Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E3sconf Icbte2019 01040
E3sconf Icbte2019 01040
1Faculty of Business and Information Science, UCSI University, Jalan Menara Gading, 56000 Cheras, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Abstract. Going green in logistics business operation has been the main initiatives to reduce the carbon
footprint while generating profit. This study describes about the green practice and the drivers in the
Malaysian warehousing industry. The purpose of the study is to investigate the factors of adopting green
warehousing (GWH) with the main aim of exploring current green warehouse practice (GHP) in Malaysia
and the factors affecting them. The relationship between government engagement, customer, supplier,
manager, employee's engagement, technology innovation and green warehouse practice has been analyzed.
Data was gathered by survey methods. The survey was established for warehouse's employees with
superior or managerial position based in Malaysia. Quantitative methods used to emphasize the objective
measurements and to identify how closed the relationship are. Data were analyzed using SPSS software in
terms of inferential analysis. The key findings show that the independent variables had a strong and
significant relationship with the GWP.
© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Machine Translated by Google
E3S Web of Conferences 136, 010 40 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2019136010 40
ICBTE 2019
When looking into environmental-friendly approach, The adoption of GWH was identified based on the green
reduce, reuse and recycle (3R) is one of the undeniable initiatives of warehousing industry regarding to the
practices that should be implemented in the operation. As efficiency in Malaysia. In this paper, the quantitative
an important component in green logistics and green method was used. This method was commonly used to
supply chain, the activities happening were measured and determine the relationship mathematically between the
redesigned according to the environment compliance independent variable (IV) and dependent variable (DV)
which reduces energy consumption and reduce the use of [20, 21]
materials [15]. In addition, 3R concept points out another The survey was established for warehouse's employees
matter concerning, wastage of packing is significant in the with superior or managerial position based in Malaysia in
warehousing as many packaging processes will be going order to clarify the green initiatives or practices that
through in the warehouse for an instance re-packaging for implemented in their warehouse. The researchers wanted
promotion items [16]. IT application was perceived as a to investigate the awareness level in this industry as it was
new idea and adopted for the organization to manage the still a new concept and idea for Malaysia-based
operating activities that raging from the planning, controlling organization. Warehouse managers and superior position
the transportation procedure to the storage function from holders considered as internal stakeholders were chosen
the origin to the destination [17]. as the participants in the survey
The present academic literature identifies GWH because of their knowledge and experiences.
adoption affected by warehouse organization as well the
external forces exerted on the organization [18, 19]. The
2.2 Hypothesis
internal forces within the warehouse are managers and
employees where external forces are government, This paper was developed and adapted from the theories
suppliers and customers. However, there was no much from Ayuso et al. [22] as shown in Figure 1 where to
research that discussed the green warehousing adoption discuss the green warehouse practice in Malaysia that
and implementation. This research paper would test the initiated and were driven by both internal and external
significant relationship between the internal force, external pressure. The (1) government, (2) customer (3)
force and information technology by using hypotheses engagement of supplier, (4) manager, (5) employee and
testing method where the initiative taken would be identified (6) technology innovation in logistics industry were used
as well. in this study as the Independent Variables (IVs) with the
Therefore, an empirical study of the factors determined relationship of the green warehouse practice, the
that influence on the implementation of green warehousing Dependent Variable (DV). The hypothesis under study is
was done. In this work, the factors of adopting green stated as follow. Ho1: There is no relationship between
warehousing (GWH) with the main aim of exploring current governments and green warehouse practice H11: There
green warehouse practice (GHP) in Malaysia and the is relationship between governments and green warehouse
factors affecting them were carried out. practice. Ho2: There is no relationship between customer
This research paper would test the significant relationship and green warehouse practice.H12: There is relationship
between the internal force, external force and information between customer and green warehouse practice. Ho3:
technology by using hypotheses testing method where the There is no relationship between suppliers and green
initiative taken would be identified as well. warehouse practice. H13: There is relationship between
supplier and green warehouse practice. Ho4: There is no
relationship between manager and green warehouse
practice. H14: There is relationship between manager and
2 METHODOLOGY
green warehouse practice. Ho5: There is no relationship
between employees and green warehouse practice. H15:
2.1 Research Design There is relationship between employees and green
warehouse practice. Ho6: There is no relationship between
The objective of this study was to investigate the technology innovations and green warehouse practices.
relationship between the GWH adoption and the H16: There is relationship between technology innovations
stakeholders involved (manager, employee, government, and green warehouse practices.
supplier and customers) and information technology (IT).
