Professional Documents
Culture Documents
P119 - Module 1 - 7
P119 - Module 1 - 7
P119 - Module 1 - 7
The word dynamic means ‘force’ The continuous ongoing movement of the
group toward the achievement of its goals
GROUP DYNAMICS means the study of forces within It represents the flow of the group from its
a group. Since human beings have an innate desire starting point to its termination.
for belonging to a group, group dynamism is bound
to occur. TERMINOLOGIES IN GROUP WORK/PROCESS
NOT 3rd quadrant 4th quadrant DISCONFIRMATION occurs when others fail to respond in
KNOWN TO HIDDEN UNKNOWN a neutral way. Neutrality may not sound disconfirming,
OTHERS but consider small children who have continual attempts
to gain responses to their notions of self from their parents.
DEGREE OF OPENNESS Think about grandparents who are the recipients of little
conversation and almost no conversation about how
QUADRANT 1 – the area of free activity or openness refers they are seen by others. The individuals are disconfirmed,
to a behavior known to self and known to others. “People and their self-concept may be altered as a result of such
see me the way I see myself” e.g., name, gender, and interactions. Disconfirmation suggests to people they do
affiliations not exist or they are irrelevant to others.
QUADRANT 2 – the blind area, is where one can see WHAT CAUSES POOR GROUP DYNAMICS?
things in ourselves of which we are unaware. This is the
“bad breath” area. “People have certain beliefs about Group leaders and group members can contribute to a
me but they don’t tell me.” negative group dynamic. Let's look at some of the most
common problems that can occur:
QUADRANT 3 – repressed or hidden area. Things we do
not reveal to others or that which are sensitive, like
1. WEAK LEADERSHIP: when a team lacks a strong
embarrassing experiences.
leader, a more dominant member of the group can
QUADRANT 4 – the area of the unknown where neither often take charge. This can lead to a lack of
the individual nor others are aware of certain behavior direction, infighting, or a focus on the wrong priorities.
that could influence interpersonal relationships. 2. EXCESSIVE DEFERENCE TO AUTHORITY: this can
Sometimes hypnosis, psychotherapy, or other mind- happen when people want to be seen to agree with
altering experiences allow a person to get a glimpse into a leader, and therefore hold back from expressing
the unknown self. Later as the group interacts, there is a their own opinions.
shift from Q4 to one of the other quadrants. The changes 3. BLOCKING: this happens when team members
from one quadrant to another require different levels of behave in a way that disrupts the flow of information
trust to share self-perception with one another. in the group. People can adopt blocking roles such
as:
PRINCIPLES OF CHANGES FROM QUADRANT 1 TO o AGGRESSOR: this person often disagrees with
QUADRANT 4 others, or is inappropriately outspoken.
1. Any changes in any one quadrant can have a chain o NEGATOR: this group member is often critical of
reaction to all other quadrants others' ideas.
2. It takes energy to hide, denies, or repress behavior. o WITHDRAWER: this person doesn't participate in
Threat decreases awareness, while mutual trust the discussion.
enhances interaction. o RECOGNITION SEEKER: this group member is
3. An increase in Q1 means better interaction. The boastful, or dominates the session.
smaller the Q1, the poorer the communication. o JOKER: this person introduces humor at
4. Increase awareness or sensitivity means appreciating inappropriate times.
the covert aspects of behavior in quadrants 2,3, & 4. 4. GROUPTHINK: this happens when people place a
desire for consensus above their desire to reach the
Watzlawick, Beavin, and Jackson have right decision. This prevents people from fully
suggested that other people respond to us in three exploring alternative solutions. – is a phenomenon
distinct ways. These three responses include: where people tend to confirm with group decisions
to avoid feeling outcast, leading to errors in decision
CONFIRMATION occurs when others treat us in a manner making.
consistent with our own notion of who we are. For 5. FREE RIDING: here, some group members take it easy,
instance, if we see ourselves as athletic and and leave their colleagues to do all the work. Free
knowledgeable about physical fitness, we are confirmed riders may work hard on their own, but limit their
when others ask our advice about jogging, working out, contributions in group situations; this is known as
and staying in good physical health/shape. Confirmation "social loafing."
