Real Estate Finance

Francesco Zadro

Academic Year 2023/2024

Chapter 1

The Real Estate Market

1.1 General Assumptions

Real estate encompasses the contemporary concept of land and all its enduring attachments. Within this realm, we
can distinguish between fixtures, which encompass structures like buildings, fences, and components integrated into
these structures such as plumbing, heating, and lighting fixtures. Conversely, possessions that lack this permanent
attachment are classified as Personal Property. Furniture and draperies are prime examples of such personal
items.
This dynamic sector plays a pivotal role in our economy, with real estate undergoing governance by a set of
regulations. It comprises two principal categories: commercial and residential real estate. The former deals
with the buying and leasing of properties for business purposes, while the latter pertains to the buying and renting
of land and houses by individuals and families for their daily living needs.

The Vendor and Buyer within this particular market exhibit characteristics that set them apart from other
markets. These distinctions include:
• Lower Liquidity: This market generally experiences reduced ease of buying and selling assets, making it
less liquid compared to others.

• Lower Transparency: Information and data accessibility in this market tends to be less transparent, po-
tentially hindering informed decision-making.
• Lack of Standardization: There is a notable absence of standardized practices and norms, leading to
variations in how assets are structured and traded.
There is a strong perception of Assets as a ”Shelter”. Many investors view real estate assets as a secure haven,
given their relatively stable nature.
• Market’s Recurrent Tendencies: This market often displays recurring trends and patterns, which can
affect investment strategies.
• Counter-Cyclical Nature: It’s worth exploring whether this market behaves counter-cyclically in compar-
ison to the stock market, potentially offering a hedge against economic downturns.
Real estate assets serve various purposes, including residential housing, industrial production, managing private
or collective savings, and offering protection against market saturation.
• Regional Market Influence: The geographic location significantly impacts this market, resulting in varia-
tions in pricing, demand, and supply. Certain regions hold distinct advantages in this market due to factors
like local demand, infrastructure development, and economic growth. These factors can significantly influence
investment outcomes.
• Information Asymmetry: Information is not equally distributed among market participants, leading to an
imbalance in knowledge and potentially affecting investment decisions.

1
1.2 Major Factors that influence the Real Estate Market
1.2.1 Demographics
Demographics encompass essential population data, such as age, race, gender, income levels, migration patterns,
and population growth. Often underestimated, these statistics play a pivotal role in shaping real estate pricing and
the types of properties in demand. Profound shifts in a nation’s demographics can have a large impact on real
estate trends for several decades.

1.2.2 Interest Rates

Interest rates also have substantial influence over real estate markets. Fluctuations in interest rates can signif-
icantly affect an individual’s capacity to acquire residential properties. When interest rates decrease, the cost of
obtaining a mortgage for home purchases diminishes, amplifying demand for real estate and subsequently driving
prices higher. Conversely, rising interest rates result in increased mortgage costs, dampening demand and putting
downward pressure on real estate prices.

1.2.3 The Economy

The overall economic health is a pivotal determinant of real estate value. Indicators like GDP, employment
figures, manufacturing activity, and the prices of goods gauge economic well-being. In broad terms, a slow economy
tends to correlate with poor real estate performance. Nevertheless, the cyclical nature of the economy can have
divergent impacts on various real estate types.

1.2.4 Government Policies and Subsidies

Legislative measures have a significant influence over property demand and prices. Government-initiated mecha-
nisms like tax credits, deductions, and subsidies can temporarily stimulate demand for real estate while they are in
effect. Staying informed about prevailing government incentives is crucial for gauging shifts in supply and demand,
as well as identifying potential anomalies in market trends.

1.3 The Italian Context

In Italy, the predominant mode of asset-ownership leans heavily toward direct ownership rather than leasing, a
distinction that holds true not only for residential purposes. Over the past decade, Italy has embarked on the
process of ”Finanziarizzazione” in the real estate sector, following in the footsteps of mature markets such as the
UK, USA, and Germany.

This transformation has introduced new investment vehicles, including Real Estate Funds (since 1994), Securiti-
zation (since 1999), and Listed Real Estate Investment Trusts/Società di Investimento Immobiliare Quotate (since
2007).
Simultaneously, there has been a surge in innovative real estate products, mirroring those developed in ma-
ture markets. This includes the establishment and expansion of diverse property types such as shopping malls,
entertainment centers, and logistic complexes.
Additionally, there has been a growing emphasis on refurbishment and investment activities, signifying a
shift from greenfield development to brownfield projects in Italy’s real estate sector.

1.3.1 The Finanziarizzazione of the Real Estate Market

Over the past decade, Italy has witnessed a gradual convergence between the financial and real estate markets. Real
estate assets are no longer evaluated solely for their architectural merit but are increasingly appraised based on their
potential to generate cash flows and revenues. This paradigm shift allows real estate assets to be ”securitized,”
where they can be represented through specific financial instruments that encapsulate their financial and economic
worth.

2
1.4 Types of Assets
The real estate market comprises a diverse array of segments based on their intended uses:
• Residential Assets: Properties designed for residential purposes, including houses, apartments, and condo-
miniums.
• Industrial Assets: Real estate tailored for industrial activities, such as factories, warehouses, and manufac-
turing facilities.
• Retail Assets: Properties utilized for retail activities, encompassing shopping centers, malls, and standalone
retail spaces.
• Office Assets: Real estate designated for office-related operations, like corporate offices, co-working spaces,
and business centers.
• Receptive Assets: Properties primarily serving the hospitality and tourism industry, such as hotels, resorts,
and vacation rentals.
This segmentation holds significance not only for general economic assessments but also for determining property
valuations. Additionally, a special category in the real estate market pertains to the land itself.

1.5 Segmentation of the Real Estate Market

The real estate market exhibits multifaceted segmentation across various dimensions:

• Segmentation by Destination:
– Residential: Properties designed for living, including houses, apartments, and condominiums.
– Retail: Real estate tailored for commercial businesses and shopping, such as malls and retail spaces.
– Industrial: Properties geared towards manufacturing and industrial activities, like factories and ware-
houses.
– Offices: Real estate allocated for office-related operations, including corporate offices and business cen-
ters.
– Logistic: Real estate intended for distribution and logistics, such as warehouses and distribution centers.
– Hotels: Properties catering to the hospitality and tourism industry, including hotels, resorts, and vacation
rentals.
– Health Services: Real estate designed for healthcare facilities, hospitals, and medical offices.
• Segmentation by Location:
– Luxury: High-end properties with premium features and amenities.
– Central/CBD (Central Business District): Real estate situated in the core business and financial districts.
– Semi-Central: Properties located in areas between the CBD and periphery.
– Periphery: Real estate on the outskirts of urban centers.
• Segmentation by Availability:
– Vacant: Properties currently unoccupied and available for sale or lease.
– Occupied: Real estate currently in use by owners or tenants.
– Leased: Properties with long-term or short-term lease agreements in place.
• Segmentation by State of Repair:
– New: Newly constructed or never occupied properties.
– Used: Previously owned or occupied properties.
– Refurbished: Real estate that has undergone significant renovation and improvement.

3
 – To Be Refurbished: Properties in need of renovation or improvement.
• Segmentation by Type of Ownership:
– Freehold: Properties owned outright, granting full ownership rights.
– Leasehold: Properties held under a lease agreement, with ownership rights limited to the lease term.

Figure 1.1: Examples

1.5.1 The Real Estate Market Segmentation: Land

Land is the fundamental category within the real estate spectrum, with distinctive features and attributes:
• Diverse Categories of Land: Land can be broadly categorized into two groups: building and non-building
land. Building land is typically designated for construction purposes, while non-building land often serves
agricultural activities, parks, and similar functions.
• Location and Size Significance: The location (geographical placement) and size of a piece of land are
integral factors that profoundly influence its potential for development. A prime location and ample size can
significantly increase a land parcel’s development prospects.

• Role of Zoning Regulations: Zoning regulations, also known as zoning laws, play a pivotal role in land use.
These regulations delineate what can be built on a specific piece of land. They employ indices or parameters
based on the essential elements, such as location and size, to specify buildable land areas.
• Indices as Land Characteristics: Indices within zoning regulations provide insights into the characteristics
of a piece of land from a regulatory perspective. These indices encompass essential elements that impact land
use and development. They often contribute to the valuation of land, as they indicate the scope of permissible
development.

1.5.2 The Real Estate Market Segmentation: The Residential Building

The housing market is distinctive in several aspects:

4
 Figure 1.2: Indici

• Uniqueness and Irreproducibility: Residential properties are unique and irreproducible, often tailored
to specific needs and functions. Each home is designed to meet the particular requirements of its occupants,
making it a highly personalized asset within the real estate market.
• Economic Linkage: The performance of the residential real estate market is intricately linked to various
economic factors, including the overall economic development of the country. Additionally, the rate at which
new households are created, and the financial policies and regulations implemented, significantly influence
this market.
• Semi-Elastic Demand: The demand for housing exhibits semi-elastic characteristics. As income levels rise
and cultural developments occur, there is an increased focus on the quality of residential applications. This
heightened demand for improved quality is particularly evident in this segment of the market.

• Market Segmentation: The residential market can be further segmented into two key categories:
• ”First Home”: This market segment is typically limited to a specific local market and a confined geographical
area.
• ”Second Home”: In contrast, the ”second home” market features broader geographical boundaries but may
have a smaller overall market size.

The residential building sector is characterized by its unique nature, sensitivity to economic fluctuations, and
evolving demands driven by cultural and income factors. Additionally, market segmentation helps categorize and
understand the varying dynamics within the housing market.

Residential Buildings - Classifications

Residential properties in the British market are typically classified into different quality classes (A, B, C) and their
respective subclasses (A higher, C higher). The classification process takes into account several variables, including:
• Location: The geographic location of the property significantly influences its classification.

• Years of Property Life: The age of the property plays a role in determining its quality class.
• Quality of Construction: The level of construction quality is a critical factor.
• Services Offered: The services and amenities provided by the property are considered.

• Local Standards: The average standards in the area where the property is situated also impact its classifi-
cation.

5
 Figure 1.3

It’s important to note that there isn’t a universally recognized standard for assessment. Consequently, the same
property could be classified as an A by a seller, a B by a buyer, or even differently when situated in various regions.
For instance, a property in Rome might be classified as an A, while a similar one in Manhattan could be considered
a B.

Market Trends: In the years following the burst of the dot-com bubble, the residential real estate market
experienced several significant trends:
• Price Appreciation: The market benefited from a substantial influx of liquidity as investors sought ”safer”
alternatives to stocks. Low-interest rates also played a role, spurring steady and significant price increases.
• Increased Loans: The low-interest rates not only drove property values but also led to a surge in loans
being signed, as borrowing became more affordable. Subsequently, there was a change in market dynamics:
– Declining Demand: Demand for residential properties decreased, resulting in extended average selling
times and a decline in market values. The extent of these changes varied from one country to another.
These market trends highlight the sensitivity of the residential real estate sector to economic and financial
factors, as well as shifts in demand and investor sentiment.

Residential Buildings (In Italy) - Risks and Opportunities

Risks:
• Interest Rate Fluctuations: Changes in the cost of borrowing, particularly influenced by interest rates such
as EURIBOR and the European Central Bank’s (ECB) rate, can significantly impact the Italian residential
real estate market. This is particularly relevant for adjustable rate mortgages, while the IRS serves as a
benchmark index for fixed-rate mortgages.
• Unfavorable Demographics: Italy faces demographic challenges with a very low population growth rate.
This can affect the demand for residential properties, especially in regions with declining or stagnant popula-
tions.
• Increased Supply: The selection of residential properties is expected to grow in the future due to numerous
development projects initiated in recent years. An oversupply of properties can lead to increased competition
and possibly declining property values.
Opportunities:

6
 • Foreign Resident Demand: There’s an opportunity in catering to the demand for residential properties
among the foreign population residing in Italy. Attracting expatriates and foreign residents can bolster the
residential real estate market.
• Second Homes Market: Italy has the potential to further develop the market for second homes, particularly
among European buyers. Increased ease and affordability of travel can stimulate interest in second home
ownership, presenting opportunities for growth.
• Transparent and Professional Lease Market: The residential lease market has the potential for growth
with increased transparency and professionalism. Improving leasing practices and regulations can attract both
tenants and landlords, enhancing market dynamics.
• Introduction of ”Dry Coupon”: The introduction of a ”dry coupon” in lease agreements can enhance
market transparency. Such measures can provide clarity on the terms of lease agreements, making the rental
market more predictable and secure for both landlords and tenants.

In summary, the Italian residential real estate market faces certain risks related to economic factors, demograph-
ics, and supply, but it also presents several opportunities such as catering to foreign residents, developing second
homes, enhancing the lease market’s transparency and professionalism, and introducing measures to improve mar-
ket clarity and predictability. Balancing these factors will be crucial for long-term success in the Italian residential
property sector.

1.5.3 The Real Estate Market Segmentation: The Industrial Constructions

The market for industrial construction possesses several distinct characteristics when compared to the residential
sector:
• Prefabrication Techniques: Industrial construction frequently relies on prefabrication techniques, enabling
rapid construction within a minimal time-frame (as short as 6 months). This flexibility in construction aligns
with the dynamic nature of demand in the industrial sector.
• Continuous Production: The industrial sector exhibits a higher level of continuous ”production” as com-
pared to the residential market. It is less susceptible to immediate economic trends and is often considered a
long-term and capital-intensive investment.
• Stability with Intensity Shocks: While the industrial real estate market can be relatively stable over
time, it is susceptible to significant shocks, particularly during periods of high-intensity economic downturns
or recessions.
• Asset Reselling Challenges: A notable challenge in the industrial real estate sector is reselling assets once
the tenant departs, especially in leasing agreements. The unique nature of industrial properties can pose
difficulties in attracting new tenants.
• Steady Demand in Stressful Economic Conditions: The industrial sector tends to maintain consistent
demand even during economic stress. Investment decisions in this sector are often driven by medium to
long-term considerations rather than short-term fluctuations. This makes it one of the more stable segments
within the real estate industry.
• Custom-Built Structures: Industrial properties can often be customized and built to order. As a result,
there is limited risk of unsold or vacant space, with vacancy rates typically hovering around 5%. However,
the challenge of reselling these custom-built properties remains.
• Types of Properties: Industrial properties are generally categorized as factories and warehouses. Ware-
houses, in particular, feature simple yet precise technical specifications, including ceiling height, floor slope,
and unobstructed space to meet specific logistical requirements.
• Shift to Logistics: In recent years, there has been a notable shift from traditional production facilities to
industrial real estate dedicated to logistics. This transformation has occurred in response to the relocation of
production to countries with lower labor costs, such as China, India, and Eastern Europe.
• Strategic Location: The location of industrial properties is crucial, with prime areas situated near major
communication arteries, including ports, highways, and airports. These locations enhance logistical efficiency.

7
1.6 Real Estate Market Cycles
Real estate values are in a constant state of flux, moving through various phases within the economic cycle.
Gaining insight into these phases is essential for successful real estate investment. It’s important to note that
different types of commercial properties (e.g., office, retail, multi-family, industrial) within the same market may
be at different points in the real estate cycle. Here’s an overview of the key phases:

• Recovery Phase
– Characteristics:
∗ Decreasing Vacancy Rates
∗ Low New Construction
∗ Moderate Space Absorption
∗ Low to Moderate Employment Growth
∗ Negligible to Low-Rate Rental Growth
– Description: The recovery phase marks the early stage of an upswing in the real estate market. Vacancy
rates begin to decline, but new construction remains limited. Space is gradually being absorbed, and
employment figures are showing some growth. Rental rates may start to rise, although at a moderate
pace.
• Expansion Phase
– Characteristics:ù
∗ Decreasing Vacancy Rates
∗ Moderate to High New Construction
∗ High Absorption
∗ Moderate to High Employment Growth
∗ Medium to High Rate of Rental Growth
– Description: The expansion phase sees a more robust market. Vacancy rates continue to decrease,
while new construction becomes more pronounced. High absorption rates indicate strong demand, and
employment growth is in full swing. Rental rates experience significant growth during this phase.
• Over Supply Phase
– Characteristics:
∗ Increasing Vacancy Rates
∗ Moderate to High New Construction
∗ Low to Negative Absorption
∗ Moderate to Low Employment Growth
∗ Medium to Low Rate of Rental Growth
– Description: The oversupply phase emerges when the market becomes saturated with new construction,
leading to increasing vacancy rates. Absorption rates slow down or become negative, indicating an excess
of available space. Employment growth decelerates, and rental rates may stagnate or decline.
• Recession Phase
– Characteristics:
∗ Increasing Vacancy Rates
∗ Moderate to Low New Construction
∗ Low Absorption Rate of Space
∗ Low to Negative Employment Growth
∗ Low to Negative Rate of Rental Growth
– Description: The recession phase is characterized by rising vacancy rates, limited new construction,
and low absorption of available space. Employment growth is sluggish or negative, leading to reduced
demand. Rental rates may either remain flat or decline during this challenging economic phase.

8
 Vacancy Rates in the real estate industry refer to the percentage of available rental units or properties that
are currently unoccupied or vacant within a specific market or area. Low vacancy rates indicate a strong and
competitive real estate market where demand for rental properties or commercial spaces is high. This can lead to
higher rental prices and a more favorable environment for property owners and landlords.
Absorption rates in real estate refer to the rate at which available properties or rental units are being leased
or sold within a specific market or area over a defined period. A high absorption rate suggests strong demand for
properties in the market. This can indicate a healthy and competitive real estate environment, which may lead
to increased property values and rental prices. A negative absorption rate occurs when the number of properties
leased or sold is less than the number of properties available at the start of the period.

1.6.1 Phases of the Real Estate Cycle: GROWTH

In the growth phase of the real estate market cycle, several key dynamics come into play:

• Demand Surpasses Supply: This phase marks the beginning of a cycle where demand for real estate
surpasses the available supply, resulting in a situation where the demand for properties starts to outstrip their
availability.
• Escalating Rents: As demand surges, rental prices begin to rise. These annual rents continue to climb,
eventually reaching a point where the potential yield for real estate development projects within the region
becomes sufficiently appealing for real estate development firms. It’s during this period that these firms start
contemplating the construction of new units, particularly when rents approach the replacement cost.
• Appreciation in Property Prices: Not only do rental rates increase, but the prices of existing properties
also experience an uptick. This uptrend can be attributed to the growing occupancy rates and a simultaneous
reduction in the supply of available space.

• Renegotiation Opportunities: Real estate managers and property owners, given the favorable market
conditions, have the opportunity to renegotiate lease agreements and secure higher rents. Moreover, the
prospect of constructing new properties becomes increasingly attractive.

The growth phase of the real estate market cycle is characterized by a dynamic interplay of factors that ultimately
lead to higher rental and capital values, stimulating real estate development activities and investment in the sector.

1.6.2 Phases of the Real Estate Cycle: MATURITY

During the maturity phase of the real estate market cycle, we observe a different set of dynamics:

• Thriving Real Estate Development: This phase is marked by robust real estate development activities,
fueled by increasing rents that surpass the cost of replacement. The market enjoys a period of sustained
growth.
• Supply and Demand Balance: The supply of available space continues to expand until it either reaches
equilibrium with demand or experiences a partial surplus, where the supply surpasses the space sought by
applicants. When this surplus occurs, the rate of rent growth starts to decelerate, and the vacancy rate
initiates a reversal in its trend.
• Slowdown in Rent Growth: As the properties become ready for new construction, with additional leasable
space entering the market, the growth of rents experiences an abrupt halt. In many cases, rents may even
begin to decrease. Simultaneously, the vacancy rate undergoes significant growth and is no longer negligible.

• Managerial Adaptation: A proficient real estate property manager must possess the foresight to perceive
this market shift and anticipate its effects. This may involve decisions to halt new development activities and
make strategic adjustments to navigate the evolving landscape.

The maturity phase signifies a market that has reached a pinnacle, with rental and capital values growth slowing
down, requiring adaptability and astute decision-making by industry professionals to respond to these changing
dynamics.

9
1.6.3 Phases of the Real Estate Cycle: FALL
The decline phase of the real estate market cycle introduces a series of noteworthy developments:

• Market Peaks and Flattens: During this phase, property prices reach their cycle peak and level off. Real
estate becomes overpriced, and the market starts to exhibit signs of saturation.
• Reduced Buyer Activity: The market experiences a decline in buyer activity. Most prospective buyers
have already entered the market, and fewer new participants are seen.

• Seller Resistance to Price Reduction: Sellers, recognizing the peak in prices, often resist lowering their
asking prices. They hope to maintain their property values, even as market conditions signal the need for
adjustment.
• Reluctant Price Reductions: As market pressure intensifies, some sellers are compelled to begrudgingly
reduce their prices, albeit by a small margin.

• Buyer Perceptions: Buyers who enter the market at this stage may perceive these price reductions as a
”good deal.” Their emotions may urge them to buy, despite the market value not yet aligning with their
purchase.
• Uncertain Future: Little do these buyers know that they are entering a challenging phase of the market
cycle. Phase 4 holds unforeseen challenges and potential for further price declines.

The decline phase characterizes a market that has peaked and started to contract, leading to decreasing rents
and capital values. It’s a critical juncture where buyers and sellers must navigate changing dynamics with caution
and prudence.

1.6.4 Phases of the Real Estate Cycle: CRISIS

The crisis phase of the real estate market cycle presents a unique set of characteristics and challenges:

• Rock-Bottom Prices: In this phase, rental and capital values hit their lowest points, often characterized
by exceedingly low property prices. The market is devoid of new real estate development activities, leading
to a stable supply.
• Excess Space: A substantial surplus of available space is a hallmark of this phase. The market grapples
with high vacancy rates, and competition for occupants is fierce.
• Economic Weakness: This phase is frequently coupled with limited economic growth and weak demand for
real estate space. The broader economy faces challenges, and this is reflected in the real estate market.
• Stabilization and Recovery: The crisis phase marks the point at which the market stabilizes. With a slow,
but discernible increase in demand and a stable supply (owing to limited development activities), the market
sets the stage for a return to the growth phase of the cycle.
• Investment Opportunities: Far-sighted investors recognize the potential inherent in this phase. Many real
estate portfolios are valued by the market at levels below the cost of replacement for the underlying properties,
presenting opportunities for strategic acquisitions and value-driven investments.

The crisis phase represents the nadir of the market cycle, offering unique prospects for investors who can discern
the potential for recovery and future growth in real estate values.

10
1.7 Market Timing
Strategically timing the real estate market is a fundamental aspect of successful real estate investments. While
pinpointing the precise moment when a market reaches the bottom of the real estate cycle can be challenging,
recognizing the signs of an upward trend and taking proactive steps can lead to robust future returns. Here’s a
more exhaustive breakdown of this critical concept:

• Buy Low, Sell High Philosophy: The essence of market timing in real estate revolves around the clas-
sic principle of ”buy low and sell high.” Investors seek to acquire properties when they are undervalued,
anticipating their future appreciation in value.
• Complexity of Timing: The real estate market is complex, and various factors influence its cyclical move-
ments. These factors include economic conditions, supply and demand dynamics, interest rates, and local
market peculiarities. Timing the market precisely is challenging due to these multifaceted influences.
• Due Diligence and Research: Effective market timing requires thorough research and due diligence.
Investors should stay informed about local and national market trends, economic indicators, and the specific
factors influencing the property’s value.

• Diversification: Diversifying a real estate portfolio across different markets or property types can help
mitigate the risks associated with market timing. Some markets may reach the bottom of their cycles earlier
or later than others, providing a degree of safety through diversification.

Real estate market timing is indeed an intricate discipline. Numerous elements, including seller motivation,
supply and demand, interest rates, employment trends, and population growth, can have significant influence on
property pricing. In order to successfully navigate the market, it is required a strong grasp of the real estate cycle,
extensive research in the market area, and the determination to enter the market. While this can be a daunting task
for individuals, partnering with Strategic Investment Realty provides access to a team of industry experts dedicated
to ensuring your investment success.

Seller motivation is a particularly influential factor impacting property prices and the timing of purchases.
Recognizing the emotional cycle that buyers typically undergo can offer valuable insights into the motivations of
sellers, ultimately aiding in negotiation efforts to secure favorable purchase prices. The emotional journey that
buyers embark upon mirrors the sentiments that sellers themselves once experienced, making it a powerful tool for
assessing seller motivations and, consequently, achieving advantageous outcomes in real estate transactions.

1.8 The Real Estate Market - Retail

The retail sector has been a focal point for significant investments, particularly in Europe, with a substantial focus
on Italy and Spain. These investments have aimed to address the gap in supply compared to the more extensive
shopping center markets in Anglo-Saxon countries, such as the USA and the UK. However, the retail real estate
market presents specific challenges and potential risks:

• Consumption Levels: In Italy, as in other parts of Europe, one of the potential risks is the persistence of
low to medium levels of consumption in various regions. Economic challenges and a lower ”consumer culture”
compared to the USA can impact the demand for retail properties. Consumers in Italy may have a reduced
propensity to borrow to finance their consumption, affecting the performance of retail spaces.

• E-commerce Impact: The growing influence of e-commerce presents an additional risk to the retail real
estate market. As online shopping gains popularity, there is a potentially reduced demand for physical retail
stores. The convenience and variety offered by e-commerce platforms can divert consumers from traditional
brick-and-mortar retail.

The retail segment of the real estate market in Italy and Europe is influenced by economic and cultural factors
that can affect consumer behavior and, consequently, the demand for retail properties. Balancing these factors is
essential for investors and developers in the retail sector.

11
1.8.1 Retail Properties
Retail properties, particularly shopping malls, have distinctive characteristics that impact their long-term success.
A key factor is their competitive positioning within the local market. To remain relevant, shopping malls require
consistent investment to prevent obsolescence and attract and retain consumers and tenants. However, this ongoing
need for investment can strain cash flow, creating a complex financial challenge.

The presence of an anchor tenant (Inquilino principale) is critical for a mall’s success. Should the anchor
tenant decide to vacate, it can lead to a significant decline in foot traffic and, often, a cascade of other tenants
abandoning the mall. This phenomenon, known as a ”Death spiral,” can have devastating consequences for the
property.
Furthermore, even if an anchor tenant continues to pay rent for the remaining contract period without being
present in the mall (commonly referred to as ”going dark”), this absence indirectly affects other tenants. It’s
important to note that the majority of income for mall managers comes from non-anchor tenants. When consumer
traffic dwindles due to the absence of the anchor tenant, other tenants may also decide to leave, driven by decreased
business.

Rental agreements for retail properties typically include three components: a basic fee, inflation indexation,
and an overage, which is a percentage of revenues exceeding specific parameters. Overage agreements are a common
practice in the commercial sector and are used to ensure that tenants can maximize their sales and profitability.

In Italy, the retail market has experienced substantial growth since the early 2000s, with numerous shopping
centers emerging near major cities like Rome and Milan. This growth aligns with the increasing importance
of shopping centers in the Italian retail landscape. However, the market faces challenges such as low consumer
spending power and different cultural attitudes toward shopping compared to countries like the United States.

Notably, the retail market segment of supermarket premises is particularly interesting. Many retailers have
adopted sale and leaseback agreements. In this arrangement, retailers sell their properties and subsequently enter
into lease agreements with the buyers. This practice provides immediate financial resources for the development of
their core business, while real estate investors benefit from long-term contracts and strong market demand.

In summary, the retail real estate sector, especially shopping malls, requires ongoing investment to maintain
competitiveness. The departure of an anchor tenant can have a profound impact, and rental agreements often
include an overage component to share in tenant success. The Italian retail market has grown significantly but
faces challenges related to cultural attitudes and consumer spending. Sale and leaseback agreements have become
a notable trend in the supermarket premises segment.

Figure 1.4: Types of retail properties

12
1.9 The Real Estate Market - Office Buildings
Office properties in the real estate market are closely tied to job creation rates and, indirectly, to the unemployment
rate. Several factors influence this demand, including:
• Local Government Policies: The orientation of local governments towards business plays a role. In states
that are more business-oriented, such as Singapore, the demand for office space tends to be higher.
• Skilled Labor Availability: The presence of skilled labor and nearby residential areas can impact the
demand for office properties. Employees need to be accessible to workplaces.
• Infrastructure and Accessibility: The availability of facilities like parking, public transport, road net-
works, and ease of access to airports can influence the appeal of office locations.
Office properties are typically classified into categories like A, B, C, and so on, reflecting their quality and amenities.

Analyzing the vacancy rate is crucial in the office sector. It’s essential to examine this rate within specific
segments. For example, in a given market, the overall vacancy rate might be 15%, but this can vary significantly
between different property classes. For instance, class A properties might have a vacancy rate as low as 5%, while
classes B and C could experience vacancy rates as high as 40%.
The office sector is one of the most sensitive to economic cycles and is closely tied to the overall health of
companies and public administrations. Given the considerable time required for the construction of office properties,
the market can be more risky and challenging to navigate in terms of timing.
Furthermore, a potential future consideration for office properties could be the cost per workstation. This metric
may become increasingly important for tenants and investors as the way we work and use office spaces evolves.
In summary, the demand for office properties is intricately linked to economic trends, local government policies,

labor availability, and infrastructure. Analyzing vacancy rates within specific property segments is essential, and
the office sector’s sensitivity to economic cycles and the construction lead time make it a challenging market to
navigate. Future considerations may include the cost per workstation as office space usage evolves.

Figure 1.5: Examples

1.9.1 Offices - Market Trends

Understanding market trends, particularly in terms of office spaces, is essential for real estate stakeholders. Here’s
an in-depth look at the current dynamics in the office market:
• Vacancy Rate as an Indicator: A critical metric for assessing market performance is the vacancy rate,
which measures the availability of office spaces. It serves as a barometer for supply and demand dynamics in
the office market.

13
 • Tenant-Led Market: Across Europe, the office market is currently predominantly characterized as ”tenant-
led.” In most major cities, the market is either in the ”decline” phase with falling rents or in a ”crisis” phase
where rents have bottomed out.
• Rising Average Vacancy Rates: The average vacancy rate at the European level is on the rise, indicating
a challenging market environment. This negative trend is primarily attributed to the impact of the global
financial and economic crisis, coupled with an increase in the supply of office spaces at a time when demand
is significantly decreasing.
• Property Quality Differentiation: A key distinguishing factor in this scenario is the quality of the office
properties. Categories such as Class A and Class B properties vary significantly in their vacancy rates. High-
quality and highly functional properties, often classified as Class A, tend to have remarkably low vacancy
rates even in challenging market conditions.
In summary, the European office market currently leans towards being tenant-driven, with declining or bottomed-
out rents in major cities. A surge in vacancy rates at the European level is largely attributed to the broader economic
and financial crisis, with differentiating factors being the quality and functionality of office properties, where Class A
properties stand out with low vacancy rates. Investors, tenants, and real estate professionals should closely monitor
these trends to make informed decisions in the ever-evolving office market.

1.10 Hospitality
The hospitality sector comprises various types of accommodation properties, each offering distinct services. These
properties can have separate owners and managers. In many advanced economies, there’s a growing trend to
separate ownership from management to enhance operational efficiency.
Creating large chains, whether at a national or international level, has become imperative due to the competitive
nature of the hospitality industry. It helps address two key structural challenges faced by hotel managers:
• Limited Bargaining Power: Hotel managers often have restricted negotiation power with suppliers and
customers. Forming larger chains can amplify this power and lead to better deals.

• Market Visibility: Being ”visible” in the market, aside from promotional and marketing efforts, is chal-
lenging for hotel managers. Large chains have stronger brand awareness and market presence.

Limited Bargaining Power: Hotel managers often have restricted negotiation power with suppliers and customers.
Forming larger chains can amplify this power and lead to better deals.
Market Visibility: Being ”visible” in the market, aside from promotional and marketing efforts, is challenging
for hotel managers. Large chains have stronger brand awareness and market presence.
In Europe, management contracts usually stipulate that the manager directly collects and handles revenues.
The manager then pays the owner a percentage of these revenues. Consequently, the risk predominantly rests with
the manager.
In the United States, management contracts differ by having the owner directly collect revenues and re-
munerate the operator with a fixed amount, often accompanied by a percentage of the generated revenues. This
arrangement places the risk primarily on the property owner.

Within the hospitality sector, various types of contractual agreements exist, each with distinct characteristics
and implications. These agreements define the relationship between operators and property owners. Here’s a
comprehensive overview of the main types of agreements:
• Franchising: In a franchising arrangement, the hotel chain allows a franchisee to operate under its brand and
utilize its commercial services, which may include booking systems, marketing, and promotional support. In
return, the franchisee typically pays a royalty fee, often calculated as a percentage of gross revenue per room.
Franchising agreements are contingent upon the franchisee meeting specific standards related to location,
interior space size, and services offered. The primary risk in a franchising agreement lies with the operator
(franchisee), while the owner receives a regular ”canon” or fee.

14
 • Management Contract: In a management contract, the property owner entrusts the management of their
hotel to a chain, which operates it using its own brand, reservation services, and marketing efforts. The owner
retains the entire risk in this type of agreement. The manager (often the hotel chain) receives compensa-
tion, typically through management fees and performance-based incentives, often calculated based on Gross
Operating Profit (GOP).

• Lease: In a lease arrangement, the operator (lessee) obtains a license to operate the hotel business and pays
an annual fee to the property owner (lessor). In this arrangement, the owner retains the license, which is then
”leased” to the operator for operation. The lessee is responsible for managing the day-to-day operations of
the hotel business, while the owner primarily receives a fee for granting the license.
Each of these contractual agreements offers distinct advantages and entails specific responsibilities. Hotel opera-
tors, property owners, and investors must carefully consider these agreements’ terms and implications when entering
the hospitality sector

1.10.1 Hospitality in Italy

The hospitality sector in Italy exhibits a unique set of characteristics and potential for growth. Let’s delve into the
dynamics, opportunities, strengths, and weaknesses within this market:

• Market Fragmentation:

– The Italian hotel industry is notably fragmented in terms of property types, locations, and management
structures.
– This fragmentation has a direct impact on corporate forms, with entrepreneurs often serving as both
property owners and operators.

• Modernization and Supply Reduction:

– The Italian hotel industry is gradually modernizing, moving toward consolidation and supply reduction.
This includes the development of larger hotels with a greater number of rooms, allowing for economies
of scale.

• Challenges:
– Italy still lags behind in terms of international standardization of its hotel offerings and the presence
of large hotel chains. This factor limits the interest of international institutional investors in Italian
hospitality properties. Regulatory instability and policy uncertainties further discourage international
investments in the sector.

Opportunities and Risks

• Opportunities:
– Italy’s real estate market enjoys stable growth alongside a rising demand for overnight stays, both for
business and leisure purposes, driven in part by greater intra-European mobility.
– There is a growing interest from real estate funds and investors in the Italian hospitality sector.
– A noticeable scarcity of 4-star hotels with a good quality/price ratio presents a market segment with
significant growth potential.
– Italy is ranked fourth globally for incoming tourism and boasts numerous UNESCO-listed ”Cultural
heritage sites of humanity.”
• Risks:

– The Italian hospitality market suffers from a lack of transparency and a prevalence of less ”professional”
and ”craft enterprises.”
– The market remains highly fragmented, and there is a significant disparity between property values and
income potential.

15
 – High purchase prices and substantial renovation costs pose challenges, especially in properties with
medium to low quality standards.
– Labor costs are relatively high in Italy, impacting operational expenses.

Efficiency and Institutional Investment: To attract institutional investors and ensure efficient management,
there’s a pressing need to separate property ownership from management, moving beyond the current ”craft” style
of operation.

16
1.11 Glossary
• Gross Leasable Area: The total area of a building measured from exterior wall to exterior wall, encom-
passing all space within its boundaries.
• Net Area: The Gross Floor Area minus areas not used for rentable purposes, such as interior walls, stairs,
lobbies, and other non-rentable spaces. Net areas are what can be rented, making efficient space design crucial,
especially in properties like hotels.

• Occupancy: The ratio of occupied spaces within a property. It’s essential to distinguish between occupied
spaces that generate income (e.g., rented units) and those occupied but not generating income (e.g., common
areas or vacant units).
• Vacancy: The ratio of unoccupied space within a property that has the potential to be occupied in the future
and generate income.

• Loan to Value (LTV): The ratio between the amount of a loan granted and the appraised value of the
property.
• Loan to Cost (LTC): The ratio between the amount of funding provided for a project and the total cost of
the project, including construction and development expenses.

• Greenfield Development: The development of areas that are free from prior development and constraints,
providing developers with the freedom to choose how to develop the land.
• Brownfield Development: The redevelopment of industrial or commercial areas that were previously used
but have been discontinued, often due to environmental or operational issues.
• Tenant: A lessee or renter of a property, typically used in the context of commercial real estate.

• Anchor Tenant: The primary tenant in a shopping center, often a retailer with a well-known brand, capable
of attracting significant foot traffic to the shopping center and benefiting all other tenants.
• Overage (Percentage Rents): A portion of the rent for commercial properties that allows the landlord to
share in the positive performance or sales of the tenant, typically in addition to a base rent.

• Death Spiral: Occurs when an anchor tenant leaves a mall (sometimes referred to as ”going dark” because
they continue to pay rent) and, as a result, many or all small tenants follow suit, leading to a significant drop
in customer traffic within the mall.
• Securitization: A financial operation in which future cash flows from a pool of assets are bundled together,
converted into tradable securities, and transferred to investors in the capital market.

17
Chapter 2

Due Diligence Process in Real Estate

Transactions

2.1 Real Estate Due Diligence

Due diligence refers to the comprehensive analysis process used to assess the viability and integrity of a real estate
asset, business unit, or company, typically in preparation for acquisition or investment. It is a critical step in
mitigating risks and ensuring informed decision-making in the complex world of real estate transactions.

2.1.1 Key Components of Real Estate Due Diligence

Real estate due diligence encompasses a multifaceted approach involving several critical components:

1. Documentation Assessment: This phase involves a meticulous review of all relevant documentation as-
sociated with the property, business unit, or company in question. The aim is to verify the accuracy and
completeness of the provided information.
2. Practical Assessment: This phase involves on-site inspections and assessments to evaluate the physical
condition of the real estate asset.

3. Discrepancy Evaluation: This phase involves a careful examination of potential inconsistencies or discrep-
ancies between the documentation and the actual state of the real estate asset. It is essential to identify any
material differences that could impact the decision-making process or require corrective action.

Real estate due diligence is a complex and crucial process that serves to minimize risks and ensure that potential
real estate investments or acquisitions align with the objectives of the investor or purchaser. Thoroughly executed
due diligence provides valuable insights and enables informed decision-making in the dynamic and intricate realm
of real estate transactions.

Conducting thorough due diligence in real estate is essential for several reasons:
1. To ensure that the real estate asset is in compliance with the law.
2. To evaluate potential financial and administrative challenges that may arise if the property does not meet
legal requirements.
3. Due diligence is a time-intensive process and is typically undertaken when there is a genuine interest in buying
or selling the property.

18
 There are two main phases of due diligence:
1. Pre-Acquisition Due Diligence (Ex-Ante): This phase involves gathering comprehensive information be-
fore a transaction to ensure that both parties have access to the same data, minimizing information imbalances
and ensuring a fair deal. ”Pre-acquisition” due diligence involves a series of crucial steps:
• Reviewing Seller’s Documentation (Data Room): The first step is to carefully analyze the doc-
umentation provided by the seller, which may be supplemented with additional information upon the
buyer’s request.
• On-Site Inspection: A site visit is conducted to physically examine the real estate property. This visit
aims to verify the property’s condition, including maintenance, the quality of the building, the status of
its systems, and other relevant aspects.
• Due Diligence Report: A comprehensive report is prepared, highlighting critical findings. This report
may include issues such as the potential need to abandon the acquisition due to non-compliance with
certain parameters or the necessity to renegotiate the terms of the acquisition. The report is typically
a collaborative effort involving both technical and legal consultants who express their opinions on the
property’s compliance. These judgments are based on an analysis of the provided documents and on-site
inspection findings.
The purpose of ”pre-acquisition” due diligence is to:
• Facilitate Negotiations: It serves as a starting point for negotiations between the buying and selling
parties, allowing them to address any issues or concerns that arise during the due diligence process.
• Negotiate Clauses and Warranty Mechanisms: The findings from due diligence may lead to ne-
gotiations on contractual clauses and warranty mechanisms. This can include discussions on potential
changes to the purchase price or other terms of the agreement to ensure both parties are in agreement.
Moreover, we can distinguish in this section:
• Due Diligence Desktop: This serves as an initial assessment aimed at identifying crucial factors
affecting asset valuation and the feasibility of the transaction. It results in a concise, summary report.
• Due Diligence Full: This comprehensive evaluation provides a detailed overview of the asset’s current
condition and offers insights into long-term maintenance requirements and planning.
2. Post-Acquisition Due Diligence (Management, Ex-Post): It becomes essential once the new owner
takes possession of the property and has a growing need for a comprehensive analysis to ensure effective
management of the asset. This process may involve an initial phase as part of property management activities.
The main phases of post-acquisition due diligence include:
• Documentation Review: The first step is to receive all documentation related to the property, in-
cluding location details, procurement contracts, and any other relevant records. This documentation is
then thoroughly assessed for accuracy and completeness.
• Recovering Missing Documentation: In cases where certain documents are missing, efforts are made
to recover them, which may involve contacting public authorities or other relevant sources to ensure a
complete record.
• Legal Compliance Assessment: An assessment is conducted to determine whether the property is in
compliance with all relevant laws and regulations. This is crucial to ensure that the property’s operations
are in accordance with legal requirements.
• Review of Rental and Procurement Contracts: Existing rental and procurement contracts are
examined in detail to understand their terms and conditions. This helps in managing and potentially
renegotiating these agreements if necessary.
• Maintenance Planning: A comprehensive maintenance plan for the property is drafted. This plan
outlines strategies for ongoing property maintenance, which is essential to preserve its value and ensure
smooth operations.

2.1.2 Due Diligence: Main Themes

Due diligence deeply examines the real estate property under several aspects:

19
Technical Due Diligence
Aims to thoroughly understand the technical aspects of a property, identify potential sources of risk, and evaluate
the need for both routine and significant maintenance.

1. Tools:
• Specific documentation related to the property and its systems.
• On-site visits for a physical assessment. The site visit involves inspecting the building and its surround-
ings to understand potential development trends. This is important for both technical and commercial
analyses. In commercial analysis, the focus is on assessing the area’s future development trends, tenant
analysis, overall quality, and value enhancement opportunities. Comparables analysis is a key compo-
nent, helping to understand competition by examining similar real estate assets in terms of size, usage,
and rental rates.
• Reference to local and national laws and regulations.

2. Main Analysis Areas:

• Property Description: Understanding the property’s characteristics and features.
• Rental Status: Evaluating existing rental agreements and their impact.
• Cadastral and Urban Status: Ensuring alignment with land registry and urban planning regulations.
• Building Status: Assessing the condition of the physical structure.
• Plant Status: Evaluating the condition and functionality of building systems.
• Fire Prevention (C.P.I.): Verifying compliance with fire prevention regulations.
3. Results:

• Assessment of Property Law Compliance and Analysis of Costs for Meeting Plant and Facility Standards.
• Identification of Structural Anomalies (e.g., construction flaws) and Suggestions for Remediation.
• Long-term Planning for Routine and Extraordinary Maintenance, with the plan being documented in
the Business Plan (BP).
• Confirmation of Fundamental Data for Business Plan Input (e.g., rent, management costs).
• Estimation of Construction Costs for Insurance and Valuation Purposes.
• Recommendations for Completing Information Related to the Property (e.g., document reconstruction).
• Technical Due Diligence provides critical insights into the property’s technical condition and legal compli-
ance, facilitating informed decision-making, maintenance planning, and financial assessment for potential
investors or property owners.

20
Enviromental Due Diligence
It is conducted to identify environmental risks associated with a property and its usage. This assessment focuses
on both legal compliance and potential health risks. To achieve this, various tools and analysis areas are employed:

1. Tools:
• Specific documentation related to the property and its systems. Historical reconstruction of property
usage. Site visits, including mapping of potentially hazardous materials. Possible sampling of materials
and subsequent laboratory analysis.
2. Main Analysis Areas (Potentially Dangerous Materials):
• Asbestos.
• Artificial vitreous fibers.
• Substances that deplete the ozone layer.
• PCB/PCT (Polychlorinated Biphenyls and Polychlorinated Terphenyls).
• Underground storage tanks.
3. Results:
• Assessment of Environmental Law Compliance for the property and cost analysis for adapting to envi-
ronmental standards.
• Identification of significant anomalies and potential solutions, such as asbestos removal.
• Long-term planning for routine and extraordinary environmental maintenance, with the plan documented
in the Business Plan (BP).

Environmental Due Diligence is typically carried out by companies specialized in chemical analyses of materials.
Environmental experts utilize the results of technical due diligence and site visits to gather evidence of potential
environmental risks, which may then be subject to further in-depth examination. The growing attention to envi-
ronmental issues has contributed to the increasing adoption of Environmental Due Diligence in Italy, reflecting a
broader global trend in addressing environmental concerns.

Legal Due Diligence

Legal Due Diligence is conducted to identify and mitigate legal risks associated with the acquisition and use of a
property. It aims to understand these risks and minimize their potential impact. The tools and analysis areas for
legal due diligence are as follows:

1. Tools: Analysis of various documentation, including public records and contracts.

2. Main Analysis Areas:
• Identification of Real Rights and Burdens (e.g., mortgages, easements).
• Examination of Current Notary Records.
• Catastal and Urban Status Assessment.
• Review of Rental Contracts.
• Assessment of the Existence of Condominium or Consortium Associations.
• Evaluation of Tender and Other Passive Contracts.
• Analysis of Insurance Status.
• Identification of Any Ongoing Legal Disputes.
• Examination of Tax Status (e.g., IMU - Property Tax).
• Property Origin and History.
3. Reuslts:
• Identification of legal risks associated with the property’s acquisition and ownership.

21
 • Risk mitigation through the inclusion of specific clauses in the acquisition contract.

Legal professionals typically conduct Legal Due Diligence and are responsible for drafting the acquisition con-
tract. The results of the due diligence process are integrated into the acquisition contract to protect the buyer
against the risks identified during due diligence.
Lawyers play a critical role in serving as a bridge between the due diligence process and the acquisition. Warranty
and protection clauses within the acquisition contract are essential components that help safeguard the buyer’s
interests.

Urban Due Diligence

Urban Due Diligence is conducted to assess the urban status of a property in relation to the General Urban Plan
(Piano Regolatore Generale or PRG) of the municipality in which it is situated. The goal is to verify associated
restrictions and estimate the property’s development possibilities. This process employs specific tools and focuses
on key analysis areas:

1. Tools:
• Cadastral analysis.
• Technical analysis of the property.
2. Main Analysis Areas:
• General Overview of the Area.
• Assessment of Cadastral Status.
• Evaluation of Urban Status.
• Exploration of Potential Urban Developments, including changes in intended uses and potential burdens.
3. Results:
• Confirmation of Urban Compliance or Recommendations for Achieving Compliance.
• Definition of Potential Future Development Opportunities for the Property.

Urban Due Diligence helps stakeholders determine whether the property aligns with urban regulations and
provides insights into its potential for development. It is crucial for making informed decisions regarding the
property’s use and potential enhancements.

2.1.3 Conclusion
Conclusions of a Due Diligence (DD) process typically involve the generation of descriptive reports shared among
the DD team to enhance their understanding of the property. The final result is a SWOT analysis, which breaks
down as follows:

• Threats:
– Risks Allocation between Buyer and Seller.
– Quantification of Risks and Their Inclusion in the Business Plan (BP).
• Strenghts and Opportunities:
– Consideration as Possible Scenarios in the Business Plan (BP).
• Weaknesses:
– Identification of Corrections Needed.
– Quantification of Corrections and Their Inclusion in the Business Plan (BP).

These SWOT analyses help stakeholders make informed decisions and strategize effectively by recognizing potential
risks, leveraging strengths and opportunities, and addressing weaknesses. The information obtained through Due
Diligence is critical for developing comprehensive business plans and ensuring a successful outcome in property
transactions.

22
2.2 Due Diligence in RE Transactions
2.2.1 Definition
Due diligence is a comprehensive research and investigation process that occurs before entering into a contract,
particularly in real estate transactions. In the context of real estate, it primarily involves a specified period within
a real estate contract, during which a buyer examines the property in question to ensure their satisfaction before
finalizing the purchase.
In any real estate transfer, whether it’s an apartment lease, residential home purchase, commercial business
lease, acquisition of a shopping center, or even the purchase of a skyscraper in Manhattan, the prospective buyer
or tenant must engage in some form of due diligence to assess the quality, both physical and intangible, of the real
estate being conveyed.
The underlying principle behind conducting property investigations at both ends of this spectrum remains
consistent: it’s essential to understand the characteristics of the real estate being conveyed in order to effectively
manage risks and confirm that the perceived value, as represented by the purchase price or rental rate, aligns with
the actual condition of the property.
However, well before any initial offer is made, properties under consideration for real estate investment should
undergo a thorough assessment using all publicly available information. This preliminary due diligence phase may
involve property visits, discussions with brokers, and consultations with advisors, such as attorneys and financial
experts. It is a crucial step to make informed decisions and evaluate the potential value and risks associated with
a real estate investment.

2.2.2 Preliminary Due Diligence

In the realm of real estate, the property evaluation process often commences well before the formal offer to purchase
real estate, or even the drafting of a letter of intent outlining the purchase terms. This preliminary phase involves
several key activities:

1. Property Visits: Prospective buyers or investors visit the property.

2. Engagement with Real Estate Professionals: Conversations and discussions take place with real estate
brokers and property sellers.

This preliminary step should not be underestimated or hastily skipped because it serves a crucial role in building
informal connections. These connections are vital for gathering essential information during the due diligence
process.
Moreover, the initial phase of property assessment can reveal questions or investigative paths that may initially
appear unproductive but ultimately provide unique insights into the transaction. As negotiations progress and the
real estate sales contract is being drafted, it’s imperative to identify potential challenges related to representations,
warranties, and the provision of property-related information by the seller.
Resistance or reluctance from the seller regarding these aspects can often serve as a red flag, indicating potential
issues related to the property’s condition. Once the real estate sales contract is signed, there’s a race against time
to efficiently gather the maximum amount of information. It’s essential to balance cost-effectiveness with the need
for timely investigation.
The investigatory period is typically shorter than the purchaser would prefer, underscoring the importance of
time efficiency.
Assuming that the seller has maintained adequate documentation, a thorough review of their documents can
significantly save time, effort, and resources that the purchaser might otherwise expend procuring the same infor-
mation independently. This emphasizes the critical nature of early and effective preliminary due diligence in the
real estate transaction process.

Review of Seller Documents

In the context of real estate transactions, it is crucial to request from the seller all documents and materials that
they received or should have obtained during their due diligence process when they acquired the property, especially
if the purchase occurred recently. This comprehensive list may include:

• Current tenant information.

23
 • Details about the current uses of the real estate.
• Any third-party reports or inspections initiated by the seller.
• Surveys of the land and improvements in the seller’s possession.
• The seller’s current title insurance policy.

• Relevant condominium documents.

• Notices of any ongoing or potential litigation or governmental actions related to the property or the seller.
• Notices regarding environmental conditions.

• Notices of any new or special assessments or taxes.

• Copies of all current bills for the property.
• Service contracts.
• Evidence of current zoning regulations.

• As-built plans and specifications.

• All construction-related documents, including warranties.
• Evidence of insurance coverage.

To ensure a thorough due diligence process, it’s imperative to review each of these documents or items inde-
pendently. The objective is to identify potential problem areas that may necessitate deeper investigation. This
comprehensive review of seller-provided documents is a critical component of the due diligence process and plays a
pivotal role in uncovering any issues or risks associated with the property being conveyed.

Independent Investigation
After receiving and reviewing the seller’s delivery documents, it’s time to move beyond these documents and embark
on your independent investigation of the real estate’s condition. Utilize the insights you’ve gained so far to chart
the appropriate course for this investigation.
While a Due Diligence Checklist is a valuable resource to guide you on your property investigation journey, it’s
highly recommended to engage the services of a real estate agent or attorney to assist you in this process. Their
expertise can be invaluable in ensuring a thorough and successful due diligence process.
Your primary goal in the due diligence process is to confirm that the property you believe you’re acquiring aligns
with the property being conveyed. This verification is crucial to avoid any unexpected surprises or discrepancies.
It’s essential to remember that each real estate transaction is unique, with its own set of obstacles and consid-
erations. Approach each purchase with the individual attention and respect it deserves.

2.2.3 Due Diligence Period

Buying Commercial & Residential Real Estate
Preliminary due diligence plays a pivotal role in both commercial and residential real estate transactions, primarily
to empower the buyer to accurately evaluate the property’s value and strategically formulate an offer.
In many instances, the documents required to delve into a property’s net profitability are only accessible to
the buyer after an offer has been made. However, at its core, when it comes to assessing the value of commercial
property, income production is of utmost importance.
A critical ratio to consider in this context is the Net Operating Income (NOI), calculated by subtracting
operating expenses (excluding taxes and interest) from income. NOI should stand as one of the key factors guiding
your decision on how much you are willing to pay for the property.

24
Commercial RE Due diligence in commercial real estate is of paramount importance to ensure that the buyer
has a precise understanding of what they are purchasing. This critical process typically commences after:
• The prospective buyer has made an offer.
• The seller has accepted the offer, subject to the due diligence period.
• The buyer has placed a down payment in an escrow account, to be applied towards the purchase.
The duration of this due diligence period can vary, ranging from 30 days to more than nine months. The process
encompasses various aspects, including:
• Physical inspections of the real estate.
• An assessment of related environmental conditions.
• A review of the property’s title.
• Evaluation of zoning requirements.
• Examination of contracts, leases, and surveys.
• A partial review of documents provided by the seller.
In addition to document review, the buyer should also undertake an independent investigation. The buyer can
request that the seller conducts and/or covers the cost of specific third-party assessments that the buyer wishes to
inspect and negotiate these assessments into the contract.

Residential RE Just as in the case of commercial real estate, a comprehensive assessment of the value and
market for residential real estate is essential before making an offer. However, in residential real estate, there are
fewer objective measures of property valuation, especially in the case of single-family residences.
For multifamily units, it’s advisable to review the property’s income alongside property taxes and utility costs.
For single-family residences, your primary methods for valuing the property include: Comparative market analysis
(comps), Real estate appraisals, Monitoring local real estate trends.
The due diligence period for residential real estate purchases typically spans 30 days, with a window of 10 to
15 days allocated for inspections. During this due diligence phase, you should diligently review various aspects,
including:
• The deed and title.
• Surveying documents.
• Zoning documents.
• Property inspections.
• Property appraisals.
• Environmental assessments.
• Insurance documents.
• Any other available documents related to the property.

2.2.4 Title Review

One of the first steps in the due diligence process is to review the property’s title. Ideally, unless you are purchasing
a distressed property, the title should be free from any liens or other claims against it.
The title represents the transferable right to the property, and it is crucial to ensure that the seller possesses a
clear title (often confused with the deed, which is the document used to transfer the property to another party).
Typically, sellers take steps to ensure they can convey a clear title before listing the property on the market.
The title review process for commercial real estate purchases is quite similar and involves a thorough examination
of all claims against the property, which is known as a title search. To safeguard your interests in case the title
search misses any claims against the property, which may surface after your purchase, it is advisable to purchase
title insurance. This insurance policy holds the policyholder responsible for such claims.

25
Commercial RE In the due diligence process, you will likely receive a document known as a Preliminary Title
Report (PTR) from a title insurance company. This report includes essential information such as a description
of the land, the type of estate, details regarding the title holder, and any claims to the estate.
When reviewing the title commitment, it’s crucial to pay attention to any Exceptions or exclusions from the
title. These exceptions define known claims to the property by other parties, including taxing agencies. PTRs may
also list various aspects, such as liens, restrictions, special assessments, and more.
It is highly advisable to have your real estate attorney meticulously examine these details. This step ensures
that you have a clear understanding of what you are purchasing, the rights you will possess, and any rights that
others may hold in relation to the property.

Residential RE In residential property transactions, a title insurance company conducts the residential title
search. When you purchase a residential property using financing (leverage), the lender typically requires you to
obtain clear title to the property. If the title insurance company discovers any claims, such as a lien against the
property, the seller is notified and typically required to address and resolve such claims.
Once the title is clear of any encumbrances, the title insurance company issues a title commitment. This
commitment is a statement indicating their willingness to insure the property. Subsequently, the lender is likely to
approve the mortgage.
In the case of distressed properties, you may be required to agree to settle existing liens, which can include
environmental, judgment, or mechanics’ liens, at the time of closing to obtain a title commitment.

2.2.5 Real Estate Surveying

In any real estate transaction, whether it’s residential or commercial, surveying is a critical process that allows you
to gain a comprehensive understanding of the land underlying the property you intend to purchase.
A professional survey can reveal important details, including whether any neighboring entity holds:

• An easement, which is a legal right to pass through or access a specific portion of the land you plan to
purchase.

• An encroachment, where a portion of someone else’s property intrudes on the land you intend to buy.

Additionally, there may be other covenants, conditions, and restrictions associated with the land that you need
to be aware of before proceeding with the purchase. All of this information is crucial to have before making a real
estate investment.

Commercial RE Easements and restrictions can pose more complex challenges for a buyer in commercial real
estate transactions, especially if you have plans to renovate or expand the property. These concerns can often be
more significant than dealing with zoning regulations.
When obtaining a survey for commercial real estate, it’s crucial to look for one prepared by a licensed surveyor
in compliance with international standards. Typically, title insurers require the results of such a survey before
issuing a commitment.
The survey for commercial real estate will provide information on several critical aspects, including:
- Encroachments onto the property you intend to purchase.
- Encroachments the property you intend to purchase has on neighboring properties.
- Easements that may affect the property you plan to acquire.

Residential RE In the context of residential real estate, surveys should be current, as many lenders may not
accept surveys older than six months. Most residential real estate buyers obtain house location surveys due to their
cost-effectiveness. However, it’s important to note that title insurance companies do not consider these surveys in
coverage of encroachments and boundary line disputes.
For title insurance that covers these issues, it’s advisable to obtain a survey when purchasing residential real
estate as an investment.

26
2.2.6 Zoning Regulations
Zoning certifications are obtainable from the planning offices of the jurisdiction in which the property is situated.
As a buyer, it is essential to ensure that the building complies with the existing zoning regulations. Additionally,
it’s prudent to be informed about any planned zoning changes that might negatively impact the intended use of
the property by engaging in discussions with local zoning office representatives.

Commercial RE Owners of commercial real estate must take measures to confirm that the property is in accor-
dance with the current zoning regulations, especially if they have plans for renovations, development, or expansion.
Zoning also encompasses assessments, exactions, and impact fees, all of which can directly influence the expected
net income from the property. After the purchase, staying informed about the city’s evolving zoning plans is of
utmost importance.

Residential RE Residential zoning laws, similar to commercial ones, can vary significantly between cities and
states. Understanding these laws and ensuring compliance for yourself and your tenants is crucial. For instance,
tenants who decide to operate a home-based business in the apartment they lease from you might lead to legal
complications. Staying updated on zoning plans is also vital, as a city’s decision to develop commercial property
could lead to rezoning your property and potential pressure to sell (although they cannot force you to do so). It’s
advisable to familiarize yourself with the relevant zoning laws in advance and anticipate potential changes during
your property ownership.

2.2.7 Property Inspections

In any real estate transaction, it’s imperative that all building inspections are conducted by a certified third-party
to verify that the property is compliant with building codes and is structurally sound. Buyers should actively seek
a recent inspection report or stipulate that one must be carried out during the due diligence period.
Environmental inspections play a crucial role, with commercial properties often facing more significant
concerns due to potential environmental hazards from owners and/or tenants who might be dealing with environ-
mentally harmful waste products in substantial quantities. The property you intend to purchase might have a
history of environmental damage from prior use, which can impact your intended use.

Commercial Real Estate Environmental Inspections In the case of commercial properties, environmental
assessments usually commence with a Phase I Environmental Report. This report aims to determine if there are
any serious environmental issues that require remediation. These reports encompass assessments by licensed third
parties and reviews by state and federal compliance agencies of the property in question. If there are concerning
findings, the next step typically involves a Phase II investigation, often entailing more extensive testing.

Environmental Assessments in Residential Real Estate Residential property transactions also entail envi-
ronmental assessments, conducted by assessors chosen by title insurance companies. Although Phase I and Phase
II assessments are not mandatory, it is highly advisable to obtain the most thorough environmental assessment
available to ensure full use and safety of the property.

2.2.8 Real Estate Leases

As previously mentioned, it’s essential to assess the income generated by the existing leases to determine the
property’s value. However, evaluating the leases goes beyond income. You should also thoroughly examine tenant
files and their credit-worthiness. Additionally, personally inspecting the condition of their leased space is crucial to
validate the seller’s assessment of the property’s condition.
In conjunction with existing leases, there are several other documents that warrant evaluation:

• Existing loan documents.

• Insurance documents, which may provide valuable information.

• A risk assessment from the insurer.

• Utility expenses.

27
 • Property taxes, as you will be responsible for them when the property is vacant.

This comprehensive evaluation ensures a more thorough understanding of the property and its financial aspects.

Evaluating Existing Commercial Real Estate Leases For commercial real estate leases, experts often rec-
ommend reviewing the Net Operating Income (NOI) for the previous three years to accurately project income.
Instead of relying on pro forma statements, which can be misleading, it’s crucial to assess the actual operating
performance from the preceding period. Additionally, thoroughly reviewing lease terms, durations, and tenant files
is essential. If possible, direct interviews with tenants can provide valuable insights, as you’ll be responsible for
their management soon.
During the due diligence process, it’s advisable to request the seller to keep you informed about any tenant
issues that arise. This can help you gain an understanding of any problematic tenants.

Evaluating Existing Residential Real Estate Leases In the context of residential real estate leases, beyond
evaluating them for income projections, it’s essential to review the clauses related to access to the leased space,
potential renovations, and the property’s sale, especially if you plan to flip it. Furthermore, it’s important to ensure
that the seller promptly informs you of any lease amendments made during the due diligence period. Additionally,
confirm that the seller provides appropriate credits for the tenants’ security deposits at the time of closing.

2.2.9 Real Estate Appraisals

Real estate appraisals are a critical component of the real estate purchase process and serve as a key determinant
in assessing the property’s value. These appraisals are not only used by the seller to set their price but also play a
crucial role in the lender’s decision on how much to lend and in tax assessments.

Commercial RE In commercial real estate, appraisals consider various factors such as the physical condition of
the property, zoning records, geo-demographic information, and comparisons to determine its value. It’s essential
to ensure that the appraisal provided by the seller is up-to-date and consider conducting your own appraisal during
the due diligence period to validate the seller’s assessment. It’s also important to communicate to the appraiser the
intended use of the appraisal and its purpose. Different types of commercial real estate appraisals include: - Fee
Simple Interest: The value of the property.
- Leased Fee Interest: The value of the property when leased.
- Leasehold Interest: The value of a lease to a tenant.

Residential RE Licensed residential real estate appraisers typically employ various approaches:
- The Sales Comparison Approach: This method emphasizes comparisons with similar properties.
- The Cost Approach: It examines the replacement cost of the property.
- The Income Approach: This approach is used to develop an initial opinion of value.
When reviewing a residential real estate appraisal, it’s essential to understand the approach used, the date of
valuation, and the appraiser’s independence.

28
Chapter 3

Real Estate Financing

3.1 Introduction
We can distinguish the participants in two main categories:
• Institutional Clients: This category includes Private Equity Real Estate, Asset Managers (SGR), Family
Funds, and Sovereign Funds. These participants are predominantly professionals who demand a structured
approach, have limited time constraints, and possess substantial financial resources.
• Territorial Clients: This category encompasses Corporate Real Estate and Local Developers. These par-
ticipants are primarily entrepreneurs who require an unconventional approach, often involving more time
investment, and may have limited financial resources.
After the pandemic of COVID-19 we have witnessed a substantial change in the hierarchy of the demanded asset
classes:

• Pre-COVID: • Post-COVID:
1. Office 1. Logistics
2. Shopping Centers 2. Residential
3. Residential 3. Hospitality
4. Hospitality 4. Office
5. Logistics 5. Shopping Center

Figure 3.1

29
 Figure 3.2

Figure 3.3

3.2 Dividend Yield Ratio

The dividend yield ratio is a financial metric used by investors to evaluate the attractiveness of a stock or an
investment in terms of the income it generates through dividend payments. This ratio is expressed as a percentage
and is calculated by dividing the annual dividend per share by the current market price per share. We mainly focus
in an alternative version:
N OI
DY R =
Loan Amount

Let’s break down the components:

• NOI (Net Operating Income): NOI is a fundamental metric in real estate investment. It represents the
income generated from a property after deducting operating expenses. These expenses may include property
management costs, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and other operating costs. NOI gives you a clear
picture of the property’s profitability before considering financing costs.

30
 • Loan Amount: This represents the amount of money borrowed to purchase the property. When you buy a
real estate property, you often finance it through a mortgage loan or some other form of financing. The loan
amount is the principal amount that you have borrowed.

The equation, NOI/Loan Amount, essentially measures the ratio of the property’s net operating income to the
amount of financing used to acquire it. This ratio can be helpful for investors to gauge the efficiency and potential
return on their investment, taking into account the leverage (the use of borrowed money) involved in the acquisition.
It’s important to note that this is not a dividend yield in the traditional sense, as you would find with stocks; it’s
more akin to a return on investment or capitalization rate for real estate.
- A high DYR indicates that the property is generating a substantial income compared to the financing used,
potentially resulting in a higher return on investment. However, it’s essential to consider other factors like interest
rates, loan terms, and the overall risk associated with the investment.

3.3 Market Trend

Figure 3.4

See remaning slides ”Real Estate Financing”

31
3.4 Real Estate Financing Case Study - Scannel Properties
3.4.1 Who are we?
With a deeply entrepreneurial and proactive mindset, our primary focus is to comprehensively grasp your unique
requirements and challenges, ensuring an adept approach to resolve them effectively.
As an independently-owned entity with robust capitalization, we possess the agility to outpace our rivals,
resulting in swift project turnarounds, assuring a sense of security and peace of mind. This, in turn, facilitates the
most streamlined and efficient supply chain transition for your business.
By alleviating your concerns, we empower you to seize full command over your logistics operations, thereby
allowing you to redirect your energy towards core business activities.

Figure 3.5: Timeline

3.4.2 Overview
Real estate financing can be categorized into two distinct macro-categories, each tailored to specific real estate
investment objectives:

• Development Financing: This category is designed to facilitate the acquisition and subsequent develop-
ment of a property. It provides financial support not only for the purchase of the property but also for
its development and enhancement. Development financing is ideal for investors and developers looking to
undertake construction, renovation, or other value-adding projects on the property they acquire.
• Acquisition Financing: On the other hand, acquisition financing is geared towards the purchase of prop-
erties or real estate portfolios that are already generating income. This form of financing is well-suited for
investors seeking to acquire properties with established revenue streams, such as income-producing commer-
cial buildings or rental properties. Acquisition financing helps investors secure the capital needed to purchase
these income-generating assets.

32
 Similar to various other forms of financing, real estate financing offers flexibility and can be structured to align
with the financial needs and preferences of the borrower. This may include:
• Bullet Repayment: Under this arrangement, the borrower typically repays the entire principal amount at
the loan’s maturity, while paying interest on scheduled payment dates. This approach is often referred to as
a ”bullet” repayment method and is commonly used when the borrower anticipates a lump sum payment or
revenue realization at the loan’s maturity.
• Amortizing Repayment: In contrast, an amortizing repayment schedule entails regular payments that
cover both the interest and principal components of the loan. These payments are spread out over the loan’s
term, resulting in a gradual reduction of the outstanding principal. This method is chosen when borrowers
prefer a more systematic and predictable approach to repay the loan over time, especially when they do not
anticipate a significant lump sum payment at the end.
Real estate financing typically falls within the medium to long-term category, encompassing loan terms
exceeding 18 months. This preference for extended terms is driven by the potential advantages offered by the
substitute tax regime, as stipulated in Articles 15 and subsequent provisions of Presidential Decree No. 601/1973.

Development Financing typically encompasses the utilization of multiple lines of credit, each tailored to
meet specific financial requirements. These lines of credit are structured to provide the borrower with the necessary
resources to fund, either in entirety or in part, the following aspects:

1. Acquisition of the Asset: Often, one of these credit lines is designated for the acquisition of the property.
It comes into play at the completion of the transfer of ownership, ensuring the necessary funds are available
for this pivotal stage of the development project.
2. Value Added Tax (VAT) Provision: Another line of credit is directed towards covering the VAT associated
with the acquisition and/or development of the property. This funding is coordinated with the acquisition
and development lines to address the specific tax obligations tied to the project.
3. Real Estate Development (Capex Facilities): In addition, development financing includes a line of credit
earmarked for real estate development activities, often referred to as capex facilities. This line is accessed at
various stages throughout the development process, providing the necessary financial resources for ongoing
works and enhancements to the property.

These multiple lines of credit ensure that the borrower has the flexibility and financial support required for the
various facets of the development project.

Of particular importance are the prodromal activities that precede the acquisition of the property and
the signing of related financing agreements, as these serve as conditions precedent to disbursement. To facilitate
this process, several crucial steps must be taken, including:

1. Engaging Independent Consultants for Due Diligence: Independent consultants specializing in urban
planning, construction, and permitting must be enlisted to conduct comprehensive due diligence. This dili-
gence can reveal critical issues for the real estate development project, such as the absence of required permits
or non-compliance with obligations to public authorities regarding the property.

2. Employing Technical Survey Consultants: Technical survey experts should be engaged to perform assess-
ments that can unveil discrepancies in aspects such as cadastral data, landscape conditions, or environmental
considerations concerning the property’s current state.
3. Involving a Notary Public for a 20-Year Notarial Report: A notary public is required to prepare a
20-year notarial report. This report can uncover various aspects, including constraints and limitations on the
transfer of ownership or the execution of planned development works.

33
3.4.3 Importance of Due Diligence
Conducting due diligence assumes particular importance in the context of a comprehensive risk assessment for
a transaction and the meticulous preparation of financial documentation. This process is crucial for ensuring
the thorough evaluation and mitigation of potential risks associated with the transaction. Moreover, it plays
a pivotal role in the meticulous compilation and verification of financial documentation, thereby enhancing the
overall transparency and integrity of the transaction.

Documentation for First Disbursement of Financing

To facilitate the first disbursement of financing, the borrower must provide the financing bank with additional
documents related to the property and its development, including:

1. Business Plan: A strategic plan detailing the property’s intended use, such as sale or lease, along with
expected financial flows.
2. Capex Plan: A comprehensive account of the property’s development program, including the allocation of
financial resources.

3. Timeline: A timeline of expected milestones and events related to the property’s development.
4. Draft Contracts: Documents related to the property acquisition, including preliminary contracts or agree-
ments.
5. Permits and Approvals: Evidence of obtaining all necessary permits and approvals for the property’s
development.

These documents are essential for the successful disbursement of financing and the transparent management of
the property development project.

3.4.4 Control Mechanism in Real Estate Development

Throughout the duration of the loan, a control mechanism is typically established to oversee the progress of real
estate development and the utilization of funds provided to the borrower at various intervals. This mechanism
involves the engagement of independent technicians, appointed by the borrower and in accordance with the bank’s
preferences. These technicians include:

1. Project Monitor: Responsible for verifying the project’s proper progression from an administrative and
accounting perspective, ensuring adherence to financial parameters.
2. Appraiser: Conducts periodic valuations of the asset’s value, including assessments for compliance with
specified financial parameters.

3. Construction Manager: Certifies the progress of work and its relative completion status, providing timely
updates on the construction phases.

The documentation generated by these professionals may serve various purposes, including meeting disclosure
requirements on the part of the borrower and serving as conditions precedent for the disbursement of drawdowns
under the development line.

3.4.5 Mandatory Early Repayment and VAT Line of Credit

Failure to complete the development within the specified timeframe, delays in project commencement, or the
imposition of measures causing a significant halt in construction typically constitute mandatory early repayment
events of the loan or provide grounds for termination by the bank, among other potential triggers.
Regarding a Value-Added Tax (VAT) line of credit, repayment is usually anticipated to be sourced from the
VAT credits accrued and received by the borrower, as specified within a mandatory early repayment provision.

34
3.4.6 Mandatory Partial Early Repayments
Mandatory partial early repayments can also be triggered by various factors, including acts of disposition affecting
the property and pathological events like destruction or perishing.
Regarding acts of disposition, the rules differ depending on whether the financing is associated with a single
asset or multiple assets:

• Single Asset or Real Estate Portfolio as a Unit: In this case, any act of disposition affecting the
property will result in full repayment of the financing.
• Multiple Assets or Assets with Multiple Portions: If the financing is related to multiple assets or assets
with multiple portions, the act of disposition of an asset or portion thereof will lead to a partial repayment
of the loan. This partial repayment is generally calculated as the greater of (i) the allocated loan amount for
the disposed asset or portion, or (ii) the net sales proceeds obtained from the disposition.

Additionally, there may be provisions for mandatory partial early repayment of amounts received as down
payments.

3.4.7 Key Contractual Provisions in Real Estate Financing

Several crucial contractual provisions are typically included in real estate financing agreements, with a focus on risk
mitigation and financial management. These provisions encompass:

• Insurance Requirements: Mandating the borrower to maintain adequate insurance coverage to safeguard
against property destruction, damage, or income loss due to property use.
• Utilization of Insurance Claims: Defining how insurance claims collected by the borrower should be used,
often governed by mandatory prepayment clauses that determine whether the insurance proceeds are to be
directed toward loan repayment.
• Control of Cash Flows: Regulating the flow of the company’s financial resources into current accounts
pledged in favor of the lender banks, facilitating financial management and oversight.

3.4.8 Preliminary Activities in Property Acquisition Financing

Financing for property acquisition typically involves a single line of credit, with the possibility of a separate Value-
Added Tax (VAT) line for a specific component of the acquisition price. In addition to the preliminary activities
mentioned in the context of development financing, the following aspects are particularly pertinent in property
acquisition financing:

• Due Diligence on Leases: This entails a thorough examination of the leases associated with the asset
to be acquired. It aims to uncover any restrictions on property ownership transfer, such as pre-emption
rights or prohibitions on assignment as collateral. Additionally, it assesses provisions related to withdrawal
or non-market rents, which can significantly impact the financial aspects of the acquisition.
• Due Diligence on Rent Guarantees: This process involves a detailed evaluation of guarantees for rent
payment, including limitations on new beneficiaries and potential issues related to the maximum guaranteed
amount.
• Due Diligence on Required Authorizations: To ensure the seamless operation of activities within the
property, due diligence on the necessary authorizations and permits is essential. This step helps in identifying
and addressing potential legal and operational challenges.

3.4.9 Protection Provisions in Lease Analysis

When dealing with leases, which serve as the primary source of cash flows for financing repayment, it’s imperative
to scrutinize specific provisions for inclusion of appropriate safeguards in the financing agreement. These provisions
should cover:

• Tenant’s Waiver of Rights: Assess whether the tenant has committed to waiving any rights of first refusal
in the event of property transfer, which can facilitate the transaction.

35
 • Tenant’s Termination Rights: Examine the presence of contractual termination rights granted to the
tenant, understanding the circumstances under which the tenant can terminate the lease.
• Maintenance Responsibilities: Ensure there are clear regulations regarding routine and extraordinary
maintenance responsibilities and whether these costs are borne by the tenant.
• Rent Adjustments and Modifications: Evaluate provisions related to rent adjustments and modifications,
including elements like free rent periods, step rent increases, and capital expenditure (capex) contributions.
• Prohibitions on Assignment: Check for any prohibitions on the assignment of rent or the lease contract,
which can impact the lender’s ability to rely on the lease as a repayment source.
• Collateral for Rent Guarantees: Determine if there is collateral in place to guarantee rent payments,
which may include bank guarantees, security deposits, or corporate guarantees.

In the context of leases, it is imperative to incorporate provisions in the financing agreement to address the
following:

• Lease Satisfaction: If the existing leases are deemed satisfactory in their current wording, they may not be
subject to modification, or any modifications must not be detrimental to the interests of the lenders. This
safeguards the financial stability of the property and the lenders’ interests, preventing changes that could
negatively impact the repayment capacity.
• Lender-Friendly Lease Provisions: In the case of development finance contracts, it is vital to ensure that
leases, when signed, conform to the preferences and requirements of the lenders. These leases should include
provisions that align with the lenders’ interests and protect their investments.

3.4.10 Provisions for Early Tenant Termination

In the event of early termination by the tenant, the financing agreement should include several key provisions, such
as:

• Tenant Replacement: The requirement for prompt replacement of the departing tenant with a new tenant
of primary standing within a reasonable timeframe to ensure the continuity of cash flows supporting the
financing.
• Guarantees by Guarantors: The provision of suitable guarantees by guarantors of primary standing within
the same timeframe as the signing of the new lease, safeguarding the financial stability of the lease and the
interests of the lenders.
• Maintaining Contractual Terms: The commitment to maintain the same contractual terms and condi-
tions with the new tenant as were in place with the previous tenant, ensuring the stability of the financing
arrangement.
• Loan Repayment Obligation: A stipulation regarding an obligation to repay the loan early if the tenant
has not been replaced within the agreed-upon terms. The extent of the repayment obligation may cover all
or part of the financing, depending on the presence of a single tenant or multiple tenants.

3.4.11 Collateral and Personal Guarantees in Real Estate Financing

Both acquisition and development financing may trigger several common mandatory early repayment events, in-
cluding acts of property disposition, insurance damages, indemnities, and VAT line repayment.
Additionally, the following events are applicable to both types of loans:

• Change of Control of the Borrower: A change in control of the borrower or, for real estate fund financing,
a change in the SGR, can trigger an early repayment event.
• Indemnifications from Contracts: Early repayment events may arise from indemnifications related to
acquisition contracts or due diligence reports.

36
 Real estate financing typically benefits from an extensive package of collateral and personal guarantees, which
may include:

• Mortgage on the assets, extendable to properties constructed during development.

• Assignment as collateral for claims from various contracts, including acquisition contracts, due diligence
reports, insurance indemnities, development contracts, leases, and related personal guarantees.
• Lien on the borrower’s current accounts to secure the lender’s interests.

• Pledge on the borrower’s share capital, providing an interest in ownership.

• Lien appendix on insurance policies associated with financed properties.
• Personal guarantees, if any, granted by the borrower’s partner, further enhancing the lender’s security.

37
Chapter 4

Valuation Process

4.1 Overview
The Valuation Assignment
• Opinion of Value: This type of valuation is typically conducted by landlords and investors, with the objective
of determining the property’s current market value. It is primarily used in scenarios involving property disposal
and acquisitions, aiding property owners and investors in making informed decisions regarding the purchase,
sale, or management of real estate assets. An opinion of value takes into account the property’s location,
physical condition, comparable sales data, and market trends to establish an estimate of its worth in the
current market.
• Formal Valuation: Formal valuation is a comprehensive and legally robust assessment performed by ac-
credited professionals. This type of valuation is typically required by the court, financial institutions, real
estate funds, and other stakeholders for a range of purposes. It serves crucial roles in legal processes, such as
property disputes and litigation, and is often a prerequisite for securing financing. Additionally, it is used for
preparing financial statements, ensuring that property values are accurately reflected in financial reporting.
Formal valuation involves a rigorous approach, employing recognized valuation methods and standards. It is
conducted by certified appraisers or valuation experts and provides a precise, well-documented estimate of a
property’s value.

In Italy, the execution of the valuation assignment is relatively flexible in terms of who can perform it, with the
general practice being that it is often carried out by a chartered architect or engineer. However, there are exceptions
and specific requirements, depending on the context and the parties involved. These include:

• Real Estate Fund: Esperto Indipendente (Independent Expert):

1. For Natural Persons: This role can be assumed by individuals who are architects, engineers, or surveyors
and have been registered in their respective professional bodies for at least five years.
2. For Legal Entities: To qualify, a legal entity must have the valuation purpose explicitly included in its
business objectives.
• Court: Chartered ”CTU” (Consulente Tecnico d’Ufficio): Valuation assignments required by the court are
typically entrusted to chartered experts known as ”CTU.” These experts are appointed by the court to provide
objective and professional assessments in legal proceedings.

On an international level, there is an alternative standard recognized for individuals who can perform valuation
assignments. MRICS - Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors): Members of the Royal Institution of Chartered
Surveyors (MRICS) are also considered qualified to carry out valuation assignments. The MRICS designation is an
international standard that ensures a high level of professionalism and expertise in the field of property valuation.

38
Types of Valuation
• Opinion of Value: It offers flexibility in reporting, allowing tailored content to suit client preferences. It may
incorporate special assumptions for specific analyses, but competence, objectivity, and transparency remain
obligatory. Unlike formal valuations, it carries fewer legal obligations for the valuator, reducing liability
but placing greater responsibility on the client. In cases of market uncertainty, an Opinion of Value can be
expressed as a range, acknowledging variability and offering a more realistic view of potential property value.
• Formal Valuation: It adheres to strict guidelines, such as ”The Red Book,” ensuring standardized, com-
prehensive reports. It follows mandatory rules and ethical standards, often set by organizations like RICS.
Special assumptions beyond current property value may be considered. Like an Opinion of Value, competence,
objectivity, and transparency are mandatory. Valuators have a legal duty to provide reliable valuations, with
a strong focus on client accountability and informed decision-making.

RICS
RICS, or the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, is a globally renowned professional body for chartered
surveyors with a rich history and a vital role in the real estate and construction industry. It was established in
London in 1868 and is the world’s largest professional body for chartered surveyors, with a substantial international
presence. It is dedicated to maintaining and promoting the highest professional qualifications and standards in
various fields related to land, real estate, construction, and infrastructure.
RICS is responsible for accrediting and overseeing approximately 125,000 qualified and trainee professionals
worldwide, ensuring that they meet rigorous standards of competence and ethical conduct. In Italy, RICS has
experienced significant growth, accrediting more than 470 members. This represents an impressive increase of over
80% in the past nine years, indicating the organization’s influence and recognition in the Italian real estate and
construction sector.

Roles and Functions:

• Professional Qualifications and Standards: RICS plays a crucial role in establishing and enforcing
the highest professional qualifications and standards within the fields of land, real estate, construction, and
infrastructure. It ensures that its members adhere to these standards, promoting professionalism and ethical
conduct.

• The Red Book: One of RICS’s notable contributions is the issuance of the ”RICS Valuation - Professional
Standards,” commonly known as ”The Red Book.” This document, first published in 1974, contains mandatory
rules, best practice guidance, and associated commentary. It serves as a comprehensive guide for all RICS
members involved in asset valuations. The Red Book sets the benchmark for conducting valuations and is
widely respected in the industry for its adherence to rigorous and transparent standards.

- Impose Mandatory Obligations that encompass:

Competence: Ensuring that valuers are suitably trained, qualified, and possess adequate experience
for the specific task.
Objectivity and Transparency: Promoting independence, objectivity, and transparency in the val-
uer’s approach, contributing to consistency in valuation methods and practices.
- Establish a Framework for Uniformity and Best Practice, with a focus on:
Clarity in Engagement: Defining clear terms of engagement between the valuer and the client.
Basis of Value: Providing clarity regarding the basis of value, including any assumptions or consider-
ations to be factored into the valuation process.
Reporting Clarity: Ensuring clear and comprehensive reporting, making valuations more understand-
able and accessible.
- Comply with RICS Rules of Conduct: The standards set by the Red Book align with and comply
with the Rules of Conduct established by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS), reinforcing
the importance of professional ethics and conduct in the valuation profession.

39
4.2 The Valuation Process
4.2.1 Step 1 - Terms Of Engagement
The terms of engagement in a valuation process are critical for establishing clear expectations and understanding
between the valuer and the client. They encompass key elements like the valuer’s identity, client information, asset
details, valuation currency, purpose, basis of value, valuation date, data sources, assumptions, report format, usage
restrictions, fee calculation, and liability limitations. These terms ensure that the valuation process aligns with the
client’s needs and objectives and sets the framework for a transparent and effective valuation.

4.2.2 Step 2 - Inspections and Investigations

An inspection in the context of real estate and property evaluation typically consists of the following key components:
• Site Inspection:
- Analysis of the Context: This involves assessing the location of the property, its accessibility, visibility,
and the surrounding environment, which can impact its value.
- Analysis of the Property: This includes evaluating the property’s uses, dimensions, age, construction
type, the nature of buildings or structures, the condition of plant and equipment, and overall state of
repair. This analysis provides critical information about the physical attributes of the property.
• Collection of Documents: Gathering various types of documentation, including urbanistic (related to zon-
ing and land use regulations), cadastral (pertaining to property boundaries and ownership), contractual (such
as lease agreements or contracts related to the property), and other relevant documents. This documentation
is essential for a comprehensive evaluation.
• On-Site Market Analysis: Assessing the market dynamics directly on-site. This involves the examination
of comparable properties (comparables), an analysis of demand and supply in the local real estate market,
and an evaluation of the competition. Understanding the local market conditions is vital for accurately
determining the property’s value.
In a property inspection and evaluation, the following data and documents are investigated to gather com-
prehensive information about the property:

- Characteristics of the Context: Assess the availability of communications, services, and facilities in the
surrounding area, as they can influence the property’s appeal and value.
- Characteristics of the Property and Its Use: Analyze the property’s size, use, age, construction type,
and the nature of its buildings or structures. This information is fundamental in understanding the physical
attributes of the property.
- Characteristics of the Site: Identify any natural hazards, such as ground instability, mining activities,
mineral extraction, and flood risks from various sources (including rainfall and rivers) that may affect the
property.

- Market Analysis Based on Historical Data: Examine historical market data to understand factors like
competition, vacancy rates, ongoing or upcoming development projects, property take-up, and comparable
properties. This analysis provides insights into the local real estate market’s dynamics.
- Potential for Development or Redevelopment: Review town planning regulations and any physical
constraints that may impact further development or redevelopment of the property. This helps assess its
future potential.
- Leasing Contracts: Study existing leasing contracts to understand their type, remaining duration, tenant
outlook, and any special provisions like break options. This data is crucial for evaluating the property’s
income potential.

- Service Charges Paid by Tenants: Collect information about the service charges paid by tenants. This in-
cludes fees for services like maintenance, security, and utilities. These charges affect the property’s operational
costs.

40
4.2.3 Step 3 - Valuation
Market Approach
The Market Approach, specifically the Comparable Transactions Method, is a valuation technique used to
estimate the value of an asset by comparing it to similar assets for which price information is available. The Market
Approach involves comparing the subject asset with identical or comparable assets to derive an indication of value.
It is a common approach in property valuation, especially when there is relevant market data available.

Many assets are heterogeneous, making it difficult to find identical or closely comparable assets in the market.
Even when the Market Approach isn’t the primary method used, market-based inputs (e.g., effective yields and
rates of return) should be maximized. When direct comparisons aren’t possible, valuers perform a comparative
analysis, both qualitatively and quantitatively, between the subject asset and comparable assets.The Market Ap-
proach often utilizes market multiples derived from a set of comparable assets, each with different multiples.

Comparable Transactions Method: This method involves analyzing transactions of assets similar to the
subject property. Steps in this method include analyzing the units of comparison, identifying at least 3 to 4
comparable transactions with similar characteristics, standardizing the data, and making adjustments to account
for differences between the subject asset and the comparables.

• Pros: Recommended for standard and homogeneous assets where market conditions play a significant role.

• Cons: Challenges in selecting comparable transactions, especially when assets are highly heterogeneous,
which can limit the number of available comparables.

Cost Approach
The Cost Approach is a valuation method that provides an indication of value based on the economic principle that
a buyer will not pay more for an asset than the cost to obtain an asset of equal utility. This approach calculates the
current replacement or reconstruction cost of an asset and makes deductions for physical deterioration and various
forms of obsolescence. It is used when there is no evidence of transaction prices for similar properties or when no
identifiable income stream is available.

Reconstruction Cost Method: In this method, the asset’s value is determined by the sum of the land value, the
replacement cost of the asset (comprising direct and indirect costs, financial expenses, etc.), and depreciation factors.
These factors include physical depreciation, economic obsolescence, and functional depreciation or obsolescence.
• Principle of Substitution: The approach is based on the principle of substitution, where no rational
individual would pay more for an asset than the sum of the land value and the building costs. In conclusion, the
Cost Approach involves estimating the value of the property as the land value plus the adjusted construction
cost, accounting for any necessary refurbishment expenses to ensure the property’s utility is comparable to
that of a new building.

• Pros:
1. Recommended when there is no evidence of transaction prices or no identifiable income stream.
2. Suitable for unique properties or for insurance purposes to define the value of a new building.

• Cons:
1. Market value cannot be determined using this method.
2. Operational challenges may arise, such as defining the land value and estimating depreciation.

Residual Method: The Residual Method is typically applied to vacant properties needing conversion or refur-
bishment and land intended for development. It calculates the property’s value as the difference between the Gross
Development Value and the sum of refurbishment costs, including construction costs, professional fees, urbanization
costs, financial and agency expenses, and the developer’s profit.

41
 • Steps:
1. Define the type of building and the land transformation rate.
2. Estimate the market selling price of the asset.
3. Deduct specific costs, including construction and refurbishment expenses, planning fees, technical charges,
relief events, financial expenses, and the developer’s profit.

This method is particularly relevant for properties undergoing development or transformation.

Overall, the Cost Approach, including the Reconstruction and Residual Methods, is a valuable approach in
property valuation, especially when other approaches, such as the income or market approaches, are not applicable
or sufficient to determine the property’s value.

Income Approach
The Income Approach is a valuation method that estimates the value of an asset by converting its future cash flows
into a single present value. It is based on the premise that investors expect a return on their investments, which
should reflect the perceived level of risk associated with the investment. The Income Approach is implemented
through two primary methods:

• Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Method: In this method, projected cash flows are discounted back to the
valuation date, resulting in a present value for the asset. Key steps in the DCF method include selecting the
appropriate type of cash flow, determining the explicit forecast period (if any), preparing cash flow forecasts,
considering the appropriateness of a terminal value, determining the discount rate, and applying the discount
rate to the forecasted future cash flows. The ideal Scenarios of use are: Partially leased properties, Multi-
tenancy properties, Properties with rents above or below the market level and Properties requiring refurbishment
works with associated capital expenditures (CAPEX)

• Direct Capitalization Method: This method is employed when the asset is operating at a stabilized level
of growth and profitability at the valuation date. It often relies solely on a terminal value for the basis of
the valuation. The direct capitalization method is suitable for fully leased properties with stabilized rental
income over the long term. It is based on the capitalization of rental income using a capitalization rate, often
derived from the comparable transactions method. The ideal Scenarios of use are: Fully leased properties,
Single-tenancy properties, Properties with rents at the market level and Properties with stabilized rental income
over the holding period

In the DCF method, total net cash flows are projected over a specific holding period, which includes factors
like rental income, non-recoverable expenses (operating expenses), other costs (e.g., capital expenditures, tenant
incentives), and a projected sale value at the end of the cash flow period. The resulting cash flow is then discounted
back to the valuation date using an appropriate discount rate based on rates of return available from alternative
investments of similar type and quality.
The direct capitalization method is based on the capitalization of rental income at a specified cap rate, with the
reference rent typically being the gross rental income obtained from lease contracts.
In summary, the Income Approach is used to estimate the value of an asset based on its potential income or
cash flows, taking into account factors such as risk, cash flow projections, and terminal values. The specific method
chosen depends on the characteristics of the asset and its market conditions.

42
Chapter 5

Asset Management and Real Estate

Services

5.1 Real Estate Services

Real Estate Services encompass a range of activities and professional services to cater to various aspects of the real
estate industry.
• Advisory: This service provides consulting and guidance to investors involved in complex or large-scale real
estate operations. It assists investors who may not have the expertise or resources to manage every aspect of
the deal independently.
• Appraisal & Valuation: Activities under this service involve determining the value of property assets.
Typically, the focus is on market value, although the valuation may vary based on the evaluation’s purpose
and the type of property being assessed.
• Asset Management: Asset management services involve a series of coordinated activities and professional
services aimed at maximizing the value and/or income generated by a real estate portfolio or property.
• Property Management: This service entails the economic, administrative, and technical management
of real estate assets. The primary goal is to monitor profitability and plan activities to optimize property
operations.

• Building Management: Building management focuses on the coordination, management, and control of
technical and operational activities related to buildings and their systems. The aim is to maintain efficiency,
value, and compliance with legal regulations.
• Due Diligence: Due diligence services involve a thorough physical and documentary analysis of proper-
ties. The purpose is to identify and highlight any non-conforming aspects related to the property’s legal,
administrative, and technical status, which may require regularization or upgrading.
• Energy and Environment (Energy Management): This service combines technological and economic
expertise to guide decision-making in the realm of energy and environmental sustainability within real estate.
It acts as a bridge between investor needs and specialized real estate professionals, ensuring consistency in
resource allocation and results in energy-related technologies and infrastructure.

5.2 Asset Management

Asset Management involves a series of activities and coordinated professional services aimed at optimizing the value
and income generated by a real estate portfolio or investment property.
Asset Management follows a dynamic model that encompasses the management of assets from their acquisition
to eventual sale. It involves a wide range of skills, including analyzing investments holistically, devising marketing
strategies, projecting cash flows, structuring financial plans, evaluating sustainable leverage, and implementing
project management practices, including contract control systems.

43
Primary Task: The main responsibility of the asset manager is to ensure continuity in income generation while
coordinating with property managers and building managers. This task involves managing property activities to
maintain consistent returns.

Key Processes/Activities in Asset Management:

• Purchase of Property: This phase involves acquiring real estate assets to add to the portfolio.
• Value Maximization During the Investment Period: During this period, the focus is on maximizing
the value and income generated by the portfolio. This may include property improvement, optimization of
cash flows, and other strategies.
• Sale of the Property: When the time is right, the asset manager looks for opportunities to sell properties
in a manner consistent with an exit strategy that maximizes the captured value.
In essence, Asset Management is a comprehensive and dynamic approach to managing real estate portfolios and
investment properties, ensuring that they generate optimal returns throughout their lifecycle, from acquisition to
eventual divestment.

5.3 Real Estate Asset Management

Real Estate Asset Management is a comprehensive process that encompasses the activities of acquiring, managing,
and selling real estate assets.
Real estate asset management is the culmination of three primary processes: acquisition, management, and sale
of real estate assets. While the acquisition phase is typically handled by investment managers, real estate asset
management, in a more precise sense, excludes the purchase process and focuses on the remaining tasks related to
the management and sale of real estate assets.
Real estate asset management encompasses all activities from the acquisition phase (excluded) to the sale of the
property (included). These activities are strategically designed to maximize returns and minimize investment risks.
The asset manager collaborates with various professionals to execute these activities effectively:
• Property Manager: Responsible for the daily management of the property, including rent collection, to
meet the Net Operating Income (NOI) targets set by the asset manager.

• Project Manager: Manages property renovation and modernization projects, ensuring that cost and timing
parameters, defined by the asset manager, are met.
• Leasing Agent: Engaged in marketing rentable space based on price and tenant quality parameters, espe-
cially focusing on credit quality, as determined by the asset manager.

Real estate asset management involves a coordinated effort to enhance the performance and value of the portfolio.
The asset manager collaborates with a team of professionals to achieve the strategic goals established for the assets
in their care.

