Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Korraa 2022
Korraa 2022
Korraa 2022
net/publication/362285329
CITATION READS
1 88
24 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Yasser Sami H. Abdel Dayem Amer on 09 March 2023.
Original Article
Severe Hyperbilirubinemia in Term and Late Preterm Newborns: An Evidence-Based
Clinical Practice Guideline Adapted for The Use in Egypt Based on The ‘Adapted
ADAPTE’ Methodology
Afaf Korraa1*, Mossallam M. Nasser2, Ahmed Youssef 3, Hesham Awad 4, Safaa Emam4 ,Ghada Gad 4 ,
Dina Rabie4, Effat Assar5, Eman Almorsy1, Suzan S. Gad 6, Sameh Tawfik 7, Nefeisa Refat8, Hala
Fouad9, Mohamed S. Abdelkader9, Osama El Fikey5, Walaa A Abuelhamd10, Zahraa Ez El-Din10,
Mohammed Abdelshafy11, Nouran B AbdAlla6, Nesreen Kamal12, Iman F. Iskander10
Methodology Group: Ashraf Abdelbaky13, Tarek E.I.Omar14, Yasser S. Amer15
DOI: 10.21608/anj.2022.121921.1055
*
Correspondence: Pediatric Department, Faculty of medicine for girls, Al-Azhar University, Egypt
Email: afafkorraa@gmail.com
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article.
Abstract
Background: The presented evidence-based clinical practice guideline (CPG) is proposed as a National
CPG using an evidence-based and formal CPG adaptation methodology. The purpose of this study was
to adapt the international CPGs’ recommendations for term and late preterm neonates with severe
hyperbilirubinemia to suit the healthcare system in the Egyptian context. This CPG provides a
framework for prediction, prevention and management of severe hyperbilirubinemia in newborn infants
of 35 or more weeks of gestation. The quality of evidence and strength of recommendations are
indicated. The guideline adaptation group was chosen from various Egyptian Universities. There was an
active involvement of a Multidisciplinary Review Committee following a standardized process. The
Neonatology Guideline Adaptation Group (NGAG) was assigned individual health questions to cover
the different sections of the required CPG. A literature search for source CPGs was carried out. The
NGAG studied several guidelines. Critical appraisal was done by AGREE II (Appraisal of Guidelines
for Research and Evaluation) Instrument to rate and select the appropriate guidelines. Results: The
NGAG decided to adapt mainly the American Academy of Pediatrics Guideline (2004, 2009 & 2011)
and for the questions which were not answered; the best and most relevant evidence available was used.
Implementation tools were sought for to facilitate the application of the adapted CPG. Conclusion: The
finalized CPG offers healthcare providers with applicable evidence-based guidance for severe neonatal
hyperbilirubinemia in the Egyptian context. The Adapted ADAPTE method emphasized the value of
collaborative clinical and methodological expert groups’ efforts for adaptation of national guidelines.
Key words: Guidelines; bilirubin; hyperbilirubinemia; kernicterus, newborn
term morbidity and mortality from severe consisting of sensory neural hearing
neonatal hyperbilirubinemia. loss or auditory dys-synchrony, (3)
Definitions used in this Guideline: oculomotor impairments especially
Kernicterus: is the pathological impairment of up-gaze, but also
finding of deep-yellow staining of lateral gaze impairments including
neurons and neuronal necrosis of the strabismus, and (4) dental enamel
basal ganglia and brainstem nuclei; hypoplasia of the deciduous teeth
and clinically associated with chronic [12].
bilirubin encephalopathy [12]. Severe neonatal hyperbilirubinemia
Acute bilirubin encephalopathy (SNH): a total serum bilirubin (TSB)
(ABE): a clinical syndrome, that concentration greater than 20 mg/dL
occurs in the presence of severe in the first 72 hours of life [12].
hyperbilirubinemia, presenting with Critical or extreme
various combinations of decreased hyperbilirubinemia: a TSB
feeding, lethargy, hypotonia and/or concentration greater than 25 mg/dL
hypertonia, high-pitched cry, during the first 28 days of life [12].
retrocollis, opisthotonus, setting sun Methods
sign, fever, seizures, and death [12]. This study is part of a major project by
Chronic bilirubin encephalopathy the Egyptian Pediatric Clinical Practice
(CBE): a clinical tetrad that occurs Guidelines Committee (EPG) which was
after the history of severe formulated by members of the
hyperbilirubinemia consisting of (1) a Departments of Pediatrics from multiple
movement disorder consisting not Egyptian Universities. EPG is currently
only of athetosis and dystonia, but affiliated to the Supreme Council of the
may also include spasticity and Egyptian University Hospitals
hypotonia, (2) auditory dysfunction (http://epg.edu.eg). The committee is
Pediatrics and a general pediatrician who (2010 [20] , 2016 [21] CPGs, the
are experts in evidence-based CPG Australian (Queensland, 2017) [22] CPG
adaptation methodologies. Clinical as well as Canadian Pediatric Association
questions are identified, using the PIPOH (2018) [23] CPG were considered. The
model, including questions for risk first draft of the adapted CPG marks the
factors, prevention, prediction, diagnosis, last step of this phase.
and treatment (Table 1). The PIPOH Phase 3 (Finalization phase): In phase
model includes the target patient 3, the first draft of the adapted CPG is
population (P), intervention(s) (I), finalized after assessing whether it is
professionals and clinical specialties (P), acceptable and applicable to the Egyptian
outcomes (O), and healthcare settings or healthcare context. The draft was then
context (H). The literature search was disseminated to a panel of external
conducted using MEDLINE/PubMed and reviewers of topic experts. Afterwards,
Google Scholar portals. The Appraisal of the feedback of reviewers was revised
Guidelines for Research and Evaluation and discussed within the NGAG with
Instrument (AGREE II) [16] was used to consideration of the national healthcare
appraise the eligible Source CPGs. context. The finalized version of the
AGREE II is considered the gold adapted CPG included relevant practical
standard for quality assessment of CPG. implementation tools and strategies.
It is a reliable tool that consists of 23 Ethical approval
items organized in six domains. The Ethics approval and consents: are not
neonatology guideline adaptation group applicable in this context.
(NGAG) studied several CPGs using the Results
criteria of the AGREE II. The American We identified 19 clinical questions using
Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) (2004 the PIPOH model. We studied several
[17], 2009[18], 2011 [19] CPGs, NICE source original CPGs for prediction,
prevention and management of severe These tools were developed and revised
neonatal hyperbilirubinemia. Based on by the NGAG group to be used by
the results of the AGREE II appraisal and healthcare providers and families of
in-depth content review, there was a neonates for education and awareness, so
consensus among the members of the that the tools would be effective in our
NGAG to adapt the AAP CPGs (2004, community. Implementation tools are
2009 & 2011) [18-20] to answer the 19 shown in Appendices 1-5. The most
clinical questions posted. For questions important of which were the summary of
not answered within the chosen source, recommendations, the discharge card for
the group searched for other most the parents that shows the possible risk
relevant evidence available providing its for developing severe jaundice in their
grading and reference. The AGREE II babies and the time of follow up. The
ratings of the AAP CPG were 96% algorithm for the management of a case
(domain 1: scope and purpose), 90.7% presenting with neonatal jaundice, the
(domain 2: stakeholder involvement), decision making graphs as well as how to
97.9% (domain 3: rigor of development), make phototherapy most effective.
98 (domain 4: clarity and presentation), Future updates to this adapted CPG will
72.2% (domain 5: applicability), 97.2% review and consider any evidence
(domain 6: editorial independence), 88.8 published after our cut-off date.
% (overall assessment 1), and the overall Key to Evidence: The evidence
assessment 2 showed that NGAG presented in this CPG is categorized
recommended its use in practice. The according to the categorization of the
summary recommendations of the AAP Steering Committee on Quality
adapted CPG are highlighted in Table 1. Improvement and Management [17]
A set of CPG implementation tools were
attached to the finalized adapted CPG.
[24] . The importance of this work lies in practical framework for the prediction,
using the Adapted ADAPTE method [13] prevention and management of SHB
to expedite the production of this adapted through the use of this adapted CPG.
evidence-based CPG, for the use in the Testing the blood group and RH type of
Egyptian community, to prevent further the mother can identify risky blood
increase in the number of kernicterus groups; and health education at that point
cases by following the instructions in the antenatal care clinic can raise
provided to healthcare physicians and awareness of the mother to the possible
other medical personnel that deal with risks her baby may be exposed to if she
newborns. The presence of the Egyptian belongs to a risky blood group. Also,
pediatric guidelines committee has clear instructions regarding breast
provided support and has been a feeding support as well as date of follow
facilitator for this project and the up for jaundice are essential. Education
inclusion of representative professors of the mother for red flags her baby
from multiple universities all over Egypt might show that require urgent medical
has enriched the process bringing in advice can allow timely medical
different experiences that were essential intervention that would prevent acute
for the completion of this work. bilirubin encephalopathy which is the
The aim of this project was to produce consequence of neglected severe neonatal
an available evidence-based document hyperbilirubinemia.
that caters to the need and increases the Measuring a predischarge TSB or TcB
awareness of Egyptian physicians for newborn infants, and plotting it on
managing newborn babies regarding the the Bhutani hour-specific nomogram
risk of developing severe neonatal [25] provides an excellent guide for
hyperbilirubinemia and kernicterus and timely follow up and for predicting
to provide them with a standardized which infants are at increased risk for
the importance of close follow up after 3. Protocols for monitoring and assessment of
delivery. Also, resources are required for the risk for severe neonatal
hyperbilirubinemia using the bilirubin
providing points of care, bilirubin
nomogram should be present in all nurseries
measuring devices, affordable
including bilirubin measurement (TcB or
phototherapy and training personnel on TSB) and the risk factors for neurotoxicity.
how to make it more effective. 4. Blood group testing of mothers and infants
Conclusions as well as direct Coombs’ test should be
Using the Adapted ADAPTE method performed in every baby who appears
jaundiced in the first 24 hours of life. If
facilitated the production of an adapted
there is no mother-infant Rh or ABO
evidence-based CPG for the predication,
incompatibility and Coombs’ test is
prevention and management of severe negative, other causes of hemolysis should
neonatal hyperbilirubinemia in late be sought for (e.g. G6PD).
preterm and term newborns in prompt 5. Every infant jaundiced in the first 24 hours
time, and with the required should have total serum bilirubin (TSB)
measurement and be managed accordingly.
implementation tools. The effectiveness
6. If treatment is required, it should be based
of this CPG should be assessed by
on TSB (do NOT subtract the direct
monitoring the impact of the use of these fraction)
CPGs in the reduction of cases of 7. All bilirubin levels should be interpreted
kernicterus that still occur in our country. according to the infant’s age in hours using
antenatal care, about the risks of severe discharge and the risk assessment; all should
neonatal jaundice especially if her blood be arranged and written in a follow-up card.
Dr. Hesham Abdel-Hady, Mansoura University financial funding throughout the development of
and Dr. Abdel Latif Abdel Moez, Assuit this work in terms of utilization of its facilities.
University; or at the international level : Dr. This work is not related to any pharmaceutical
Vinny Bhutani, Stanford University and Dr. company. The members of the NGAG and their
John Watchco, Pittsburgh University. universities volunteered their participation.
Author's contributions Funding
Members of the CPG adaptation group (Clinical The research was self-funded by the authors and
subgroup) (searching, screening, AGREE II no funding was received from any funding body
assessment): Iman Iskander, Mossallam or organization.
Mohamed Nasser, Afaf Korraa, Ahmed Availability of Materials
Youssef, Dina Rabie, Ghada Gad, Effat Assar Any relevant material in addition to future
, Eman Almorsy, Mohammed Abdelshafy , revisions and updates will be made available
Mohamed Abdel Kader, Nouran AbdAllah, and downloadable from the official website of
Safaa Shafik, Suzan Gad. the Egyptian Pediatrics Clinical Practice
Methodology Group: Ashraf Abdelbaky, Tarek Guidelines Committee (http://epg.edu.eg).
