Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PROPOSAL MONICA PATTIWAEL (201836031) Last
PROPOSAL MONICA PATTIWAEL (201836031) Last
2018-36-031
PATTIMURA UNIVERSITY
AMBON
2023
i
Table of Contents
CHAPTER I.......................................................................................................................1
1.1. Background of the Study..........................................................................................1
1.2. Problem statement.....................................................................................................4
1.3. Research Questions...................................................................................................5
1.4. Hypothesis of the Research.......................................................................................6
1.5. Research Purposes....................................................................................................6
1.6. Scope and Limitation of the Research......................................................................7
1.7. Significance of the Study..........................................................................................7
1.8. Definition of Key Terms...........................................................................................7
CHAPTER II......................................................................................................................8
2.1. Listening...................................................................................................................8
2.1.1 Listening in a Foreign Language........................................................................9
2.2. Listening Habit........................................................................................................10
2.3 Listening Interest.....................................................................................................12
2.4 Listening Achievement............................................................................................13
2.6. Conceptual Review.................................................................................................14
2.5. Empirical Review....................................................................................................16
CHAPTER III..................................................................................................................18
3.1. Research Methodology...........................................................................................18
3.2. Time and Place of the Research..............................................................................18
3.3 Population and Sample of Research........................................................................19
3.3.1 Population.........................................................................................................19
3.2.2 Sample...............................................................................................................19
3.4. Variables of the Study.............................................................................................20
3.5 Data Collection........................................................................................................21
3.5.1 Technique of Collecting Data...........................................................................21
3.5.1.1 Questionnaire.............................................................................................21
3.5.1.2 Grade Documentation................................................................................22
3.5.2 Validity and Reliability of the Questionnaire...................................................23
ii
3.5.2.1 Validity of the Questionnaire.....................................................................23
3.5.2.2 Reliability of the Questionnaire.................................................................23
3.6 Technique and Data Analysis..................................................................................24
3.6.1 Descriptive Statistical Analysis........................................................................24
3.6.2 Inferential Statistic Analysis.............................................................................25
References.........................................................................................................................28
iii
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
of the Study, Significance of the Study, Scope and Limitation, and Definition of
Key Terms.
and age (Noor, 2011). This is why English lesson has been integrated into the
Indonesian curriculum so that students can learn English. In the newest curricula,
students hoped to be able to listen, listen, speak, and write. The hurdle in learning
usually starts from the first stage which is listening (Zhou, 2021).
Listening habit as well ( Musa & Fojkar, 2019; Nurjanah et al., 2018; Putri &
Surlitasari Dewi, 2019; Suharja, 2020; Yunita & Jumiyanti, 2021) , Listening interest is
defined as listening done when students are outside the school environment.
as whether or not students like to listen in their spare time or at home. In this case,
it can be said simply that Listening habits synergize well with Listening interest.
As indicated that students with Listening habit involuntarily listen because of their
habit, while students with Listening interest can be simply defined as the fact that
1
In line with what has been discussed above, Listening habit and Listening
Wigfield & Cambria (2010) achievement is a threshold of certain level that which
is valuable to the one who pursue it. In other words, there is a measure of level
that should be passed by the students. When their Listening performance is higher
than the standard that has been decided, the result can be called as an
achievement. On the other hand when the Listening performance is below from
students who listen and have achievement in their Listening will more likely to
develop Listening habit because they feel rewarded by their activity (Rositasari &
Larasati, 2019).
establish a good Listening habit. Almost every material taught in the Study
Program is spoken in English, hence students are familiar with Listening materials
regularly coupled with a genuine interest in Listening, it will become part of their
being; a habit so to speak. One of the problems that students have in Listening is
not because the inability in Listening, but the lack of interest in Listening besides
music (Nurjanah et al., 2018; Rositasari & Larasati, 2019) . If students have an interest
in Listening, it will be easy for them to gain Listening habit. Listening habit can
Listening and they will develop Listening habit later on. Nevertheless, this
2
attitude should be reinforced in order to make this attitude remain positive and for
et al., 2018). The result shows that there is a positive relationship between those
two variables albeit small. The small positive relationship is caused by most of her
research participants have little to no Listening habit. Still, her research implies
that students with good Listening habit are more likely to have good Listening
achievement. The second one was conducted by (Rositasari & Larasati, 2019) in
Again, in this study, most of the participants have little to no Listening habit due
Besides the participants have little to no Listening habit, the most glaring
researchers (Nurjanah et al., 2018; Rositasari & Larasati, 2019). The researcher
thought that conducting such test is questionable in both reliability and accuracy
of the data obtained. The researcher thought that Listening achievement can be
seen accurately from the Listening class scores because the lecturer in Listening
achievement.
