Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Al Araidah2010
Al Araidah2010
Al Araidah2010
1 January/February 2010 59
Lean manufacturing principles, introduced by Abstract: The healthcare arena, much like the manufacturing in-
the Japanese automotive industry, namely the dustry, benefits from many aspects of the Toyota lean principles.
Toyota production system, are being applied Lean thinking contributes to reducing or eliminating nonvalue-
successfully in manufacturing as well as service added time, money, and energy in healthcare. In this paper, we
arenas. Utilizing lean tools, improvement ideas apply selected principles of lean management aiming at reducing
are pursued and implemented in a systematic the wasted time associated with drug dispensing at an inpatient
manner. Lean thinking drives out wastes so pharmacy at a local hospital. Thorough investigation of the drug
that performed work adds value and serves in- dispensing process revealed unnecessary complexities that
tended needs. In assessing improvement contribute to delays in delivering medications to patients. We
opportunities, it should be noticed that prob- utilize DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) and 5S
lems might result from people doing their job (Sort, Set-in-order, Shine, Standardize, Sustain) principles to
incorrectly or from incorrect work procedures. identify and reduce wastes that contribute to increasing the lead-
Lean methods are relatively low cost tools that time in healthcare operations at the pharmacy understudy. The
help companies reduce costs, increase quality, results obtained from the study revealed potential savings of
and enhance timely delivery of services (Kra- 445% in the drug dispensing cycle time.
jewski, Ritzman, & Malhorta, 2007). By
eliminating or reducing waste, lean focuses improve quality of care and cut down operat- Keywords
on value-added activities as perceived by cus- ing expenses. Consequently, savings can be uti- Quality of healthcare
tomers. In healthcare, lean aims to improve lized to invest in medical care technologies that lean thinking
care by eliminating waste activities that under- further help improve customer satisfaction. DMAIC
mine efficient treatments. Moreover, lean This confirms the growing need to eliminate 5S
enhances the quality of care by reducing de- wastes, optimize procedures, and improve reli-
lays and waiting for care, and by speeding up ability and efficiency. Lean principles have
processes such as the delivery of drugs to the been successfully adapted to the healthcare
patient. While these may lead to cost savings, environment enabling hospitals and clinics to
profit must not be the primal goal in health- streamline their operations and to focus on
care; efforts should be oriented toward value as perceived by their patients. Many
improving the quality of care. healthcare organizations have sought the sup-
The lean thinking process begins with iden- port of lean manufacturing to improve their
tifying value-added and nonvalue-added steps efficiency. Examples include Virginia Mason
in a process. To this end, a process can be im- Medical Center, ThedaCare Inc., The Clear-
proved by eliminating unnecessary steps, view Cancer Institute, Mayo clinic Division of
combining steps, reordering steps, simplifying Cardiovascular Diseases, WestCare Heath Sys-
procedures, or improving the reliability of the tem, Midwestern Regional Medical Center,
process (Meyers & Stewart, 2002). Unlike many Hotel-Dieu Grace Hospital, Western Pennsyl-
production and service processes, unreliable vania Hospital, and University of Pittsburgh
healthcare can be lethal and results in serious Medical Center. These and more examples and
consequences for the health organization. studies can be accessed through the URLs of
Eliminating, combining, or simplifying steps, American Society for Quality, U.S. National Li-
on the other hand, reduces the cycle time of brary of Medicine (PubMed), Lean Enterprise
the process and hence enables physicians and Institute, and Healthcare Financial Manage-
nurses to spend more time caring for patients. ment Association referenced below.
As a result, this may improve the quality of Recent investigations show that significant
healthcare and reduce costs that make it more accomplishments have been reported in
affordable to many. healthcare environment worldwide using lean Journal for Healthcare Quality
Public and publicly-owned healthcare en- process tools. Van Lent, Wineke, Goedbloed, Vol. 32, No. 1, pp. 59–66
& 2010 National Association for
terprises are largely experiencing efforts to and Van Harten (2009) applied a lean thinking Healthcare Quality
60 Journal for Healthcare Quality
nonvalue-added, and support activities. An ac- hances flexibility and ensures the contiguity
tivity without which the process cannot be of work. Preventive actions performed in the
completed is considered a value-added activity. workplace avoid unexpected malfunctions/
Moreover, no outcome is achievable from the mistakes. The control of activity outcomes as-
process if a value-added activity is eliminated. sure customer satisfaction by reducing errors
On the other hand, eliminating a nonvalue- and rework, and by minimizing the time
added activity does not affect the outcome of needed to perform the activity. Moreover, time
the process. Support activities do not add value and effort are further optimized using tech-
to the process but at the same time, the process nology, especially information technology.