Omar and Yasser Amer. Author's details
1
Iman F. Iskander was the Chair of the NGAG. Pediatric Department, Faculty of medicine for
Afaf A. Korraa, Iman Iskander and Mossallam girls, Al-Azhar University, Egypt
2
Nasser have written the first draft of the Pediatric Department, Faculty of medicine for
manuscript. Ashraf Abdelbaky and Tarek E. boys, Al-Azhar University, Egypt
3
Omar conceptualized and designed the study. Pediatric Department, Armed Forced College
Yasser S. Amer reviewed the methodology, of Medicine, Egypt
4
drafts and the final version of this manuscript. Pediatric Department, Ain Shams University,
All authors contributed to the data collection, Egypt
5
critical appraisal of guidelines and approved the Pediatric Department, Benha University, Egypt
6
final version of the manuscript. Pediatric Department, Suez Canal University,
Conflict of interest Egypt
7
The Armed Forces College of Medicine Pediatric Department, Military Medical
(AFCM) and The Neonatology Guideline Academy, Egypt
8
Adaptation Group (NGAG) provided non- Pediatric Department, Assuit University, Egypt
9
Pediatric Department, Misr University for 3- Maisels MJ. Epidemiology of neonatal
Science and Technology, Egypt jaundice. In: Maisels MJ, Watchko JF,
10
Pediatric Department, Cairo University, Egypt editors. Neonatal jaundice. Amsterdam:
11
Pediatric Department, Benha Children’s Harwood Academic Publishers; 2000. p. 37–
Hospital, Egypt 49.
12
Public health Department, Cairo University, 4- Ebbesen F, Andersson C, Verder H, Grytter
Egypt C, Pedersen-Bjergaard L, Petersen JR, et al.
13
Pediatric Department, Allergy, Immunology & Extreme hyperbilirubinaemia in term and
Rheumatology unit, Ain Shams University, near-term infants in Denmark. Acta
Egypt, Chair of EPG. paediatrica. 2005;94(1):59-64.
14
Pediatric Department, Pediatric Neurology, 5- Slusher TM, Zamora TG, Appiah D, Stanke
Alexandria University, Egypt. JU, Strand MA, Lee BW, et al. Burden of
15
Pediatrics Department and Clinical Practice severe neonatal jaundice: a systematic
Guidelines and Quality Research Unit-Quality. review and meta-analysis. BMJ paediatrics
Management Department, King Saud University open. 2017;1(1):e000105.
Medical City, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
6- Basheer H, Makhlouf M, El Halawany F,
Fahmy N, Iskander I. Screening for neonatal
Date received: 24th April 2021, accepted 17th
jaundice in El Galaa Teaching Hospital: A
July 2021
Egyptian Maternity Hospital – Can
References the model be replicated? Journal of Clinical
1- Ayyappan S, Philip S, Bharathy N, Ramesh Neonatology. 2017;6(2):128-33.
V, Kumar CN, Swathi S, et al. Antioxidant 7- Gamaleldin R, Iskander I, Seoud I, Aboraya
status in neonatal jaundice before and after H, Aravkin A, Sampson PD, et al. Risk
phototherapy. Journal of pharmacy & factors for neurotoxicity in newborns with
bioallied sciences. 2015; 7(Suppl 1):S16-2 severe neonatal hyperbilirubinemia.
2- Bhutani VK, Johnson LH, Keren R. Pediatrics. 2011;128(4):e925-31.
