11/25/22, 12:44 PM SMART

Create ER Report Comments(1)

ER Request Information

ER Request No.: R2A-22-ER04242 Submitted Date 09/11/2022 15:50

Time:

ER Request Status: Approved ER Request General

Category:

ER Criteria Health Safety Security School Operation Statutory Compliance Political

Sensitivity Other Consideration:

School Code: 5107 School Name: CNEC TA TUNG SCHOOL

School/Boarding School 中華傳道會許大同學校

Section:

District: Kwai Chung & Tsing Yi School Share N

Indicator:

School Level: Primary Asbestos Exists: N

Contact Name: 梁志偉主任 Contact Tel: 24219159

Contact Fax: 24283310 Contact Email:

Estate / Non-Estate: Estate

Address: Address 1

ESTATE SCHOOL NO.1 KWAI HING ESTATE KWAI CHUNG NT

Works Item(s)

Item Location Description Reason Address Uploaded Attachments

No.

1 舊翼課室牆身爆裂 修復爆裂和剝落的牆 因鹹水樓關係，舊 1

及剝落(206室、 身 翼課室牆身石屎及

303室、306室) 灰經常爆裂及剝落,

而且該位置經常有

學生出入，剝落的

碎塊或其他潛在危

險，有可能令師生

受傷，危及師生安

全。

https://smartschool.edb.gov.hk/portal/desktop/index.do 1/5
11/25/22, 12:44 PM SMART

Part I. General Information

School Rep: 梁志偉主任

Consultant Rep: Gary Chan

Sub Consultant Rep:

Contractor Rep:

Inspection Date 14/11/2022 Inspection 16:00

Time:

Part II. Description of Defects

Works Item 1

Defects Location:

-Room 206, 303, 306

Observation:

-During the site inspection, debonded plaster at wall was noted.

Those defects may cause incidents at high level. It should be

considered a safety issue and reported as an ER.

Description:location plan

Location:2/F Recommendation:

-Removal of debonded plaster, plastering to the defective areas

and repaint the affected areas were recommended.

https://smartschool.edb.gov.hk/portal/desktop/index.do 2/5
11/25/22, 12:44 PM SMART

Remarks:

Description:location plan

Location:3/F

Description:

Location:Room 303

Description:

Location:Room 306

Recommendation:Recommended

Part III. Estimation Sheet

B-Order, Estimation Sheet

Item: SoR/NSR Description Quantity Unit Rate Contract Amount

1. Works Item: 修復爆裂和剝落的牆身

1.Plastering to defective areas (Location:Room 206, 303, 306)

11329A T/D & C/A PLASTER 3 m2 $12.20 123.74% $45.29

https://smartschool.edb.gov.hk/portal/desktop/index.do 3/5
11/25/22, 12:45 PM SMART

11044D INT'L LIME PLASTER 2 COAT ON WALL 3 m2 $53.30 123.74% $197.86

Sub-Total $243.15

Contingency $2,917.80

Total $3,160.95

Contingency: 1200%

Reason Contingency exceeds 10%: Safety issue.

Justification of Special SoR (for B/P/E Estimation Sheet)

If there is any SoR item in YELLOW in estimation sheet, it indicates that you have
selected to use some special materials. For those special materials, you have to
provide justification in the report/in the box below why those materials are needed.

SoR item in GREEN represents works item which isn't recommended.

SoR item in YELLOW represents special SoR which requires justification of the usage of such
material.

Part V-I. Contains Repeated ER

By Laura Works Item 1: 修復爆裂和剝落的牆身

YUEH Contains No

(9OG102SSS- Repeated

2A4) ER

ER

Request

No. of

Related

Case

Type of

Repeated

Case

https://smartschool.edb.gov.hk/portal/desktop/index.do 4/5
11/25/22, 12:45 PM SMART

Remark (TC

to advise

reason(s)

for

repeated

item and

recommend

follow up

actions)

Back

ER Report Prepared By:

For 1st submission, Updated by Laura YUEH, dated 16/11/2022

For subsequent submission, Created by Laura YUEH, dated 16/11/2022

Date User Comment

17/11/2022 11:52 WONG Kee Soon(CW(SPM)21) No comment.

https://smartschool.edb.gov.hk/portal/desktop/index.do 5/5