Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vishwakarma Et Al. - 2017 - The Need To Study, Mimic, and Target Stem Cell Nic
Vishwakarma Et Al. - 2017 - The Need To Study, Mimic, and Target Stem Cell Nic
1
The Need to Study, Mimic, and Target Stem
Cell Niches
Ajaykumar Vishwakarma1,2, Jeroen Rouwkema1,2,3,
Peter Anthony Jones1,2,4, Jeffrey M. Karp1,2,4
1
Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Cambridge, MA, United States; 2Harvard-MIT Division of
Health Sciences and Technology, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, United States; 3University of
Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands; 4Harvard Stem Cell Institute, Cambridge, MA, United States
O U T L I N E
1. INTRODUCTION
is composed of extracellular matrix (ECM) components
1.1 The Stem Cell Niche in Health and Disease for attachment/anchorage, diffusible biomolecules for
As opposed to single-celled organisms, cells in cell signaling, cell surface ligands for signal transduc-
complex multicellular organisms are associated with a tion, and essential cellecell interactions.
tissue-specific physiological environment. Different cell Studies of cell populations during embryonic devel-
types differ in morphology and function; yet, they are opment have led to the identification of stem cells that
genetically identical. This variation, caused by possess the capacity to produce a full organism from a
differential gene expression, is controlled by intrinsic fertilized egg.1 Stem cells are functionally defined as
mechanisms and by extrinsic signals from the local envi- undifferentiated embryonic or adult cells, which can
ronment, thereby controlling distinct cellular behavior, self-renew and generate differentiated cell types with
or “phenotype.” The local physiological microenviron- varying degrees of potency. The fundamental replicative
ment supporting the cell and driving extrinsic cues feature of stem cells, along with their generation of
from outside the cell is known as the “cell niche,” which differentiated progeny, accounts for the origin of the
word “stemness.” However, whether stem cells need a only dependent on factors promoting stemness but is
special environment that controls stem cell renewal, also a result of factors inhibiting differentiation path-
maintenance, and survival, and what is the nature of ways. Hence, in homeostasis, the underlying relation-
such microenvironment are pertinent questions many ship between stem cell and niche accommodates
researchers continue to explore. With growing evidence, nuances and involves various elements influencing the
there is a growing consensus that in vivo function and the stem cell functional parameters: replicative capacity
fate of stem and progenitor cells are regulated by the and potency. However, when tissue is injured or
interplay of various extrinsic signals of tissue-specific mi- diseased, the niche actively engages stem cells; guides
croenvironments, often referred to as “stem cell niches.” their proliferation, migration, and differentiation; and
The concept of a stem cell niche was first proposed by regulates their participation in tissue regeneration and
Schofield in the late 1970s as a physiologically restricted repair. Therefore, the niche should be regarded as a dy-
microenvironment that supports stem cells.2 The initial namic participant controlling stem cell number, fate, and
concept of anatomically distinct sites that regulate behavior in the health and disease of the tissue and the
hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) activity and self- organism.
renewal was later extended to acknowledge the discov-
ery of stem cells and their niches in multiple tissues.3
Stem cells are often linked with asymmetrical cell divi-
sion, and the niche maintains a stable number of stem
1.2 Components of Stem Cell Niche
cells during homeostasis, and removal of the niche in- The stem cell niche is a complex, heterotypic, and
duces differentiation. Extrinsic signals interact and inte- dynamic structure, which includes supporting ECM,
grate to ensure that one cell remains in the niche, while neighboring niche cells, secreted soluble signaling
another escapes it by receiving a differentiation signal. It factors (such as growth factors and cytokines), physical
is now clear that in high-turnover systems, such as in the parameters (such as shear stress, tissue stiffness, and topog-
gut and blood, the behavior of stem cells is not uni- raphy), and environmental signals (metabolites, hypoxia,
formly quiescent, and the various niche components inflammation, etc.) (Fig. 1.1).7,8 Stem cell niches are highly
may govern their relative proliferative activity.4e6 innervated and densely vascularized, thus are directly or
Also, it is emerging that stem cell performance is not indirectly influenced by vascular and neural inputs.
