Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Information Systems Management

ISSN: 1058-0530 (Print) 1934-8703 (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/uism20

Lessons Learned from an Initial E-Commerce


Failure by A Catalog Retailer

Dien D. Phan, Jim Q. Chen & Sohel Ahmad

To cite this article: Dien D. Phan, Jim Q. Chen & Sohel Ahmad (2005) Lessons Learned from an
Initial E-Commerce Failure by A Catalog Retailer, Information Systems Management, 22:3, 7-13,
DOI: 10.1201/1078/45317.22.3.20050601/88740.2

To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1201/1078/45317.22.3.20050601/88740.2

Published online: 21 Dec 2006.

Submit your article to this journal

Article views: 107

View related articles

Citing articles: 1 View citing articles

Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at


https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=uism20
E-BUSINESS

LESSONS LEARNED
FROM AN INITIAL
E-COMMERCE FAILURE
BY A CATALOG RETAILER
DIEN D. PHAN is a
professor in the
Business Computer Dien D. Phan, Jim Q. Chen, and Sohel Ahmad
Information Systems
Department, St. Cloud As companies rushed into E-commerce in the late 1990s, many predicted that existing catalog
State University, MN. retailers would have a natural advantage over physical store retailers. However, confusing mar-
He holds an M.B.A. ket signals and incorrect management assumptions led to some poor decisions. This article
from the University of explores what went wrong with a successful catalog retailer, Fingerhut Inc., as it initially
Minnesota and a Ph.D. embraced E-commerce in the late 1990s, and some of the lessons learned.
from the University of
Arizona.

JIM Q. CHEN is a HE R A P I D P R O L I F E R AT I O N O F This article explores what went wrong.


professor in the
Business Computer
Information Systems
T E-commerce and rising values of many
E-commerce companies in the 1990s
First we discuss E-commerce concepts and the
visions that evolved. Then we introduce the
convinced many observers that a new case of Fingerhut and some of its competitive
Department, St. Cloud
State University. He
economy had emerged. However, the emer- strengths prior to its initial entry into
holds a B.S. degree gence of this new economy brought many risks E-commerce. We end the article with a discus-
from Xian University as well as opportunities. Scholars and business sion of lessons learned and an update on Fin-
of Technology, China, people alike feared that the price and cost gerhut’s resurrection.
an M.B.A. from transparencies would harm prices and brands
Northern Illinois and make it difficult for traditional companies
University, and a EVOLVING E-COMMERCE CONCEPTS
to survive (Bakos, 1997; Sinha, 2000).
Ph.D. from University In response to the hype and perceived AND VISIONS
of Nebraska at threats, many existing business organizations As technology advanced and the E-commerce
Lincoln. market developed and grew, market niches
redesigned their processes, shifted strategies,
SOHEL AHMAD is a and entered new partnerships. Some emerged opened and closed frequently. As a niche
professor in the successfully, while many others failed. opened up to take advantage of a technology
Management The purpose of this article is to focus on a innovation, enterprises competed to take ad-
Department, St. Cloud catalog retailer: Fingerhut Inc. Pundits predict- vantage of cost savings and first mover advan-
State University. He ed that catalog mail-order telephone-order tages that often result in better market
holds a B.S.M.E. from penetration and profits. At the beginning of the
(MOTO) retailers would have a natural advan-
Bangladesh Institute E-commerce evolution, the potential of online
tage when entering online business because of
of Technology, a
the similar business approach, such as no phys- business was so great that many believed
M.S.I.E. from The
University of Alabama, ical retail stores and efficient order fulfillment E-commerce models would determine the suc-
and a Ph.D. from the centers (Turban et al., 2004). However, Finger- cess of the retailing industry. In particular, on-
University of hut, the second largest MOTO company in 1998, line retailers were perceived as threats to price,
Minnesota-Twin initially failed after it entered E-commerce in brands, and traditional ways of competing in
Cities. 1999. the retail industry. For example, Evans and
I N F O R M A T I O N S Y S T E M S
S U M M E R 2 0 0 5
M A N A G E M E N T
7
E-BUSINESS

Wursters (2000) predicted the demise, literally Furthermore, applications of E-commerce are
“blown to bits,” of traditional retailers as online not stand-alone technologies; they must be in-
companies replaced them. The basic premises tegrated into the company’s overall business
for this prediction were: value chain model (Porter, 1985).
Today’s E-marketplace thus has several new
❚ Price and cost transparency. Because vast
characteristics (Laudon and Traver, 2004):

