Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 67

ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

First of all, I am grateful to my God and advisor, Dr TASEW SHEDAGA for his valuable
advice, tolerance and professional guidance to accomplish my thesis. His consideration and
encouragement have inspired and helped me to put my best efforts in the study. I would like
to extend my genuine thanks to my mother, friends, without them assistance the study would
not have been realized. Also I would like to acknowledge all my informants- principals and
teachers of Gibson school system, Bole sub city, Addis Ababa.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page i


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

ACRONOMYS/ABREVIATION
BA/BSC:-Bachelor degree of art/Science

Phd :- Doctor of Philosophy

MA/MSC:- Master degree of art/Science

Ads:- Administrative staff

ACS:- Academic staff

NACS:- Non Academic staff

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page ii


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

DECLARATION
I Misgana Yacob, the under signed, declare that this research proposal entitled
“ASSESSEMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE IN CASE OF GIBSON
SCHOOL SYSTEM” is my original work. I have undertaken the research work
independently with the guidance and support of the research advisor. This study has not been
submitted for any degree or diploma program in this or any other institutions and that all
sources of materials used for the research has been duly acknowledged.
Declared by
Name _______________________
Signature: ____________________
Department ___________________
Date _______________________

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page iii


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

TABLE PAGE
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS....................................................................................................................i
ACRONOMYS/ABREVIATION..........................................................................................................ii
DECLARATION..................................................................................................................................iii
ABSTRACT..........................................................................................................................................1
CHAPTER ONE....................................................................................................................................3
1. INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................................3
1.1. Background of the Study............................................................................................................3
1.1.2. Organizational Back Ground...............................................................................................4
1.2. Statement of the Problem............................................................................................................5
1.2. Objectives of the Study...............................................................................................................8
1.2.1 General Objective.................................................................................................................8
1.2.2. Specific Objectives..............................................................................................................8
1.3 Significance of the Study.............................................................................................................8
1.4 Delimitation of the Study.............................................................................................................8
1.5 Definition of Terms.....................................................................................................................9
1.6 Limitation of the study.................................................................................................................9
CHAPTER TWO.................................................................................................................................10
2. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE.......................................................................................10
2.1. Meaning and Nature of Conflict...............................................................................................10
2.2 Views of Conflicts.....................................................................................................................10
2.3 Constructive Views of Conflict..................................................................................................10
2.5 Types of Conflict.......................................................................................................................11
2.6 .The Conflict Process.................................................................................................................12
2.7. Sources of Conflicts..................................................................................................................13
2.9. Conflict Resolution Styles........................................................................................................15
2.10. Conflict Management Strategies.............................................................................................17
2.10.1. Coordination Strategies for Avoiding Intergroup Conflict Rules and Procedures............17
2.11. Conflict Outcomes..................................................................................................................19
2.12. Structural Approaches to Conflict Management.....................................................................21
CHAPTER THREE.............................................................................................................................23
3. METHDOLOGY AND RESEARCH DESIGN...............................................................................23
3.1. Research Design and Research Approach.................................................................................23
3.2. Population, Sample Size and Sampling Techniques.................................................................23

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page iv


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

3.2.1 Target Population................................................................................................................23


3.2.2. Sample Size.......................................................................................................................23
3.2.3. Sampling Techniques.........................................................................................................24
3.3. Data Types and Sources............................................................................................................24
3.3.1. Primary data.......................................................................................................................24
3.3.2. Secondary data...................................................................................................................24
3.4. Method of Data Collection........................................................................................................24
3.5. Data Analysis Methods.............................................................................................................25
CHAPTER FOUR...............................................................................................................................26
4. DATA ANALYSIS AND PRESENTATION..................................................................................26
4.1 Introduction...............................................................................................................................26
4.2 Analysis and Presentation of Data Gathered from Administrative Staff....................................26
4.2.1 General Bio Data of Respondents.......................................................................................26
4.2.2 Existence of Conflict and Perception on Conflict...............................................................29
4.2.3 Frequency of Conflict in an Organization and Parties Involved in it..................................32
4.2.4 The Way an Administrative Staff Get Information about Existence of Conflict.................33
4.2.5 Sources of Conflict.............................................................................................................34
4.2.6 Conflict Outcomes..............................................................................................................35
4.2.7 Conflict Management Styles...............................................................................................37
4.2.8 Conflict Management Practice of the Organization............................................................37
4.2.9 Training on Conflict Management......................................................................................38
4.2.10 Effect of Gender on Conflict Management.......................................................................38
4.3 Analysis and Presentation of Information Gathered from Academic and Non Academic Staff. 39
4.3.1 General Bio Data of Respondents.......................................................................................39
4.3.2 Conflict Existence...............................................................................................................41
4.3.3 Frequency of Conflict and Parties Involved in it in the Organization.................................44
4.3.4. The Way Academic and Nonacademic Staff Members Obtain Information about an
Existence of Conflict...................................................................................................................45
4.3.5 Conflict Sources..................................................................................................................45
4.3.6. Conflict Outcomes.............................................................................................................46
4.3.7. Style of Conflict Management...........................................................................................46
4.3.8 The Institution’s Conflict Management Practice.................................................................47
4.3.9 Training on Issues Related to Conflict................................................................................47
4.3.10 Gender Effect on Conflict.................................................................................................48

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page v


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

CHAPTER FIVE.................................................................................................................................49
5. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS....................................................49
5.1 Summary..............................................................................................................................49
5.2 Conclusions.........................................................................................................................50
5.3 Recommendations.....................................................................................................................51
REFERENCE..................................................................................................................................54
APPENDIX.........................................................................................................................................55
APPROVAL SHEET...........................................................................................................................59

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page vi


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

LIST OF TABLE
Table 1 profile of respondents from Administrative staff.......................................................26
Table 2-Educational and marital status....................................................................................27
Table 3 Years of experience of respondents from administrative staff...................................28
Table 4-existence of conflict (response of administrative staff)..............................................29
Table 5- Perception on conflict (response of Administrative staff..........................................31
Table 6 Frequency of conflict in the organization and parties involved in it..........................33
Table 7 The way administrative staff gets information about existence of conflict...............34
Table 8 Conflict out comes......................................................................................................36
Table 9. Conflict management styles.......................................................................................37
Table 10. Effect of gender on conflict management................................................................39
Table 11- General Bio-data of respondents (from Academic and Non academic staff)........39
Table 12 Educational marital status of respondents from academic and non academic staff..40
Table 13.Years of experience of respondents from academic and Nonacademic staff............41
Table 14- Conflict existence (response from Academic staff and Non Academic staff).........42
Table 15- perception on conflict (response from Academic and Non Academic staff)...........43
Table 16. Frequency of Conflict and Parties Involved in it in the Organization.....................44
Table 17.The way academic and non academic staff members obtain information about an
existence of Conflict................................................................................................................45
Table 18 .Conflict Outcomes...................................................................................................46
Table 19 Conflict management styles......................................................................................47
Table 20. Gender effect on conflict..........................................................................................48

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page vii


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1. The conflict process ………………………………12
Figure 2 Conflict causes, process and outcome……………. 20
Figure 3 - structural approach to conflict management……. 21

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page viii


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

ABSTRACT

Conflict is the situation in which one party perceives that its interests are being opposed or
negatively affected by another party which is in the same group, in another group, in
the same organization or in another organization. Accordingly, we can classify those conflicts
in to: intra group conflict, intergroup conflict, intra organizational conflict and inter
organizational conflict. There is also other type of conflict which happens within one self and
between peoples who came from different cultures, which are called intrapersonal conflict
and cross cultural conflict respectively.
The fact that individuals have different backgrounds, point of views, values, needs,
personalities and other additional realities prevailing in an organizational environment. This
made an organization a place where conflict is common. Regardless of the quality of a
manger’s leadership or his or her style of management and regardless of how well planned
the organizational structure is, conflicts will occasionally arise within an organization. These
conflicts can be functional or dysfunctional in nature. This study is conducted on Gibson
School System under a title of “Assessment of Conflict Management Practice”. The major
problems which initiate this research are: the prevalence of conflict between several parties in
the school, problem on perception of conflict and the unsatisfactory of the conflict
management system of the institution. The outcomes of all these problems made conflict an
issue at Gibson School System.
The major objectives of the research are: Assessing the conflict resolution practice of
Gibson School System, assessing the major sources of conflict in the organization,
assessing the attitudes that an employees of the organization have towards conflict and
forwarding possible solutions for the problems identified from the collected and analyzed
data.

The major limitations faced in conducting this research are: Some respondents did not give
the required full information because of the fear that they have on this area and
insufficiency of time that is provided to conduct this research. Both primary and secondary
sources of information are used in collecting the data. Questionnaires are distributed to the
institution’s academic, non academic and administrative staff members and the information
gathered is analyzed accordingly. According to the analysis made, there is a wide range of

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 1


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

conflict in the organization, a problem of conflict perception is also observed but, there is no
special training and orientation prepared to change this perception. The conflict management
practice of the organization is found to be poor. There is also a tendency to relate the
effectiveness in conflict management to gender difference. To avoid the above problems; the
organization should prepare several occasions in which the employees can develop the
relationship between them, a special training and orientation program should be prepared in
order to create better grasping on conflict related issues. Additionally, several points are
forwarded as a recommendation to solve the problems observed.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 2


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

CHAPTER ONE
1. INTRODUCTION

1.1. Background of the Study


The ideas to be focused in this research are conflict management practices. According to
cook and Hunsalker (2001:374). Conflict is a disagreement between two or more parties for
example individuals, groups, departments, organizations, countries who perceive that they
have incompatible concerns. Conflicts exist when ever an action by one party is perceived as
prevention or interfering with the goals needs or actions of another party. Some
organizational conflict involves disagreement on issues such as allocation of resources,
organizational procedures and policies, nature of assignments and distribution of benefits and
rewards etc. It is stated by Ivancvich, (1987:307). Conflict at its worst can lead to
unnecessary stress, blockage in communication, lack of cooperation, increase sense of
distrust and reduce organizational effectiveness. But it may not be necessary to eliminate all
conflicts as they are not always harmful. In fact conflict can contribute in positive way to
organizational creativity and productivity. Serious conflicts can be destructive, hinder
activities, and affect the healthy exchange of ideas and information. Conflict highly affects
the effectiveness of the organization if it is not resolved properly. In view of this, Kumar
(2001:438) States that continuing conflict between superiors and subordinates may adversely
affect the performance of both parts but on the other hand conflict could be helpful and
constructive if it is managed properly. Therefore, this study attempts to assess conflict
management practices between employees and management. It focuses on the causes of
conflict, how they can be resolved and how labor and management can work in a cooperative
spirit for effective work.

Conflict management refers to the way of handling disagreement, grievances, disputes which
arises between individuals, groups and organizational. Individual conflict exists between
people having different styles of communication behavior, ambition, political and or religious
views and different cultural backgrounds. A group conflict emphasizes the things that make
their group better from other group. Such as Mistreatment of interests, unfair distribution of
work, different values and perceptions and lack of teamwork. (Available at http://www
onDec.23, 2010)

As an organization is a state of universe having employees with different behavior,


perception, intellectual and culture, interpersonal conflict exists as usual phenomena on the

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 3


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

ground of common task interest. Therefore, this study will focus on Organizational conflict
handling in Gibson school system.