6. EVALUATION APPREHENSION: team members' – Team acquaints and establishes group rules, formalities
perceptions can also create a negative group are preserved and members are treated as strangers.
dynamic. Evaluation apprehension happens when
people feel that they are being judged excessively – Members start interacting and try to work out what is
harshly by other group members, and they hold back expected of them. Excitement and enthusiasm are mixed
their opinions as a result. with fear and uncertainty.
ADJOURNING STAGE: A well-integrated group is able to 1. HARMONIZER: agrees with everyone in the group,
disband, if required when its work is accomplished. The wants everyone to get
adjourning stage of group development is especially 2. TENSION-REDUCER: jokes or clowns around, wants the
important for the many temporary groups. When these group to be relaxed.
tasks have been accomplished, the group reaches a 3. QUESTIONER: keeps the group moving forward with
natural end to its existence or sets itself new tasks - in this questions.
case, the group development process starts again from 4. ENCOURAGER: helps others contribute to the group,
the start. Work and processes are reflected upon and wants the group to reach its goal.
objectives are readjusted. If the team will stop existing 5. ENERGIZER: keeps the group on the topic, pushes the
after intensive cooperation, participants need time to tie group forward.
up loose ends and become familiar with the idea that the 6. DESERTER: withdraws from group, wanders from the
end is near. The stronger the relationships that have subject, distracts others.
developed, the more emotional this parting process will 7. AGGRESSOR: see himself as more important than
be. others, wants attention
8. NEGATIVIST: rejects others' ideas, refuses to
– The team conducts an assessment of the year and
cooperate, always finds something wrong.
implements a plan for transitioning roles and recognizing
9. DOMINATOR: wants everything to be his way, often
members’ contributions.
interrupts others
– Having completed their task the group dissolves.
Members will share either a sense of loss or relief, ALL TEAMS ARE GROUPS BUT NOT ALL GROUPS ARE TEAMS
depending on the outcome of the task.
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A GROUP AND A TEAM
2.2.1: Roles in a Group
GROUP COMPOSITION
- refers to the compatibility of the group
members with each other. How much they feel relaxed
after being part of the group.
COMMUNICATION is the process of generating meaning VOCAL AND NONVOCAL ELEMENTS OF COMMUNICATION
by sending and receiving verbal and nonverbal symbols
and signs that are influenced by multiple contexts.
Verbal
Nonverbal Communication
FIVE FORMS OF COMMUNICATION: Communication
HAPTICS refers to touch behaviors that convey meaning change plans often and
during interactions. Touch operates at many levels, adhere strictly to plans
easily
including functional-professional, social-polite, friendship-
warmth, and love-intimacy.
are concerned about not are more concerned with
VOCALICS refers to the vocalized but not verbal aspects disturbing others; follow rules those who are closely
of nonverbal communication, including our speaking of privacy and consideration related than with privacy
rate, pitch, volume, tone of voice, and vocal quality.
Monochronic People Polychronic People To make sure someone is available for interaction
and to avoid being perceived as rude, it is usually a
good idea to “catch their eye” before you start
do one thing at a time do many things at once talking to them.
Avoiding eye contact or shifting your eye contact
from place to place can lead others to think you are
do not see interruptions or
being deceptive or inattentive.
concentrate on one task diversion as something to
be avoided
Facial Expressions
take time commitments you may be able to strategically use your facial
consider an objective to
(deadlines, schedules) expressions to cheer someone up, lighten a mood, or
be achieved, if possible
seriously create a more serious and somber tone
Smiles are especially powerful as an immediacy
behavior and a rapport-building tool. Smiles can also
are low-context and need are high-context and help to disarm a potentially hostile person or
information already have information deescalate conflict.
4.1: Leadership delegation of important responsibilities, and information
sharing.
