Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Comparative Controlled Study
A Comparative Controlled Study
To cite this article: Hend D. Gamil, Mohamed M. Nasr, Fathia M. Khattab & Amira M. Ibrahim
(2019): Combined therapy of plantar warts with topical bleomycin and microneedling: a comparative
controlled study, Journal of Dermatological Treatment, DOI: 10.1080/09546634.2019.1612837
Article views: 28
ARTICLE
CONTACT Fathia M. Khattab fathiakhattab@yahoo.com Department of Dermatology, Faculty of Medicine, Zagazig University, Zagazig, Egypt
ß 2019 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
2 H. D. GAMIL ET AL.
then superficially pared with a scalpel (blade no. 22) to remove Evaluation of response was done as, complete response (CR):
the associated callus without reaching the bleeding points. disappearance of the wart(s) and a return of the normal skin mark-
Microneedling (pen-type) was performed on each lesion using a ings with no recurrences, partial response (PR): 50–99% reduction
36 pins needle cartridge with a 1-cm tip diameter at a 2-mm in wart size, and no response (NR): 0–49% decrease in wart size.
depth setting for 2–3 min, with intermittent topical application of Follow up was done for 6 months after completion of the
bleomycin. In a single visit, a total of 0.2–0.5 mL of 0.1% of bleo- treatment for detection of any wart recurrence.
mycin solution was applied depending on the size of the single A chi-square (v2), t-test or Fisher’s exact test and ANOVA (f test)
wart with a maximum of 2 mL for multiple warts in each patient were applied for statistical analysis. In all tests, statistical signifi-
and occlusion for 12 h. Treatment was done for a maximum of cance was set at p .05.
four sessions at 2 weeks intervals (4).
As regards group B, it included 18 patients subjected to intra- Results
lesional bleomycin injection. The bleomycin vial containing 15 mg
powder was first diluted by 5 mL saline (3 mg/1 mL). Before injec- A total of 54 patients with plantar warts of different sizes, sites,
and numbers were enrolled in this study. Baseline parameters
tion, further dilution with 2% lidocaine was done using double
(age, sex, number, size, sites of warts, and wart duration) of the
the amount taken from the bleomycin vial, so their concentration
studied patients in the three groups are presented in Table 1.
becomes 1 mg/1 mL (1 unit/mL). This was injected into the base
As regards clinical response after the end of therapy among
of the wart, using a 100-unit insulin syringe that also provides
three groups showed a highly statistically significant difference of
concurrent acceptable anesthesia. The injection was continued
groups A and B as compared to the control group. In group A, CR
until each wart had blanched. was detected in 16 patients (88.9%) and PR in two patients
In a single visit, less than 2 mL of 0.1% bleomycin solution was (11.1%). In group B, complete clearance was observed in 15
given to avoid any systemic side effects in a given patient. patients (83.3%) and PR in three patients (16.7%). In group C,
Treatment was done for a maximum of four sessions at 3 weeks complete clearance of the treated warts was observed only in one
intervals (9). Intralesional injection of normal saline was done in patient (5.6%) and PR in two patients (11.1%) (Table 2).
group C into warts for up to four sessions. Comparison of clinical response after the end of therapy
The response was evaluated by a decrease in the size of warts according to the number of warts among group A and group B
and photographic comparison at baseline and at each visit. showed a statistically significant difference of group A as com-
Immediate and late adverse effects of microneedling with topical pared to group B in the fourth session (p ¼ .0017) and the overall
bleomycin and intralesional bleomycin (including local pain dur- response (p ¼ .02).
ing and after treatment, pigment changes, scarring, tissue dam- No statistically significant relation was detected between the
age, itching) were recorded at each treatment session. size of warts and clinical response in group A and group B.
A pain scale of 0 (no pain) to 10 (the worst pain the patient In group A, a highly statistically significant relation was detected
has ever felt) was used to measure the injection pain as (1–3) between age (mean age 25.6 ± 7.8 and range 13–40) and CR to
mild, (4–6) moderate, and (7–10) severe. therapy (p < .001) while a non-significant relation was detected in
Table 2. Comparison of overall response according to number of warts in the three studied groups.
Group A Group B Group C
(81 warts) (63 warts) (41 warts)
Overall response No. % No. % No. % v2 p Value
CR 77 95.06 53 84.12 1 2.44 174.6 <.001
PR 4 4.9 10 15.87 2 4.8 (HS)
NR 0 0.0 0 0.0 38 68
v2 ¼ chi-squared test.
p < 0.001 ¼ highly significant (HS).
Table 3. Side effects of treatment among group A and group B. In this study, comparison of clinical response in the three
Group A Group B groups showed a highly statistically significant difference of
microneedling group (group A) and intralesional group (group B)
Side effects No. % No. % v2 p Value
as compared to the control group. Complete clearance was
Local pain 18 100.0 18 100.0 0.0 1.0 (NS)
Mild hyperpigmentation 2 11.1 3 16.67 0.23 .62 (NS) detected in 88.9% of patients in group A and 83.3% of patients in
Erythema, edema 0 0.0 10 55.5 13.05 <.001 (HS) group B compared to 5.6% in the control group, with no recur-
Hemorrhagic blister 0 0.0 6 33.3 5.0 .025 (Sig.) rence during the 6 months follow up. Also, comparison of clinical
Infection 0 0.0 1 5.5 0.0 1.0 (NS) response according to the number of warts showed a statistically
Local itching 0 0.0 1 5.5 0.0 1.0 (NS)
significant difference in group A (95.06%) as compared to group
means significant (Sig.).
means highly significant B (84.12%) and control group (2.44%).
(HS).
The results of this study in group A, with complete clearance
in 88.9% of patients using dermapen with topical 1 U/mL bleo-
Table 4. Comparison of pain scale degree among group A and group B. mycin coincides with that reported by Al-Naggar et al. (10) of
Pain scale Group A (n¼ 18) Group B (n¼ 18) t p Value 83.3% clearance in their non-controlled study, using the same
Mild (1–3) 18 0 14.75 <.001 technique with no recurrence during 3 months follow up.
Moderate (4–6) 0 18 (HS) In contrast, it reported 100% clearance of recalcitrant warts
Severe (7–10) 0 0
using the same technique, which may be attributed to the low
Mean ± SD 1.1 ± 0.3 4.7 ± 0.9
Range (1–2) (4–6) number of treated cases (three cases only) in their study (4); also,
t-test or Fisher Exact test. reported complete clearance in 74% of patients with plantar warts
p < 0.001 ¼ highly significant (HS). using the translesional multipuncture technique (11). This
decrease in clearance rate may be attributed to the very low con-
centration (0.1 U/mL) of bleomycin used compared to 1 U/mL of
group B. In group A, a statistically significant association was bleomycin concentration in this study.
detected between unilateral lesions and CR to therapy (p ¼ .018) In the present work, CR was detected in 95.06% of treated
while a non-significant relation was detected in group B. warts in group A. Similarly, Shelley and Shelley (12), who were the
In group A, there was a highly statistically significant associ- first to use the multipuncture technique for warts via a bifurcated
ation between the clinical response of patients to therapy and vaccination needle, reported 92% clearance rate of treated warts
disease duration (p < .001) with increase mean duration among after a single treatment with no recurrence for 6 months. A non-
partially responder cases (24 ± 0.0 months) compared to com- controlled early multipuncture technique reported using a
pletely responded (10.8 ± 10.4 months). Monolet needle in plantar, palmar and periungual warts showed
The relation between previous therapy and clinical response 92% clearance rate with 11% recurrence after 1–4 years follow up
among group A and group B showed no statistically significant (13). Also, a case with a recalcitrant plantar wart that responded
association among partially responded cases compared to com- completely to multipuncture administration of higher concentra-
pletely responded. tion of bleomycin (3 U/mL) with no side effects was reported (14).
The adverse effects in group A revealed that mild hyperpig- Superficial paring was done with a scalpel before micronee-
mentation was observed in two patients (11.11%); as regards dling with dermapen in group A. The abrupt separation between
group B, erythema and edema at injection site in 10 patients the wart tissue and the protective horny ring becomes more obvi-
(55.5%), Hemorrhagic blister in six patients (33.3%), mild hyperpig- ous, as the epithelial ridges of the plantar skin are not continued
mentation in three patients (16.67), local infection in one patient over the surface of the wart. If the paring is continued, small
(5.5%), and local plantar itching in one patient (5.5%) (Table 3). bleeding points, the tips of the elongated dermal papillae, are evi-
A high statistically significant difference in the pain scale dent (15).
degree was recorded in group A compared to group B (p < .001) The results of this study in group B, with complete clearance
(Table 4). The photomicrographic documentations are shown in in 83.3% of patients treated by intralesional injection of 1 U/mL
Figures 1–4. bleomycin, higher than that reported by Al-Naggar et al. (10) in
In the present study, no recurrence was observed in any of the their non-controlled and that reported by Barkat et al. (16) in their
studied patients after the 6-month follow-up period. dermoscopic assisted placebo-controlled of 70% clearance using
the same technique (paring before injection at 2 weeks interval)
with no recurrence during 3 months follow up. This decrease in
Discussion
clearance rate may be attributed to debridement of the lesions
Treatment of plantar warts is a therapeutic challenge regarding prior to injection allows leakage of the solution and reduces the
both tolerability and efficacy. An innovative approach to combin- effectiveness of intralesional bleomycin.
ing microneedle with topical bleomycin for the treatment of recal- Similarly, reported 94.9% clearance in their noncontrolled
citrant plantar warts was reported (4). study, using the same technique with 13% recurrence rate. This
4 H. D. GAMIL ET AL.
Figure 1. A 25 years old male with multiple warts on right big toe and 4th metatarsal head showed a complete response after two sessions of dermapen with topical
bleomycin.
Figure 2. A 42 years old male with a wart lesion on right sole showed partial response after four sessions of dermapen with topical bleomycin.
may be attributed to more bleomycin solution remained within In contrast, 23% clearance of recalcitrant plantar warts with
warts during the high-pressure injections and through one punc- perilesional bleomycin injection after paring was reported. In their
ture site (9). subsequent study, they reported 65% clearance with intralesional
In the present work, CR was detected in 84.12% of injected single-injection bleomycin without paring suggesting that the suc-
warts in group B that coincides with that reported to use the cess of bleomycin treatment can be technique dependent (18).
intralesional technique of 1 U/mL bleomycin for plantar warts via In the current study, a statistically significant difference was
the dermojet for a maximum of five sessions with 5 weeks inter- found between groups A and B in therapy duration where a more
val, reported 89.9% clearance of treated warts with 4.4% recur- rapid response was observed in group A (p ¼ .0012). Therapy dur-
rence rate (17). ation was 6.4 ± 1.8 weeks for microneedling and 9 ± 2.3 weeks for
JOURNAL OF DERMATOLOGICAL TREATMENT 5
Figure 3. A case of 53 years old male with wart lesions on left sole showed complete response after two sessions of intralesional bleomycin.
Figure 4. A case of 32 years old male with a recalcitrant wart on right sole showed partial response after four sessions of intralesional saline.
intralesional bleomycin. The mean number of sessions for CR was Also, in this study, a highly statistically significant correlation
3.18 ± 0.8 in group A at 2-week intervals and 3.2 ± 0.7 in group B was only detected in group A, between the CR and both the age
at 3-week intervals. These results coincide with that reported by of patients (p < .001) and duration of warts (p < .001). Warts with
Al-Naggar et al. (10). shorter duration were more likely to respond to microneedling
6 H. D. GAMIL ET AL.