listening to English audio content reveals a notably positive attitude. Their habit
of listening regularly to various English audio materials, coupled with the use of
3
aids like transcripts and subtitles, signifies a genuine fondness for the activity.
and grammar rules. Beyond just listening, the student not only comprehends and
remembers information effectively but also skilfully applies learned language and
concepts in their own speaking and writing. Overall, the student displays a solid
through audio content. This result make the researcher is quite positive that
focused with correlation between college students’ Listening habit and Listening
researcher hoped that this research can add more to previous research by
(Latupono & Nikijuluw, 2022; Lewier & Nendissa, 2020) on Listening strategies. This
research hopefully can shed some light into students’ Listening habit and
struggle with listening, and their achievement in this skill often falls below their
4
potential. One factor that may affect students listening achievement is
activities that students engage in outside of the classroom. Students who have a
In addition to listening habit, another factor that may affect students listening
The findings of this study will provide valuable insights into the factors that
3. Does students listening habit mediate the relationship between their interest
in listening and their listening achievement?
5
1.4. Hypothesis of the Research
In this research, there were three hypotheses based on the research
question number 4, 5, and 6 that stated above before. These were;
1. There is a positive and significance relationship between students’
Listening habit and Listening achievement.
2. There is a positive and significance relationship between students’
Listening interest and Listening achievement.
3. There is a positive and significance relationship between students’
Listening habit and Listening interest toward their Listening
achievement.
6
1.6. Scope and Limitation of the Research
In order to avoid misunderstanding and clarify the problem, the researcher will
limit the research on:
1. The participants are third semester English Study Program students’ at
Pattimura University.
2. Researcher would collect the data about the correlation between students’
Listening habit, Listening interest, and Listening achievement.
3. The aspects that include on Listening habit are Listening materials,
frequency of Listening, time spent in Listening and purpose of Listening.
4. The aspects that include in Listening interest are the preferences of
Listening and appeal factors when it comes to Listening,
5. The place for this research is in Pattimura University.
students using new Curriculum, this study can be used as a feedback in Listening
Class. The result of this study is also expected to encourage college students’
awareness about the role of Listening habit toward their Listening achievement.
7
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
In this chapter, the researcher would like to discuss theories related to the
study. The main focuses in this chapter includes the explanation of several aspects
2.1. Listening
In Indonesia, teaching English is a way to cope with the current trend of
21st century skills. In which learning English is mandatory for applying for jobs
and schools. That is why Listening English materials has grown to be a popular
experience that connects people in a way far beyond space or time. Listening
many ways.
with audio; as individuals listen, they use their background knowledge along with
clues from the audio to construct meaning. This way Listening process go deeper
8
than just relies on surface information. In this Listening process, the brain will
construct new ideas by going through related information inside the brain;
materials listen.
academic language skill for all second and foreign language learners. Through
Listening, students can get and learn new information and become more
achievement because from Listening students can acquire other skills such as
Listening a simple audio first, after that they can listen a complex audio and they
can take their time to listen and relisten the audio (Pikulski, 2005). This should be
done in order to have good Listening skills and improving Listening fluency as an
important aspect for students. If students have Listening fluency, they will easily
listen without any difficulties, such as losing idea in the middle of Listening.
Listening fluency can students get when students practice Listening day by day.
That is also why the amount of Listening material can influence their Listening
9
2.2. Listening Habit
Listening habit can be acquired by listeners if they are frequently listen a
music with any reasons that they have. When they get used to listen and search for
a music to listen, Listening can become their habit. Listening habit can naturally
for a lifetime for children (Paping et al., 2021). It is also the reason why Listening
habit is conversely harder to form with older people like college students.
because the first music that they listen did not catch their interest. It is important
for the listener to find a music that draw their interest, so they will listen and
finish it. When the listener hooked into a music, they will try to find similar
musics or genres to listen and if it happens, Listening will instantly become their
habit.
