Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Statistics
Statistics
Factors Impacting Online Gaming Addiction and Mental Health of Adolescents Studying in Five
Sadia Shaheen
University of Karachi
January, 2022
A research report submitted in partial fulfilment of the course requirements of the Masters of Philosophy
Table of Contents
Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... 4
Factors Impacting Online Gaming Addiction and Mental Health of Adolescents Studying in Five
Hypotheses .................................................................................................................................. 6
Rationale: .................................................................................................................................... 7
Literature Review............................................................................................................................ 8
Methodology ................................................................................................................................. 10
Research Design........................................................................................................................ 10
Participants ................................................................................................................................ 11
Sampling ................................................................................................................................... 12
Procedure .................................................................................................................................. 13
Influence of time spent on online gaming on adolescents’ online gaming addiction ............... 18
Influence of different games played by adolescents on their internet gaming addiction score 21
The relationship between mental health and internet gaming addiction ................................... 23
References ..................................................................................................................................... 26
4
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to investigate the factors impacting online gaming addiction and mental health
including emotional, psychoNo table of figures entries found.logical and social well-being of adolescents who
are studying in five secondary schools of Karachi, Pakistan. Pakistan has about 118.8 million internet users,
making it the 8th-largest population of internet users in the world (“Wikipedia: Internet in Pakistan”, 2021,
para.1). This fact implies that even the adolescents who belong to low socio-economic status have access to
internet. This was initially due to the online teaching and learning demands. Most of the adolescents in Karachi
got the access to internet and digital devices during COVID-19. Now these adolescents after attending their
classes and researching on internet are exposed to multiple internet games and got indulged in playing these
games more often. It is hypothesized that engagement in the online gaming, refers electronic game playing over a
computer network, particularly over the Internet, has impacts on the overall mental health including emotional,
psychological and social well-being of these adolescents. The design of this study is between-subject design and it
is a quasi-experimental study in which a sample from the population of gamers is taken on purposive sampling
basis. The sample is comprised of 103 participants who play online games (average age = 14.6, SD=1.8). As the
sample is already involved in gaming, the researcher will conduct a survey by finding out the factors impacting
online gaming addiction (OGA) and Mental Health (MH) including the adolescents’ emotional, psychological and
social wellbeing. The Internet gaming Disorder Scale–Short-Form (IGDS9-SF) (Pontes & Griffiths, 2015)
comprises of 9-items and Mental Health Continuum Short Form (MHC-SF) (Keyes, 2007) comprises of 14-items,
is utilized as measures for data collection. Statistical analysis is done through SPSS V-26.0. Descriptive statistical
tools is used for demographics, Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) for determining the influence of different
variables and Pearson r correlation is used to find out the correlation of online gaming with mental health. The
results showed that there is a significant influence of several factors on OGA and MH where as a weak negative
correlation is found between online gaming addiction and mental health of adolescents. On the basis of result
findings, recommendations are made for the concerned parents, teachers and adolescents themselves to see the
other side of the coin. Keywords: online gaming, mental health, adolescents
5
Factors Impacting Online Gaming Addiction and Mental Health of Adolescents Studying in Five
Online games and their effects on mental health is one of the increasing concerns of all
concerned with adolescents. Out of 54%, about 76% of Pakistanis are connected to the internet in
Karachi, Lahore, Rawalpindi and Islamabad (“Country’s Internet Penetration stands at 54%”, 2021,
para, 1).
Adolescents are the future of any society. Their engagement with productive activities is always
cherished but not to the extent of addiction. There are studies that give a positive outlook to this
engagement (Dumrique & Castillo, 2018). Yet there are several researches done on the online gaming
addiction showing adverse effects on wholistic development of an adolescent (Kuss et al., 2013,
This study is conducted in Karachi, one of the cosmopolitan cities of Pakistan. As per statistics
already shared in the abstract, more than 75% of the population here has access to internet (Tribune
Newspaper). But the proper usage of this facility is unknown to adolescents due to which most of them
are using it for playing online games. Here comes the question of their mental health status as four
youths reportedly committed suicide across the country after missing a task on a famous online video
game that triggered a big debate on the psychological impact of the online games (Asia Pacific).
Following the incidents, the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA), a state-run regulatory
authority, which was already pressured by a series of complaints from parents, slapped a ban on several
online games. But the ban was quickly lifted as activists argued this was an attack on freedom of
expression (Pakistan: Teen suicide triggers debate on the online gaming, 2020, para 1). Arthur Cassidy,
6
an associate fellow of the British Psychological Society, said that cases of growing attachment to gaming
devices among children, which subsequently leads to suicide or self-harm, are on the rise across the
world. Whereas our neighbour China’s video game regulator has said that online gamers under the age
of 18 will only be allowed to play for an hour on Fridays, weekends and holidays (Daily Times, 2021).
Research Questions
1. Does the time spent on online gaming (IV) significantly influence Online Gaming
2. Does different games played online gaming (IV) significantly influence Online Gaming
3. Is there a significant relationship between adolescents’ online gaming addiction and their
mental health?
Hypotheses
On the basis of the research questions, I have framed my alternate and null hypotheses.
Ho1: It is hypothesized that there is no significant difference in the online gaming addiction
Ho2: It is hypothesized that there is no significant difference in the online gaming addiction
Ho3: It is been hypothesized that online gaming has no significant relationship with mental
Alternate Hypotheses:
Ha1: there is a significant difference in the internet gaming addiction score of adolescents,
Ha3: There is a significant relationship between online gaming and mental health of adolescents.
Rationale:
This study is inevitable firstly, to investigate the factors impacting online gaming addiction and
mental health status of the adolescents. It will also lead to subsequent study of the relationship and
causation components among these variables in the context of Pakistan which will bring in view the
insights regarding positive and negative impacts of online gaming on adolescents’ mental health.
8
Literature Review
Extensive literature is available since online gaming has become a disorder and accepted by
DSM V in 2013. When the researcher studied the components of addiction and the criteria to make
online gaming a disorder, it was something shocking. For becoming addicted, a person has to meet the
criteria and according to the researchers’ observations, adolescents in Karachi are developing some of
the attitude that may lead to addiction and disorder. The present state of wellbeing of these adolescents is
"Winning always attracts the children which manipulates them. The manufacturers of video
games surely know how to make these apps addictive," Cassidy told Anadolu Agency. The World Health
Organization has also classified the phenomenon as gaming disorder. People are watching online content
more than ever as they have nothing to do during the lockdown. Online gaming platforms are even
turning into international level tournaments with huge investments," the PTA spokesman said.
Online gaming
The term online gaming has been explored by many psychologists and not just recently but it had
been the point of concern since early 1990s. As internet was officially launched in 1983, these online
games became popular in late 1980s and people switched from video games to online gaming. Internet
as a source of information plays an important role in developing one’s mind and life experiences by
creating productive works in schools, offices, and even at home. Nowadays, this can be a person’s most
efficient strategic tool for enabling himself to take charge and cope with the fast growing technology.
The fact that people live in on informative lifestyle where everything is updated, internet became one of
the necessities of human beings regardless of age or sex in today’s society. However, the influence of
this useful machine on youth is undeniably questionable. As to what Rock (2008) said, all these
technologies are very good at distracting people. In line with this development, online gaming was
9
created to give entertainment to people. Online gaming is one of the widely used leisure activities by
many people. For some people it is said that playing video games has a number of reasons to be played,
for it can be a stress reliever, challenge and competition, relaxation, enjoyment, social interaction, and
even mentally escaping from the real world. For most people, on-line gaming is one of the best past time
that they acquire specially for teenagers, youngsters and students. According to Kuss & Griffiths (2012),
teens who play online games are just having fun. They do not just actually play because of some sort of
seriousness, but also because they just want to feel relief. During school hours, students tend to feel
stressed due to loads of school works and through playing it will relive their stress. It is undeniably
questionable that playing online games provide them something that no one can give. According to some
researches it is beneficial. It enables the mind of the players to be more active, especially those puzzle-
based games. Furthermore, it helps the player to come up with decisions in tight situations, especially
those adventure games that keep the players to be alert, active and strategic. Students’ learning takes
place unexpectedly, but the inappropriate usage of playing online games also leads in some problems
such as being distracted in school. Further, it is where the attention of the child were divided that even
their health and social life is unknowingly affected. Several studies in psychology have found out that
increased time spent on the Internet can lead to negative impact on a person’s ability to communicate
appropriately face-to-face with friends, peers, family members including parents. Studies revealed that
the human brain is easy to destruct and one of the reasons is using technology. The education system
tends to go with the flow with this constant change in the society in order to get things relevant with the
generations today.
Mental Wellbeing
Wellbeing is always a big concern of all linked with adolescents: their parents, teachers, and so on.
There are areas of wellbeing such as emotional wellbeing, psychological wellbeing and social wellbeing.
10
Methodology
Research Design
This research study is based on quasi experimental – between subject design (AKA independent
subject design). Quasi-experimental studies evaluate the association between an intervention and an
outcome using experiments in which the intervention is not randomly assigned. Quasi-experimental
studies can be used to measure the impact of large-scale interventions where data are reported in
Sensitivity Analysis
Before starting the research, for a good power and effect size, the sample size was calculated
keeping in view the error margin as 5%, confidence level as 95% whereas the population size is 2500
approximately and 50% response distribution. The ideal sample size came as 334 participants.
Sensitivity analyses suggest this sample size provides adequate power (.809). So I went ahead
but with limited time and tedious process of data collection, I could only manage to approach 200
participants out of which 97 did not meet the inclusive criteria set for maintaining the homogeneity of
the sample to apply One-Way ANOVA which is one of the basic assumption of the applied test.
Null Hypothesis is …
True False
Seemingly smaller sample size than suggested might have triggered the Type I error (False
Positive Error). Type I error is essentially the rejection of the true null hypothesis. Note that type I error
does not imply that we erroneously accept the alternative hypothesis of a study. This is not possible to
11
completely eliminate the chances of a Type I error in hypothesis testing however there are opportunities
to minimize the risks of obtaining results that contain Type I error by minimizing the significance level
of a hypothesis testing (α level to p<.01 or p<.001) since it is chosen by the researcher. Having said that
by lowering the significance level one may lead to a situation where in the results of the hypothesis test
may not capture the true parameter or the true different of the test.
Participants
The constitution of the participants is based on 200 adolescents from five secondary schools of
Karachi out of which 103 met the inclusive criteria i.e. they were online gamers (average age = 14.6, SD
= 1.8) who play online games daily. Out of the inclusive participants 81 were male and 22 were females.
Due to the set criteria for homogeneity, the sampling distribution is found to be mesokurtic and
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
Sampling
For this study, purposive sampling is preferred. Just to keep track of the errors, that might be
committed due to less representative sample, the researcher selected five secondary schools of Karachi
in the district central and east of Karachi, Pakistan. A sample of 103 participants consisting of 81 males
Ethical consideration
As the researcher selected the schools for data collection, the administration of these schools
were approached through a prior appointment. The purpose of the research study and all potential
concerns were shared. On the basis of the meeting, the administration allowed the researcher to
approach the respective class teacher and in the presence of the class teachers that survey questionnaire
Participants’ demographics such as gender, age, socio-economic background, game type and name, no.
of hours spent on playing game, days of the week on which they play games, pocket money range and
grade level.
13
The short forms of mental health continuum (MHC - SF) through which their current level of
psychological functioning and confirms the implication of the mental health linear model.
The short-form is an abridged version of the MHC-LF that consists of 14 items in total: 3 items
measuring emotional well-being, five items assessing the five dimensions of Keyes’ model of social
well-being (Keyes, 1998) and six items measuring the six dimensions of Ryff’s model of psychological
well-being (Ryff, 1989). The test has high validity and internal consistency reliability, making its
usefulness unquestionable for assessing mental health and mental health problems. The long and short
forms of the mental health continuum model are useful for the neuropsychological understanding of
mental health disorders and their impact on our daily lives (Keyes & Simoes, 2012).
The third measure is the internet gaming disorder scale – short form (IGDS-SF) by Pontes an Griffiths
(2015). It consists of nine items based on the gaming activity during the past year (i.e. last twelve
43 Online adolescents
54 were not gamers playing for few 103 Online adolescents
adolescents gamers hours on weekends gamers playing throughout
(excluded) (excluded) the week
The participants of this research were approached through proper channel that means their school
administration was asked for permission and were told about the details and nature of the study. Once
they agreed, researcher went to the schools at different intervals on different ask participants to give
basic demographic information about themselves on the basis of which almost half of the participants
were excluded and around 103 participants were included in the study after seeking their informed
consent.
As the participants were not very much familiar with the research and use of Likert scales and
even the language of the scales used in the survey questionnaire (researcher came to know this during
the pilot study) so researcher read the questionnaire to them in small groups and they also asked for any
further clarification (if needed) as researcher was present there with them throughout.
The researcher reached out for the adolescents in a school setting. After taking the informed
consent, students were approached and then purposive only those were asked to be the part of the study
Those participants were given the main research instrument i.e. the survey questionnaire.
Students were given collective instructions and if someone still unclear, then individual instructions
were also given. Once they filled the form, researcher glanced at those and check for any
incompleteness. This process took around 10 -15 different sessions altogether in five different schools.
Researcher properly thanked the concerned personnel and the participants for their voluntary
participation. Once all the data was collected then researcher coded the demographics and both scales
Analysis technique
Pearson correlation and One-Way ANOVA is applied and analyzed using SPSS (v.26). The
The objectives of the research study were analyzed through the use of descriptive statistics. The sample
was collected through purposive sampling as only those students were asked to fill the research survey
questionnaire (the main instrument of data gathering consisted of relevant demographics, basic
information regarding gaming behaviour, IGDS9-SF and MHC-SF) who play online games and age
range between 12-18 years. This study was conducted with 103 participants belonging to five different
secondary schools of Karachi, who completely filled the survey questionnaire. Statistical measures of
the descriptive statistics such as frequencies, percentages and Pearson r Correlation was applied.
Based on the data gathered and analyzed, the following salient features are drawn.
Table 1
Frequencies and percentages of the different categories showing profile of the participants
Category Sub-category F %
Age 12 years old 7 6.8
13 years old 29 28.2
14 years old 20 19.4
15 years old 23 22.3
16 years old 4 3.9
17 years old 7 6.8
18 years old 13 12.6
Total 103 100
Gender Male 81 78.6
Female 22 21.4
Total 103 100
Monthly Less than 500 rupees 20 19.4
Pocket Money 500-1000 rupees 5 4.9
1000-1500 rupees 22 21.4
More than 1500 rupees 56 54.4
Total 103 100
Internet gaming is high among adolescents between 13-15 years as they constituted 70% of the
total sample. This is the age when they have entered their teen age and forming their identity where they
16
want to satisfy their power need, increase their buying capacity and socialize with their peer as many of
The sample had 78.6% of the male participants and only 21.4% were female so we cannot
Preferred games
Table 2
N %
PubG 48 46.6
Free Fire 15 14.6
Candy Crush Saga 12 11.7
Minecraft 6 5.8
Solitaire 1 1.0
8-Balls Pool 2 1.9
Others 19 18.4
Total 103 100
Most of the participants play that genre of the games that have social element in it such as teams
This data distribution shows a positively skewed sample with a leptokurtic appearance. Ideally
for a normal distribution, this histogram should look symmetric around the mean of the distribution.
17
Table 3
N %
None (play alone) 17 16.5
One 14 13.6
Two 16 15.5
Three 20 19.4
Four 28 27.2
More than four 08 7.8
Total 103 100
Approximately 60% of the participants, always play with 2-4 players due to which their social
wellbeing and personal interaction with others is not affected. The participants have the partners as
Table 4
N %
Yes 47 45.6
No 56 54.4
Total 103 100
Number of hours spent on gaming daily
Table 5
N %
Less than an hour 14 13.6
1-2 hours 45 43.7
3-4 hours 16 15.5
5-6 hours 18 17.5
7-8 hours 6 5.8
More than 8 hours 4 3.9
Total 103 100
18
As almost half of the participants only play for 1 to 2 hours daily, this could be the reason that
When we address this research question “does the time spent on online gaming (IV) significantly
My null hypothesis is that there is no significant difference in the internet gaming addiction
scores, adolescents have, dependent on the time they spent daily on online gaming.
