Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Proposal Final Submittd
Research Proposal Final Submittd
Research Proposal Final Submittd
FICHE, ETHIOPIA
FEBRUARY, 2015
Table of Contents
Contents page
Table of Contents......................................................................................................................i
Acronyms................................................................................................................................iii
CHAPTER ONE..........................................................................................................................1
1.INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................................1
1.1 Background of the study................................................................................................1
1.2 Statement of the problem..............................................................................................3
1.3. Research Question........................................................................................................5
1.4 objective of the study....................................................................................................5
1.4.1 General objective.....................................................................................................5
1.4.2 Specific objectives...................................................................................................5
1.5. Significance of the Study...............................................................................................5
1.6 Scope of the study..........................................................................................................6
1.7 limitation of the study....................................................................................................6
1.8 Organization of the Study..............................................................................................6
CHAPTER TWO.........................................................................................................................7
2. LITERATURE REVIEW............................................................................................................7
INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................................7
2.1 Theoretical Review.........................................................................................................7
2.1.1 Basic Concept and Definitions.................................................................................7
2.1.2 An Overview of Investment theory.........................................................................7
2.1.3 Determinants of Industrial growth..........................................................................9
2.1.4 The Determinants of Investment in manufacturing sector...................................10
CHAPTER THREE.....................................................................................................................12
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY...............................................................................................12
3.1. Description of the study area......................................................................................12
3.2. Sources and Type of Data............................................................................................12
3.3. Method of Data Collection..........................................................................................12
3.4 Method of Data Analysis..............................................................................................13
3.4.1 Descriptive Method of Analysis.............................................................................13
3.4.2 Econometric model................................................................................................13
3.4.3. Description of variables and expected signs........................................................15
CHAPTER FOUR......................................................................................................................16
4. BUDGETING.......................................................................................................................16
4.1. Budget Setting.............................................................................................................16
4.2 Work Plan.....................................................................................................................17
4.2.1 Time Schedule.......................................................................................................17
REFERENCES...........................................................................................................................18
2
3
Acronyms
ADF………………………….Augmented dickey fuller
CSA…………………………..Central statistical agency
CPI……………………………Consumer Price Index
ECM………………………….Error correction model
EIA……………………………Ethiopian investment agency
FDRE…………………………Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia
FDI……………………………foreign direct investment
FIF……………………………Variance Inflation Factor
GDP………………...............Goss Domestic Product
GTP…………………………Growth and Transformation Plan
IMS………………………….Investment in the manufacturing sector
MOFEC……………………Ministry of finance and economic cooperation
MOFED…………………..Ministry of Finance and Economic Development
OLS…………………………Ordinary Least Square
iv
CHAPTER ONE
1. INTRODUCTION
Generally in all over the world the term manufacturing refers to the production of finished
and semi-finished goods for the purpose of use or resale by using labor and machines, tools,
chemical and biological processing, or formulation .The term also refer to a range of human
activity, from handicraft to the practical application of science to commerce or industry.
Manufacturing sector is the physical or chemical transformation of materials or components
into new products, whether the work is performed by power-driven machines or by hand,
whether it is done in a factory or in the worker’s home, and whether the products are sold at
wholesale or retail. The assembly of the component parts of manufactured products is also
considered a manufacturing activity (ISIC, 2007/08).
Ever since the industrial revolution moved of 19 thcentury Europe in to modernity the
significance of manufacturing as vital engine for sustainable growth has been a questioned.
It does not only feed and satisfy domestic demand for products, it also diversity economies,
capture mass employment and earn export driven income. In many LDCs countries, their
socio political and economic characterized by low productivity, low income per capita,
inadequate finance, weak technological progress, and lack of skilled man power results
poor performance of their investment level.Immediately after independence African
countries implemented comprehensive stat directed industrialization policies, establishing
high tariff and subsidizing firms. Because of this manufacturing share of total GDP rose
from 6.3% in 1970 to 15.3 in 1990 for Africa. (African union official publication, 2012)
Even though the manufacturing sector have a strong correlation with the other stalk holders
of the economy and undeniable vivid circumstance by ensuring faster and enhanced
development it began to in Ethiopia during the time of imperial regime in 1950s.but it
starts much earlier than many of the Sub-Saharan African countries. Early l970s, the
governmental adopted industrialization policy included a range of fiscal incentives, direct
1
government investment and equity participation in private enterprises. This government's
policy attracted considerable foreign investment to the industrial sector. For instance, in
1971/72 the share of foreign capital in manufacturing industries amounted to 41% of the
total paid-up capital and many foreign enterprises operated as private limited companies,
usually as a branch or subsidiary of multinational corporations. (Ethiopian industrial
development strategic plan 2013-2025)
The derg come to power with a new ideology, socialism, which emphasizes on a strong
public sector and a weak private sector in 1974.to this effect a decree was enacted in 1974,
which nationalized almost all of medium and large scale industries that were owned by the
private sector. In addition to this the manufacturing industries of the country was
characterized by the revolution included a predominance of foreign ownership and foreign
managerial, professional, and technical staffing; heavy emphasis on light industries; inward
orientation and relatively high tariffs; capital-intensiveness; underutilized capacity; minimal
linkage among the different sectors; and excessive geographical concentration of industries
in Addis Ababa. The economic dislocation that followed the 1974 revolution had a
significant impact on the manufacturing industries. Private sector capital investment ceased
and labor's marginal productivity began to decline. A period of decline from l974/75 to
l977/78 and an average annual growth rate of l8.9 % for l978/79 and l979/80 was followed
by a reduction of about 3.1 % per annum between l980/81 and l984/85 and 3.8% per annum
from 1985/86 to 1988/89( Ethiopian Industrial Development Strategic Plan 2013-2025).
After the fall of the Derg regime in 1991 the new transitional government of Ethiopian
claimed for increased participation of private investment to give new life to socio economic
condition of the country. The economic system has been transformed from command to
market based system through decentralized planning, privatization of public enterprise,
promoting investors and the introduction of market based planning. The economy policy
which adopted and implemented under Structural Adjustment programs(SAP)during the
transitional period and thus followed by Agricultural development–Led Industrialization
(ADLI), in which enhanced agricultural growth and expanding agricultural surpluses
provide the necessary savings for financing structural transformation and rapid
2
industrialization. The industry sector in general and the manufacturing sector in particular
where given due national importance following the formulation of the national industry
policy in 2002 by the FDRE. (Ethiopian investment climate assessment report, 2004)
The central focus of industrial development strategy in Ethiopia is the development of
micro and small scale enterprise. As a result in 2015/16upda comprehensive development
strategy was devised and approved by government in consolation with all relevant
actors .extension services and support were accorded to small business to create productive
jobs in the industrial sector during the fiscal year. In 2010/11, around 542000 jobs were
created of which 53% were accounted for women (MOFED, 2010/11)
The plan has a target of an average growth rate of 20 percent per annum of an industrial
output over the five – year plan period and increase the static share of the industrial sector
in the GDP from 15.1 percent in 2015 to 22.3 percent in 2020.In particular, the
manufacturing sector is expected to grow annually at a rate of 21.9 percent over the five
year period (Ethiopian national planning commission, May, 2016)
Investing in manufacturing sector is very essential over the other sector of the economy in
many world countries because of the manufacturing sector capability to provide important
material support for national economy, huge potential for employment creation, to create
wealthy economy, and to help developing nations to alleviate their balance of payments
problems by generating more foreign currency as compared to the other sector. In addition
if industrial development is directed to use local raw materials, it can create strong linkages
among the different sectors of the domestic economy. Zinabu(2006) as well as to indicate
the effect of growth in manufacturing on sustainable economic development. But many
LDCs lack this opportunity because of low level income, capital deficiency, technological
backwardness and lack of skilled manpower to exploit their resource and many socio
economic and political related problems including Ethiopia.
3
The Ethiopian economy is dominated by the agriculture, services and industry sectors.
during the last five years (2010/11_2014/15) with respective annual average value added
growth rate of 6.6% agriculture ,10.8 % service and 20.2% industry. The manufacturing
accounts for about 14.6% during the same period.
The share of agriculture, service and industry in GDP averaged 41.5%, 45.6% and12.9, in
2014/15, respectively. Generally the share of the manufacturing subsector was remained
below 5%. This showed that the contribution of Ethiopian manufacturing sector to the
economy is still at low level (Growth and Transformation Plan II, 2015/16_2019/20)
The stagnation of manufacturing sector could be attributed to less than optimal investment
levels in manufacturing sector. The reason for this will be credited to Ethiopian business
environment being suitable for investments in the service sector. Both the government and
the private sector invest in the service sector. The reason for low concentration of
investment in manufacturing can be attributed to lack of access to finance due to bank
policy. In addition investors are happy to engage in making easy money which contradicts
with manufacturing sector which has high risk. Manufacturing sector is also susceptible to
fluctuations in prices and exchange rates which make it less attractive to prospective
investors (Berihu Assefa, 2010).
Therefore, the studies on the determinant of investment in manufacturing industries of
Ethiopia, comparative analysis of the effect of investment in manufacturing variables
among small, medium and large sized industries are scant. In their analysis small scale
firms are not included while the Ethiopian manufacturing is mainly covered by cottage and
handicraft industries most of which considered as small scale firms and they also focus
mainly on the determinants of firm size rather than to identify variables which affect the
investment in manufacturing industries in Ethiopia. As far as my review this paper is the
first attempt to analyze firms with greater than 10 employees and will help the existing gap.
So the main determinants of investment in the manufacturing sector in Ethiopia are tried to
be explained with relevant and update data.
Research gap while the investment in the manufacturing sector is important in economic
transformation from agriculture to industrial in LDC. However little has been done
4
regarding the determinants of investment in the manufacturing sector in study area. So this
study of plan to fill this research gap by studying determinants of investment in the
manufacturing sector in Ethiopia.
In order of the achievement of the above research objectives, the following question will be
answered.
1. Why investment in manufacturing g industry is very low in Ethiopia as compared to
other developing countries?
2. Why investment in manufacturing industry is important for economic development?
3. How can investment in manufacturing industry aid economic development?
4. What are the determinants of investment in manufacturing sector?
It is not new for all that investment in manufacturing industries would provide an important
role for economic growth which further leads to development. In addition to this the need of
this study is to give current and relevant information about the determinants of Investment
5
in manufacturing industries in the country. The paper will attempt to address the factors that
determine in manufacturing sector relative to other sectors. Thus, the paper hope that the
result will help to formulate policies that facilitate the investment in the manufacturing
industries, attracts investors from domestic and foreign.
The study will focus on the determinants of investment in the manufacturing industries in
Ethiopia by using the determinate variable of investments manufacturing Real interest rate,
inflation rate, the real GDP, Real Effective Exchange Rate, drought and identifying factors
that affect investment directly or indirectly in the manufacturing industries in the period
from 1991/2-2016/17 by using secondary data.
When the researcher conducts, this study faced several challenges, like lack of internet
access, financial problems, and the shortage of data collection. This study also had the
limitation of lack of organized and full information about the determinants of investment in
manufacturing industries in Ethiopia and lack of experience for the study of research. It
would also be unable to get sufficient and reliable data from the respondent, the lack of
awareness of the respondents. In case of this, most of respondents the true information likes
wages, income or other gives false information.
The paper will be organized into four chapters; the first chapter will include the
introduction, statement of the problem, objective of the study, significance of the study and
scope of the study. The second chapter will contain review literature which includes
theoretical and empirical literature studies .The third chapter will include research
methodology, method of data analysis, budgeting and work planning studies.
6
CHAPTER TWO
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
INTRODUCTION
this chapter will be include literature review, basic concept and definition, an over view of
different investment theory, role of manufacturing sector in economic growth, determinant
of investment manufacturing sector and determinants of industrial growth and empirical
literature review like determinants of investment in the manufacturing sector in developing
country, determinants of manufacturing sector in Africa and determinants of manufacturing
sector in Ethiopia, will be included in the chapter two.
7
increasing the marginal efficiency of capital or by reducing the rate of interest. In addition
to the above variables, he introduce expectation of future demand for firms output, violating
of investment, uncertainty and other non-economic variables such as political environment
as possible determinant of investment. These factors determine investment decision because
rational assessment of them is impossible.
Keynesian analysis is the observation that although savings and investment must be
identical ex-post, different decision makers in general, take savings and investment
decisions and there is no reason why ex-ante savings should equal ex-ante investment.
B. The Neoclassical Theory
Jorgenson (1971) and others have formulated the neoclassical approach, which is a version
of the flexible accelerator model. In this approach, the desired or optimal capital stock is
proportional to output and the user cost of capital (which in turn depends on the price of
capital goods, the real rate of interest, the rate of depreciation and the tax structure).
C. The Harrod Domar Model
Theory of investment after Keynes was linked to simple growth model based on Harrod
Domar growth model (a model used as economic analysis to project some macro variables)
and he accelerate the theory of saving and investment. These models are used to determine
the rate of saving and hence investment required to achieve a given target of economic
growth rate with a given technology. In these theories, investment is simply made to
ascertain proportion of changes of output. These models therefore sail to have much
relevant for developing countries because they do not have cost of capital and profitability
of investment decisions (Mankiw, 2007).
D. Structural Change Models
Structural change theory focuses on the mechanism by which underdeveloped economies
transform their domestic economic structures from a heavy emphasis on traditional
subsistence agriculture to a more modern, more urbanized, and more industrially diverse
manufacturing and service economy. It employs the tools of neoclassical price and resource
allocation theory and modern econometrics to describe how this transformation process
takes place. This section will discuss some of the renowned structural change models which
8
can be helpful in understanding how a country transforms itself from agrarian into
industrialized nation.
9
surrounding the growth in natural resources, labor productivity, capital formation and so
on, are a large contributing factors to economic growth. A competitive market system may
encourage invention and rapid innovation. All private and public restraints on competition,
including excessive or unnecessary regulation or tariffs or quotas on goods exchanged in an
international and trade, will trend to reduce the rate of growth in real per capital GNP.
(Urgaia Rissa Worku,2007)
Industrial Policy: Industrial policy concerns with the effective and coherent
implementation of all policies, which enhance the structural adjustment of industry to
promote competitiveness. Then after, the infant industries (like Ethiopian manufacturing
case) can develop and prosper by remedying the structural deficiencies and addressing areas
where the market mechanism alone fails to correct. Though industrialization in Ethiopia
was initiated three -quarters of a century ago, manufacturing sector is still in an incipient
stage characterized by unbalanced and distorted internal and external structural linkage,
backward technology and lack of technological capability (Kibre and Worku, 2003/04).
Infrastructural provision: Easy access to quality infrastructure is vital for the development
of the manufacturing sector. But many LDCs are lacked this opportunity such as provision
of electricity, transport etc. that are affecting the performance of manufacturing sector.
10
and sell its output at price P, the real cost of a unit of capital to the production firm is
R/P .the real benefit of a unit of capital is the marginal product of capital MPK the extra
output produced with one more unit of capital. The more capital the firm uses the less an
addition capital will add to its output.
Limited to access to raw material: Raw materials are the main ingredients in the
production of any economic activity .the availability of wide alternative of raw materials are
the primary question of firm to produce and supply their output timely. In other word the
presence of well-functioning input market and early access to imported raw materials help
for the growth of private investment.
Inadequacy of infrastructural facilities: infrastructural facilities in Africa are the main
barriers for computation, intercontinental trade and others. Infrastructure access indicators
rose between 1990 and 2000s.but this was mainly in communication technology led by
cellular revolution and water supply and sanitation (Jhon Page, 2012)
Exchange rate devaluation: exchange rate fluctuation are not favorable to economic
activities in the manufacturing sector specifically and the whole economy in general.
Exchange rate can adversely affect the ability of import and therefore manufacturing output
fluctuation in exchange rate will result the instability of purchasing power and
hence .negative impact on manufacturing inputs. (Opaluwa, and others, 2010)
High inflation rate: high rate of inflation adversely affect (but not necessarily) investment
activity by increasing the risk of long term investment project, reducing maturity of
commercial lone, and distorting the information conveyed by price in the economy.
( http://www.pimcoetfs.com/SiteCollectionDocuments/BAS087-Inflation.pdf)
11
CHAPTER THREE
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Ethiopia is one of the most beautiful and attractive under Africa sky, a destination with
variety of fascinating to show off is very popular destination because of its geographical
structure: unique collection of wild animals, birds, and plant life (being a land of extreme
endemism): ancient historical background, with much less fovea ancient relics and different
nationalities with their different languages, cultures, living in harmony. In geographically,
Ethiopia is located in the north eastern part of Africa bounded north east by Eritrea and
Djibouti, East and south east by Somalia, south west by Kenya and North West by Sudan. It
is known as roof of Africa because in the northern part and south eastern extended mountain
Stranger associated with plateaus (Goodo, 2012)
The main source of data will be secondary data source. The use of secondary data is valid
for this study for the purpose of gathering back ground information and comparing the past
experience with the current. The data obtained from (CSA) central statistical agency, and
World Bank (WB), as much as reliable source of data for the determinant and I will be use
world bank source of data and the other is if it’s important like, Ethiopia economic
association (EEC), Research department of national bank of Ethiopia (RDNBE), Ethiopia
investment cooperation (EIC), Ethiopian Economic Association (EEA), International
Monetary fund (IMF)
12
3.3. Method of Data Collection
The researcher will be collected through secondary data sources. The secondary data
collected from different published and unpublished document like journal, book, magazine,
articles, website, research finding, policy document, manual and other relevant materials.
The reason why the researcher was providing these methods of data collection is to acquire
the accurate and reliable data directly from the organization and its worker.
∞ -rt
N= [p(t)Q(t)-w(t)l(t)–q(t)i(t)]
∫e
o
13
Q= quantity of output produced W= price of variable inputs L=quantity of inputs
used q=price of capital i=investment in durable goods
r=discount rate
Since investment is based on expected future income streams which are not known with
certainty, expected income is probabilistic in nature. To reflect the fact that operators may
value non uniform probabilistic income streams differently, the model must be placed in a
utility framework. Thus, the utility of expected income becomes a basic factor which may
influence investment. From this model, it is clear that investment is a function of the prices
of output, inputs and capital, the production function which establishes the level of output
as a function the amount of inputs and capital used and the time value of money or discount
rate. This model is theory of optimal investment capital (Jorgensen, 1966).
This model is very helpful in explaining the working of the economic environment
especially the investment environment. But this doesn’t mean I am totally depending up on
this model to explain the entire real world phenomenon on investment. In addition to this,
the paper is not concerned with the decision to invest or not or how much to invest. My
concern is more related with which sector to invest in the economy to promote economic
growth. This means this paper will not use the model as it is. There will be changes to the
optimal investment theory of Jorgensen in this paper. Some variables will be rejected and
other variables are added. Therefore, the model estimation technique will be estimated by
Ordinary least square (OLS) estimation technique using STATA econometric software will
be as follows
IMFG =F (RLIR, REER, INFR, GDP, BD, RIR, DR) stands for…………………..1
Investment in the manufacturing sector = function of (lending rate, Real Effective
Exchange Rate, inflation rate, gross domestic product, budget deficit, real interest rate
drought) Hence, the model is specified as follow:
IMFG=αo+β1RLIR+β2REER+β3INFR+β5RGDP+β6BD+β7RIR+β8DR+Ut ………………2
Where IMFG=investment in the manufacturing sector
RLIR=lending rate REER = exchange rate INFR = inflation rate
DB = budget deficit GDP = gross domestic product RIR=real interest rate
α= constant β’s=coefficient of the variable Ut=error term
14
DR=drought
15
Real Exchange Rates (RER) between the country and each of its trading partners, weighted
by which measures the cost of the funds used to finance investment. For an investment
project to be profitable, its return or the revenue from increased future production of goods
and services must exceed its cost or the payments for borrowed funds. Another distributive
share that Marshall considered is interest.
CHAPTER FOUR
4. BUDGETING
Throughout the investigation each activities as and shop will be under take according to
their relevance for the success fullness of the study. Each activities under associated with
current and market condition of our country, it describes by the table as follows:
5 Internet 300.00
16
4.2 Work Plan
Activity Months
Title selection
Literature review
Data collection
17
interpretation
Write research
Submission final
research
Presentation of final
research
REFERENCES
Addis Ababa Chamber of Commerce and Sect oral Association (AACCSA)( 2015), ‘an
overview of Ethiopian manufacturing sector’’ ,Addis Ababa ,ETHIOPIA
Arne B. et.al (1997), “Investment in Africa’s manufacturing sector”: a four country panel
data analysis.
Bezawork Hailu (2007),’’the determinants of investment in manufacturing in Ethiopia’’,
Addis Ababa University
Belayneh B. (2010), “Reimagining Ethiopian manufacturing timely” published by Hibret
bank of Ethiopia.
Everett M. (1995), Manufacturing industries in the U.S economy.U.S department of
commerce economics and statistics administration office of business and industrial
analysis.
Gregory Mankiw,(2007) “macroeconomic” Harvard University
G.S. Maddala (1992). Introduction to Econometrics University of Florida and Ohio State
University.
18
Hanibal B. (2014), “Determinants of investment in manufacturing sector” Mekele, Ethiopia.
Kefyalew Endale (2011), ‘Investment Climate and Manufacturing Performance in
Ethiopia’’, Addis Ababa university
FDRE Ministry of Industry (2013),’’Ethiopian Industrial Development Strategic Plan
(20132025)’’, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Mbugua (2000), “Micro and macro determinants of private investment in manufacturing
sector”, Kenya
19