into TV shows, as pro-
their phone consumption. Consequently, transmedia urbanism of Milano 2 and motional segments devoted to sponsors
these men became a group defined by their Tele Milano. Finally, advertisers would not started to be included in Mediaset pro-
use of time, their media, and their gender be charged for the amount of time their grams. Apartments, celebrities, mirrored
practices. commercials were broadcast, but for the homes, and advertisers constituted a daily
In 1975, Berlusconi's Fininvest be- increase in their sales. Fininvest would life to inhabit, one that was not contained
came the owner of Tele Milano, seduced get fifteen percent of the increase in sales in any city, but in an urban enactment
by its unexpected success.17 Edilnord's for companies advertised on Mediaset's resulting from the large corporations' cho-
project to segregate Milan's sectors of channels. Talking of Publitalia's activity, reography of techno-social interaction.
mass consumption and solidify control of Berlusconi stated: "I do not sell spaces; I In the late 1970s, in the underground
the interactions and purchases of residents sell sales."23 If nation-driven TV-urbanism basement of an ordinary bar in Milano 2,
extended to Tele Milano, which would in the postwar era constructed space and the popular DJ Claudio Cecchetto hosted
quickly consider its mission as increas- organized society in social classes, Milano Chewing Gum , a musical TV show. Week
ing Milano-2-based commerce.18 With a 2 instead constructed sales and structured after week, Cecchetto brought dancers
1976 ruling by the constitutional court of society in consumption targets. By defining to populate his basement audience from
Italy authorizing the aerial transmission and sorting targeted groups, then utilizing Milan's disco temple, Divina, where he was
of private local TV channels, Tele Milano differentiated channels and timetables resident DJ. Valerio Lazarov, the "King of
became Tele Milano 58, and then Canale and depicting and instigating exemplary the Zoom Shot," would edit and broadcast
5, and started to be broadcast over the air subjectivities, consumptions, and practices the show in such a way so it would not only
beyond Milano 2. 19 Fininvest purchased for each individual sector, television would bring the best of Milan's nightlife into Mi-
local TV channels across the country and, produce urban difference. lano 2's living rooms, but would also bring
taking advantage of a legal loophole in Ita- Publitalia's project worked. Small the bodily experience of psychedelia and
ly's aerial transmission regulations, made local companies such as the furniture disco dancing to the Number Ones. At the
all the channels broadcast the same con- manufacturers Aiazzone and Foppap same time that Charles and Ray Eames's
tent simultaneously, giving birth to what Pedretti, the mattress company Permaflex, Powers of Ten (1977) used the zoom to
was, in fact, a private national TV network: and fur coat seller Annabella unexpectedly provide universal constancy and "non-
Mediaset.20 What had started as a trans- grew when advertised by Mediaset. This discontinuity,"26 Lazarov would expand
media satellite city expanded into a nation- success fueled the expansion of Publitalia. bodies in the living rooms of apartments in
al transmedia urbanism- one that would Mediaset's ventures into France, the Neth- Milano 2 by turning these private spaces
produce urban settings in the interaction of erlands, Spain, and other countries were into centers of disco nightlife. To go out,
actual space with media domains- trans- followed by the organization of new corpo- one could stay at home.
ferring the segregationist project tested in rations, such as Publifrance, Publiespaña, In March 2012, Clemente Russo,
Milano 2 to the scale of Italy. and Publieurope. In 1984, Publitalia sur- a well-known boxer and policeman, made
passed Sipra, RAI's advertising sales unit, his début as the main character in the
SCALING UP: THE BIRTH OF in revenue.24 That same year, Auditei, the reality show Fratello Maggiore , in which he
TARGETED DIFFERENCE Italian research company that measures corrected the behavior of spoiled teenagers
In the 1980s, Fininvest developed television ratings and statistics, was creat- by becoming their fictional older brother.
two related initiatives. First, it acquired the ed. For the first time, the demographics of In this show on Mediaset's TV channel
retail chain Standa with the intention of audiences were monitored.25 Italia 1, he can be seen interacting with
controlling the node between distributors In 1980, Mike Bongiorno, the original ordinary people in domestic interiors,
and Number Ones, already exiled from host of RAI's biggest hit- Lascia o raddop- where problematic teenagers are asked
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
to reshape their lives according to his 1 Boccazzi Varotto Carlo, "Costruire la RAI.
azine, consumes Enervit Sport, communi- 6 Maurizio Coppo and Marco Cremaschi, eds.,
Strutture territoriali e questione abitativa (Milan:
cates with a Samsung phone, and travels
Franco Angeli, 1994).
on Alitalia.
7 In Italy, although 26% of new residential
Today, Milano 2's banality is inces- units were publically financed in the 1950s, that
santly published on Instagram accounts: figure dropped to less than 6% by the end of
1960s. Coppo and Cremaschi, eds., Strutture
its swans and its trees, the changing
territoriali e questione abitativa.
seasons of the grass, its living rooms, cats 8 "Guerra perla casa," Casabella 344 (1970).
in front of red pitched roofs, people in front 9 P. Ceretti and R. Fantacci, I nostri alberi. Una
of TV sets. With more than four million passeggiata botanica tra le Residenze ed i luoghi
paying subscribers in Italy, Sky-TV, d'incontro di Milano 2 (Segrate: Edilnord, 2011).
10 S. E. D'Anna and G. Moncalvo, Berlusconi
Europe's most popular satellite TV plat- in Concert (London: Otzium, 1994).
form, currently doubles the number of sub- 11 Edilnord Centri Residenziali S.A.S., Milano
scribers to Mediaset Premium digital cable 2. Una cita per vivere (Milan: Edilnord Centri
television, Mediaset's satellite television Residenziali, 1976).
12 Silvio Berlusconi, in Milano 2 sales bro-
service. Together, Mediaset Premium and
chures. Edilnord Centri Residenziali, Milano, 1970.
Sky-TV, as transnational media platforms,
13 This consolidation of ownership of the mar-
are globalizing direct-to-home urbanism, ket facilities would remain until the 2000s, when
in which the architectural embodiment of the Fondo Mario Negri sold a large number of the
the political has been implemented in a spaces to independent retailers.
14 Early Milano 2 apartment buyers, discus-
way that has so far remained unexplained.
sion with author, October 2013 - April 2014.
The effects of what once started in Milano
15 Giancarlo Ragazzi, discussion with author,
2 can be seen everywhere that people 2014.
consume, and it has become the urbanism 16 Edilnord, Milano 2. Una cita per vivere.
17 Eugène Saccomano, Berlusconi: le dossier
we mainly live by.
vérité (Paris: Parole Et Silence, 1994).
18 Former Tele Milano executive, discussion
with author, 2014.
19 F. Colombo, Le tre stagioni. Problemi
dell'Informazione 4 (1990): 593-97.
20 Gabriele Balbi and Benedetta Prario, "The
History of Fin invest/ Mediaset's Media Strategy:
30 Years of Politics, the Market, Technology and
Italian society," Media Culture & Society 32, no. 3
(May 2010): 391-409.
21 Paul Ginsborg, Silvio Berlusconi: Television,
Power and Patrimony (London: Verso, 2004).
22 This information is the result of an eth-
This content downloaded from 132.174.251.250 on Mon, 06 Mar 2023 15:35:31 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms