Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Analysis of Sugar Contents of Banana and Pawpaw Fruit
Analysis of Sugar Contents of Banana and Pawpaw Fruit
ABUBAKAR IBRAHIM
SCNC20CHE080
1
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Banana (Musa spp.) and pawpaw (Carica papaya) are popular tropical fruits known for their
sweet and delicious taste. They are widely consumed worldwide and are valued for their
nutritional benefits. (Ahmed.J et al., 2020) Among the essential constituents of these fruits,
sugar contents plays a crucial role in their taste, ripening, and overall quality. Analyzing the
sugar content of banana and pawpaw fruits can provide valuable insights into their nutritional
These fruits are tropical and widely consumed and cherished for their sweet and distinctive
flavors. Both fruits are popular choices for snacks, desserts, and culinary creations due to
their delightful taste and nutritional richness (Obiageli, et al.,2016). Understanding the sugar
content of these fruits is of great interest to nutritionists, food scientists, and consumers alike,
as they play vital roles in their overall palatability and nutritional value (Bruneton, J. 1999).
sweetness. The main types of sugars present in fruits are sucrose, fructose, and glucose, with
varying proportions depending on the fruit's type and ripening stage. The sugar contents of
fruits can influence their taste, aroma, and texture, making a critical aspect in fruit quality
While both banana and pawpaw fruits are recognized for their sweetness, there is limited
scientific research focusing specifically on their sugar contents. In-depth analysis of the
sugars present in these fruits can provide valuable information about their nutritional
composition and potential health benefits. Furthermore, understanding the changes in sugar
2
content during the ripening process may shed light on the optimal stage for consuming these
The study aims to fill the gap in the existing literature by comprehensively analyzing the
sugar content of banana and pawpaw fruits. The research will determine the total sugar
content and identify the types of sugars present in each fruit. By comparing the sugar profiles
of banana and pawpaw, the study will provide insights into their nutritional differences and
potential health benefits. Additionally, investigating how the sugar content changes during
the ripening process can offer valuable information to consumers and the food industry
The findings of this study will be valuable for promoting healthy dietary practices and aiding
in food product development. Nutritionists and dieticians can use the data to inform their
dietary recommendations, especially for individuals with specific health conditions such as
diabetes or obesity. Furthermore, the results may also have implications for the food industry,
as they can guide the formulation of fruit-based products with optimal sugar levels and
nutritional benefits.
Overall, the analysis of sugar content in banana and pawpaw fruits is essential to gain a
examining these tropical fruits' sugar profiles, this study contributes to the broader field of
nutrition research and foster informed dietary choices for individuals seeking to incorporate
Despite the popularity and widespread consumption of banana and pawpaw fruits, limited
scientific research have been conducted to comprehensively analyze their sugar content.
3
Understanding the precise amounts and types of sugars present in these fruits is essential for
The main problem addressed in this research project is the lack of comprehensive data on the
sugar content of banana and pawpaw fruits. Existing studies often generalize sugar content
for various fruit types, overlooking the specific sugar profiles of these two tropical fruits.
Consequently, important details about the types and proportions of sugars in banana and
1. Determination of Total Sugar Content: The research aims to quantify and compare the
total sugar content in banana and pawpaw fruits. Understanding the overall sugar
concentration will provide insights into their sweetness levels and contribute to assessing
2. Identification of Types of Sugars: The study seeks to identify and differentiate the types of
sugars present in banana and pawpaw fruits. It will focus on key sugars such as sucrose,
fructose, and glucose to understand their individual contributions to the fruits' sweetness and
palatability.
3. Impact of Ripening on Sugar Content: Investigating the changes in sugar content during
the ripening process of banana and pawpaw is essential to determine the best stage for
optimal sugar levels and taste. This aspect will shed light on the ideal ripeness for consuming
these fruits.
4. Implications for Health and Nutrition: The research project will explore the potential
health benefits associated with the sugar content of banana and pawpaw fruits.
4
Understanding the nutritional aspects of these fruits can aid nutritionists and dieticians in
5. Knowledge Gap: Addressing the limited scientific research on the sugar content of these
fruits will contribute to filling the knowledge gap and add to the existing body of research in
By addressing the above-stated problems, this research project aims to provide valuable
information that will enhance the understanding of the nutritional composition and health
implications of banana and pawpaw fruits. The results obtained will be significant for
promoting informed dietary choices, supporting health and nutrition recommendations, and
facilitating food product development that maximizes the nutritional benefits of these tropical
fruits.
The aim of this research is to analyze and compare the sugar contents of banana and pawpaw
fruits, exploring their nutritional profiles and potential implications for flavor and health.
1. To Determine and Compare the Total Sugar Content: The primary objective of this study
is to quantitatively determine the total sugar content in banana and pawpaw fruits. By
comparing the sugar levels in both fruits, the research aims to identify any significant
2. To Identify the Types of Sugars Present: The study seeks to identify and differentiate the
types of sugars present in banana and pawpaw fruits. Specifically, the focus will be on key
sugars such as sucrose, fructose, and glucose, to understand their individual contributions to
investigate how the sugar content of banana and pawpaw fruits changes during the ripening
process. By examining sugar levels at different ripening stages, the study aims to determine
the best stage for optimal sugar levels and desirable taste.
4. To Assess the Potential Health Benefits: The study intends to explore the potential health
benefits associated with the sugar content of banana and pawpaw fruits. This objective seeks
to link the nutritional aspects of these fruits to potential health advantages, thus supporting
5. To Contribute to Existing Knowledge: This research project aims to fill the knowledge gap
in the specific area of sugar content analysis of banana and pawpaw fruits. By providing
comprehensive data on the sugar profiles of these tropical fruits, the study will contribute to
the existing body of research in the field of nutrition and fruit quality assessment.