“Leadership is the ability of a person in a position to
influence others to behave in such a manner that goals LEADERSHIP STYLE
are achieved.” – Chester Barnard
1. Autocratic (authoritarian) Power is centralized and
LEADERSHIP decision-making is assumed by the leader. The
leader determines the policy of the group
A process by which an individual guides others in their
collective pursuits, often by organizing, directing, Advantages: Foster decision and implementation
coordinating, supporting, and motivating their efforts. of goals. Leaders have a high sense of responsibilities
Before we move onto specific approaches to studying Disadvantages: More frustrations and conflicts
leadership, let’s distinguish between designated and since members are not asked to share opinions or
emergent leaders. In general, some people gravitate decisions. Have low consideration to others
more toward leadership roles than others, and some
leaders are designated while others are Three types of autocratic leaders:
emergent. Designated leaders are officially recognized in Strict Autocrat- influences the members by
their leadership role and may be appointed or elected frightening, criticizing and imposing penalties
by people inside or outside the group. Designated Benevolent autocrat- influences the
leaders can be especially successful when they are members by encouragement and guidance
sought out by others to fulfill and are then accepted in Incompetent autocrat- hides his
leadership roles. On the other hand, some people seek incompetence and lack of skill by being
out leadership positions not because they possess harsh with the members
leadership skills and have been successful leaders in the
past but because they have the drive to hold and wield 2. Democratic (Participative). Decentralized authority,
power. Many groups are initially leaderless and must consult follower, decisions are not one-sided or
either designate a leader or wait for one to emerge unilateral.
organically. Emergent leaders gain status and respect
through engagement with the group and its task and are Advantages:
turned to by others as a resource when leadership is Better understanding between followers
needed. Emergent leaders may play an important role Encourages constructive suggestions
when a designated leader unexpectedly leaves.
1. Good leaders know how to listen. Listening is a CAUSES FOR FAILURE IN LEADERSHIP
developed art. The leader who is always talking and
seldom listens will soon have difficulties and no one to 1. Pride. This may be overconfidence in one's ability,
listen to him. education, physical appearance, personality, or
2. Good leaders live on ideas. They are looking for new powers to manipulate others. He expects to be
ideas, new methods, new procedures, and new rewarded for who he is or what he knows rather than
people to train. for what he is or what he does.
3. Good leaders set clear goals. The leader does not 2. Everything has to be for his personal benefit. All praise
operate from the point of personality or impulses. He and accomplishments must be for him. He cannot
sets priorities for his life and organization. The goals allow others to receive appreciation. He holds on to
are shared and mutually agreed objectives are set to all important positions and tasks so he will get all the
reach the goals. The priorities become group credit.
priorities because they are democratically selected. 3. Disloyalty. For fear of not being accepted by all, he
The leader communicates these priorities and helps compromises on his convictions and beliefs. He
the group accomplish them. criticizes those for whom he works if it will gain
4. Good leaders share both the work and the personal advantage.
honors. The leader does not use his time on minor 4. Lack of Discipline. He is unable to control his own
tasks which others can handle as well as he. He does time. Being unable or unwilling to organize he is
not waste his energy with decisions others can make. always behind in his work or forgetting to do what is
He has trained others to function so he delegates expected of him. He is not concerned about his
freely to these. He delegates with appropriate dress, attitudes, emotions, or passions.
responsibility to others. He does not seek for and 5. Unable to Express Emotions. People respond to a
keep all the honors for himself. He looks for and is leader who is human. Inability to laugh with and at
quick to express appreciation for others and call self and his problems will handicap a leader.
attention to their accomplishments. Expressing compassion and other emotions are good
5. Good leaders know how to meet challenges and to attributes. Willingness to "unwind" with others lends
use their energies for the relevant and important itself to acceptance as a leader.