NICHE
Stem cell
Self-
renewal
Progenitor
cell
Differentiation
FIGURE 1.1 Components of stem cell niche. Adapted from Lane SW, Williams DA, Watt FM. Modulating the stem cell niche for tissue regeneration.
Nat Biotechnol 2014;32(8):795e803.
Stem cell
Self
renewal
Transit
amplifying
cells
Differentiated cells
yet also support that progenitors can behave in a sto- molecular signaling emanating from them. They discuss
chastic manner.10,11 Different types of stem cells at recent findings on how the niche network maintains
various body sites with distinct niches may work in different states of HSCs by providing multiple signaling
different ways, and it is possible that both these theories inputs from different cellular sources during homeosta-
are correct. In addition, based on recent discoveries, it sis and mobilization/homing.
has been proposed that the stem cell niche has a bicom- Compared with other somatic stem cell microenviron-
partmental organization12: one compartment that en- ments described since the late 1970’s, the microenviron-
gages in immediate, rapid new growth and one that ment of pluripotent cells had not been characterized
contributes later to long-term growth. In this way, until relatively recently. This is largely because of the tran-
stem cells might work cooperatively with their progeny sient nature of pluripotent cells in vivo and the character-
to sustain tissue regeneration. Although the precise ization of their regulation being restricted to in vitro
mechanisms mediating these phenotypic changes may methods. Also, pluripotent cells seem to be mutually
be complex, these lineage tracing studies demonstrate interacting with their neighboring cells, which are
that the niche is a critical component for the stem cells. dynamically changing in a short period of time relative
to somatic stem cells. Chapter 3 describes the microenvi-
ronment in early embryogenesis, which provides robust
information about cellular interactions required for the
2.2 Embryonic and Adult Stem Cell Niches acquisition of a pluripotent state. It also describes the
The first example of a stem cell niche was demon- transcriptional and functional heterogeneities observed
strated by Kimble and White in 1981, who showed that within established ESC cultures and their emerging sig-
the mesenchymal distal tip cell provides the essential nificance for self-renewal and maintenance of differentia-
microenvironment for the maintenance of the germ line tion potentials of ESCs.
stem cell in Caenorhabditis elegans.13 Later, Drosophila mela- Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) are multipotent stem
nogaster became the best characterized system to analyze cells found in stromal or connective tissue and are distinct
the relationship between stem cells and their niche from stem cells found in parenchymal or “functional” tis-
through studies in Drosophila germline stem cells.14 These sue. The MSC niche will not be discussed in this edition of
studies have provided an extensive understanding of the the book, since our understanding of what constitutes an
molecular basis of stem cell niche regulation. Meanwhile, MSC niche at different tissue sites is limited due to few
several niches of mammalian adult tissue stem cells were in vivo studies and heterogenous population variation of
discovered, for example, the HSC niche in bone marrow, MSCs in vitro. Further chapters in this section will discuss
hair follicle stem cells at the follicle bulge, and skin inter- stem cell niches in specific organs or organ systems.
follicular epidermis stem cells located in clusters at the In the adult mammalian brain, the two major stem
tops of rete ridges in the basal layer,15e17 among others. cell niches that support neurogenesis are the
This book covers in-depth many of the studied examples ventricularesubventricular zone that lies along the
of embryonic and adult stem cell niches, along with mo- lateral walls of the lateral ventricles and the dentate gy-
lecular mechanisms, in Section 1. rus subgranular zone found within the hippocampus.