Listening (Dewi et al., 2020; Nurjanah et al., 2018; Rindiyanti & Widyaningrum, 2022;
Zulianti, 2009). The frequency of Listening refers to the number of times that they
spent Listening in a week, while as time of Listening refers to how many hours
students spent when they are Listening. Types of Listening materials refer to
have good Listening habits usually listen a variety of Listening materials. When
10
Listening and speaking skills in both native and foreign language (Pinem, 2020;
how many times students listen in one week is determined by their Listening
habits. When students have good Listening habits, they tend to listen a lot in a
Good Listening habit can be a strong weapon for people to excel in their
life (Paping et al., 2021). When students listen a variety of musics, they spend
more time to listen, listen more than 5 times a week and find enjoyment in
is also considered to know students' Listening habits. When students listen for
pleasure and enjoyment, they tend to listen more and continue to listen because of
Listening (Zulianti, 2009). This Listening attitude will lead them to Listening
habit. Assuming that students form a positive attitude toward Listening EFL, they
will have good Listening habit. Conversely, when they have negative attitudes
toward Listening it is hard for them to acquire Listening habit. It will give a
negative impact if EFL students do not like to listen Listening materials in their
second language because from Listening EFL students will gain a lot of
vocabulary knowledge, grammar structure and information that important for EFL
students.
11
2.3 Listening Interest
Listening interest is Listening activity that students do outside of school
(Atmaja et al., 2017; Tsang, 2022). Students who have an interest in Listening do
this activity in their spare time. They tend to go to the library or just Listening in
their home. When someone has a Listening interest, it will show by the amount of
the musics that they listen and the frequency of Listening time. For English as
Foreign Language (EFL) students, the amount of materials that are spoken in their
second language is very important to determine their Listening interest. The early
Tsang, 2022). This early Listening activity experience will develop students’
students will gain confidence to listen more Listening materials in English and it
will lead them to have Listening interest as well. If students have poor Listening
experience in their earlier stages of Listening, they will lose interest to listen audio
that spoken in English Listening materials. They will find Listening is a boring
Students who have lost interest in Listening their second language will feel
frustrated if they should listen it and they will listen it because they have to, not
students’ Listening achievement. When students listen, they will gain more
information and it will widen their knowledge and broaden their perspective on
certain issues. Listening interest also has been linked to vocabulary development,
12
comprehension, fluency and intellectual development (Tsang, 2022). For EFL
for them to acquire their second language skills. Students who have Listening
interest and love to listen will be able to write well and have more ideas which
to learn (Tsang, 2022). When students lack interest in Listening they do not have a
(Safitri et al., 2021). So, when students show interest in Listening it is possible for
that students do in their Listening class. In other words, there is a measure of level
al., 2021; Safitri et al., 2021). So, in general, it shows that when students have
good Listening habits they will have good Listening achievement. Listening in
13
everyday activity that students do sometimes have different purposes, they can
listen for relaxation or for information. These activities will affect their academic
performance.
The result of educational problem is students will often fail their examination and
they will have low scores. It will be hard for them to obtain good scores and past
the standard especially for students that learn English particularly students that
(Zhou, 2021) shows that students who have poor Listening habit will have poor
listening habit and interest not only affect students in Listening but also in the
other skills like writing, reading, or speaking. The researcher conducts this study
with students’ Listening achievement because there an interest to know how their
Listening habit and interest affect their Listening achievement. Listening habit
and interest is utterly needed for students in any situations. For Listening habit
and interest will shape the way they think about the materials given by the
well.
14
Figure 2.1
Conceptual Framework of the study
15
2.5. Empirical Review
There are previous studies regarding college students’ Listening habit in
et al. (2018). The result shows that there is a positive relationship between those
two variables albeit small. The small positive relationship is caused by most of her
research participants have little to no Listening habit. Still, her research implies
that students with good Listening habit are more likely to have good Listening
achievement. The second one was conducted by Rositasari & Larasati (2018). In
the study they found that there is a small positive relationship between Listening
habit and Listening comprehension achievement. Again, in this study most of the
beside music. +
Besides the participants have little to no Listening habit, the most glaring
researchers (Nurjanah et al., 2018; Rositasari & Larasati, 2018). The researcher
thought that conducting such test is questionable in both reliability and accuracy
of the data obtained. The researcher thought that Listening achievement can be
seen accurately from the Listening class scores because the lecturer in Listening
achievement.
