Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Investigation of Photoneutron Dose Equivalent From High-Energy Photons in Radiotherapy
Investigation of Photoneutron Dose Equivalent From High-Energy Photons in Radiotherapy
Abstract
Spatial distribution of photoneutron dose equivalent during radiotherapy at different beam size, depth, and distance from a 15 MV
linear accelerator was investigated with bubble detectors in a water phantom. The photoneutron dose equivalent was mainly from fast
neutrons, and decreased with distance at a fixed field and with depth. Besides, photoneutron dose equivalent was slightly affected by
beam size due to the variation of tungsten area exposed in the beam direction and photoneutrons occurred at the jaws. Fast
photoneutron dose equivalent of shallow critical organs was represented still considerably outside the beam size.
r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0969-8043/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.apradiso.2007.01.017
ARTICLE IN PRESS
600 J.-P. Lin et al. / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 65 (2007) 599–604
Many detectors are available for the evaluation of considered. Therefore, we combined both BD-PND and
photoneutron contamination from medical linear accel- BDT bubble detectors in this research to estimate the
erators (Swanson, 1978). Among them, the bubble detector spectrum and the amount of generated photoneutrons as
is especially a convenient tool for neutron detection (Ing well as spatial distribution of the dose equivalent of
et al., 1997), which earned the inventor, Glaser, the Nobel photoneutrons in a water phantom, which may provide
Prize in 1960 (Glaser, 1952). In the bubble chamber, the actual accepted doses of the patients during radiotherapy.
superheated droplet (typically chlorofluorocarbons) main-
tains its liquid state above its normal boiling point and 2. Experimental
suspends in a viscous polymer emulsion (Lo, 1987; Roy
and Roy, 2003). When energetic particles pass through the 2.1. Materials and methods
liquid, the chamber pressure is abruptly reduced to
nucleate superheated droplets into vapor bubbles along Bubble detectors, BD-PND and BDT (with a sensitivity
the particle paths (Fig. 1). The neutron dose is proportional of 0.43–6 and 19–20 bubble/mrem, respectively), obtained
to the number of bubbles, which can be readily estimated from Bubble Technology Industries (Canada) were utilized
with an automatic bubble reader or bubbles in the polymer to investigate fast and thermal neutron doses, respectively.
can readily be counted by eye. In addition, photons A 15 MV linear accelerator (Siemens Primus, Germany;
generated from the LINAC have low linear energy transfer quality factor ¼ 20, neutron source strength ¼ 2.0
(LET) and thus will not contribute an ample energy (Green 1011 neutron/Gy (Chibani and Ma, 2003)) installed in the
et al., 2005) to the nucleation of bubbles since the Radiotherapy Department of the Changhua Christian
nucleation length is only about 100 nm (Tu et al., 1997). Hospital was assembled with tungsten target, shielding
Such a property is favorable for discriminating neutron and flattening filter to provide high-energy photons. The
dose from that of the photons. Considering different spectrum of photon-induced neutrons is similar to that of
energies of neutrons existing in the radiation field, specific 252
Cf neutron source (Peurrung, 2000; Green et al., 2005),
bubble detectors should be chosen to distinguish fast from which was employed for calibrating the bubble detectors.
thermal neutrons (Ing et al., 1997). The bubble detectors were positioned in the water phantom
Among the bubble detectors, BD-PND and BDT bubble and oriented with a monitoring computer.
detectors, which are temperature compensated over the In order to evaluate photoneutron doses of the healthy
range of 20–37 1C, are commonly used as neutron tissues and its neighboring area of the patients, parameters
dosimeters. The BD-PND is designed for fast neutron including irradiation field, depth under water (the sub-
(200 keV–15 MeV) detection corresponding to 0.01–50 mSv cutaneous depth), and distance away from the beam axis
with a threshold around 100 keV, and insensitive to (the off-axis distance) were considered in this experiment
thermal neutrons; while the BDT senses mainly thermal (Fig. 2). On the axis of the 15 MV photon beam, the
neutrons to respond the dose of 0.01–1 mSv. In general photoneutron dose equivalent (PNDE) of the water
diagnosis and therapy under a radiation field, contribu- phantom was measured five times with the bubble detectors
tions of fast and thermal neutrons are both necessary to be at the depth of 0, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25 and 30 cm under various
Fig. 1. Response of BD-PND bubble detectors before (a) and after (b)
neutron irradiation. Superheated liquid in viscous polymers transforms Fig. 2. Illustration of placed positions of bubble detectors in the water
into bubbles while energetic neutrons pass through the detectors. phantom. The top face was confronting the 15 MV photon beam.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
J.-P. Lin et al. / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 65 (2007) 599–604 601
irradiation beam size (10 10 cm2 or 40 40 cm2 (the Under the beam size of either 10 10 cm2 or 40 40 cm2,
largest field)). Besides, under the beam size of 10 10 cm2 both the dose equivalents in water caused by fast neutrons
and the depth of 0 and 10 cm, the bubble detectors were and thermal neutrons decrease with irradiation depths at
positioned at various distance (3, 5, 10, 15 and 20 cm) from the isocenter axis as illustrated in Fig. 3. Furthermore,
the beam axis. For each position, five measurements were PNDEs from fast neutrons are similar at depths shallower
done. More than 1 h of standing was allowed after each than 10 cm under both fields. However, they decay slightly
measurement to stabilize the bubble detectors for next faster under the beam size of 40 40 cm2 than those under
detection. Furthermore, to obtain actual dose equivalent 10 10 cm2 as the depth further increases. This may be
caused by each Gy of photons at the detection point, the ascribed to higher amount of tungsten in the beam
MU (monitor unit) value of the LINAC was varied with direction under smaller field size (10 10 cm2), which
detecting position of the bubble detectors inside the increases the neutron production.
phantom. After 10 min of standing following each expo- On the other hand, the thermal PNDEs under
sure, bubbles generated in the detectors were estimated 40 40 cm2 and 10 10 cm2 are similar (Fig. 3). However,
with a BDR-III automatic reader (Bubble Technology the thermal PNDEs on the axis under larger beam size are
Industries, 2006). By proper compression, the bubbles were slightly less than those under the smaller one at depths
vanished and the detectors are capable of reusing shallower than 15 cm. The slight difference may arise from
immediately. The obtained data were diagramed for more thermal neutrons occurring at the jaws under smaller
further analysis. beam size, which contributes higher thermal PNDE to the
shallower region.
3. Results and discussion By nonlinear curve fitting, the PNDE of fast and thermal
neutrons under the above fields may be symbolized as f(r),
Photoneutrons generated in the accelerator head shield- a function of the depth, r, on the beam axis. The function
ing are mainly produced from two mechanisms: evapora- f(r) reveals composite effect of the decay of photon flux
tion contribution and direct process. The evaporation after flattening, the decay of neutron fluence/energy
neutrons are in the majority of the photoneutrons and their by scatter or collision with the nuclei of collimator and
spectra are described by Eq. (1), where E and T denote the jaws, as well as the deceleration of fast neutrons in the
energy and nuclear temperature of the neutrons from a water phantom. Furthermore, the PNDE function f(r)
certain nucleus (NCRP No. 79, 1984; Tosi et al., 1991), for fast neutrons may be approximately represented as
respectively, ff(r)1600( ¼ 14.0r3+249.9r21577.9r+4079.8) and ff(r)100
( ¼ 21.1r3+327.9r21789.5r+4262) under the beam size
dN n E E of 40 40 cm2 and 10 10 cm2, respectively, where the
¼ 2 exp . (1)
dE T T subscripts f and the numerals (100 and 1600) denote fast
neutron and beam size. Similarly, PNDEs from thermal
Considering the relative contribution of the components
neutrons under the beam size of 10 10 cm2 and
described above, the total spectrum of an isotropic neutron
40 40 cm2 are represented as ft(r)100 ( ¼ 0.8278r3+
source can be mathematically illustrated by Eq. (2) (Tosi et
23.82r2212.0r+656.9) and ft(r)1600 ( ¼ 1.84r3+35.8r2
al., 1991), where EM denotes the maximum energy of the
240.2r+623.3), respectively, where the subscripts t denote
photons, and the numeral 7.34 denotes the average binding
thermal neutron. It is observable that the dose equivalent
energy (7.34 MeV) of neutrons emitted from the tungsten
from fast neutrons is about five times higher than that from
dN n 0:8929E expðE=TÞ thermal neutrons as shown in Fig. 3. Obviously, fast
¼
dE T2 photoneutron emission is dominant in the photonuclear
0:1071 ln½E M =ðE þ 7:34Þ reaction initiated by the 15 MV photon beam, and
þ R E M 7:34 . ð2Þ contributes the major part of photoneutron contamination
0 ln½E M =ðE þ 7:34Þ dE
during the operation of high-energy clinical LINAC.
The corresponding nuclear temperature for the produc- According to PNDE curves of fast neutrons in Fig. 3,
tion of neutrons in tungsten is 0.5 MeV (NCRP No. 79, accumulated PNDE, D(r), along the axis between depth a
1984). By introducing EM ( ¼ 15 MeV) and T ( ¼ 0.5 MeV) and b may be calculated by Eq. (4), to estimate total dose
into Eq. (2), the photoneutron spectrum can then be equivalent inside a specific region
expressed as Z b
DðrÞ ¼ 2p rf ðrÞ dr. (4)
dN n 15
¼ 3:5716E expð2EÞ þ 0:044366 ln . (3) a
dE E þ 7:34
As illustrated in Fig. 4, fast PNDEs at the depth of 0 and
Accordingly, the mean and maximum energy of neutrons 10 cm under the field of 10 10 cm2 are both decreased
before crossing the head of 15 MV LINAC is 1.15 MeV and abruptly with off-axis distance inside the beam size while
about 7.6 MeV (Swanson, 1980; Facure et al., 2005), are moderately decreased outside the beam size. This
respectively. In addition, the most probable energy in the approximately conforms to the inverse proportionality of
spectrum is 0.5 MeV (ascribed to the evaporation term). the direct neutron fluence to the square distance as derived
ARTICLE IN PRESS
602 J.-P. Lin et al. / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 65 (2007) 599–604
2000
1500
1000
500
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
r (cm)
Fig. 3. Photoneutron dose equivalents f(r) (mSv/Gy) measured with BD-PND and BDT bubble detectors at the depth (r) of 0, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25 and 30 cm
on axis of the photon beam under the field of 10 10 cm2 and 40 40 cm2, respectively, were represented as ff(r)100 and ff(r)1600. Similarly, PNDEs from
thermal neutrons under the field of 10 10 cm2 and 40 40 cm2 were represented as ft(r)100 and ft(r)1600, respectively. The PNDE functions were described
as follows: ff(r)100 ¼ 21.1r3+327.9r21789.5r+4262, R2 ¼ 0.998; ff(r)1600 ¼ 14.0r3+249.9r21577.9r+4079.8, R2 ¼ 0.994; ft(r)100 ¼ 0.8278r3+
23.82r2212.0r+656.9, R2 ¼ 0.994; ft(r)1600 ¼ 1.84r3+35.8r2240.2r+623.3, R2 ¼ 0.992.
d’Errico, F., Nath, R., Silvano, G., Tana, L., 1998a. In vivo neutron National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurement, 1984.
dosimetry during high-energy bremsstrahlung radiotherapy. Int. J. Neutron contamination from medical electron accelerator. NCRP
Radiat. Oncol. 41 (5), 1185–1192. Report No. 79, Washington, DC, pp. 5–60.
d’Errico, F., Nath, R., Tana, L., Curzio, G., Alberts, W.G., 1998b. In- Ongaro, C., Zanini, A., Nastasi, U., Ródenas, J., Ottaviano, G.,
phantom dosimetry and spectrometry of photoneutrons from an Manfredotti, C., 2000. Analysis of photoneutron spectra produced in
18 MV linear accelerator. Med. Phys. 25 (9), 1717–1724. medical accelerators. Phys. Med. Biol. 45, L55–L61.
d’Errico, F., Luszik-Bhadra, M., Nath, R., Siebert, B.R., Wolf, U., 2001. Peurrung, A.J., 2000. Recent development in neutron detection. Nucl.
