Groupes Remarks

Nbr of hours?Timing Clear

Corbisier BAD KOK OK

Allard KOK KOK OK

Swert… BAD KOK KOK

Coates BAD KOK OK

 5

Quiriny BAD KOK KOK

Boggis BAD OK BAD

7
de Jaeger KOK KOK OK

Docquier KOK OK KOK

Pinsar BAD BAD BAD

 10

Lemaire BAD KOK KOK

11
André BAD BAD BAD

12

Vraux BAD KOK BAD

13

de Vischer KOK OK KOK

15

Vancoillie BAD KOK KOK

 16

Adriaens KOK KOK KOK

17

Ngapmou BAD KOK KOK

18

Muhoza KOK OK KOK

19

Everard BAD BAD KOK

 20

Adam KOK OK KOK

21

Serruys BAD OK KOK

22

Usama Bin BAD KOK OK

23

Colling BAD BAD BAD

 24

Balivarcq BAD KOK KOK

25

Schrurs BAD OK OK

26

Cornet BAD BAD KOK

29

Rezsöhazy BAD KOK KOK

30

Peeters BAD KOK OK

 31

Berlengee KOK KOK KOK

34

Nennen BAD KOK BAD

35

Debray BAD KOK OK

36
Kouraichi KOK OK OK
Autres

- CT takes little time and can be done in // with

the rest. You can do it at the beginning to warm
up
- GT takes longer (due to combustion), however,
you should try to achieve it in 2 weeks in order
to have enough time for the next point
- You underestimate the amount of work for the
ST, you shall account for 40 to 80h.
- I like to week 'PROBLEMS', ah ah ah, you are
right. However we call it buffer or something
more elegant ;-).
- I don't see an amount of time, I can't give
feedback

- Did you finish GT in time?

- Cooling tower can be done in // with the rest
(and it takes little time).
- ST will take more time.
- The intermidiary steps are not accurate. With
the course, you will have a better view of which
are the intermediary steps
- 3-4h of meting is enough. However, you will
need to work separetely each week.

- CT takes little time and can be done in // with

the rest. You can do it at the beginning to warm
up
- GT takes longer (due to combustion), however,
you should try to achieve it in 2 weeks in order
to have enough time for the next point
- You underestimate the amount of work for the
ST, you shall account for 40 to 80h.
- Good idea to work on the report continiously!

- Nice 1st slide, but a little out of scope ;-).

-Nice layout
- Did you finish the GT in 6h? I suppose that you
won't, it takes more 20-30 hours (including the
combustion).
- You will have the same problem at the other
setps : ST takes around 40-80 hours
- CCGT around 20h, but it can be done in 2
weeks after the ST.
- The combustion must be done for the GT => it
must be dne at the beginning
- CT takes little time and can be done in // with
the rest. You can do it at the beginning to warm
up
- GT takes longer (due to combustion), however,
you should try to achieve it in 2 weeks in order
to have enough time for the next point
- You underestimate the amount of work for the
ST, you shall account for 40 to 80h.

- It is easier to correct based on a timeline ;-).

- Are you in line with your schedule?
- GT might take a little bit longer. As a
counterpart, the report shall take less than
aweek (we are talking of 2-3 pages).
- The ST wil take much more time (40-80 hours).
It will take 4-6 weeks.
- CCGT might take longer

- You might need more time to do the ST.

- 90h sounds ok, but I don't know how you
distribute them between each cycles

- The amount of time is underestimate (you can

easily double or even triple it).
- Good that you already have done the
exercices! Good that you continue on the GT!
Do not forget to include the combustion
- ST is the largest cycle and it takes long. You will
spend more 4 weeks rather than 2.
- You can do the cooling tower in // with the
other functions. You can start it whenever you
want.

-Il y a peu d'informations dans votre devoir, je

ne peux pas donner beaucoup de retour.
- Vous sous estimer fortement la quantité de
travail, ST prend plutôt 40-80h, vous allez passer
au moins 30h à coder.
-En conséquent, vous allez passer plus de
semaines sur la GT et la ST
- CT takes little time and can be done in // with
the rest. You can do it at the beginning to warm
up
- Try to code before S6. Humid air is used in CT
and a little in combustion, it takes little time.
- I advise to do GT before ST
- ST is the biggest part, it can easily takes 40h
- Cooling tower can be done whenever. You can
start with this function to warm up.

- Vous demanderez les commentaires au groupe

que vous avez copié ou qui vous a copié

- Le format n'est pas le plus pertinent.

- Vous pouvez tripler le temps pour chacun des
cycles.
- => de ce fait la ST risque de déborder d'1 à 2
semaines.
- Il n'y a pas bcp d'infos, je ne peux pas donner
beaucoupl plus de commentaires.

- Steams and steams turbine can be regrouped.

