0$.

,1* '(&,6,216

Bdhi egd\gVbh i]Vi lZ jhZ dc V YV^an WV"
h^h WZ]VkZ Y^[[ZgZcian YZeZcY^c\ dc l]Vi
]VeeZch Yjg^c\ i]Z^g ZmZXji^dc# ;dg ZmVb"
eaZ! l]Zc V ldgY egdXZhhdg Vh`h jh l]Zi]Zg lZ
lVci id hVkZ djg ldg`! ^i bV`Zh V YZX^h^dc WVhZY dc
djg gZhedchZ/ hVk^c\ djg ldg` ^[ lZ VchlZg ÅnZhÆ VcY
cdi hVk^c\ djg ldg` ^[ lZ VchlZg Åcd#Æ >c i]^h X]Ve"
iZg! lZÈaa aZVgc VWdji LI hiViZbZcih! l]^X] aZi djg egd"
\gVbh bV`Z YZX^h^dch#
LZÈaa hdakZ ild egdWaZbh/ YZiZgb^c^c\ i]Z gZhjai d[ V WVh`ZiWVaa \VbZ
VcY YZiZgb^c^c\ l]Zi]Zg V e]dcZ cjbWZg WZadc\h id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg#

3UREOHP  :LQQLQJ 7HDP

>c i]^h egdWaZb! lZÈaa cZZY id djieji V bZhhV\Z i]Vi YZeZcYh dc i]Z dji"
XdbZ d[ V WVh`ZiWVaa \VbZ# Id Yd i]Vi! lZÈaa aZVgc Vaa VWdji LI hiViZbZcih#
LZÈaa Vahd aZVgc ]dl lZ XVc hidgZ VcY bVc^ejaViZ igjZ VcY [VahZ kVajZh ^c
djg egd\gVbh#
I]^h ^h 9BD? egdWaZb FFFM#
 7KH &KDOOHQJH
>c WVh`ZiWVaa! i]gZZ eaVnh hXdgZ ed^cih/ V i]gZZ"ed^ci h]di! V ild"ed^ci h]di!
VcY V dcZ"ed^ci [gZZ i]gdl#
Ndj _jhi lViX]ZY V WVh`ZiWVaa \VbZ WZilZZc i]Z 6eeaZh VcY 7VcVcVh
VcY gZXdgYZY i]Z cjbWZg d[ hjXXZhh[ja i]gZZ"ed^ci! ild"ed^ci! VcY dcZ"
ed^ci eaVnh [dg ZVX] iZVb# >cY^XViZ l]Zi]Zg i]Z \VbZ lVh ldc Wn i]Z
6eeaZh! i]Z \VbZ lVh ldc Wn i]Z 7VcVcVh! dg i]Z \VbZ lVh V i^Z#

,QSXW
I]ZgZ VgZ h^m a^cZh d[ ^ceji# I]Z [^ghi i]gZZ \^kZ i]Z hXdg^c\ [dg i]Z 6eeaZh!
VcY i]Z aViiZg i]gZZ \^kZ i]Z hXdg^c\ [dg i]Z 7VcVcVh#
™ I]Z [^ghi a^cZ \^kZh i]Z cjbWZg d[ hjXXZhh[ja i]gZZ"ed^ci h]dih [dg
i]Z 6eeaZh#
™ I]Z hZXdcY a^cZ \^kZh i]Z cjbWZg d[ hjXXZhh[ja ild"ed^ci h]dih [dg
i]Z 6eeaZh#
™ I]Z i]^gY a^cZ \^kZh i]Z cjbWZg d[ hjXXZhh[ja dcZ"ed^ci [gZZ i]gdlh
[dg i]Z 6eeaZh#
™ I]Z [djgi] a^cZ \^kZh i]Z cjbWZg d[ hjXXZhh[ja i]gZZ"ed^ci h]dih [dg
i]Z 7VcVcVh#
™ I]Z [^[i] a^cZ \^kZh i]Z cjbWZg d[ hjXXZhh[ja ild"ed^ci h]dih [dg i]Z
7VcVcVh#
™ I]Z h^mi] a^cZ \^kZh i]Z cjbWZg d[ hjXXZhh[ja dcZ"ed^ci [gZZ i]gdlh
[dg i]Z 7VcVcVh#
:VX] cjbWZg ^h Vc ^ciZ\Zg WZilZZc % VcY &%%#

2XWSXW
I]Z djieji ^h V h^c\aZ X]VgVXiZg#
™ >[ i]Z 6eeaZh hXdgZY bdgZ ed^cih i]Vc i]Z 7VcVcVh! djieji $ 6 [dg
6eeaZh#
™ >[ i]Z 7VcVcVh hXdgZY bdgZ ed^cih i]Vc i]Z 6eeaZh! djieji % 7 [dg
7VcVcVh#
™ >[ i]Z 6eeaZh VcY 7VcVcVh hXdgZY i]Z hVbZ cjbWZg d[ ed^cih! dji"
eji 7 I [dg I^Z#

&RQGLWLRQDO ([HFXWLRQ
LZ XVc bV`Z V adi d[ ]ZVYlVn ]ZgZ Wn jh^c\ l]Vi lZ aZVgcZY ^c 8]VeiZg &#
LZ XVc jhZ LQSXW VcY LQW id gZVY ZVX] d[ i]Z h^m ^ciZ\Zgh [gdb i]Z ^ceji# LZ
XVc jhZ kVg^VWaZh id ]Vc\ dc id i]dhZ kVajZh# LZ XVc bjai^ean i]Z cjbWZg
d[ hjXXZhh[ja i]gZZ"ed^ci h]dih Wn ( VcY i]Z cjbWZg d[ hjXXZhh[ja ild"ed^ci
h]dih Wn '# LZ XVc jhZ SULQW id djieji Vc $! %! dg 7#

 &KDSWHU 
 L]Vi lZ ]VkZcÈi aZVgcZY nZi ^h ]dl djg egd\gVbh XVc bV`Z V YZX^h^dc
VWdji i]Z djiXdbZ d[ i]Z \VbZ# > XVc YZbdchigViZ l]n lZ cZZY i]^h i]gdj\]
ild iZhi XVhZh#
;^ghi! Xdch^YZg i]^h iZhi XVhZ/








I]Z 6eeaZh hXdgZY * ∗ ( & ∗ ' ( 2 '% ed^cih! VcY i]Z 7VcVcVh hXdgZY
& ∗ ( & ∗ ' & 2 + ed^cih# I]Z 6eeaZh ldc i]Z \VbZ! hd i]^h ^h i]Z XdggZXi
djieji/

HZXdcY! Xdch^YZg i]^h iZhi XVhZ! l]ZgZ i]Z 6eeaZhÈ VcY 7VcVcVhÈ hXdgZh
]VkZ WZZc hlVeeZY/








I]^h i^bZ! i]Z 7VcVcVh ldc i]Z \VbZ! hd i]^h ^h i]Z XdggZXi djieji/

Djg egd\gVb bjhi WZ VWaZ id XdbeVgZ i]Z idiVa ed^cih hXdgZY Wn i]Z
6eeaZh VcY i]Z idiVa ed^cih hXdgZY Wn i]Z 7VcVcVh VcY jhZ i]Z gZhjai d[ i]Vi
XdbeVg^hdc id X]ddhZ l]Zi]Zg id djieji $! %! dg 7#
LZ XVc jhZ Eni]dcÈh LI hiViZbZci id bV`Z i]ZhZ `^cYh d[ YZX^h^dch# 6
XdcY^i^dc ^h Vc ZmegZhh^dc i]ViÈh igjZ dg [VahZ! VcY Vc LI hiViZbZci jhZh XdcY^"
i^dch id YZiZgb^cZ l]Vi id Yd# LI hiViZbZcih aZVY id XdcY^i^dcVa ZmZXji^dc! hd
cVbZY WZXVjhZ i]Z ZmZXji^dc d[ djg egd\gVb ^h ^c[ajZcXZY Wn XdcY^i^dch#
LZÈaa [^ghi aZVgc VWdji V cZl ineZ i]Vi aZih jh gZegZhZci igjZ dg [VahZ kVa"
jZh! VcY ]dl lZ XVc Wj^aY ZmegZhh^dch d[ i]^h ineZ# I]Zc! lZÈaa jhZ hjX] Zm"
egZhh^dch id lg^iZ LI hiViZbZcih#

7KH %RROHDQ 7\SH

EVhh Vc ZmegZhh^dc id Eni]dcÈh W\SH [jcXi^dc! VcY ^iÈaa iZaa ndj i]Z ineZ d[ i]Z
ZmegZhh^dcÈh kVajZ/

!!! W\SH 
FODVV jLQWj!

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 !!! W\SH 
FODVV jIORDWj!
!!! W\SH jKHOORj
FODVV jVWUj!
!!! W\SH   
FODVV jLQWj!

DcZ Eni]dc ineZ lZ ]VkZcÈi bZi nZi ^h i]Z 7ddaZVc ERRO ineZ# Jca^`Z
^ciZ\Zgh! hig^c\h! VcY [adVih! l]^X] ]VkZ W^aa^dch d[ edhh^WaZ kVajZh! i]ZgZ
VgZ dcan ild 7ddaZVc kVajZh/ 7UXH VcY )DOVH# I]ZhZ VgZ ZmVXian i]Z kVajZh lZ
cZZY id gZegZhZci i]Z gZhjai d[ V XdcY^i^dc#

!!! 7UXH
7UXH
!!! )DOVH
)DOVH
!!! W\SH 7UXH
FODVV jERROj!
!!! W\SH )DOVH
FODVV jERROj!

L]Vi XVc lZ Yd l^i] i]ZhZ kVajZh4 L^i] cjbWZgh! lZ ]VY bVi]ZbVi^XVa

deZgVidgh a^`Z  VcY  i]Vi aZi jh XdbW^cZ kVajZh ^cid bdgZ XdbeaZm ZmegZh"
h^dch# LZÈaa cZZY V cZl hZi d[ deZgVidgh i]Vi ldg` l^i] 7ddaZVc kVajZh#

5HODWLRQDO 2SHUDWRUV
>h  \gZViZg i]Vc 4 >h  aZhh i]Vc 4 LZ XVc bV`Z hjX] XdbeVg^hdch jh^c\
Eni]dcÈh gZaVi^dcVa deZgVidgh# I]Zn egdYjXZ 7UXH dg )DOVH VcY VgZ i]ZgZ[dgZ
jhZY id lg^iZ 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dch#
I]Z ! deZgVidg iV`Zh ild deZgVcYh VcY gZijgch 7UXH ^[ i]Z [^ghi ^h \gZViZg
i]Vc i]Z hZXdcY! VcY )DOVH di]Zgl^hZ/

!!!  ! 
7UXH
!!!  ! 
)DOVH

H^b^aVgan! lZ ]VkZ i]Z  deZgVidg [dg aZhh"i]Vc/

!!!   
)DOVH
!!!   
7UXH

I]ZgZÈh ! [dg \gZViZg"i]Vc"dg"ZfjVa"id! VcY  [dg aZhh"i]Vc"dg"ZfjVa"id/

!!!  ! 
7UXH
!!!  ! 

 &KDSWHU 
7UXH
!!!  ! 
)DOVH
!!!   
)DOVH

Id YZiZgb^cZ ZfjVa^in! lZ jhZ i]Z deZgVidg# I]ViÈh ild ZfjVa h^\ch!

cdi dcZ# GZbZbWZg i]Vi dcZ ZfjVa h^\c   ^h jhZY ^c Vc Vhh^\cbZci hiViZ"
bZci0 ^i ]Vh cdi]^c\ id Yd l^i] X]ZX`^c\ ZfjVa^in#

!!!  
7UXH
!!!  
)DOVH

;dg ^cZfjVa^in! lZ jhZ i]Z  deZgVidg# >i gZijgch 7UXH ^[ i]Z deZgVcYh VgZ
cdi ZfjVa VcY )DOVH ^[ i]Zn VgZ ZfjVa/

!!!   
)DOVH
!!!   
7UXH

GZVa egd\gVbh ldjaYcÈi ZkVajViZ ZmegZhh^dch l]dhZ kVajZh lZ VagZVYn

`cdl# LZ YdcÈi cZZY Eni]dc id iZaa jh i]Vi  YdZhcÈi ZfjVa # BdgZ ine^"
XVaan! lZÈY jhZ kVg^VWaZh ^c i]ZhZ `^cYh d[ ZmegZhh^dch# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! QXPEHU
  ^h Vc ZmegZhh^dc l]dhZ kVajZ YZeZcYh dc l]Vi QXPEHU gZ[Zgh id#
I]Z gZaVi^dcVa deZgVidgh Vahd ldg` dc hig^c\h# L]Zc X]ZX`^c\ ZfjVa^in!
XVhZ bViiZgh/

!!! jKHOORj jKHOORj

7UXH
!!! j+HOORj jKHOORj
)DOVH

DcZ hig^c\ ^h aZhh i]Vc Vcdi]Zg ^[ ^i XdbZh [^ghi ^c Vae]VWZi^XVa dgYZg/

!!! jEUDYHj  jFDYHj

7UXH
!!! jFDYHj  jFDYHUQj
7UXH
!!! jRUDQJHj  jDSSOHj
)DOVH

7ji i]^c\h XVc WZ hjgeg^h^c\ l]Zc adlZgXVhZ VcY jeeZgXVhZ X]VgVXiZgh

VgZ Wdi] ^ckdakZY/

!!! jDSSOHj  j%DQDQDj

)DOVH

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 LZ^gY! g^\]i4 >i ]Vh id Yd l^i] i]Z lVn i]Vi X]VgVXiZgh VgZ hidgZY ^ciZg"
cVaan ^c V XdbejiZg# <ZcZgVaan! jeeZgXVhZ X]VgVXiZgh XdbZ Vae]VWZi^XVaan
WZ[dgZ adlZgXVhZ X]VgVXiZgh# 6cY X]ZX` i]^h dji/

!!! jj  jj

7UXH

>[ i]ZhZ lZgZ cjbWZgh! i]Zc i]Z gZhjai ldjaY WZ )DOVH# 7ji hig^c\h VgZ
XdbeVgZY X]VgVXiZg Wn X]VgVXiZg [gdb aZ[i id g^\]i# Eni]dc XdbeVgZh i]Z jj
VcY jj! VcY WZXVjhZ jj ^h hbVaaZg! i]Z  deZgVidg gZijgch 7UXH# 7Z hjgZ i]Vi
ndjg kVajZh ]VkZ i]Z ineZh ndj i]^c` i]Zn ]VkZ
DcZ gZaVi^dcVa deZgVidg i]Vi ldg`h dc hig^c\h Wji cdi cjbWZgh ^h LQ# >i
gZijgch 7UXH ^[ i]Z [^ghi hig^c\ dXXjgh Vi aZVhi dcXZ ^c i]Z hZXdcY! VcY )DOVH
di]Zgl^hZ/

!!! jSSOj LQ jDSSOHj

7UXH
!!! jDOHj LQ jDSSOHj
)DOVH

&21&(37 &+(&.

:KDW LV WKH RXWSXW RI WKH IROORZLQJ FRGH"

D 
E D  
SULQW E

$ 7UXH
% )DOVH
& 
' 7KLV FRGH SURGXFHV D V\QWD[ HUURU

$QVZHU % 7KH H[SUHVVLRQ D   HYDOXDWHV WR )DOVH E LV WKHQ PDGH WR UHIHU WR

WKLV )DOVH YDOXH

7KH LI 6WDWHPHQW
LZÈaa cdl ZmeadgZ hZkZgVa kVg^Vi^dch d[ Eni]dcÈh LI hiViZbZci#

 &KDSWHU 
LI E\ ,WVHOI
HjeedhZ lZ ]VkZ djg [^cVa hXdgZh ^c ild kVg^VWaZh! DSSOHBWRWDO VcY EDQDQD
BWRWDO! VcY lZ lVci id djieji $ ^[ DSSOHBWRWDO ^h \gZViZg i]Vc EDQDQDBWRWDO#
=ZgZÈh ]dl lZ XVc Yd i]Vi/

!!! DSSOHBWRWDO 
!!! EDQDQDBWRWDO 
!!! LI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO
 SULQW j$j

$

Eni]dc djiejih $! Vh lZÈY ZmeZXi#

6c LI hiViZbZci hiVgih l^i] i]Z `ZnldgY LI# 6 `ZnldgY ^h V ldgY i]Vi ]Vh
heZX^Va bZVc^c\ id Eni]dc VcY XVccdi WZ jhZY Vh V kVg^VWaZ cVbZ# I]Z `Zn"
ldgY LI ^h [daadlZY Wn V 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc! [daadlZY Wn V Xdadc! [daadlZY
Wn dcZ dg bdgZ ^cYZciZY hiViZbZcih# I]Z ^cYZciZY hiViZbZcih VgZ d[iZc gZ"
[ZggZY id Vh i]Z WadX` d[ i]Z LI hiViZbZci# I]Z WadX` ZmZXjiZh ^[ i]Z 7ddaZVc
ZmegZhh^dc ^h 7UXH VcY ^h h`^eeZY ^[ i]Z 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc ^h )DOVH#
Cdi^XZ i]Vi i]Z egdbei X]Vc\Zh [gdb !!! id # I]ViÈh V gZb^cYZg i]Vi
lZÈgZ ^ch^YZ i]Z WadX` d[ i]Z LI hiViZbZci VcY bjhi ^cYZci i]Z XdYZ# >ÈkZ
X]dhZc id ^cYZci Wn [djg heVXZh! hd id ^cYZci i]Z XdYZ! egZhh i]Z heVXZWVg
[djg i^bZh# HdbZ Eni]dc egd\gVbbZgh egZhh i]Z I67 `Zn id ^cYZci! Wji
lZÈaa ZmXajh^kZan jhZ heVXZh ^c i]^h Wdd`#
DcXZ ndj ineZ SULQW j$j VcY ]^i :CI:G! ndj h]djaY hZZ Vcdi]Zg 
egdbei# H^cXZ lZ YdcÈi ]VkZ Vcni]^c\ ZahZ id eji ^c i]^h LI hiViZbZci! egZhh
:CI:G V\V^c id Y^hb^hh i]^h egdbei VcY gZijgc id i]Z !!! egdbei# I]^h
ZmigV egZhh d[ :CI:G ^h V fj^g` d[ i]Z Eni]dc h]Zaa0 hjX] WaVc` a^cZh VgZ cdi
gZfj^gZY l]Zc lZ lg^iZ V Eni]dc egd\gVb ^c V [^aZ#
AZiÈh hZZ Vc ZmVbeaZ d[ ejii^c\ ild hiViZbZcih ^c i]Z WadX` d[ Vc LI
hiViZbZci/

!!! DSSOHBWRWDO 
!!! EDQDQDBWRWDO 
!!! LI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO
 SULQW j$j
 SULQW j$SSOHV ZLQj

$
$SSOHV ZLQ

7di] SULQW XVaah ZmZXjiZ! egdYjX^c\ ild a^cZh d[ djieji#

AZiÈh ign Vcdi]Zg LI hiViZbZci! i]^h dcZ l^i] V 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc i]ViÈh
)DOVH/

!!! DSSOHBWRWDO 
!!! EDQDQDBWRWDO 

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 !!! LI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO
 SULQW j$j


I]Z SULQW [jcXi^dc ^h cdi XVaaZY i]^h i^bZ/ DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO ^h

)DOVH! hd i]Z WadX` d[ i]Z LI hiViZbZci ^h h`^eeZY#

LI ZLWK HOLI
AZiÈh jhZ i]gZZ hjXXZhh^kZ LI hiViZbZcih id eg^ci $ ^[ i]Z 6eeaZh l^c! % ^[ i]Z
7VcVcVh l^c! VcY 7 ^[ ^iÈh V i^Z/

!!! DSSOHBWRWDO 
!!! EDQDQDBWRWDO 
!!! LI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO
 SULQW j$j

!!! LI EDQDQDBWRWDO ! DSSOHBWRWDO
 SULQW j%j

!!! LI DSSOHBWRWDO EDQDQDBWRWDO
 SULQW j7j

7

I]Z WadX`h d[ i]Z [^ghi ild LI hiViZbZcih VgZ h`^eeZY! WZXVjhZ i]Z^g 7dda"
ZVc ZmegZhh^dch VgZ )DOVH# 7ji i]Z WadX` d[ i]Z i]^gY LI hiViZbZci ZmZXjiZh!
egdYjX^c\ i]Z 7#
L]Zc ndj eji dcZ LI hiViZbZci V[iZg Vcdi]Zg! i]ZnÈgZ ^cYZeZcYZci#
:VX] 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc ^h ZkVajViZY! gZ\VgYaZhh d[ l]Zi]Zg i]Z egZk^djh
7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dch lZgZ 7UXH dg )DOVH#
;dg Vcn \^kZc kVajZh d[ DSSOHBWRWDO VcY EDQDQDBWRWDO! dcan dcZ d[ djg LI
hiViZbZcih XVc gjc# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! ^[ DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO ^h 7UXH! i]Zc
i]Z [^ghi LI hiViZbZci l^aa gjc! Wji i]Z di]Zg ild l^aa cdi# >iÈh edhh^WaZ id
lg^iZ i]Z XdYZ id ]^\]a^\]i i]Vi dcan dcZ WadX` d[ XdYZ ^h VaadlZY id gjc#
=ZgZÈh ]dl lZ XVc Yd i]Vi/

‚ !!! LI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO

 SULQW j$j
ƒ  HOLI EDQDQDBWRWDO ! DSSOHBWRWDO
 SULQW j%j
 HOLI DSSOHBWRWDO EDQDQDBWRWDO
 SULQW j7j

7

 &KDSWHU 
 I]^h ^h cdl V h^c\aZ LI hiViZbZci! cdi i]gZZ hZeVgViZ LI hiViZbZcih# ;dg
i]^h gZVhdc! YdcÈi egZhh :CI:G Vi i]Z  egdbei0 ^chiZVY! ineZ i]Z HOLI a^cZ#
Id ZmZXjiZ i]^h LI hiViZbZci! Eni]dc WZ\^ch Wn ZkVajVi^c\ i]Z [^ghi 7dda"
ZVc ZmegZhh^dc ‚# >[ ^iÈh 7UXH! i]Zc $ ^h djieji! VcY i]Z gZhi d[ i]Z HOLIh VgZ
h`^eeZY# >[ ^iÈh )DOVH! Eni]dc Xdci^cjZh! ZkVajVi^c\ i]Z hZXdcY 7ddaZVc Zm"
egZhh^dc ƒ# >[ ^iÈh 7UXH! i]Zc % ^h djieji! VcY i]Z gZbV^c^c\ HOLI ^h h`^eeZY#
>[ ^iÈh )DOVH! Eni]dc Xdci^cjZh! ZkVajVi^c\ i]Z i]^gY 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc „# >[
^iÈh 7UXH! i]Zc 7 ^h djieji#
I]Z `ZnldgY HOLI hiVcYh [dg ÅZahZ"^[#Æ JhZ i]^h Vh V gZb^cYZg i]Vi Vc HOLI
ZmegZhh^dc ^h X]ZX`ZY dcan ^[ cdi]^c\ ÅZahZÆ WZ[dgZ ^i ^c i]Z LI hiViZbZci lVh
ZmZXjiZY#
I]^h kZgh^dc d[ i]Z XdYZ ^h Zfj^kVaZci id i]Z egZk^djh XdYZ l]ZgZ lZ
jhZY i]gZZ hZeVgViZ LI hiViZbZcih# =VY lZ lVciZY id Vaadl i]Z edhh^W^a^in
d[ ZmZXji^c\ bdgZ i]Vc dcZ WadX`! lZÈY ]VkZ id jhZ i]gZZ hZeVgViZ LI hiViZ"
bZcih! cdi V h^c\aZ LI hiViZbZci l^i] HOLI WadX`h#