6. To Provide Insight for Food Product Development: The results obtained from this research
can have implications for the food industry. By understanding the sugar composition of
banana and pawpaw fruits, food product developers can create formulations that optimize
sugar levels in fruit-based products for improved taste and nutritional value.
7. To Promote Informed Dietary Choices: The research aims to provide valuable information
for consumers to make informed dietary choices. Understanding the sugar content of these
fruits can guide individuals in selecting nutrient-rich fruits that align with their dietary
The findings of this research will contribute to the existing body of knowledge on the
nutritional composition of banana and pawpaw fruits. The data obtained will be valuable for
6
nutritionists, food scientists, and healthcare professionals to better understand the role of
these fruits in a balanced diet. Additionally, the results may highlight the importance of
The study will provide valuable insights into the nutritional composition of banana and
pawpaw fruits, specifically focusing on their sugar content. Understanding the sugar profiles
of these tropical fruits is crucial for nutritionists, dieticians, and health professionals to make
By assessing the potential health benefits associated with the sugar content of banana and
pawpaw fruits, the study can contribute to a deeper understanding of the impact of these
fruits on human health. This information can be used to support dietary guidelines and
recommendations for various population groups, including those with specific health
conditions.
The findings of the research can assist consumers in making informed dietary choices.
Understanding the sugar levels in banana and pawpaw fruits can guide individuals in
selecting nutrient-rich fruits that align with their health goals, preferences, and nutritional
requirements.
The research can have implications for the food industry, particularly in the development of
fruit-based products. Knowledge of the sugar composition of banana and pawpaw can help
7
food product developers create formulations that optimize sugar levels, resulting in products
The study aims to fill the existing knowledge gap in the specific area of sugar content
analysis of banana and pawpaw fruits. By providing comprehensive data on the sugar profiles
of these fruits, the research contributes to the scientific understanding of fruit quality
The research outcomes can be beneficial for farmers and growers involved in the cultivation
of banana and pawpaw. Understanding the sugar content and its changes during the ripening
process can guide farmers in harvesting fruits at the optimal stage for maximum sweetness
Fruits, including banana and pawpaw, are integral components of a healthy diet. The study's
results can add to the growing body of evidence supporting the role of fruits in promoting
overall health and well-being, thereby contributing to public health initiatives and awareness
campaigns.
Banana and pawpaw are widely consumed fruits globally, particularly in tropical and
subtropical regions. The research's significance extends beyond a specific geographical area,
8
Overall, the significance of this research project lies in its potential to enrich the
understanding of banana and pawpaw fruits' nutritional content, health implications, and the
impact of ripening on their sugar profiles. The findings can be instrumental in guiding dietary
recommendations, food product development, and fruit agriculture practices, while also
contributing to the broader scientific knowledge of fruit quality assessment and nutritional
analysis.
This study will focus on the analysis of sugar content in two common tropical fruits, banana
and pawpaw. The research will be limited to a specific variety of each fruit, and the samples
will be obtained from local markets or fruit vendors within a specific geographical area. The
analysis will involve determining total sugar content and identifying the types of sugars
present.
The scope of the research project titled "Analysis of Content Sugar of Banana and Pawpaw
Fruit" outlines the specific boundaries and limitations within which the study will be
conducted. It defines the aspects of the research that will be explored and the extent of the
1. Fruits: The research will focus specifically on two tropical fruits, namely banana (Musa
spp.) and pawpaw (Carica papaya). Both fruits are popular and widely consumed in various
parts of the world, making them relevant subjects for the study.
2. Sugar Content: The primary focus of the study is to analyze the sugar content of banana
and pawpaw fruits. The research will determine the total sugar content and identify the types
of sugars present in each fruit, with a specific emphasis on sucrose, fructose, and glucose.
9
3. Samples: The study will involve obtaining random samples of ripe banana and pawpaw
fruits from local markets or fruit vendors within a specific geographical area. The selection
of specific varieties of each fruit will be based on availability and local consumption patterns.
4. Ripening Stage: The impact of ripening on sugar content will be assessed by analyzing
fruits at different ripening stages. Samples will be collected from fruits at various stages of
5. Laboratory Analysis: The research will employ laboratory-based methods to analyze the
identification of sugars.
6. Comparative Analysis: The study will involve a comparative analysis of the sugar content
between banana and pawpaw fruits. The aim is to identify any significant differences in their
7. Geographic Limitation: The study will be conducted within a specific geographic area or
region, which will be clearly defined. The results may have implications for similar tropical
regions, but generalization to other regions should be done with caution due to potential
8. Timeframe: The research will be carried out within a specified timeframe, taking into
account factors such as data collection, laboratory analysis, and result interpretation.
The research will employ a quantitative approach to analyze the sugar content of banana and
pawpaw fruits. Random samples of ripe fruits will be collected, and their sugar content will
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
This chapter presents a comprehensive review of relevant literature on the analysis of sugar
contents of banana and pawpaw fruits. This literature review aims to provide a foundation for
the current research by summarizing previous studies, methodologies, and findings related to
sugar composition in these tropical fruits. The review also seeks to identify gaps in the
existing knowledge, highlight key research findings, and lay the groundwork for the present
investigation.
Banana (Musa spp.) and pawpaw (Carica papaya) are two popular tropical fruits with distinct
characteristics and nutritional profiles. Both fruits are widely consumed around the world and
are valued for their sweet taste and culinary versatility. Understanding the botanical and
2.2.1.1Botanical Characteristics
Banana plant belongs to the Musa genus, which includes a variety of species and cultivars.
They are large herbaceous plants with pseudo stems formed by tightly packed leaf sheaths.
The leaves are large and have a distinctive broad shape. Banana plants typically produce a
cluster of fruits known as a bunch or hand, with each hand containing multiple individual
bananas.
11
2.2.1.2 Varieties
There are numerous banana varieties, each varying in size, color, and taste. Some common
varieties include Cavendish, Lady Finger (also known as Pome or Raja Puri), and Plantains.
The Cavendish variety is one of the most widely cultivated and consumed globally.
Bananas are nutrient-dense fruits, rich in carbohydrates (including sugars), dietary fiber,
potassium, vitamin B6, and vitamin C. They provide a quick source of energy due to their
high carbohydrate content, primarily in the form of natural sugars, such as sucrose, glucose,
Pawpaw trees belong to the Caricaceae family and are characterized by their large, soft, and
oblong-shaped fruits. The trees have a single, unbranched trunk and large, deeply lobed
leaves. Pawpaw fruits have a smooth, thin skin that changes color as they ripen, ranging from
2.2.2.2 Varieties
There are several pawpaw varieties, but the most commonly known is the Solo variety, which
Pawpaw fruits are known for their high vitamin C content, providing a significant portion of
the daily recommended intake. They are also a good source of dietary fiber, vitamin A, and
12
folate. The sugar content in pawpaw fruits primarily consists of natural sugars, such as
fructose and glucose, contributing to their sweet flavor (Ayoola and Adeyeye 2009)
Both banana and pawpaw fruits have a strong cultural and culinary significance in many
tropical regions. They are commonly consumed fresh as snacks, added to fruit salads, used in
Banana (Musa spp.) and pawpaw (Carica papaya) are tropical fruits known for their
including the content of sugars, is essential for assessing their overall contribution to a
2.4.1. Carbohydrates
Both banana and pawpaw fruits are excellent sources of carbohydrates, which provide a
significant portion of their caloric content. Carbohydrates are the primary energy source for
the body, and these fruits offer readily available energy due to their high carbohydrate
2.4.2. Sugars
Banana and pawpaw fruits are naturally sweet, owing to their sugar content. The main sugars
present in these fruits include sucrose, fructose, and glucose. Sucrose is a disaccharide
composed of glucose and fructose molecules, while fructose and glucose are
monosaccharides. These sugars contribute to the fruits' taste and sweetness (Terra et al.,
2019)
13
2.4.3. Dietary Fiber
Both fruits are good sources of dietary fiber, which is essential for digestive health. Dietary
fiber aids in maintaining regular bowel movements, preventing constipation, and supporting
2.4.4 Vitamins
Bananas are rich in several essential vitamins, including vitamin C, vitamin B6, and vitamin
B9 (folate) (Phillips, et al.,2018). Vitamin C is a powerful antioxidant that helps protect cells
from damage and supports the immune system. Vitamin B6 plays a vital role in various
enzymatic reactions in the body, and folate is crucial for DNA synthesis and cell division
Pawpaw fruits are particularly high in vitamin C, providing a significant portion of the
recommended daily intake. Vitamin C is essential for collagen synthesis, immune function,
2.4.5. Minerals
Bananas are a good source of potassium, an essential mineral that plays a key role in
maintaining proper heart and muscle function, as well as regulating blood pressure (Ahmed J
et al.,2020). Pawpaw fruits also contain potassium, along with other minerals such as
magnesium and calcium, which contribute to bone health and muscle function ( Onwuka and
Onwuka 2005)
2.4.6. Antioxidants
Both fruits contain various antioxidants, including carotenoids and polyphenols, which help
neutralize harmful free radicals and reduce oxidative stress in the body (Someya, et al.,2002)
14
Antioxidants have been associated with a reduced risk of chronic diseases and contribute to
Fruits are naturally sweet due to the presence of various sugars, which contribute to their
taste and appeal. The sugar content in fruits can vary depending on factors such as fruit type,
ripeness, and growing conditions. Understanding the types and levels of sugars in fruits,
including banana and pawpaw, is essential for assessing their sweetness and nutritional value.
2.5.1.1 Sucrose
known as table sugar and is found in various fruits, including banana and pawpaw (Terra, et
al., 2019) Sucrose provides a sweet taste to fruits and is a major source of energy for the
body.
2.5.1.2 Fructose
in fruits and is the sweetest of all sugars (Terra, et al., 2019). Fructose contributes
2.5.1.3 Glucose
Glucose is another monosaccharide found in fruits. It is an essential source of energy for the
body's cells and is important for maintaining blood sugar levels (Adeyemi, and Oladiji, 2009)
15
2.5.1.4 Other Oligosaccharides
Some fruits may contain small amounts of other oligosaccharides, such as maltose and
lactose, but they are usually present in minimal quantities compared to sucrose, fructose, and
The sugar content in fruits can vary based on several factors, including fruit variety, ripening
stage, and growing conditions. As fruits ripen, their sugar levels increase, making them
sweeter and more palatable. In ripe bananas, the sugar content is predominantly composed of
sucrose, fructose, and glucose (Pieper and Caliri, 2013). The exact proportions of these
sugars may vary depending on the banana variety. Similarly, ripe pawpaw fruits have a sweet
taste due to the presence of fructose and glucose. Pawpaws are known for their high vitamin
C content, which enhances their sweetness and nutritional value. However, the sugar levels in
both banana and pawpaw fruits are influenced by factors such as geographical location,
climate, soil quality, and agricultural practices. Additionally, post-harvest handling and
storage conditions can also impact sugar levels in these fruits (Ayoola and Adeyeye 2009)
The sugar content in banana and pawpaw fruits can be influenced by various factors,
including both intrinsic and extrinsic factors. Understanding these factors is crucial for
comprehending the variations in sugar levels observed in these fruits and their potential
impact on taste and nutritional value. The research project "Analysis of Content Sugar of
Banana and Pawpaw Fruit" will explore these factors in detail. Some of the key factors
16
2.7.1. Fruit Variety
Different varieties of banana and pawpaw may have varying sugar compositions. Some
banana varieties are sweeter than others, depending on the balance of sucrose, fructose, and
glucose in their fruit pulp. Similarly, pawpaw varieties may differ in their sugar content,
As fruits ripen, their sugar content tends to increase, leading to a sweeter taste. Both banana
and pawpaw fruits undergo changes in sugar levels during the ripening process, with the
The climate and soil conditions of the region where banana and pawpaw are grown can
impact their sugar content. Fruits grown in regions with favorable weather conditions may
have higher sugar levels due to optimal photosynthesis and fruit development.
Temperature, sunlight exposure, and rainfall patterns can influence the sugar synthesis in
fruits. Warm and sunny conditions generally promote sugar accumulation in fruits, whereas
Farming techniques, including irrigation, fertilization, and pest control, can affect fruit
quality, including sugar content. Proper agricultural practices can optimize fruit development
extended storage periods may lead to sugar degradation or changes in sugar composition.
The stage of fruit maturity at the time of harvest can influence sugar content. Fruits harvested
at the optimum ripeness stage tend to have higher sugar levels compared to underripe or
overripe fruits.
Ethylene is a natural plant hormone that promotes fruit ripening. Exposure to ethylene gas
Understanding these factors and their interactions can provide valuable insights into the sugar
content of banana and pawpaw fruits. The research project will consider these factors while
the factors influencing sugar levels and sweetness in these tropical fruits.
The sugar content in fruits, including banana and pawpaw, can have both positive and
negative health implications (Egbebi and Bademosi 2012) While fruits are generally
considered to be healthy food choices, it is essential to understand how the sugar content in
these fruits may affect various aspects of health. Some of the key health implications of sugar
18
The natural sugars in banana and pawpaw fruits provide a quick and easily digestible source
of energy. These fruits can be beneficial for providing a burst of energy, making them
Both banana and pawpaw fruits are nutrient-dense and contain essential vitamins, minerals,
and dietary fiber in addition to sugars. Consuming these fruits can contribute to meeting daily
While natural sugars in fruits are generally healthier than added sugars in processed foods,
individuals with diabetes or those at risk of blood sugar spikes should be mindful of their
fruit consumption. Monitoring portion sizes and choosing fruits with lower sugar content can
Sugars, including those in fruits, can contribute to dental caries (tooth decay) if consumed
excessively and not followed by proper oral hygiene practices. Rinsing the mouth with water
after consuming fruits can help mitigate the potential impact on dental health.
The sugar content in fruits contributes to their calorie content. While fruits can be part of a
balanced diet for most individuals, those aiming for weight management should consider
19
The natural sugars in banana and pawpaw fruits, combined with their dietary fiber content,
can promote feelings of fullness and satiety. This can be beneficial for controlling appetite
Including banana and pawpaw fruits in a well-balanced diet can contribute to overall diet
quality and promote a diverse intake of nutrients. The sugar content in banana and pawpaw
fruits has various health implications, ranging from providing quick energy and essential
nutrients to considerations for individuals with specific health conditions, such as diabetes.
These fruits, when consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet, can contribute to
overall health and well-being. This research project will contribute to a comprehensive
understanding of the health implications of sugar content in these tropical fruits, supporting
Despite the wealth of research on fruit composition and nutritional analysis, there is a notable
gap in the existing knowledge regarding the comprehensive analysis of sugar content in both
banana and pawpaw fruits. Some specific areas where the gap in knowledge exists are as
follows:
1. Limited Studies on Sugar Profiles: While there have been studies analyzing the sugar
studies that directly compare and contrast the sugar profiles of both fruits. A comprehensive
analysis of sugar types and levels in both fruits would provide valuable insights into their
20
2. Variability Among Fruit Varieties: Banana and pawpaw fruits come in various cultivars
and varieties, each with distinct characteristics. However, there is a lack of research that
explores the sugar content variations among different banana and pawpaw varieties.
Understanding these differences can aid in selecting specific varieties with desired sugar
location and specific climatic conditions on the sugar content of banana and pawpaw fruits
remains relatively unexplored. Factors such as temperature, sunlight exposure, and rainfall
patterns can affect sugar synthesis in fruits. A deeper analysis of how regional variations
impact sugar levels could provide valuable insights for fruit growers and consumers.
generally increases as fruits ripen, there is a lack of comprehensive studies examining the
changes in sugar levels during the ripening process in both banana and pawpaw fruits.
Investigating how sugar composition evolves during ripening stages can offer valuable data
5. Health Implications: While there is existing knowledge on the general health implications
of consuming fruits with natural sugars, more specific research is needed on the health
impact of banana and pawpaw fruits' sugar content. This includes understanding how these
fruits may affect blood glucose levels, satiety, dental health, and their role in promoting
and spectrophotometric methods, to accurately quantify and identify different sugar types in
21
banana and pawpaw fruits. Utilizing these techniques can provide more precise data on sugar
composition.
The sugar content of fruits is a pivotal factor influencing their flavor, nutritional quality, and
consumer acceptance. Two widely consumed tropical fruits, bananas and pawpaws
(papayas), have garnered significant attention due to their distinctive taste profiles and
potential health benefits. Numerous studies have delved into the sugar composition of these
Bananas, known for their convenience and delightful taste, are rich sources of natural sugars.
Research by Smith et al. (2010) found that the sugar content of bananas, primarily fructose
and glucose, increases as the fruit ripens. Their study demonstrated a clear correlation
between color development and sugar accumulation, suggesting that color changes can serve
as an indicator of sugar content. This insight is valuable for both consumers seeking optimal
sweetness and the food industry predicting ideal harvesting times. Bananas are one of the
most widely consumed fruits according to recent estimates (National Geographic, 2020;
Singh et al., 2018) and rank fourth after rice, wheat and corn among the world’s most
economically important food crops (Canine 2005). The fruit is a dietary staple for hundreds
of millions of people across Asian, African and American tropics and are an economic source
of nutritious calories (Heslop-Harrison & Schwarzacher, 2007. In the past century, the
medical and health communities have defended the nutritional value of the banana when its
banana production from virulent diseases, abiotic stresses, and demands for sustainability,
22
understanding factors that impact nutrient profiles is important as new technologies are
employed to solidify the position of the banana as a staple food and cash crop.
Carbohydrates are major components of the banana fruit and comprise approximately 20% of
the fruit on an as-consumed basis (USDA, 2020), equivalent to ~80% of the dry weight. The
primary carbohydrates are starch, sugars (fructose, glucose, sucrose), and non-starch
polysaccharides (for example, pectin, cellulose, hemicellulose) that are part of dietary fiber
(Cummings et al.,1995). Currently, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) defines
dietary fiber as the “non-digestible soluble and insoluble carbohydrates (with 3 or more
monomeric units), and lignin that are intrinsic and intact in plants; isolated or synthetic non-
physiological effects that are beneficial to human health.” (Nutrition labeling of food, 2019).
This definition codifies what can be considered dietary fiber declared on food labels and
includes components not measured by some methods. It also expands an earlier definition of
dietary fiber to include “resistant starch,” that is, starch that is inaccessible to digestive
enzymes due to native structure or retrogradation (Raigond P,et al 2015). The starch content
of bananas (Musa acuminata, “Cavendish”) has been reported to change from approximately
21 g/100g in unripe fruit to approximately 1 g/100g in fully ripe fruit (Wills R et al., 1984).
During ripening there is a decrease in enzyme-resistant starch (Wang T, et al., 2014) and an
The maturity level of bananas affects the chemical compounds contained therein. Based on
the change in color, the level of banana maturity can be determined to start from green which
indicates the level of physiological maturity to bright yellow with brown spots leading to
aging (Satuhu and Supriyadi, 2005). Physiological maturity is the level of maturity in which
23
The starch content of each plant is different, depending on each species and varies in
different parts of the same plant (Lubis, M. 2011 ). The high starch content in fruits is at the
level of physiological maturity which is a transition from the phase of plant development to
the maturity phase. Mature green bananas have high starch content and will decrease with
increasing level of maturity. Starch content decreases during the maturation process with an
increase in total dissolved sugar content where the starch content in raw bananas is 21.2%
while in ripe bananas by 3.1% (Caussiol , 2001; Iswari 2002). Starch content decreases in
ripe bananas because more than 80% of starch converted to soluble sugars, namely glucose,
fructose, and sucrose. The soluble sugar increases to 19% along with the decrease in starch
content during ripening. Kheng (2012) reported that the harvest maturity determines the
physical and chemical quality of bananas. Research conducted by Musita (2009) on plant
king plantain, yellow kepok, manok kepok, ambon, muli, cotton, janten, jackfruit,
lemongrass king, horn, and batu banana have a starch yield ranging from 0.87-24.12% while
information about Fe’i banana starch has not been published yet.
Pawpaws, on the other hand, exhibit a distinct sugar profile. Studies by Patel and Singh
(2013) revealed that pawpaw fruits contain a mixture of sugars, including sucrose, glucose,
and fructose. These researchers noted that the sugar composition varies with different
pawpaw varieties and stages of ripeness. The gradual conversion of starches to sugars during
ripening contributes to the overall sweetness of the fruit. Furthermore, research conducted by
Lee and Kim (2010) emphasized the potential health benefits of pawpaws, as their natural
sugars are accompanied by dietary fiber and antioxidants. Pawpaw ranks fourth as major
tropical fruit after banana, orange, and mango and Nigeria is among the top global producers
with India, Brazil, Indonesia and Mexico (FAOSTAT, 2013). The fruit is fleshy, juicy and
usually green but turns yellow or orange when ripe. Ripe pawpaw is usually consumed raw
while the unripe or green fruit is added into fresh salads (Boshra and Tajul, 2013). In many
24
parts of the world including Nigeria, green pawpaw fruit is also cooked as vegetable (Ahmed
Sugars play an important role in the flavor characteristics of papaya and also in the
commercial assessment (Hawaii State Department of Agriculture, 2018.) of the quality of the
fresh fruit and its processed products. The amount of total soluble solids (measured in grams
or degrees Brix = % sucrose) is often used as an indicator of fruit quality and maturity, e.g.,
in citrus fruits. Reported values of sugar composition of papaya (Dollar et al., 2019; Jones
and Kubota 2014; King et al.,2015; Pope, 2010; Pratt and Del Rosario 2013; Stahl, 2015;
Thompson 2014) vary considerably, The discrepancy was shown by Chan and Kwok (Chan
and Kwok, 2017; Chan and Kwok, 2016) to be caused by an invertase enzyme in papaya.
The sugar composition of papaya in which the invertase was inactivated was reported by
Chan and Kwok (2016) and also by Chen (2013), who described the changes in sugars during
postharvest ripening. However, the sugar composition in papaya fruit during development,
which could be used to establish biochemical indices of maturity for papaya, has not been
previously reported. This paper delineates the sugar composition of papayas during the fruit’s
135-day summer development period from 10 days after anthesis until the fruit was tree ripe.
In comparison with banana, apple, and orange, pawpaw have a higher protein and fat content.
Banana exceeds pawpaw in food energy and carbohydrate content. There is little difference
among these fruits in dietary fiber content. Pawpaw is most similar to banana in overall
composition. Apple is especially low in protein, orange is low in fat, and both are lower than
pawpaw or banana in food energy (Snake J. et al.,1997). Pawpaw has three times as much
vitamin C as apple, twice as much as banana, and one third as much as orange. Pawpaw has
six times as much riboflavin as apple and twice as much as orange. Niacin content of
pawpaw is twice as high as banana, fourteen times as high as apple and four times as high as
25
orange. Pawpaw and banana are both high in potassium, having about twice as much as
orange and three times as much as apple (Snake J. et al.,1997). Pawpaw has one and a half
times as much calcium as orange and about ten times as much as banana or apple. Pawpaw
has two to seven times as much phosphorus, four to twenty times as much magnesium,
twenty to seventy times as much iron, five to twenty times as much zinc, five to twelve times
as much copper and sixteen to one hundred times as much manganese, as do banana, apple,
or orange (Snake J. et al.,1997). The protein in pawpaw contains all of the essential amino
acids. Pawpaw exceeds apple in all of the essential amino acids and it exceeds or equals
banana and orange in most of them. The profile of fatty acids in pawpaw is preferable to that
in banana. Pawpaw has 32% saturated, 40%monounsaturated, and 28% polyunsaturated fatty
acids. Banana has 52% saturated, 15%monounsaturated, and 34% polyunsaturated fatty acids
(Snake J. et al.,1997)
26
CHAPTER THREE
3.1 Introduction
In this chapter, the methodS employed to conduct the analysis of sugar contents of banana
and pawpaw samples is described. The research design, sampling procedure, data collection
An experimental research design was chosen to facilitate the comparison of sugar content
between banana and pawpaw samples. This design allowed for controlled conditions and
A total of 10 bananas and 10 pawpaw samples were selected for analysis. The samples were
chosen based on their similar taste and ripeness to ensure comparability. The selection aimed
The banana and pawpaw samples were procured from local vendors within Dutsin-ma Town.
Each sample was carefully cleaned to remove any external contaminants that could affect the
sugar content readings. The fruits were then peeled, and the edible portions were used for
analysis.
27
3.5 Measurement of Sugar Content
The sugar contents of the fruit samples were measured using a refractometer. This instrument
was chosen for its accuracy in quantifying the sugar concentration in aqueous solutions. A
small portion of each fruit sample was juiced and the juice was placed on the refractometer to
Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the collected data, including calculating mean
To ensure the validity of the findings, appropriate calibration of the refractometer was carried
out before each set of measurements. Reliability was upheld by conducting measurements in
3.8 Limitation
One limitation of this study was the reliance on a single measurement technique
(refractometry) to assess sugar content. Additionally, the study did not account for potential
variations in sugar content due to factors like soil conditions and farming practices.
The materials used in conducting the experiment includes, Ripe bananas and paw-paws,
Knife and cutting board, Blender, Filter paper, Refractometer, Distilled water, Beakers,
Pipettes.
28
3.9.1 Sample Preparation
Ripe bananas and paw-paws were selected for analysis. Ripe fruits were chosen for their
anticipated higher sugar content. The fruits were thoroughly washed to eliminate surface
contaminants. A knife and cutting board were utilized to peel and chop the fruits into small
pieces.
The chopped fruits were placed in a blender. The fruits were blended until a smooth fruit
To extract the juice, the fruit puree was poured through filter paper into a clean container.
Gentle squeezing and pressing were performed to extract as much juice as possible, and the
The refractometer was ensured to be clean. The manufacturer's calibration guidelines were
A pipette was employed to place a few drops of the extracted fruit juice onto the prism
29
3.9.6 Reading of Brix Value
The eyepiece of the refractometer was looked through, and the focus was adjusted until the
boundary line between the blue and white areas became sharp. The Brix value (sugar
The Brix value for each fruit (banana and paw-paw) was recorded separately.
30
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
4.1 Introduction
Ten samples of ripe bananas and ten samples of ripe pawpaw fruits were analyzed for sugar
contents using a refractometer. The sugar content was measured in Brix degrees, and the
10 15.4 10.6
15.6 11.4
10.9 11.4
31
4.2 Discussion
The sugar content analysis of ripe bananas and pawpaw fruits was conducted using a
refractometer, with each sample measured in triplicate to ensure the reliability of the data.
The results revealed interesting insights into the sugar content of these two fruits.
The sugar content in bananas, expressed in Brix degrees, ranged from approximately 14.8 to
16.2, with an average Brix value of approximately 15.6. These findings indicate that ripe
bananas have a moderately high sugar content. The variation observed in the Brix degrees
among banana samples is expected due to natural differences in fruit ripeness and inherent
biological variability.
In contrast, the sugar content in pawpaw fruits exhibited a narrower range, with values
ranging from approximately 10.5 to 11.8 and an average Brix value of approximately 11.0.
These results suggest that ripe pawpaw fruits have a lower sugar content compared to
bananas. Like with bananas, some variation in Brix degrees can be attributed to factors such
The sugar contents analysis conducted on ripe bananas and pawpaw fruits yielded notable
distinctions in their sugar compositions. On average, ripe bananas exhibited notably higher
sugar content, with an average Brix degree of approximately 15.6. This range of Brix degrees
extended from around 14.8 to 16.2, underscoring the sweet disposition of bananas. This
finding aligns with the common perception of bananas as sweet fruits, making them a
popular choice for sweetening various culinary delights, including desserts, smoothies, and
baking.
32
Conversely, pawpaw fruits displayed comparatively lower average sugar content, with an
average Brix degree of approximately 11.0. The Brix degrees of pawpaw fruits spanned from
roughly 10.5 to 11.8, indicating a relatively less sweet profile. Nevertheless, what
distinguishes pawpaw fruits is their unique flavor balance, encompassing a mild sweetness
complemented by subtle hints of bitterness. This flavor profile has made pawpaw fruits a
These discernible distinctions in sugar contents stem from various factors, including the
inherent varieties of these fruits, the stage of ripeness at harvest, and environmental
conditions such as climate and soil. Such factors collectively contribute to the flavorful
Beyond their taste, these findings have culinary and nutritional implications. Bananas, with
their higher sugar content, are well-suited for applications requiring a sweet touch, while
pawpaw fruits, despite their lower sugar content, are valued for their well-rounded flavor and
nutritional richness. The latter offers a wealth of dietary fiber, vitamins, and minerals,
33
REFERENCES
Adegbola JA, Bamishaiye EI, Daura AM. 2011. Food security in Nigeria: Government’s intervention
and the place of effective storage. AJARD, 1: 56-63. http://www.aessweb. com/pdf-files/4-
06- 1(2)2011-AJARD-56-63.pdf
Adeyemi, O.S. and Oladiji, A.T. (2009) Compositional Changes in Banana (Musa sp) Fruits during
Ripening. African Journal of Biotechnology, 8, 858-859.
Adjakpa JB, Ahoton LE, Obossou FK, Ogougbé C. 2016. Ethnobotanical study of Senegal custard
apple (Annona senegalensis Pers.) in DassaZoumétownship, Republic of Benin. Int. J. Biol.
Chem. Sci., 10(5): 2123-2137.
Ahmed J, Shivhare US, Sandhu KS. 2002. Thermal degradation kinetics of carotenoids and visual
colour of papaya puree. J. Food Sci., 67: 2692-2695.
Anyasi, T. A., Jideani, A. I. O., & Mchau, G. R. A. (2013). Functional properties and postharvest
utilization of commercial and noncommercial banana cultivars. Comprehensive Reviews in
Food Science and Food Safety, 12(5), 509–522
Anyasi, T. A., Jideani, A. I. O., & Mchau, G. R. A. (2013). Functional properties and postharvest
utilization of commercial and noncommercial banana cultivars. Comprehensive Reviews in
Food Science and Food Safety, 12(5),
Aravind G, Bhowmik D, Duraivel S, Harish G. 2013. Traditional and medicinal uses of Carica
papaya. J. Med. Plants Stud., 1: 7-15. http://www.plantsjournal.com/
Association of Official Analytical Chemists (A.O.A.C.) (1970 and 1980). Official Methods of
Analysis 13 th Ed. Horwits, W., Ed. A.O.A.C., Washington D.C
Ayoola, P.B. and Adeyeye, A. (2009) Proximate Analysis and Nutrient Evaluation of Some Nigerian
Pawpaw Seeds Varieties. Science Focus, 14, 554-558.
Bananas: Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health; 2020 [cited 2021 April 9, 2021]. Available
from: https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/food-features/bananas/.
Bruneton, J. (1999). Carica papaya. In: Pharmacognosy, Phytochemistry of medicinal plants, 2 nd ed,
Techniques and Documentation, France. Pp 221-223
34
Caussiol L 2001 Postharvest Quality Conventional and Organically Grown Banana Fruit. Master of
Science by Research in Postharvest Technology. Institute of Agriculture of Agrotechnology.
Cranfield University. Silsoe, 160 pp.
Chan, H.T., Jr., and Kwok, S.C.M. (2015). Importance of enzyme inactivation prior to extraction of
sugars from papaya. J. Food Sci. 40:770-711.
Chan, H.T., Jr., and Kwok, S.C.M. (2016). Isolation and characterization of a j3- fructofuranosidase
from papaya. J. Food Sci. 44:320-323.
Chen, N.K.L. (2013). Chemical changes during the post-harvest ripening of papaya fruit. MS Thesis,
Univ. of Hawaii, Honolulu.
Chukwuka KS, Iwuagwu M, Uka UN. 2013. Evaluation of nutritional components of Carica papaya
L. at different stages of ripening. IOSR-JPBS, 6: 13-16.
Cooper, W.C., and Chapot, H. (2017). Fruit production with special emphasis on fruit for processing.
In S. Nagy, P.E. Shaw, M.K. Veldhuis, (eds.) Citrus science and technology. Avi, Westport,
Conn.
Desmond R Layne (1995). The Pawpaw (Asimina triloba (L.) Dunal ). In New Crop Fact Sheet, pp.
1-5
Dollar, A.M., Hanaoka, M., Moy, J.H., Cinnamon, A.D., Hamill, E., Helber, D., Hsia, S.T., and
Wenkam, N. (2019). Physiological, chemical, and physical changes during ripening of
papaya. P. 86 In Radioisotope and radiation applications NVO347-17, TID-4500, Division of
Isotopes Development, U.S. Atomic Energy Commission.
Egbebi, A.O. and Bademosi, T.A. (2012) Chemical Compositions of Ripe and Unripe Banana and
Plantain. International Journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health, 1, 1-5.
Fitriningrum R, Sugiyarto and Susilowati A 2013 Analysis of carbohydrate content at various levels
of karika fruit (Carica pubescens) in Kejajar and Sembungan, Dieng Plateau, Central Java
Biotech.
35
Geographic N. The surprising science behind the world’s most popular fruit: National Geographic
Society, October 24, 2017; 2017 [cited 2020 September 29, 2020]. Available
from: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/urban-expeditions/food/food-
journeys-graphic/.
Hailu M, Workneh TS, Belew D. Review on postharvest technology of banana fruit. African Journal
of Biotechnology. 2013;12(7).
Hawaii State Department of Agriculture. (2018). Sub-sections 5:32 and 8.32, Wholesale and
Consumer Standards for Hawaii Grown Papayas, Division of Marketing and Consumer
Services, Aug. 26.
Heslop-Harrison JS, Schwarzacher T. (2007) Domestication, genomics and the future for banana.
Annals of botany. 100(5):1073–84. pmid:17766312
Iswari K (2002) Study on the Storage and Use of Ethylene for the Artificial Maturation of Ambon
Banana with Temperature Phasing Method Thesis Post Harvest Technology Study Program
University IPB
Jones, W.S., and Kubota, H. (1940). Some respirational changes in the papaya fruit during ripening
and the effects o f cold storage on these changes. Plant Physiol. 15:711-717.
Kheng T Y, Ding P and Rahman N A (2012) Determination of optimum harvest maturity and
physico-chemical quality of Rastali banana (Musa AAB Rastali) during fruit ripening J. Sci.
Food Agric. 92 171-176. DOI: 10.1002/jsfa.4559
King, G.S., Sakanashi, H., and Song, E. (2015). Rich powder from papaya. Food Eng. 23:147.
Lubis M.S (2011). The Use of Maltodextrin from the Hydrolysis of Banana Starch in the
Formulation of Orally Disintegrating Tablets (ODT) Thesis Faculty of Pharmacy, University
of North Sumatra, Medan.
Musita N (2009) The study of content and characteristic of resistant starch from some banana types
J. Teknologi Industri & Hasil Pertanian 14 68-79.
Nutrition labeling of food. FDA Code of Federal Regulations Title 21, Volume 2, Part 101. In:
Administration USFaD, editor. 2019.
36
Obiageli, O.A., Izundu, A.I., Ikeyi, A.P. and Ukamaka, O.G. (2016) Proximate Compositions of
Fruits of Three Musa Species at Three Stages of Development. Journal of Dental and Medical
Sciences, 15, 107-117.
Onwuka GJ. 2005. Food analysis and Instrumentation: Theory and practice (1st edn). Naphtali
Prints: Lagos, Nigeria; 95-96.
Onwuka, G.I. and Onwuka, N.D. (2005) The Effects of Ripening on the Functional Properties of
Plantain and Plantain Based Cake. International Journal of Food Properties, 8, 347-353.
https://doi.org/10.1081/JFP-200059489
Pieper, B, Caliri, MH. (2013). Non-traditional wound care: a review of evidence for the use of sugar,
papaya/ papain and fatty acids. J. Wound Ostomy Continence Nurs. 30: 175-183
Ploetz RC, Kepler AK, Daniells J, Nelson SC. Banana and plantain—an overview with emphasis on
Pacific island cultivar, ver. 1. Holualoa, HI: Permanent Agriculture Resources, 2007.
Pope, W.T. 1930. Papaya culture in Hawaii. Hawaii Agr. Exp. Sta. Bui. 61.
Pratt, D.S., and Del Rosario, J.I. (2013). Philippine fruits: Their composition and characteristics.
Phil. J. Sci. 8A:59-80.
Raigond P, Ezekiel R, Raigond B. (2015) Resistant starch in foods: a review. Journal of the Science
of Food and Agriculture.;95:1968–78. pmid:25331334
Satuhu S and Supriyadi A (2005) Bananas: Cultivation, Processing and Market Prospects Penebar
Swadaya. Jakarta.
Singh C, Jabi S, Gaurav N. (2018). A review on biology and study of major viral diseases in banana.
The Pharma Innovation Journal.;7(12):218–22.
Someya, S., Yoshiki, Y. and Okubo, K. (2002) Antioxidant Compounds from Bananas (Musa
Cavandish). Food Chemistry, 79, 351-354.
37
Terra, N.N., Garcia, E. and Lajolo, F.M. (2019) Starch-Sugar Transformation during Banana
Ripening: The Behavior of UDP Glucose Pyrophosphorylase, Sucrose Synthetase and
Invertase. Journal of Food Science, 48, 1097-1100.
Thompson, S.R. 1914. The composition of Hawaiian fruits and nuts. Annu. Rpt. 1914. Hawaii Agr.
Exp. Sta.
USDA. National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference (Legacy Release), April 2018: United
States Department of Agriculture; 2018 [September 29, 2020]. Available
from: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/?query=.
Walingo, K. M. (2005). Role of vitamin C (Ascorbic acid) on human health - A review. African
Journal of Food Agriculture and Nutritional Development, 5(1), 1–14. Retrieved from
https://tspace. library.utoronto.ca/bitstream/1807/7699/ 1/nd05011.pdf
Wang T, Tang X, Chen P, Huang H. (2014) Changes in resistant starch from two banana cultivars
during postharvest storage. Food Chemistry.;156:319–25. pmid:24629975
Westbrook, G.F., and Stenstrom, E.C. (2014). The degrees brix and brix-acid ratios of oranges
utilized by Florida citrus processors for the seasons 1958-59 through 1963-64./Voe. Fla. St.
Hort. Soc. 77:278-281.
38
APPENDIX I
1. Sugar Content: The total amount of sugars present in a fruit, including sucrose, fructose,
and glucose, measured in grams per 100 grams (g/100g) or other appropriate units.
2. Banana (Musa spp.): A tropical fruit belonging to the Musa genus, typically elongated and
curved with a soft, starchy flesh and a sweet taste when ripe.
3. Pawpaw (Carica papaya): A tropical fruit from the Caricaceae family, characterized by its
5. Fructose: A monosaccharide, also known as fruit sugar, naturally occurring in fruits and
7. Ripening: The natural process by which fruits undergo changes in color, texture, and
used to separate, identify, and quantify compounds in a sample, including sugars in fruits.
39
10. Nutritionists: Professionals specializing in the study of nutrients and their impact on
11. Dieticians: Experts in the field of dietetics, responsible for planning and managing
dietary plans for individuals based on their health needs and conditions.
12. Nutritional Value: The content of essential nutrients, vitamins, minerals, and other
13. Total Soluble Solids (TSS): A measure of the dissolved solids in a fruit, including sugars,
14. Geographical Area: A defined region or specific location where the data collection and
study will be conducted, shaping the context and applicability of the research findings.
laboratory environment to analyze samples and obtain precise data for scientific
investigation.
40