2022; Tsang, 2022) who stated that Listening interest was also a strong factor
when it comes to Listening habit. That was why in this study the Listening interest
16
was added as a variable alongside Listening habit to determine their relationship
Study Program in Pattimura University have better Listening habit based on his
(2020), because his research was more concerned with reading, not listening.
17
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
This chapter discusses all about the compositions of the research. It includes
Research Methodology, Time and Place of the Research, Population and Sample
relations among two or more variables (Lomax & Li, 2011). Additionally, Sukardi
(2003) stated that correlational study is used to conduct the research toward several
variables that have been judged to have an important role in achieving success in the
Furthermore, as this study was designed to identify the relationship between 3rd
semester students’ Listening habit and Listening interest toward their Listening
design was used to examine the relationship between those three variables.
18
3.3 Population and Sample of Research
3.3.1 Population
Population is an individual group that has one characteristic that
distinguish them from other groups Casteel and Bridier (2021). Population is
subject. In this case, the population of this study is the third semester
(Class A and B). Their age range is from 19-21 years old.
3.2.2 Sample
A sample can be defined as a subset of the individuals in a
and Wallen (1993) asserted that more than 30 sample sizes are eligible for
Noya (2016, p. 41) used Taro Yamane sampling technique with the
formula:
19
𝑁
𝑛=
𝑁. 𝑑2 + 1
Explanation:
n : total sample
N : total
population d2 :
Precision level
With the total Population (N) is 80 with the precision level decided (d2) is
𝑁 80 80
𝑛= = = = 44,44 = 44
𝑁. 𝑑2 + 1 (80). (0, 01) + 1 1,8
relationship between students’ Listening habit and their Listening interest toward
and Listening interest is put under the independent variable while as students’
20
Graphic 3.3 Constellation relationship between Listening habit and
Listening achievement.
rx1y
X1
rx1x2
Y
X2 rx2y
Where:
x1 : Listening Habit
x2 : Listening Interest
y : Listening Achievement
3.5.1.1 Questionnaire
Survey of Listening Habit and Listening Interest
follows:
Listening Habit
1. How often do you listen to English audio content (e.g.,
songs, podcasts, movies, TV shows, etc.)?
2. What types of English audio content do you typically
listen to?
3. Where do you typically listen to English audio content?
4. How long do you typically listen to English audio
content at a time?
21
5. How do you typically find English audio content to
listen to?
6. Do you have any favorite English audio content
creators or sources?
7. Do you listen to English audio content with others, or
do you usually listen by yourself?
8. Do you use any tools or resources to help you
understand English audio content (e.g., transcripts,
subtitles, dictionaries, etc.)?
9. How much do you enjoy listening to English audio
content on a scale of 1 to 5, with 1 being "not at all"
and 5 being "very much"?
10. How would you rate your English listening
comprehension skills on a scale of 1 to 5, with 1 being
"poor" and 5 being "excellent"?
Listening Interest
1. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content overall?
2. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content as a way to improve your English language
skills?
3. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content that features native English speakers?
4. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content that features topics that are relevant to your
academic or professional interests?
5. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content that is challenging and thought-provoking?
6. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content that is lighthearted and entertaining?
7. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content that is focused on a specific topic or genre
(e.g., news, current events, comedy, music, etc.)?
8. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content that is interactive or participatory (e.g., live
podcasts, radio shows, etc.)?
9. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content that is produced by professional organizations
or individuals?
10. How interested are you in listening to English audio
content that is produced by amateurs or hobbyists?
22
have actual experience and expertise in Listening class.
can help the researcher to collect data to answer the research questions.(
students Listening interest and Listening habit. Hale (2017, p.56) proposed
score of two different categories which measure the same content or skill
category in the questionnaire was calculated with SPSS version 25. The
23
test the consistency of the questionnaire as Gliem & Gliem (2003) stated
statistical analysis. The method of data analysis in this study was divided into
two: Descriptive Statistics Analysis used to identify the students’ Listening habit
and Research Question 5). The data analyses were explained as follows:
portray the English study program students’ Listening habit and Listening
interest.