T
information about prices and costs are avail-
he hype able on the Web, the cost of searching for ❚ Traditional companies were not always hurt
prices, product information, and transac- by the impacts of price and cost transparen-
that had fueled tions would fall drastically.As a consequence, cies. Online shoppers are not necessarily
the growth of consumers would use the Web to shop for cost driven, and can be sensitive to brand
E-commerce products at lowest costs. It was assumed that names and quality.
Web consumers were rational and cost ❚ Intermediaries continue to play an important
indeed created driven. As more consumers shop online, only role in both physical and online retail trade,
opportunities low-cost, high-quality online retailers survive. and many new intermediaries have emerged.
for strong ❚ Lower costs of operations. It was assumed ❚ Online businesses focus on earnings and
that the entry costs to the online retail mar- profits, not just revenue growth.
brick-and- ket were much less than those of traditional ❚ Many brick-and-mortar companies have suc-
mortar brick-and-mortar retail stores because online cessfully expanded into online retailing to
companies to stores would not need physical stores and become click-and-mortar companies, and
warehouses. With the continuous decline in continue to dominate their markets.
expand into technology costs, the cost of building online ❚ New laws and regulations have emerged to
click-and- stores would fall further over time. fuel the growth of E-commerce and protect
mortar ❚ Disintermediation. In some industries, man- the public.
ufacturers and distributors would sell mer-
companies. chandise directly to customers online, However, not all click-and-mortar firms
reduce prices and costs, and eliminate inter- were initially successful in E-commerce. One of
mediaries. As a consequence, traditional the early visible failures was Fingerhut Inc., a
retail stores, as intermediaries, would be catalog mail-order company that by 1998 had
replaced by the Web. revenues of $1.9 billion. Given the authors’
❚ Profits. Low price and disintermediation geographic proximity to the company’s past
would make it difficult for traditional brick- and current headquarters, the case study analy-
and-mortar stores to make profits, and they sis in this article is based on various opportuni-
would be forced out of business. New online ties to gather information from corporate
stores such as Amazon.com would replace speakers, company presentations, press confer-
traditional brick-and-mortar stores. ences, the local media, as well as interviews
with former employees.
Ultimately, these threats to traditional brick-
and-mortar retail stores proved to be greatly ex-
aggerated. By 2000, traditional brick-and-mor- FINGERHUT INC.
tar companies continued to dominate the Fingerhut Inc. opened its doors in 1948 to sell
marketplace while numerous online retailers automobile seat covers in Minneapolis, Minne-
had failed.The hype that had fueled the growth sota. In 1949, it entered the mail-order business
of E-commerce indeed created opportunities and began direct marketing car seat covers to
for strong brick-and-mortar companies to ex- car owners with extended payments and free
pand into click-and-mortar companies. gifts. In 1957, it expanded into selling general
As the surviving traditional companies be- merchandise via catalog mail order. In 1960,
gan to reassess their E-commerce visions, Fingerhut moved its operations to St. Cloud,
Michael Porter (2001) argued that to stay com- Minnesota.As early as 1975, Fingerhut began to
petitive, the key question was not whether to exploit the capabilities of information technol-
deploy technology to enter E-commerce, but ogy to gain competitive advantages and devel-
how to deploy it. Traditional businesses could oped sophisticated credit screening and
achieve a sustainable competitive advantage via consumer buying pattern analysis systems. It
the Internet by using the new technologies to was acquired by American Can Company in
improve their operational effectiveness and 1979. With its sophisticated database market-
their strategic positioning. That is, Internet ing capabilities, it began to offer deferred pay-
technologies could be used as a “complement ment plans to attract new customers and
to” rather than a “cannibal of” traditional ways. extended credit to existing customers in 1981.
8 W W W . I S M - J O U R N A L . C O M
S U M M E R 2 0 0 5
E-BUSINESS

TABLE 1 Fingerhut’s Five-Year Earnings before Acquisition

For the fiscal year ended Dec. 26, 1997 Dec. 27, 1996 Dec. 29, 1995 Dec. 30, 1994 Dec. 31, 1993

Revenues (in thousands) $1,798,617 $1,762,865 $1,814,853 $1,699,772 $1,652,244


Earnings before income taxes (in thousands) $120,871 $64,991 $76,306 $70,926 $111,879
Net earnings (in thousands) $69,329 $40,159 $50,858 $45,925 $75,328
Source: Form 10-K.

Revenues reached $1 billion in 1988; and in catalogs. Then telemarketers would call to fol-
1990, Fingerhut Inc. went public with 6.3 mil- low up with new products. The database mar-
lion shares of stock. In 1995, Fingerhut began keting program worked well and the company
order fulfillment contracts for Infochoice and had a very high rate of repeat purchases: about
Montgomery Ward Direct. That year, about 25 80 percent of the company’s sales came from
million packages were shipped, and Fingerhut repeat buyers.
became the second largest catalog mail-order Through customer data mining, Fingerhut
company in the United States with $1.8 billion also found that customers who recently
in revenues (Table 1). changed their residence were likely to triple
One of Fingerhut’s competitive advantages their purchasing in the twelve weeks after their
was its strategic positioning. It had successfully move, with a peak in buying in the first four
targeted customers in the “sub-prime” credit weeks. Their selections also often followed a
market serving low credit customers who pattern — new furniture, telecommunications
needed extra credit to buy. These customers equipment, and home decorations, but seldom
were willing to pay a premium for the extra jewelry or home electronics. The company
buying power. Fingerhut introduced a so-called used this discovery to tailor a new “mover’s cat-
closed-end credit coupon system that allowed alog” to entice customers who recently moved.
its customers to make installment payments. Because of the large dollar values, the high
In addition, Fingerhut had a vast data min- profit margins, and the effectiveness of its data
ing capability that enabled it to analyze data on mining, Fingerhut initiated significant efforts to
buying habits and demographics to pinpoint sell furnishings and appliances to customers
products that might interest consumers. With who had just moved. By 1998, its warehouses
this capability, Fingerhut could quickly answer were full of appliances and furnishings.
questions such as how much a certain group of Supporting Fingerhut operations were two
customers would spend and who would be IBM 390 mainframes running MVS, a Hitachi
likely to pay their debts. multiprocessor supercomputer, 274 Sun work-
At Fingerhut’s peak, as many as 200 analysts stations, and over 500 Windows NT servers, all
and 40 statisticians mined the database for in- connected via a distributed network. The data
sights that helped the company differentiate it- warehouse was operated in the UNIX Sun envi-
self from competitors and maintain its unique ronment. The 7-terabyte Oracle database could
value proposition. They helped Fingerhut spot crunch up to 2000 variables about a single cus-
consumer shopping patterns and bring rele-
tomer. The data warehouse contained informa-
vant product offerings at attractive prices to
tion on about 71 million customers who made
the customers who were going to be most in-
at least one purchase. Each customer had a pro-
terested.The faster its marketers could identify
file with numerous attributes.
significant new patterns in behavior, the faster
Fingerhut could reach customers with the right This company has focused on refining
offerings at the right time. brilliantly simplistic insight to precisely
For example, Fingerhut published about 25 target the audiences that may want your
different catalogs, but shipped only the general products,” said Andy Johnson, SVP of
merchandise catalog monthly and then tracked market development. “We’ve never
customers’ buying patterns and behaviors. If a done business without some form of da-
customer bought cookware, Fingerhut would tabase marketing. It’s the heart and soul
first follow up with specialized Cooks’ Book of this company, and we wouldn’t be in
and More Houseware & Cooking Supplies business without it (Pearson, 1998).
I N F O R M A T I O N S Y S T E M S
S U M M E R 2 0 0 5
M A N A G E M E N T
9
E-BUSINESS

Fingerhut’s Entry into E-Commerce ❚ Giving customers more buying power


By the end of 1998, Fingerhut management through Fingerhut’s extended credit prod-
was convinced that E-commerce was the new ucts that were not available at other online
way to grow its business. Seeing rapid revenue retailers
growth and soaring stock prices of online re-
However, as Fingerhut moved forward with
tailers such as Amazon.com and AOL.com, Fin-