cannot be completed without them. Such ac- Examples of the use of information technol-
tivities are required to connect value-added ogy in healthcare is electronic medical records
activities (transportation), assure that a value- that ease access to patient records by medical
added activity never starves (waiting lines/in- and administration personnel throughout the
ventory), and assures the quality of output of a medical organization.
value-added activity (inspection). Although The various improvement opportunities are
supporting processes are vital for the contigu- evaluated in the future state analysis and im-
ity of the process and the quality of the plementation phases. One may select among
outcome, customers are not willing to pay for the many opportunities based on ease of
such activities. If long times are spent at sup- implementation, cost of implementation, ex-
port processes, then such times are considered pected savings in effort and/or time, expected
waste. losses, or any combinations of these objectives.
In phase two, the time required to perform An improvement plan is then documented and
each activity is measured and documented. Us- validated with management before applying
ing a Gantt chart, activities are represented in improvements. Customers are re-approached
sequence along the timeline where a box with a for evaluating the process after the implemen-
width equal to the time required to perform an tation of the improvement plan. Standardizing
activity represent that activity. Moreover, one work procedures and communicating them
can use Pareto chart to identify the 20% of the to employees is a vital step that assures the
activities that contribute to 80% of the cycle holding of gains. Furthermore and to ensure
time of the process. These activities are to be sustainability, efforts must include monitoring
considered foremost during the improvement and auditing of procedures on continuous
phase. bases. Table 1 summarizes details of the pro-
To improve an activity, we walk through de- posed phases.
tails about why the activity is performed, when
it is performed, where it is performed, and who
is performing it. To this end, Brainstorming Model Assessment
and the 5 Whys are very useful tools for an- In this section, we apply the proposed model to
swering these questions. Results obtained from the drug dispensing process from the inpatient
this investigation help us decide whether to pharmacy at a local hospital. The inpatient
eliminate the activity, combine it to another pharmacy consists of 10 pharmacies including
activity, or simplify the way it is performed. For the main pharmacy (IPS), the chemotherapy
pure nonvalue-added activities, this study pharmacy, and eight satellite pharmacies lo-
should favor the elimination of such activities. cated on the third–sixth and the ninth–twelfth
For support and value-added activities, various floors of the hospital. Initial investigation of the
solutions may be proposed based on the nature process shows that the average cycle time of the
of the way the activity is performed and the process exceeds 2.5 hr. In this study, we aim at
recourses used in performing that activity. Ex- simplifying the process and reducing the cycle
amples of improvements include relocating time without jeopardizing the quality of the
successive value-added activities close to each dispensing process. Moreover, the improve-
other to cut down on transportation; this saves ment process must be at low or no added cost
effort and time of employees and/or custom- to the hospital.
ers. Assuring the availability of materials and
equipment at the workplace reduces waiting Data Collection
time for customers and assures utilization of The process of dispensing the medication from
employees. Cross-training of employees en- the inpatient pharmacy is rather complicated
62 Journal for Healthcare Quality
and time consuming. Moreover, the process of patients (sample size). For each ward, the
has plenty of paperwork and many check times required for performing each activity in
points. This complexity results in large delays Table 2 are measured and documented. Table
in the delivery process that may be fatal to 3 illustrates activity times and the average time
patients. In addition to on-time delivery, the to complete a medication dispensing process.
quantity of the medication must be correct The cycle time for a ward equals the summa-
because under-dosage and over-dosage might tion of times required to complete all activities
be life threatening to patient. Internal and for all patients
P in that ward (Cycle time for
external customers agree that the process is ward i ¼ time to perform activity j, for all
lengthy and has many inspection activities. activities
After medications are prescribed by physicians, j activities performed on ward i). The average
the drug dispensing process consists of the cycle time equals
P
activities detailed in Table 2. ðnumber of patients in ward cycle time of wardÞ
ward
:
Current State Analysis Total number of patients
Sixteen wards utilize the satellite pharmacy of From Tables 2 and 3, note that the process is
the fourth floor. The wards exist on various rather complicated and includes different time-
wings of the floor and have different numbers consuming inspection points. Moreover, many
Vol. 32 No. 1 January/February 2010 63
activities are manually performed and others process takes valuable efforts from many staff
are redundant ones. members.