24
3.6.2 Inferential Statistic Analysis
Myers and Well (2013) stated that Inferential Statistical Analysis
used by the researchers to generate the result of the study from the data of
the sample to the population of the research. Inferential statistical was used
to answer hypothesis made before by the researcher, in this case to test the
statistics used for this study were Pearson Product Moment Formula and
test the 1st and 2nd hypotheses while as Multiple Correlation Formula used
where:
r : pearson r correlation coefficient
N : number of value in each data set
𝛴𝑥𝑦 : sum of the products of paired scores
𝛴𝑥 : sum of students’ Listening habit
𝛴𝑦 : sum of students’ Listening achievement
𝛴 𝑥2 : sum of squared students’ Listening habit
𝛴 𝑦2 : sum of squared students’ Listening achievement
25
where:
r : pearson r correlation coefficient
N : number of value in each data set
𝛴𝑥𝑦 : sum of the products of paired scores
𝛴𝑥 : sum of students’ Listening interest
𝛴𝑦 : sum of students’ Listening achievement
𝛴 𝑥2 : sum of squared students’ Listening interest
2
𝛴𝑦 : sum of squared students’ Listening achievement
where:
R : multiple correlation coefficients
ry.x1 : correlation between Listening habit with Listening interest
ry.x2 : correlation between Listening habit with Listening achievement
rx1.x2 : correlation between interest with Listening achievement
to +1. The correlation +1 means that both variables have a positive linear
straight line). This implies that the increase of x variable will be followed
26
Furthermore, the criteria of correlation coefficient were also
was calculated in SPSS version 25 based on the criteria (Sarwono, 2009) which
are: the H0 is rejected if the significant value is < 0.05 while the H0 is accepted if
the significance value is > 0.05, then if in SPSS output has two asterisk (**) the
Before analyzing the data, the normality and linearity of the data must be
tested by SPSS version 25. The distribution of the data must be done first to make
sure that the data was normally distributed. The normality test was calculated with
Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (or called Lilliefors test) with the standard significant
value must be higher than 0.05 indicating normal distribution and the linearity
was tested using Test for Linearity with the standard of significant value must be
27
References:
. W., S., B., & . E. (2019). The Correlation Between Listening Habit to English Song and
Vocabulary Mastery. Journal of English Education and Teaching, 3(3).
https://doi.org/10.33369/jeet.3.3.287-298
Atmaja, D. A. D., Ngadiso, N., & Setyaningsih, E. (2017). Relationship Between Interest
in Listening English Songs, Vocabulary Mastery Toward Listening Skill. English
Education, 5(2). https://doi.org/10.20961/eed.v5i2.36058
Cahape, P., & Howley, C. B. (1992). Indian Nations At Risk: Listening to the People.
Summaries of Papers Commissioned by the Indian Nations At Risk Task Force of
the US Department of Education.
Clark, L. A., & Watson, D. (2019). Constructing validity: New developments in creating
objective measuring instruments. Psychological assessment, 31(12), 1412.
de Noya, B. A., Colmenares, C., Díaz-Bello, Z., Ruiz-Guevara, R., Medina, K., Muñoz-
Calderón, A., ... & Abate, T. (2016). Orally-transmitted Chagas disease:
epidemiological, clinical, serological and molecular outcomes of a school
microepidemic in Chichiriviche de la Costa, Venezuela. Parasite epidemiology
and control, 1(2), 188-198.
Dewi, S. K., Sukarni, S., & Tusino, T. (2020). The Influence of Students’ Habit of
Listening to English Songs on Their Pronunciation Ability. Scripta : English
Department Journal, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.37729/scripta.v7i2.827
Gliem, J. A., & Gliem, R. R. (2003). Calculating, interpreting, and reporting Cronbach’s
alpha reliability coefficient for Likert-type scales. Midwest Research-to-Practice
Conference in Adult, Continuing, and Community Education.
