Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Motor Competence Assessment in Young Children: Convergent Validity Between The KTK and MOT 4-6 Test Batteries
Motor Competence Assessment in Young Children: Convergent Validity Between The KTK and MOT 4-6 Test Batteries
net/publication/267455465
CITATIONS READS
0 1,432
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Farid Bardid on 29 July 2015.
[2] Spengler, et al. A cluster-analytic approach towards multidimen- Introduction Among the factors influencing school sports today,
sional health-related behaviors in adolescents: the MoMo-Study. one of the most important is the socialisation process, which
BMC Public Health 2012;12. involves various social agents such as the family, school, peers,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scispo.2014.08.035 etc., and continues to transmit a considerable number of stereo-
typed behaviours and attitudes that impede participant equality
and models of best practice with children [1,2].
P15
Experience This analysis was based on a review of various theo-
Gender stereotypes as a determinant retical and empirical perspectives reported in the literature, which
of participation in sports in childhood indicated that the process of socialisation in sports exerts a strong
C. Tuero 1,∗ , R. González-Boto 2 , J. Espartero 1 , B. Zapico 1 influence on behavioral differences and the development of iden-
1 Faculty Physical Activity Sciences and Sport. University of León, tity at this age (between 12 and 13 years). Moreover, in girls, this
Spain process often leads to a conflict of roles between femininity and
2 León City Council, Spain participation in sport. Thus, sport seems to the maintenance of
∗ Corresponding author. inequality and gender stereotypes from the beginning of sports par-
ticipation. In fact, the cultural traits that are transmitted continue
Introduction Even today, negative stereotypes and patterns of
to steer boys and girls towards sports that are associated more with
inequality still exist that determine women’s participation in sports.
masculinity or femininity, respectively.
In the case of girls, adherence to the principle of equality in sports
Critical analysis Sport is also a social agent that can be used as a
during schooling gradually declines from preadolescence onwards.
force for change in gender relations, if multisport activities are pro-
The objective of this study was to analyse children’s participation
moted in which skills and abilities are developed according to the
in municipal sports schools and determine whether it reflected the
person rather than to his or her sex. Action is also needed in the
gender stereotypes reported in the specialist literature [1—3].
immediate environment, so that socialisation in terms of role learn-
Methods Using a qualitative approach, the specialist literature
ing does not entail a disadvantage when choosing and participating
was reviewed to identify traits associated with male sports activ-
in sports.
ities (strength, stamina, more active, aggressive, risk) and female
Conclusions Multisports activities can propose the development
sports activities (rhythm, expression, elasticity, flexibility, coordi-
of several skills and abilities focusing on the person needs rather
nation). The sample consisted of children (n = 3506) participating in
than to his/her sex. If such activities are promoted, sports can
the various sports activities offered by the Municipal Sports Schools
become a social agent that can be used as an agent for change in
in the 2012/2013 season and aimed at children of both sexes aged
gender relationships. To carry out a more equality peer socialization
7—11 years. A descriptive statistical analysis was performed.
is very important to act in the family and educational contexts.
Results Overall participation in sports was higher among boys
Keywords Socialisation process; School sport; Gender inequality
(51.5%) than girls (48.5%). The highest rates of participation were
observed in activities associated with male traits (handball 72.6%, Disclosure of interest The authors have not supplied their decla-
futsal 91.3%, hockey 88.9%, Leon wrestling 57.9%, rugby 66.7%), ration of conflict of interest.
compared with those in which the female traits described in the References
literature predominated (rhythmic and artistic gymnastics 98.8% [1] Ervilla R. Agentes socializadores, educación y deporte en edad
— 81.8%, volleyball 94.6%). However, the data also revealed that escolar. Granada: Ada Book; 2009.
female participation was higher in activities such as athletics and [2] Molina G. Sociología del fenómeno deportivo. Claves para
basketball. prácticas responsables sociales y educativas. Madrid: Librerías-
Conclusions From infancy, gender role socialisation and social Deportivas Esteban Sanz; 2013.
and cultural pressures inculcate socially acceptable gender prac- http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scispo.2014.08.037
tices. Coeducation and the involvement of various social agents
would enhance adherence to sport, especially among girls.
Keywords Sport in childhood; Participation; Gender stereotypes
sports and other physical activities. In view of the decreasing lev- olympiques, cow-boys, etc.). Toutes les activités font référence à
els of physical activity and motor skills in children over the past la thématique et comporte un défi motivant.
decades, an appropriate assessment and monitoring of motor com- Analyse critique L’expérimentation a été réalisée auprès d’une
petence in early childhood is invaluable, for both research and centaine d’enfants d’une même école. L’intérêt des parents
practice [1]. The purpose of this study was to investigate the con- (inscriptions) et l’évolution motrice des enfants semblent confir-
vergent validity between two motor competence assessment tools: mer l’efficacité du programme « Apprenti-moteur ». La direction de
the KörperkoordiantionsTest für Kinder (KTK) and the Motoriktest l’école l’a même inscrit dans son plan de réussite scolaire. Cepen-
fûr Vier- bis Sechsjährige Kinder (MOT 4-6). dant, la formation des animateurs est essentielle pour s’assurer du
Methods Five hundred and thirty 5- and 6-year-old children (277 succès d’un tel programme.
