This rubric evaluates student scene writing based on four criteria: dialogue, creative process, dramatic structure, and a 4-3-2-1 scoring system. For the highest score of 4, the dialogue must reveal character traits and personalities through natural, conversational exchanges that flow logically. Students also received higher scores if they collaborated effectively and presented original material. Well-developed dramatic structure with a clear beginning, middle, and end was important, as was including logical transitions between scenes.
Excerpts From The Book 'The Lawless State (The Crimes of The U.S. Intelligence Agencies) ' by Morton H. Halperin, Jerry Berman, Robert Borosage, Christine Marwick (1976)
This rubric evaluates student scene writing based on four criteria: dialogue, creative process, dramatic structure, and a 4-3-2-1 scoring system. For the highest score of 4, the dialogue must reveal character traits and personalities through natural, conversational exchanges that flow logically. Students also received higher scores if they collaborated effectively and presented original material. Well-developed dramatic structure with a clear beginning, middle, and end was important, as was including logical transitions between scenes.
This rubric evaluates student scene writing based on four criteria: dialogue, creative process, dramatic structure, and a 4-3-2-1 scoring system. For the highest score of 4, the dialogue must reveal character traits and personalities through natural, conversational exchanges that flow logically. Students also received higher scores if they collaborated effectively and presented original material. Well-developed dramatic structure with a clear beginning, middle, and end was important, as was including logical transitions between scenes.
This rubric evaluates student scene writing based on four criteria: dialogue, creative process, dramatic structure, and a 4-3-2-1 scoring system. For the highest score of 4, the dialogue must reveal character traits and personalities through natural, conversational exchanges that flow logically. Students also received higher scores if they collaborated effectively and presented original material. Well-developed dramatic structure with a clear beginning, middle, and end was important, as was including logical transitions between scenes.
Dialogue Dialogue reveals Dialogue generally Dialogue Dialogue rarely
character traits, reveals character, sometimes reveals reveals character, personalities, traits, personalities, character, traits, traits, personalities, conflict, and mood. conflict, mood, and personalities, conflict, mood, and is consistent with conflict, mood, and is not consistent It is conversational style and form. is sometimes with style and form. in nature and flows Feels authentic, consistent with Does not feels from one thought to consistent with style and form. It authentic and is not the next within the character voice occasionally feels consistent with context of the throughout script authentic and/or character voice play’s storyline. consistent with throughout script. character voice throughout script.
Creative Very original Originality apparent Material presented Unoriginal or
Process presentation of with variety and with some repetitive with little material captures blending of originality/interpreta or no variety; no audience’s material. Students tion. Student’s collaboration attention. Student’s shared ideas, not shared ideas but collaborated to able to incorporate disagreed on using incorporate all of them. them. everyone’s ideas.
Dramatic Logical, fluid Adequate Poor development No development of
Structure development of development of of play. Transitions play. Scenes play. Very clear play. Clear may be weak. contain no beginning, middle, beginning, middle, Some elements of transitions. Major and end. Includes and end. structure are aspects of structure seamless Transitions are missing Conflict are missing. transitions. It evident. It serves and conclusions Conflict may be serves the the characters are weak. nonexistent. characters regarding solid regarding conflict, crisis, meaningful conflict, climax, and climax, and conclusion. conclusion.
Excerpts From The Book 'The Lawless State (The Crimes of The U.S. Intelligence Agencies) ' by Morton H. Halperin, Jerry Berman, Robert Borosage, Christine Marwick (1976)