LI ZLWK HOVH
LZ XVc jhZ i]Z HOVH `ZnldgY id gjc XdYZ ^[ Vaa i]Z 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dch ^c
i]Z LI hiViZbZci VgZ )DOVH# =ZgZÈh Vc ZmVbeaZ/

!!! LI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO

 SULQW j$j
 HOLI EDQDQDBWRWDO ! DSSOHBWRWDO
 SULQW j%j
 HOVH
 SULQW j7j

7

Eni]dc ZkVajViZh i]Z 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dch [gdb ide id Wdiidb# >[ Vcn
d[ i]Zb ^h 7UXH! Eni]dc gjch i]Z VhhdX^ViZY WadX` VcY h`^eh i]Z gZhi d[ i]Z LI
hiViZbZci# >[ Vaa i]Z 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dch VgZ )DOVH! Eni]dc ZmZXjiZh i]Z HOVH
WadX`#
Cdi^XZ i]Vi i]ZgZ ^h cd adc\Zg V iZhi [dg DSSOHBWRWDO EDQDQDBWRWDO# I]Z
dcan lVn id \Zi id i]Z HOVH eVgi d[ i]Z LI hiViZbZci ^h ^[ DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQD
BWRWDO ^h )DOVH VcY EDQDQDBWRWDO ! DSSOHBWRWDO ^h )DOVH! i]Vi ^h! ^[ i]Z kVajZh VgZ
ZfjVa#
H]djaY ndj jhZ hZeVgViZ LI hiViZbZcih4 6c LI hiViZbZci l^i] HOLIh4 6c
LI hiViZbZci l^i] Vc HOVH4 >i d[iZc XdbZh Ydlc id egZ[ZgZcXZ# JhZ V X]V^c
d[ HOLIh ^[ ndj lVci Vi bdhi dcZ WadX` d[ XdYZ id ZmZXjiZ# 6c HOVH XVc ]Zae
bV`Z i]Z XdYZ XaZVgZg VcY gZbdkZh i]Z cZZY id lg^iZ V XViX]Vaa 7ddaZVc Zm"
egZhh^dc# L]ViÈh [Vg bdgZ ^bedgiVci i]Vc i]Z egZX^hZ hina^c\ d[ Vc LI hiViZ"
bZci ^h lg^i^c\ XdggZXi ad\^X

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 &21&(37 &+(&.

:KDW LV WKH YDOXH RI [ DIWHU WKH IROORZLQJ FRGH UXQV"

[ 
LI [ ! 
[ 
LI [ ! 
[ 
HOVH
[ 

$ 
% 
& 
' 
( 

$QVZHU ' %HFDXVH [ !  LV 7UXH WKH EORFN RI WKH ILUVW LI VWDWHPHQW H[HFXWHV
7KH DVVLJQPHQW [  PDNHV [ UHIHU WR  1RZ IRU WKH VHFRQG LI VWDWHPHQW
+HUH [ !  LV )DOVH VR WKH HOVH EORFN UXQV DQG [  PDNHV [ UHIHU WR  , G
VXJJHVW FKDQJLQJ LI [ !  WR HOLI [ !  DQG REVHUYLQJ KRZ WKH EHKDYLRU RI WKH
SURJUDP FKDQJHV

&21&(37 &+(&.

'R WKH IROORZLQJ WZR VQLSSHWV RI FRGH GR H[DFWO\ WKH VDPH WKLQJ" $VVXPH WKDW
WHPSHUDWXUH DOUHDG\ UHIHUV WR D QXPEHU

6QLSSHW 

LI WHPSHUDWXUH ! 
SULQW jZDUPj
HOLI WHPSHUDWXUH 
SULQW j]HURj
HOVH
SULQW jFROGj

 &KDSWHU 
 6QLSSHW 

LI WHPSHUDWXUH ! 
SULQW jZDUPj
HOLI WHPSHUDWXUH 
SULQW j]HURj
SULQW jFROGj

$ <HV
% 1R

$QVZHU % 6QLSSHW  DOZD\V SULQWV FROG DV LWV ILQDO OLQH RI RXWSXW EHFDXVH
SULQW jFROGj LV QRW LQGHQWHG ,W LV QRW DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK DQ\ LI VWDWHPHQW

6ROYLQJ WKH 3UREOHP

>iÈh i^bZ id hdakZ L^cc^c\ IZVb# >c i]^h Wdd`! >Èaa \ZcZgVaan egZhZci i]Z [jaa
XdYZ VcY i]Zc Y^hXjhh ^i# 7ji Vh djg hdaji^dc ]ZgZ ^h adc\Zg i]Vc i]dhZ ^c
8]VeiZg &! >ÈkZ YZX^YZY ^c i]^h XVhZ id egZhZci i]Z XdYZ ^c i]gZZ e^ZXZh WZ"
[dgZ egZhZci^c\ ^i Vh V l]daZ#
;^ghi! lZ cZZY id gZVY i]Z ^ceji# I]^h gZfj^gZh h^m XVaah d[ LQSXW! WZXVjhZ
lZ ]VkZ ild iZVbh VcY i]gZZ e^ZXZh d[ ^c[dgbVi^dc [dg ZVX] iZVb# LZ Vahd
cZZY id XdckZgi ZVX] e^ZXZ d[ ^ceji id Vc ^ciZ\Zg# =ZgZÈh i]Z XdYZ/

DSSOHBWKUHH LQW LQSXW

DSSOHBWZR LQW LQSXW
DSSOHBRQH LQW LQSXW

EDQDQDBWKUHH LQW LQSXW

EDQDQDBWZR LQW LQSXW
EDQDQDBRQH LQW LQSXW

HZXdcY! lZ cZZY id YZiZgb^cZ i]Z cjbWZg d[ ed^cih hXdgZY Wn i]Z

6eeaZh VcY i]Z 7VcVcVh# ;dg ZVX] iZVb! lZ VYY i]Z ed^cih [gdb i]gZZ"ed^ci!
ild"ed^ci! VcY dcZ"ed^ci eaVnh# LZ XVc Yd i]Vi Vh [daadlh/

DSSOHBWRWDO DSSOHBWKUHH   DSSOHBWZR   DSSOHBRQH

EDQDQDBWRWDO EDQDQDBWKUHH   EDQDQDBWZR   EDQDQDBRQH

I]^gY! lZ egdYjXZ i]Z djieji# >[ i]Z 6eeaZh l^c! lZ djieji $0 ^[ i]Z
7VcVcVh l^c! lZ djieji %0 di]Zgl^hZ! lZ `cdl i]Vi i]Z \VbZ ^h V i^Z! hd lZ
djieji 7# LZ jhZ Vc LI hiViZbZci id Yd i]^h! Vh [daadlh/

LI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO
SULQW j$j

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 HOLI EDQDQDBWRWDO ! DSSOHBWRWDO
SULQW j%j
HOVH
SULQW j7j

I]ViÈh Vaa i]Z XdYZ lZ cZZY# HZZ A^hi^c\ '"& [dg i]Z XdbeaZiZ hdaji^dc#

DSSOHBWKUHH LQW LQSXW

DSSOHBWZR LQW LQSXW
DSSOHBRQH LQW LQSXW

EDQDQDBWKUHH LQW LQSXW

EDQDQDBWZR LQW LQSXW
EDQDQDBRQH LQW LQSXW

DSSOHBWRWDO DSSOHBWKUHH   DSSOHBWZR   DSSOHBRQH

EDQDQDBWRWDO EDQDQDBWKUHH   EDQDQDBWZR   EDQDQDBRQH

LI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO
SULQW j$j
HOLI EDQDQDBWRWDO ! DSSOHBWRWDO
SULQW j%j
HOVH
SULQW j7j

/LVWLQJ  6ROYLQJ :LQQLQJ 7HDP

>[ ndj hjWb^i djg XdYZ id i]Z _jY\Z! ndj h]djaY hZZ i]Vi Vaa iZhi XVhZh
eVhh#

&21&(37 &+(&.

