Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

Average true range is often used as an indication of a security’s volatility.

Although the
raw number alone does not imply high or low volatility, plotting the historical average true
range of a security allows you to view where volatility was decreasing, increasing, or
reaching a peak or a trough. In this paper, I will introduce an indicator and strategy that
try to take advantage of the increased trading opportunities that occur during times of
higher- or lower-than-average volatility for a stock when compared to the overall market.
This is accomplished by comparing the relative strength index (RSI) of the average true
range (ATR) of a specific stock to the relative strength index of the average true range of
the overall market.

In order to standardize the average true range of the security and the overall market, the
indicator calculates the RSI of the ATR. This helps standardize the changes in ATR of the
overall market versus the changes in ATR of a stock. The RSI of the ATR is calculated on
both the ATR of the overall market and the ATR of the security you want to trade. Once
both RSIs are calculated, the RSI spread is determined by dividing the RSI ATR calculation
of the tradeable security by the RSI ATR calculation of the market. We then take an
average of the RSI spread and look for trading opportunities by finding occurrences in
which the current RSI spread is greater or less than the average RSI spread. If the RSI
spread is above its average, then the tradeable security is currently experiencing higher
volatility than normally experienced when compared to the market. This is a bearish
signal and the strategy will correspondingly sell. If the RSI spread is below its average,
then the tradeable security is currently experiencing lower volatility than normally
experienced when compared to the market. This is a bullish signal and the strategy will
correspondingly buy.

To demonstrate the RSI Volatility Spread, I will introduce several indicators that plot the
RSI spread idea, as well as a strategy that uses the indicator’s results to generate buy and
sell signals. The strategy works well on several international market exchange-traded
1|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com
funds (ETFs) as well as other sector ETFs. For demonstration purposes, I will present the strategy’s results
on the iShares MSCI Australia Index. However, I will also present a summary of results for several other ETFs
in the Portfolio Spotlight section. In Figure 1 below, you can view several strategy sample trades along with
the accompanying indicator that is plotting the average RSI spread difference. When the average spread
difference is above zero—signifying higher volatility—the histogram color is red to identify a bearish
outlook. When the average spread difference is below zero—signifying lower volatility—the histogram color
is green to identify a bullish outlook.

Strategy Style Intermediate Term


Asset Type Stocks
Symbol 1 (Traded Symbol) EWA - iShares MSCI Australia Index Fund
Symbol 2 $SPX.X - S&P 500 Index
Alternative Symbols to Trade IXC, IXJ, EWU, EWD, and EWL
Data Interval Daily
Period Tested 19 years

2|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com


 Buy when the average spread difference (AvgSpreadDiff) is below zero and the RSI of the ATR of the
market (S&P 500) is greater than the RSI of the ATR of the security you are trading.

 Sell when the average spread difference (AvgSpreadDiff) is above zero and the RSI of the ATR of the
security you are trading is greater than the RSI of the ATR of the market (S&P 500).

Name Default Description


Length used to calculate the average true range of the
ATRLen 20 security and of the overall market.
AvgLen 120 Length used to calculate average spread difference.
Length used to calculate RSI of the ATR of the market
and RSI of the ATR of the security. Also used to
RSILen 50 calculate the average RSI spread.

This strategy uses only three inputs and all of them are lengths used to calculate a variable. The same inputs are
used in the accompanying indicator. The first input, “ATRLen,” is used as the length to calculate the average true
range of both the tradeable security and the overall market, which we define as the S&P 500 Index. The second
input, “AvgLen,” is used only to calculate the length of the average spread difference, which is the difference between
the current RSI spread and the average RSI spread. The last input, “RSILen,” is used to calculate the RSIs of the ATRs
of the security and the market, respectively, and to calculate the average RSI spread. The average RSI spread, which
is defined in the strategy variables section below, is simply the ratio of the RSI of the ATR of the security and the RSI
of the ATR of the market.

Variable Definition
ATR Average true range of the security you are trading.
RangeMkt Range of the S&P 500 Index.
ATRMkt Average true range of the S&P 500 Index.
RSIATR Relative strength index of the ATR of the security.
RSIATRMkt Relative strength index of the ATR of the S&P 500 Index.
The relative strength index of the ATR of the security
divided by the relative strength index of the ATR of the
RSISpread S&P 500 Index.
AvgSpread The exponential average of the RSI spread.
The difference between the current RSI spread and the
SpreadDiff average of the RSI spread.
The exponential average of the difference between the
AvgSpreadDiff current RSI spread and the average of the RSI spread.

3|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com


In essence, this TradeStation Labs report introduces an alternative method by which to analyze a given
stock’s volatility. The concepts of RSI and ATR are very common in technical analysis. Here, we combine two
very familiar technical indicators to create a new one. The average spread difference, which is the indicator
that we use to generate the buy and sell signals, is a derivative of the two common indicators. Once we
standardize the average true range of both the stock and the market, the strategy looks for trading
opportunities in which the current RSI spread ratio is above the average RSI spread ratio. This means that
the current ratio between the volatility of the security and the market is higher than the average ratio
between the volatility of the security and the market. For high-beta securities, volatility should always be
higher than the overall market.

In this case, we are comparing not just volatility, but the ratio of volatility between the security and the
market. Because we are always comparing volatility to the market, in order for the strategy and indicator to
calculate accurately, the S&P 500 Index ($SPX.X) needs to be placed into the chart as Data 2. In Figure 2
below, you can see how the different variables appear plotted below the price data. Subgraph 2 plots the RSI
of the ATR of the security (purple line) against the RSI of the ATR of the market (orange line). With this
indicator, you can see historically when the security’s volatility was higher than the market’s volatility and
vice versa. In subgraph 3, the actual RSI spread (red line), or the ratio between the RSI of the ATR of the
security and the RSI of the ATR of the market, is plotted against the average RSI spread (blue line). When the
ratio is 1.0, the security’s volatility and the market’s volatility are approximately equal. Remember that in
order to calculate both the indicator and the strategy, the S&P 500 Index needs to be placed into the chart as
Data 2. In Figure 2, the price data of the S&P 500 is hidden by formatting the symbol and hiding the subgraph
in the Scaling tab.

4|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com


In this paper, we’ve presented the strategy’s results for the iShares MSCI Australia Index Fund. However, this
strategy would most likely be applied to a portfolio of securities, as it is an intermediate-term strategy and
doesn’t generate many trades. In addition, the diversification effects of adding securities that are not
perfectly positively correlated to a portfolio would help to reduce your portfolio’s overall risk.

5|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com


6|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com
7|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com
Symbol Description K-Ratio RINA Index Buy and Hold Return Return on Account
EWA iShares MSCI Australia Index Fund 3.89 41.81 164.71% 742.45%
IXC iShares S&P Global Energy Sector Index 3.74 23.89 72.26% 675.24%
IXJ iShares S&P Global Health Sector Index 2.77 27.51 15.84% 728.60%
EWU iShares MSCI U.K. Index Fund 3.76 61.16 48.34% 535.57%
EWD iShares MSCI Sweden Index Fund 4.82 67.61 226.14% 625.93%
EWL iShares MSCI Switzerland Index 4.88 72.86 256.33% 777.48%
PBJ PowerShares Dynamic Food & Beverage 3.96 16.30 1.75% 2226.70%
PWC PowerShares Dynamic Market Portfolio 3.23 38.19 9.03% 3219.42%
XLP S&P Select Consumer Staples SPDR Fund 2.57 17.73 -1.28% 166.79%

Return on Initial Capital 177.75%


Buy and Hold Return 164.71%
Return on Account 742.45%
Annual Rate of Return 5.45%
Profit Factor 4.52
Avg Monthly Return $120.02
Std. Deviation of Monthly Return $685.44
Net Profit / Maximum Drawdown 5.06
Weekly Underwater Equity -15.64%
Buy and Hold Weekly Underwater Equity -68.25%
K-Ratio 3.89
RINA Index 41.81

 The strategy’s profit factor of 4.52 signifies that for every $1.00 lost, $4.52 was earned in profit.
 The return on account—742.45% over the approximately 19 years that the strategy was back-
tested—far exceeded the buy-and-hold return of 164.71% (generated by simply buying at the
beginning of the testing period and holding the security).
 The K-ratio, which is a risk-adjusted performance measure, is 3.89. The higher the K-ratio, the better
the strategy in terms of risk-adjusted performance. The industry standard is 2.50.
 The strategy’s weekly underwater equity of (-15.64%) is much better than that seen under the buy-
and-hold strategy of the security (-68.25%).
 Average profit by month was positive 9 of 12 months, with January being the worst-performing
month.
 The detailed equity curve is fairly linear over the 19 years that the strategy was back-tested. The
strategy was back-tested over the entire period during which the security was tradeable.
 Risk-adjusted performance is consistent across several ETFs, as presented in the Portfolio Spotlight
table.
 The net profit divided by maximum drawdown ratio was 5.06, signifying low drawdown during the
back-test.
8|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com
 Because the strategy is intermediate-term, it has a low number of total trades during the period (33).
However, if the strategy were implemented on a portfolio of securities, the total number of trades
would increase, allowing for more diversification and lower total risk.
 The standard deviation of monthly return is 571% times the average monthly return, signifying
higher risk in the strategy.
 The last trade the strategy generated is currently a losing trade.
 The strategy had negative annual returns in 7 of the 19 years it was back-tested, with 2008 being the
worst-performing year (-8.20%).

This report introduced a new indicator to compare a given security’s volatility to overall market volatility in
order to generate buy and sell signals. As displayed in the relationship between the CBOE Volatility Index
($VIX.X) and the S&P 500 Index ($SPX.X), a spike in volatility may indicate a market downturn. This is
because a spike in the VIX usually means there is fear in the market. It is common knowledge that when
there is fear in the market, investors sell. This indicator and strategy try to take advantage of this
relationship by buying when volatility is lower than average compared to the market and selling when
volatility is higher than average compared to the market. Although the relationship does not always hold—
since higher volatility does not guarantee lower stock prices—it appears to hold more often than not over the
long term, allowing you to exploit these trading opportunities.

Alexandra Guevara is a Market Technician for TradeStation Securities.

In order to open the sample workspaces provided, you may first need to import the custom EasyLanguage file with the
extension .eld. Copy the attached .eld file and workspaces to your computer. Then import the indicators or strategies
by double-clicking on the EasyLanguage .eld file. This will automatically start the TradeStation import wizard. Click
‘Next’ until the Analysis Techniques and/or strategies have been imported. The indicators are now available and you
can now open the provided workspaces. Other supportive documents or files may also be attached to this email.

All support, education and training services and materials on the TradeStation Securities website are for informational
purposes and to help customers learn more about how to use the power of TradeStation software and services. No type of
trading or investment advice is being made, given or in any manner provided by TradeStation Securities or its affiliates.

This material may also discuss in detail how TradeStation is designed to help you develop, test and implement trading
strategies. However, TradeStation Securities does not provide or suggest trading strategies. We offer you unique tools to
help you design your own strategies and look at how they could have performed in the past. While we believe this is very
valuable information, we caution you that simulated past performance of a trading strategy is no guarantee of its future
performance or success. We also do not recommend or solicit the purchase or sale of any particular securities or derivative
products. Any symbols referenced are used only for the purposes of the demonstration, as an example ---- not a
recommendation.

Finally, this material may discuss automated electronic order placement and execution. Please note that even though
TradeStation has been designed to automate your trading strategies and deliver timely order placement, routing and
execution, these things, as well as access to the system itself, may at times be delayed or even fail due to market volatility,
quote delays, system and software errors, Internet traffic, outages and other factors.

9|Page Questions or comments? Contact us at TSLabs@TradeStation.com

You might also like