Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bookreviewconsolidated 2
Bookreviewconsolidated 2
Author - S. S. Gill
Gist -
Analysis -
The author has held nothing back in dealing with corruption in different
spheres of our national life and the treatment is fair, objective and
balanced. This is perhaps the most comprehensive and incisive critique
of corruption in India written so far.
Comments -
Weak Enforcement of Law: Various laws have been made to curb the
evil of corruption but their weak enforcement has acted as a hindrance in
curbing corruption.
Greed for Illegitimate Money: Various scams like the telgi stamp scam
took place due to the inexhaustible appetite for illegal illegitimate funds.
Free and Fair media: A free media has a crucial role in prevention,
monitoring and control of corruption.
ANKITA GAUTAM, C8
Book name: Anticipating India – The Best of National Interest
Author: Shekhar Gupta
About the author: Shekhar Gupta is an Indian journalist and author. He
is the founder and current editor-in-chief of The Print. He was awarded
the Padma Bhushan in 2009.
Summary of the Book: This book gives a sneak peak at the changing
face of Indian politics, and other national issues that took place during
the last two decades. This book interprets everything from the successes
and failings of Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh to the ascent
of Rahul Gandhi, Narendra Modi and Arvind Kejriwal, from the forces
that have deepened Indian federalism and constitutionalism to the public
mood that keeps a check on excesses in the use of political power. This
book is based on themes of politics and political economy. It is not a
work of contemporary history and is not entirely chronological either.
In the book the author clearly mentions that he has no answers for how
things change in Indian politics and why. It is not as if there is no logic to
Indian politics. It is just that it is complex, with many variables, shuffling
loyalties, shifting priorities, alliances, flexible ideologies and unshakable
vested interests.
The author says that a journalist should never ignore politicians when
they are not in power. That is when they have the most time and
patience. Also, there are no permanent pygmies or titans in our politics.
The author suggests to keep one’s distance, in politics even more that in
armed conflict, because love and hate cloud judgement.
The book describes about the modern India politics by putting across
various questions to the politicians. Looking forward to the progress and
development of India, covering every crucial and central aspect the
author answers the questions like When did the Congress first start
shrinking its prime minister? When did it become clear that Narendra
Modi would take over his party? And what does an angry Arvind Kejriwal
say about us?
Each and every chapter in Anticipating India, is in the format of
questioning power, its use and abuse, carries within it ideas of India
challenging conventional wisdom, destroy stereotypes and, in the end,
question our long-held postulations and statements of who we are as a
nation and its pupil.
ARZOO, C09
Colonel M.S Jarg is the third out of the only five Indian Army officers to
have been awarded the MacGregor Medal for the successful completion
of an important military task at great personal risk. He devotes some of
his time to writing and already has three books to his credit.
In this book he discussed and opened up the unknown facts and
incidents of the famous events like the post cold war era, anomalies of
India's post independence foreign policy, why nations disintegrate,
impact of Soviet disintegration on the international political environment,
The euphoria of solidarity of the North and it's impact upon the South,
India's security perception, emerging changes in the US - Pak scenario
with a cause, changing military strategies, India's role in the future of
SAARC and China's role in Asia.
Understanding these important phases of world is vital to know the
geopolitics of the world.
Global politics has undergone a wide array of changes over the years
and accordingly International Relation too has adapted itself. Keeping in
mind those changes this book covers chapters on themes like security,
area wise trends, globalisation, regionalism, regional response to
terrorism, environmental governance, gender etc. Contemporary
International Relations have been highlighted comprehensively.
To briefly sum up, the deficit of global governance is growing bigger and
bigger. The current International regimes are more and more unable to
deal with the emerging global issues and urgently need to be renovated.
Otherwise political, ethical and religious conflicts in certain areas will run
out of control the cooperation between great powers cannot be
deepened and continued and the harmony between human and nature
will be seriously damaged.
Gist: The book alarmingly presents the horrifying realities of future war
describing the criteria for war and how the war strategy has evolved over
the centuries. Through the presentation of this rational evolution, authors
scientifically project the trajectory of future war. However, they also
present curiously optimistic and exciting strategies for future peace.
Because it is with the knowledge of war, peace is attainable. Anti-war
strategy is incomprehensive unless it takes into account the in and out of
war.
Analysis: The book is written in six parts, each talking about various
dimensions of war and peace. The first part, ‘Conflict’, introduces the
readers to the genesis of war, detailing how the world has evolved with
wars. The next, ‘Trajectory’, draws a picture of how the war itself has
been evolving with time and also the interrelation between changes in
the way of making money and the developments of war tactics.
‘Exploration’ talks about various types of wars that did and could happen
both in and out of the battlefield. ‘Knowledge’ is all about the brains that
work behind the military might. It beautifully convinces the readers in
such a convincing manner that brains play a more active role than
swords in wars. ‘Danger’ brings forward the real problems that the world
might and will have to face at the advent of ultra modernity. The last part
‘Peace’ enlists the forms of peace in the future and also predicts the
global form of the 21st century.
The book opens with one of the authors’ meeting with one of the top
military officials in the USA who is into devising war strategies keeping in
mind the future courses of war techniques. The author takes inspiration
from the officer that he could work for the security of the nation of
tomorrow and not just today. Eventually, the author realises that though
scholars opined that the shape of tomorrow would essentially be
determined by economic, not military warfare; economic wars just acted
as prelude to military warfare.
According to authors, the first wave war is of the period in which the
economy is majorly dependent on land. The second wave is of the
period of mass production in the economy accompanied by mass
destruction in warfare. This period explains how standardisation of
weapons, military training, organisation and doctrines has taken place.
The authors defined this as the period of ‘industrialising death’.
The conclusions drawn from the examples of the Israel - Syria war and
the wars that the US led in Central Asia added to the war studies.
The lessons learnt from those conclusions helped the authors to define
the tactics of anti-war and peace in the last part of the book. It opens up
interesting ideas towards peace and proposes rational doctrines not for
individual countries but for the larger global system to stay intact.
In the third chapter, the author nicely delineated the organization of the
movement, the supply, civil administration, the role of women, sabotage,
medical care industry, propaganda, intelligence, training and overall
leadership were thoroughly discussed. He pointed out the organisation
of the initial clandestine Guerilla band defending that which has been
won and an epilogue about the analysis of the Cuban situation is
presence and its future.
Gist: The author in the book tries to analyse the similarities and contrasts
in the making of the two neighbouring countries from where he
elaborated the evolution of the two. All the spheres of administration,
politics and democracy were comprehensively presented to draw an
articulate picture in the minds of readers about the length and breadth of
the countries so that the reasons for conflict and warfare could well be
understood. The book ends noting that the future of the relations
between the two nations is indefinite as the developments never gave
hope for stability.
Analysis: Pakistan and India are the two immediate neighbours having
common history and culture. In this way, they should have the warmest
ties. But their relationships have remained hostile all the time. Kashmir is
the bone of contention between the two nations, over which three main
wars have been fought between them. Despite some important and
effective peace initiatives, the main problems in maintaining the bitter
taste in bilateral relations remain unresolved.
The book throws light on the political developments in both nations
before and after the independence to let us appreciate the role played by
the politics in driving both the nations to the path which they are on
today. Socio-economic constraints have been kept in mind while
analysing the political structures in both the countries. Though the author
chose not to suggest any logical solution either for the Kashmir
conundrum or the water issues between the states, the reason for it
could well be understood in the articulations he has put forward in the
analysis. However, the author was clear enough about the coming
course of both the countries in the last chapter saying that the future is
indefinite. The author was humble to understand and make the readers
appreciate the complexities and intricacies that both the countries are
entangled in.
“A king shall have his agents in the courts of the enemy, the ally, the
middle and the neutral kings to spy on the kings as well as eighteen
types of high officials”
– Kautilya’s Arthashastra
BOOK REVIEW
TITLE
" The Islamist Threat , Myth or Reality"
ABOUT OF AUTHOR
John Louis Esposito (born May 19, 1940) is an Italian-American
academic, professor of Middle Eastern and religious studies, and scholar
of Islamic studies,who serves as Professor of Religion, International
Affairs, and Islamic Studies at Georgetown University in Washington,
D.C. He is also the founding director of the Prince Alwaleed Center for
Muslim–Christian Understanding at Georgetown.
ANALYSIS
Are Islam and the West on a collision course? From the Ayatollah
Khomeini to Saddam Hussein, the image of Islam as a militant,
expansionist, and rabidly anti-American religion has gripped the minds of
Western governments and media. But these perceptions, John L.
Esposito writes, stem from a long history of mutual distrust, criticism, and
condemnation, and are far too simplistic to help us understand one of
the most important political issues of our time. In this new edition of The
Islamic Threat: Myth or Reality?, Esposito places the challenge of Islam
in critical perspective. Exploring the vitality of this religion as a global
force and the history of its relations with the West, Esposito
demonstrates the diversity of the Islamic resurgence and the mistakes
our analysts make in assuming a hostile, monolithic Islam.
This third edition has been expanded to include new material on current
affairs in Turkey, Afghanistan, Palestine, and Southeast Asia, as well as
a discussion of International terrorism.
The author lets us to rethink either true or not that Islam and the west is
a clash of civilisation. By historical explanation between Iran and the
west, he deeply tried to revise back what was happened to Iran that
leads to the clash of civilisation. From his point of view, Saddam is
subjected to this clash. Clash of civilisations were raised by Saddam in
the name of Islam. They were rejected with equal force by other
Muslim countries and religious leaders such as the official ulama of
Egypt and Saudi Arabia. The author compares Islam to the west
and explains the western viewpoint on Islam. Even though Islam and
Christianity share the same roots, the two have always been in a state of
struggle against each other. The author also explains that the Muslims
settled in the west are constantly being “othered” unlike other
minorities present in the same region. The reason explained is that
the Muslims are considered to be a threat for the west. The author
quotes several examples that prove this as incorrect. Islamic
fundamentalism identified as threat and has reinforced a tendency to
equate violence with Islam. This belief has been informed by the impact
of the Iranian Revolution. The nineties have challenged this
assumption. There have been no any radical groups. Now they called
as Islamic revivalism. At the end, the author concludes that Islamic
threat is a reality and comprehensive action should be taken by both
Islam and west parties to make the world peace and avoid terrorism
or extremism in religion practise. However, this statement is not true
since the author is American, he possibly not truly understand deeply
Islamic religion from the whole perspectives. Islam is not a threat to
everybody. Islam has proved that Islamic principles and knowledge
is able to attract more positive impacts to the society and a country in
the context of economy.