'RHV WKH IROORZLQJ YHUVLRQ RI WKH FRGH FRUUHFWO\ VROYH WKH SUREOHP"

DSSOHBWKUHH LQW LQSXW

DSSOHBWZR LQW LQSXW
DSSOHBRQH LQW LQSXW

EDQDQDBWKUHH LQW LQSXW

EDQDQDBWZR LQW LQSXW
EDQDQDBRQH LQW LQSXW

DSSOHBWRWDO DSSOHBWKUHH   DSSOHBWZR   DSSOHBRQH

EDQDQDBWRWDO EDQDQDBWKUHH   EDQDQDBWZR   EDQDQDBRQH

LI DSSOHBWRWDO  EDQDQDBWRWDO
SULQW j%j

 &KDSWHU 
 HOLI DSSOHBWRWDO ! EDQDQDBWRWDO
SULQW j$j
HOVH
SULQW j7j

$ <HV
% 1R

$QVZHU $ 7KH RSHUDWRUV DQG RUGHU RI WKH FRGH DUH GLIIHUHQW EXW WKH FRGH LV
VWLOO FRUUHFW ,I WKH $SSOHV ORVH ZH RXWSXW % EHFDXVH WKH %DQDQDV ZLQ  LI WKH
$SSOHV ZLQ ZH RXWSXW $ RWKHUZLVH ZH NQRZ WKDW WKH JDPH LV D WLH VR ZH
RXWSXW 7

7Z[dgZ Xdci^cj^c\! ndj b^\]i a^`Z id ign hdak^c\ ZmZgX^hZ & [gdb Å8]Ve"
iZg :mZgX^hZhÆ dc eV\Z )*#

3UREOHP  7HOHPDUNHWHUV

HdbZi^bZh lZ cZZY id ZcXdYZ bdgZ XdbeaZm 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dch i]Vc
i]dhZ i]Vi lZ ]VkZ hZZc hd [Vg# >c i]^h egdWaZb! lZÈaa aZVgc VWdji 7ddaZVc
deZgVidgh i]Vi ]Zae jh Yd i]^h#
I]^h ^h 9BD? egdWaZb FFFM#

7KH &KDOOHQJH
>c i]^h egdWaZb! lZÈaa VhhjbZ i]Vi e]dcZ cjbWZgh VgZ [djg Y^\^ih# 6 e]dcZ
cjbWZg WZadc\h id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg ^[ ^ih [djg Y^\^ih hVi^h[n Vaa i]gZZ d[ i]Z [da"
adl^c\ egdeZgi^Zh/
™ I]Z [^ghi Y^\^i ^h  dg #
™ I]Z [djgi] Y^\^i ^h  dg #
™ I]Z hZXdcY VcY i]^gY Y^\^ih VgZ i]Z hVbZ#
;dg ZmVbeaZ! V e]dcZ cjbWZg l]dhZ [djg Y^\^ih VgZ  WZadc\h id V
iZaZbVg`ZiZg#
9ZiZgb^cZ l]Zi]Zg V e]dcZ cjbWZg WZadc\h id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg! VcY ^c"
Y^XViZ l]Zi]Zg lZ h]djaY VchlZg i]Z e]dcZ dg ^\cdgZ ^i#

,QSXW
I]ZgZ VgZ [djg a^cZh d[ ^ceji# I]ZhZ a^cZh \^kZ i]Z [^ghi! hZXdcY! i]^gY! VcY
[djgi] Y^\^ih d[ i]Z e]dcZ cjbWZg! gZheZXi^kZan# :VX] Y^\^i ^h Vc ^ciZ\Zg WZ"
ilZZc % VcY .#

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 2XWSXW
>[ i]Z e]dcZ cjbWZg WZadc\h id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg! djieji LJQRUH0 di]Zgl^hZ!
djieji DQVZHU#

%RROHDQ 2SHUDWRUV
L]Vi ]Vh id WZ igjZ VWdji V e]dcZ cjbWZg i]Vi WZadc\h id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg4
>ih [^ghi Y^\^i ]Vh id WZ  dg # 6cY! ^ih [djgi] Y^\^i ]Vh id WZ  dg # 6cY! i]Z
hZXdcY VcY i]^gY Y^\^ih ]VkZ id WZ i]Z hVbZ# LZ XVc ZcXdYZ i]^h ÅdgÆ VcY
ÅVcYÆ ad\^X jh^c\ Eni]dcÈh 7ddaZVc deZgVidgh#

RU 2SHUDWRU
I]Z RU deZgVidg iV`Zh ild 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dch Vh ^ih deZgVcYh# >i gZijgch
7UXH ^[ Vi aZVhi dcZ deZgVcY ^h 7UXH! VcY )DOVH di]Zgl^hZ/

!!! 7UXH RU 7UXH

7UXH
!!! 7UXH RU )DOVH
7UXH
!!! )DOVH RU 7UXH
7UXH
!!! )DOVH RU )DOVH
)DOVH

I]Z dcan lVn id \Zi )DOVH dji d[ i]Z RU deZgVidg ^h ^[ Wdi] d[ ^ih deZgVcYh
VgZ )DOVH#
LZ XVc jhZ RU id iZaa jh l]Zi]Zg V Y^\^i ^h Vc  dg V /

!!! GLJLW 
!!! GLJLW  RU GLJLW 
7UXH
!!! GLJLW 
!!! GLJLW  RU GLJLW 
)DOVH

GZbZbWZg [gdb Å>ciZ\Zg VcY ;adVi^c\"Ed^ci CjbWZghÆ ^c 8]VeiZg &

i]Vi Eni]dc jhZh deZgVidg egZXZYZcXZ id YZiZgb^cZ i]Z dgYZg i]Vi deZgV"
idgh VgZ Veea^ZY# I]Z egZXZYZcXZ d[ RU ^h adlZg i]Vc i]Z egZXZYZcXZ d[ gZaV"
i^dcVa deZgVidgh! l]^X] bZVch i]Vi lZ YdcÈi d[iZc cZZY eVgZci]ZhZh VgdjcY
deZgVcYh# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! ^c GLJLW  RU GLJLW ! i]Z ild deZgVcYh id RU
VgZ GLJLW  VcY GLJLW # >iÈh i]Z hVbZ Vh ^[ lZÈY lg^iiZc ^i Vh GLJLW 
RU GLJLW  #
>c :c\a^h]! ^i bV`Zh hZchZ ^[ hdbZdcZ hVnh Å^[ i]Z Y^\^i ^h - dg .#Æ 7ji
lg^i^c\ i]Vi ldcÈi ldg` ^c Eni]dc/

!!! GLJLW 
!!! LI GLJLW  RU 

 &KDSWHU 
 SULQW j\HVj

\HV

Cdi^XZ i]Vi >ÈkZ ^cXdggZXian lg^iiZc i]Z hZXdcY deZgVcY Vh  ^chiZVY

d[ GLJLW # Eni]dc gZhedcYh Wn djiejii^c\ \HV! l]^X] ^h XZgiV^can cdi
l]Vi lZÈY lVci \^kZc i]Vi GLJLW gZ[Zgh id # I]Z gZVhdc ^h i]Vi Eni]dc Xdc"
h^YZgh cdcoZgd cjbWZgh id WZ 7UXH# H^cXZ  ^h Xdch^YZgZY 7UXH! i]^h bV`Zh i]Z
l]daZ RU ZmegZhh^dc 7UXH# 8VgZ[jaan YdjWaZ"X]ZX` ndjg 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dch
id Vkd^Y i]ZhZ `^cYh d[ b^hiV`Zh l]Zc igVchaVi^c\ [gdb cVijgVa aVc\jV\Z id
Eni]dc#

DQG 2SHUDWRU
I]Z DQG deZgVidg gZijgch 7UXH ^[ Wdi] d[ ^ih deZgVcYh VgZ 7UXH! VcY gZijgch
)DOVH di]Zgl^hZ/