19
My alternate hypothesis is that there is a significant difference in the internet gaming addiction
scores, adolescents’ have, depending on the time they spent daily on online gaming.
Table 6
Means and Standard Deviations on the Measure of Internet Gaming Addiction Score
To find out the answer for my first research question, I have run it in SPSS V.26. The first output
box is shown in the table 6 above – descriptive statistics. This is going to tell us about total and
individual groups. We had 103 participants, their means and standard deviations. I analyzed the data
using a one-way analysis of variance set at a .05 alpha level. The group that played online games for less
than an hour daily scored an average of 17.57 (SD = 7.37) on internet gaming addiction scale, the group
that played online games for 1-2 hours daily scored an average of 20.91 (SD = 4.56), the group that
played online games for 3-4 hours daily scored an average of 24.31 (SD = 8.97), the group that played
online games for 5-6 hours daily scored an average of 24.11 (SD = 7.55), the group that played online
games for 7-8 hours daily scored an average of 31.00 (SD = 8.56) and the group that played online
games for more than 8 hours daily scored an average of 32.00 (SD = 1.16).
20
Table 7
One-Way Analysis of Variance of Internet Gaming Addiction Scores of Adolescents by Time Spent Daily
on Online Gaming
Source Df SS MS F Sig.
The second output is shown in table 7 – F statistics. First thing, I checked was the significance
value and I can see it is .000 and it is below the alpha level α of 0.05 so this is significant. Here the
significant level is .000 so I can write it is <.001 level. I can’t say it is equal to zero as it could be .0001
- .00049. If it were any other number, I am going to report it as p = exact number shown in Significance
column.
Here F-statistics means result of ANOVA is 6.228 and degree of freedom –between groups is 5
ANOVA is actually a ration that F statistic is actually a ratio that looks at the between groups
over the within groups so we always need to report for the both and this is how it is written in APA
format.
I have found that there is a significant difference in the internet gaming addiction scores that
each group average showed. Each group has been averaged so unfortunately, I cannot make out that
which group is different from which group. I just know that somewhere between these six groups there
is a significant difference in the internet gaming addiction score. For this I need to run a post-hoc test
that is also known as after-the-fact test. I have used Tukey HSD for that. It indicated that the mean
scores for each group was significantly different from each other. This means that the difference
identified is correct.
Influence of different games played by adolescents on their internet gaming addiction score
When we address the second research question “does different games (IV) played by daily online
adolescents gamers significantly influence internet gaming addiction score (DV), an adolescent has?”
into 6 groups):
Group 1: PubG
Group 2: FreeFire
Group 5: Solitaire
Group 6: Others
22
My null hypothesis is that there is no significant difference in the internet gaming addiction
scores, adolescents have, dependent on the different online games they play.
My alternate hypothesis is that there is a significant difference in the internet gaming addiction
scores, adolescents’ have, depending on the different online games they play.
Table 8
Means and Standard Deviations on the Measure of Internet Gaming Addiction Score
Table 7
One-Way Analysis of Variance of Internet Gaming Addiction Scores of Adolescents by Different Games
Source Df SS MS F Sig.
Here F-statistics means result of ANOVA is 3.420 and degree of freedom –between groups is 5
The assessment of the participants gave the inference that online gaming addiction is negatively
correlated (-0.279) to the mental well-being of the participants. At the same time, the significance level
is 0.01. This correlation between mental health and internet gaming addiction is weak. For this, there are
studies that gave the indication that these games are played as coping mechanism (Durmique & Castillo,
2018). It could be due to the initial and minimum exposure to the online gaming (Gismundo, 2020). Yet
24
another study done in Pakistan by Khan and Muqtadir (2014) also narrated that some gaming is
problematic where as some gaming is non-problematic. This weak correlation indicates that there are
other variables that are working on the neutralization of the mental health.
25
The limitations of the present study is the limited sample size. Even if more female participants could be
approached that there could a comparison between male and female gaming attitude.
Secondly, the tools for gathering data are not contextual and language of the tools also causes barrier in
understanding.
Third limitation is the group administration of the tool. Even after conscious instructions, many students
were confirming their answers with their peers. This might have also influenced the results.