It is worth noting that the time consumed by
activities 1 (data entry at satellite pharmacy), 5
(data verification and re-entry at IPS), 6 Improvement Suggestions
(label preparation at IPS), and 7 (drug prep- The drug dispensing process can be largely
aration at IPS) contribute to 460% of the simplified using information technology. It
cycle time. Moreover, redundant data entries is worth mentioning that computers at the
of the same information are performed at various levels of the hospital are connected
the satellite pharmacy (activity 1) and at IPS through a network of fiber optics. Utilizing
(activity 5). Four inspection activities of drug computers, medical software already in use,
quantities (activities 3, 5, 8, and 10) are per- and networking, various activities can be elim-
formed at various locations and include inated or simplified and hence save time and
different personnel. In addition to consuming effort. Explanations of suggested improve-
440% of the total cycle time, the inspection ments follow:
64 Journal for Healthcare Quality
Table 3. Time (minutes) per Activity and Cycle Time (minutes) for the Drug
Dispensing Process at the Satellite Pharmacy of the Fourth Floor
Activity
# of Cycle
Ward Patients 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Time
4C 17 20 3 5 15 22 20 30 11 12 12 150
20 20 3 7 13 30 22 36 13 10 15 169
20 17 4 8 16 36 24 35 12 13 13 178
21 20 4 9 17 40 21 32 14 14 10 181
4B 21 19 4 9 15 33 18 33 13 12 13 169
20 21 3 8 16 15 20 28 12 14 13 150
21 17 3 9 10 28 21 20 11 9 14 142
18 17 3 8 13 45 17 25 11 12 13 164
PICU 6 15 3 6 10 13 10 15 10 19 10 111
5 8 2 5 12 55 8 9 8 13 8 128
2 12 2 4 7 20 7 10 6 11 9 88
4 10 2 3 9 23 9 13 8 15 7 99
GICU 11 16 4 9 7 30 15 35 14 11 18 159
10 19 5 8 9 22 16 40 15 10 21 165
10 20 3 9 5 40 14 25 16 7 20 159
11 22 3 10 7 25 17 27 18 11 18 158
Average time 18.36 3.38 7.91 12.60 30.58 18.56 28.87 12.58 11.83 13.76
per activity
Average cycle time 158.43
Activities 2 (printing records) and 3 (man- of a label printing setup that includes a
ual documentation of drug quantities): word template, label paper, and a printer.
These activities only contribute to assuring This assures that label preparation can
that drug quantities are correctly docu- be performed in a fraction of the original
mented. Note that combining activity 1 activity time.
(data entry of drug information excluding Activity 7 (drug preparation): This is the
drug quantities) and activity 3 eliminates most value-added activity that can be
the need for activity 2, adds little time to speeded up through the practice and study
activity 1, and eliminates the time needed of the medication order picking process.
to perform activity 3. This requires the For the purpose of this study, we assume
presence of the head nurse at the satellite that the process is optimal.
pharmacy for parts of the data entry pro- Activity 8 (receiving and checking medica-
cess. Note that this combination saves tions at IPS): This activity is vital and hence
valuable times for both the nurse and the will be unchanged.
pharmacist. Activity 9 (transporting drugs to the floor):
Activity 4 (transporting drug sheets to IPS): This activity is vital and hence will be un-
This process can be eliminated as drug changed.
sheets are communicated to IPS using in- Activity 10 (receiving and checking medi-
formation technology. This saves time for cations at satellite pharmacy): The activity
the satellite pharmacy pharmacist. is redundant to activity 8 and hence can be
Activity 5 (verification of drug information eliminated.
and re-entry of data): The activity is redun-
dant to activity 1 and hence can be Future State Analysis
eliminated. Remember, verified drug in- We eliminate activities 2, 3, 4, 5, and 10 and
formation is digitally transferred to IPS speed up activity 6 such that the process will
using computer network. take approximately 5 min for any ward. More-
Activity 6 (manual preparation of drug over, we increase the time for performing
labels): This process is vital and can only activity 1 by 5 min per ward. Table 4 illustrates
be simplified. To do so, we suggest the use activities and times for the modified drug dis-
Vol. 32 No. 1 January/February 2010 65
Table 4. Time (minutes) Per Activity and Cycle Time (minutes) for the Drug
Dispensing Process After Improvement
Activity
References
American Society for Quality, Quality in Healthcare,
Concluding Remarks Retrieved March 20, 2009, from http://www.asq.org/
Lean manufacturing principles found various healthcare-use/why-quality/overview.html
Arbos, L. (2002). Design of a rapid response and high ef-
successful applications in service organizations ficiency service by lean production principles:
including healthcare. Many hospitals world- Methodology and evaluation of variability of perfor-
wide reported savings attained using lean mance. International Journal of Production Economics, 80,
169–183.
thinking. Lean tools focus on eliminating Bisgaard, S., & Does, R. (2009). Quality quandaries: Health
wastes from the medical delivering process care quality—reducing the length of stay at a hospital.
aimed at saving efforts and times of internal Quality Engineering, 21, 117–131.
Dickson, E., Singh, S., Cheung, D., Wyatt, C., & Nugent, A.
and external customers. This reduces the cost (2009). Application of lean manufacturing techniques
of healthcare and gives the medical staff more in the emergency department. The Journal of Emergency
time to spend with patients. To this end, Medicine, 37, 177–182.
Evans, J. R., & Lindsay, W. M. (2005). The management and
we present a systematic DMAIC-based proce- control of quality (6th ed.). Singapore: Thomson South-
dure for analyzing and improving ongoing Western.
processes with the focus on lead-time reduc- Healthcare Financial Management Association (HFMA),
HFMA Publications, Retrieved March 15, 2009, from
tion. Moreover, we offer alternative tools for http://www.hfma.org/publications/
documenting and evaluating each step of the Krajewski, L., Ritzman, L., & Malhorta, M. (2007). Opera-
procedure. The procedure is validated through tions management: processes and value chains (8th ed.).
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
a case study performed for improving the lead- Lean Enterprise Institute, Healthcare is going ‘lean’,
time of the drug dispensing process at the in- Retrieved February 10, 2009, from http://www.lean.
patient pharmacy of a local hospital. Results org/common/display/?o=880
Lloyd, R. (2004). Quality health care: a guide to developing and
obtained from the study show potential savings using indicators (1st ed.). Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bart-
of 448% in the cycle time. lett Publishers.
66 Journal for Healthcare Quality
Meyers, F. E., & Stewart, J. R. (2002). Motion and time study for and Technology. He received his PhD in Industrial Engi-
lean manufacturing. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. neering from University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in
Raab, S. S., Andrew-Jaja, C., Condel, J., & Dabbs, D. (2006). 2005. His research focuses on functionality-based design,
Improving papanicolaou test quality and reducing med- decision analysis, cost management, and performance mea-
ical errors by using Toyota production system methods.
surement and evaluation.
American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 194, 57–64.
U.S. National Library of Medicine, PubMed, Lean case Mohammad Khasawneh is an Associate Professor in
study, Retrieved March 12, 2009, from http://www.ncbi. the Department of Systems Science & Industrial Engineer-
nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez ing at the State University of New York at Binghamton.
Van Lent, W. A. M., Goedbloed, N., & Van Harten, W. H.
(2009). Improving the efficiency of a chemotherapy day He received his PhD in Industrial Engineering from
unit: Applying a business approach to oncology. Euro- Clemson University, South Carolina, in August 2003.
pean Journal of Cancer, 45, 800–806. His research has an interdisciplinary emphasis that
links human factors in manufacturing, quality, and
simulation.
Authors’ Biographies Mohammed Momani works at the quality assurance de-
Omar Al-Araidah is an Assistant Professor in the Indus- partment at Shifa Pharmaceutical Industries, Aleppo,
trial Engineering Department at Jordan University of Syria. He worked at the in-patient pharmacy at King
Science and Technology. He received his PhD in Decision Abdullah University Hospital, Jordan, at the time of the
Sciences and Engineering Systems from Rensselaer Poly- study. He received his MSc in Pharmaceutical Technology
technic Institute, New York, in 2005. His research from Jordan University of Science and Technology, Jordan,
emphasizes links between the multidisciplinary areas of in 2006.
Industrial Engineering.
Amer Momani is an Assistant Professor in the Industrial For more information on this article, contact Omar
Engineering Department at Jordan University of Science Al-Araidah at alarao@just.edu.jo.