- You will need to do the heat exchanger for the
ST.
- CT can be done in // with the rest.
- I don't see how the time is split between the
different cycles. However, it looks
underestimated for all the cycles

- The amount of work is underestimated. You

will spend around 30h in the GT? 40-80h on the
ST and 20-30h on the CCGT.
- The cooling tower can be done in // to the
other functions.
- If you take almost as much time for the oral
examination than the GT, I expect an amazing
oral!
-GT which includes the combustion will take
more time
- the ST is the longest function and you will need
at least 40 hours (around 60h usually).
- The milestones you put are unrelevant. You
plan to work 15h in S5 (or S4?) and 15h between
S9 and S11. Ok to work 15h a week, that sounds
correct, but at the end of the semester, you
might rush and work 15h/week on this project.
- They are no subpoints, hence I can't comment
them
- Humid air is needed in combustion and cooling
tower. However, it represents a small amount of
work (max 10-15h)

-GT which includes the combustion will take

more time
- the ST is the longest function and you will need
at least 40 hours (around 60h usually).
- They are no exercices for the CCGT or Cooling
tower
- Cooling tower can be done in // with the rest
of your work.

- Steam turbine might take more time. Cooling

tower can take less time and It can be done in //
with other tasks
- For the timing, 3 weeks for the ST sounds too
short.
-For the GT, you might need more time to do
the combustion function.

- The project is underestimated. I advise to start

it sooner. You should start to code in S4-S5 if
you want to have enough time and to avoid to
rush at the end.
- The ST cannot be done in 1 week, even for
me ;-). I takes between 40 to 80h.
- As you have courses about the GT before the
ST, I will advise you to start with the GT.
- They are no exercices on CCGTs.
- you might spend more time on the
modelisation.
- the CT can be done in // with the other
function (it is independend to the rest of the
work).
- The major milestones are mixed with
secondary milestones.
- I don't see the exact date of the major
milestones, hence I canno't comment on this
point

- I will advise to start the GT at the beginning,

but why not, as you propose, in // with the ST.
- The cooling tower can be done in // with the
other functions.
- There is no specification about the amount of
time, I cannot comment this part. Try to stick
with your milestones

- I see maturity in the slide! Good!

- I don't see the amount of hours you expect,
the GT (accounting for the combustion) takes
30h, the ST around 60 and the CCGT 20.
- The cooling tower can be done is independent
of the other functions and can be done in //.
- The ST takes easily 4 weeks.
- Feel free to contact me often, this project is
demanding and I don't want you to waste time
on unecessary things.
- I will organise a special session for foreigner
students.

- A timeline is easier to correct.

- No interface required
- I don't see how you will work on the cycles,
which will be the first? Which the second? In
general the 'tasks' description are non accurate
and too broad.
- You underestimate the amount of work and
consequently the amount of time you will spend
on this project
- Ok for the milestones.
- They are no information about the time it will
take, I cannot comment. Try to stick to your
milestones.
- The cooling tower can be done in // with the
rest of your work.
- There are few information, I cannot give a lot
of feedback

- There is no time estimation => I can't comment

- ST is the hardest part and takes easily 4 weeks
and 40-80h.
- CT can be done in // to the rest.
- The intermediary steps are not relevant for the
ST (but you don't know the architecture yet, so
it is normal ;-). The compression and expansions
are easy. The drum, feedheaters and exchangers
are the though parts. In addition, the code must
be parametric, which is another difficulty

- So, in 22h the project is finished, this is

equivalent to 3 days of work. Unfortunately, it
won't be the case (even for me). You can
confirm what I said: did you finish the GT in
6h ;-)?
=> the amount of work is totally
underestimated.
- The ST will take longer and at least 40h.
The CT is independent to the other sections and
can be done in // with the rest of the functions.
- THe CCGT can take shorter if it is done after
the ST. This last is the biggest part

- There is no time estimation => I can't comment

- ST is the hardest part and takes easily 4 weeks
and 40-80h.
- CT can be done in // to the rest.

-CT can be done in // with the rest.

- ST might take longer than 3 weeks, depend
how much you work on it. However, do not start
it after S7
- I don't see the estimated amount of hours, I
cannot give a feedback about it.
- Tu connais mieux le travail que les autres
étudiants. Si tu estimes que 10h sont suffisantes
pour retravailler le code GT, tu peux avoir
raison, mais attention depas sous estimer la
charge. Je te conseille de bien garder tes jalons
comme limites.
- Les tâches du style 'améliorer le code' ne sont
pas assez claires, c'est comme dire 'faire le
projet', trop général. Je ne peux pas donner de
feedback.
- La cooling tower peut se faire en // de tes
autres fonctions. Ce sera une bonne manière de
reprendre la main sur matlab.

- Try to verify that at the end of each week you

achieved your target
- GT might takes longer (with the combustion
function).
-The ST will take longer, you can expect
between 40 and 80h of work. Hence, you need
also 2-3 more weeks. However, with a good ST,
CCGT goes faster and you can achieve it in 20h
- Cooling tower can be done in // with the other
functions.
- It is easier to read this information on a
timeline
- Indeed, try to the report in // with the project.

-Are you in line with your roadmap? Was 5h

enough for the GT?
- The ST is maybe 5 times more work than the
GT.
- The cooling tower is a little part that can be
done in // with other functions
- In general, you underestimate the amount of
work for each package (except cooling tower).

- The ST will take longer (40-80h)

- The rest seems ok :). Do not forget to do the
Cooling tower