5.3.1 The Asset Management Plan

Asset Management Plan typically consists of three distinct phases:

1. Asset Analysis and Planning: This initial phase involves a comprehensive analysis of the property or
portfolio to assess its potential, opportunities, risks, and weaknesses. The goal is to formulate a strategy that
maximizes the asset’s value. Several types of analysis are commonly used, often simultaneously:
- SWOT Analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats): Identifies the internal strengths
and weaknesses of the asset as well as external opportunities and threats in the market.
- Hold/Sale Analysis: Similar to SWOT but with a primary focus on determining the optimal time for
selling the asset.
- Highest and Best Use Analysis: Seeks to identify the most profitable use of the property through
cost/benefit analysis, considering opportunities for repositioning and changing its use.

44
 The plan details various aspects, including: Objectives in terms of Net Operating Income (NOI), Costs and
timing for any redevelopment or renovation projects, Marketing plan, Exit strategy, including the anticipated
exit value.
2. Implementation of the Plan: In this phase, the strategies and actions outlined in the asset management
plan are put into action. This may involve executing redevelopment or renovation projects, marketing the
property, and following the exit strategy.
3. Testing and Measuring the Results and Variances: Continual monitoring is essential to gauge the
performance of the investment. This phase involves comparing actual results to budgeted values and un-
derstanding the reasons behind any deviations to make informed corrective actions. Specific areas of focus
include: Performance in terms of Net Operating Income (NOI) and real Internal Rate of Return (IRR) com-
pared to target values. Actual project costs compared to estimates outlined in the plan. Market values of the
property, relative to the agreed plan.

5.3.2 The Property Management Plan

The Property Management Plan is a pivotal document that forms the basis for the property manager’s actions. It is
formulated in alignment with the strategic directives set by the asset manager and encompasses operational elements
aimed at achieving specific objectives. The Property Management Plan is developed in accordance with the strategic
guidelines provided by the asset manager. It serves as a roadmap for operational activities at the property level.
The plan contains detailed guidance on day-to-day operations, maintenance, and tenant management necessary to
achieve the defined objectives.

Role of the Property Manager: The role of the property manager is of significant importance. They
possess in-depth knowledge of individual properties within the portfolio, maintenance requirements, and related
information. This knowledge is crucial for various aspects, including:
1. Tenant Retention: The property manager’s familiarity with tenants’ needs and characteristics is essential for
negotiating lease renewals effectively.

2. Operating Expense Optimization: Their understanding of cost determinants, service providers, and quality
enables them to optimize operating expenses.
3. Maximization of Net Operating Income (NOI): Property managers contribute to the strategy to enhance NOI.
4. Planning Extraordinary Maintenance: Through regular assessments of building conditions, property managers
can plan and choose maintenance actions that maximize long-term value.
In the past, the role of the property manager was often seen as purely administrative with limited added value.
However, in the present real estate landscape, property managers play pivotal roles throughout the real estate cycle:
• Acquisition Phase: Involved in due diligence and supporting the acquisition process.

• Active Asset Management Phase: Responsible for a wide array of administrative, documentation, legal,
and technical tasks.
• Strategic Management Phase: Assists the asset manager in activities aimed at increasing profitability,
enhancing property value, and reducing costs.
• Sales Stage: Provides support for the entire sales process, including facilitating the buyer’s due diligence.

The property manager’s role has evolved to become more strategic and integral to real estate operations, with
a focus on value creation and tenant satisfaction.

45
5.3.3 Property Management and Fund
In the late ’90s, the real estate market began a significant transformation, driven by factors like the ”Finanziariz-
zazione” of real estate and the adoption of the euro as a single currency. This transformation led to a surge in
real estate properties being put on the market by various entities such as industrial companies, banks, insurance
companies, and government agencies. The reasons for this included policies aimed at reducing deficits and public
debt to align with the criteria established in the Maastricht Treaty. This changing landscape necessitated more
efficient and transparent property management, particularly to cater to the requirements of international investors
who were increasingly investing in Italian real estate.
The shift in the market dynamics and the rise of real estate funds played a crucial role in the growth of property
management as a business. Several factors contributed to this growth:

• Professionalism: Property management companies had to meet higher standards, adhering to the best
international practices. They had to comply with regulatory and reporting standards set by entities like
Consob, the Bank of Italy, and custodian banks. This was in response to the demands of foreign investors.
• Operational Focus: Property management became more focused on efficient operational management. Real
estate funds typically have medium- to long-term investment horizons (10, 15, or even 30 years), allowing for
the creation of value through careful asset management. This included cost minimization and property
improvements, making property management a value-added activity.
• Certification of Managed Values: Property management companies took on a role as ”certifiers” of
managed values. They gained prominence in relation to asset managers and were entrusted with a wide range
of portfolio management activities.

• Expanded Scope: Property management activities expanded to encompass various functions, including
participation in the due diligence process.

5.3.4 The Marketing Plan

The marketing plan is a strategic document that is formulated based on the objectives outlined in the asset man-
agement plan. It is designed to achieve specific goals, which can include:
• Leasing of Real Estate: This aspect of the marketing plan is focused on activities related to tenant retention
and attracting new tenants. It aims to maximize the property’s rental income and occupancy rate.

• Sale of Properties: In cases where the goal is to divest or sell the real estate assets, the marketing plan is
centered around the sale of these properties. It aims to attract potential buyers and facilitate the successful
sale of the assets.
Depending on the specific objectives, the marketing plan may involve different key figures:
1. Leasing Agent: If the primary goal is to enhance rental income through leasing activities, a leasing agent
is typically involved. Their role is to work on tenant retention strategies and attracting new tenants to the
property.
2. Sales Agent: When the objective is to sell the real estate assets, a sales agent is engaged. This individual or
team is responsible for marketing the properties to potential buyers and managing the sales process.

The marketing plan plays a critical role in achieving the objectives outlined in the asset management plan,
whether it involves optimizing rental income or successfully selling properties. It outlines the strategies, tactics,
and resources required to execute these goals effectively.

46
Chapter 6

Taxation in Real Estate

6.1 Property Taxes in Different Jurisdiction

Figure 6.1

6.2 Why Taxation Matters

6.2.1 Characteristics and Taxation of Real Estate
Properties, often referred to as ”immovable,” possess distinct characteristics that set them apart:

• Ownership and Trackability: Real estate is characterized by its immovable nature, making ownership and
use easily trackable and measurable.

However, real estate also presents challenges and opportunities:

• Changing Value: Real estate holds significant value, which can fluctuate over time due to market dynamics.

• Non-Consumable: Properties are not subject to immediate consumption; instead, they can be used over
extended periods and can be ”circulated” or utilized in various ways.

47
 • Varied Ownership Purposes: Real estate may be owned for personal reasons, investment, or business
purposes, and can also be made available for use by third parties.

Furthermore, real estate has distinctive taxation characteristics:

• Taxability: Real estate is subject to taxation, and its tax treatment can have a substantial impact on
taxpayers’ financial accounts and the Treasury’s balance sheet.
• Recurring Taxation: Taxes can be levied multiple times during the property’s lifecycle, affecting different
parties and uses.
• Diverse Tax Rules: Tax rules must be applied differently based on the nature of the parties involved and
the specific use of the property.

The taxation of real estate demands careful planning at the policy level and plays a pivotal role in shaping
how properties are acquired, held, used, and transferred. It significantly influences the structuring of real estate
transactions.

6.3 Which and How Taxes Apply

Taxes can be classified in various ways. According to the OECD’s definition, property taxes encompass recurrent
and non-recurrent taxes on the use, ownership, or transfer of property. These taxes include those on immovable
property or net wealth, taxes related to changes in property ownership through inheritance or gifts, and taxes on
financial and capital transactions.
A general classification of taxes can be based on the reasons for their application:

• Income Taxes: These taxes are levied on recurrent revenues and capital gains. These are levied on lease
payments and capital gains, with deductions for allowable expenses such as depreciation and interest expenses.
Timing rules, exemptions, and limitations may apply.
• Indirect Taxes (or Transfer Taxes): These are imposed when ownership or rights to use properties are
transferred. They are calculated based on the value of properties transferred or leased, with the taxable base
subject to different rules and legal arrangements.
• Inheritance and Gift Taxes: These taxes are associated with the transfer of property through inheritance
or as gifts. They are imposed on the value of properties included in the estate of a deceased person or donated
or transferred without charge to a third party, whether an individual, charity, or trust.

• Wealth Taxes: These taxes are applicable based on the mere ownership of assets. So, they are applied based
on the value of properties owned.

6.4 Italian Properties Taxes

In Italy, property taxes encompass a range of taxes and rates:

- Personal Income Taxes (IRPEF): Applicable to individuals, with rates that can go up to 43%.
- Corporate Income Taxes (IRES): Imposed on corporate entities at a rate of 24%.
- Regional Tax on Productive Activities (IRAP): Generally levied at a rate of 3.9%.
- Local Surcharges: Additional charges imposed by local authorities.

- Flat Tax on Residential Leases (Cedolare Secca): A tax on residential lease income, with rates of 10%
or 21%.
- Registration Taxes (Registro): Levied on various property transactions, with rates going up to 9%.
- Mortgage and Cadastral Taxes (Ipotecaria e Catastale): Taxes related to property mortgages and
cadastral records, with rates going up to 4%.

48
 - Stamp Duty (Bollo): Taxes on various documents and transactions.
- Value Added Taxes (IVA): Applicable to goods and services, with rates that can go up to 22%.
- Imposte di Successione e Donazione: Taxes on inheritances and gifts, with rates of up to 8%.
- Local Taxes: These include IMU (Imposta Municipale Propria), TASI (Tributo per i Servizi Indivisibili),
and TARI (Tassa sui Rifiuti). They are related to municipal services and waste management.
- Tax on Properties Held Abroad (IVAFE): Taxes on properties owned abroad by Italian residents.

These taxes and rates can vary depending on the specific circumstances and location within Italy. Property
owners and investors need to be aware of these tax obligations when dealing with real estate in Italy.

Figure 6.2: Such taxes have a significant impact on structuring a real estate transactions

6.5 Key Phases of a Real Estate Transaction

1. Due Diligence & Valuation
2. Structuring (Business Plan, Legal and tax)
3. Drafting + Negotiations
4. Closing

5. Post Closing Activities/Implementation

49
6.6 Which Factors Affects Property Taxation
Several features typically influence the tax treatment of a transaction, and these are essential considerations for tax
advisors. Here’s a breakdown of what a tax advisor should ask:

1. Legal Context: Understanding the reason for the transfer and the legal arrangements the parties intend to
enter into, such as a sale agreement, lease, contribution of business, or fund investment.
2. Parties Involved: Gathering information about the number, tax status, tax residence, and type of activity
of the parties involved, including the seller, purchaser, lender, security provider, and others.
3. Type of Property: Identifying the type of property being transferred, whether it’s business property,
residential property, or any other classification.
4. Property Location: Determining the location of the property, which includes the country, region, and
municipality. Local tax regulations can vary significantly.
5. Accounting Treatment: Exploring the accounting treatment applied by the relevant parties, as this can
impact the tax implications of the transaction.
6. Financing Structure: Understanding the financing structure in place and any securities required by the
lender(s). This includes details about loans, mortgages, and collateral.
7. Other Relevant Elements: Considering other relevant factors, such as the property’s construction history
(e.g., when it was built), whether it has undergone refurbishment works in the last five years, and any other
aspects that could affect the tax treatment of the transaction.

By addressing these key elements, a tax advisor can provide comprehensive guidance and ensure that the tax
treatment of the transaction aligns with the specific circumstances and objectives of the parties involved.

6.7 Sale of a Commercial Property - Structuring Options and Exam-

ples
In the sale of a commercial property, there are various structuring options, and the tax treatment can vary depending
on the circumstances. Here are some examples of structuring options and their tax implications:

1. Seller is an Entity Subject to VAT - General Rule:

• VAT: Exempt
• Registration Tax: €200
• Mortgage and Cadastral Taxes: 3% + 1%
2. Seller is an Entity Subject to VAT - Option to VAT by the Seller:
• VAT: 22%
• Registration Tax: €200
• Mortgage and Cadastral Taxes: 3% + 1%
3. Seller is an Entity Not Subject to VAT - General Rule:
• VAT: Not Applicable
• Registration Tax: 9%
• Mortgage and Cadastral Taxes: €50 + €50

It’s important to note that there may be specific rules for sales carried out by construction or renovation
companies. The exercise of these options can depend on various factors, including the tax status of the seller and
the type of property being sold. The tax status of the purchaser can also be relevant in determining the most
suitable structuring option.
Tax advisors and legal experts should be consulted to ensure that the chosen structuring option aligns with the
specific circumstances of the transaction and complies with applicable tax regulations.

50
6.8 Structuring for Real Estate Funds - Favorable Tax Treatment
In the structuring of real estate funds (REFs) in Italy, there is favorable tax treatment for various aspects, including
the setup of the fund and the contribution of assets. Here’s a summary of the favorable tax treatment:

• Full Exemption from Income Taxes: Italian REFs enjoy a full exemption from income taxes, including
both IRES (Corporate Income Tax) and IRAP (Regional Tax on Productive Activities), on both current
income and capital gains generated by the fund.
• Withholding Tax on Distributions: There is a 26% withholding tax applied to distributions made by the
fund. This tax is typically deducted at the source.

• Exemptions for Qualifying Institutional Non-Resident Investors: Qualifying institutional non-resident

investors, such as international funds, banks, and insurance companies, may be eligible for exemptions and
favorable tax treatment when investing in Italian REFs. These investors are often white-listed.
• Favorable VAT Regime: Italian REFs may benefit from a favorable Value Added Tax (VAT) regime, which
can be advantageous for their operations and transactions.

• Reductions for Other Indirect Taxes: There may be reductions and favorable treatment for other indirect
taxes, such as registration tax, mortgage tax, and cadastral tax, which can reduce the overall tax burden
associated with real estate fund activities.

These favorable tax provisions aim to encourage investment in Italian real estate funds, attract institutional
investors, and stimulate the real estate market. It’s essential for those involved in setting up or investing in real
estate funds to be aware of these tax benefits and comply with the applicable regulations.

6.9 Property financing Highlights

In the context of loans, there are several key tax considerations to be aware of:

6.9.1 Structuring of the Loan

• Tranching (e.g., dedicated VAT facility)
• Nature of the parties and their residence
• Jurisdictions involved

6.9.2 Indirect Taxes on Loans and Guarantees

• No VAT on loans, but potential application of registration tax at 3% and VAT issues related to banking fees
• Theoretical high indirect taxes applicable to certain securities (e.g., mortgages)

• ”Substitutive tax” regime on medium/long-term loans, which is a 0.25% flat tax that replaces all other indirect
taxes

6.9.3 Income Taxes

• Withholding taxes on interest and fees paid to non-resident lenders
• Availability of exemptions for certain qualifying foreign lenders
• ”Gross up” clauses to ensure the lender receives the expected net payment

6.9.4 Reps & Warranties / Covenants

Ensuring that the transaction includes necessary representations, warranties, and covenants to protect all parties
involved.

51
6.9.5 The ”Circulation” of the Loan
Addressing the potential circulation of the loan from the original lender to third lenders or parties, which can impact
the overall transaction.
These key tax issues are fundamental in loan transactions and require careful consideration to ensure compliance
with tax regulations and the efficient structuring of the loan.

52
Chapter 7

Real Estate Actors - Investment Funds

Definition
A fund is an autonomous patrimony that does not have legal personality. It is characterized by the division into
shares of equal unit value and is intended for a plurality of subjects.

Main Features
The fund exhibits the following main features:
• Subdivision into shares

• Capital autonomy
• Collective management delegated to a professional financial intermediary
• Plurality of participants

Principal Subjects
The principal subjects involved in a fund typically include:

• Investors
• Fund
• SGR - Società di Gestione del Risparmio

• Depository Bank

7.1 SGR - Società di Gestione del Risparmio

SGR, or Società di Gestione del Risparmio, is a financial intermediary with essential roles and responsibilities within
the realm of investment and fund management. Its primary functions encompass the following areas:

7.1.1 Roles and Responsibilities

• Resource Collection: SGR plays a crucial role in collecting financial resources from savers and investors.
It acts as an intermediary through which individuals and entities can channel their investments into various
funds.
• Share Issuance and Placement: SGR is responsible for the issuance and placement of fund shares. It
manages the processes related to the creation of shares and their distribution to subscribers.
• Fund Asset Management: SGR undertakes the management of fund assets on behalf of the subscribers.
It is entrusted with the task of optimizing the performance and value of the funds it manages.

53
 • Fund Portfolio Management: SGR can manage not only the funds of its own institution but also funds
established by other companies. This capacity allows it to diversify and extend its portfolio management
services.

7.1.2 Key Objectives

SGR has several key objectives, including:

• Strategic Asset Allocation: SGR is responsible for the strategic distribution of fund assets among different
types of securities. This allocation is designed to achieve long-term objectives and optimize returns.
• Tactical Asset Allocation: SGR also engages in short-term asset allocation adjustments, adapting the
fund’s portfolio to capitalize on market conditions.
• Stock Picking: SGR employs technical and fundamental analysis to select specific securities for purchase or
sale within the fund’s portfolio.
• Market Timing: SGR assesses market conditions to determine the optimal times to buy, sell, or adjust the
weighting of assets in the portfolio.

7.1.3 Code of Conduct

In carrying out its responsibilities, SGR adheres to a set of principles and conducts its operations with diligence,
transparency, and fairness. It operates in the best interests of fund participants and upholds market integrity.
Additional elements of its conduct include:

• Conflict of Interest Mitigation: SGR endeavors to minimize the risk of conflicts of interest that could
compromise the fair and ethical management of funds.
• Participant Rights Protection: SGR takes appropriate measures to safeguard the rights of fund partici-
pants, ensuring that their interests are protected and respected throughout the investment process.

SGR’s pivotal role in fund management, along with its commitment to ethical conduct and investor protection,
contributes to the integrity and efficiency of financial markets.

7.2 Depositary Bank

The Depositary Bank is a critical entity in the world of fund management, entrusted with various responsibilities
and functions aimed at safeguarding the interests of fund participants. Here is a comprehensive overview of the
Depositary Bank’s role:

7.2.1 Roles and Responsibilities

• Custodian of Assets: The Depositary Bank serves as a financial intermediary responsible for holding and
safeguarding the financial instruments and cash reserves of a fund. It plays a pivotal role in the secure custody
of these assets.
• Issue and Redemption Oversight: One of the central responsibilities of the Depositary Bank is to ensure
the legitimacy of the issue and redemption of fund shares. This involves verifying that share issuances and
redemptions adhere to the fund’s governing rules and regulatory requirements.
• Verification of Share Values: The Depositary Bank plays a crucial role in ascertaining the correctness
of the value of the fund shares. It conducts rigorous assessments to verify the accuracy of share valuations,
contributing to transparency and investor confidence.

The Depositary Bank’s meticulous oversight and safeguarding of assets contribute to the overall integrity and
trustworthiness of fund operations.

54
7.3 Fund Types: Open and Closed
Funds come in two primary types, open and closed, each with distinct characteristics and implications for partici-
pants. Here’s a comprehensive explanation of these fund types:

7.3.1 Open Funds

Open funds offer participants the flexibility to subscribe to and redeem shares at any time. These funds do not
impose rigid redemption schedules, allowing investors to enter and exit the fund as per their preference. Key features
of open funds include:

• Flexibility: Participants have the right to subscribe to and redeem their shares whenever they choose.
• Continuous Accessibility: Investors can access their investments without waiting for predetermined dead-
lines.
• Variable Share Count: The number of shares in open funds can fluctuate based on participant activity.

7.3.2 Closed Funds (RE Funds)

Closed funds, on the other hand, provide participants with the right to redeem their shares only at specific,
predetermined deadlines. These funds are characterized by a fixed and unchanging number of shares over time.
Key features of closed funds, particularly in the context of Real Estate (RE Funds), include:

• Fixed Redemption Schedules: Participants can redeem their shares only at scheduled intervals, typically
with set deadlines.

• Invariable Share Count: Closed funds maintain a constant number of shares, which does not change over
time.

7.3.3 RE Fund Advantages

Real Estate (RE) Funds offer several advantages for investors:

• Diversification: RE Funds provide diversification by investing in a range of real estate assets, reducing
individual property risk.
• Small Investment (Share): Participants can invest in real estate with smaller sums by purchasing shares
of the fund.
• Professional Management: Funds are managed by professionals with expertise in real estate, optimizing
investments.
• Lower Interest Rate Sensitivity: RE Funds may be less sensitive to interest rate fluctuations than direct
property investments.
• Not Linked to Market Indices: They are not directly tied to market indices, offering a degree of indepen-
dence.

• More Liquid than Property: Shares in RE Funds tend to be more liquid than direct property investments,
offering easier entry and exit.

7.3.4 RE Fund Disadvantages

However, there are certain disadvantages associated with RE Funds:

• Less Liquid than Shares: Shares in RE Funds may be less liquid compared to traditional financial market
shares.
• High Sensitivity to Vacancy Rate: The performance of RE Funds can be significantly impacted by
changes in property vacancy rates.

55
 • More Difficulty in Portfolio Rebalancing: Rebalancing the portfolio of real estate assets in the fund may
present challenges.
• High Duration: RE Funds often have a longer investment horizon and may have a high duration.
• High Commissions: Management fees and commissions in RE Funds can be relatively high.

These characteristics and considerations help investors make informed decisions when choosing between open
and closed funds, and particularly when investing in Real Estate Funds.

Figure 7.1: First Phase

Figure 7.2: Second Phase

56
Chapter 8

Real Estate Leasing - Case Study: Alba

Leasing

8.1 Historical Trend of the Italian Leasing Market

The Italian leasing market exhibited a significant recovery since its lowest point in 2012, successfully regaining all
lost market share across various sectors:

• Real Estate
• Car
• Equipment

• Air/watercraft & Rolling stock

• Energy

Notable trends include the decline in market share for the real estate sector over the last 14 years. Conversely,
both the car and equipment markets surged, capturing over 75% of the total market share.

57
8.2 Benefits of Leasing
When considering leasing as a financial option, several compelling reasons stand out:
Extreme Contract Flexibility:
• Tailored solutions designed to meet specific needs.
• Continuous support from specialists throughout the entire process.
Enhanced Credit Capacity:
• The asset being leased does not reflect on the company’s balance sheet for the contract’s entire duration.
Impact on Company Debt Ratio:
• Leasing does not exacerbate the company’s debt ratio.
Amortization Period Comparisons:
• The typical amortization period for leased assets is approximately 12 years.
• In contrast, real estate acquired with a mortgage often involves a longer amortization period, roughly 20 to
30 years, with an annual rate around 3%.
Tax Benefits:
• Leasing installments are entirely deductible, while in a mortgage, only the interest is deductible.
• The substitute tax in leasing ranges from 0 to a maximum of 200 €, whereas in a mortgage, it stands at
0.25% of the total amount.

8.3 Alba Leasing Real Estate Products

Real Estate Leasing Under Construction
In this particular real estate leasing category, the property is yet to be constructed, leading to a structured act
divided into two phases:
• Land Acquisition: The procurement of the land.
• Construction of the Building: The development and construction phase.
It’s essential to consider that contracts of this nature incur additional costs in terms of time, notaries, and
consultants due to the nature of the project being in progress.

Real Estate Leasing Built

In the case of real estate leasing where the property is already constructed and prepared for sale, it’s noteworthy that
the buyer might request further modifications or additional work to adapt the property to their specific operational
needs.

8.4 How Alba Leasing Operates

The Stipulation Process it is divided in the following steps:
1. Collection
2. The Control by the Credit Office
3. Technical and Legal Investigation
4. Investigations Concluded with Positive Results
5. Deed
6. Stipulation

58
Collection:
During the initial phase of the leasing process, the sales representative, whether from Alba or a bank agent in the
case of Presto Leasing, meets with the potential client. This meeting involves aligning the client’s needs with the
available offerings, encompassing:
• Estimation of the initial property cost.
• Crafting the first financial plan.
• Consideration of any advance payment requirements.

Control by the Credit Office:

In the subsequent phase, the customer’s profile undergoes scrutiny by the credit office. This examination assesses the
creditworthiness of the client, analyzing risks associated with the spread and advance payment to ensure alignment
with the commercial estimate.

Technical and Legal Investigation:

Here, legal and technical experts come into play:
• Notary: Prepares a comprehensive report certifying the property’s status, ensuring it’s free from mortgages,
inheritance claims, and confirming its rightful ownership.
• Consultant: Evaluates the property to determine if the sales representative’s set price aligns with the actual
property value.

Investigation Concluded with Positive Results:

In the fourth phase, the credit department conducts a second-level verification of the contract. Once satisfied that
the data aligns with the client, they authorize the real estate office. This marks the signing of the contract, with
the client making the advance payment and covering contractual expenses.

Deed:
Moving to the fifth phase, the notarial deed phase occurs. This involves a tripartite agreement between the seller,
the leasing intermediary (ALBA), and the client, typically on the same day as phase four.

Stipulation:
The sixth and final phase involves the contract being processed by various departments at Alba, systematically
organizing all relevant contract data. This phase is primarily practical in nature.

8.5 Non-Performing Loans (NPLs)

Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) refer to loans where the borrower has stopped making payments or has significantly
breached the loan terms. This could involve not paying interest or principal for an extended period, typically around
90 days or more.
NPLs are problematic for both the lender and the borrower. For the lender, they represent assets that are
not generating the expected income and may be at risk of default. Financial institutions prefer their loans to be
performing to ensure a steady income stream and a healthier balance sheet.
The classification of a loan as non-performing varies across different jurisdictions and regulatory authorities.
Once a loan is classified as non-performing, financial institutions often take measures to manage or resolve these
loans. This could involve restructuring the loan terms, selling the debt to collection agencies, or writing off the loan
as a loss.
High levels of NPLs can have implications for a financial institution’s profitability and capital adequacy. For
the borrower, having a loan labeled as non-performing can impact their credit rating and result in financial and
legal consequences, including potential asset seizure and negative credit reporting.
Governments and regulatory bodies monitor the levels of NPLs within the financial system to understand the
overall health of banks and financial institutions, particularly during economic downturns or financial crises.

59
Chapter 9

Real Estate Business Plan

9.1 Introduction
A real estate business plan is a vital operational tool that systematically explains all the elements comprising
a managerial project. It is designed to facilitate planning, analysis, and the identification of potential issues while
assessing both qualitative and quantitative outcomes. Essentially, it is a comprehensive document summarizing the
key aspects of a project or activity along with its projections.

9.2 Aims of a Real Estate Business Plan

The real estate business plan aims to achieve several objectives:

1. Strategic Direction: Define the vision, goals, and objectives for a real estate venture, providing a clear
strategic direction for the business.
2. SWOT Analysis: Analyze the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats inherent in the real estate
project or company.
3. Financial Planning: Determine the financial requirements and the best structure to acquire financial re-
sources, such as loans or equity from investors.
4. Risk Assessment: Identify potential risks, challenges, and critical points that may arise during the project
and establish strategies to mitigate them.

5. New Initiatives: Propose innovative strategies, like joint ventures, mergers and acquisitions, or partnerships,
to stakeholders for further growth and development.

For what it concerns the addresses we distinguish:

Inside the Company: Outside the Company:

1. Launch of New Products 1. New Partnerships
2. New Investments 2. Recall Equity from Venture Capital

3. Raise a Bank Loan

60
9.3 Real Estate Business Plan Focus
A Real Estate Business Plan (BP) can be tailored to concentrate on various aspects within the real estate sector.
It can focus on:

• A single investment in a real estate asset or a portfolio of assets, particularly emphasizing:

– Lease-up of assets or portfolios

– Development, refurbishment, and subsequent disposal of real estate assets (which involves high-risk
activities)

In this industry, creating a business plan is crucial due to the multitude of risks involved, including:

• Development risk, such as timing and finding suitable building areas with associated development costs.
• Financial risk, which includes securing financing and managing financial costs.
• Administrative risk, for instance, obtaining building permits.

A comprehensive business plan aids in monitoring and managing these risks effectively.
Moreover, the business plan involves a sensitivity analysis, demonstrating the impact on key performance indi-
cators (KPIs) resulting from changes in critical factors like vacancy rates, interest rates, economic trends, prices,
rents, and capital expenditures (capex). The real estate business plan also manages specific features of the real
estate industry, such as real estate vehicles and funds, each governed by unique laws and fiscal issues.
Furthermore, the real estate business plan serves as a crucial tool for the banking system. It assesses the
guarantees underpinning real estate mortgages by analyzing their capacity to generate positive cash flows.

9.4 Index Classification

Typical Index of BP: Typical Index of RE BP:

I Executive summary I Executive summary

II General description of the company II Description of the real estate assets
III Products and services III Market analysis
IV Marketing plan IV Development project

V Operating plan V Investment estimation

VI Management and organization VI Management and organization
VII Financial plan (details) VII Financial plan (details)

I. Executive Summary
The executive summary acts as the introductory business card for a project. Its concise nature allows for a
swift understanding of the concept, capturing attention and stimulating immediate interest in other sections of the
Business Plan (BP). It’s a brief section that provides a summarization of background information, analysis, and
key conclusions. Notably:

• It serves as a decision-making aid for managers and is often considered the most crucial part of the BP.
• It is typically the section that everyone reads, often the only part for most readers.

61
 The executive summary should not:

• Merely replicate the short project description or details of the asset/product/service. This information is
covered in subsequent sections of the BP and should not be duplicated in the Executive Summary. Instead,
it presents an overarching view of the entire BP without delving deeply into details included elsewhere.
• Just function as an index of the BP. Instead, it should highlight the main issues of the document, briefly
emphasizing essential aspects like competitive advantages or standout features of the project/firm.
• Include excessive detail, as its purpose is to encourage the reader to explore the entire document.

• Solely present an overly optimistic viewpoint. An Investor/CEO can easily detect if only optimistic aspects
are highlighted, potentially affecting the credibility of the entire document.
• Be a copy-and-paste compilation of other sections. It should offer a condensed, comprehensive view rather
than being a duplicate of various parts of the document.

II. Description of the Real Estate Assets

In general, the description section of a real estate asset contains specific subjects, which typically include:

• Description of the location

• Description of the property’s conditions, encompassing physical characteristics and intended use

• Analysis of tenants and ownership

• Development plans
• Overview of main administrative regulations
• Any constraints, including urban, legal, and architectural limitations

Although each operation may have its distinct features, these key subjects are commonly included in the de-
scription section of a real estate asset.

III. Market Analysis

The market analysis is a crucial stage in real estate development and typically follows a top-down logic. It serves
as the starting point for the property’s development plan, catering to sector experts.
A comprehensive market analysis commonly includes the following key elements:

• Macro-economic features of the country and city where the property is situated.

• Real estate sector analysis categorized into segments.

• Analysis of nearby real estate, encompassing location, property types, sizes, uses, and rents.
• Examination of development plans for adjacent areas.

• Analysis of the property’s tenants, including their activities, occupied space, and contract types.

It’s essential to conduct a thorough study of the evolving disposal and rental average prices (€/sqm) in the area,
varying based on location and use. This section aids in understanding the market trend, detailing trade volumes
and the duration required to finalize transactions. A highly liquid market reduces the selling time and is less risky
for developers. A comprehensive market analysis provides insight into comparable properties, aiding in forming
reliable assumptions.
The real estate market is primarily local, so a macro-analysis might not offer a complete understanding. It’s
a parameter showing trend lines that will be tested in the specific market of interest. To comprehend the current
market and future trends, a detailed analysis should include:

62
 • Examination of ongoing development projects in local areas.
• Review of town planning (piano regolatore) provided by public administration.
• Scrutiny of administrative rules or planning tools that could affect the project’s appeal, such as new infras-
tructures or requalification plans of deteriorated areas.

An effective market analysis also includes an overview of the macro-economic financial trend. Notable empirical
studies indicate:

• A strong inverse correlation between interest rates and transaction volumes. For instance, lower interest rates
could result in a higher number of real estate transactions.

• A significant positive correlation between the efficiency of the mortgage market and transaction volumes,
which could potentially lead to extreme situations, as seen in the American housing market.

IV. Development Project

The development project section focuses on describing the specifics of a real estate development project, each
with its unique characteristics. Typically, this section includes the following details:

• The development strategy • Intended use purposes

• Areas designated for specific purposes
• Anticipated layout of the property (intended lay-
out) • Timeline for required work

The development strategy, a significant section of the Business Plan, enables potential investors to grasp the
project idea from its inception to completion. It is a critical phase from both technical and economic perspectives.
Key points related to the development strategy:

• Often a critical phase involving various technical and economic aspects.

• Administrative issues, such as delays in acquiring building permits, can negatively impact final returns by
affecting timing and resource costs (increase in raw material costs and salaries).
• Any delay in the development plan can impact the overall economic viability of the entire operation.
• Managing different potential risks that may arise is essential.

V. Investment Estimation
The feasibility analysis of an operation must incorporate an evaluation of costs required for the investment’s real-
ization. This assessment typically relies on estimates from various experts, including technicians, engineers, and
project managers. The accuracy of the cost estimation is contingent upon the level of detail in the project, with
higher detailing reducing associated risks.
Investment costs are generally divided into the following categories:

• Construction costs (hard costs)

• Engineering costs/project and design costs (soft costs)
• Unexpected or contingency costs

63
VI. Management and Organization
The project can be realized through either a startup company or an existing company. Depending on the situa-
tion, the management and organization section includes the company’s characteristics, financial and organizational
structure. This section should encompass:

• Description of the management team

• Managerial skills and expertise

• Organizational chart and responsibilities

• Brief job descriptions of departments (e.g., legal, finance, property, etc.)
• Information on Board of Directors (BOD) members

A high-skilled management team, recognized in the market and distinguished by a successful track record, brings
substantial value to the entire operation in terms of ”reputational capital.”

9.5 VII. Financial Plan

The financial plan serves several key purposes:

• Allowing investors to comprehend the potential return on capital and capital requirements.
• Enabling lenders to assess the project’s capacity to repay financial debts.

From multiple perspectives, the financial aspect is often the most adaptable section of the Business Plan.
Generally, it’s considered best practice for the Financial Plan template to maintain a standardized format.
The financial plan represents the quantitative section of the business plan and typically includes the following
sections:

• Assumptions • Expected cash flows

• Expected income statement (Profit & Loss)
• Expected balance sheet • Return indexes (e.g., IRR)

The initial assumptions in the financial plan are usually related to the timing of the deal, which depends on the
type of investment and the expected return by the investors.

9.5.1 Assumptions
1. General Assumptions
General assumptions regarding the project’s general data typically include:

• Inflation expectations
• Fiscal regime (taxes on profits, VAT, property taxes, amortization rates)
• Working capital trend (in terms of payable and receivable days)

• Exchange rate trend (if the project is located in a country with a currency different from the euro)
• Average cost of salaries for the firm
• Managerial organization of the project (e.g., for an SPV, numbers of employees, variations over time)

64
2. Investment Assumptions
Investment assumptions are detailed in the investment plan, covering the following information:
• The required investment amount (e.g., purchase price and development costs)
• Timing of the investment, including the acquisition date, development period, and sales date
Additionally, the amortization plan, based on general assumptions regarding amortization rates stipulated by
law, is included. Note that in the case of selling the property in the future, an amortization plan might not be
necessary.

3. Revenue Assumptions
Revenue sources generally consist of rental income and disposals and are influenced by several factors:
• Revenues are contingent upon the use destination and surface area.
• Assumptions for rental income rely on market comparables and lease agreements, including:
– Annual rental rates per Euro/square meter for different use destinations.
– Percentage of vacancy/occupancy space.
• Disposal revenues are derived from market comparables and trends.
• Other revenue categories may exist, such as accessory revenues (e.g., advertising), notably in Real Estate
Company scenarios.
The potential gross revenue can be calculated using the formula:
Potential Gross Revenue = Rentable Surface × Average Rent per Square Meter
− Vacancy Space + Potential Lease-up Space × Average Rent per Square Meter
Several considerations to note include:
• Accounting for potential gross revenues must consider vacancy rates and associated potential rents. Vacancy
levels often stem from tenant turnover and the time spent seeking new tenants.
• Additional revenues, particularly in the American market and mainly in commercial properties, may arise
from percentage rents (or overage), where owners participate in tenant revenues above certain levels.

4. Costs Assumptions
Cost assumptions encompass various expenses related to the project, including:

• Taxes on property • Safety-related costs

• Employee salaries • Facility management and property management
• Maintenance costs and routine interventions commissions

• Insurance premiums • Supplies

• Utility costs • Intermediation commissions

It’s essential to deeply comprehend key factors influencing cost variations, such as:
- Extraordinary events impacting costs (e.g., increased insurance costs post 9/11)
- Macroeconomic trends affecting costs (e.g., utility cost increases relative to inflation rates)
- Asset status (e.g., reduced utility costs with higher vacancy rates)
- Type of lease contract (single net lease, double net, or triple net), allowing owners to charge specific costs to
tenants, including maintenance costs of common areas (parks, lifts, security, etc.), and property taxes (IMU).
For real estate companies, IMU functions more as an operational cost than a real tax.

65
9.5.2 Expected Income Statement

(a) RE Company (b) RE Fund

9.5.3 Expected Balance Sheet

(a) RE Company (b) RE Fund

9.5.4 Sensitivity Analysis

The sensitivity analysis is crucial for presenting a realistic and feasible financial plan, providing insights into a wide
range of potential scenarios.
Key points about sensitivity analysis:

• It assesses how different values of an independent variable impact a particular dependent variable based on a
specific set of assumptions.
• A comprehensive sensitivity analysis not only involves changing inputs but also requires a deep understanding
of the interrelations between variables. Inputs can be strongly correlated; for example:

– Intermediation commissions are closely linked to the vacancy rate. Higher vacancy rates imply higher
commissions for the agency. This circumstance might lead to a preference for paying more rather than
leaving a vacancy.
– While some operational costs decrease with a general decrease in the vacancy rate (e.g., utilities), other
costs, such as insurance costs, remain unaffected by the occupancy rate.

66
9.5.5 Return Indexes
I. NPV
The Net Present Value (NPV) represents the current value of the sum of cash flows generated by a project’s
implementation.
Key points about NPV:

• Cash flows are discounted using a specific discount rate that reflects the project’s opportunity cost of capital,
typically the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC).
• NPV represents the excess profit, not the total profit, of a particular operation compared to its opportunity
cost. A project with a positive NPV indicates that it is generating value.
• NPV serves as a relative return index. To compare projects with varying invested capital, it’s advisable to
use NPV alongside other methods, such as the Internal Rate of Return (IRR).

II. IRR
The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is the rate that renders the Net Present Value (NPV) of expected cash
flows to zero.
Key points about IRR:

• IRR of an operation or project is compared to the opportunity cost of capital or hurdle rate to assess the
feasibility of the operation.
• IRR is utilized to compare operations with differing time periods and amounts.
• Mathematically, computing the IRR is challenging as it involves solving a polynomial equation through suc-
cessive interpolations. However, various tools like spreadsheets (e.g., Excel) enable immediate computation.
• A significant limitation of the IRR is its assumption that it’s possible to reinvest periodic cash flows at the
same rate as the IRR (assuming a flat yield curve). This might not always be feasible in practice.

III. ROE
Return on Equity (ROE), calculated as Net Income divided by equity, is a key profitability index specifically
relevant to shareholders.
Key points about ROE:

• ROE serves as an attractive index for shareholders and should ideally surpass the rate of return of alternative
investments to entice additional capital.
• It should never fall below the rate of return of risk-free investments.
• While a higher ROE is generally preferred in comparative analysis, caution is necessary when comparing
projects/firms that differ significantly.
• In a comparative context, it’s essential to consider that naturally, a firm with lower capital (e.g., advisory or
utilities) tends to have a higher average ROE compared to high-capital firms (e.g., oil companies), indicating
higher efficiency for the former.

IV. ROI
Return on Investment (ROI) elucidates the profitability of the invested capital within the firm, encompassing
both equity and debt.
Key points about ROI:

• ROI (Operative Income divided by net invested capital) assesses the profitability specifically within the core
business operations of the firm.
• It’s vital to compare ROI with the cost of debt. A positive spread between these two indicators (ROI ¿ cost
of debt) leads to a leverage effect, which in turn has a multiplier effect on Return on Equity (ROE).

67
 • ROI can be deconstructed into two components:
– ROS (Return on Sales): The ratio between operative income and sales.
– CT (Capital Turnover): Represents the rate of rotation of invested capital (sales revenues/invested
capital).

9.5.6 Relationship Between ROE and ROI

The Du Pont Formula explains the relationship between Return on Equity (ROE) and Return on Investment (ROI).

• Du Pont Formula:
     
OperativeIncome
– ROE = N etInvestmentCapital × ROI × N etInvestmentCapital
Equity × N etIncome
OperativeIncome =
N etIncome
Equity

– ROE = ROI × Leverage × Extra-Operating Costs

The Du Pont Formula elaborates how Return on Equity (ROE) is composed of Return on Investment (ROI),
leverage, and extra-operating costs.

9.5.7 Patrimonial Ratios

• Financial Autonomy Ratio (Long-term Debt/Equity): This ratio assesses the balance between inter-
nally and externally sourced financing. A ratio of zero indicates no debt. Standard values are typically at or
above 1, though in the real estate sector, higher values are admissible due to the industry’s ”real” nature.
• Debt Ratio (Third-party Resources/Net Invested Capital): This ratio measures the impact of debt
on invested capital. For a ”normal” firm, values higher than 0.5 might not be favorable. However, given the
real estate industry’s tendency to heavily utilize debt, values greater than 0.5 are acceptable in this sector.

68
Chapter 10

Real Estate Fund

10.1 Introduction
A fund represents an autonomous pool of assets lacking legal personality. It is delineated by the division into shares
of uniform unit value and is designed to serve multiple entities.

Main Features
— Subdivision into Shares: The fund is structured through shares of equal value.
— Capital Autonomy: It operates autonomously concerning its capital management.
— Collective Management by Professional Financial Intermediary: Management is delegated to a
professional financial intermediary.
— Multiplicity of Participants: The fund accommodates a diverse range of participants.

10.2 Principal Subjects:

• Investors: Individuals, organizations, or entities that allocate their financial resources into various assets or
investment vehicles with the expectation of generating returns or profits.
• Fund: An investment vehicle or pool of money/assets managed by professionals, typically structured as a
collective investment scheme, allowing multiple investors to combine their resources for diversified investment
purposes.
• SGR (Società di Gestione del Risparmio): An Italian term for a Fund Management Company (FMC)
responsible for managing and administrating investment funds. SGRs/FMCs handle fund operations, invest-
ment decisions, and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements.
• Depositary Bank: A financial institution entrusted with the safekeeping and custody of a fund’s assets. It
plays a crucial role in overseeing and verifying the fund’s transactions, ensuring compliance with regulations,
and protecting investors’ interests.

10.2.1 SGR (Società di Gestione del Risparmio)

An SGR, or Fund Management Company, undertakes several key responsibilities:

Primary Functions:
— Capital Accumulation: Gathers financial resources from savers/investors.
— Share Issuance and Placement: Facilitates the issuance and placement of shares.
— Asset Management for Subscribers: Manages fund assets in the interest of subscribers.
— Management Scope: Handles both its institution’s funds and those established by other companies.

69
Objectives (AIMS):
— Strategic Asset Allocation: Distributes assets across various security types.
— Tactical Asset Allocation: Adjusts short-term asset allocation.
— Stock Selection (Picking): Analyzes and chooses securities based on technical and fundamental analysis.

— Market Timing: Determines optimal times for buying, selling, or adjusting portfolio weights.

Code of Conduct:
— Operating Principles: Operates with diligence, transparency, and fairness in the interest of fund partici-
pants and market integrity.
— Conflict Management: Endeavors to minimize the risk of conflicts of interest.

— Participant Rights Protection: Takes appropriate measures to safeguard the rights of fund participants.

10.2.2 Depositary Bank:

The Depositary Bank functions as a crucial financial intermediary responsible for various aspects related to the
safekeeping and legitimacy of a fund’s operations. Its key responsibilities include:

• Safekeeping of Financial Instruments and Cash Reserves: Holding and safeguarding the financial
instruments and cash reserves belonging to a fund, ensuring their security and proper custody.
• Verification of Share Issuance and Redemption Legitimacy: Ensuring the legitimacy and accuracy
of the issuance and redemption of fund shares, validating these transactions to maintain compliance with
regulatory standards.

• Validation of Fund Share Values: Verifying and confirming the accuracy of the valuation of the fund
shares, ensuring that the declared values align with the actual market or asset valuations.

The Depositary Bank’s role is critical in upholding transparency, reliability, and regulatory compliance within
the fund’s operations. It acts as a custodian, verifier, and guardian of the fund’s assets and transactions, fostering
investor confidence and market integrity.

10.2.3 Fund Types:

Open Funds:
• Description: Open funds grant participants the right to subscribe to and redeem shares at any time.

Closed Funds:
• Description: Closed funds allow participants to redeem shares only at predetermined intervals. They main-
tain a fixed number of shares that remain constant over time.

70
10.3 Fund VS RE Fund
The primary difference between a ”fund” and a ”real estate fund” lies in their underlying assets and investment
focus.

Fund
A ”fund” is a broad term that refers to a pool of money or assets, which can encompass various investment
vehicles, such as mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), hedge funds, or other collective investment schemes.
Funds, in general, can invest in a wide array of asset classes, including stocks, bonds, commodities, and alternative
investments.

Real Estate Fund

On the other hand, a ”real estate fund” is a specialized type of fund that focuses specifically on real estate assets.
These funds invest primarily in real estate properties, including residential, commercial, industrial properties, or real
estate-related securities (such as Real Estate Investment Trusts - REITs). Real estate funds aim to generate returns
primarily through rental income, property appreciation, and potential capital gains from the sale of properties.

Key Differences:
• Underlying Assets: Funds can invest in various asset classes, while real estate funds concentrate solely on
real estate assets.
• Investment Focus: Funds have a broader investment focus, while real estate funds specifically target real
estate-related investments.
• Returns Generation: Funds may derive returns from diverse sources, whereas real estate funds focus on
rental income, property appreciation, and potential capital gains from real estate assets.
• Risk and Volatility: The risk profile and volatility of funds can vary significantly based on their diversified
portfolio, whereas real estate funds may be influenced by factors specific to the real estate market.

In essence, while a fund can encompass a range of investment types, a real estate fund is a specialized subset
that exclusively deals with real estate assets, aiming to capitalize on opportunities within the real estate market.

10.4 SIIQ (Società di Investimento Immobiliare Quotata)

SIIQ, which translates to ”Listed Real Estate Investment Company,” is a specific type of Italian real estate invest-
ment company with distinctive features:

• Listed Status: SIIQs are publicly listed on the Italian Stock Exchange, allowing investors to trade shares of
these companies.

• Real Estate Focus: SIIQs primarily invest in real estate assets such as residential, commercial, or industrial
properties.
• Tax Benefits: Enjoying favorable tax treatment, SIIQs must adhere to specific conditions related to asset
allocation and dividends distribution.

• Regulatory Compliance: SIIQs are subject to regulations concerning the composition of their asset port-
folios and profit distribution to shareholders.
• Investor Attraction: SIIQs can be appealing to investors seeking exposure to real estate markets while
benefiting from the liquidity and transparency of listed securities.

Overall, SIIQs provide a structured and regulated way for investors to access real estate investments through
listed companies, often offering potential benefits such as dividends, tax advantages, and portfolio diversification.

71
Chapter 11

Strategic Financial Real Estate

11.1 Characteristics of the Real Estate Market

In the realm of the real estate market, demand is represented by prospective buyers or renters, while the supply
side is shaped by property owners seeking to sell or lease their assets. Compared to other markets, the participation
of sellers and buyers in the real estate market is relatively limited, leading to lower liquidity, reduced transparency,
and a lack of standardization.
The real estate market is notably fragmented, lacking homogeneity, with its assets distinguished by unique
characteristics such as location, designated use, and pricing. Consequently, perfect substitutes are challenging to
find within this market.

One of the fundamental traits of the real estate market lies in its low standardization, limited liquidity, and
decreased transparency. This situation, compounded by asymmetric information, emanates from the multitude of
entities operating within the market and the absence of stringent regulations ensuring the reliability of rental and
sale prices.
Traditionally, the real estate market has been deemed one of the safest arenas for investment. However, partic-
ipation in real estate investment necessitated substantial capital outlay due to the acquisition of physical assets.

To address these challenges, financialization and securitization have emerged as pivotal strategies in mitigating
the limitations associated with low liquidity and transparency in the real estate market. Additionally, the concept
of project financing, originating in the United States during the 1990s, has contributed significantly to alleviating
these constraints.
The proliferation of these processes has stimulated the adoption of innovative financial instruments like invest-
ment funds and securitized securities, fostering a more dynamic and accessible real estate investment landscape.

11.2 The Life Cycle of the Real Estate Market

The real estate market operates in a continuous cycle, delineated by distinct phases that can vary across different
market sectors. Typically, four phases are discernible: recovery, expansion, oversupply, and recession. Transitions
between these phases are influenced by a combination of external (exogenous) and internal (endogenous) forces.
Various factors exert influence on the real estate market, including demographic shifts, fluctuations in interest
rates, overall economic conditions, and governmental policies.
As previously mentioned, the four phases in the real estate market encompass the recovery phase, expansion
phase, oversupply phase, and recession phase.

11.2.1 Recovery Phase:

This marks the inception of the cycle, characterized by an upsurge in demand surpassing available supply. Conse-
quently, vacancy rates decrease, prompting an escalation in both prices and rents. The phase witnesses a scarcity
of new constructions, leading real estate entities to contemplate the construction of fresh units.

72
11.2.2 Expansion Phase:
During this stage, the supply increases until the market attains equilibrium, resulting in a decline in vacancy rates.
Occasionally, the supply might outstrip demand, leading to a slowdown in rent growth and a reversal in vacancy
rate trends.

11.2.3 Oversupply Phase:

At the onset of this phase, the supply surges beyond demand, leading to inflated prices and an overpriced real
estate market. With diminishing buyers, property owners begin liquidating their assets at reduced prices, fearing
potential vacancies or unsold properties. Consequently, the phase witnesses a spike in vacancy rates.

11.2.4 Recession Phase:

In this phase, while the supply remains stable, demand dwindles, resulting in increased vacancy rates and plum-
meting prices. This represents the nadir of the real estate cycle. Savvy investors often seize the opportunity during
this phase to acquire high-quality properties at reduced prices, anticipating the market’s subsequent recovery.
Eventually, with a gradual rise in demand and stable supply, the economy cycles back to the initial phase.

Market Timing:
Timing is critical for successful real estate investments. Determining the market’s bottom, indicating the best time
to purchase, or identifying its peak, signaling the optimal time to sell, poses challenges.

Seller Motivation:
The motivation of sellers directly impacts property prices, influencing the market dynamics significantly.

Overall Understanding:
Comprehending the four market phases, discerning seller motivation, and gauging market timing are pivotal in
navigating the real estate landscape.
Real estate economic cycles vary based on the type of investment. Additionally, considering the specific city
and locality where an asset is situated is essential.

Regional Variances:
The European context reveals divergent situations across cities in different countries. Generally, cities within the
same country exhibit similar trends. However, exceptions like Milan, differing slightly from Rome’s situation,
emphasize localized variations.

11.3 Real Estate Market Segmentation

The real estate market, as previously discussed, stands out for the distinctive nature of its assets, leading to a lack of
substitutability among products or suppliers. Consequently, this market undergoes segmentation to accommodate
these unique characteristics.
The segmentation of the real estate market can be based on several factors, including:

• Location
• Condition and attributes of the property
• Availability

• Types of demand and supply

• Intended use

73
 Notably, based on the intended use of assets, the real estate market can be broadly categorized into five segments:
residential properties, commercial properties, office spaces, industrial properties, and properties designated for
hospitality activities. This classification holds paramount significance for both comprehensive economic assessments
and estimative evaluations of assets.

11.3.1 Primary Real Estate Category: Land

Land constitutes a primary category within real estate. Various indices aid in estimating the value of land, such as:

• Degree of use: This measures the ratio between the area available for occupation and the total area.
• Building index: Indicates the maximum buildable volume within a territorial area (exclusive of roads).
• Degree of buildability: The ratio between the volume of buildings and the land surface.

• Land use index: This ratio signifies the usable area of buildings concerning the land area.

11.4 The Real Estate Market Crisis of 2023 in Italy

Following the exceptional performance in 2022, the real estate market in Italy faced challenges in 2023 due to
elevated interest rates and inflation, which significantly eroded the demand for homes.

11.4.1 Scenari Immobiliari Estimates for 2023:

• A decrease of approximately 13% compared to 2022 in residential sales, with an estimated 680 thousand
transactions.

• An increase of 2.8% in the average price per dwelling.

Forecast for 2024: A further projected decrease of 6%, leading to an estimated 640 thousand purchase and sale
transactions.

11.4.2 Nomisma Estimates for 2023:

• Closing 2022 witnessed 800 thousand residential sales transactions and 12 billion euros of investments in the
non-residential sector.
• Estimated 2023 figures: A decline of 12.4% with 687 thousand transactions and 8.1 billion euros invested in
non-residential real estate.
• Forecasts for 2024: A projected decrease to 633 thousand residential transactions.

• Forecasts for 2025: Further decline to 624 thousand residential transactions.

11.4.3 Potential Future Scenario: Crowdfunding

Crowdfunding, a novel method of gathering funds through online platforms, gained traction globally in 2023.
With 146 platforms, it amassed 45.2 billion euros in global funding, compared to 36 billion in 2022. Real estate
crowdfunding in Europe alone raised 9.8 billion euros, with 2.8 billion raised in 2022.
The adaptation of platforms to comply with the new European regulation, EU 2000/1503 on crowdfunding, is
imperative. Notably, the regulation extends equity crowdfunding (previously restricted to SMEs and innovative
start-ups) to encompass all corporations, including larger entities.
In Italy, there exist 28 real estate crowdfunding platforms - 11 equity-based and 17 lending-based. Up to June
30, 2023, 1113 crowdfunding campaigns raised a total capital of 434.92 million euros, with 500 campaigns between
July 2022 and June 2023 raising 172.55 million euros.

74
11.4.4 Impact on Real Estate Projects:
• In equity crowdfunding, an estimated impact of 28% on total project budgets.
• In lending campaigns, an average contribution of 46%. However, in 13% of the campaigns, this contribution
rises to 90%.

11.4.5 Future Vision of ”Progetto Cmr”

”Progetto Cmr” envisions flexible and multifunctional architecture adaptable to organizational, technological, and
social changes, transitioning from working spaces to living spaces.
The objective is to create versatile spaces capable of accommodating diverse user needs, ranging from individual
to multiple tenants. The project must swiftly adapt to market changes and user demands while estimating operation
costs at approximately 2000 euros per square meter, with a margin of 10-20% contingent on finishes and furnishings.

11.5 ESG: Main Goals and Application in Real Estate

11.5.1 Main Goals of ESG Integration
The integration of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) criteria involves the issuance of ratings and
standards based on collected data, resulting in an ESG score. This score assists investors in gauging a company’s
alignment with ESG factors and its utilization of related tools in investment strategies.
Companies increasingly prioritize ESG indicators and standards, seeking positive feedback from external stake-
holders. Consequently, investors have become highly sensitive to ESG issues, prompting companies to comply with
ESG standards to retain shareholders and consumers.
To define responsible and sustainable investment, there is a need to create value for investors and companies by
integrating financial analysis with ESG factors through medium- and long-term strategies.

11.5.2 Seven Categories of ESG Strategies

As part of applying ESG criteria, the following strategies have been identified:
• Sustainability-themed investments
• Best Investment Choices
• Exclusion of holdings, countries, and sectors from investment portfolios

• Norm-based screening
• Integration of ESG factors in financial analysis
• Participation and voting on sustainability issues
• Impact investments

11.5.3 EU Activities in Sustainable Finance

The European Green Agreement aims to transform the EU into a modern, resource-efficient, and competitive
economy. The Sustainable Finance Action Plan, introduced by the European Commission in March 2018, focuses
on establishing a financial system that promotes sustainable development aligned with the United Nations 2030
Agenda.
The action plan recommends ten actions at the European level:
• Directing financial investments toward a more sustainable economy

• Incorporating sustainability into risk management procedures

• Enhancing transparency and long-term investment
• Improving the quality of non-financial reports by companies

75
 • Strengthening sustainability factors and disclosure obligations for institutional investors and asset managers
• Integrating sustainability into credit rating agencies’ practices
• Embedding sustainability into the prudential requirements of credit institutions
• Creating an EU label for green financial products based on EU classification schemes

11.5.4 Application of ESG Standards in Real Estate

This article explores the application of ESG criteria and assessments in the real estate market, considering both
assets (PropCo) and operations and management (OpCo).

OpCo Side
OpCo, responsible for daily operations, assumes the tenant role and pays rent to PropCo, which owns the real estate
assets. Implementing ESG standards in OpCo operations safeguards against risks, reduces costs, ensures access to
funds, enhances customer relations, manages human resources effectively, and fosters innovation capabilities.

PropCo Side
ESG analysis of the real estate sector (PropCo) involves researching and analyzing key certification standards,
notably BREEAM and LEED, to harness their potential for sustainable development. BREEAM offers comparison
and benchmarking of buildings, but has stringent requirements and compliance costs. In contrast, LEED emphasizes
strong marketing but necessitates intense documentation and lacks independent assessment, based on US systems.

76