!!! 7UXH DQG 7UXH

7UXH
!!! 7UXH DQG )DOVH
)DOVH
!!! )DOVH DQG 7UXH
)DOVH
!!! )DOVH DQG )DOVH
)DOVH

I]Z dcan lVn id \Zi 7UXH dji d[ i]Z $QG deZgVidg ^h ^[ Wdi] d[ ^ih deZgVcYh
VgZ 7UXH#
I]Z egZXZYZcXZ d[ DQG ^h ]^\]Zg i]Vc RU# =ZgZÈh Vc ZmVbeaZ d[ l]n i]^h
bViiZgh/

!!! 7UXH RU 7UXH DQG )DOVH

7UXH

Eni]dc ^ciZgegZih i]Vi ZmegZhh^dc a^`Z i]^h! l^i] i]Z DQG ]VeeZc^c\ [^ghi/

!!! 7UXH RU 7UXH DQG )DOVH

7UXH

I]Z gZhjai ^h 7UXH WZXVjhZ i]Z [^ghi deZgVcY d[ RU ^h 7UXH#

LZ XVc [dgXZ i]Z RU id ]VeeZc [^ghi Wn ^cXajY^c\ eVgZci]ZhZh/

!!! 7UXH RU 7UXH DQG )DOVH

)DOVH

I]Z gZhjai ^h )DOVH WZXVjhZ i]Z hZXdcY deZgVcY d[ DQG ^h )DOVH#

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 QRW 2SHUDWRU
6cdi]Zg ^bedgiVci 7ddaZVc deZgVidg ^h QRW# Jca^`Z RU VcY DQG! QRW iV`Zh dcan
dcZ deZgVcY cdi ild# >[ ^ih deZgVcY ^h 7UXH! cdi gZijgch )DOVH! VcY k^XZ
kZghV/

!!! QRW 7UXH

)DOVH
!!! QRW )DOVH
7UXH

I]Z egZXZYZcXZ d[ QRW ^h ]^\]Zg i]Vc RU VcY DQG#

&21&(37 &+(&.

+HUH V DQ H[SUHVVLRQ DQG YHUVLRQV RI WKDW H[SUHVVLRQ ZLWK SDUHQWKHVHV :KLFK

RI WKHP HYDOXDWHV WR 7UXH"

$ QRW 7UXH DQG )DOVH

% QRW 7UXH DQG )DOVH
& QRW 7UXH DQG )DOVH
' 1RQH RI WKH DERYH

$QVZHU & 7KH H[SUHVVLRQ 7UXH DQG )DOVH HYDOXDWHV WR )DOVH WKH QRW WKHUHIRUH
PDNHV WKH IXOO H[SUHVVLRQ 7UXH

&21&(37 &+(&.

&RQVLGHU WKH H[SUHVVLRQ QRW D RU E

:KLFK RI WKH IROORZLQJ PDNHV WKH H[SUHVVLRQ )DOVH"

$ D )DOVH E )DOVH
% D )DOVH E 7UXH
& D 7UXH E )DOVH
' D 7UXH E 7UXH
( 0RUH WKDQ RQH RI WKH DERYH

$QVZHU & ,I D LV 7UXH WKHQ QRW D LV )DOVH 6LQFH E LV )DOVH WRR ERWK RSHUDQGV
WR RU DUH )DOVH VR WKH ZKROH H[SUHVVLRQ HYDOXDWHV WR )DOVH

 &KDSWHU 
6ROYLQJ WKH 3UREOHP
L^i] 7ddaZVc deZgVidgh Vi i]Z gZVYn! lZ XVc iVX`aZ i]Z IZaZbVg`ZiZgh egdW"
aZb# Djg hdaji^dc ^h ^c A^hi^c\ '"'#

QXP LQW LQSXW

QXP LQW LQSXW
QXP LQW LQSXW
QXP LQW LQSXW

‚ LI QXP  RU QXP  DQG

QXP  RU QXP  DQG
QXP QXP 
SULQW jLJQRUHj
HOVH
SULQW jDQVZHUj

/LVWLQJ  6ROYLQJ 7HOHPDUNHWHUV

6h ^c L^cc^c\ IZVb! lZ hiVgi Wn gZVY^c\ i]Z ^ceji VcY XdckZgi^c\ ^i id

^ciZ\Zgh#
I]Z ]^\]"aZkZa higjXijgZ d[ djg LI hiViZbZci ‚ ^h i]gZZ ZmegZhh^dch Xdc"
cZXiZY Wn DQG deZgVidgh0 ZVX] d[ i]Zb bjhi WZ 7UXH [dg i]Z Zci^gZ ZmegZhh^dc
id WZ 7UXH# LZ gZfj^gZ i]Vi i]Z [^ghi cjbWZg WZ  dg ! i]Vi i]Z [djgi] cjb"
WZg WZ  dg ! VcY i]Vi i]Z hZXdcY VcY i]^gY cjbWZgh WZ ZfjVa# >[ Vaa i]gZZ
d[ i]ZhZ XdcY^i^dch ]daY! i]Zc lZ `cdl i]Vi i]Z e]dcZ cjbWZg WZadc\h id V
iZaZbVg`ZiZg! VcY lZ djieji LJQRUH# Di]Zgl^hZ! i]Z e]dcZ cjbWZg YdZh cdi
WZadc\ id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg! VcY lZ djieji DQVZHU#
>ÈkZ hea^i i]Z 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc dkZg i]gZZ a^cZh# I]^h gZfj^gZh lgVe"
e^c\ i]Z Zci^gZ ZmegZhh^dc ^c Vc VYY^i^dcVa eV^g d[ eVgZci]ZhZh! Vh > ]VkZ
YdcZ# L^i]dji i]dhZ eVgZci]ZhZh! ndjÈaa \Zi V hnciVm Zggdg! WZXVjhZ i]ZgZÈh
cd ^cY^XVi^dc id Eni]dc i]Vi i]Z ZmegZhh^dc ^h Xdci^cj^c\ dc i]Z cZmi a^cZ#
Eni]dc hinaZ \j^YZh hj\\Zhi i]Vi V a^cZ WZ cd adc\Zg i]Vc ,. X]VgVXiZgh#
6 a^cZ l^i] i]Z [jaa 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc ldjaY hfjZV` ^c i]ZgZ Vi ,+ X]VgVX"
iZgh# 7ji > i]^c` i]Z i]gZZ"a^cZ kZgh^dc ^h XaZVgZg! ]^\]a^\]i^c\ ZVX] XdcY^i^dc
i]Vi bjhi WZ 7UXH dc ^ih dlc a^cZ#
LZ ]VkZ V \ddY hdaji^dc ]ZgZ# Id ZmeadgZ V a^iiaZ [jgi]Zg! aZiÈh Y^hXjhh
hdbZ VaiZgcViZ VeegdVX]Zh#
Djg XdYZ jhZh V 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc id YZiZXi l]Zc V e]dcZ cjbWZg WZ"
adc\h id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg# LZ XdjaY ]VkZ Vahd X]dhZc id lg^iZ XdYZ i]Vi YZiZXih
l]Zc V e]dcZ cjbWZg YdZh cdi WZadc\ id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg# >[ i]Z e]dcZ cjb"
WZg YdZhcÈi WZadc\ id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg! lZ h]djaY djieji DQVZHU0 di]Zgl^hZ! lZ
h]djaY djieji LJQRUH#
>[ i]Z [^ghi Y^\^i ^hcÈi  VcY ^hcÈi ! i]Zc i]Z e]dcZ cjbWZg YdZhcÈi WZ"
adc\ id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg# Dg! ^[ i]Z [djgi] Y^\^i ^hcÈi  VcY ^hcÈi ! i]Zc i]Z
e]dcZ cjbWZg YdZhcÈi WZadc\ id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg# Dg! ^[ i]Z hZXdcY VcY i]^gY
Y^\^ih VgZcÈi ZfjVa! i]Zc i]Z e]dcZ cjbWZg YdZhcÈi WZadc\ id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg#
>[ ZkZc dcZ d[ i]ZhZ ZmegZhh^dch ^h 7UXH! i]Zc i]Z e]dcZ cjbWZg YdZhcÈi WZ"
adc\ id V iZaZbVg`ZiZg#

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 HZZ A^hi^c\ '"( [dg V kZgh^dc d[ i]Z XdYZ i]Vi XVeijgZh i]^h ad\^X#

QXP LQW LQSXW

QXP LQW LQSXW
QXP LQW LQSXW
QXP LQW LQSXW

LI QXP   DQG QXP   RU

QXP   DQG QXP   RU
QXP  QXP 
SULQW jDQVZHUj
HOVH
SULQW jLJQRUHj

/LVWLQJ  6ROYLQJ 7HOHPDUNHWHUV DOWHUQDWH DSSURDFK

>iÈh cdi ZVhn \Zii^c\ Vaa d[ i]dhZ  ! RU! VcY DQG deZgVidgh XdggZXi Cdi^XZ!
[dg ZmVbeaZ! i]Vi lZÈkZ ]VY id X]Vc\Z Vaa deZgVidgh id  ! Vaa RU deZgVidgh
id DQG! VcY Vaa DQG deZgVidgh id RU#
6c VaiZgcViZ VeegdVX] ^h id jhZ i]Z QRW deZgVidg id cZ\ViZ i]Z Å^h V iZaZ"
bVg`ZiZgÆ ZmegZhh^dc ^c dcZ h]di# HZZ A^hi^c\ '") [dg i]Vi XdYZ#

QXP LQW LQSXW

QXP LQW LQSXW
QXP LQW LQSXW
QXP LQW LQSXW

LI QRW QXP  RU QXP  DQG

QXP  RU QXP  DQG
QXP QXP 
SULQW jDQVZHUj
HOVH
SULQW jLJQRUHj

/LVWLQJ  6ROYLQJ 7HOHPDUNHWHUV QRW RSHUDWRU

L]^X] d[ i]ZhZ hdaji^dch Yd ndj [^cY bdhi ^cij^i^kZ4 I]ZgZÈh d[iZc bdgZ
i]Vc dcZ lVn id higjXijgZ i]Z ad\^X d[ Vc LI hiViZbZci! VcY lZ h]djaY jhZ i]Z
dcZ i]ViÈh ZVh^Zhi id \Zi g^\]i# Id bZ! A^hi^c\ '"' ^h i]Z bdhi cVijgVa! Wji ndj
bVn [ZZa di]Zgl^hZ
8]ddhZ ndjg [Vkdg^iZ kZgh^dc VcY hjWb^i ^i id i]Z _jY\Z# Ndj h]djaY hZZ
i]Vi Vaa iZhi XVhZh eVhh#

&RPPHQWV
LZ h]djaY ValVnh hig^kZ id bV`Z djg egd\gVbh Vh XaZVg Vh edhh^WaZ# I]^h
]Zaeh id Vkd^Y ^cigdYjX^c\ Zggdgh l]Zc egd\gVbb^c\ VcY bV`Zh ^i ZVh^Zg
id [^m djg XdYZ l]Zc Zggdgh Yd ha^e ^c# BZVc^c\[ja kVg^VWaZ cVbZh! heVXZh

 &KDSWHU 
 VgdjcY deZgVidgh! WaVc` a^cZh id hZ\bZci i]Z egd\gVb ^cid ^ih ad\^XVa e^ZXZh!
h^beaZ LI hiViZbZci ad\^X/ Vaa d[ i]ZhZ egVXi^XZh XVc ^begdkZ i]Z fjVa^in d[
i]Z XdYZ lZ lg^iZ# 6cdi]Zg \ddY ]VW^i ^h VYY^c\ XdbbZcih id djg XdYZ#
6 XdbbZci ^h ^cigdYjXZY Wn i]Z  X]VgVXiZg VcY Xdci^cjZh jci^a i]Z ZcY
d[ i]Z a^cZ# Eni]dc ^\cdgZh XdbbZcih! hd i]Zn ]VkZ cd ^beVXi dc l]Vi djg
egd\gVb YdZh# LZ VYY XdbbZcih id gZb^cY djghZakZh! dg di]Zgh! VWdji YZ"
h^\c YZX^h^dch i]Vi lZÈkZ bVYZ# 6hhjbZ i]Vi i]Z eZghdc gZVY^c\ i]Z XdYZ
`cdlh Eni]dc! hd Vkd^Y XdbbZcih i]Vi h^bean gZhiViZ l]Vi i]Z XdYZ ^h Yd"
^c\# =ZgZÈh XdYZ l^i] Vc jccZXZhhVgn XdbbZci/

!!! [ 
!!! [ [    ,QFUHDVH [ E\ 

I]Vi XdbbZci VYYh cdi]^c\ WZndcY l]Vi lZ VagZVYn `cdl VWdji Vhh^\c"
bZci hiViZbZcih#
HZZ A^hi^c\ '"* [dg V kZgh^dc d[ A^hi^c\ '"' l^i] XdbbZcih#

‚  FFFM 7HOHPDUNHWHUV

QXP LQW LQSXW

QXP LQW LQSXW
QXP LQW LQSXW
QXP LQW LQSXW

ƒ  7HOHPDUNHWHU QXPEHU ILUVW GLJLW  RU  IRXUWK GLJLW  RU 

 VHFRQG GLJLW DQG WKLUG GLJLW DUH VDPH
LI QXP  RU QXP  DQG
QXP  RU QXP  DQG
QXP QXP 
SULQW jLJQRUHj
HOVH
SULQW jDQVZHUj

/LVWLQJ  6ROYLQJ 7HOHPDUNHWHUV FRPPHQWV DGGHG

>ÈkZ VYYZY i]gZZ XdbbZci a^cZh/ i]Z dcZ Vi i]Z ide ‚ gZb^cYh jh d[ i]Z
egdWaZb XdYZ VcY cVbZ! VcY i]Z ild WZ[dgZ i]Z LI hiViZbZci ƒ gZb^cY jh
d[ i]Z gjaZh [dg YZiZXi^c\ V iZaZbVg`ZiZg e]dcZ cjbWZg#
9dcÈi \d dkZgWdVgY l^i] XdbbZcih# L]ZcZkZg edhh^WaZ! lg^iZ XdYZ i]Vi
YdZhcÈi gZfj^gZ XdbbZcih ^c i]Z [^ghi eaVXZ# 7ji [dg ig^X`n XdYZ dg id YdXj"
bZci l]n ndj X]dhZ id Yd hdbZi]^c\ ^c V eVgi^XjaVg lVn! V lZaa"eaVXZY Xdb"
bZci cdl XVc hVkZ i^bZ VcY [gjhigVi^dc aViZg#

,QSXW DQG 2XWSXW 5HGLUHFWLRQ

L]Zc ndj hjWb^i Eni]dc XdYZ id i]Z _jY\Z! ^i gjch bVcn iZhi XVhZh id YZiZg"
b^cZ l]Zi]Zg ndjg XdYZ ^h XdggZXi# >h hdbZdcZ i]ZgZ! Yji^[jaan lV^i^c\ [dg
cZl XdYZ VcY i]Zc [gVci^XVaan ]VbbZg^c\ iZhi XVhZh Vi ^i [gdb i]Z `ZnWdVgY4

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV 
 Cd lVn >iÈh Vaa VjidbViZY# I]ZgZÈh cd dcZ ine^c\ iZhi XVhZh Vi i]Z `Zn"
WdVgY# =dl YdZh i]Z _jY\Z iZhi djg XdYZ! i]Zc! ^[ lZ hVi^h[n V XVaa id LQSXW Wn
ine^c\ hdbZi]^c\ [gdb i]Z `ZnWdVgY4
I]Z igji] ^h i]Vi LQSXW ^hcÈi cZXZhhVg^an gZVY^c\ ^ceji [gdb i]Z `ZnWdVgY#
>iÈh gZVY^c\ [gdb V hdjgXZ d[ ^ceji XVaaZY hiVcYVgY ^ceji! l]^X]! Wn YZ[Vjai! ^h
i]Z `ZnWdVgY#
>iÈh edhh^WaZ id X]Vc\Z hiVcYVgY ^ceji hd i]Vi ^i gZ[Zgh id V [^aZ gVi]Zg
i]Vc i]Z `ZnWdVgY# I]Z iZX]c^fjZ ^h XVaaZY ^ceji gZY^gZXi^dc! VcY ^iÈh l]Vi i]Z
_jY\Z jhZh id egdk^YZ ^ceji#
LZ XVc Vahd ign ^ceji gZY^gZXi^dc djghZakZh# ;dg egd\gVbh l]dhZ ^ceji
^h hbVaaÄ_jhi V a^cZ d[ iZmi dg V XdjeaZ d[ ^ciZ\ZghÄ^ceji gZY^gZXi^dc bVn cdi
hVkZ jh bjX]# 7ji [dg egd\gVbh l]dhZ iZhi XVhZh XVc WZ iZch dg ]jcYgZYh d[
a^cZh adc\! ^ceji gZY^gZXi^dc bV`Zh ^i bjX] ZVh^Zg id iZhi djg ldg`# GVi]Zg
i]Vc ine^c\ i]Z hVbZ iZhi XVhZ dkZg VcY dkZg! lZ XVc hidgZ ^i ^c V [^aZ VcY
i]Zc gjc djg egd\gVb dc ^i Vh bVcn i^bZh Vh lZ lVci#
AZiÈh ign ^ceji gZY^gZXi^dc dc IZaZbVg`ZiZgh# CVk^\ViZ id ndjg egd\gVb"
b^c\ [daYZg VcY XgZViZ V cZl [^aZ XVaaZY iZaZbVg`ZiZghT^ceji#imi# >c i]Vi [^aZ!
ineZ i]Z [daadl^c\/






I]Z egdWaZb heZX^[^Zh i]Vi lZ h]djaY egdk^YZ dcZ ^ciZ\Zg eZg a^cZ! hd
lZÈkZ lg^iiZc i]Zb dcZ eZg a^cZ ]ZgZ#
HVkZ i]Z [^aZ# Cdl ZciZg S\WKRQ WHOHPDUNHWHUVS\  WHOHPDUNHWHUVBLQSXWW[W
id gjc ndjg egd\gVb jh^c\ ^ceji gZY^gZXi^dc# Ndjg egd\gVb h]djaY djieji
LJQRUH! _jhi Vh ^i ldjaY ^[ ndjÈY ineZY i]Z iZhi XVhZ [gdb i]Z `ZnWdVgY#
I]Z  hnbWda ^chigjXih ndjg deZgVi^c\ hnhiZb id jhZ V [^aZ gVi]Zg i]Vc
i]Z `ZnWdVgY id egdk^YZ ^ceji# 6[iZg i]Z  hnbWda XdbZh i]Z cVbZ d[ i]Z
[^aZ i]Vi XdciV^ch i]Z ^ceji#
Id ign ndjg egd\gVb dc Y^[[ZgZci iZhi XVhZh! _jhi bdY^[n i]Z iZaZbVg`ZiZgh
T^ceji#imi [^aZ VcY gjc ndjg egd\gVb V\V^c#
LZ XVc Vahd X]Vc\Z l]ZgZ djg djieji \dZh! i]dj\] lZ ldcÈi cZZY id [dg
i]^h Wdd`# I]Z SULQW [jcXi^dc djiejih id hiVcYVgY djieji! l]^X]! Wn YZ[Vjai! ^h
i]Z hXgZZc# LZ XVc X]Vc\Z hiVcYVgY djieji hd i]Vi ^i ^chiZVY gZ[Zgh id V [^aZ#
LZ Yd hd jh^c\ djieji gZY^gZXi^dc! l]^X] ^h lg^iiZc Vh V ! hnbWda [daadlZY Wn V
[^aZcVbZ#
:ciZg S\WKRQ WHOHPDUNHWHUVS\ ! WHOHPDUNHWHUVBRXWSXWW[W id gjc ndjg
egd\gVb jh^c\ djieji gZY^gZXi^dc# Egdk^YZ [djg ^ciZ\Zgh d[ ^ceji! VcY ndj
h]djaY WZ WVX` id ndjg deZgVi^c\ hnhiZb egdbei# 7ji ndj h]djaYcÈi hZZ Vcn
djieji [gdb ndjg IZaZbVg`ZiZgh egd\gVb I]ViÈh WZXVjhZ lZÈkZ gZY^gZXiZY
i]Z djieji id [^aZ WHOHPDUNHWHUVBRXWSXWW[W# >[ ndj deZc WHOHPDUNHWHUVBRXWSXW
W[W ^c ndjg iZmi ZY^idg! ndj h]djaY hZZ i]Z djieji i]ZgZ#
7Z XVgZ[ja l^i] djieji gZY^gZXi^dc# >[ ndj jhZ V [^aZcVbZ i]Vi VagZVYn Zm"
^hih! ndjg daY [^aZ l^aa WZ dkZglg^iiZc 6alVnh YdjWaZ"X]ZX` i]Vi ndjÈgZ jh^c\
i]Z [^aZcVbZ ndj ^ciZcYZY#

 &KDSWHU 
6XPPDU\
>c i]^h X]VeiZg! lZ aZVgcZY ]dl id jhZ LI hiViZbZcih id Y^gZXi l]Vi djg egd"
\gVbh Yd# I]Z `Zn ^c\gZY^Zci d[ Vc LI hiViZbZci ^h V 7ddaZVc ZmegZhh^dc!
l]^X] ^h Vc ZmegZhh^dc l^i] V 7UXH dg )DOVH kVajZ# Id Wj^aY je 7ddaZVc Zm"
egZhh^dch! lZ jhZ gZaVi^dcVa deZgVidgh hjX] Vh VcY ! ! VcY lZ jhZ 7ddaZVc
deZgVidgh hjX] Vh DQG VcY RU#
9ZX^Y^c\ l]Vi id Yd WVhZY dc l]Vi ^h 7UXH VcY )DOVH bV`Zh djg egd\gVbh
bdgZ [aZm^WaZ! VWaZ id VYVei id i]Z h^ijVi^dc Vi ]VcY# 7ji djg egd\gVbh VgZ
hi^aa a^b^iZY id ]VcYa^c\ hbVaa Vbdjcih d[ ^ceji VcY djiejiÄl]ViZkZg lZ
XVc Yd l^i] ^cY^k^YjVa XVaah id LQSXW VcY SULQW# >c i]Z cZmi X]VeiZg! lZÈaa
hiVgi aZVgc^c\ VWdji addeh! l]^X] aZi jh gZeZVi XdYZ hd i]Vi lZ XVc egdXZhh
Vh bjX] ^ceji VcY djieji Vh lZ a^`Z#
LVci id ldg` l^i] &%% kVajZh4 =dl VWdji &!%%%4 6cY l^i] _jhi V hbVaa
Vbdjci d[ Eni]dc XdYZ4 >i ^h V a^iiaZ ZVgan [dg bZ id WZ egdkd`^c\ ndj! >
`cdl! WZXVjhZ ndj hi^aa ]VkZ i]Z [daadl^c\ ZmZgX^hZh id Yd# 7ji l]Zc ndjÈgZ
gZVYn! gZVY dc

&KDSWHU ([HUFLVHV
=ZgZ VgZ hdbZ ZmZgX^hZh [dg ndj id ign#

&# 9BD? egdWaZb FFFM! 8VcVY^Vc 8Vadg^Z 8djci^c\

'# 9BD? egdWaZb FFFM! HeZX^Va 9Vn
(# 9BD? egdWaZb FFFM! =Veen dg HVY
)# 9BD? egdWaZb GPRSFFS! 8#8# VcY 8]ZZhZ"`jc
*# 9BD? egdWaZb FFFM! L]d ^h ^c i]Z B^YYaZ

1RWHV
L^cc^c\ IZVb ^h dg^\^cVaan [gdb i]Z '%&. 8VcVY^Vc 8dbeji^c\ 8dbeZi^"
i^dc! ?jc^dg AZkZa# IZaZbVg`ZiZgh ^h dg^\^cVaan [gdb i]Z '%&- 8VcVY^Vc 8db"
eji^c\ 8dbeZi^i^dc! ?jc^dg AZkZa#

0DNLQJ 'HFLVLRQV