Looking at the results of this study, it seems that internet gaming activities of the participants have not
yet came to a point where they could affect the mental health and wellbeing of the participants.
Several of the gaming attitudes such as playing for a limited time daily and playing with partners as a
team, have sustained their mental health and did not affect their wellbeing.
Having said that it cannot be ignored that the relationship between internet gaming addiction and mental
health is negatively associated and especially as the participants were mostly male, there is a dire need
of arranging more physical sports and indoor games that can be played more often so that to enhance
their physical, mental, social, emotional and overall sportsmanship. It will hopefully reduce the tendency
Furthermore, parents, school administrators, teachers need to build an alliance so that they can motivate
these teens in the same direction to be involved in more physical and practical activities rather than
virtual activities. It can also be a good idea to strength the bond between parents and teachers and make
the responsibilities functional so that time to time, both can inform each other of certain anti-social and
addictive behaviours. School administrations can organize certain awareness sessions for parents and
teachers so that they could be trained to handle the adolescents’ demands and channelize them in
References
Adolescent problematic internet use and parental mediation: A Bangladeshi structured interview
study. Addictive Behaviors Reports, 12, 100288.
Britannica encyclopedia https://www.britannica.com/technology/online-gaming
Butt, K. (2020, August 2) Pakistan: Teen suicides trigger debate on online gaming. Asia-Pacific
https://www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/pakistan-teen-suicides-trigger-debate-on-online-gaming/1929402
Chandrima, R. M., Kircaburun, K., Kabir, H., Riaz, B. K., Kuss, D. J., Griffiths, M. D., & Mamun, M. A.
(2020).
Country’s Internet Penetration Stands at 54%. (2020, July 30) Tribune: The Express
https://tribune.com.pk/story/2312994/countrys-internet-penetration-stands-at-54Dumrique, D. O., & Castillo, J. G.
(2018). Online gaming: Impact on the academic performance and social behavior of the students in Polytechnic
University of the Philippines Laboratory High School. KnE Social Sciences, 1205-1210.
Gismundo, G. I. A. W. (2020). Gaming Habits of Post-Millennial Gamers in Pangasinan State
University. ASEAN Multidisciplinary Research Journal, 5.
Internet in Pakistan (2021. September 26) Wikipedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Internet_in_Pakistan&oldid=1046499305
Kardefelt-Winther, D. (2014). The moderating role of psychosocial well-being on the relationship between
escapism and excessive online gaming. Computers in Human Behavior, 38, 68-74.
Khan, A., & Muqtadir, R. (2016). Motives of problematic and nonproblematic online gaming among
adolescents and young adults. Pakistan Journal of Psychological Research, 119-138.
Khan, A., & Muqtadir, R. (2014). Problematic online gaming in Pakistan. International Journal of Science
and Research, 3(6), 2522-2525.
Kuss, D. J., Van Rooij, A. J., Shorter, G. W., Griffiths, M. D., & van de Mheen, D. (2013). Internet
addiction in adolescents: Prevalence and risk factors. Computers in Human Behavior, 29(5), 1987-1996.
Lim, W., Lau, B. T., Chua, C., & Islam, F. M. A. (2021). Do information and communication technologies
influence skills, competencies, health and well-being of teenagers? Current evidence. EAI Endorsed Transactions on
Pervasive Health and Technology, 7(27), e4.
Nawaz, M. W., Nadeem, T., Rao, S. L., Fatima, T., & Shoaib, S. (2020). Impact of PUBG game addiction
on social isolation and narcissistic tendencies among gamers. Asian Journal of Social Sciences and Management
Studies, 7(3), 166-172.
Pápay, O., Urbán, R., Griffiths, M. D., Nagygyörgy, K., Farkas, J., Kökönyei, G., ... & Demetrovics, Z.
(2013). Psychometric properties of the problematic online gaming questionnaire short-form and prevalence of
problematic online gaming in a national sample of adolescents. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social
Networking, 16(5), 340-348.
Park, H. E., & Tan, B. (2020). The Mechanisms of Mobile Gaming Addiction.
Web desk, (2021, August 30) China restricts online gaming to an hour amid rising addiction in teenagers.