♂ and 253 ♀; mean age = 5.95; SD = 0.57) were tested by practiced Conclusions Actuellement, des perspectives de développement
assessors on the KTK and MOT 4-6 during the same day. From the sont en cours pour implanter ce programme dans les écoles franco-
raw scores, a Motor Quotient was calculated based on normative phones ayant des classes de préscolaire.
data of the KTK and MOT 4-6. Mots clés Habiletés motrices fondamentales ; Programme
Results A Pearson correlation demonstrated a moderately strong parascolaire
positive association between KTK Motor Quotient and MOT 4-6 Motor
Déclaration d’intérêts L’auteur n’a pas transmis de déclarations
Quotient (r = 0.605). Crosstabs showed a fair level of agreement
de conflits d’intérêts.
between the two tests (K = 0.313; P < 0.001).
Conclusion These findings provide some but limited evidence of http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scispo.2014.08.039
convergent validity between KTK and MOT 4-6. The explanation for
the lack of stronger associations probably lies in the different con- P19
cepts that are evaluated in each test battery. The implication of Studies using the
this moderate level of agreement between KTK and MOT 4-6, is that körperkoordinationstest für (ktk): A
practitioners and/or clinicians should be aware of possible categori-
sation errors when using the KTK or MOT 4-6 test to detect motor
review
impairments. S. Iivonen ∗ , A. Sääkslahti , A. Laukkanen
Keywords Motor competence; Test battery; Validity University of Jyväskylä, Department of Sport Sciences, Finland
∗ Corresponding author.
Disclosure of interest The authors have not supplied their decla-
Introduction When encouraging children to active lifestyle, a
ration of conflict of interest.
suitable test for the gross motor coordination, specifically mas-
Reference
tering of fundamental motor skills, is of great use. To evaluate
[1] Fransen, et al. Convergent and discriminant validity between
and choose a suitable test for different purposes it is important
the KTK and BOT-2 short form testing batteries for motor com-
to know its usage in different settings. The Körperkoordinationstest
petence. Res Develop Disab 2014;35:1375—83.
für Kinder (KTK) [1] is a test, which mainly focuses on gross motor
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scispo.2014.08.038 coordination of both normal and impaired children. The KTK is quite
simple and quick to administer, the same items cover all age groups
(5—15 years). This study aims to introduce the KTK’s usage on a basis
P18
of literature review. Specifically, the aim is to extract information
« Apprenti-moteur » : un programme on KTK’s pros, cons and suggestions to help evaluate its suitability
québécois de littératie physique de to different purposes.
niveau parascolaire Methods To gather articles reporting on the KTK we made a
J. Beaulieu systematic search from MEDLINE (ProQuest), PsycINFO (ProQuest),
A+ ACTION, Consultant en motricité et en pédagogie sportive, SPORTDiscus with Full Text (EBSCO), PubMed (Medline) and Web of
Canada Science - WoS. Inclusion criteria were:
— a search term existed in the title or abstract;
Introduction Au Québec, les enfants d’âge préscolaire (mater- — the ‘‘KTK’’ did not refer something else than Körperkoordinations
nelle 5 ans) ont en moyenne 30 minutes d’éducation physique et à test;
la santé (ÉPS) par cycle. La balance du temps de stimulation motrice — published in English/German peer reviewed journal.
est sous la responsabilité de la titulaire de classe et du service de Results We identified 192 potential titles. After duplicates
garde scolaire. Toutefois, la motricité globale est souvent délaissée removal 42 articles (13 German) satisfied the criteria. The articles,
chez les intervenantes du préscolaire pour plusieurs raisons (forma- published 1975—2013, reported 8 different designs taking place in
tion, surprotection, environnement, culture de la motricité fine, jeu 11 countries with 17—7175 participants (age range 5—26 years). The
libre, etc.). À notre connaissance, il n’existerait pas, actuellement articles fell into 6 categories according to purposes for which the
dans les écoles du Québec, de programme de littératie physique de KTK was used in normal or special populations. The KTK’s use in
niveau parascolaire adapté pour les tout-petits. different settings, pros, cons, and suitability based on the authors’
Structure mise en place Pour pallier à ce manquement, la judgments will be presented.
firme A+ Action a développé le programme « Apprenti-moteur ». Conclusions Results will be scrutinized and some key points will
Ce programme parascolaire développe la littératie physique par les be formulated to generate critical discussion.
habiletés motrices fondamentales (courir, sauter, gambader, rouler, Keywords Motor coordination; Test; Review
botter, lancer, attraper, etc.). « Apprenti-moteur » est basé sur une
approche ludique qui cible 23 habiletés motrices fondamentales. Disclosure of interest The authors have not supplied their decla-
Ces habiletés sont réparties à travers 22 séances pour une moyenne ration of conflict of interest.
de 13 habiletés stimulées par séance. Le programme est divisé Reference
en trois sessions pendant l’année scolaire à raison d’une séance [1] Kiphard EJ, Schilling F. Körperkoordinationstest für Kinder KTK.
par semaine d’une durée de 50 minutes. Chaque séance est liée à Weinheim: Beltz; 1974.
une thématique symbolique (pirates, cirque, conte classique, jeux http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scispo.2014.08.040