2
Machine Translated by Google
E3S Web of Conferences 136, 010 40 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2019136010 40
ICBTE 2019
3
Machine Translated by Google
E3S Web of Conferences 136, 010 40 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2019136010 40
ICBTE 2019
4
Machine Translated by Google
E3S Web of Conferences 136, 010 40 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2019136010 40
ICBTE 2019
Based on the Table 6, it shows the t value for the six variables. variables. Moreover, the t value of on supplier factor is -
independent variables in this research. The t value of government 1.889, the t value of management factor is -3.787 and the t value
factor is 14.615, the t value of customer factor is 2.141 and the t of technology innovations factor is -2.343. Hence, there is strong
value of employee factor is 3.860. negative relationship with dependent variables.
It shows a strong positive relationship with dependent
Table 6. Coefficients
Model Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized t Sig.
B Std Error Coefficients
1Constant -.371 .053 -7,047 .000
IV1 1,464 .100 1,365 14,615 .000
IV2 .067 .031 .064 2.141 .034
IV3 -.109 .058 -.094 -1,889 .061
IV4 -.387 .102 -.372 -3,787 .000
IV5 .070 .018 .086 3,860 .000
IV6 -.048 .021 -.051 -2,343 .020
Thus based on Table 6, the following regression equation is Moreover, the p-value for the six independent variables in this
reduced. Y (Green Warehouse Practices) = X1 (1.464) + X2 research had been shown in the table above. When the p-value is
(0.067) + X3 (-0.109) + X4 (-0.387) + X5 (0.070) + Based on the lower than value of 0.05, it shows that the predictor independent
table above, it shows that if government factor increase one unit variables are significantly affect the dependent variable.
in the result, it would increase 1,464 units for green warehouse
practices adoption. In contrast, customer factor increase one unit From the table 6, it shows that the p-value for customer factor
in result, it would increase 0.067 units for green warehouse is 0.034. However, the p-value for supplier factor is 0.061 and the
practices adoption. p-value of IT factor is 0.020. Then, the p-value for of government
factor, manager factor and employee factor is 0.000. Thus, in the
result, all of the p-value for independent variables except customer,
When employee factor increase one unit in result, it will supplier and technology innovations factor are lower than value of
increase 0.070 units for green warehouse practices adoption. On 0.05 that will influence the dependent variables in this research
the other hand, if supplier factor increase one unit in result, it finding.
would decrease 0.019 for green warehouse practices adoption.
When manager factor increase one unit in result, it will 3.6 Overall discussion
decrease 0.387 for adopting green warehouse practices. Moreover,
if technology innovations factor increase one unit in result, it will Thus overall, based on the analysis done, the following are
decrease 0.048 for adopting green warehouse practices. reduced. Based on the result shown in Pearson Correlation
Coefficient Test, the correlation value for government factor is
r=0.982 which in between 0.5 to 1.0.
5
Machine Translated by Google
E3S Web of Conferences 136, 010 40 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2019136010 40
ICBTE 2019
Thus, the strength of relationship between government is lower than 0.05. Hence, it shows that employee factor
factor and green warehouse practices adoption is strong had a relationship with GWP.
and positive. Plus, the p-value for government factor is In addition, based on the result in regression analysis
p=0.000 which is lower than 0.05. Hence, it shows that that analyzed by using SPSS, it demonstrates that the p-
government factor affects as well as had a relationship value for of employee factor is p=0.000. This value of
with GWP. 0.000 is lower than 0.05 which shows that the employee
In addition, based on the result in regression analysis factor significantly affects the GWP. Thus, H15 is accepted
that analyzed by using SPSS, it demonstrates that the p- whereas Ho5 is rejected.
value for government factor is p=0.000. It is lower than Based on the result shown in Pearson Correlation
0.05 which shows that the government factor is significantly Coefficient Test, the correlation value for technology
affecting the dependent variable of GWP adoption. Thus, innovations factor is r=0.562 which in between 0.5 to 1.0.
H11 is accepted whereas Ho1 is rejected. Thus, the strength of the relationship between technology
According to the result shown in Pearson Correlation innovations factor and GWP is strong and positive. And
Coefficient Test, the correlation value for customer factor also, the p-value for the IT factor is p=0.000 which is lower
is r=0.730 that is within the range of 0.5 to 1.0. Thus, than 0.05. Hence, it shows that this influencing factor had
there is a strong and positive relationship between a relationship with GWP.
customer factor and GWP adoption. Moreover, the p- In addition, based on the result in regression analysis
value for customer factor is p=0.000 which is lower than that analyzed by using SPSS, it demonstrates that the p-
0.05. Hence, it describes that customer factor had a value for technology innovation factor is p=0.020. This
relationship with GWP and will also influence them. value of 0.020 is lower than 0.05 which shows that the
In addition, based on the result in regression analysis independent variable of technology innovations factor
that analyzed by using SPSS, the customer factor had a significantly affects the GWP. Thus, H16 is accepted
p-value of p=0.034. The value of 0.034 is lower than the whereas Ho6 is rejected.
significant level 0.05. Thus, it shows that customer factor From the results in the table of Coefficients in
is significant affect to the dependent variable of GWP regression analysis, the suppliers, managers and
adoption. It also represents that H12 is accepted whereas technology innovation were a negative significant variables
Ho2 is rejected. as they had a B=-0.109, -0.387 and -0.048 respectively
Based on the result shown in Pearson Correlation whereas government, customers and
Coefficient Test, the correlation value for supplier factor is employee had a B=1.464, 0.067 and 0.070 respectively.
r=0.899 which in between 0.5 to 1.0. Thus, the strength These three variables were positively significant variables.
of relationship between supplier factor and green The negative value indicates there was an inverse
warehouse practices adoption is strong and positive. And relationship between supplier, manager and technology
also, the p-value for of supplier factor is p=0.000 which is innovation with green warehouse practices.
lower than 0.05. Hence, it shows that supplier factor The supplier has an inversely relationship with the
affects as well as had a relationship with GWP. GWP. As the number of green suppliers emerge along
In addition, based on the result in regression analysis the supply chain and logistics industry, what they have
that analyzed by using SPSS, it demonstrates that the p- expected for being green in the operation, would only be
value for supplier factor is p=0.061. This value of 0.061 is in term of the transportation and shipping sectors. Since
lower than 0.05 which shows that the supplier factor is the carbon footprint reduction was significant in those
significantly affecting GWP. Thus, H13 is accepted industries involving vehicles. Hence, the focus will be only
whereas Ho3 is rejected. stress on these industry but not the intermediated
Based on the results shown in Pearson Correlation elements such as warehousing. As Malaysia is a
Coefficient Test, the correlation value for manager factor developing country, most of the people living with old-
is r=0.963 which in between 0.5 to 1.0. Thus, the strength fashion and narrow vision are going green. The expansion
of relationship between management factor and green to the warehouse industry will be neglected more as the
warehouse practices is strong and positive. Plus, the p- demand from green suppliers increased in the market.
value for the manager factor is p=0.000 which is lower However, the situation could be recovered if the customers'
than 0.05. Hence, it shows that manager factor had a requisition on greener warehouse to store their commodity
relationship with GWP adoption. and goods. The customers promoting the use of green
In addition, based on the result in regression analysis warehouse will definitely increase the demand in turn
that analyzed by using SPSS, it demonstrates that the p- increase the number of GWP in the industry as the “green”
value for manager factor is p=0.000. This value of 0.000 term is emerging as a competitive advantages in getting
is lower than 0.05 which shows that the manager factor is more customers. Hence, customers and the GWP have a
significantly affects the GWP. Thus, H14 is accepted positive variable relationship with B=0.067.
whereas Ho4 is rejected.
Based on the result shown in Pearson Correlation This could be the reason that managers did not see
Coefficient Test, the correlation value for employee factor green practice as a future opportunity to be sustainable in
is r=0.589 which in between 0.5 to 1.0. Thus, the strength the industry and they were not active to encourage their
of relationship between employee factor and GWP is employees to have green mind set. Besides, they might
strong and positive. And also, the p-value for the internal not think that warehousing industry could help to reduce
stakeholders of employee factor is p=0.000 which the carbon footprint as they concern only in the
6
Machine Translated by Google
E3S Web of Conferences 136, 010 40 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2019136010 40
ICBTE 2019
transportation part. Managers hold a crucial role in the industry interprets the effect on negative environmental
company, from the results from the coefficient can be seen significances.
that the more involvement of manager, the least the GWP.
This might be due to, the local employees' view on the
term of “green” and “eco”. Although the mangers encourage References
the employees to go green and help them to adopt green
1. Saad, R., Rahim, S.A., & Fernando, Y. (2016).
initiatives during daily activities yet the old-fashion thought
Sustainable green supply chain management and
that held by the employees are hardly changed. A
impact on organizations. Journal of Emerging Trends
transformation of type of business across the organization
in Economics and Management Sciences, 7(3),
is difficult without the participation of all the levels of
147-155.
employees. Hence, the researcher could say that the
2. Xia, Y., & Wang, B. (2013). Green Logistics in Logistics
involvement of employees might contribute more on the
Industry in Finland. Bachelor Thesis, Lahti University
decision for the organization to go green. This was
of Applied Sciences, Finland.
indicated by the B value of the employee factor (B=0.007).
3. Laari, S., Töyli, J., & Ojala, L. (2017). Supply chain
perspective on competitive strategies and green
Furthermore, the more technology innovated did help
supply chain management strategies. Journal of
to promote greener facilities and tools, yet it needed large
cleaner production, 141, 1303-1315.
initial investment before little profit return as it generated
4. Evangelista, P. (2014). Environmental sustainability in
in long run competition. The huge investments are only
the transport and logistics service industry practices:
affordable for huge and large-scale company, such as
An exploratory study investigation. Research in
case. case
7
Machine Translated by Google
E3S Web of Conferences 136, 010 40 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2019136010 40
ICBTE 2019
17. Lee, VH, Ooi, KB, Chong, AYL, & Seow, C. 23. Teo, AC, Tan, GWH, Ooi, KB, Hew, TS, & Yew, KT
(2014). Creating technological innovation via green (2015). The effects of convenience and speed in m-
supply chain management: An empirical analysis. payment. Industrial Management & Data Systems,
Expert Systems with Applications, 41(16), 6983-6994. 115(2), 311-331.
24. Rajendran, SD, Wahab, SN, Ling, YW, and Yun, LS
18. Chen, X., Wang, X., Kumar, V., & Kumar, N. (2018). The Impact of Logistics Services On the E-
(2016). Low carbon warehouse management under Shoppers' Satisfaction, International Journal of Supply
cap-and-trade policy. Journal of cleaner production, Chain Management, 7(5), 461-469.
139, 894-904. 25. Tunstall, Samuel L. (2016). Open Access!: Review of
19. Rüdiger, D., Schön, A., & Dobers, K. (2016). Online Statistics: An Interactive Multimedia Course of
Managing greenhouse gas emissions from Study by David Lane. Numeracy 9, Iss. 1: Article 9.
warehousing and transshipment with environmental DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5038/1936-
performance indicators. Transportation Research 4660.9.1.9