1.1.2. Organizational Back Ground


Many challenges arise from conflicts, which are inevitable in any school set up including
tertiary institutions. Conflict culminates in friction, disagreement or discord arising within a
group when the belief or actions of one or more members of the group are either resisted by
or unacceptable to one or more members of another group. The problems associated with
conflict can be found at both ends of school managers, teachers and even throughout the
educational hierarchical structure (Sergiovanni and Starrat, 1987). Conflict between peoples a
common problem in schools and adversely affects the involved students as well as affecting
the schools from attaining their desired outcomes (goals).

The ability to successfully minimize and resolve conflict is an important skill for school
administrators to develop. Since conflict is inevitable in schools, administrators must be
prepared to deal with it. There are different strategies and methods suggested by the literature
to manage the conflicts in the schools. An educational institution is a heterogeneous assembly
of youths and adults from different family, cultural, religious, ethnic and socio-economic
backgrounds. The management of a school like any human organization is more complex
than the management of business due to the tendency of the “managed” to accept or resist a
managerial process.
Conflict is a natural and inevitable phenomenon in the human society. The theme of conflict
has attracted the attention of the human mind from time immemorial. Over the years, the
issue of conflict is treated by authors in all of the social sciences. But it received different
degrees of emphasis from social scientists during various periods of history (Rahim, 2001).
According to (Schellenberg 1996), most of the contributions to the study of social conflict
came from philosophy and sociology, while a few contributions came from other disciplines,
such as biological science.

In recent years, there is renewed interest and significant changes in the study of conflict in
social and organizational contexts. According to Thompson (1998), the formation of the
“International Association of Conflict Management” to encourage research, teaching, and
training and development on organizational conflict and the publication of the “International
Journal of Management” confirms this renewed interest. Furthermore, since the recent past, a
number of universities across the globe have shown great interest in teaching and research on
social and organizational conflicts (Rahim, 2001).

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 4


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Vision
The vision of Gibson school system is to be a highly recognized institution of higher learning
nationally as well as internationally identified by its quality education, research output,
competence of graduates, and fulfillment of social responsibilities with maximum devotion.
Mission
Gibson school system, being a privately owned higher and lower learning institution, has the
following missions to accomplish:

 Provide quality higher education at all levels and at affordable price through regular,
continuing (extension) and distance education modes so as to produce competent
professionals who can support the development endeavor of the country.
 Undertake scientific research that helps to solve the socio-economic problems of the
country and that can also add new values & knowledge to the society.
 Render consultancy and short term training services to businesses, government and
non government organizations to help them accomplish their objectives.
 Render various community services to fulfill social responsibilities which are
expected of it as an academic institution.
Values
Gibson school system believes in the paramount importance of promoting the following
values at the institution level and among the staff of the college:
1. Equal opportunity
2. Honesty Transparency
3. Healthy academic environment
4. Gender equality Respect to people (society) and Impartiality (A broacher prepared by
Gibson school system, 2015, p. 4)
1.2. Statement of the Problem
Conflict is an important to an organization in increasing its performance as well as employees
productivity. Conflict, particularly in teaching learning process, where the role of teachers is
crucial for the transfer of knowledge should be managed properly before it leads to undesired
directions. Whenever, there is conflict workers tend to miss more work, lose commitment,
aggravate turnover.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 5


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

This study will try to assess and find out the causes of conflict that has happened in
Gibson school system. In recent years, there is renewed interest and significant changes in the
study of conflict in social and organizational contexts. According to Thompson (1998), the
formation of the “International Association of Conflict Management” to encourage research,
teaching, and training and development on organizational conflict and the publication of the
“International Journal of Management” confirms this renewed interest. Furthermore, since the
recent past, a number of universities across the globe have shown great interest in teaching
and research on social and organizational conflicts (Rahim, 2001).
This school is an institution composed of employees with different interest and unique
characteristics shaped by cultural, social, environmental and educational background, under
similar institutional goals and objectives. These heterogeneous factors leads to affect the
interaction between and or among individuals and groups in the organization while
performing their daily activity. Consequently, this situation affects the organizations’
performance.
The factors of conflict between teachers and educational managers on secondary schools of
Addis Ababa, (Gebretensay 2002), he concluded that poor communication styles, out-dated
rules, and inefficiency of educational managers were some of the sources of conflict. A study
on teacher-principal conflicts in secondary schools of the Amhara Regional state, (Gonie
1998). In his conclusion, he indicated that problems of performance evaluation and career
development plan were the major causes of conflict. Depending on the above mentioned
problems, the student researcher will try to assess the major factors that contribute for
conflicts in school system and to forward possible solutions that help to alleviate the school’s
problem in handling the conflict.
The fact that individuals have different backgrounds, point of views, values, needs,
personalities and other additional realities prevailing in an organizational environment made
an organization a battle in which conflict is common. Regardless of the quality of a manger’s
leadership or his or her style of management and regardless of how well planned the
organizational structure is, conflicts will occasionally arise within an organization.
In fact every organization undergoes a certain amount of internal conflict that must be
recognized and dealt with in a positive fashion if the organization is to prosper. In neither
case, if the organization is tends to recognize all the conflicts encountered in a negative way,
it will most likely lose some of the benefits that it can obtain. It may be said that it is the
mismanagement of conflict rather than conflict itself that causes real trouble in an

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 6


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

organization. Management’s task is to recognize conflict whenever it occurs and use it


whenever possible to secure the organization’s best advantage.
With this regard, Gibson school system encountered several conflicts since its existence
which are existed between different parties in the institution. As far as the institution’s
conflict history is concerned, several individuals who were its employees were resigned from
it because of the conflict that they confronted with different parties in the organization.
Currently also, there are several dysfunctional conflicts which are observed between several
parties in the organization. For instance frequent conflicts are being observed between
academic staff members of the institution and campus deans.
There is also a conflict which is often observed between the academic staff members with the
rest of the institution’s administrative staffs like personnel and finance department heads. The
non academic staff members of the organization are also faced several conflicts in between
themselves and with administrative and academic staff members of the organization because
of existence of several sources of conflict and a wide range of conflict of interest between
these parties. Because of this fact, employees of an organization are being less committed to
their responsibilities, there is also an increasing rate of turnover, there is low level of
worker’s job satisfaction …etc. this in turn creates some gap in quality service provision and
the overall effectiveness of the organization, On the other hand, there is a tendency to
recognize all conflicts encountered in an organization as a destructive conflict.
There is also failure to apply an appropriate style or mechanism of conflict management to
solve the conflicts. These problems made conflict management an issue at Gibson school
system. To this end, the institution called for any interested researcher who is willing to
conduct a research on several organizational issues including the one under which this
research is conducted six months ago. All these realities provoke this research to assess the
conflict and conflict management practice of Gibson school system so that some useful
recommendations have been forwarded.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 7


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

1.2. Objectives of the Study


1.2.1 General Objective
As a general objective this study was investigating the practices and challenges of conflicts
by school in Gibson school system, Addis Ababa.
1.2.2. Specific Objectives
The specific objectives of the study are:
1. To identify the sources of conflict among academic and non academic staff in Gibson
School.
2. To identify the conflict management styles of school in Gibson school.
3. To examine the influence of conflicts on the teaching –learning process in Gibson School.
1.3 Significance of the Study
The study was focuses on the assessment of conflict management practice in the case of
Gibson school system and it was also try to identify the major source of conflict among the
staff member in the school. The investigation of the research expected to provide a base
information concerning of how to manage conflict in the organization. It is creating
awareness among employees, managers and other members of the organization about the
need for effective conflict management mechanism. In addition, the study used as a reference
material for interested researchers for further investigation, and serve as feedback for the
organization.

1.4 Delimitation of the Study


The research was more fruitful if it would be conducted widely by including other similar
private school.
But due to time money constraints it was too tedious to include all private schools. Thus, the
scope of the research will be delimited to Gibson school system which is found in Bole sub
city. The reason that the student researchers select Gibson school system because, the student
researchers know and frequently observed problems in the school. Therefore, Gibson school
system is taken as a target population. The study confined to assess conflict management
practice on Gibson school system and the study content to conflict management and
mechanism to solve such conflict.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 8


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

1.5 Definition of Terms


Conflict: Is any situation in which incompatible goals attitudes, emotions, or behaviors lead
to disagreement or opposition between two or more parts (Nelson Quick 2000:422).
Conflict Management: The use of resolution and stimulations techniques to achieved the
desired level of conflict.(Robinson, 2000:392).
Cooperation: refers to healthy and good relationship which creates concessive environment
for common goal.
1.6 Limitation of the study
Due to resource constraints, the study did not include other private school it is thus
understandable that this may have its own limitations on the findings of the study. The
following are the major limitations of the study:
 Some respondents did not give the required full information because of the fear that
they have on this area.
 Insufficiency of time that is provided to conduct this research is also one potential
limitation of the study.
At the time of conducting the research, the researcher has faced face limitations. The major
limitations were time and budget constraints. In addition to the above challenges, lack of
williingness or interest from participants to fill the questionnaire and return it at the right time
would also be another constraint or limitation. However, the researcher has followed effective
mechanisms to solve those constraints. The researcher has used the available time efficiently
to solve the problem of time constraint to accomplish the study. Above all, the researcher
gave brief orientation about the purpose of the questionnaire before distributing the
questionnaire to the participants. Additionally, the researcher also explained to them as the
information obtained from the respondents wouldbe kept confidential and approached them
with good discipline and sense of humor.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 9


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

CHAPTER TWO
2. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
2.1. Meaning and Nature of Conflict
Conflict is disagreement or grievance between two different parties it highly affects the
effectiveness of the organization. Since conflict is an integral part of our life, it is not possible
to avoid it totally. Wherever there is interaction, there will be also conflict. Because
organization consists of many diversified workforces, there would be conflict for different
reasons at different times. As it is stated above, workforce diversity is the common features
of many different business organizations. This workforce diversity can be due to religion,
gender, ethnics, culture, values personality and the likes. So, conflict may arise among these
diversified groups due to common objectives in order to achieve their goals effectively. They
must understand and support the end point of the objective of the organization (William
Bingham, 1994:204).

2.2 Views of Conflicts


Conflict is inevitable in any organization where individuals and groups interact to produce
complex outputs. Although conflict can often be destructive, at other times it may stimulate
creativity, encourage flexibility and even be satisfying because it provides an interesting
environment to work in. (Cook and Honaker 2001: 384 )

2.3 Constructive Views of Conflict


Whether conflict works beneficially or not to the organization, it depends on two factors. One
is the intensity of the conflict and the second one is how well the conflict is managed.
Conflict of moderate intensity of very high intensity conflict can be bed. Too much conflict
over rowers the organization and its people, it districts and interface with other more task
relevant activities. Too little conflicts prevent organization and people from achieving a
creative performance edge. It affairs little challenge or stimulation for change.

