Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Snap 1 Evidence Sonali
Snap 1 Evidence Sonali
Snap 1 Evidence Sonali
-1
LawofEv
idence
BY:SONALITRI
PATHI
I
UU19BAL060
Quest
ion1:
-Cr
it
ical
lyanal
yzet
hedoct
ri
neofResGest
aei
nthechangi
ng
t
imes.Expl
ainoneofy
ourownhy
pot
het
icali
nst
ancesf
ort
heshowi
ngt
he
appl
icat
ion&scopeoft
hisdoct
ri
ne.
(
Mar
ks5)
Sect
ion6oft heactt al
ksaboutResGest ae.Itsaysrelevancyoffactsfor
mingpartof
sametransact
ion.Factswhichdonoti ni
ssuearesoconnect edwiththefacti
nissueso
astoform partofthesamet ransact
ionaretheydif
ferentwhethertheyoccur
redatthe
sametimeandpl aceordif
ferentti
mesandpl aces.
I
ll
ust
rat
ion:
-
a)AisaccusedofmurderofAbybeati
nghi
m whatev
erhassaidordonebyAorBor
thest
andar
dsatthebeati
ngorsoshor
tl
yoraf
teri
tastof
orm partoft
hetr
ansact
ioni
s
arel
evantf
act.
Essent
ial
sofResGest
ae:
1)Fact
sconnect
edwi
thf
acti
nissue
Case:
Rat
tanv
.Queen
Al adycall
edtel
ephoneoperat
orandut t
eredgetmet hepol
iceandsuddenlycal
l
droppedShewasfounddeadandherhusbandbei
ngpr
osecut
edatthecour
tformur
der
ofthelady
.
Thecourtsai
dt hecal
lwasar el
evantfactandcanbepr
esent
edbef
oret
hecour
t.I
t
doesn'
tmatt
ertheactoccuratsameplaceornot.
2)SameTr
ansact
ion.
SirJamesStepheninhisbooksdi gestofev
idencehi
mselfdef
inedt
hewor
dsame
tr
ansact
ion.I
tmeanstheser
iesofactstowhi
chyoucangiv
eonename.
3)Samet
imeandsamepl
aceanddi
ff
erentt
imeanddi
ff
erentpl
ace.
Except
ion:
ther
eshoul
dbenotbeaconcocat
ingst
ory
.
Case:
Rv.Bedi
ngFi
eld
Aladycameoutofherhome.Shehadani
njur
yonherneckandsheut
ter
ed"
seemy
aunt
ywhatr
edi
ngfi
eldhasdonetome"
.
Thecourtsai
dshehasgetsuff
ici
enttimet oconcoctt
hest
atementasi
twasaf
ter
someti
meofcomingauntandi
tisnotadmissi
ble.
Real
li
feI
ll
ust
rat
ion:
Once2ofmyneighborsstart
edf i
ght
ingoverani
ssueofl
and.Oneofthem sai
dthatI
'
ll
ki
llyoui
fyouint
erf
ereinmyl andandaftersometi
meshebr i
ngsoutaknifefr
om hi
s
houseandst
abstheotherperson.
Her
e,hi
sst
atementi
sal
sopar
tofsamet
ransact
ion.