RUBRIC FOR PROJECT 1 AND PROJECT 2: FOR BAA2422 AND BCB3223

ANSWER SCHEME 1
Criteria Unacceptable Weak Marginal Acceptable Exceptional Marks

No or erroneous Effective
major deficiencies minor deficiencies Critical selection
application of application of
in proper selection in proper selection and application of
engineering engineering
Fundamental Design and use of and use of engineering
principles yielding principles resulting
Application engineering engineering principles ensuring
unreasonable in reasonable
principles. principles. reasonable results.
solution. solution.

3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24 27 30 30

Excellent Case
study with clearly
Good Case study documented
with clearly conceptual
Limited Case study
Poor Case study documented scheme that
Incomplete Case with documented
with documented conceptual consist of layout
study without any conceptual
conceptual scheme that plan, full
Selected / Simulated documented scheme that
scheme that consist of layout specification,
Case Studies conceptual consist of layout
consist of layout plan, full material schedule,
scheme plan and
plan only specification and complete
schematic diagram
complete schematic diagram
schematic diagram and supported
with axonometric
diagram

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 20
TOTAL MARKS (ANSWER SCHEME 1 – 50%)
ANSWER SCHEME 2
 Criteria Unacceptable Weak Marginal Acceptable Exceptional Marks
ANSWER SCHEME 1
Excellent Layout
plan with clearly
poor layout plan
Good layout plan documented
with partially limited layout plan
no evidence of with documented conceptual
documented with documented
layout plan of any conceptual scheme that
conceptual conceptual
documented scheme that consist of layout
Conceptual Layout Plan scheme that scheme that
conceptual consist of plan, full
consist of consist of
scheme specification and specification,
incomplete specification only
schematic diagram material shedule,
specification
and complete
schematic diagram
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 20

Calculation is
clearly written out
completely where
units included at
Calculation is
Calculation not all steps, answer
written out (steps) Calculation is
completely written easy to find,
Calculation with right units, clearly written out
out (steps) with answer shown
completely wrong however it is (all steps) with
Calculation / wrong answer with units, correct
with not accurate incorrect with or right units and
Specification shown in units and answer, answer
choice of formula without right right number of
wrong significant has correct
number of significant digits
digits requirement number of
significant digits
significant digits
with clear
indication of cross
reference material

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 20
ANSWER SCHEME 2 (continue)
Criteria Unacceptable Weak Marginal Acceptable Exceptional Marks
 Uses all specific
lacks use of and relevant
wrong diagram / Has a few diagram Uses a few specific
diagram / tables / diagram / tables /
tables / figures or / tables / figures - diagram / tables /
figures or figures and
Diagram / Figures and examples to but not enough to figures but enough
examples to examples that
Tables presents relevant support their to support their
presents relevant make sense and
information. writing or topic writing or topic
information. support their topic
completely.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 10
TOTAL MARKS (ANSWER SCHEME 2 – 50%)

Prepared
by:

NAME: DR OMAR JAMALUDIN

DATE: