Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

summary.

written by Gari De Ramos | edited by Katya Zabelski

Abolition Democracy is a book that consists of four interviews


with Angela Davis. Davis is a renowned activist and leading
thinker on the prison-industrial complex, prison abolition,
and abolition democracy–concepts that will be explored in
this book.

Davis is the former nominee for Vice President of the


Communist Party of the United States, founder of abolition
organization Critical Resistance, and a feminist scholar and
professor. She was previously placed on the Federal Bureau
of Investigation’s Ten Most Wanted for being a “terrorist,
communist, and criminal.” She was eventually arrested
and incarcerated for several months. The Free Angela Davis
campaign was launched around the world advocating for her
eventual release.

In Abolition Democracy, which originally came out in 2004,


Davis articulates the prison-industrial complex problem,
the need for abolition democracy, and what it all means in
the context of the American-led global war on terror and
human rights violations in detention centers Abu Ghraib and
Guantanamo Bay.

Our The book itself jumps around from concept to concept

book study g
(including concepts that go beyond abolition democracy),

Emp ‘Aboli uide of


so this study guide will not be a chronological summary of
its content. Instead, this study guide’s summary will group

ire, P tion Ange


questions and terms.

rison Demo la D First, we will discuss Davis’s conception of the prison-

s, an crac avis’ 2 industrial complex, prison abolition, and abolition

d To y: Be 0
democracy. Second, we will look at these concepts in the

rture yond 04
modern (i.e., post-9/11) context. Third, we will point out
other observations from Davis that are less directly connected
.’ with abolition democracy, but are still worth articulating.

2 3
The prison-industrial complex in action
The prison-industrial wealth as the wherewithal Davis has two critiques that

The Prison-Industrial complex perpetuates what


Davis calls ritual violence.
of a community to sustain
itself through schools,
homeownership, churches,
question the necessity of
prisons.

Complex, Prison Abolition, “The prison system


naturalizes the violence
that is enacted against
and more.

Once you are in prison, you


First, there is no correlation
between imprisonment and
crime. Instead, the rate of

and Abolition Democracy racial minorities by


institutionalizing a viciously
circular logic: blacks are in
are socially branded. Things
that allow people to re-enter
society, such as owning a
imprisonment is correlated
with the rate of surveillance.

prisons because they are home, getting a job, and Second, the prison system
criminals; they are criminals more, are stripped away exists as a punitive solution
because they are black, and from you. to social problems that can
if they are in prison, they and should be addressed by
From slavery to Prison and deserved what they got. The prison-industrial social institutions to allow
Prison is more than one complex exists because of people to lead better lives.
Jim Crow to prison the military way institutionalized the two assumptions widely
lynchings of the turn of the held in society. Such social problems
Oppression towards Black people The term ‘prison-industrial complex’ 20th century when Jim Crow include but are not limited
in the United States has evolved. It describes a system in which the was at its cruelest and most First, the understanding to houselessness, poverty,
began with slavery, then evolved into government and industry (read: violent.” of the racial contract. The drugs, and more. With these
segregation and the era of Jim Crow, economic forces) have created a racial contract “refers to the assumptions, Davis argues
and then now the prison-industrial system of surveillance, policing, Like slavery, the prison- social, political, cultural and that the state practices
complex. Slavery, Jim Crow, and prison and imprisonment. It is a term that industrial complex economic reality in which an imprisonment binge
are all institutions where punishments purposely mirrors a term that came disenfranchises the Black it is more advantageous to where the state removes the
considered too barbaric for the before it, ‘military-industrial complex.’ community since they make be white than a person of “dispensable populations
democracy are permitted–and they are According to Davis, both complexes up the majority of America’s color because all norms are from society” by putting
permitted because they largely target “earn profit while producing the imprisoned population. de facto whiteness norms. them in prison.
Black people and those considered not means to maim and kill human beings In many states, former Within the racial contract,
to be full humans or citizens. and devour social resources.” felons are stripped of their social punishment is Davis argues that while
right to vote and unable accepted because it is done prisons may make people
Both the prison and military become to participate in American primarily to blacks.” feel safer from crime,
important parts of the country’s democracy. doing so actually diverts
economy. We saw this during the Second, society believes attention away from threats
Vietnam War with the crucial role The fact that most people do that surplus repression – that come from the police,
military production played in the not question the process that the idea that restrictions military, profit-seeking
economy and how prisons now provide robs prisoners of their right and punishment (in this corporations, and intimate
cheap labor to build, among other to vote, Davis says, is a way case, imprisonment) are an partners–all of which are
things, weaponry. of thinking rooted in slavery “inevitable and desirable” more common sources of
and how certain people part of society – is a “logical violence.
aren’t full citizens because of way to deal with crime.” In
certain factors. her fight for prison abolition Another major part of the
and abolition democracy, prison-industrial complex
The prison-industrial Davis wants us to question is the torture and sexual
complex also robs Black if imprisonment truly is the coercion within it, but this
communities of their social only way to deal with crime. will be elaborated upon later.
wealth. Davis defines social

4 5
Another way the prison- Davis also makes the point
and military-industrial that the presence of female
complexes manifest in the torturers says nothing

The Prison- and Military Sexual


modern context is through
sexual coercion. Davis argues
that sexual coercion (i.e.,
about feminism and gender
equality. Although women
may now be in places they

Industrial Complexes in coercion.


sexualized abuse for social
control) is assumed to be a
normal and routine aspect
were not usually in before,
the places they are in (e.g.,
the military) are institutions

the Modern Context of women’s punishment–


both in domestic prisons and
in wartime.
that rely on ideologies of
male dominance.

Simply adding more women


Davis argues that the prison-industrial complex has That said, in the modern to flawed institutions
duplicated itself in the American-led global war on context of the American- does not achieve gender
terror that occurred after 9/11 to “divert attention from led war on terror, sexual equality, but rather the
the everyday domestic reality of torture and sexual coercion was used in a “equal opportunity to
coercion.” racist way to punish Arab, kill, to torture, to engage
Middle Eastern, and Muslim in sexual coercion.” This
prisoners. Female torturers brings us, Davis argues, no
in detention centers were closer to democracy and
Torture. documented, for example,
dressing as dominatrixes
justice. Instead, Davis states
that a more productive
smearing menstrual blood approach to feminism must
One way both complexes feed into each Lynching pictures, Davis states, were on prisoners under the consider the “socialization
other can be seen with the prevalence items that commemorated gatherings that assumption that prisoners and institutionalization of
of torture in the Guantanamo Bay and celebrated Jim Crow, capital punishment, from Islamic cultures are misogynist strategies and
Abu Ghraib detention centers, which and the oppression of the Black body. This more sexist than so-called modes of violence for men
housed foreign prisoners believed to be was done in public, whereas torture today western cultures. and women.”
part of what the President George H. W. is hidden behind prison walls.
Bush administration dubbed the ‘war on

Extraordinary
terror’. The abusive acts of torture and Torture and executions have moved from
Both the domestic prison-industrial complex and military-
sexual coercion that the public is horrified the public eye to the private eye.
industrial complex practice extraordinary rendition. In
rendition.
by in these detention centers come from
the military, extraordinary rendition refers to the process
punishment techniques “deeply embedded Davis also argues that because the Bush
of transporting prisoners to other countries to have them
in the history of the institution of prison.” administration has othered prisoners as
interrogated because those countries have more lenient
terrorists in response to 9/11, they have
rules around the use of torture. In the prison-industrial
Around the time of the book’s publication, put citizens in a position of having to
complex, this refers to prisoners being transferred to out-
pictures of the torture in Abu Ghraib sever themselves from the pain of others.
of-state prisons with more lenient prison systems. The
and Guantanamo Bay had been released. The way the public engages with torture
American public does not think extraordinary rendition
Davis spends some time articulating the reaffirms, defends, and reinforces the
occurs within American borders, but it does.
relationship between the pictures from idea that American democracy is here to
Abu Ghraib to the pictures of lynching in protect the nation from external threats to
American history. democracy.
Further Context
Click here for two examples of extraordinary rendition in
action, courtesy of the American Civil Liberties Union.

6 7
Thinking So, what is the
solution to the
How to Connected
organize. struggles.
About prison-industrial
complex? Prison
abolition and Throughout the book, Davis Davis spends time discussing the

Solutions
abolition democracy. provides some advice on Vietnam War, which was in full
how to organize for abolition swing in the lead up to her arrest.
democracy. Davis does During her activism in the 1970s,
distinguish between organizing she and others saw connections
What is prison abolition? and mobilizing. She argues
that mobilization (the ability
between the war against racism
at home with the war against
Prison abolition is not the isolated dismantling of prisons and jails, but rather to bring out the masses) has fascism abroad. Police, for
a “way of talking about the pitfalls of the particular version of democracy unfortunately taken priority example, slinked along the
represented by US capitalism.” over organization (creating a ground like soldiers in combat.
sustained movement beyond
Davis pulls from the thinking of W. E. B. DuBois, who articulated that prison demonstrations). The connection between these
abolition is not only the negative process of tearing down, but also the two struggles begged the
process of building up new democratic institutions that take away the need Her biggest point is that question of how one participates
for prisons in the first place. everyone must experiment– in the anti-war movement
when creating something new, while opposing the strategy
Davis sees prison abolition as a project that “involves re-imagining nobody knows what will or will of treating peace as an issue
institutions, ideas, and strategies, and creating new institutions, ideas, and not work or where things will unrelated to racial inequality?
strategies that will render prisons obsolete.” She states that “it is up to us end up going. “I think the best Davis emphasizes that any fight
to insist on the obsolescence of imprisonment as the dominant mode of way to figure out what might for abolition democracy can and
punishment, punishment ... by demanding new democratic institutions that work is simply to do it,” she should include and learn from
take up the issues that can never be addressed by prisons in productive ways.” says, “regardless of the potential related struggles against, for
mistakes one might make.” example, fascism.

What is abolition democracy? Visit Radical in Progress’ Connected Movements study guide, which
covers Angela Davis’ 2016 book ‘Freedom is a Constant Struggle.

For Davis, true democracy cannot exist without abolition democracy. Again
pulling from DuBois, abolition democracy includes three forms of abolition:
the abolition of slavery, the abolition of the death penalty, and the abolition
of the prison-industrial complex.

Slavery cannot be truly abolished until the people are provided the economic
means for their subsistence. By this definition, slavery today is not fully
abolished because Black communities are not provided the means for their
subsistence because of, among other things, the prison-industrial complex.

The death penalty, which concealed racism after slavery was made illegal,
and the prison-industrial complex perpetuates the idea that death and
imprisonment are valid forms of punishment. Davis, however, argues this is
not the case. When thinking about abolition in terms of abolition democracy,
she proposes creating social institutions that solve the social problems that
send people to prison in the first place and “render the prison obsolete.”

8 9
Global alternative to capitalism.
“We must be able to
a racial link, but by virtue
of a political identification Equal Movement was to purge the law of
its references to specific kinds of

capitalism. disentangle our notions of


capitalism and democracy
that is forged in struggle
… We should be attentive opportunity bodies, thus enabling racial equality
before the law.

Public discourse gives


to pursue truly egalitarian
models of democracy
to Africa not simply
because this continent is under the law. But, Davis argues, this process also
the impression capital … Communism—or populated by black people, enabled racial inequality in the
has only recently become socialism—can still help us not only because we trace Davis considers the law and sense that it prevented the law from
global, but it has a “long to generate new versions of our origins to Africa, but legal system as having strategic acknowledging that people and
and brutal history of democracy.” primarily because Africa significance in the struggle for communities are racialized.
moving across national has been a major target of progress and abolition democracy,
colonialism and but recognizes that it is not the

Other Observations imperialism.”

Davis also argues


ultimate authority of social
problems because the law has its
limitations.
Multiculturalism
and diversity.
from Davis that identity has
never been an
adequate criterion
The law, after all, cannot take
into consideration the “social
“The challenge of the twenty-first
century is not to demand equal
around which communities conditions that render certain opportunity to participate in the
borders—imperialism … of struggles can be communities much more machinery of oppression. Rather,
is not a minor consort of
capitalism, but rather a
Black organized. Communities susceptible to imprisonment than
others.” Davis goes on:
it is to identify and dismantle
are political projects; those structures in which racism
fundamental feature of its
development.” In the early
identity and therefore they are never
“The law does not care whether
continues to be embedded. This
solely built on identity. is the only way the promise of
20th century, Davis points
out that global capitalism
community. this individual had access to good
education or not, or whether he/
freedom can be extended to masses
“What would be the of people.”
existed with American Throughout the book, purpose of uniting the she lives under impoverished
imperialist ventures into Davis articulates her black community?” she conditions because companies in What she means here is that
Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the perception of Black asks. “It would be futile his/her communities have shut racism cannot simply be
Philippines in the wake of political thought and to try to create a single down and moved to a third world solved with diversification and
the Spanish-American War. the Black community. black community today. country, or whether previously multiculturalism.
Traditionally, Black But it does make sense to available welfare payments have
Today, this era of global political thought was think about organizing vanished. The law does not care We must get rid of the “persisting
capitalism is defined by primarily concerned with communities, not simply about the conditions that lead some structures of racism, economic
the power of international the debate between Black around their blackness, but communities along a trajectory and political structures that do not
financial organizations nationalism versus Black primarily around political that makes prison inevitable. Even openly display their discriminatory
like the International assimilation or integration. goals.” though each individual has the strategies, but nonetheless serve
Monetary Fund and the Davis, however, identifies right to due process, what is called to keep communities of color in a
World Bank, as well as more with pan-Africanism Going off of this logic, the blindness of justice enables state of inferiority and oppression.”
the ability of capital to described by DuBois, who Davis states that she would underlying racism and class bias to Davis points to Black people in
move across murders, argued the following: prefer a white person resolve the question of who gets to power like Condoleezza Rice,
restructure economies, in power who is more go to prison and who does not.” Alberto Gonzalez, and Colin Powell
and, in the process, “Black people in the committed to ending the as leaders who got to where they are
“[wreak] havoc on social West do have a special global war on terror than The law operates with a blindness in part because of the Civil Rights
relations everywhere.” responsibility to Africa, any Black leader who of justice that is due to, in part, the Movement, but are nonetheless
Latina America, and does not make the same Civil Rights Movement. The grand people who play major roles in
Davis believes that there Asia—not by virtue of a commitment. achievement of the Civil Rights sustaining contemporary racism.
must be and that there is an biological connection or

10 11
comprehension. praxis.
Abolition
Before engaging in critical analysis and applying abolition
organizations
The goal of this exercise is to learn
democracy as outlined by Davis, we must first make sure we from organizations that are doing
understand what she is saying. the work to either be encouraged
A plethora of resources articulate to support them or learn lessons
Take the following questions and answer them in your own the prison-industrial complex Davis that you can apply to your own
words. When doing so, try to limit the number of sentences you describes, including but not limited community.
use and aim to explain these concepts succinctly. To double- to the following.
check your work, or if you are truly stuck, you may visit the
summary sections that address the question. • Resources provided by Davis’s Future Research
organization Critical Resistance
1. What is the prison-industrial complex? Describe its history
related to slavery and Jim Crow, and its present as it relates to
• Resources provided by Black and Activities
Lives Matter’s 8 to Abolition
the military-industrial complex. movement • Read this article outlining how
2. How does the prison-industrial complex work? • Resources provided by MPD150, global capitalism and the prison-
a. What is ritual violence? a police abolition group based in industrial complex are related
b. How does the prison-industrial complex disenfranchise Minneapolis, MN • Read any article from The Marshall
the Black community? Project, a news outlet dedicated to
c. How does the prison-industrial complex prevent the As you learn more about abolition, criminal justice
Black community from flourishing? it is also important to consider • Find and write to a prison pen pal
3. What societal assumptions are present that justify the ‘need’ how you can work towards an here or here (before you start, visit
for prisons? abolition democracy. The three this article for advice!)
4. What are Davis’s critiques of the need for prisons? aforementioned organizations • Donate to bail funds, which you
5. How do the prison- and military-industrial complexes are all good examples of abolition can identify by searching for “bail
practice… work in practice. Go through their funds” on GoFundMe, Twitter,
a. Torture? websites and look for the following: Instagram, and more
b. Sexual coercion?
c. Extraordinary rendition? 1. What is their vision?
6. What is prison abolition? What is abolition democracy? 2. How do they define the prison- Source
7. What advice does Davis have for abolition democracy activists? industrial complex?
3. What is their attitude towards Davis, Angela Y. Abolition democracy:
reform? Beyond empire, prisons, and torture.
4. What policies do they support? Seven Stories Press, 2011.
5. How do they advocate for those
policies? We based this study guide off the
6. What work do they do beyond ebook version, which is why we do not
advocating for policy, if any? list page numbers for quotes.

Support the author


Visit and donate to Davis’ organization Critical Resistance.
Read Davis’ books, a collection of which you can find here.

12 13

You might also like