F ingerhut
gerhut management wanted to copy their
successes and remake Fingerhut into an
more acquisitions and orders, its information
technology failed to keep pace, although plans
were in place to upgrade the Oracle database
struggled with E-commerce player.
with an IBM DB2 running in an IBM multipro-
implementing In the spring of 1998, Fingerhut hired Will-
cessor supercomputer (Pearson, 1998). “The
iam Lansing, a business development manager infrastructure was always a-step-and-half be-
the technology from General Electric Co., as the new president hind,” said a former Fingerhut executive (Bern-
it needed to be of Fingerhut. The goals were to launch the on- er, 2000).
a major line retail operations and boost catalog sales.
Lansing started an E-tailing site called The-
E-commerce Federated’s Acquisition and
Hut.com and bought minority stakes in other
player. E-commerce sites, including PC Flowers and Liquidation of Fingerhut
In 1999, Federated Department Stores ac-
Gift, MountainZone.com, and FreeShop.com.
quired Fingerhut for $1.7 billion as part of its
Between August and November 1998, he also
expansion into E-commerce. Lansing was pro-
acquired other catalog retailers such as Arizona
moted to be the head of Federated Direct,
mail order and Popular Club. To further boost
which included the Internet operations of Fin-
sales, Fingerhut offered credit cards to riskier
gerhut and most Internet operations of Federat-
customers and accelerated its credit rollout
ed. He launched additional Web retailer sites,
schedule, giving cards to 4 million customers
made more investments in Internet start-ups,
in two years instead of the previously sched- and received order fulfillment contracts with 22
uled three years. Revenues soared to $1.9 bil- companies, including eToys and Walmart.com.
lion and Fortune magazine named Fingerhut However, Fingerhut struggled with imple-
one of the “10 companies that get it” in 1999. menting the technology it needed to be a major
“Our business is now the Internet. Fast- E-commerce player. In particular, it needed re-
forward two years and we’ll be one of liable systems to support its order fulfillment
the big five players doing retailing processes (Figure 1). To overcome problems
there.” caused by lack of integration between its front-
office and back-office systems, Fingerhut devel-
— William Lansing, Fingerhut President oped Fingerhut Logistics Software (FLS). Unfor-
(as quoted in Warner, 1999) tunately, the FLS application had a lot of bugs
Fingerhut’s E-commerce objectives also in- that caused order fulfillment problems, such as
cluded building a value proposition that pro- lost orders, shipment delays, and shipments of
vided value-added services to existing mail and incomplete orders. When large waves of orders
telephone order customers. The specific goals from the Web overloaded its processing capaci-
were as follows (Docherty, 2000): ty, the systems crashed. Because the software
did not always accurately track inventory,
❚ Leveraging existing order fulfillment and Fingerhut did not have accurate numbers of
data mining expertise in E-marketplaces stock on hand. In some instances, Fingerhut re-
❚ Shifting from traditional mail and telephone ceived fulfillment orders from customers of val-
orders to more interactive and personal ue-chain partners for items that it did not have
shopping experiences through the Web in stock. In other instances, the orders took so
❚ Shifting from traditional company-centric long to assemble at Fingerhut that its Web part-
“telling and selling” marketing to Web-based, ners had to pay for express shipments.
customer-centric “listening and suggesting” Fingerhut’s expansion plans ran into mas-
marketing based on consumer buying pat- sive problems over the Christmas 1999 selling
terns season. A toy retailer (eToys) that had contract-
❚ Storing customer E-wallets or profiles in a ed Fingerhut to fill and deliver orders suffered
customer relationship management (CRM) numerous order problems, such as incomplete
system order shipments and late delivery of Christmas
❚ Allowing customers better control during gift items. By February 2000, eToys terminated
the purchase process its contract with Fingerhut (Sogini, 2000).
10 W W W . I S M - J O U R N A L . C O M
S U M M E R 2 0 0 5
E-BUSINESS