things. The leader does not major in minor issues. He 6. Authoritarian Attitude. He demands people to follow
does not exhaust himself caring for items that are not him because of who he is or his position. He has not
relevant to the total task. learned that respect comes from recognition of his
6. Good leaders are never judgmental. A leader does caring attitude and his competent performance.
not deal in generalities. He does not condemn or 7. Fear of Competition from Followers. Being afraid that
fasten labels to persons. He speaks out full others in the group are as competent as he makes
information on an issue and deals with the issue and the leader develop a sense of inferiority about his
not the person. He is sensitive to each person's needs ability to perform. When he discovers the abilities of
and tactfully relates to each person according to others he may develop a self-pitying attitude to call
those needs. attention to himself. He may tend to ignore or put
7. Good leaders are involved "with people. Each person down others who are also capable leaders.
is important and worthwhile. He does not compare or 8. Lack of Imagination. He wants to know the future
play one person against another. He is available to and all that is involved before daring to attempt the
everyone and has no favorites. Interaction with new. He avoids projects in which all things are not
others gives him insight into himself and others. He clearly marked out. He is afraid of anything which
learns from all how to correct undesirable features in carries with it an idea of failure. He is bound by
his own personality, attitudes, or conduct. the "status quo".
8. Good leaders learn from their mistakes. A leader who 9. Emphasis on Title. He has not learned that titles are
does anything will make mistakes. The leader does given by man and are only an indication of a point
not fear his mistakes. When one is made, admit it. reached in the growth pattern. Insistence upon being
Correct it, if possible— evaluate it—learn why it "titled" creates a barrier between the people and the
happened then proceed with the knowledge of how leader.
not to make the same mistake again. 10. Unwillingness to Organize. Failure to set long and
9. Good leaders are flexible. The leader must be open short-range goals is a failure on the part of the
to changes. Any program not achieving results needs leader. His unwillingness to set objectives and
priorities for a project leads to failure. Fearing failure THREE CATEGORIES OF COMMON GROUP ROLE
he fails to plan to succeed.
1. Task-Related Roles and Behaviors. Task-related roles
11. Lack of Understanding of the Job. Failure to have a
typically serve leadership, informational, or procedural
clear understanding of his job leads to confusion,
frustration, and ultimate failure? Being unable to give functions.
a clear job description to others tends to turn people Task Leader: Within any group, there may be a
away from him as a leader. task leader who has a high group status because of his or
her maturity, problem-solving abilities knowledge, and/or
LEADERSHIP AND POWER leadership experience, and skills and functions primarily to
help the group complete its task.
Leaders help move group members toward the
completion of their goals using various motivational Task-leader behaviors:
strategies. The types of power leaders draw on to
motivate have long been a topic of small group study. A The substantive leader is the “idea
leader may possess or draw on any of the following five person” who communicates “big picture” thoughts and
types of power to varying degrees: legitimate, expert, suggestions that feed group discussion.
referent, information, and reward/coercive. Effective
The procedural leader is the person who
leaders do not need to possess all five types of power.
gives the most guidance, perhaps following up on the
Instead, competent leaders know how to draw on other
ideas generated by the substantive leader.
group members who may be better able to exercise a
type of power in a given situation. Expediter: functions to keep the group on track
toward completing its task by managing the agenda and
Legitimate power flows from the officially recognized setting and assessing goals in order to monitor the group’s
power, status, or title of a group member. progress.
Expert power comes from knowledge, skill, or
expertise that a group member possesses and other Information Provider: Includes behaviors that are
group members do not. more evenly shared. In other roles, ideally, all group
Referent power comes from the attractiveness, members present new ideas, initiate discussions of new
likeability, and charisma of the group member. topics, and contribute their own relevant knowledge and
experiences.
Information power comes from a person’s ability to
access information that comes through informal Information seeker: Asks for more information,
channels and well-established social and professional elaboration, or clarification on items relevant to the
networks. group’s task.
Reward power comes from the ability of a group
member to provide a positive incentive as a Gatekeeper: Manages the flow of conversation
compliance-gaining strategy, and coercive power in a group in order to achieve an appropriate balance so
comes from the ability of a group member to provide that all group members get to participate in a
a negative incentive (punishment). meaningful way.
4.2: Group Member Roles Recorder: takes notes on the discussion and
activities that occur during a group meeting. The
GROUP MEMBER ROLES recorder is the only role that is essentially limited to one
person at a time since in most cases it wouldn’t be
Group roles are more dynamic than leadership roles in necessary or beneficial to have more than one person
that a role can be formal or informal and played by more recording.
than one group member. Additionally, one group
2. Maintenance Roles and Behaviors. Maintenance roles
member may exhibit various role behaviors within a single
and their corresponding behaviors function to create and
group meeting or play a few consistent roles over the
maintain social cohesion and fulfill the interpersonal
course of his or her involvement with a group. Some
needs of group members. All these role behaviors require
people’s role behaviors result from their personality traits,
strong and sensitive interpersonal skills.
while other people act out a certain role because of a
short-term mood, as a reaction to another group Social-Emotional Leader is generally someone
member, or out of necessity. Group communication who is well-liked by the other group members and whose
scholars have cautioned us to not always think of these role behaviors complement but don’t compete with the
roles as neatly bounded all-inclusive categories. After all, task leader.
we all play multiple roles within a group and must draw
on multiple communication behaviors in order to Supporter: The role of supporter is characterized
successfully play them. When someone continually by communication behaviors that encourage other
exhibits a particular behavior, it may be labeled as a role, group members and provide the emotional support
but even isolated behaviors can impact group needed. The supporter’s work primarily occurs in one-on-
functioning. one exchanges that are more intimate and in-depth than
the exchanges that take place during full group
meetings.
Tension Releaser: Is someone who is naturally others within the group, and being outspoken to the point
funny and sensitive to the personalities of the group and of distraction.
the dynamics of any given situation and who uses these
qualities to manage the frustration level of the group. Doormat is a person who is chronically
submissive to the point that it hurts the group’s progress.
Harmonizer: played by group members who help Doormat behaviors include quickly giving in when
manage the various types of group conflict that emerge challenged, self-criticism, and claims of inadequacy.
during group communication. They keep their eyes and
ears open for signs of conflict among group members
and ideally intervene before it escalates.
3. Self-Centered Roles
Unproductive Roles
11 Qualities of A Great Team Member Organizations use teams in a variety of ways. Because of
this variety, there are many ways to classify teams and
1. Self-aware. Teams benefit when individual members these classifications help explain the psychological and
are fully aware of their strengths and weaknesses, but it’s organizational differences among different types of
especially important that leaders understand the key teams.
attributes of their subordinates. Good leaders know how
to delegate effectively, while bad leaders give Sundstrom (1999) identifies six types of work teams on the
inappropriate work to the wrong workers. basis of the functions they perform:
2. Committed to mastery. As Robert Greene, author
of Mastery, states: “The time that leads to mastery is 1. Production teams, such as factory teams,
dependent on the intensity of our focus.” When every manufacture or assemble products on a repetitive
member of the team is committed to personal growth, basis.
this not only creates an awesome working atmosphere, 2. Service teams, such as maintenance crews and food
but it constantly brings new information into the services, conduct repeated transactions with
organization which assists creative problem-solving. customers.
3. Intrinsically motivated. When your teammates are 3. Management teams, composed of managers, work
passionate about their disciplines and intrinsically together, plan, develop policy, or coordinate the
motivated, the POSITIVITY IS INFECTIOUS. activities of an organization.
4. Project teams such as research and engineering
4. Honest. Team members should be honest about their teams, bring experts together to perform a specific
achievements as well as their shortcomings. Everyone task within a defined period.
makes mistakes from time to time, but when people try to 5. Action or performing teams, such as sports teams,
shift the blame and weave false narratives, disasters can entertainment groups, and surgery teams, engage in
occur. “Honesty is the fastest way to prevent a mistake brief performances that are repeated under new
from turning into a failure.” conditions and that require specialized skills and
5. Positive. Positivity means finding a solution to a problem extensive training or preparation.
rather than passing the blame and dwelling on things you 6. Parallel teams are temporary teams that operate
can’t control. outside normal work, such as employee involvement
groups and advisory committees that provide
6. Empathic. Empathy is about being aware of how other
suggestions or recommendations for changing an
people feel. If you’re unable to put yourself in someone
organization.
else’s shoes and see things from their viewpoint, people
are not going to enjoy working with you.