Depth dose-equivalent and effective energies of photoneutrons Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 443, 400–415.
generated by 6–18 MV X-ray beams for radiotherapy. Health Phys. Roy, S.C., Roy, B., 2003. Use of superheated liquid in neutron detection.
80 (1), 4–11. Curr. Sci. 84 (4), 516–528.
Facure, A., Falcãl, R.C., Silva, A.X., Crispim, V.R., Vitorelli, J.C., 2005. Scott, M.B., Hanson, A.O., Kerst, D.W., 1955. Electro- and photo-
A study of neutron spectra from medical linear accelerators. Appl. disintegration cross sections of 63 Cu. Phys. Rev. 100, 205.
Radiat. Isotopes 62, 69–72. Sohrabi, M., Mostofizadeh, A., 1999. Measurement of photoneutron
Glaser, D.A., 1952. Some effects of ionizing radiation on the formation of doses in and out of high-energy X-ray beam of a Saturne-20 medical
bubbles in liquids. Phys. Rev. 87, 665. linear accelerator by ECE polycarbonate detectors. Radiat. Meas. 31
Green, A.R., Andrews, H.R., Bennett, L.G.I., Clifford, E.T.H., Ing, H., (1–6), 479–482.
Jonkmans, G., Lewis, B.J., Noulty, R.A., Ough, E.A., 2005. Bubble Spicka, J.I., Kim, H.S., Oh, D.W., Marable, V., Fleury, K., 1989. Equal
detector characterization for space radiation. Acta Astronaut. 56, 949–960. surface dose compensation. Med. Dosim. 14 (4), 287–290.
Hall, E.J., 1996. Neutrons and carcinogenesis: a cautionary tale. Bull. Swanson, W.P., 1978. Calculation of neutron yield released by electron
Cancer/Raidother. 83 (1), 43s–46s. incident selected materials. Health Phys. 35, 353–367.
Ing, H., Noulty, R.A., Mclean, T.D., 1997. Bubble detectors—a maturing Swanson, W.P., 1980. Estimate of the risk in radiation therapy due to
technology. Radiat. Meas. 27 (1), 1–11. unwanted neutrons. Med. Phys. 7 (2), 141–144.
Konefat, A., Dybek, M., Zipper, W., Lobodziec, W., Szczucka, K., 2005. Tosi, G., Torresin, A., Agosteo, S., Para, A.F., Sangiust, V., Zeni, L.,
Thermal and epithermal neutrons in the vicinity of the Primus Siemens Silari, M., 1991. Neutron measurements around medical accelera-
biomedical accelerator. Nukleonika 50 (2), 73–81. tors by active and passive detection techniques. Med. Phys. 18 (1),
Lin, J.P., Chu, T.C., Lin, S.Y., Liu, M.T., 2001. The measurement of 54–60.
photoneutron in the vicinity of Seimens primus linear accelerator. Tu, C.Q., Guo, S.L., Wang, Y.L., Hao, X.H., Chen, C.M., Su, J.L., 1997.
Appl. Radiat. Isotopes 55, 315–321. Study of bubble damage detectors for neutron detection. Radiat.
Lo, Y.C., 1987. Characterization of a neutron detector based on super- Meas. 28 (1–6), 159–162.
heated drops. Ph.D. Thesis, Yale University. Turner, J.E., 1995. Atoms, Radiation, and Radiation Protection, second
McCall, R.C., Almond, P.R., Holeman, G.R., Devanney, I.A., Lanzl, ed. Wiley, New York, p. 184.
L.H., Fuller, E.G., 1984. Neutron contamination from medical Zanini, A., Nastas, U., Scielzo, G., Bum, K.W., Ongaro, C., Fasolo, F.,
electron accelerator. NCRP Report 79, Bethesla, MD, USA. 2001. Analysis of photoneutrons produced in medical accelerators with
McGinley, P.H., 1998. Shielding Techniques for Radiation Oncology different collimation techniques. Radiother. Oncol. 61 (Suppl. 1),
Facilities. Medical Physics Publishing, Madison, WI, pp. 9–79. S112.