Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Actionable Harm
Actionable Harm
Physical harm:
Within negligence:
ii. Rothwell- Question of whether the symptomless plaques were, in and of themselves,
a form of actionable damage. Held: must be pain + immediate consequence
Difference: in Dryden had an effect on the claimants physical functioning, whereas in Rothwell it did
not. In Dryden, the change experienced by the claimants, led to the loss of their capacity to continue
working in the red zones [47] and so they were appreciably worse off. In Rothwell, the pleural
placques suffered increased the claimants chance of developing an illness in the future, but did not
have an effect on the claimants health or way of life at the time of the trial.
Mental harm:
See PI notes
Mental harm