Theory on group dynamics is changing and becoming What makes an ineffective team?
more sophisticated. Rather than simple models that look
at cause-effect relationships, new models focus on the People talk more than they listen and only a few
conditions that help teams manage their own processes. people may contribute.
Instead of looking at group behavior as the sum total of
Some members are silent and don't contribute. They
individual variables, there is a focus on the emergent
may be indifferent, bored, or afraid to contribute.
properties of teams. The search to find the best approach
Members' ideas are dismissed or even ridiculed and
to manage a team has been replaced by the
their views are ignored.
recognition of what is termed equifinality-- that there are
many ways for teams to operate There are arguments between members of the group
successfully. Researchers have conducted a number of (as opposed to constructive differences of opinion).
studies on work teams to determine the characteristics One or two members dominate the others and make
that predict success. Successful teams have clear goals, the decisions.
good leadership, appropriate task characteristics, and Disagreements are put to the vote without being
mutual accountability with rewards. discussed.
Some members are unhappy with decisions
A team must develop social relations among its members. and grumble privately afterward.
The social interactions necessary for teamwork require Little effort is made to keep to the point or to work to
group cohesion and good communication. Cohesion deadlines.
comes from the emotional ties that team members have There is a lack of clarity regarding goals and specific
with one another. Good communication depends on tasks are not agreed to.
understanding and trust. When team members fail to Roles are not delegated to particular team members.
develop good social relations, they do not communicate
There is a lack of trust and helpfulness.
well, have interpersonal problems that interfere with task
Members don't talk about how the group is working
performance, and are unable to reward and motivate
or the problems it faces.
one another. This limits the ability of the team to continue
to operate.
5.2: Team Leader
What makes an effective team?
Team leadership is a process whereby an individual
It has a range of individuals who contribute in influences the progress of team members toward the
different ways and complement each other. A good attainment of a goal. Leadership can be centralized in
team produces more than the individual one person or distributed among various roles. Teams vary
contributions of members. in types of leadership, selection of leaders, and
delegation of leader powers. Teams rarely exist without
Clear goals are agreed on that everyone
leaders, since leaders emerge through a team’s
understands and is committed to.
interactions. Leaders may be designated, or teams may
Everyone understands the tasks they have to do and
select their own leaders and be self-managing.
helps each other.
It has a coordinator who may adopt a leadership The focus of the team leader depends on the situation
style from autocratic to democratic depending on the team faces and the maturity of the team. Leaders
the circumstances. Different people may assume the help the team solve problems in order to meet its goals
role of leader for different tasks. while developing the skills and abilities of the team
There is a balance between the task (what do we members in order to meet goals while developing the
need to do?) and the process (how do we achieve skills and abilities of the team members so they have the
this?) collective capacity for leadership. They promote team
There is a supportive, informal learning by giving performance feedback to the team
atmosphere where members feel able to take risks and using this information to help the team develop
and say what they think. performance strategies that are more effective.
The team is comfortable with disagreement and can
successfully overcome differences in opinion. There are several approaches that team leaders can
There is a lot of discussions in which everyone take to support the team. Research on project team
participates. Team members listen to each other and leaders at Google shows that effective leaders give the
everyone's ideas are heard. team freedom while being available to provide advice
and support when needed.
Members feel free to criticize and say what they think
but this is done in a positive, constructive manner. 9 Roles of Team Leader
The group learns from experience: reviewing and
improving performance in the light of both successes 1. Provide purpose. Everything starts with → VISION.
and failures. Capturing and communicating vision is your role as a
team leader. Only you can do it. Create an
inspiring vision. Provide the big picture and keep the
vision of the big picture before yourself and your people.
Every team member … "has a role to play, and every role
has its part in contributing to the bigger picture. Without
that perspective, the team cannot accomplish its goal,
whether the team's "game" is sports, business, family, performance evaluation, corrective feedback,
ministry, or government," John C. Maxwell, the author praise, discussions, etc.
of The 17 Indisputable Laws of Teamwork
communicate in a way that is truthful and
2. Build a star, not a team of stars. Your team will not
believable to team members.
reach its potential if players are unwilling to subordinate
provide constructive feedback to the team
their personal goals to the good of the team. "Everybody
on where and how it might improve
on a championship team doesn't get publicity, but
encourage open communication among
everyone can say he's a champion." - Ervin “Magic”
team members and communicate team
Johnson
views to and from other teams
3. Establish shared ownership for the results. Start with encourage self-criticism and rehearsal
yourself – share your own individual results with the group. strive for team consensus and win-win
Shared responsibility is better achieved if the pay and agreements
reward system has a significant element that is provide guidance to the team based on
dependent on the overall outcome. Keep the team upper management direction
informed how individual members are performing – it is escalate issues that cannot be resolved by
important if Individuals' rewards depended on the the team and communicate team views to
performance of the group as a whole. upper management
serve as a focal point to communicate and
4. Develop team members to the fullest potential. Bring resolve interface and integration issues with
out the best in your people. Help team members to other teams.
develop so that all of them could effectively participate
on the team. Lead by setting a good example. 9. Monitor, but don’t micromanage.
Norms
Team Cohesiveness
Personality influences on decision making 1. The majority rule is a commonly used decision-
making technique in which a majority (one-half plus
A long-studied typology of value orientations that affect one) must agree before a decision is made.
decision making consists of the following types of 2. The Minority rule is a decision-making technique in
decision-makers: which a designated authority or expert has the final
say over a decision and may or may not consider the
input of other group members.
The economic decision-maker makes decisions
3. The consensus rule is a decision-making technique in
based on what is practical and useful.
which all members of the group must agree on the
The aesthetic decision-maker makes decisions based
same decision. Although this can be positive, be
on form and harmony, desiring a solution that is
cautious that this isn’t a sign of groupthink.
elegant and in sync with the surroundings.
4. The Nominal Group Technique is a decision-making The Black Hat is judgment – the devil’s advocate or why
technique that allows a group of people to focus on something may not work. Questions include:
the task of making a decision without developing
any social relations. It is called "nominal" because it What are the weaknesses?
does not require a true group. This technique can be
What may go wrong if we implement this suggestion?
used by a collection of people who are brought
What are the potential problems?
together to make a decision. When using this
technique, the leader states the problem to the Do we have the resources to do it?
group. People write down their solutions to the
problem privately. Each person then publicly states
his or her problems, and the answers are recorded so
everyone can see them. The Red Hat signifies feelings, hunches, and intuition.
5. The Delphi Technique uses a series of written surveys Questions include
to make a decision. a group of experts is given a
survey containing several open-minded questions Based upon my emotions, what is my commitment
about the problem to be solved. The results of this level to the issue?
survey are summarized and organized into a set of How do I feel about a decision I might make?
proposed solutions. Those solutions are sent to the What is my intuition regarding this issue?
members, who are then asked to comment on the
solutions, which are based on the first survey. The
process is repeated until the members start to reach
an agreement on a solution to the problem. The Green Hat focuses on creativity; possibilities,
6. The Ringi Technique is a Japanese decision-making alternatives, and new ideas. Questions include:
technique used for dealing with controversial
topics. It allows a group to deal with conflict while
avoiding a face-to-face confrontation. (Face-to- What alternative solutions are possible?
face confrontations are considered inappropriate in Could a recommendation be done in another way?
Japanese culture). In this approach, a written What is a unique way of looking at the issue?
document presenting the issue and its proposed
resolution are developed anonymously. This
document is circulated among group members, who
individually write comments, edit the documents, The Blue Hat is used to manage the thinking process. This
and forward them to other group members. After hat is the facilitator. Questions include:
completing a cycle, the comments are used to
rewrite the document, and it is recirculated through Where do we start?
the group. This process continues until group
What sequence of hats will be most appropriate?
members stop writing comments on the draft.
How much time should be allocated to each hat?
What is the action plan for the next steps, roles,
SIX HATS METHOD OF DECISION MAKING (by Edward de responsibilities, and time frame?
Bono)