2.4 Destructive Conflict


Is a dysfunctional and works to the disadvantage of the people and the organization. This
occurs for example, when two employees are unable to work together because of inter
personal hostilities (destructive emotional conflict) or when the members of a committee
can’t agree on group goals (a destructive substantive conflict) can reduce the effectiveness of

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 10


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

individuals, groups and organization, lower job satisfaction unnecessary or over powering
stress and decreased concern for common goal. Constructive conflict by contrast is
functional. It results in benefits instead of disadvantages for the people and organization
involved. The potential benefits of Constructive Conflicts include increased creativity and
innovation, greater effort, increased cohesion and reduced tension (Schermerhorn , 1996:240)

Negative Consequence
If it is not resolved, may lead to unnecessary blockage of communication, stress, lack of
cooperation, lose of friendship and reduced organizational effectiveness.
According to modern management theory, some positive consequences of conflict are:-
Analytical thinking, increasing of cohesion, the promotion of competition, organizational
development and the reduction of tension.

It helps in Analytical Thinking: Conflict may induce challenge to views, opinions, rules,
policies, goals, plans etc. Which would require critical analysis in order to justify these as
they are or make changes as required?

Increased Cohesion: Conflict between different organizations develops loyalty and cohesion
within the organizations and also create greater sense of group identify. In order to compute
against outsiders, it helps to committee and dedicate to organizational goals.

Organizational Development: It serves as a foundation for the organizational development.


Conflict can change creative and innovative. People are always looking for grounds to
challenge the statuesque. This challenges lead to search for alternatives to existing pattern
which again directs to organizational challenge and development.

To Reduce Tension: Conflict when expressed, can clear the air and reduce tension. Some
disagreement if unexpressed can lead to imaginative distortion of truth, sense of frustration,
tension, high mental – exaggeration and biased opinions resulting in fear and distrust.
However, when it is expressed, it may show the causes of conflicts to be minor, resulting in
cooperation and compromise.

2.5 Types of Conflict


The relationship between employee and manager has never been very smooth. Managers
have to make hard decisions that often do not let them win popularity contests. Labor is
interested in fair and competent management, human dignity and reasonable share in the
wealth its work generates. Over time rules, promotions, layoffs, transfers, job assignments

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 11


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

and so far are generally source of labor management conflicts (Mcgraw-Hill, 2002:362) It is
very essential that managers understand the types of conflict to manage and know its basic
causes:-

a. Inter Group Conflict: is a type of conflict which occurs between two or more
different groups. This type of conflict can occur in variety ways some of the basic
reasons or cause for this conflict are value difference, difference on goals, plants and
opinions.
b. Intra Group Conflict: It is a type of conflict within the same groups. This may occur
due to communication failure and completion for limited resources.
c. Interpersonal Conflict: This conflict involves conflict between individuals and is
probably the most common and most recognized conflict.
d. Inter Organizational Conflict: This conflict occurs between organizations, which
are dependent upon each other.
e. Conflict within Individuals: This conflict is usually value related. Where the role
playing expected on individual doesn’t conform with the values and believes held by
the individual.(Fremont , 1987:345).

2.6 .The Conflict Process


When we describe an incident involving conflict, we are usually referring to the observable
part of conflict-the angry words, shouting matches, and actions that symbolize opposition.
But this manifest conflict is only a small part of the conflict process. As Exhibit 1 below
illustrates, the conflict process begins with the sources of conflict like; Incompatible goals,
different values, and other conditions lead one or both parties to perceive that conflict exists.
We will look closely at these sources of conflict later because understanding and changing
the root causes is the key to effective conflict management.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 12


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Figure 1. The conflict process

Sources of Conflict
conflict Perception Conflict
• Goals s Manifest outcomes
• Values conflict Positive
• Tasks • Conflict • Decisions
• Resources • Decisions •Cohesiven
• Rules Conflict • Overt ess
•Communicati emotions behaviors Negative
on • Turnover
• Politics
2.7. Sources of Conflicts
Generally, organizational research findings confirm the following six categories of conflicts.

1. Goal Incompatibility: a common curse of conflict is goal incompatibility. As the main


implies, goal incompatibility occurs when people or work units have goals that interfere
with each other. Financial rewards for goal accomplishment further entrench the
perceived conflict because employees more motivated to pursue their own goal.
2. Differentiation: differentiation occurs when people hold divergent beliefs and altitudes
due to their unique background, experience of training.
3. Task Interdependence: conflict tends to increase with the level of task interdependence.
It exists when team members share common inputs to their individual tasks, need to
interact in the process of execution their work or receive their outcome (such as rewards)
that is partly determined by the performance of others. The higher the level of the task
interdependence, the greater the risk of conflict will be.
4. Scarce Resource: Scarce resource generates conflict it motivates people to compete with
others, who also need those resources to achieve their objectives.
5. Ambiguity: Ambiguity breeds conflict, because the uncertainty increases the risk that one
party intends to interface with other party’s goals. Ambiguity also encourages political
tactics and in some cases, employees enter a free for all battle to win decisions in their
flavor. When rules exist on the other hand, everyone knows what to expect from each
other and have agreed to abide by those rules.
6. Communication Problems: Conflict often occurs due to lack of opportunity, ability or
motivation to communicate effectively. Let’s look at each of these cases.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 13


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

First which two parties lack the opportunity to communicate, they tend to use stereo type to
explain post behaviors and anticipate future actions.

Second some people lack the necessary skills to communicate in a diplomatic way no
confrontational manner, when one party communicates its disagreement in an arrogant way
opponent are more likely to heighten their perception of the conflict. Arrogant behavior also
sends a message that one side intends to be competitive rather than cooperative. This may
lead to the other party to reciprocate with a similar conflict management style. (Vong
linow ,2000:408)

2.8. Stages of Conflicts: - Conflict can be more readily understood if it is considered as


dynamic process. Process here indicates a series of events. Each conflict is made up of a
sequence of inter locking conflict episodes. The stages of conflicts namely:- latent conflict,
perceived conflict, felt conflict manifest to conflict and conflict aftermath.

Stage1: Latent Conflict – Each episode of conflict being with a “Latent Conflict” important
source of organizational conflict such as competition for scarce resources, divergence of sub
unites goals, completion for position in the organization, role conflicts are present, and butte
conflict has not yet emerged. Latent conflict provides the necessary antecedent conditions for
conflict in organizations, here participants only anticipate conflict.

Stage2: Perceived Conflict – Here the basic sources of conflict like divergent goals,
competition for scarce resources, do not exist. Conflict results induce to the parties
misunderstanding of each other’s true position. Such a conflict can be resolved by improving
communication between the parties.

Stage3: Felt Conflict: Now the parties become emotionally involved and being to focus on
differences of opinion and opposing interests, sharpening perceived conflict. Internal tensions
and frustrations begin to crystallize around specific, defined issues, and people begin to build
an emotional commitment to their particular position.

Stage4: Manifest Conflict – This stage for open confrontation. It takes the form of conflict
full behavior. Including open aggressions, sabotages, withdrawal, letter perfect obedience to
rules etc. all or which reduce organizations effectiveness.
Stage5: Conflict Aftermath – The aftermath of conflict may be either positive or negative
for the organization depending on how the conflict is resolved. If the conflict is genuinely,

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 14


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

resolved. It can lead to a more enduring and cooperative relationship between


organization participants, if the conflict is merely suppressed but not resolved, the latent
conditions of conflict may be aggravated and explode in more violent and serious forms. This
legacy of conflict is called “conflict after math” ( Kumar and Mital, 2001:440).

2.9. Conflict Resolution Styles


Conflict can be resolved in different ways but the following are some of the commonly used.

(1) Goal Structure Goals should be clearly defined and the role and contribution of each unit
towards the organizational goals must be clearly identified. All units and the individuals in
these units must be aware of the importance of their role and such importance must be fully
recognized.

(2) Reward System The compensation system should be such that it does not create
individuals competition and conflict within the unit. It should be appropriate and
proportionate to interdependence among units wherever necessary.

(3) Trust and Communication The greater the trust among members of the unit, the more
honest and open the communication among them would be individuals and units should be
encouraged to communicate openly with each other so that they can all understand each
other. Understand each other’s problems and help each other when necessary.

(4) Smoothing means covering up the conflict by appealing for the need for unity rather than
addressing the issue of conflict itself. An individual with internal conflict may try to “count
his blessings” and forget about the conflict. If two parties have a conflict within the
organization, the supervisor may try to calm things down by being understanding and
supportive to both parties and appealing them for cooperation. The supervisor does notignore
or with draw from the conflict or does he try to address and solve the conflict butexpresses
hope that “everything will work out to the best of all.”

(5) Compromising a compromise in the conflict is reached by balancing the demands of the
confliction parties’ band bargaining in a give and take position to goal a solution. Each party
gives up same thing and also gains something. The technique of conflict resolution is very
common in negotiations between the labor unions and management. It has become customary
for the union to ask for more than what they are willing to give in the initial stages. Then
through the process of negotiation and bargaining, mostly in the presence of arbitrary, they

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 15


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

reach a solution by compromising. This type of compromise is known as integrative


bargaining in which both sides win in away.

Compromising is a useful technique, particularity when two parties have relatively equal
power, thus no party can force its view point on the other and the only solution is to
compromise. It is also use full when there are time constraints.
(6) Avoidance Conflict can also be reduced by avoiding it altogether.. This involves efforts
on the part of the confliction parties either to withdrawal, or disguises the in consistency. By
withdrawal, one party enables the other to “win” by being and exclusive occupant of the
goals through mutual withdrawal and establishing other non-overlapping goals. When
withdrawal is not feasible, attempts may be made to disguise the in consistency of goals by
withholding information related to them. Sometimes, subordinates with hold or suppress
certain unpleasant information to avoid conflict with their supers certain unpleasant
information to avoid conflict with their superiors.

(7) Problem Solving


This technique involves “Confronting the conflict” in order to seek the best salutation to the
problem. This approach objectively assumes that in all organizations, no
matter how well they are managed, there will be differences of opinions which must be
resolved through discussions and respect for differing viewpoints. In general this technique is
very useful in resolving conflicts arising out of semantic misunderstandings. It is not so
effective in resolving non – communication types of Conflicts such as those that are based
differing value systems, were it may each intensity differences and disagreements in the long
run; however, it is better to solve conflicts and take such preventive measures that would
reduce the likelihood of such conflicts surfacing again.
8. Forcing: - the simplest conceivable resolution is the elimination of the other party to force
opponents to flee and give up the fight or say them this is technique of domination where the
dominator has the power and authority to enforce his own views over the opposing party.
This technique is potentially effective in situation, such as a president of a company firing a
manger because he is considered as a trouble – maker and conflict creator.
This technique always ends up in one party being a loser and the other party being a clear
Winner (Ivancivch, 1998:550).

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 16


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

2.10. Conflict Management Strategies


It is a truism that parties, be the individuals, groups, organizations or countries, they
cooperate with each other are usually more productive than those that do not. But there are
many areas of potential conflict. Since dysfunctional conflict can have destructive
consequences, it is important to detect reduce and act to prevent its recurrence. On the other
hand, even dysfunctional conflicts useful in that it signals needed changes. Also, functional
conflict that serves to improve the quality of decision making and stimulate creative break
through should be judiciously managed to achieve the most beneficial results for the
organization. Consequently, the critical issue is not how to eliminate conflict but how to
manage it productively to obtain positive change and avoid negative consequences.

Attempts to manage intergroup conflict take the form of win – lose (competing and
accommodating), lose – lose (avoiding), win – win (collaborating) or compromise
(bargaining) outcomes. Win lose outcomes are brought about by all or nothing competitive
strategies that encourage one group to win at the expense of the other. Since organizations
consist of ongoing relationships, zero sum strategies create destructive political environment.
Avoiding strategies don’t solve problems, they leave the problems to fester and erupt later. At
best, they allow some temporary productivity until the groups can address the conflict more
effectively compromise strategies allow both groups to gain a little, but neither to obtain all
that its member’s desire. Since win–win strategies allow both groups to obtain their goals
through creative integration of their concerns, the best practice is to try a win–win strategy
first. If it doesn’t work, a compromise strategy can provide some benefits to both groups.
Organizations with intergroup coordination strategies can often mange conflict productivity
without becoming destructive. (Cook and Hunsalker, 2001:396

2.10.1. Coordination Strategies for Avoiding Intergroup Conflict Rules and Procedures
One of the simplest and least costly ways of avoiding intergroup conflict is to spell out in
advance the required activities and behaviors in the form of rules and procedures.

Written standards tell interacting parties what to do in specific situations to ensure adequate
performance and avoid having to work things through each time.

Hierarchy
When rules and procedures are not sufficient for coping with inter group problems. Conflict
can be passed up the hierarchy to a common superior for resolution. If conflict arises between
copywriters and graphic designers in an advertising department, for example, the advertising

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 17


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

production manger may intervene as mediator. But if the sales force perceives conflict with
entire advertising operation, the vice president in charge of marketing may have to resolve
the issue planning.
In more complex situations, coordinating inter group activities requires more than rules,
procedures, or hierarchies. Planning can be essential to task accomplishments when it is
necessary to determine in advance the goals, roles and responsibilities of all groups that need
to co-operate a classic example of the need for planning is in building construction. All
workers must know in advance what they are supposed to do and when. Activities are
controlled by a master plan that coordinates the efforts of the interacting groups.
Liaison Roles
When the number of interaction between several groups becomes more frequent or complex,
organizations often establish coordinating personnel to handle these ongoing interaction
requirements. A liaison expedites lateral communication much more effectively than could a
cumber some formal information system alone. Because liaisons are well acquainted with the
nature of the work all parties perform, they can cut through the bureaucracy to provide
quicker, more effective communication. An example would be an MBA with an
undergraduate degree in engineering who acts as a liaison between the engineering and
production departments.
Taskforces
When several groups interact over time in a complex situation, another way of facilitating
cooperation is to establish a temporary task force made up of one or more individuals from
each of the interacting units. This group investigates problems, suggests solutions, and
facilitates communication among all groups involved. When the problem or task has been
completed, the task group disbands and members return to their respective groups and resume
their normal activities. A task force of a new product for a major customer, for example,
might consist of individuals from production and marketing along with the customer’s
representative.
Teams
when several groups must interact in a complex situation over a long period of time, more
permanent teams can be formed to manage inter group activities. Team members maintain
their original roles in their functional department in addition to their new ones as coordinating
team members.

Task teams are established at universities to function as standing committees that periodically
make decisions about such things as granting tenure to faculty members or allocating annual
budgets.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 18


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Integrating Departments
When the complexity of information flows between several interacting groups is beyond the
capacity of plans, temporary taskforces, or permanent teams, an entire integrating department
can be established.
These are permanent departments with full time individuals whose only
responsibility is the effective coordination of inter group activities. This is a very expensive
method; it is usually used only if an organization’s business requires a lot of ongoing
cooperation between groups with conflicting goals. (Cook and Hunsalker, 2001:398)

2.11. Conflict Outcomes


It’s not surprising that people normally associate conflict management with reducing or
removing conflict. However, task related conflict should be encouraged under some
conditions.

Conflict management isn’t necessarily about minimizing conflict. It refers to interventions


that alter the level and form of conflict in ways that maximize its benefits and minimize its
dysfunctional consequences.

This sometimes means increasing the level of task-related conflict, which helps people
recognize problems, identify a variety of solutions, and better understand the relevant issues.
This positive conflict encourages people to consider new perspectives and debate these
emerging views.

Conflict is also beneficial where intergroup conflict improves team dynamics within those
units. Teams increase their cohesiveness and task orientation when they face an external
threat. Conditions of moderate conflict motivate team members to work more efficiently
toward their goals, thereby increasing the team’s productivity.

Functional Vs Dysfunctional Conflict Outcomes


Generally, conflict out comes can be classified in to functional and dysfunctional. These can
be discussed over the next few paragraphs: Modern views on conflict recognize that there are
both negative and positive consequences of conflict.

Some conflicts support the goals of the group and improve its performance; these are
functional, constructive forms of conflict. Additionally, there are conflicts that hinder group
performance; these are dysfunctional or destructive forms of conflict.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 19


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Of course, it is one thing to argue that conflict can be valuable for the group, and another to
be able to tell if a conflict is functional or dysfunctional. The demarcation between
functional and dysfunctional is neither clear nor precise. No one level of conflict can be
adopted as acceptable or unacceptable under all conditions. The type and level of conflict that
creates healthy and positive involvement toward one group’s goals today may, in another
group or in the same group at another time, be highly dysfunctional.
The criterion that differentiates functional from dysfunctional conflict is group performance.
Since groups exist to attain a goal or goals, it is the impact the conflict has on the group,
rather than on any individual member, that determines functionality. Of course, the impact of
conflict on the individual and its impact on the group are rarely mutually exclusive, so the
ways that individuals perceive a conflict may have an important influence of its effect on the
group. However, this need not be the case, and when it is not, our focus will be on the group.
So whether an individual group member perceives a given conflict as being personally
disturbing or positive is irrelevant. For example, a group member may perceive an action as
dysfunctional, in that the outcome is personally dissatisfying to him or her. However, for our
analysis, that action would be functional if it furthers the objectives of the group.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 20


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Figure 2 Conflict causes, process and outcome

Information
concealed.
Distance between
groups
increases.
Groups become
Interdependence on Conflict Process rigid and
tasks concerned only
Different goals, Frustration
Conceptualizati with their
norms, and interests.
time frames on
Behavior Interaction
Ambiguity of roles decreases.
Limited common Outcome
Potential for Good people may
resources quit.
Reward systems Conflict Time wasted.
Communication
obstacles Adaptation
Status/power Correct organizational
differences problems
Personnel skills and Increased cohesiveness
traits Within groups.
Identifies power in the
organization
Encourages flexibility.
Strengthen some
intergroup
links.
Better ideas produced.

2.12. Structural Approaches to Conflict Management


Conflict management styles refer to how we approach the other party in a conflict situation.
But conflict management also involves altering the underlying structural causes of potential
conflict. The main structural approaches are identified in Exhibit below.
Although this section discusses ways to reduce conflict, we should keep in mind that conflict
management sometimes calls for increasing conflict, mainly by reversing the strategies
described over the next few pages.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 21


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Figure 3 - structural approach to conflict management

Clarify rules
and
procedures Emphasize
super ordinate
goals

Minimizing
Dysfunctional conflict
Reduce
Increase differentia
resources tion

Improve
Reduce task
communication
interdependence
and understanding

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 22


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

CHAPTER THREE
3. METHDOLOGY AND RESEARCH DESIGN

3.1. Research Design and Research Approach


This chapter gives brief and precise explanation about the methodologies tools that the
researcher used to accomplish the study there by achieving the objectives. The chapter
organized as follows; research approach, research design, population and sampling, data
source and type, data collection procedure, and analyses of data. A research design is the
arrangement of conditions for collection and analysis of data in a manner that aims to
combine relevance to the research purpose with economy in procedure. In fact, the research
design is the conceptual structure within which research is conducted; it constitutes the
blueprint for the collection, measurement and analysis of data (Kothari, 2004).

Both descriptive and explanatory research design has been chosen considering the purpose of
the study, the research questions and the magnitude of the target population. According to
Kothari (2004), Descriptive research includes surveys and fact-finding enquiries of different
kinds. The major purpose of descriptive research is description of the state of affairs as it
exists at present. Exploratory research studies are also termed as formulate research studies.
The main purpose of such studies is that of formulating a problem for more precise
investigation or of developing the working hypotheses from an operational point of view
(Kothari, 2004)
3.2. Population, Sample Size and Sampling Techniques
3.2.1 Target Population
A population can be defined as all people or items (unit of analysis) with the characteristics
that one wishes to study (Kothari, 2004). The target populations of this study were the
employees, teachers and management body. The study target population focused on a total of
110.

3.2.2. Sample Size


Sampling is the process of selecting units (e.g. people, organizations) from a population
of interest so that by studying the sample, a fairly generalize results is trace back to the
population from which they were chosen. Probability Sampling used because each member of
the population has an equal likelihood of being selected to be part of the sample.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 23


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

From the types of probability sampling, this study find stratified random sampling
appropriate for selecting samples from the population

A stratified random sampling allows us to take into account the different subgroups of
people in the population and helps guarantee that the sample accurately represents the
population on specific characteristics.

3.2.3. Sampling Techniques


The study used non-probability sampling techniques. Purposive sampling techniques were
used by the researcher to select sample of employees.

The researcher select samples of employees by asking the persons who are interested in
participating in the survey were included into the survey and subsequent analysis. Therefore,
the researcher requested all the persons eligible for the study to participate.

3.3. Data Types and Sources


Data collection requires conducting certain procedures for further analysis. In this research,
two main types of data used to gather information, namely; primary and secondary data.

3.3.1. Primary data


These data are first time collected in solving the specific problems under study. Primary data
gathered using, questionnaires, interview and observation for the purpose of the study.
The major source of information for this primary source were employees, principals and
deputy principals

3.3.2. Secondary data


Secondary data for this study gathered through analysis of documents, reports, books,
magazines and this will help to get adequate information.

3.4. Method of Data Collection


To collect data from primary source the student researcher was use the following research
tools.

Questionnaire
One of the data collection tools that consists both open and close ended type used to gather
information form employees.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 24


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

This is because, questionnaires are an inexpensive way to gather data from potentially large
number of respondents and also protect the privacy of the participants.

Interview
This method of data collection is preferable used because it increase the precision of the data
gathered. The interview used unstructured interview which usually makes the interviewer and
the interviewee to be friendly and enable to express their views willingly on the research
problem under study.

Observation
For further and reliable information observation and recording /referring documents were
used. This serve in collecting data’s which in turn help to get reliable information.

3.5. Data Analysis Methods


After the data collected and plausible checks were conduct, and inconsistent data
cleared appropriately. Then coded to the system, so to make the data usefully and relevant to
analysis. By doing this it helps to filtered out the incomplete and irrelevant information and
accuracy of the data were maintained. The edited data are going through analysis process to
come up with concrete conclusions. Data processing and analysis have done by using
statistical package for social science (SPSS) to display findings and it helps make it easier by
processing all variable and cases

In order to achieve the findings and results for the dissertation, the researcher used
descriptive analysis to summarize the data. These methods will be numerical and/or
graphical. Graphical methods are known for recognizing patterns in the data, while the
numerical methods of analysis are acknowledged for giving precise measures. The analysis
will consist of graphs, tables, and charts to outline the responses received which will be
examined and discussed. The reasons for using this procedure were to make it easier for the
reader to compare and understand the findings by presenting the data using frequency, mean,
and standard deviation.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 25


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

CHAPTER FOUR
4. DATA ANALYSIS AND PRESENTATION
4.1 Introduction
As it was already mentioned in the research methodology part, questionnaire is used as
primary data collection method. It is distributed to the respondents by categorizing them in to
two. The first type of the questionnaire is distributed to Administrative staff and the second
type of questionnaire is distributed to Academic staff and respondents who are
neither academic staff nor administrative staff, (which we call them “Non academic staff”
now onwards for sake of consistency). Out of 35 questionnaires distributed to Administrative
staff of the organization, only 31 of them are returned back and out of 65 questionnaires
distributed to Academic and non academic staff, only 60 of them was retuned back. So In this
chapter the information gathered from the respondents is analyzed.

4.2 Analysis and Presentation of Data Gathered from Administrative Staff

4.2.1 General Bio Data of Respondents


The first part of the questionnaire solicited the respondents about their general bio data.
Accordingly the response of the respondents is depicted on the table 1, 2 &3 below.

Table 1 profile of respondents from Administrative staff

Sex Age

Male Female Total 21-25 26-30 31-40 Above 40 Total

Number 22 9 31 4 6 13 8 31

Percentag 71 29 100 13 19 42 26 100


e

According to the table 1 above 22 (71%) of the respondents are males and 9(29%) of the
respondents are females. From this data, we can easily observe as most of the organization’s
administrative staff members are males.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 26


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Out of the total respondents, 4(13%) of them are lies between an age of 21-25, 6(19%), of
them are between 31-40 years and the rest 8 (26%) of the respondents are aged above 40.

From this reality we can cascade the conclusion that most of the respondents are between
aged above 26. As it can be easily understandable, most of the time companies prefer to take
in to consideration the maturity level of the given individual in addition to his/her knowledge
and potential to provide some status. To this end, individuals whose age is above 26 are better
to solve problems faced by the organizations systematically. With this regard, the
organization’s Administrative staff combination is somehow promising.

Table 2-Educational and marital status

Educational Status Material Status

Diploma BA MA PhD Total Single Married Total


(BSC) (MSC)

Number 5 10 15 1 31 13 18 31

Percentag 16 32 48 4 100 42 58 100


e

As far as their educational status is concerned, (depicted in the above table 2), 5(16%) of the
respondents are diploma holders, 10(32%) of them are BA (BSC) holders, 15(48%) of the
respondents are MA (MSC) holders and the rest 1 (4%) of them is PhD holder.

It is definite that the educational status of the given individual has a great thing to do with the
efficiency and effectiveness of what he/she performs. So the fact that Most of the
administrative staff of the organization holds good academic status can contribute a lot
towards the effectiveness of the organization.

With regard to respondent’s marital status, 13(42%) of them are single and 18 (58%) of them
are married.

The number of years of experience of an individual can contribute a lot towards the way
he/she thinks, the method he/she performs his/her duty and the like. To this end, it is believed

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 27


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

that the more an individual stays on administrative portion, the more he/she can acquire an
experience of how to deal with several problems in an organization which intern leads to
minimization of conflict management problems. With this regard the data collected from the
respondents resembles that 14 (45%) of them have an experience of 1- 2 years, 5(17%) of
them have an experience of 3-4 years, 4(13%) of them has an experience of shears, 4(13%) of
them have an experience of 5 years 4(13%) of the respondents have an experience of 7-8
years, 2(6%) of them have an experience of 9-10 years and the rest 2(6%) of the respondents
accumulated an experience of above 10 years. This information is clearly shown on table 3
below.

Table 3 Years of experience of respondents from administrative staff

Experience (in years) Number Percentage (%)

1-2 14 45

3-4 5 17

5-6 4 13

7-8 4 13

9-10 2 6

Above 10 years 2 6

Total 31 100

As it is shown on the above table 3 most of the administrative staff of the organization have
limited years of experience in an organization. This may create some gap in an organization
with respect to managing and controlling organizational resources consistently.

4.2.2 Existence of Conflict and Perception on Conflict


As it is already said in the introductory part and literature review part of this paper now days,
conflict becomes an inevitable aspect of organizations. So it is undoubted for every
organization and almost every individual in an organization to get involved in conflict with

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 28


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

people around him/her. With this regard, the respondents are asked as to whether they have
ever encountered conflict with people in their work place. Accordingly, 18(58%) of them
respond as they encountered conflict with people with which they worked. The rest 13(42%)
of the respondents respond as if they are not ever get in to conflict with people. This figure
shows that most of the Administrative staff in an organization are get in to conflict with one
or another party.

The next question solicited was the frequency in which they get into conflict with people in
their work place accordingly out of 18 respondents who responded as they get in to conflict
with people in work place 3(16%) of them replied very often, 4(6%) of the respondents said
often and the rest 9(50%) of them said respond as the conflict arises rarely.
Have you ever How often is the conflict? With whom do you get in conflict?
encountered
conflict
with people?

Ye N Tota Very Ofte Rarel Tota Ad Student Subordinat AC NAC TOTA


s o l ofte n y l s s e S S L
n

Number 18 13 31 3 6 9 18 5 4 3 3 3 18

Percentag 58 42 100 16 34 50 100 27 22 17 17 17 100


e

From this data we can conclude that most of the respondents get in to conflict with people in
their work place rarely.

Table 4-existence of conflict (response of administrative staff)

But this does not mean that they are free of conflict. It is solely a comparative explanation for
existence and frequency of conflict. The information and additional issues are depicted on
table 4 below.
Key

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 29


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Ads- Administrative staff

ACS- Academic staff

NACS- Non Academic staff

As it is shown on the above table, 5(27%) of the respondents who encountered conflict with
people in work place are get in to conflict with Administrative staff members of the
organization, 4(22%)) of them are get in to conflict with students of the institution, 3(17
%) of them are felt in to conflict with their subordinates, 3(17%) of them are with Academic
Staff of the organization and the rest 3(17%) of them are felt in to conflict with Non
Academic staff members of the institution. From this given information it can be said that
there is greater tendency of conflict between administrative staff members of the organization
because of different reasons that they can mention. Whatever is the case, every individual in
an organization is supposed to give a due attention for those frequent four les of conflict.

The proceeding questions are solicited in an intention of knowing the perceptions of the
respondents on conflict.
From general reality point of view, it can be said that “even though people look towards the
same thing, they may interpreter it differently” because of difference in perception that they
have. To this end, every individual is expected to examine his/her perception towards conflict
so that he/she can be get benefits from functional conflicts and protect himself/herself herself
from being a victim of dysfunctional conflicts. With this regard, the respondents are asked
several questions which are intended to know their perceptions towards conflict. The
following table 5 reveals the information collected from the respondents.

Table 5- Perception on conflict (response of Administrative staff

No Questions Number Percentage


Yes No Total Yes No Total

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 30


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

1 Do you think all 12 19 31 39 61 100


conflicts harm
the
organization?

2 Have you ever 1 30 31 3 97 100


tried to create
conflict
among people?

3 Do you think 10 21 31 32 68 100


absence of
conflict shows
effectiveness of
the
organization?

As we already said earlier, most of recent literatures on conflict states that all the conflicts
encountered by the given organization may not hamper the organization’s overall efficiency
and effectiveness, rather there are conflicts which enable the organization to attain and
exceed the earlier set objectives. In any case, the extent to which the organization can be
benefited from helpful conflicts is by large determined by how the parties in the given
organization perceive it. To this end, the above table 4 shows that 12 (39%) of the
respondents perceives as if all the conflicts in an organization harm the organization’s
effectiveness and the rest 19(61%) of them replied that all conflicts may not harm the
organizational efficiency and effectiveness. This data clearly shows that there is a problem on
perception conflict.
The other question which were solicited to know the respondents perception towards conflict
is whether or not the respondents have ever tried to create conflict among people accordingly,
30(97%) of the respondents respond as if they never induce conflict among people and the
rest 1(3%) individual respond as something was done by the person to induce conflict among
people.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 31


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

As it is said above, individuals (especially persons who hold and perform administrative tasks
in an organization are required to differentiate between harmful and useful conflicts in an
organization. Then they should have to induce these usable conflicts to happen and they are
also required to avoid those harmful conflicts but, this is not holds true in most this
organization’s administrative staff case. The last question asked to know the perception of
respondents on conflict is whether they think as absence of conflict shows organizational
effectiveness. Accordingly 10(32%) of them replied that yes, absence of conflict shows
effectiveness of an organization and the rest 21(68%) respond as the absence of conflict may
not reveal an organizational effectiveness. From this data again we can conclude that there is
a perception problem on conflict on an administrative staff of the institution.

4.2.3 Frequency of Conflict in an Organization and Parties Involved in it


The essence of this information is to identify how often a conflict is encountered at
organizational level, (not at individual level, which is discussed above). It is obvious that the
frequency in which a conflict exists in an organization shows the extent to which the
organization is capable of taking remedial actions (corrective measures) to correct the
conflicting situations, if they lead to in efficiency. With this regard 5(16%) of the respondents
replied that the conflict is exists in an organization very frequently, 20(65%) of them respond
as it happens frequently and the rest 6(19%) respond as it happens not frequently (rarely).
This data reveals that the existence of conflict in an organization is mostly frequent. The next
question asked the respondents about the parties which are frequently get in to
conflict in the organization. Accordingly, 3(10%) of them replied that the conflict is
frequent between Academic staff and academic staff, 14 (45%) of them said between
academic staff and students 12(39%) of them respond between academic staff and
administrative staff and the rest 2(6%) replied between Academic staff and Non academic
staff. This information is revealed on the following table 6 precisely.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 32


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Table 6 Frequency of conflict in the organization and parties involved in it.


How frequent is conflict in the Which parties are frequently get involved
organization? in conflict

Very Frequent Not Total ACS ACS ACS ACS Total


frequent frequent with with with with
ACS student Ads NACS
s

No 5 20 6 31 3 14 12 2 31
Percentage 16 65 19 100 10 45 39 6 100

Key

Ads- Administrative staff

ACS- Academic staff

NACS- Non Academic staff

4.2.4 The Way an Administrative Staff Get Information about Existence of Conflict
There are several ways through which the given individual can get on information regarding
existence of conflict. The first way is through hearsay. This is the method in which the given
individual gets information through several chains of message which may be expected or not.
This method of transmitting information is highly susceptible to distortion of the message i.e.,
the massage transmitted via this line may miss its original nature and content. Additionally
the individual who provide us information may not have full confidence in providing the
whole information to us appropriately.

The second way of getting information about existence of conflict is from friends and school.
As we all know, our friends and school are our potential sources of several types of
information, including information regarding existence of conflict. The third method of
obtaining information about existence of conflict in the organization is through formal report.
The given individual can also get the necessary information about conflict existence from
several formal reports presented to him/her.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 33


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

The fourth potential source of information about existence of conflict is from the parties felt
in conflict themselves. Several times, the parties get in to conflict by themselves may provide
the information to the party that they think as providing them a solution or sharing their
mental stress. With his regard 10(32%) of the respondents respond that they get an
information through hearsay, 8(26%) of them replied that they get an information from
friends and school, 9(29%) of them get through formal report and the rest 4(13%) get from
parties felt in conflict. This information is depicted on the following table 7.

Table 7 The way administrative staff gets information about existence of conflict

No Ways of getting an Number Percentage

information

1 Through hearsay 10 32

2 From friends and 8 26


schools

3 Through formal 9 29
report

4 From parties felt in 4 13


conflict

Total 31 100

4.2.5 Sources of Conflict


The sources of conflict in an organization are broadly classified in to three. The first one is
personal factors which include emotions of the individual, values and ethics of the person,
attitudes and perceptions, skills and responsibility diversity of the person jealousy and
the like. To this end, all of the respondents (31 or 100% of them) replied that all of those
factors are the personal sources of conflict in the organization.
The second group of source of conflict in an organization is structural factors. The typical
factors under this are Goal differences, status inconsistencies, scarcity of resources,
PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 34
ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

interdependence, unclear job boundary and relationship among authorities. To this end, all of
the respondents replied again as if all of these structural factors mentioned above are source
of conflict in an organization. Specially, interdependence (relationship between several works
and work units) in an organization and unclear job boundary (absence of demarcation
between the responsibilities that each party in an organization is supposed to assume) are the
two most prominent sources for most of the conflicts happen in the organization.

The third source of conflict in Gibson school system is a communication factors. The major
communication factors brings conflict in an organization includes: distorted message (a
message which missed its original nature and content because of length of communication
channel and parties involved in the channel), Information overload (sending a lot of
information at once which creates difficulty to grasp and catch all the sent message),
Emotional state, lack of communications kill, use of Jargon (technical words which are only
related to some fields), information late delivery, error in perception and empathy
(recognizing all individuals to be communicated as if he have equal understanding ability
with the sender and the rest of receivers). With this regard also, all of the solicited
respondents replied as if all of these communication factors are the sources conflict in the
organization. In addition to the aforementioned three major sources of conflict, several other
factors can also cited as sources of conflict in an organization. These are: penalties, policies
and procedures, reward system, cultural differences, less obedience, performance appraisal
system and result and assignment of task. All of these factors are recognized by 31(100%) of
the respondents as a possible sources of conflict in an organization. Specially, penalties,
reward system and problems on policies and procedures are the upper most three reasons that
are resulting in conflict in the organization.

4.2.6 Conflict Outcomes


The outcomes of any conflict can be functional or dysfunctional. A given conflict outcome is
functional if it results in some useful or beneficial outcomes for the organization. The conflict
is dysfunctional if it brings some harmful out comes which may hampers the overall
organizational efficiency and effectiveness.

To this end, the respondents are solicited about the outcomes of conflicts that are encountered
by the organization accordingly, 6(19%) of them said that the conflict’s outcome was
functional, 11(35%) of them replied as it was dysfunctional and the rest 14(46%) respond as
if it resulted in both functional and dysfunctional out comes. This information is depicted on
the table 8 below.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 35


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

The next question asked the respondents about the possible functional outcomes of the
conflict. Actually, there is large number of functional outcomes of conflict.
No What are the outcomes Number Percentage
of conflicts
encountered by the
organization?

1 Functional 6 19

2 Dysfunctional 11 35

3 Both 14 46

Total 31 100

Table 8 Conflict out comes

The typical ones are promotion of organizational vitality, motivation of change, increased
commitment, and it can leads to new ideas and innovation. Accordingly, all (31 or 100%) of
the respondents replied as all of these can be cited as a functional outcomes of conflict in the
organization. The other question requested the respondents to identify dysfunctional
outcomes of conflict. Basically, the dysfunctional outcomes of conflict incorporate Employee
turnover, customer dissatisfaction, distorted group cooperation, increased job dissatisfaction,
resource wastage, diversion of energy form work, creation of negative climate and it also
results in inefficiency. Accordingly 31 (100%) of the respondents replied as if all of these
can be taken as potential dysfunctional conflict out comes in an organization
Specially, employee turnover and increased job dissatisfaction becomes the major head ache
of the organization.

4.2.7 Conflict Management Styles


Majority of organizational behaviorists and psychologists recognized the fact that conflict
management is a difficult task to perform. Actually this reality pertains to several reasons like

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 36


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

difference in personality, cultural differences between parties involved in conflict, lack of


conflict management skill, difference in status between all the parties. Accordingly, the
respondents are asked about whether they think as if conflict management is difficult task or
not. Accordingly all of the respondents replied that it is difficult task because of all the
reasons mentioned above. The proceeding question requested the respondents to identify the
best conflict management style for them out of the alternatives provided. Accordingly,
5(16%) of them replied that Avoiding (ignoring) is best, 7(23%) selected negotiation, 7(23%)
selected integration (coordination) 5(16%) selects compromising, 3(10%) third party
intervention and the rest 4(12%) selected obliging (smoothing). This information is depicted
clearly on Table 9 below.
Table 9. Conflict management styles

Which conflict management style do you think is Number Percentage


best?

1 Avoiding (ignoring) 5 16

2 Negotiation 7 23

3 Integrating (cooperating) 7 23

4 Compromising 5 16

5 Third party intervention 3 10

6 Dominating (forcing) 0 0

7 Obliging (smoothing) 4 12

Total 31 100

4.2.8 Conflict Management Practice of the Organization


The respondents are asked about the conflict management practice of the organization.
Accordingly, 3(10%) of them replied it is excellent 3(10%) of them said it is very good,
4(13%) of them respond it is fair and the rest 21(67%) of them said it is poor .From this
we can say that majority of the respondents feel as the management practice of the
organization is poor.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 37


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

4.2.9 Training on Conflict Management


In order to equip their workers with the required necessary skill, it is a must for every
organization to prepare special training programs. Specifically organizations are required
to provide special training for their worker on areas of conflict management to enable an
individual’s to develop a skill of managing conflicts arise in an organization between
several partied and to enable them to grasp the essence of conflict appropriately.

With this regard, the respondents were asked whether they ever got any chance to participate
on a training which is prepared on area of conflict management, accordingly 5 (16%) of
them replied as they get the chance to participate and the rest 26(84%) of them replied as they
didn’t get a chance to participate on such trainings. From this data we can easily
observe that the organization is poor at coordinating and preparing trainings on conflict
management areas, even though the area is too sensitive and necessary.

The next question solicits those individuals who got the chance to participate on training
prepared on areas of conflict management about how they find the training. Accordingly
4 of them said it is poor and 1 of them said it is good. So this again brings us to the
conclusion that the trainings ever given also lack quality.

The last question the respondents requested in this part is whether or not they applied what
they learnt on training. Accordingly 5 of them (all of them) replied they did not apply it.

4.2.10 Effect of Gender on Conflict Management


Several individual perceives that gender have an effect on conflict management effectiveness.
To this end, the respondents are asked whether they think as if gender has an impact on
effectiveness on conflict management or not.

Accordingly, 11 (48%) of them said as gender have an impact on conflict management


effectiveness. The rest 12 (52%) of them respond as gender have no impact on conflict
management.

The last question asked the respondents about which gender they thank in effective in
managing conflict. Accordingly 7(22%) of them said male, 8(26%) of them said female and
the rest 16(52%) respond as it depends on situations. This information is depicted precisely
on table 10 below.

Table 10. Effect of gender on conflict management

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 38


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Do you think gender have an Which gender do you think is better

impact on conflict management

Yes No Total Male Female Depending Total


on
situations
Number 15 16 31 7 8 16 31
Percentage 48 52 100 22 26 52 100

4.3 Analysis and Presentation of Information Gathered from Academic and Non
Academic Staff
In this part the data collected from Academic and non academic staff of the organization in
analyzed and presented.

4.3.1 General Bio Data of Respondents


In this part a general bio data of the respondents from Academic and Non Academic staff
members of the organization is collected. The following table 11, 12 & 13 below depicts this
information.

Table 11- General Bio-data of respondents (from Academic and Non academic staff).

Sex Age
Male Female Total 21-25 26-30 31-40 Above Total
40
Number 33 27 60 18 30 6 6 60
Percentage 55 45 100 30 50 10 10 100

According to the information given on the above table, 33 (55%) of the respondents are male
and 27 (45%) of them are female.

Regarding the age distribution of the respondents, 18(30%) of the respondents lies
between21-25, 30 (50%) of them are aged between 26- 30, 6(10%) of them are between 31-
40 and the rest 6(10%) are aged above 40. From this fact we can say that most of the
Academic and non- academic staff of the organization are youngsters aged between 25-30

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 39


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

years. As previously said, this age is an age in which peoples are more reactive to conflict. So
this can contribute a lot towards determining the level of conflict in an organization.
Regarding the respondents educational status, 2(3%) of them are grade 12 complete, 6(10%)
of them are certificate holders, 16(27%) of them are diploma holders, 20(33%) of the
respondent are BA (BSC) holders, 14 (24%) of the respondent are MA (MSC) holders and
the rest 2(3%) of the respondents are PhD holders. From this information, we can easily
observe the fact that most of the workers in an organization have good educational status.
With respect to the marital status of the respondents, 42(70%) of them are single and only
18(30%) of the respondents are married. This information is shown on table 12 below.

Table 12 Educational marital status of respondents from academic and non academic staff

Education status Marital status

Grade Certifica Diploma BA(BS MA(Ms PhD Tota Singl Marrie Tota
12 te C) c) l e d l
complet
e
No 2 6 16 20 14 2 60 42 18 60

⸓ 3 10 27 33 24 3 100 70 30 100

The next question provided for the respondents is the number of years of experience that
the accumulated in the organization. The response obtained is depicted on table 13 below.

Table 13.Years of experience of respondents from academic and Nonacademic staff

No Years of experience Number Percentage

1 1-2 32 53

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 40


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

2 3-4 19 32
3 5-6 8 13
4 7-8 1 2
5 9-10 0 0
6 Above 10 0 0
Total 60 100

According to the information given above, 32 (53%) of the respondents have 1-2 years of
experience, 19(32%) of them have an experience of 3-4 years in the organization, 8(13%)
of them have an experience of 5-6 years and the rest 1(2%) of the respondent has an
experience of 8 years.

This information shows that most of the academic and non academic staff members of the
organization are new for the organization. As it is already known, new entrants to the
organization are more exposed to conflict because of the fact that they may not get informed
and well introduced and convinced with the organizational rules and procedures. Additionally
this can also reflect that an organization is highly suffering from turn-over of its post
employees.

4.3.2 Conflict Existence


In this part information regarding the existence of conflict is solicited through the following
three major questions depicted on table-14 below.

Table 14- Conflict existence (response from Academic staff and Non Academic staff)

Have you ever How often is the conflict With who do your get in conflict?
encountered arising?
conflict with
people?

Yes No Total Very Often Rarely Total Ads Students ACS NACS Total
often
No 42 18 60 6 19 35 60 22 23 9 6 60
⸓ 70 30 100 10 32 58 100 37 38 15 10 100

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 41


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Key

Ads- Administrative staff

ACS- Academic staff

NACS- Non Academic staff

From the information given on the above table, 42 (70%) of the respondents replied as they
have encountered conflict with people in work place and 18(30%) of them respond as they
did not faced conflict with people in work place.

Regarding the frequency of conflict, 6(10%) of them respond as they very often get in to
conflict, 19(32%) of them respond as they often get in to conflict and the rest 35 (58%)
respond as they rarely get in to conflict.

With regard to the party with whom they get in to conflict, 22(37%) of t them respond as they
get in to conflict with Administrative staff of the organization, 23(38%) of them replied as
they get in to conflict with students, 9(15%) of them said that they get in to conflict with
academic staffs and the rest 6 (10%) said that they get in to conflict with Non Academic staff.

From this information we can conclude that workers are highly got in to conflict with
students and Administrative staff of the organization.

The next questions intended to know the perception of the respondents on conflict. The data
obtained from respondents is shown on table 15 below.

Table 15- perception on conflict (response from Academic and Non Academic staff)

Number Percentage

No Question Yes No Total Yes No Total

1 Do you think all 28 32 60 67 33 100


conflicts harm
the
organization?

2 Have you ever 15 45 60 25 75 100


tried to create

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 42


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

conflict among
people?

3 Do you think 17 43 60 28 72 100


absence of
conflict shows
effectiveness of
the organization

According to the information given on the above table, 28 (47%) of the respondents think as
all the conflicts harm the organization, 32 (53%) of them replied that all conflicts are not
harming the organization. The figure shows the fact that there is conflict perception problem.

For the question which says “have you ever tried to create conflict among people, 15 (25%)
of the respondents replied as they induced conflict among people.

The rest 45(75%) of the respondents responds as they did not ever induced conflict among
people. This can also be regarded as one indicator of perception problem of respondents on
conflict.

Respondents are also requested whether they think as absence of conflict shows
effectiveness of the organization.

Accordingly 17(28%) of them replied as absence of conflict shows normality and


effectiveness of the organization. The rest 43(72%) of the respondents answered that absence
of conflict in an organization may not reveal effectiveness of the organization. This
information can also be taken as a witness for the presence of problem on conflict perception.

4.3.3 Frequency of Conflict and Parties Involved in it in the Organization


Respondents are solicited an information regarding the frequency of conflict in the
organization.

Accordingly 7(12%) the respondents replied as it is very frequent, 23(38%) of them respond
as it is frequent and the rest 30(50%) of the respondents answered that conflict is not frequent
in the organization. This information is precisely given on the table 16 below.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 43


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Table 16. Frequency of Conflict and Parties Involved in it in the Organization

How frequent is conflict in your Which parties are frequently got in to conflict in
organization? your organization?

Very Frequent Not Total ACS ACS ACS Ads ACS TOTAL
frequent frequent with with with with with
ACS students Ads Ads NACS

Number 7 23 30 60 8 20 17 10 5 60

% 12 38 50 100 13 33 28 17 9 100
Key

Ads- Administrative staff

ACS- Academic staff

NACS- Non Academic staff

Regarding the parties get in to conflict 8(13%) of the respondents respond as the conflict is
between academic staffs of the organization, 20(33%) of the respondents respond as the
conflict is exists between academic staff and students, 17(28%) of the respondent replied as
the conflict is frequent between academic staff an administrative staff of the organization,
10(17%) of them said the conflict is observed often between administrative staff of the
organization, the rest 5(9%) of the respondents replied that the conflict is also observed
between academic staff and non academic staff of the organization.

4.3.4. The Way Academic and Nonacademic Staff Members Obtain Information about
an Existence of Conflict
The respondents are asked about the way they get information about the existence of conflict.
Accordingly, the following information depicted on table17 is obtained.

Table 17.The way academic and non academic staff members obtain information about an
existence of Conflict

No Ways of getting Number Parentage

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 44


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

information
1 Through hearsay 28 47
2 From friends and 10 17
schools
3 Through formal report 9 15
4 From parties felt in 13 21
conflict
Total 60 100

According to the information given above 28(47%) of the respondents respond as they get an
information regarding existence of conflict through hearsay, 10(17%) of respondents replied
that they get an information from friends and school, 9(15%) respond as they get through
formal report, 13(21%) answered as they get an information from parties felt in conflict.

From this information, we can conclude that most of the individuals get information about
existence of conflict though informal way, which is more exposed to message distortion.

4.3.5 Conflict Sources


As we said earlier, there are three major categories of sources of conflict these are personal
factors, structural factors and communication factors.

There are also additional sources of conflict out of the above three categories.

Regarding the respondents reply, all of the respondents (60 or 100% of them) recognized all
of the aforementioned sources of conflict as sources of conflict in an organization. Those
sources of conflict are clearly defined in our previous part, i.e. analysis and presentation of
data gathered from administrative staff members. So no detail explanation is given here to
avoid redundancy.

4.3.6. Conflict Outcomes


In this part the respondents are solicited about an out comes of conflicts in the organization.
Acordinglly13 (22%) of the respondents said it is functional, 17(28%) said the outcome is
dysfunctional, 30(50%) of them replied as the outcome is both functional and dysfunctional.

This information is clearly shown on table 18 below.

Table 18 .Conflict Outcomes

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 45


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

No What were the Number Percentage

outcomes of conflict

encountered by the

organization?

1 Functional 13 22
2 Dysfunction 17 28
3 Both 30 50
Total 60 100

Additionally, the respondents are requested to identify the possible types of functional and
dysfunctional outcomes of conflicts in the organization. Accordingly all of the respondents
respond as all of what is listed down in the previous part are the possible functional and
dysfunction out comes in the organization. Again the detail explanation is escaped to avoid
redundancy.

4.3.7. Style of Conflict Management


All the respondents recognized the difficulty of conflict management because of the reasons
stated in the previous part.

Additionally, the respondents are requested about the conflict management style that they
recognize as the best one. Their response is presented on table 19 below.

Table 19 Conflict management styles

No Which conflict Number Percentage

management style do

you think is best?

1 Avoiding(ignoring) 8 13
2 Negotiation 15 25

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 46


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

3 Integrating(coordinating 15 25
)
4 Compromising 8 13
5 Third party intervention 9 15
6 Dominating ( forcing) 0 0
7 Obliging (smoothing) 5 9
Total 60 100

According to the information given above 8(3%) of the respondents replied as avoiding
(ignoring) is the best style, 15(25%) of them replied as Negotiation is the best, 15(25%)
replied as integrating (coordinating) is best, 8(13%) respond as compromising is the best
style, 9(15%) respond as third party intervention is best and the rest 5(9%) respond as
obliging (smoothing) is the best style.

4.3.8 The Institution’s Conflict Management Practice


The respondents are requested about the conflict management practice of the institution.
Accordingly, 15(25%) of them replied as it is good, 9(15%) of the respondents replied as it is
fair and the rest 34(60%) of the respondents replied as it is poor. This data shows that the
organizations conflict management method is too problematic.

4.3.9 Training on Issues Related to Conflict


The respondents are requested whether they are provided with training on issues related to
conflict.

Accordingly, all of the respondents replied as no training is given to them on the issue. This
information shows that the institution is really overlooking area.

4.3.10 Gender Effect on Conflict


Respondents are asked whether gender have an effect on conflict management.
Accordingly, 37(62%) of them replied as gender can affect conflict management
effectiveness and the rest 23(38%) respond as it has no effect. This information is shown on
table 20 below.

Table 20. Gender effect on conflict

Do you think gender have impact on Which gender do you think is better?

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 47


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

conflict management?

Yes No Total Male Female Depending Total


on the
situation
Number 37 23 60 19 18 23 60
Percent 62 38 100 32 30 38 100

Additionally, respondents are asked about which gender is better in managing conflict.
Accordingly 19(32%) of them replied as male are better, 18(30%) replied as female are better
and the rest 23(38%) replied as it depends on situations. This information shows as there is a
great range of difference on perception regarding the gender effect on conflict management.

CHAPTER FIVE
5. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 Summary
The term conflict has many meanings and has been used to refer to events ranging from the
inner turmoil produced by competing needs or desires (inner conflict) to open violence
between entire societies (warfare). In the context of OB, however, conflict refers primarily to
instances in which units or individuals within an organization work against rather than with
one another. More formally, according to one widely accepted definition, conflict is a process
in which one party perceives that another party has taken some action which will exert
negative effects on its major interests, or is about to take such action. In other words, the key
elements in conflict seem to include: opposing interests between individuals or groups,
recognition of such opposition, the belief by each side that the other will thwart (or has
already thwarted) these interests, actions that actually produce such thwarting.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 48


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

It is entirely appropriate to say there has been “Conflict” over the role of conflict in groups
and organizations. One school of thought has argued that conflict must be avoided, that it
indicates a malfunctioning within the group. We call this the traditional view. Another school
of thought, the human relations view, argues that conflict is a natural and inevitable outcome
in any group and that it need not be evil, but rather has the potential to be a positive force in
determining group performance. The third, and most recent, perspective proposes that
conflict can be a positive force in a group but explicitly argues that some conflict is
absolutely necessary for a group to perform effectively. We label this third school the
interactions approach. Let’s take a closer look at each of these views.

The conflict process begins with the sources of conflict (which are broadly classified in to
personal factors, communication factors and structural factors). The second step is manifest
conflict. The next step is conflict escalation cycle and the last and the fourth one is conflict
outcomes (which can be functional or dysfunctional).

Based on the parties involved in it, conflict can be classified in to: intrapersonal conflict and
interpersonal conflicts (which in turn classified in to inter group, intra group, inter
organizational, intra organizational and cross cultural conflicts).

The conflict management styles used in avoiding dysfunctional conflicts are: dominating
(forcing), obliging (smoothing), integrating, avoiding and compromising but, the
effectiveness of these styles can be determined by situations. Negotiation and third party
intervention are also used as alternative methods of conflict management.

Recent literatures on conflict management state that functional conflicts should have to be
induced in organizations for better attainment of their objectives.

Two programmed conflict inducing techniques with proven track records are devil’s
advocacy and the dialectic method.

This paper is conducted under a title of “Conflict Management Practice in Gibson School
System”. The information required for the study is collected by applying both primary and
secondary data sources. 100 questionnaires are prepared and distributed to academic, non
academic and administrative staff of the university college. The data gathered from these
sources is analyzed and presented accordingly. Conclusions are drawn and recommendations
are also forwarded based on what is concluded.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 49


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

5.2 Conclusions
Based on the already analyzed data in the previous part, the following conclusions are
drawn.

 Most of the institution’s administrative staff members have between the ages of 25-
40 whereas most of the academic and non academic staff member’s age is between
the ages 21-30.
 Large part the institution’s staff members hold higher educational status.
 The years of experience of, most of the institution’s staff members (of all types)
ranges between 1-4.years
 At both individual and organizational level, most of the employees get in to
conflict with several parties because of several reasons.
 Conflict is frequent between administrative and academic staff and between
academic staff and students of the institution because of a wide range of conflict
of interest.
 There is a great problem on perception of conflict i.e.; most of the individuals
recognize all conflicts as harming the organization most of the individuals have not
yet tried to induce conflict among individuals and most of the individuals relate
absence of conflict in the organization with the organizational effectiveness.
 From conflict sources in the organization, work independence, unclear job
boundaries, emotions, distorted messages, information’s late delivery, penalties,
reward system and policy and procedural problems are the major ones.
 Most of conflicts in the organization have dysfunctional outcomes. Increased rate of
Turnover and job dissatisfaction are the two clearly and frequently observed
dysfunctional conflict out comes in the organization.
 The organization has not ever prepared more special training program on conflict
management related issues.
 The conflict management practice of the organization is too poor.
 There is a predisposition towards perceiving the impact of gender on conflict
management effectiveness.

5.3 Recommendations
Based on the information concluded above, the following recommendations are forwarded:

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 50


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

 The organization should use an advantage of having youngsters as academic staff


members since they are in productive age but, great emphasis is required to be given
on how to protect and manage conflicts happen between them since people in this age
are more sensitive and reactive to conflict.
 The institution should have to keep it up in hiring and retaining those highly educated
professionals to increase its service quality, which in turn can boost the institution’s
reputation and good will.
 The fact that most of the organization’s staff members have few years of experience
in the institution shows as there is great problem in retaining earlier staff. So the
institution should have to develop several mechanisms that help to keep the
employees with it.
 The organization should create some special programs in which its employees
develop a harmonies relationship among themselves. These programs are like special
trips, get together, recreational tours …etc
 The institution should also appreciate a social relationship among workers and the
heads of the institution are supposed to play a figure head role by appearing on special
occasions for the employees like, marriage, death... etc
 In order to minimize the frequent conflicts between the University College’s
academic and administrative staff and between the academic staff members and
students of the institution, the following recommendations are helpful:
 The organization is required to put individuals who have the required skill of
leading/directing in its administrative post.
 There must be clear and reasonable procedure that the administrative staffs
of the institution should have to follow in dealing with employees.
 There must be standardized rules and regulations that govern the student
of the institution and it should be communicated to the students appropriately.
 The institution is also supposed to prepare several programs to orient
students about their rights and obligations.
 Inducing functional conflicts is advantageous for the institution to be effective. So
the institution’s administrative officials are specially required to create such kinds
of conflicts among workers to come up with increased productivity.
 An absence of conflict in an organization cannot be an indicator for effectiveness of
the organization necessarily. So the individuals in the organizations should stop to

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 51


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

think as if the institution is effective because there is no conflict. Rather they are
supposed to analyze the reason why the institution is dormant and take the necessary
remedial action.
 There must be clearly set job boundary for all units and individuals operating in the
organization in order to avoid a conflict results from presence of unclear job
boundary.
 There should be clear demarcation for those works which are performed
interdependently and there should be rules and regulations for setting disputes which
arise from work interdependence.
 Managers in an organization should have to equip themselves with a mechanism to
settle emotional expressions and feelings and an appropriate remedy should be
taken accordingly.
 Every individual in an organization should refrain from transmitting distorted
message and the organization should also set formal communication channel through
which original information reaches each individual without distortion.
 All the necessary information should be disseminated to the employees timely to
avoid a conflict arise because of information’s late delivery.
 The organization should have to refrain itself from penalizing its employees as much
as possible unless the problem created in Sevier. The procedures to penalize mistaken
workers are also supposed to be communicated in advance to all of the
workers in the organization.
 The reward and promotion system of the organization requires great improvement.
There should be clear cut procedures for promoting individuals in an organization.
The reward provided is also supposed to have both internal and external equity.
 The policies and procedures of the organization should have to be communicated
to every as an orientation.
 The organization should have to examine the reason why most of the conflicts are
dysfunctional and corrective measures should have to be taken.
 In order to reduce employee turnover and dissatisfaction, the organization should
have to develop several incentive schemes and every individual should get fair
treatment. As it’s mentioned earlier, internal and external equality should have to be
kept to avoid those problems. Furthermore, conflicts happen between several parties

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 52


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

in the organization should get timely solution before they result in turn over and
dissatisfaction.
 The organizations should have to prepare a special training program for its
employees in order to provide basic information about conflict and how to manage it.
 The management of the organization should have to strive hard in order to
improve its conflict management efficiency by implementing the conflict
management styles suitable for solving the conflicts encountered timely.
 Literatures on conflict management states that gender have no impact on it. So
everybody is supposed to get involved in conflict management without any gender
demarcation for the organization’s best.

REFERENCE
 Amrik Singh Sudan and Kumar,(2003).Management Process and
OrganizationalBehavior,NewDelhi:Animol publications PV..L.T.D
 Cook and Hunsalker (2001) Management and Organization Behavior, 3rd edition,
McGraw – hill , New Delhi
 Fremont, (1987). Organization and Management, 7th edition, New York:McGraw –
hill.
 Ivancivich (1998) Human Resource Management, Donnelly and Sons, New York
 Kumar and Mittal, (2001). Organization Behavior, New Delhi :Annol Publication
PVT.LTD.
 McGraw (2002) Series in Management People in Organization, 2nd edition, New
York:McGraw-hill.
 Schermerhorz, John R, (1996). Management and Organizational Behavior
Essentials,
2nd editions, New York
 William Bengham (1994) Organizational theory, 2nd edition, New York

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 53


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

 McShane Vonglinow, (2000). Organizational Behavior, 3rd edition, New


York :McGraw-hill.
 Schermerhorn ( 1996:240),Mcgraw-Hill(2002:362),Gebretensay( 2002),
Gonie( 1998), Internet resource :- Carter MC Namara, MBA, PHD, Authenticity
consulting, LLC, 1997 ,http://www.wekipedia.com – Dictionary

APPENDIX

Questionnaire (to be filled by Academic and non Academic staff)

The purpose of this study is to assess the conflict management practices of Gibson school
system. This questionnaire is meant to secure relevant data to the study which is believed to
come up with valuable recommendations for problems observed (if any). Therefore, your
genuine support in responding to the raised questions has paramount importance for the
attainment of the study’s objectives. Furthermore, the secrecy of all the information that you
will provide is confidential. Hence, I earnestly request you to fill the questionnaire carefully.
Thank you in advance for your cooperation.

General instruction

 There is no need to write your name.


 Open- ended questions are answered by writing on the space provided. If the space is
not sufficient, please use the back page of the paper or separate paper which ever suit
for you.
 Close- ended questions are answered by placing a tick (✓) mark with in the box.

 Selecting more than one item in case of close ended questions is possible.

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 54


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

I. Respondent’s profile

1. Sex Male Female


2. Age
15-20 26-30 above 40 21-25 31-40
3. Educational level below
Grade 12 BA/ BSC
12th Grade complete MA/MSC
Certificate from technical and vocational institution PhD
Diploma Other

4. Occupation
Academic staff
Non academic staffs any other
___________________________

5. What is your experience in your current occupation in the organization (please


specify in terms of years or months) years months

Years Months

6. Marital status
Single married Divorced Widowed Others (please
specify) ___________
II. Existence of conflict and perception on conflict
7. Have you ever encountered conflict with people in your work place?
Yes No
8. If the answer for question number 7 is yes how often is it?
Very often rarely Often other (please specify)
____________________
9. With whom do you get in to conflict?
Administrative staff Academic staff Students Non Academic
Other(please specify)______________________________________________
10. Do you think all the conflicts harm the organization? Yes No
11. Have you ever tried to create conflict among workers? Yes No
12. If your institution is not faced conflict yet, do you feel that the institution is
effective?
No Yes
III. Frequency of conflict and parties get involved in it
13. How frequent is conflict in your organization? Very frequent

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 55


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Not frequent
Frequent others (please specify) ___________________________________
14. Which parties in your organization are frequently get in to conflict?
Academic staff with academic staff Academic staff with non academic staff
Academic staff with students Non academic staff with students
A academic staff with Administrative staff Administrative staff with
Administrative staff
IV. The way if obtaining information about existence of conflict
15. How do you get the information about the existence of conflict?
Through hearsay from friends and team
Through formal report from the parties felt in conflict Others (please
specify)_________________________________________________

V. Sources of conflict
The sources of conflict in an organization can be broadly classified in to three:
personal factors, structural factors and communication factors.
16. Which of the following personal factors can be a source of conflict in your
organization? Emotions attitudes skill & responsibility diversity
Values & Ethics
Jealousy others (please specify)
_______________________________________________

17. Which of the following structural factors can be source of conflict in your
institution?

Scarcity of resources Interdependence

Unclear job boundary Relationship among the authorities


Goal differences status inconsistencies others (please specify)
____________________________________________
18. Which of the following communication factors can be source of conflict in your
institution? Distorted message Information overload
Emotional state Lack of communication skill
Use of Jargon (technical terms) information’s late delivery Errors in
perceptions empathy others (please specify)
_____________________________________________
19. Are there any other sources of conflict to mention out of what said above?
Penalties Policies & procedures Reward system Cultural differences
Gender differences less obedience Performance appraisal
System & result Assignment of task Others (please specify)
______________________________________________
VI Conflict outcomes

20. What are out comes of the conflicts encountered by your organization?

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 56


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Functional Dysfunctional Both


21. If the outcomes are functional which of the following are the consequences?
It promoted organizational vitality
It increased efficiency
It motivated change
It increased commitment
It leads to new ideas & innovations
Others (please specify

22. Which of the following dysfunctional outcomes of conflict happen in your


institution? Employee turns over
Customer dissatisfactory
Distorted group cooperation
Increased job dissatisfaction
Resource wastage
Diversion of energy from work
Creates negative climate
In efficiency
Others (please specify)
V. Conflict management styles
23. Do you think that conflict management is a difficult task? No Yes
24. If your answer for question above is yes why?
Because of difference in personality
Because of cultural differences between the parties involved in conflict
Because of lack of skill in conflict management
Because of difference in status between all the parties
Other (please specify)
_______________________________________________

25. Which of the following conflict management system do you think is better?

Avoiding (ignoring) Integrating (cooperating) Compromising


Negotiation Obliging (smoothing) Third part intervention
Dominating (forcing) Other (please specify)
__________________________________
VII Information regarding training on conflict
26 Have you ever taken any special training on conflict related issues?
Yes No
27. If your answer for question number 26 is yes, how did you find it?
Excellent Very good Good poor

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 57


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

28. Have you applied what you learnt on the training regarding conflict management
styles? Yes No
VIII. The conflict management practice of the organization
29. How do you evaluate the conflict management practice of the organization?
Excellent Good poor Very good fair
IX. The effect if gender on conflict management
30. Do you think gender have an influence on the effectiveness of managing conflict?
Yes No
31 Which gender do you think is effective in managing conflict?
Male Female Depends on the parties get in to conflict

APPROVAL SHEET

Yardstick International College

Department Of Business Administration

Here by certify that I have gone through and checked this proposal and here by approve the
proposal for final presentation by the candidate.
SUBMITED BY:
Misgana Yacob _________________ ______________
Name of Student Signature Date
APPROVED BY:
Major Advisor:
Dr TASEW SHEDAGA (Doc.) _________________ ______________
Name of the Advisor Signature Date
Head of Department
_____________________ ___________________ ____________
Name Signature Date
College/Institute/Dean
____________________ __________________ ______________

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 58


ASSESSMENT OF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT PRACTICE PROPOSAL

Name signature Date


School of Graduate Studies
_____________________ __________________ _____________
Name Signature Date

PREPARED BY MISGANA Y Page 59

You might also like