28
Latupono, F., & Nikijuluw, R. (2022). The Importance of Teaching Listening Strategies
in English Language Context. MATAI: International Journal of Language
Education, 3(1). https://doi.org/10.30598/matail.v2i2.5935
Lomax, H., Fink, J., Singh, N., & High, C. (2011). The politics of performance:
Methodological challenges of researching children’s experiences of childhood
through the lens of participatory video. International Journal of Social
Research Methodology, 14(3), 231-243.
Myers, J. L., Well, A. D., & Lorch Jr, R. F. (2013). Research design and
statistical analysis. Routledge.
Musa, N. N., Mihajlovski, Z., & Fojkar, M. D. (2022). The Correlation Between
Elementary Students’ English Listening Skills and Their Interest in and Views on
Learning English. New Educational Review, 69.
https://doi.org/10.15804/tner.2022.69.3.11
Musadiq, A., Kamaluddin, & Mursalim. (2021). Lyrics Training Website; Does it Have
an Effect on Students’ Listening Achievement? Journal of Teaching of English,
6(2).
Noor, Z., & Daulay, S. H. (2023). Does the “Words of Affirmation” English Podcast
Have Any Positive Influence on Students' Listening Skills?. Lectura: Jurnal
Pendidikan, 14(2), 198-208
Nurjanah, N., Miranti, I., & Dwiastuty, N. (2018). The Correlation Between Students’
Habit In Listening Song And Students’ English Listening Skill. DEIKSIS, 10(01).
https://doi.org/10.30998/deiksis.v10i01.2125
Paping, D. E., Vroegop, J. L., Koenraads, S. P. C., le Clercq, C. M. P., Goedegebure, A.,
Baatenburg de Jong, R. J., & van der Schroeff, M. P. (2021). A smartphone
application to objectively monitor music listening habits in adolescents: Personal
listening device usage and the accuracy of self-reported listening habits. Journal
of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery, 50(1).
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40463- 020-00488-5
29
Pinem, Y. A. (2020). THE CORRELATION BETWEEN LISTENING AND SPEAKING
AMONG HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS. ELTICS : Journal of English
Language Teaching and English Linguistics, 1(1).
https://doi.org/10.31316/eltics.v1i1.435
Rindiyanti, R., & Widyaningrum, W. (2022). The Effect of English Listening Habit
Towards Vocabulary Mastery. JEdu: Journal of English Education, 2(1).
https://doi.org/10.30998/jedu.v2i1.6299
Rositasari, T., & Larasati, F. (2019). The Correlation Between Students’ Habit In
Watching English Movie And Listening Achievement (By Fourth Semester
Students Of Universitas Muhammadiyah Palembang). English Community Journal,
3(2).
Safitri, M., Wulyani, A. N., & Suharyadi, S. (2021). The correlation between students’
reading and listening score in a standardized test of TOEFL. Jurnal Penelitian
Dan Pengkajian Ilmu Pendidikan: E-Saintika, 5(2).
https://doi.org/10.36312/esaintika.v5i2.472
Sinta, N. K., Murtini, N. M. W., & ... (2021). The Correlation between Listening English
Songs Habit with Speaking Achievement of the Tenth Grade Students of SMK
SMSR Ubud in Academic Year 2020 …. Academic Journal on …, 1(April).
Yunita, W., & Jumiyanti, J. (2021). Exploring the Correlation Between Students’ Interest
in Listening and Listening Comprehension in English Context. Utamax : Journal of
Ultimate Research and Trends in Education, 2(3).
https://doi.org/10.31849/utamax.v2i3.6162
30
Zhou, Z. (2021). On college students’ listening anxiety and listening strategy. Theory
and Practice in Language Studies, 11(11). https://doi.org/10.17507/TPLS.1111.15
31
APPENDIX
No Category Checklist
1 Listening Habit
2 Listening Interest
Additional Observations
Does the student have any difficulty understanding the Not Really
English audio content?
Does the student become distracted when listening to
32
3 English audio content? No
Does the student seem to learn and retain information
from the English audio content they are listening to? Yes
Does the student use the language and concepts they learn
from English audio content in their own speaking and Yes
writing?
What are some things that would make the student more Content of the music,
likely to listen to English audio content?
movie or and audio
Overall Observation
33