Diagnosis and management of 8- El Houchi SZ, Iskander I, Gamaleldin R, El
hyperbilirubinemia in the term neonate: for a Shenawy A, Seoud I, Abou-Youssef H, et al.
safer first week. Pediatric clinics of North Prediction of 3- to 5-Month Outcomes from
America. 2004;51(4):843-61, vii. Signs of Acute Bilirubin Toxicity in
13- The ADAPTE Collaboration. The 18- Maisels MJ, Bhutani VK, Bogen D,
ADAPTE process: resource Toolkit versions Newman TB, Stark AR, Watchko JF.
for Guideline Adaptation Version 2.0 Hyperbilirubinemia in the newborn infant >
Available from :http://www.g.i-n-net/ 2009. or =35 weeks' gestation: an update with
Appendix 1
BN shows 3 risk zones by the percentile tracks, high-risk zone, Intermediate-risk zone, and Low
risk zone. The purpose of the BN is to predict which newborn is at high, intermediate, or low risk
to develop severe hyperbilirubinemia after discharge from the hospital.
Appendix 2
Appendix 3
Fig (3). Guidelines for exchange transfusion in infants ≥35 weeks’ gestation [17]
Appendix 4
Table I: Clinical assessment of neurotoxicity using the Modified (bilirubin induced neurologic dysfunction
(BIND) score
CLINICAL SIGN SCORE SEVERITY
MENTAL STATUS Date/Time
Normal 0 None
Sleepy but arousable
1 Mild
Decreased feeding
Lethargy
Poor suck and/or 2 Moderate
Irritable/jittery with short-term strong suck
Semi-coma
Apnea
3 Severe
Seizures
Coma
Total / 3
MUSCLE TONE
Normal 0 None
Persistent mild hypotonia 1 Mild
Moderate hypotonia
Moderate hypertonia
Increasing arching of neck and trunk on 2 Moderate
stimulation without spasms of arms and legs
and without trismus
Persistent retrocollis
Opisthotonus
Crossing or scissoring of arms or legs but 3 Severe
without spasms of arms and legs and without
trismus
Total / 3
CRY PATTERN
Normal 0 None
High pitched 1 Mild
Shrill 2 Moderate
Inconsolable crying or
Cry weak or absent in child with previous 3 Severe
history of high pitched or shrill cry
Total / 3
OCCULOMOTOR OR EYE MOVEMENTS
Normal 0 None, Mild
Sun-setting
3 Severe
Paralysis of Upward Gaze
Total / 3
Total ABE Score / 12
Final score out of 12 (zero: Normal, 1-4: mild encephalopathy, 5-6: moderate encephalopathy, 7-12: severe
encephalopathy) [12]
Appendix 5
Figure 4 (A): Algorithm for management and follow-up according to pre-discharge bilirubin, gestation, and risk
factors [17]
Figure 4 (B): Algorithm for management and follow-up according to pre-discharge bilirubin, gestation, and risk
factors [17]
Figure 4 (c): Algorithm for management and follow-up according to pre-discharge bilirubin, gestation, and risk
factors [17]
Submit your next manuscript to Annals of
Neonatology Journal and take full advantage of:
• Convenient online submission
• Thorough and rapid peer review
• No space constraints or color figure
charges
• Immediate publication on acceptance
• No limit as regards tables or figures.
• Open Access research freely available for
redistribution
Submit your manuscript at:
www.anj.journals.ekb.eg
Citation: Afaf Korraa; Mossallam M Nasser; Ahmed Youssef; Dina Rabie; Effat Assar; Eman Almorsy;
Tarek Omar; Suzan S Gad; Sameh Tawfik; Nefeisa Refat; Ghada Gad; Hala Fouad; Osama El Fikey;
Safaa Emam; Walaa A Abuelhamd; Zahraa Ez El Din; Mohammed Abdelshafy; Hesham Awad; Nouran
B AbdAlla; Mohamed Abdelkader; Ashraf Abdelbaky; Nesreen Kamal; Yasser S. Amer; Eman F.
Iskander. "Severe Hyperbilirubinemia in Term and Late Preterm Newborns: An Evidence-Based
Clinical Practice Guideline Adapted for The Use in Egypt Based on The ‘Adapted ADAPTE’
Methodology". Annals of Neonatology Journal 2022; 4(2):67-97 doi: 10.21608/anj.2022.121921.1055
Copyright: Korraa et al., 2022. This article is an open access article distributed under
the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) license (4).