FIGURE 1 Key Order Fulfillment Processes

Order Placement Order Preparation Order Delivery

- Product Availability - Resource Scheduling - Transport Availability


- Lead Time - Capacity Cushion - Cube Utilization

Feedback and Knowledge Acquisition for Continuous Improvement

Many other companies that had hired Finger- online customers, Fingerhut floundered.
hut to fulfill orders also terminated their con- Fingerhut’s management also failed to ade-
tracts. By the end of 2000, the number of quately analyze the ability to sustain com-
contracts to fill orders at Fingerhut had petitive advantages of the many online
dropped from 22 to 8. businesses in which it invested. Fingerhut’s
Fingerhut sales dipped significantly in 2000 mana gement lacked knowledge in
and 2001, contributing to Federated’s $795 mil- E-commerce and thus was not able to distin-
lion in losses from sales. The aggressive exten- guish between good E-commerce players
sion of credit to riskier customers also caused and the pretenders.
up to $400 million in losses on unpaid credit. 2. Inadequate order fulfillment systems.
In addition to these heavy losses, Federated’s Because E-commerce requires linkages
stock price dropped as investors became ner- between front-office and back-offices oper-
vous about online retailers in general. To turn ations within the supply chain, well-inte-
the business around, Federated tightened credit grated order fulfillment systems are crucial.
standards and closed many of the Web sites that To maintain quality of service, a backup
Fingerhut had launched earlier. In the spring of order fulfillment system may also be
2002, Federated closed the entire Fingerhut needed to temporarily handle orders until
business. problems with a back-office system are
fixed.
3. Data mining capabilities for online retail-
LESSONS LEARNED
ing. Fingerhut already had an established
As E-commerce has evolved, new visions and
data mining capability for its traditional cus-
paradigms have emerged. The lessons learned
tomers, which it considered to be a strate-
from the initial failure of Fingerhut reinforce
gic weapon, but did not initially invest in
the argument that prior success in a mail-or-
this capability for online customers. With
der catalog business does not guarantee suc-
data mining capabilities, a firm can quickly
cess in online E-commerce.That is, experience
pinpoint products that may interest con-
in order fulfillment and ample warehouse ca-
sumers and find out how much a certain
pacity do not automatically translate into suc-
group of customers would spend. Further-
cess in an online business. Three of the IT-
more, a company can look for opportuni-
related risks that caused problems for Finger-
ties to serve its customers’ entire credit
hut as it evolved its clicks-and-mortar capabili-
buying life, from the time they are still in
ties are as follows:
school until their retirement. Starting with
1. Abandoning existing competitive advan- credit purchases for “sub-prime” customers
tages in the deployment of E-commerce. who have no or very little income and poor
Before its entry into E-commerce, Fingerhut’s credit, retailers can tailor product offerings
main competitive advantage was its strategic to their needs. Then they can decide when
positioning, which included a set of “sub- to upgrade or graduate “sub-prime” custom-
prime” customers. However, the demo- ers to a higher income (“prime”) market
graphics of their online customers were not with high-price, high-quality products
the same as that of sub-prime customers. By served by value-chain partners. The deci-
abandoning its strategic positioning for new sion must be just-in-time to lure existing
I N F O R M A T I O N S Y S T E M S
S U M M E R 2 0 0 5
M A N A G E M E N T
11
E-BUSINESS

customers to the value-chain partners and a thorough analysis, design, and quality assur-
preempt them from switching to other ance for large enterprise systems is required
high-end merchants. (Phan et al., 1995), because the costs of quality
and maintenance traditionally far exceed the
Data mining capabilities are also crucial for
savings of not doing thorough front-end work
online retailing. The companies that estab-
and quality assurance. Yourdon (1997) has
lished affiliations with Amazon.com (e.g., Toys-
Rus.com in the past and physical store retailers even called these short development cycle
such as Target and Marshall Fields) are exam- projects a “death march.” However, the devel-
ples of how companies can leverage data col- opment team for Fingerhut Direct justified the
lected from online customers by partnering use of an extremely short development cycle
with a dot.com company with a trusted brand. and bypassed many front-end and testing tasks
This approach also potentially supports life-cy- because the risks from missing the Christmas
cle marketing: as young consumers grow up, season of 2002 were even greater.
they gradually spend less time shopping for
toys and games at Toys “R” Us and spend more CONCLUSIONS
time shopping for books, CDs, and other goods With rapid advances in technology, enterprises
sold by Target and Marshall Fields. today frequently are faced with the need to re-
design their processes in ways that sustain and
FINGERHUT RESURRECTED improve their competitive advantage. Howev-
During the summer of 2002, FAC Acquisitions er, gaining competitive advantage requires
Inc. (founded by Petters Group president Tom building on proven and effective strategies by
Petters and former Fingerhut CEO Ted Deikel) achieving operational efficiency and strategic
repurchased Fingerhut’s remaining assets from positioning.
Federated (which included the customer data- At the beginning of the E-commerce evolu-
base and distribution centers in St.Cloud, Min- tion, the negative effects of bad management
nesota and Tennessee). In November, Fingerhut decisions were masked by distorted market sig-
Direct Marketing was launched as a private nals and the burgeoning of the E-commerce in-
company. With the goal for the online business dustry. Today, the consequences of management
to be available in time for the holiday shopping missteps are more evident. Although the initial
season, Fingerhut outsourced the E-commerce E-commerce failure of Fingerhut can be attrib-
development project to Microsoft. The entire uted to some traditional management prob-
E-commerce system was completed within six lems, the lack of knowledge in E-commerce
weeks, using off-the-shelf components; and by and the lack of initial IT investments to support
the end of 2002, more than 90,000 transactions its new E-commerce strategies were the major
were completed (Microsoft, 2003). causes for the unexpected initial failure of this
In April 2003, the new Fingerhut received traditional catalog retailer. ▲
its first contract to fill orders for uBid.com.The
increased sales allowed Fingerhut to reopen an-
References
other call center in Eveleth, Minnesota, in Au- Bakos, Yanis, Reducing Buyer Search Costs:
gust 2003. For the year 2003, Fingerhut mailed Implication for Electronic Market Place,
5 million specialty catalogs to customers, em- Management Science, 43(12), December
ployed more than 400 people, and saw sales 1997, 1676–1692.
revenues reach $140 million. In 2004, Finger- Berner, Robert, Federated’s Fingerhut Fiasco,
hut Direct named Paul Hanson the new CIO BusinessWeek, Dec. 18, 2000, p. 198–202.
and secured an additional $63 million of equity. Docherty, D., Catalogs and E-Commerce: Key
The new Fingerhut company is reportedly pur- Similarities and Differences from an IS
suing the goal of serving customers for their en- Perspective, unpublished presentation at St.
tire buying life cycle, from the time of low Cloud State University, MN, March 28, 2000.
Evans, P. and Wurster, T., Blown to Bits: How the
income and low credit through the move into
New Economics of Information Transform
better income and credit level.
Strategy, Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business
Today, Fingerhut is back in business on a School Press, 2000.
much smaller and more humble scale. It has Laudon, K. and Traver, C., E-Commerce, Boston,
achieved some early successes in its reentry to MA: Addison-Wesley, 2004.
online business, after taking a calculated risk Microsoft, Fingerhut (Petters), Fingerhut CIO Bets
on a very short system development cycle. Tra- His Job on Microsoft and Wins, http://www.
ditional software engineering wisdom says that microsoft.com/resources/casestudies/CaseStudy

12 W W W . I S M - J O U R N A L . C O M
S U M M E R 2 0 0 5
E-BUSINESS

.asp?CaseStudyID=14281, July 18, 2003. Fulfillment Blunders, Computerworld, Nov. 27,


Accessed Feb. 22, 2005. 2000.
Pearson, David, Marketing for Survival, CIO Sinha, I., Cost Transparency: The Net’s Real Threats
Magazine, April 15, 1998. to Prices and Brands, Harvard Business
Phan, Dien D., Vogel, Douglas, and Nunamaker, Jay Review, March–April 2000.
F., Empirical Studies in Software Development Turban, E., King, D., Lee, J., and Viehland, D.,
Projects: Field Survey and OS/400 Study, Electronic Commerce 2004: A Managerial
Information & Management, No. 28, 1995, Perspective, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson
271–280. Prentice-Hall, 2004, p. 86.
Porter, Michael, Competitive Advantage, New York: Warner, Melanie, 10 Companies that Get It,
Free Press, 1985. Fortune, 140(9), November 8, 1999, 115–118.
Porter, Michael, Strategy and the Internet, Harvard Yourdon, E., Death March: The Software
Business Review, March, 2001, 63–78. Developer’s Guide to Surviving “Mission
Sogini, Marc S., Santa’s Watching Retailers: Online Impossible” Projects, Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Toy Retailers Work to Avoid Last Year’s Prentice Hall, 1997.

I N F O R M A T I O N S Y S T E M S
S U M M E R 2 0 0 5
M A N A G E M E N T
13

You might also like