Schofield’s 1978 mammalian stem cell niche hypothe- Chapter 6 focuses on the development of the brain’s
sis was based on the observation that colony-forming neuronal stem cell niches and further reviews key char-
stem cells were less capable of replacing blood cells acteristics and molecular regulators, including molecu-
compared with bone marrow cells when injected lar pathways that help support the mammalian brain’s
in vivo into irradiated animals.2 Since his discovery, two neurogenic stem cell niches.
the field of bone marrow HSCs has exploded. Schofield’s Stem cell niches play a critical role in cardiac homeo-
study postulated that HSCs reside in specific loci of bone stasis and myocardial repair after injury by replication
marrow and receive support from multiple cellular com- of a self-sustained pool of preexisting immature
ponents of their microenvironment. Since then, there myocytes. In the myocardium, cardiac progenitor cells
have been several studies that aimed at recognizing are clustered in interstitial microdomains with an archi-
such components and determining interactive signaling tectural organization distinct from the surrounding
mechanisms of the HSC niche.18e20 Chapters 4 and 5 nonestem cell tissue. The structural and molecular
comprehensively review how microenvironmental properties of this niche condition the response of the
cues from the bone marrow and intrinsic signals from tissue to physiologic and pathologic cues by creating a
the HSC dictate its fate to remain quiescent, become favorable environment for the interaction of stem cells
active, differentiate, migrate, or participate in regenera- with the surrounding cells and the interstitial space.
tion. These two chapters detail advances in genetically Chapter 7 emphasizes the relevance of cardiac progeni-
modified mouse models and high-resolution, real-time tor cells and their niches to cardiomyogenesis. Also, the
imaging to identify HSC niche components and the chapter discusses alternative stem celleindependent
metalloproteinases.23 Thus, the communication between the different niches are indicated. Looking closely at
cells and matrix is bidirectional and dynamic. the matrix, it is possible to identify the major structural
Furthermore, matrix is able to provide biochemical cues and chemical entities as patterns and combinations of
to cells effectively, because it sequesters various bio- functional groups, present in proteins, proteoglycans,
macromolecules, such as growth factors, through specific and peptide sequences. To date, many studies have
and nonspecific bindings, and makes residing cells more examined the relationship between stem cells and
accessible to these molecules.24 Cells recognize and matrix in vitro using biomaterial scaffolds that mimic
respond to secreted signaling factors through multiple the natural ECM.26 In a particularly interesting
pathways: for instance, cells express receptors to their ag- approach, researchers applied printing techniques using
onists in their microenvironment and initiate intracellular automatic pipettes or robots to generate a library of arti-
signal transduction once binding between a receptor and ficial niches in a single experiment.27 Another group
an agonist is established. created microarrays of artificial niche components
The chemical composition of the ECM can vary comprising ECM proteins for probing single stem cell
widely among tissues. Fig. 1.3 shows four different fates in high throughput.28 These studies clearly demon-
stem cell niches, together with their cellular and ECM strated a robust proof-of-concept that adding known
components. ECM molecules playing major roles in ECM molecules or functional groups to synthetic
FIGURE 1.3 Extracellular matrix composition of four different stem cell niches. Adapted from Gattazzo F, Urciuolo A, Bonaldo P. Extracellular
matrix: a dynamic microenvironment for stem cell niche. Biochim Biophys Acta (BBA) 2014;1840:2506e19.
Interfacial wettability and its effect on cellular microenvironment is best characterized in the bone
behaviors were first proposed in a study by Lampin marrow. The HSC niche is laden with immune cells
in 1997, which established a correlation between implicated in complex cell, ECM, and cytokine interac-
matrix wettability and cell adhesion and migration.34 tions, which is vital for the development of the lympho-
Over the years, many wettability-mediated matrices hematopoietic system.37e39 Researchers are also now
have been fabricated to modulate a wide range of able to reveal specific immune regulatory elements
cellular functions from cell adhesion and prolifera- involved in regulating marrow function in concert
tion35 to cell pattern.36 The matrix wettability effect with stromal cells. For example, macrophages have
on stem cell behaviors can be extremely dependent been implicated in HSC mobilization through the pro-
on the cell type. To better understand and evaluate duction of granulocyte-colony stimulating factor,40
the interfacial wettability stem cells need according whereas neutrophils are seen to indirectly influence
to their types, Chapter 16 discusses how interfacial the MSC niche through macrophages.41 Furthermore,
wettability affects stem cell adhesion, proliferation, inflammation in response to injury causes a transient in-
and differentiation. crease of immune cells in tissues to protect against path-
Stem cells, like several other cell types, are sub- ogens and promote tissue healing. The transient stem
jected to fluid flow in the body. In particular, stem cells celleimmune niche interactions mediate endogenous
in vivo experience shear and chemotransport from tissue repair and regenerative mechanisms.42 The func-
fluid flow within mechanically active tissues and tion of immune cells can be modulated to promote
while migrating from niches to homing targets in the stem cell function in cases of continuous tissue injury
body. Chapter 17 introduces this concept describing and scarring. Application of immunomodulation re-
fluid flow devices used for cell stimulation. It further mains an interesting aspect of tissue regeneration strate-
discusses fluid flow mechanical stimulus applied to gies.43 Designing and controlling for this is a current
stem cells as a regulator of proliferation and quies- challenge, and greater appreciation is needed between
cence, differentiation into various lineages (osteo- the interactions of the immune system, the cells
genic, cardiovascular, neural, etc.), migration, and involved in tissue healing, and biomaterials.
tissue remodeling, with a brief discussion of mechan-
ically active pathways.
4. MIMICKING THE STEM CELL NICHE:
BIOENGINEERING TOOLS AND
3.4 Oxygen and Metabolism TECHNIQUES
Of the many metabolic factors influencing cell
The stem cell niche is a complex, dynamic microenvi-
behavior, oxygen tension in the cellular microenviron-
ronment, which is best characterized in an in vivo
ment plays a pivotal role, serving as both metabolic sub-
model. However, it is this complexity that makes
strate and a signaling molecule regulating stem cell fate.
understanding the specific function of individual niche
In vivo, low oxygen tension or hypoxia is a common
components difficult. At the same time, decoding the
feature of stem cell niche shared among different types
effect of specific niche components at the single-cell level
of stem cells and linked to their plasticity. Chapter 18
is challenging. Studying stem cells clonally, as individ-
summarizes the physiological relevance of hypoxia in
ual cellular entities able to self-renew and differentiate,
regulating stem cell metabolism and biological proper-
is emerging as a major focus to understand their origin
ties, including self-renewal, multipotency in differentia-
and key features. Population-based analyses of stem
tion, ischemic resistance, cellular senescence, and
cell behavior often fall short in defining mechanisms
paracrine secretion. It also discusses hypoxia precondi-
that may be unique to these specialized cells. Similarly,
tioning as a therapeutic strategy to enhance efficacy
niche interactions at an individual cell level can reveal
during stem cell transplantation under the context of
significant information on a cell’s microenvironment
disease treatment, including stroke, ischemic heart
and behavior at specific locations when compared with
injury, and kidney injury.
studies performed with cell aggregates. Although the
implementation of clonal assays for the analysis of
stem cells and its niche interaction is experimentally
3.5 Immune Cells, Inflammation, and
challenging, it is crucial for understanding the complex
Immunomodulation mechanisms that govern stemness.
Immunological cells provide dynamic biochemical Although traditional two-dimensional (2D) culture
regulation of the stem cell niche during homeostasis. systems provide a simple means to study stem cell niche
The presence of innate and adaptive immune cells to interactions, they suffer from inherent limitations to
help maintain the integrity of the stem cell replicate the complexity of the native niche and in
guide stem cell fate through mechanical cues that specialized artificial stem cell niches helps researchers to
govern processes such as adhesion, proliferation, and elucidate the mechanisms by which stem cells receive in-
differentiation. Self-assembly in particular is one of the formation from the multifactorial microenvironment.
most promising fields in building materials and struc- Promoting desirable stem cell phenotypes allows for
tures at the nanoscale. It takes a bottom-up approach the exploitation of their unique property of stemness
for fabrication, where small molecular components and their ability to home and differentiate, thus contrib-
interact with each other under specific conditions to uting to tissue repair. Additionally, in vitro engineered
spontaneously organize into more complex 2D or 3D niches can be used to screen for molecules that can regu-
structures.47,48 Chapter 25 provides a comprehensive late niche biology and thus avoid the need for exogenous
background on self-assembly nanofabrication tech- cell therapy.
niques and their applications in bioengineering stem The currently available therapeutic strategies for end-
cell niches. stage debilitating disease such as congestive heart or
The in vivo ECM in particular possesses a nanoscale liver failure are all invasive surgical approaches,
fibrous topography. Chapter 26 discusses the role of including implantable devices and, ultimately, organ
this topography in modulating stem cell fates in vitro transplantation. However, these surgical treatments are
and details nanofiber fabrication techniques to produce unable to completely restore damaged tissue. For
matrices that have a morphological resemblance to example, all current therapeutic procedures for heart
fibers naturally found in the ECM. Their similar charac- failure to date only modulate hemodynamics and none
teristics suggest that nanofibers could be used as a are available to regenerate heart tissue. Regenerative
supportive matrix for creating artificial niches for stem therapies based on stem cells hold promise as a
cells, upon which additional functionalities could be treatment to overcome this limitation, but to date have
incorporated to further modulate stem cell fates.49 achieved only modest outcomes in clinical trials. To
Stem cells are exposed to a multitude of biochemical enhance potential stem cell behavior and exploit its
gradients across a niche, subjecting them to different maximum functional effect, numerous studies have
signals in different locations in the niche, which shapes taken great effort to elucidate the tissue-specific stem
the way the cells divide. Hence, engineering a modu- cell and progenitor cell niches. Chapters 28e37 demon-
lated niche with spatial complexity would better reflect strate such current advances in the construction of
the in vivo situation. Microfluidics allows for the biomimetic niches to modulate cellematrix interactions
controlled delivery of signals to specific locations within or cellecell interactions for enhanced repair or regener-
the niche, thus modulating the properties of an artificial ation in different tissue types, namely cardiac, bone,
stem cell niche. It provides ways to manipulate single cartilage, skin, and liver. For vascular tissues and
stem cells to better understand behavior across a diverse organs, de novo blood vessel formation, also known as
population of stem cells. In addition, fabricating micro- vasculogenesis, and the subsequent expansion of the
fluidic channels within biomaterials has been shown to nascent vascular network via angiogenesis, constitutes
be a promising tool to mimic nutrient and gas transport a complex vascular niche essential to tissue repair.
for stem cell niche engineering.50 Chapter 27 reviews Coordinating blood vessel generation along with paren-
microfluidic concepts used to generate a wide variety chymal tissue development is critical so that an
of biomolecule gradients and presents the most adequate supply of nutrients and oxygen is maintained
successful applications of microfluidic deviceeinduced along with the removal of waste metabolites. Harness-
gradients for pluripotent stem cell patterning. ing niche biology and in vitro model systems to engineer
a regenerative therapeutic is the ultimate goal.
5. BIOENGINEERING SPECIALIZED
ARTIFICIAL STEM CELL NICHES FOR
CLINICAL THERAPIES References
1. Blau HM, Brazelton TR, Weimann JM. The evolving concept of a
Stem cells are promising cell source candidates for use stem cell: entity or function? Cell 2001;105:829e41.
2. Schofield R. The relationship between the spleen colony-forming
in regenerative medicine. With the recent discovery of cell and the haemopoietic stem cell. Blood Cells 1978;4:7e25.
induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs), emerging combi- 3. Morrison SJ, Spradling AC. Stem cells and niches: mechanisms that
nations of biomaterials and iPSCs are bringing promote stem cell maintenance throughout life. Cell 2008;132:
unprecedented opportunities for treating debilitating hu- 598e611.
man diseases.51 Potential knowledge from the biomate- 4. Carlone DL, Breault DT. Slowly cycling versus rapidly cycling
intestinal stem cells: distinct roles or redundancy. Cell Cycle 2011;
rials-mediated approaches for enhancing stem 10:723e4.
cellebased tissue repair is being applied for achieving 5. Glauche I, et al. Stem cell proliferation and quiescenceetwo sides
many therapeutic and nontherapeutic goals. Engineering of the same coin. PLoS Comput Biol 2009;5:e1000447.